EMILY CHERTOFF Prosecuting Gender-Based Persecution: The Islamic State at the ICC ABSTRACT. Reports suggest that Islamic State, the terrorist "caliphate," has enslaved and brutalized thousands of women from the Yazidi ethnic minority of Syria and Northern Iraq. In- ternational criminal law has a name for what Islamic State has done to these women: gender- based persecution. This crime, which appears in the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC), has only been charged once, and unsuccessfully, in the Court's two decades of ex- istence. The case of the Yazidi women presents a promising opportunity to charge it again - and, potentially, to shift the lately unpromising trajectory of the Court, which has been weakened in recent months by a wave of defections by former member states. This Note uses heretofore unexamined jurisprudence of the ICC's Pre-Trial Chamber to elaborate- element by element-how the Prosecutor of the Court could charge gender-based persecution against members of Islamic State. I argue that the prosecution of Islamic State would not just vindicate the rights of Yazidi survivors of Islamic State violence. It would help to consol- idate an international norm against gender-based persecution in armed conflict- a norm that, until now, international law has only incompletely realized. This Note argues that only by prose- cuting the crime of gender-based persecution can international criminal law cognize violence, like the attacks on Yazidi women, that is motivated not just by race, ethnicity, or gender, but by the victims' intersecting gender and ethnic or racial identities. I conclude by reflecting on the role that a series of prosecutions against perpetrators of gender-based persecution might have in re- storing the legitimacy of the ailing ICC. AUTHOR. Yale Law School, J.D. expected 2017. The author would like to thank Harold Koh for his thoughtful suggestions and support throughout the drafting process, and Oona Hatha- way and Ali Miller for formative insights and conversations. Megan McGlynn provided extreme- ly helpful and professional editorial feedback, and I thank her as well as Hilary Ledwell, Urja Mittal, and the editors of the Yale Law journal. I am grateful to friends and colleagues who read early drafts of this piece and offered their comments and encouragement, among them Zak Manfredi, Hava Mirell, and Noah Rosenblum, and to my parents for their support. This Note is dedicated to Yazidi survivors of violence, especially the estimated 2,000 Yazidi women who re- mained in Islamic State captivity as of this August. 1050 NOTE CONTENTS INTRODUCTION 1052 1. EVIDENCE OF GENDER-BASED CRIMES AGAINST YAZIDI WOMEN 1056 II. GENDER-BASED PERSECUTION AND THE EXPRESSIVE VALUE OF INTERNATIONAL LAW 1063 A. International Criminal Accountability 1065 B. Creating an International Norm 1o69 C. The Insufficiency of Current Charges at the ICC 1075 1. Current Theoretical Insufficiencies 1075 2. The Need for a Composite Crime io8i III. CHARGING GENDER-BASED PERSECUTION UNDER THE ROME STATUTE: THE ELEMENTS OF A CASE 1o85 A. Threshold Questions: Procedural Matters and Individual Criminal Liability 1o85 1. Jurisdiction lo86 2. Admissibility logo 3. Individual Criminal Responsibility 1091 B. Charging Islamic State with Gender-Based Persecution Under Article 1095 7 (l)(h) of the Rome Statute 1. The Widespread or Systematic Element lo99 2. The Mens Rea Element 1102 3. The Severe Deprivation of Fundamental Rights Element 1104 4. The Nexus with Group Element 1107 5. The Other Criminal Acts Element 1109 IV. GENDER-BASED PERSECUTION AND THE EVOLUTION OF THE ICC 1111 CONCLUSION 1116 1051 THE YALE LAW JOURNAL 126:1050 2017 INTRODUCTION Over the past two years, media reports from Syria and Iraq have document- ed how the terrorist group Islamic State has systematically enslaved and raped women and girls from the Yazidi ethnic minority group.' One emblematic New York Times report details how Islamic State fighters have forced Yazidi women to take birth control in order to avoid violating a supposed religious mandate to abstain from sex with pregnant women slaves. 2 Women who have escaped this torture are fighting back. Some have spoken out against their captors in the press, to human rights observers, and at the United Nations (UN). A group of them has even taken up arms against their former tormenters: a unit of women fighters based in Iraqi Kurdistan is training to take on members of Islamic State alongside the Kurdish peshmerga.' "We want justice," the commander of this battalion told a reporter.5 "We want the men who did this to go to court."6 Yet despite the public outcry and sustained advocacy efforts, justice has remained out of reach. Of particular concern to many outside observers is the apparently premedi- tated nature of the Yazidi women's enslavement and the sexist ideology- evident in Islamic State pamphlets and articles-that underlies it.' France's Minister for Family, Children, and Women's Rights echoed other commenta- tors when she delivered a speech to the United Nations proposing a new