LISTING OF CITATIONS - VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE

Hearing on 6th June 2018 at 10.00 am in Committee Room 2, Woodhill House, Westburn Road,

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

1 15803/52449 SHOP TAWSE TYRE CO LTD P 4,900 4,900 49 DUKE STREET RYDEN LLP A

2 15846/54895 SHOP LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 5,800 5,800 1 GORDON STREET HUNTLY MONTAGU EVANS A

3 15875/53915 SHOP ETC DUNCAN TAYLOR SCOTCH WHISKY LTD P 11,750 11,750 36 GORDON STREET HUNTLY

4 15880/53239 SHOP JAMES RIZZA & SONS LTD T 4,600 4,600 16 GORDON STREET HUNTLY WYMRE A

5 15888/55549 BANK BANK OF P 16,500 16,500 2 GORDON STREET PER CBRE HUNTLY CBRE LTD A

6 15948/61833 SHOP PETERKINS P 16,750 16,750 3 THE SQUARE HUNTLY RYDEN LLP A

7 15949/57882 SHOP T M RETAIL GROUP T 9,400 9,400 5 THE SQUARE HUNTLY GERALD EVE LLP A

8 15950/55501 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 9,800 9,800 7 THE SQUARE C/O CBRE PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT HUNTLY TSB TEAM CBRE LTD A

9 15955/60210 INFORMATION CENTRE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 5,300 5,300 9A THE SQUARE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HUNTLY RYDEN LLP A

10 15955/63855 INFORMATION CENTRE VISIT SCOTLAND T 5,300 5,300 9A THE SQUARE PER MARGARET CRAWFORD HUNTLY GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

11 15957/56002 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP P 14,000 14,000 THE SQUARE PER NELSON BAKEWELL HUNTLY GVA A

12 15964/53918 SHOP RAYMOND PARKIN P 17,250 17,250 26 THE SQUARE T/A HUNTLY CARPETS HUNTLY

13 33246/60221 SHOP ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 12,500 12,500 INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STEVEN ROAD HUNTLY RYDEN LLP A

02/02/2018 Page 1 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

14 65743/54739 CAFE UA LIVESTOCK LTD P 9,400 9,400 AUCTION MART THE WARD HUNTLY PRESTON TAIT A

15 16503/57300 SUPERMARKET C W S LTD P 20,750 20,750 VICTORIA BUILDINGS RETAIL FINANCIAL SERVICES 2 DONSIDE ROAD ALFORD COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

16 39361/58165 SHOP J G ROSS (HOLDINGS) LTD P 4,200 4,200 UNIT 5 C/O J G ROSS HAUGHTON SQUARE MAIN STREET F G BURNETT LTD A

17 16519/52402 SHOP W & R MURRAY (RADIO & TV) P 15,750 15,750 27 MAIN STREET ALFORD SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

18 16526/57301 OFFICE PETERKINS T 9,900 9,900 39 MAIN STREET ALFORD RYDEN LLP A

19 16528/64089 SHOP COLTEL HOLDINGS BRAESIDE P 13,750 13,750 49 MAIN STREET BUSINESS DEVELOPMENTS LTD ALFORD

20 16545/60250 RESTAURANT THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 12,500 12,500 72 MAIN STREET PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES ALFORD RYDEN LLP A

21 16548/55990 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP T 13,250 13,250 54 MAIN STREET PER NELSON BAKEWELL ALFORD GVA A

22 16555/55507 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 10,500 10,500 32 MAIN STREET C/O CBRE PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT ALFORD TSB TEAM CBRE LTD A

23 16702/56581 SHOP ETC MRS JEAN GARDEN P 4,000 4,000 MOSSAT ALFORD

24 16995/57888 SHOP MARTIN MCCOLL LIMITED T 10,750 10,750 28 AQUITHIE ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A

25 17024/55993 SHOP KEMNAY PHARMACY LTD T 17,250 17,250 13 HIGH STREET KEMNAY SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

26 17025/57047 SUPERMARKET THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD P 24,750 24,750 20 HIGH STREET C/O RATE ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT KEMNAY COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL RATE UK LLP COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

27 17026/58157 SHOP ETC J G ROSS (HOLDINGS) LTD P 11,500 11,500 DAVIDSONS BUILDINGS C/O J G ROSS 18 HIGH STREET KEMNAY F G BURNETT LTD A

