GENERAL PLANNING CONSULTING SERVICES FOR TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT – RFP NO. PNC2119955P1 EVALUATION Kimley-Horn and Kittelson and CDM Smith, Inc. CTS Engineering, Inc. H.W. Lochner, Inc. CRITERIA Associates, Inc. Associates, Inc. PROJECT- SPECIFIC Vendor Response Vendor Response Vendor Response Vendor Response Vendor Response CRITERIA 1. Ability of Professional Personnel: (Maximum 30 points) Enhanced mobility, linked CTS Engineering, Inc. Lochner is a full-service Our core team of key Our Team understands that 1. Describe the communities, and alternatives (CTS), in association with multidiscipline firm with more personnel provides a high Broward County is poised for qualifications and to new roads are the catalysts Gannett Fleming, Inc. (GF), than 600 professionals who level of responsiveness to the success – with resident’s relevant experience of for considering public Cambridge Systematics, collaborate to deliver all modes Broward County support for their Mobility the Project Manager and transportation solutions. As Inc. (CS), Connetics of innovative, cost-effective Transportation Department Advancement Program all key staff that are an award-winning provider of Transportation Group, Inc. solutions in transportation (BCTD), both in terms of (MAP), Broward County intended to be assigned transit-related services, CDM (CTG), Via Planning, Inc. planning, traffic engineering, exceptional project stands ready to build a “safe, to the project. Include Smith applies in-depth (VIA), Smart-Sciences, Inc., roadway design, rail/transit, understanding and support, sustainable, integrated and resumes for the Project industry knowledge, research, The Leap Group, LLC. structures, environmental, and extensive technical efficient transportation system Manager and all key staff state- of-the-art planning (LEAP), ADEPT Public aviation, construction and expertise in the disciplines to enhance Broward County’s described. Include the tools, and creativity to Relations, LLC. (ADEPT), alternative delivery. With more you require. Our team is economy and livability”. With qualifications and communities everywhere. Our Habidatum International, than 30 offices across the structured to provide BCTD this vote, there is an relevant experience of all highly experienced team of Inc. (Habidatum), Hammond United States, our clients with flexibility in assignments enormous opportunity for subconsultants’ key staff transit specialists is supported & Associates, Inc., and benefit from committed of task orders, including the future of transportation to be assigned to the by dedicated resources in Optibus, Inc. are pleased to professionals with local concurrent assignments, and in Broward County, and with project. environmental, statewide and submit the responses below knowledge and national has built-in redundancies it an increase in what is multimodal, urban and land for General Planning expertise. We serve the entire among most disciplines to expected of BCTD to deliver. 1. a. Identify the key use, economics, economic Consultant Services for the state of Florida, assisting public provide staff available to To maintain the confidence of personnel who will be community development, and Broward County and private clients in their BCTD upon short notice. our citizens and elected assigned to the Scope of sustainability planning. CDM Transportation Department efforts to plan for transportation officials, BCTD must increase Work. Provide the Smith’s planners recognize (BCTD). At CTS Engineering, and livability, with the technical Key personnel: transit service on the street experience each team the importance of analyzing Inc., we pride ourselves in expertise to provide a reliable, John Lafferty – Project and quickly implement a member has had on the total door-to-door trip and providing the highest levels of convenient, safe and Manager transformative and modern completing a General modal linkage and offer a full quality and service to our connected transit network Greg Kyle, AICP – transit system that can Planning Consultant range of feasibility studies, clients. Working with CTS throughout Broward County. Principal-In-Charge effectively serve the ever- (GPC) and other transit scheduling, comprehensive means working with experts We have a vested interest in Robert Lepore, P.E. – growing and evolving system planning, operations audits, funding known to you—experts with a Broward County Transportation QA/QC Manager region. BCTD is at the analysis, and and grant applications track record of having Department’s (BCTD’s) Paul Elman, P.E. – precipice of a new future and management. Resumes support, strategic planning, successfully-joined forces for success fulfilling the service Strategic Advisor - we see this contract as a way of all team members land