inter- national crime - "femicide"' - and insisting that countries take steps to prose- 1. Rukmini Callimachi, To Maintain Supply of Sex Slaves, ISIS Pushes Birth Control, N.Y. TIMES (Mar. 12, 2016) [hereinafter Callimachi, Birth Control], http://www.nytimes.com/2016 /03/13/world/middleeast/to-maintain-supply-of-sex-slaves-isis-pushes-birth-control.html [http://perma.cc/XS8A-QBTZ]; see also Rukmini Callimachi, ISIS Enshrines a Theology of Rape, N.Y. TiMES (Aug. 13, 2015) [hereinafter Callimachi, Theology of Rape], http:// www.nytimes.com/201/08/14/world/middleeast/isis-enshrines-a-theology-of-rape.html [http://perma.cc/K36L- 4 PXT] (reporting Islamic State's development of a radical theologi- cal position that purports to justify the systemic rape of captured women). 2. Callimachi, Birth Control, supra note i. 3. See, e.g., infra notes 191, 252 and accompanying text. 4. Janine di Giovanni, How Yazidi Women Are Fighting Back Against ISIS, VOGUE (Oct. 26, 2016, 11:32 AM), http://www.vogue.com/13495865/sun-ladies-yazidi-women-isis-genocide -sexual-enslavement [http://perma.cc/74SJ-A7EU]. 5. Id. 6. Id. 7. See infra Part I. 8. Adam Taylor, As Kerry Condemns ISIS Genocide, Calls To Recognize Something Else: Femicide, WASH. POST (Mar. 17, 2016), http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp /2016/03/17/as-kerry-condemns-isis-genocide-calls-to-recognize-something-else-femicide 1052 PROSECUTING GENDER-BASED PERSECUTION cute Islamic State at the International Criminal Court (ICC).' Unfortunately, there has never been a successful international trial for gender-based persecu- tion, despite the long and tragic history of gender-based targeting in conflict. Indeed, persecutors in several recent conflicts have singled out women and girls,"o and sometimes men and boys," for vicious, differential treatment. [http://perma.cc/KR34-QM6L]; see also V.G. Julie Rajan, Women, Violence, and the Islamic State: Resurrecting the Caliphate Through Femicide in Iraq and Syria, in VIOLENCE AND GENDER IN THE GLOBALIZED WORLD: THE INTIMATE AND THE EXTIMATE 45 (Sanja Bahun & V.G. Julie Rajan eds., 2d ed. 2015). The term "femicide," which the French Minister for Family, Chil- dren and Women's Rights used in her speech to the UN, emerged not from feminist legal advocacy, but from radical feminist discourse. See, e.g., TERRORIZING WOMEN: FEMINICIDE IN THE AMERICAS (Rosa Linda Fregoso & Cynthia Bejarano eds., 2010); Steven S. Volk & Marian E. Schlotterbeck, Gender, Order, and Femicide: Reading the Popular Culture of Murder in Ciudadjudirez,32AZTLAN: J. CHICANO STUD. 53 (2007). 9. See Taylor, supra note 8. 1o. Beyond the case of Islamic State, there appear to have been patterns of gender-based target- ing of women for brutal rape during the genocides in Rwanda and Yugoslavia and the ongo- ing conflict in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC). See, e.g., infra notes 13, 315-316 and accompanying text (discussing the mass rape of women in Rwanda, Yugoslavia, and DRC, respectively). I use the categories of "women" and "men" throughout this Note to mirror the lan- guage of the Rome Statute, which was drafted in the early 1990s by a broad coalition of states and nonstate stakeholders. Although Article 7 ()(h) talks about persecution on the basis of "gender;' Article 7(3) of the Rome Statute clarifies that "[flor the purpose of this Statute, it is understood that the term 'gender' refers to the two sexes, male and female, within the context of society. The term 'gender' does not indicate any meaning different from the above." Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court arts. 7 ()(h), 7(3), July 17, 1998, 2187 U.N.T.S. 90 [hereinafter Rome Statute]. Valerie Oosterveld attributes this language to the concerns of conservative elements ("[t]he Holy See, certain Arab states, and conservative nongovernmental organizations") that worried the statute might provide a hook for the recognition of the persecution of gays and lesbians or the classification of laws discriminating against women as crimes against humanity. See Valerie Oosterveld, Gender, Persecution, and the InternationalCriminal Court: Refugee Law's Relevance to the Crime Against Humanity of Gender-Based Persecution, 17 DUKE J. COMp. & INT'L L. 49, 58 & n.37 (2006). Ironically, the Statute nonetheless could be interpreted -though in practice, this is perhaps unlikely-to provide a basis for claims of persecution by lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender individuals, since persecution "by reason of" gender as it is socially constructed can be read to permit claims on behalf of individuals who do not fit socially constructed gen- der norms and are persecuted on that basis. It is important to remember when working with international materials that to have broad effect, international law, whether customary or treaty-based, must be the product of broad international consensus (though not unanimi- ty), and that rights and recognitions only beginning to emerge in relatively socially tolerant countries may be a long way off in other countries.