The Free Electron Gas in Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics Vasil Rokaj,1, ∗ Michael Ruggenthaler,1, y Florian G. Eich,1 and Angel Rubio1, 2, z 1Max Planck Institute for the Structure and Dynamics of Matter, Center for Free Electron Laser Science, 22761 Hamburg, Germany 2Center for Computational Quantum Physics (CCQ), Flatiron Institute, 162 Fifth Avenue, New York NY 10010 (Dated: May 31, 2021) Cavity modification of material properties and phenomena is a novel research field largely mo- tivated by the advances in strong light-matter interactions. Despite this progress, exact solutions for extended systems strongly coupled to the photon field are not available, and both theory and experiments rely mainly on finite-system models. Therefore a paradigmatic example of an exactly solvable extended system in a cavity becomes highly desireable. To fill this gap we revisit Som- merfeld's theory of the free electron gas in cavity quantum electrodynamics (QED). We solve this system analytically in the long-wavelength limit for an arbitrary number of non-interacting elec- trons, and we demonstrate that the electron-photon ground state is a Fermi liquid which contains virtual photons. In contrast to models of finite systems, no ground state exists if the diamagentic A2 term is omitted. Further, by performing linear response we show that the cavity field induces plasmon-polariton excitations and modifies the optical and the DC conductivity of the electron gas. Our exact solution allows us to consider the thermodynamic limit for both electrons and photons by constructing an effective quantum field theory. The continuum of modes leads to a many-body renormalization of the electron mass, which modifies the fermionic quasiparticle excitations of the Fermi liquid and the Wigner-Seitz radius of the interacting electron gas. Lastly, we show how the matter-modified photon field leads to a repulsive Casimir force and how the continuum of modes introduces dissipation into the light-matter system. Several of the presented findings should be experimentally accessible. I. INTRODUCTION light and matter has led to a number of great funda- mental discoveries, like the laser cooling [15{17], the first The free electron gas introduced by Sommerfeld in realization of Bose-Einsten condensation in dilute gases 1928 [1] is a paradigmatic model for solid state and con- and the atom laser [18, 19], the theory of optical coher- densed matter physics. It was originally developed for ence [20] and laser-based precision spectroscopy [21, 22], the description of thermal and conduction properties of and the manipulation of individual quantum systems metals, and has served since then as one of the funda- with photons [23, 24]. mental models for understanding and describing mate- In most cases simplifications of QED are employed for rials. The free electron gas with the inclusion of the the practical use of the theory (due to its complexity) in electron-electron interactions, was transformed into the which matter is described by a few states. This leads to homogeneous electron gas [2, 3], known also as the jellium the well-known models of quantum optics, like the Rabi, model, and with the advent of density functional theory Jaynes-Cummings or Dicke models [25{27]. Although, (DFT) and the local density approximation (LDA) [4] has these models have served well and have been proven very become one of the most useful computational tools and succesful [28], recently they are being challenged by novel methods in physics, chemistry and materials science [5]. developments in the field of cavity QED materials [12]. Also within the Fermi liquid theory, developed by Lan- For this, first-principle approaches have already been put dau [6], the free electron gas model was used as the funda- forward using Green's functions methods [29], the ex- mental building block [7]. In addition, the free electron act density-functional reformulation of QED, known as arXiv:2006.09236v4 [quant-ph] 27 May 2021 gas in the presence of strong magnetic fields has also QEDFT [30{32], hybrid-orbital approaches [33, 34], or been proven extremely important for the description of generalized coupled cluster theory for electron-photon the quantum Hall effect [8, 9]. systems [35, 36]. On the other hand, the cornerstone of the modern de- Cavity QED materials [12, 37, 38] is an emerging scription of the interaction between light and matter, in field, combining many different platforms for manipulat- which both constituents are treated on equal quantum ing and engineering quantum materials with electromag- mechanical footing, and both enter as dynamical entities, netic fields, ranging from quantum optics [14], polari- is quantum electrodynamics [10{14]. This description of tonic chemistry [12, 39{47], and light-induced states of matter using either classical fields [48, 49] or quantum fields originating from a cavity [50{53]. A plethora of pathways have been explored recently from both