02/02/2018 Page 2 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

28 17051/57040 SUPERMARKET C W S LTD P 19,250 19,250 STATION ROAD RETAIL FINANCIAL SERVICES KEMNAY COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

29 17331/58034 SHOP LAASYA ENTERPRISES LTD T 13,500 13,500 EIGIE ROAD T/A CONVENIENCE STORE BALMEDIE

30 59103/57039 SUPERMARKET CO-OP GROUP T 43,500 43,500 UNIT 1 STORE ACCOUNTS BIRCH WAY BALMEDIE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

31 17517/57058 SUPERMARKET THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD T 45,750 45,750 SUMMERHILL C/O RATE ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT 27 ROAD COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL RATE UK LLP COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

32 17549/62568 RESTAURANT ETC A & M DEVELOPMENTS P 18,000 18,000 CROSSROADS CULLERLIE ECHT

33 17654/57060 SUPERMARKET THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD T 34,500 34,500 BLACKBURN C/O RATE ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT KINELLAR COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL RATE UK LLP ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

34 53980/56794 SHOP ETC LLOYDS PHARMACY LTD T 24,250 24,250 LLOYDS PHARMACY DISCOVERY DRIVE ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

35 57883/54501 SHOP CARLTON ROCK LTD P 20,000 20,000 UNIT 1 ASHDALE DRIVE WESTHILL A B ROBB A

36 57883/56824 SHOP W H (EDINBURGH) LTD O 20,000 20,000 UNIT 1 ASHDALE DRIVE WESTHILL WYMRE A

37 85838/54503 SHOP CARLTON ROCK LTD P 38,250 38,250 UNIT 2 & 3 ASHDALE DRIVE WESTHILL A B ROBB A

38 81209/54567 SURGERY CARLTON ROCK LTD P 24,500 24,500 UNIT 4A ASHDALE DRIVE WESTHILL A B ROBB A

39 56604/54570 RESTAURANT CARLTON ROCK LTD P 41,250 41,250 UNIT 4B ASHDALE DRIVE WESTHILL A B ROBB A

40 56383/54572 SHOP CARLTON ROCK LTD P 21,000 21,000 UNIT 5 ASHDALE DRIVE WESTHILL A B ROBB A

41 54304/54592 SHOP CARLTON ROCK LTD P 20,500 20,500 UNIT 6 ASHDALE DRIVE WESTHILL A B ROBB A

02/02/2018 Page 3 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

42 54527/54593 SHOP CARLTON ROCK LTD P 17,250 17,250 UNIT 7 ASHDALE DRIVE WESTHILL A B ROBB A

43 17801/56774 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 34,000 34,000 UNIT 21 & 22 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

44 17803/52485 SHOP SPECSAVERS OPTICAL SUPERSTORES LTD T 24,750 24,750 UNIT 20 C/O R2G LTD OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL GERALD EVE LLP A

45 17803/56773 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 24,750 24,750 UNIT 20 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

46 17805/55416 SUPERMARKET MARKS & SPENCER PLC T 285,000 285,000 UNIT 18 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL GERALD EVE LLP A

47 17805/56772 SUPERMARKET BNY MELLON TRUST & P 285,000 285,000 UNIT 18 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

48 17807/56791 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 25,500 25,500 UNIT 16 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 34 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

49 72303/56792 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 15,750 15,750 UNIT 16A DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 34 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

50 17808/56795 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 22,750 22,750 UNIT 15 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 32 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

51 17809/56796 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 25,000 25,000 UNIT 14 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 30 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

52 17810/56798 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 24,750 24,750 UNIT 13 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 28 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

53 17811/56799 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 25,000 25,000 UNIT 12 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 26 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

54 17812/56800 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 12,250 12,250 UNIT 11 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 24 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

55 17813/56801 OFFICE BNY MELLON TRUST & P 26,000 26,000 UNIT 10 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 22 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

02/02/2018 Page 4 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

56 17814/53957 SHOP PIZZAWEST LTD O 22,750 22,750 UNIT 1 20 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES A

57 17814/56797 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 22,750 22,750 UNIT 1 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 20 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

58 17814/63887 SHOP DP REALITY LTD T 22,750 22,750 UNIT 1 T/A DOMINO'S PIZZA 20 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES A

