Volume 2 December 2008 An Empowerment Approach to Gender Equality in the Information Society Regional Analyses from Asia Information Society for the South Series Volume 2 An Empowerment Approach to Gender Equality in the Information Society Regional Analyses from Asia IT for Change Information Society for the South Series Volume 2 An Empowerment Approach to Gender Equality in the Information Society: Regional Analyses from Asia Editors Anita Gurumurthy Parminder Jeet Singh Anja Kovacs Editorial and Production Assistance Adithi N Rao Design Krupa Thimmaiah December 2008 Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-share Alike 2.5 India Licence Published by: IT for Change Bangalore, India www.ITforChange.net Printed at National Printing Press, Bangalore Table of Contents Introduction 5 1. An Empowerment Approach to Gender Equality in the Information Society: Perspectives from East Asia Angela M. Kuga Thas 11 2. What Women Want from IT: Views from Western Asia Deborah L. Wheeler 51 3. ICTs and Women’s Empowerment: Findings from South Asia Mridula Swamy 79 Author and Editor Profiles 111 An Empowerment Approach to Gender Equality in the Information Society 4 Introduction About This Collection This document is the second in the series of publications from IT for Change under the ‘Information Society for the South’ research umbrella. The series is an attempt to build a body of critical work that offers analytical and conceptual tools to understand and engage with the structural changes that information and communication technologies (ICTs) are bringing about in society. This collection of papers comes out of a project undertaken as part of the regional activities of the Gender Caucus1 of the World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS). Advocacy on gender issues in the WSIS Phase One deliberations focused on women’s equal participation in the information society and the mainstreaming of gender perspectives, which found reflection in the ‘Geneva Declaration of Principles 2003’.2 Towards Phase Two of the WSIS held in 2005, the need for concepts to make the connections between the local and global emerged as an important gap required to be filled. Contextualising gender and making the case for gender equality in relation to the emerging information society as a global public policy issue were two sides of the gender advocacy coin. This collaborative research project, conceived in the build-up to the second phase of the WSIS, sought to address this policy advocacy imperative. It offers an analytical framework for women’s empowerment in the information society that is grounded in the particularities of the Asian region, capturing the question of the ‘opportunity structure’ for gender equality in the information society and also problematising the notion of ‘access to ICTs’. The fact that women’s ‘access’ to information and communication technologies is mediated by various factors – caste, religion, ethnicity, income, education, age, etc. – has been well established. However, it was felt that ‘access’ needs to be unpacked further and located in the context of the Asian experience. There was a need to analyse whether and how ICTs do, and can potentially, bring about structural transformation in gender relations and therefore, the conditions framing such access needed to be explored. IT for Change coordinated this effort, and also provided the broad conceptual framework. The research also fed into a wider consultation process to shape the directions for policy advocacy in the second phase of WSIS. The diverse contexts of Asia were sought to be captured through sub-regional analysis. The specific objectives of the research were defined as follows: z To attempt a systematic mapping of women and ICTs in Asia, looking at the individual and structural aspects influencing women’s agency and choices. z To provide a gendered analysis of the key individual and structural-institutional dimensions of women’s empowerment vis-à-vis information society possibilities. It was decided that for the purposes of the research, four thematic areas that are key to understanding women’s empowerment in relation to the information society context would be useful entry points to 5 An Empowerment Approach to Gender Equality in the Information Society examine ‘empowerment’: identity, control and ownership of technology within emerging knowledge paradigms, collective action, and ICTs-induced institutional transformation. Through these thematic areas, the papers examine both individual and structural dimensions of social change in the emerging information society. Broad indicators to unpack each were evolved, even though some did overlap between the themes. The indicators, outlined below, were meant to serve as exploratory pegs: Identity in the information society: z How do ICTs enable/constrain women’s ability to maintain control over their bodies and sexuality? z How can ICTs enable/constrain women’s ability to challenge stereotypes and social and religious norms that confine their choices? z How are new technologies redefining, if indeed they are, women’s identities (self-perception and social status)? z How do ICTs perpetuate/challenge existing stereotypes of ‘women’s work’ and in the process restrict/enhance opportunities available to them? z How can women be enabled to feel more comfortable in availing and optimising opportunities that become available through ICTs in widening spaces of engagement and for individual agency? Control and ownership of technology within emerging knowledge paradigms: z Do new technologies in their very design alienate women? How can women shape the design and nature of ICTs (and create new technologies) to suit their needs? z How can ICTs enable/constrain women’s ability to impart and secure knowledge? z Do existing technology paradigms allow for an equitable information society? How do alternate paradigms – Creative Commons licenses, open content and open access paradigms – further women’s interests? Collective action in the information society: z What role do ICTs play in women’s ability to organise and engage in collective action towards the realisation of their rights? z How do ICTs enable/constrain women’s ability to be represented/participate in decision making bodies and influence decisions that affect their lives? ICT-induced institutional transformation: z What are the gender dimensions of ICT-induced institutional transformation around us – in work and business as well as in governance, health, education, media, social organisation, etc? 6 Introduction For instance, why and how do citizen’s media allow for more equitable inputs from women, how and under what circumstances do ICTs contribute to the productive potential of women in their work spaces?. z How can such change be directed towards engendering institutions in ways that empower women? For instance, how can e-governance bring the interface between public authorities and the community closer to the community? Insights from the Papers about ICTs and Women’s Empowerment in Asia The three papers in this collection have been contributed by Angela Kuga Thas, Deborah Wheeler and Mridula Swamy, who examine the South East Asian, West Asian and South Asian contexts respectively. The papers are based on primary and secondary data. Kuga Thas and Swamy have used statistical data and some case studies, while also engaging in policy analysis; Wheeler, in addition to analysing statistics, has employed personal interviews to look at the interdependencies between individual choice and structural change, exploring the role of macro dimensions in defining micro outcomes as well as the place of policy in inducing transformatory change for women’s empowerment. The papers collectively speak to some key insights summarised as follows: The Empowerment Potential The research papers show how ICTs create new social spaces for women and open up avenues for women’s expression, expanding their social networks and economic opportunities. Virtual freedoms translate into ‘real’ life gains in terms of enhanced confidence and by ending isolation. Cyberspace thus become a space for the creation of new identities – where the transgression of traditional boundaries creates a flux that redefines gender norms. This may happen through avenues for discovering, interacting with, learning about, and changing attitudes toward, the opposite sex in certain cultures, like in Islamic societies. Inside- outside divides significant to women’s realities in the Asian context seem to get destabilised in the spatial reconfiguration of the information society. The information society thus presents new ontological possibilities for emancipation. The research opens up the connections between ‘collective appropriation’ (as against ‘individual consumption’) of ICTs and collective action. Women’s control over technology seems to strengthen their identity, stimulate individual and collective action and transform their status and roles in the community. The emerging public sphere has the potential to foster new sub-cultures or counter-publics through various means like professional and solidarity networks, subaltern media etc., and thus opens up spaces for feminist consciousness. By shaping the content that is shared through technology, grassroots movements and collectives can challenge negative stereotypes in mass media and violence against women in virtual spaces. Through greater networking, ICTs seem to enhance women’s capabilities to assert political claims. ICTs also seem to enable women to capture and share the realities