theo- ∗ [email protected] rists and experimenters. Quantum Hall systems under y [email protected] cavity confinement, in both the integer [54{58] and the z [email protected] fractional [59, 60] regime, have demonstrated ultrastrong 2 coupling to the light field and modifications of trans- Performing linear response [3, 91, 92] for the interact- port [61]. Light-matter interactions have been suggested ing electron-photon system in the cavity, we compute the to modify electron-phonon coupling and superconductiv- optical conductivity σ(w) in which we identify diamag- ity [62{65] with the first experimental evidence already netic modifications to the standard conductivity of the having appeared [66]. Cavity control of excitons has been free electrons gas, coming from the cavity field. Fur- investigated [67{69] and exciton-polariton condensation ther, in the static limit we find that the cavity field sup- has been achieved [70, 71]. Further, the implications presses the DC conductivity and the Drude peak of the of coupling to chiral electromagnetic fields has also at- 2DEG. This shows that a cavity can alter the conduc- tracted interest and is currently investigated [72{75]. tion properties of 2D materials as suggested also experi- Much of our understanding and theoretical descrip- mentally [61, 66]. Our linear response formalism demon- tion of light-matter interactions and of these novel ex- strates that plasmon-polariton resonances exist for this periments, is based on finite-system models from quan- interacting electron-photon system [93, 94] and provides tum optics. However, extended systems like solids be- a microscopic quantum electrodynamical description of have very much differently than finite systems and it plasmon-polaritons. is questionable whether the finite-system models can be To overcome the discrepancy between the electronic straightforwardly extended to describe macroscopic sys- sector, in which the energy density of the electrons is tems, like materials, strongly coupled to a cavity. It is finite, and the photonic sector, whose energy density in therefore highly desirable, in analogy to the Rabi and the the thermodynamic limit vanishes, we promote the single Dicke model [25{27], to have a paradigmatic example of mode theory into an effective quantum field theory in the an extended system strongly coupled to the quantized 2D continuum by integrating over the in-plane modes of cavity field. the photon field. The area of integration in the photonic The aim of this work is to fill this gap, by revisiting momentum space is directly connected to the effective Sommerfeld's theory [1] of the free electron gas in the cavity volume and the upper cutoff in the photon mo- framework of QED and providing a new paradigm for menta defines the effective coupling of the theory. More- many-body physics in the emerging field of cavity QED over, in the effective field theory the energy density of the materials. photon field becomes finite and renormalizes the electron In this article we introduce and study in full general- mass [95{97]. The renormalized mass depends on the full ity the 2D free electron gas (2DEG) coupled to a cav- electron density in the cavity which means that we have ity. We show that this system in the long-wavelength a many-body contribution to the renormalized mass due limit and for a finite amount of cavity modes is ana- to the collective coupling of the electrons to the cavity lytically solvable and we find the full set of eigenstates field. In addition, the renormalized electron mass shows and the eigenspectrum of the system. Specializing to the up in the expression for the chemical potential and mod- paradigmatic case of just one effective mode (with both ifies the fermionic quasiparticle excitations of the Fermi polarizations included) we highlight that in the large N liquid. Upon the inclusion of the Coulomb interaction, or thermodynamic limit the ground state of the elec- the mass renormalization leads also to a shrinking of the trons is a Slater determinant of plane waves with the Wigner-Seitz radius, which implies a localization effect momenta of the electrons distributed on the 2D Fermi for the electrons. From the energy density of the photon sphere, thus it is a Fermi liquid. On the other hand, the field in the cavity we compute the corresponding Casimir photon field gets strongly renormalized by the full elec- force [98, 99] (pressure) and we find that due to the in- tron density and the combined light-matter ground state teraction of the cavity field with the 2DEG, the Casimir exhibits quantum fluctuation effects and contains virtual force is repulsive [100]. Furthermore, we are able to de- photons. Moreover, we study the full phase diagram of scribe consistently and from first principles dissipation the system (see Fig. 4) and we find that when the cou- and absorption processes without the need of any artifi- pling approaches its maximum value (critical coupling) cial damping parameter [3, 92].