Decision Decision Appellant (party who Case Ref Characteristic Case Detail Site Address Case Status Number Of Units Proposed Date Description submitted the appeal) PPA-190-2016 Housing (more erection of 2 dwelling houses Land At C116 than one house) Loudonston From Decision B730 To South 05/01/2012 Appeal Dismissed 2 units. Mr Sloan Ayrshire Boundary, issued Stair, East Ayrshire PPA-260-2017 Housing (more Erection of 4 storey residential 384-386 Tantallon Decision than one house) development of 24 flats Road, Langside, 12/01/2012 Appeal Allowed 24 flats. Mr Wilson issued Glasgow, G41 3HR PPA-180-2013 Housing (more Change of use and internal conversion of Taymills, 19 Brown Decision Crosslane Investment than one house) existing retail unit (class 1) and store to Street, Dundee,, 12/01/2012 Appeal Allowed 25 apartments. issued Partners (Dundee) LLP 25 student studio apartments DD1 5EF PPA-270-2059 Housing (more Creation of new access and erection of Land At 30 Kilmuir, Decision than one house) 10 affordable houses and 5 serviced Dunvegan, Isle Of 25/01/2012 Appeal Dismissed 6 units. Tulloch Homes Express issued plots Skye PPA-280-2009 Housing (more Application for residential development in Barr'S Brae, Port Decision than one house) principle, including the formation of a Glasgow 08/02/2012 Appeal Dismissed 15 units. Mr Geral Timoney issued new access road PPA-230-2047 Housing (more Res. dev.(incl. affordable housing Land 196m South Of than one house) provision) open space, structure planting 49 Burdiehouse Decision 10/02/2012 Appeal Allowed 100 units. Hallam Land Management & access junction & road alignment Road, Edinburgh issued PPA-110-2013-1 Housing (more Erection of 27 dwellinghouses and Whole Site Land At Decision than one house) garages and access road Upper Arbeadie, 17/02/2012 Appeal Dismissed 27 units. Bancon Developments Ltd issued Banchory PPA-250-2093 Housing (more Planning permission in principal for Tykesburn, Coaltown Decision Lomond Group (Scotland) than one house) residential development Of Balgonie Fife 20/02/2012 Appeal Dismissed 4 units. issued Ltd PPA-250-2097 Housing (more Change of use and demolition of Equestrian Centre, than one house) equestrian centre and erection of 5 Kinaldy Meadows, Decision dwellinghouses and landscaping South Of St 05/03/2012 Appeal Dismissed 5 units. Blazon Investments Ltd Andrews, St issued Andrews PPA-250-2092 Housing (more Erection of 7 dwellinghouses and Mayview, Fa-Latch than one house) alterations to existing dwellinghouse Road, Balcurvie, Decision Davidson Baxter 19/03/2012 Appeal Dismissed 7 units plus alterations to exisiting unit. including new road structure and Leven, KY8 5DS issued Partnership Ltd upgrade PPA-270-2060 Housing (more Conversion of offices to 7 flats Former Highland Decision than one house) Council Offices, Main 23/03/2012 Appeal Allowed 7 flats. Mr & Mrs Smienk issued Street, Golspie PPA-140-2032 Housing (more Erection of 82 dwellinghouses Land East And North than one house) incorporating affordable housing East Of St Andrew'S Decision 05/04/2012 Appeal Dismissed 82 units. Springfield Properties Plc. Close, West Linton issued PPA-270-2072 Housing (more Erection of three houses Land To South West than one house) Of Craigmore, Upper Decision 12/04/2012 Appeal Allowed 3 units. Mr John Bird Ardelve, Ardelve, issued Kyle PPA-280-2012 Housing (more Flatted development Ground Off Decision than one house) Killochend Drive, 16/04/2012 Appeal Dismissed 31 units. Ecos Construction issued Greenock PPA-250-2108 Housing (more Appeal against imposition of condition 9 Leng Home, 59 Kirk Decision than one house) of planning permission 11/00878/full Road, Newport On 25/04/2012 Appeal Allowed 3 units. Mr Kitching issued Tay, Fife, DD6 8JB PPA-170-2031 Housing (more Residential development including Laverockhall, than one house) formation of access, open space, Lochmaben Decision R&D Construction Group 27/04/2012 Appeal Dismissed 52 units. footpaths, landscaping and associated issued Limited works PPA-190-2015 Housing (more Residential development with access, Land At Fardalehill, than one house) community infrastructure, West Of Bonnyton, Decision landscaping,earthworks,suds & Land To North Of 08/05/2012 Appeal Allowed Up to approcimately 550 units. Lands Improvement associated works Irvine Road, issued Kilmarnock PPA-100-2036 Housing (more Erection of 5 no. town houses 46 Culter House Decision than one house) Road, (plots 3&4), 14/05/2012 Appeal Dismissed 5 units. Place D'Or 659 Ltd issued Milltimber PPA-340-2067 Housing (more Erectionof 14 dwellinghouses Land West Of Fraser Decision than one house) Avenue, Wolfhill, 14/06/2012 Appeal Dismissed 14 units. Mr Fenton issued PH2 6DG PPA-290-2015 Housing (more In principle for residential development, Kevock Vale Park, than one house) associated infrastructure, landscaping West Mill Road, Decision 18/06/2012 Appeal Allowed Not more than 64 units. Mr Aston and ancillary works Lasswade, EH18 issued 1LX PPA-110-2102 Housing (more Erection of 24 dwellinghouses and Site At