use and transit-oriented you. The CTS Team has a and capital needs of the Vision Multimodal to help BCTD get ready for shall be provided and up- development, and traffic and long history of collaborating Plan outlined in the Transit Planning/Project this new challenge. Our to-date. The Vendor travel demand services. on similar projects, including Development Plan, ultimately Development Kittelson team of must demonstrate that it Our hand-selected team our current General Planning assisting BCTD’s Paul Pattison, P.E. – transportation and has sufficient personnel members provide a depth of Consultant (GPC) type implementation of the projects community-building with the various types of Strategic Advisor - General Planning Consultant contracts for the Florida that compose the overall Penny Conceptual Design professionals has assisted skills needed to staff the (GPC) contract as well as Department of Transportation for Transportation Surtax Plan communities across the task orders when Clarence Eng, FAICP – transit-related task (FDOT), Districts 4 and 6, and recently approved by Broward Transportation county to plan and implement needed. experience, both locally and other agencies across County voters. We will partner transformative transit and Planning & Analysis from around the nation. We Florida. CTS is ready to assist with BCTD and implement our Lead multimodal infrastructure to BCTD by providing a Team alliance through teamwork and have chosen members, Yonel Grant, PMP – meet similar goals. Points Value: 10 with local and national the right allocation of resources including our teaming Organizational 1 GENERAL PLANNING CONSULTING SERVICES FOR TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT – RFP NO. PNC2119955P1 EVALUATION Kimley-Horn and Kittelson and CDM Smith, Inc. CTS Engineering, Inc. H.W. Lochner, Inc. CRITERIA Associates, Inc. Associates, Inc. partners, based on their overlapping skillsets and within our proposed team. Our Assessment, Research How the Kittelson Team can location as well as their availability. At any given team will perform the required Analysis & Planning help leverage and address backgrounds in relevant moment over the last ten services, on-time, with the right Lead BCTD’s challenges and services. This mix will provide years, CTS has been a Prime personnel, which will ultimately Jill Capelli, P.E. – opportunities the County the local, Consultant, serving similar be beneficial to the public and Information Challenge/Opportunity #1: responsive service of a small transit-related General produce technically sound Technology (IT) Lead Immediate access to more firm as well as the diverse Planning Contracts for contract documents that are Corey Hill – Grants staff with the skills needed wealth of experience that only FDOT’s Districts 4 and 6. cost-conscious. Constant and Compliance, to deliver a robust and a large, nation-wide firm can CTS has a proven track proactive communication with Monitoring & efficient transportation provide. Our team members, record of producing the the BCTD’s Project Manager Development Lead program outlined on the following highest quality deliverables will be maintained throughout Melissa DuMond, AICP It will take a larger and more page, have worked together on time and within budget for the life of the contract. – Grant Management skilled workforce to deliver on several similar contracts, tasks under those contracts. PROJECT MANAGER Peter Meyerhofer, P.E. BCTD’s expanded such as the ones listed below. As such, there is no learning Lochner’s team will be led by – Transit Facilities multifaceted transit program Having worked together on curve, and we can start work Project Manager, James E. Edgar Torres, P.E. – that will include new transit numerous transit-related immediately. The CTS Team Spinks III, PE, PTOE. Service /Operations modes, such as light rail tasks around the country, our brings national, state, and James brings with him more Planning transit (LRT), bus rapid transit team knows how to local expertise in capital than 20 years of multimodal Stewart Robertson, (BRT), streetcar, and more. collaborate with each other transit technical support, experience in traffic operations P.E. – Multimodal Several Kittelson team and the client to complete system, route and service and safety, transportation Planning members have helped transit successful projects. planning, NEPA and planning, signal design, traffic agencies get ready to operate engineering design, impact analysis, and ITS Resumes for all Kimley- new service types and CDM Project Team innovative data collection and planning. He has managed Horn team members understand the full range of includes: analysis, and research DOT projects and served as a (including those not listed human and capital support for new TDM, public