59 17815/54812 SHOP DONE BROTHERS (CASH BETTING) LTD T 22,750 22,750 UNIT 2 T/A BETFRED 18 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL GERALD EVE LLP A

60 17815/56802 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 22,750 22,750 UNIT 2 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 18 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

61 17816/55020 SHOP SPORTSWIFT LTD T 22,750 22,750 UNIT 3 T/A CARD FACTORY 16 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL GERALD EVE LLP A

62 17816/56803 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 22,750 22,750 UNIT 3 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 16 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

63 17817/56825 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 22,750 22,750 UNIT 4 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 14 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

64 17818/56804 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 22,750 22,750 UNIT 5 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 12 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

65 17819/55597 HAIRDRESSING SALON JOHN LOW T 22,750 22,750 UNIT 6 T/A LOW & CO 10 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL RYDEN LLP A

66 17819/56783 HAIRDRESSING SALON BNY MELLON TRUST & P 22,750 22,750 UNIT 6 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 10 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

67 17820/56782 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 22,750 22,750 UNIT 7 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 8 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

68 17820/62385 SHOP BARNARDOS T 22,750 22,750 UNIT 7 8 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL G L HEARN LIMITED A

69 17821/56781 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 22,500 22,500 UNIT 8 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 6 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

02/02/2018 Page 5 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

70 17822/56779 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 51,000 51,000 UNIT 9 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD 4 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

71 17822/57031 SHOP THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD T 51,000 51,000 UNIT 9 C/O RATE ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT 4 OLD SKENE ROAD COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL RATE UK LLP WESTHILL COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

72 87466/56775 VETERINARY SURGERY BNY MELLON TRUST & P 17,750 17,750 UNIT 24 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

73 87466/57364 VETERINARY SURGERY TOWN & COUNTRY VETERINARY GROUP T 17,750 17,750 UNIT 24 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL F G BURNETT LTD A

74 87585/56776 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 160,000 160,000 UNIT 25 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

75 87585/62916 SHOP T J MORRIS LTD T 160,000 160,000 UNIT 25 T/A HOME BARGAINS OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL THE BEATTIE PARTNERSHIP A

76 87709/56777 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 38,750 38,750 UNIT 26 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

77 87709/56793 SHOP LLOYDS PHARMACY LTD T 38,750 38,750 UNIT 26 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

78 87360/52481 SHOP COSTA LTD T 30,750 30,750 UNIT 27 OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL GERALD EVE LLP A

79 87360/56789 SHOP BNY MELLON TRUST & P 30,750 30,750 UNIT 27 DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD OLD SKENE ROAD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

80 17823/56003 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP T 42,750 42,750 2 OLD SKENE ROAD PER NELSON BAKEWELL WESTHILL GVA A

81 17823/56778 BANK BNY MELLON TRUST & P 42,750 42,750 2 OLD SKENE ROAD DEPOSITORY (UK) LTD WESTHILL CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

82 81777/63603 LICENSED RESTAURANT MRS K WONG P 76,500 76,500 UNIT 2 WESTHILL DRIVE WESTHILL INTERIM PROFESSIONAL SERVICES A

83 35440/55648 SHOP WILL CHEMISTS () LTD P 22,000 22,000 2A BURGHMUIR DRIVE INVERURIE J & E SHEPHERD A

02/02/2018 Page 6 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

84 17869/57063 SUPERMARKET THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD T 35,250 35,250 BURGHMUIR DRIVE C/O RATE ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT INVERURIE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL RATE UK LLP COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

85 50969/57049 SHOP NEW LOOK RETAILERS LTD T 75,500 75,500 UNIT 1 STATION SQUARE BURN LANE G L HEARN LIMITED A INVERURIE

86 53881/52487 SHOP SUPERDRUG STORES PLC T 43,250 43,250 UNIT 2A STATION SQUARE BURN LANE GERALD EVE LLP A INVERURIE

87 50197/52486 SHOP POUNDLAND LTD T 78,000 78,000 UNIT 3 PER GERALD EVE STATION SQUARE BURN LANE GERALD EVE LLP A INVERURIE

88 53938/57773 SHOP EDINBURGH WOOLLEN MILL T 41,500 41,500 UNIT 2B STATION SQUARE BURN LANE WYMRE A INVERURIE

89 79743/55417 SUPERMARKET MARKS & SPENCER PLC T 153,000 153,000 UNIT 4 & 5 STATION SQUARE BURN LANE GERALD EVE LLP A INVERURIE

