Unholy Ghosts in the Age of Spirit: Identity, Intersectionality, and the Theological Horizons of Black Progress The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:40046529 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use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`)55&-#(5$%+%+5=-955D+$3-90;5%4-""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-!O>! J"?"! <')&035-%'-E+$(-V'65-+$-.$5a=-952;-"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-8X!! J"J"! `)55&-G&0$=3&5==+'$=-0$(-#$(5*5$%-G15'2'3+*02-/&':'=02=-""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-8!7! @$81*,2!SA! J#2+7$+#.!01+2+*3!:%C825!9$L2D8#!8#5!8!9$,%&%.'!%/!*$,!K+)+#$,2+*,5!AAAAAAAAAAAA!GGV! >"!"! G15-UQ$*&50%5(-[2565$%W,-V'S0&(-G1)&60$a=-Mb4=%+*02N-<022-';-9:+&+%-"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-8?X! >"8"! G15-K5A+0$%-Y5=)=-';-%15-K+=+$15&+%5(-""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-8JX! >"?"! 9%+22-b'&5-F+A5&=-%'-<&'==,-9+$3+$3-%15-c53&'-9:+&+%)02=-"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-8JO! >"J"! <&50%+A5-[$*')$%5&=,-/$5)60%'2'3+*02-H;;+$+%4-%'-G1)&60$a=-9:+&+%-""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-87X! >">"! 9:+&+%-0$(-%15-/'S5&-\+%1+$,-.A5&*'6+$3-%15-E50&-';-K50%1-"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-87P! >"7"! <'$*2)(+$3-G15'2'3+*02-/'=%=*&+:%=-"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-8O>! <+?&+%.281$'!AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!GWX! ! ! ! ! $D! >2,/87,! - ! - ! "%!)+!9+#&'>')#9)(&!M!%)(!$+!(8&!,&N%!*<!E+$*+!E+$(&#!G&(8*#$%(!F89';84!)+#!)%!)! #*;(*')0! %(9#&+(! M! %(**#! $+! $(%! ,90,$(6! "(! <$'%(4! M! N*'%8$,,&#! )%! )! 2&2-&'! *<! (8&! #&+*2$+)($*+O%! <$'%(! ,'&#*2$+)(&0.! "<'$;)+P"2&'$;)+4! 1/Q7RP)<<$'2$+>4! S'&;*+;$0$+>! ;*+>'&>)($*+6TJ!1)(&'4!M!,)%(*'&#!(8&!,&*,0&!N8*!+9'(9'&#!2.!<)$(8!)%!)!;*00&>&!%(9#&+(6!7*! %).!(8)(!M!N)%!%9','$%&#!N8&+!2.!-$%8*,!;)00&#!N*90#!-&!)+!9+#&'%()(&2&+(6!U&D&'!$+!)! (8*9%)+#!.&)'%!;*90#!M!8)D&!#'&)2&#!(8$%6!! ! M! &V,&'$&+;&#! 2)+.! A*.%! )+#! 2)+.! ;8)00&+>&%! $+! 2$+$%('.! )(! E+$*+W%*2&! )+($;$,)(&#4!*(8&'%!;*2,0&(&0.!9+&V,&;(&#6!M!X+&N!(8)(!2.!<$'%(!<9+&')0!N*90#!-&!#$<<$;90(! )+#!2.!<$'%(!-),($%2!,9'&!-0$%%6!Q9(!M!+&D&'!$2)>$+&#!(8&!8&)'();8&!(8)(!M!N*90#!&V,&'$&+;&! )%!)!,)'$%8!,)%(*'4!N8$0&!(8&!#&+*2$+)($*+!%('9>>0&#!*D&'!892)+!%&V9)0$(.6! ! 38)(! #*! .*9! &50224! %).! (*! )! N*2)+! $+! 8&'! (N$0$>8(! .&)'%! N8*! #*&%! +*(! <900.! 0*D&! 8&'%&0<!-&;)9%&!*<!8&'!%&V9)0$(.Y!C*N!#*!.*9!8&0,!N$,&!)N).!(8&!(&)'%!*<!)!.*9+>!2)+!N8*! ;'$&%! 8$2%&0<! (*! %0&&,! &D&'.! +$>8(! -&;)9%&! 8&! $%! $+! 0*D&! N$(8! )+*(8&'! 2)+Y! 38&+! #*&%! )! 2)''$&#!%)2&P>&+#&'!;*9,0&!%()'(!&+A*.$+>!(8&$'!8*0.!2)('$2*+.4!<'&&!<'*2!(8&!A9#>2&+(! *<!<)2$0.!)+#!;89';8Y!78&%&!)'&!)2*+>!(8&!=9&%($*+%!(8)(!X&,(!2&!9,!)(!+$>8(6!! ! :($004!%*!2)+.!($2&%!M!%)N!'&0$&<!$+!(8&!&.&%!*<!2&+!)+#!N*2&+4!*0#!)+#!.*9+>4!N8*! 8)D&! <$+)00.! <*9+#! )! -0);X! ;89';8! (8)(! ('90.! &2-');&%! (8&2! )+#! (8&$'! %&V9)0$(.W<900.4! 9+;*+#$($*+)00.6!M!N$(+&%%&#!%8&&'!%9','$%&!N8&+!)!N*2)+!$+('*#9;&%!8&'!N$<&!(*!E+$*+!