Energy Extraction from Static Black Hole Binaries Lucas Timotheo Sanches1, ∗ and Maur´ıcio Richartz2, y 1Centro de Ci^enciasNaturais e Humanas, Universidade Federal do ABC (UFABC), 09210-170 Santo Andr´e,S~aoPaulo, Brazil 2Centro de Matem´atica, Computa¸c~aoe Cogni¸c~ao, Universidade Federal do ABC (UFABC), 09210-170 Santo Andr´e,S~aoPaulo, Brazil We define and sketch the generalized ergosphere of the Majumdar-Papapetrou spacetime. In particular, we demonstrate the existence of closed orbits of negative energy that live outside the event horizon of such a spacetime. Relying on the Penrose process mechanism, we use these orbits to illustrate the possibility of energy extraction from a binary black hole by particle scattering. We also analyze the efficiency of the process, and construct explicit examples that optimize the extraction of energy. I. INTRODUCTION interaction allows for highly efficient energy extraction schemes, such as the one introduced in Ref. [8] to model The best mathematical description of rotating black the emission of ultra-high energy cosmic rays from su- holes is given by the theory of General Relativity and, in permassive black holes. Furthermore, recent numerical particular, by the Kerr metric [1{4]. Unlike static black simulations of plasma and jets around Kerr black holes holes, a Kerr black hole is characterized by the existence indicate the important role that negative energy parti- of a very peculiar region around its event horizon, known cles and the Penrose process play on the total energy as the ergosphere. Particles that reach the ergosphere can flux coming from the black hole's jets [9]. still avoid the event horizon and, hence, are not doomed The aim of our work is to investigate energy extrac- to end at the spacetime singularity. Nevertheless, any ob- tion via the Penrose process in a black hole binary sys- server lying inside the ergosphere is unavoidably dragged tem. Any study involving astrophysical binary systems along by the rotational motion of the black hole. must acknowledge the fact that there is no known ex- Particles inside the ergosphere may have negative en- act analytical solution of Einstein's equations describing ergies (according to a static observer at infinity). Relying such a system. Even if numerical or approximate analyt- on this property, Penrose and Floyd devised a mechanism ical solutions (obtained, for example, through Numerical (known as the Penrose process) to extract energy from Relativity or Post Newtonian methods) are employed, a rotating black hole [5]. The idea consists in sending a the fact that the associated metric is non-stationary lim- particle from infinity towards the black hole and assumes its the applicability of the standard concept of an ergo- that, once inside the ergosphere, it decays into two other sphere. Recognizing these difficulties, in this paper we particles. If one of the fragments is counter-rotating with investigate the possibility of energy extraction from the the black hole and has negative energy, it will be captured Majumdar-Papapetrou (MP) metric [10, 11], which is an by the black hole, meaning that the other fragment will exact solution of Einstein's equations that describes a escape to infinity. Due to the conservation of the four- static binary of extremally charged black holes. momentum, the escaping fragment will have more energy and more angular momentum than the incident particle. Despite its simplicity, the MP solution has recently Rotational energy and angular momentum are, thus, ef- been used as a surrogate model for black hole binaries fectively extracted from the black hole. in order to understand how single black hole phenomena To illustrate the importance of the Penrose mechanism, transpose to a binary system. For instance, Ref. [12] has we highlight a few of the many recent research endeav- employed the MP metric to understand the connection ours that attempt to establish a relation with observ- between quasinormal modes and light rings in the context able astrophysical phenomena. The collisional version of black hole binaries. Refs. [13, 14], on the other hand, of the process, for instance, considers multiple particles have computed the shadows cast by a MP binary to bet- that collide and scatter in the ergoregion, allowing ar- ter understand chaotic scattering in a binary black hole bitrarily high center-of-mass energies. This process can system. The resulting shadow shares many similarities arXiv:2108.12408v1 [gr-qc] 27 Aug 2021 potentially act as a mechanism to eliminate dark matter and qualitative features with the shadows computed in particles near a supermassive black hole [6]. The mag- Ref. [15] using