South Of The than one house) associated works Aberdeen/tarves Decision Road, Pitmedden, 26/06/2012 Appeal Dismissed 24 units. Chap Homes Ltd Ellon issued PPA-280-2013 Housing (more Construction of 42 terraced houses Vacant School Site than one house) including new access road and all Between Banff Road Decision 29/06/2012 Appeal Allowed 42 units. River Clyde Homes ancillary works And Nairn Road, issued Greenock PPA-170-2036 Housing (more Erection of 10 holiday units, install Bardistane Farm, than one house) sewage treatment plant and soakway. Gatehouse Of Fleet, Decision 12/07/2012 Appeal Dismissed 10 units. Mr Hussey formation of access and assoc works Castle Douglas, DG7 issued 2HA PPA-400-2028 Housing (more A 0.3 ha residential development Land At Main Street, Decision Not specified as planning permission in 20/07/2012 Appeal Dismissed Mr Paton than one house) Stoneyburn issued principle. PPA-320-2039 Housing (more Construction of 80 flats (approval of Moodiesburn House than one house) reserved matters specified in planning Hotel, 6 permission 05/01935/out) Cumbernauld Road, Decision 24/07/2012 Appeal Dismissed 80 flats. Tulloch Homes Ltd Moodiesburn, North issued Lanarkshire, G69 0AA PPA-110-2112 Housing (more Demolition of existing supermarket and Haldanes Store, than one house) redevelopment of site (erection of 62 no. Ythan Terrace, Ellon Decision 25/07/2012 Appeal Dismissed 62 flats. Warsash Properties flats, 1,000 sq metres of retail units. issued PPA-220-2018 Housing (more Erection of 6 dwellinghouses Site Adjacent To than one house) North Of 30 And 68 Decision Moray Gardens, 30/07/2012 Appeal Dismissed 6 units. Sim Building Group Ltf Clarkston, East issued Renfrewshire PPA-320-2041 Housing (more Demolition of church hall and erection of Holy Trinity Scottish than one house) flatted residential development(6 units) Episcopal Church Decision and car parking Hall, Crawford 30/07/2012 Appeal Allowed 6 units. Ms Fowler Street, Motherwell, issued ML1 3AD PPA-320-2040 Housing (more Residential development (in principle) Land At Stable Road, than one house) Shotts (also Known Decision Hazeldene Homes Shotts 01/08/2012 Appeal Dismissed 186 units. As Torbothie) issued Ltd PPA-250-2112 Housing (more Erection of 28 flatted dwellings and St Nicholas, St than one house) conversion/refurbishment of building into Leonards School Decision 14 flatted dwellings and alterations Abbey Walk St 03/08/2012 Appeal Dismissed 42 flats. Knightsbridge Homes Andrews Fife, KY16 issued 9LE PPA-300-2017 Housing (more Creation of a children's nursery and 9 no. Woodlands, Roseisle Decision than one house) private dwellings Drive, Elgin 23/08/2012 Appeal Allowed 9 units & 1 nursery Mrs Robertson issued PPA-270-2074 Housing (more Erection of 3 dwellinghouses and Fern Hollow And Decision than one house) garages Evelix Cottage, 29/08/2012 Appeal Allowed 3 units Galliford Try Construction issued Scotsburn PPA-340-2065 Housing (more Residential-led development to provide Land Adjacent To Court of than one house) 1800 new homes, primary school, Huntingtowerfield Session 12/09/2012 Appeal Dismissed 1800 units. The Pilkinton Trust leisure, retail, office facilities and access And Ruthvenfield, Decision Perthshire Issued PPA-240-2021 Housing (more Demolition of former hotel and erection of The Former than one house) 56 flats with associated roads, Whyteside House Decision infrastructure and landscaping Hotel, 1 Lewis Road, 20/09/2012 Appeal Dismissed 56 flats. Eadie Developments Ltd Polmont, Falkirk, issued FK2 0XJ PPA-340-2070 Housing (more Residential development comprising 6 Kirktonlees Farm, than one house) low density crofts, woodland, paddocks Castleton Road, Decision 01/10/2012 Appeal Dismissed 6 units. Kirktonlees Farm Ltd and permaculture working environments Auchterarder,, PH3 issued 1JS PPA-250-2117 Housing (more Erection of 4 flatted dwellings Land To North Of Decision than one house) Clifton Bank, Well 04/10/2012 Appeal Dismissed 4 flats. Mr Roberts issued Street, Cupar, Fife PPA-110-2108 Housing (more Erection of 60 houses, bridge, business Land At Fetternear than one house) & tourism accom. visitors centre to Estate, Kemnay, Decision 10/10/2012 Appeal Dismissed 60 units. Mr David Fyffe bishop's palace & renov of cottage Inverurie issued PPA-230-2074 Housing (more Mixed use development Unit 13, 1 Slateford Decision than one house) Road, Edinburgh, 11/10/2012 Appeal Allowed 34 units. AMA (New Town) Ltd issued EH11 1NX PPA-120-2018 Housing (more Residential development with associated 129 Dundee Road Decision than one house) vehicular access ( including demolition of Forfar, DD8 1JD 15/10/2012 Appeal Dismissed 20 units. Mr Allan Butchart issued dwellinghouse) PPA-110-2116 Housing (more Erection of 8 dwellinghouses Land To North Of Decision than one house) Shannoch, Breda 17/10/2012 Appeal Dismissed 8 units. Mr Hamish McLean issued Estate, Alford PPA-110-2117 Housing (more Erection of 8 dwelling houses Land To South East Decision than one house) Of Fairlea, Breda 17/10/2012 Appeal Dismissed 8 units.