a numerically simulated binary black hole netic Penrose process [7], on the other hand, considers background. Ref. [16] has also applied the MP metric charged particles and black holes surrounded by mag- to analyze particle scattering around a black hole binary netic fields (originated, for instance, by plasma accre- and asserted its effectiveness in approximating a head on tion disks around the black hole). The electromagnetic collision in the limit of large separations and small ap- proach speeds. We follow here an analog approach in order to gain physical intuition and qualitative insights about energy extraction from black hole binaries by the ∗ [email protected] Penrose mechanism. In particular, we extend the con- y [email protected] cept of a particle dependent generalized ergosphere [17], 2 which enables the extraction of electromagnetic energy forces and, hence, do not follow geodesics. If the electro- from Reissner-N¨ordstrom(RN) black holes, to the MP magnetic interaction is attractive, negative energy tra- solution and study how the energy extraction efficiency jectories and energy extraction are, in principle, possi- is affected by the presence of a companion black hole. ble. For a single charged black hole described by the Our paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II A we in- RN metric, the fact that the Penrose process is viable troduce the MP spacetime and derive the equations of was shown in Ref. [20]. Building on the notion of a gen- motion for a charged massive particle. In Sec. II B the eralized ergosphere [17, 20], we shall study the motion notion of a generalized ergosphere is laid down and ex- of charged particles around the MP spacetime to investi- plored, while the existence of negative energy orbits is gate the possibility of negative energy motion and energy studied in Sec. II C. In Sec. III we show how a Penrose extraction. process can be set up in the MP spacetime and we give explicit examples of such a process. In Sec. IV we analyze how much energy can be extracted and how it depends A. Motion of charged particles in MP on the several parameters describing the system. The last section is dedicated to our final remarks. The motion of a massive charged test particle (with charge-to-mass ratio µ) in a spacetime with metric gµν , subject to the electromagnetic potential Aµ, is deter- II. THE MAJUMDAR-PAPAPETROU mined by the Lagrangian SPACETIME 1 µ ν α L = gµν x_ x_ − µAαx_ ; (2.4) The MP spacetime is a static electrovacuum solu- 2 tion of Einstein's equations that represents a set of ex- where xµ = xµ(λ) denotes the position of the particle at tremal black holes whose mutual gravitational attrac- proper time λ and the dots represent derivatives with re- tion is cancelled by their mutual electromagnetic repul- spect to λ. Adopting Weyl's cylindrical coordinates, and sion [10, 11, 18]. For two black holes of masses M1 and taking into account the explicit form of the MP metric, M2 and electric charges Q1 = M1 and Q2 = M2, in equi- the Lagrangian above can be recast as [21] librium and separated by a distance 2a along the z-axis, the MP line element, in Weyl's cylindrical coordinates 1 t_2 1 (t; ρ, φ, z), is given by [19] L = − + U 2 ρ_2 + ρ2φ_2 +z _2 − µ 1 − t:_ 2 U 2 U (2.5) dt2 2 2 2 2 2 2 Since the Lagrangian does not depend explicitly on t ds = − 2 + U(ρ, z) dρ + ρ dφ + dz ; (2.1) U(ρ, z) and φ, two constants of motion (as measured by freely- falling observers at infinity) can be readily identified. The where constant associated with the time symmetry is the energy M M divided by the mass m of the particle: U(ρ, z) = 1 + 1 + 2 : (2.2) pρ2 + (z + a)2 pρ2 + (z − a)2 @L t_ 1 E = − = + µ 1 − : (2.6) _ 2 The electromagnetic potential Aµ associated with the @t U U MP solution is The constant associated with the angular symmetry is 1 the angular momentum per unit mass (with respect to A = 1 − δ ; (2.3) µ U µt the z axis): @L where δµν is the Kronecker delta. We note that Weyl's L = = U 2ρ2φ._ (2.7) coordinates describe only the exterior of the black holes. @φ_ The event horizons and the black holes themselves are collapsed into the points ρ = 0; z = ±a. We denote the Plugging the constants of motion into the 4-velocity normalization condition, i.e.x _ µx_ = −1, and solving for total mass of the binary system by MT = M1+M2 and its µ E, yields mass ratio by MR = M2=M1. Without loss of generality, we assume that 0 ≤ MR ≤ 1. s Being described by a static metric, the MP spacetime 1 L2 1 E = µ 1 − + + +ρ _2 +z _2; (2.8) does not possess an ergosphere (in the usual sense of a U ρ2U 4 U 2 spacetime region outside the black hole where the Killing µ vector (@t) becomes spacelike).