90 64883/62374 RESTAURANT WILLIAM BIRD P 38,000 38,000 BURN LANE T/A FENNEL RESTAURANT & GALLERY INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

91 85243/56829 SHOP CANCER RESEARCH UK T 23,000 23,000 UNIT B C/O COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL BURNSIDE COURT WEST HIGH STREET COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A INVERURIE

92 87650/52457 SHOP INVERURIE WHISKY SHOP LTD T 19,750 19,750 UNIT A BURN LANE INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

93 30516/53964 SHOP DP REALITY LTD T 12,000 12,000 UNIT 5 T/A DOMINO'S PIZZA CENTRE CONSTITUTION STREET WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES A INVERURIE

94 30518/57420 SHOP CAREERS SCOTLAND T 25,250 25,250 UNIT 6 PER CUSTOMER SERVICES MANAGER GARIOCH CENTRE CONSTITUTION STREET GVA A INVERURIE

95 31046/55563 BANK BANK OF SCOTLAND P 43,250 43,250 UNIT 10-12 PER CBRE GARIOCH CENTRE CONSTITUTION STREET CBRE LTD A INVERURIE

96 17890/63599 OFFICE SWINTON PROPERTIES LTD P 11,250 11,250 2 CONSTITUTION STREET INVERURIE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

97 17960/56590 SHOP MRS VIVIENNE STEWART P 17,000 17,000 39 HIGH STREET INVERURIE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

02/02/2018 Page 7 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

98 17961/62428 SHOWROOM A & J ROBERTSON (GRANITE) LTD T 28,750 28,750 43 HIGH STREET INVERURIE MITCHELL MANAGEMENT SERVICES A

99 17964/52333 SHOP MAX BRUCE T 40,500 40,500 63 HIGH STREET T/A CRAIGDON MOUNTAIN SPORTS INVERURIE (INVERURIE) LTD RYDEN LLP A

100 17983/56820 SHOP MACKAYS STORES LTD T 32,250 32,250 15 MARKET PLACE INVERURIE J & E SHEPHERD A

101 17985/56004 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP P 37,250 37,250 21 MARKET PLACE PER NELSON BAKEWELL INVERURIE GVA A

102 17987/52473 SHOP BOOTS UK LIMITED T 35,750 35,750 25 MARKET PLACE PER GERALD EVE LLP INVERURIE GERALD EVE LLP A

103 17990/56823 SHOP MACKAYS STORES LTD T 66,000 66,000 27 MARKET PLACE OWNERS OF 27-31 MARKET PLACE INVERURIE J & E SHEPHERD A

104 17992/58161 SHOP J G ROSS (HOLDINGS) LTD P 13,750 13,750 35 MARKET PLACE C/O J G ROSS INVERURIE F G BURNETT LTD A

105 17993/58903 SHOP BEGG SHOES & BAGS LIMITED P 41,500 41,500 37 MARKET PLACE INVERURIE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

106 17997/52578 SHOP THE ASHVALE FISH RESTAURANTS LTD P 33,750 33,750 51 MARKET PLACE INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

107 18001/61819 SHOP T & H SINCLAIR T 78,500 78,500 63 MARKET PLACE INVERURIE F G BURNETT LTD A

108 18014/54971 SHOP DALCARNIE LTD P 30,500 30,500 1 NORTH STREET INVERURIE

109 18017/58159 SHOP J G ROSS (HOLDINGS) LTD P 10,750 10,750 9 NORTH STREET C/O J G ROSS INVERURIE F G BURNETT LTD A

110 18018/57062 SUPERMARKET THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD P 52,250 52,250 11 NORTH STREET C/O RATE ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT INVERURIE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL RATE UK LLP COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

111 31981/54973 SHOP DALCARNIE LTD P 10,500 10,500 4A NORTH STREET INVERURIE

02/02/2018 Page 8 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

112 18040/54972 SHOP DALCARNIE LTD P 29,750 29,750 6 NORTH STREET INVERURIE

113 18040/57373 SHOP RAEBURN CHRISTIE CLARK & WALLACE T 29,750 29,750 6 NORTH STREET INVERURIE F G BURNETT LTD A

114 49972/63394 SHOP LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 37,250 37,250 UNIT 1-2 STATION ROAD INVERURIE MONTAGU EVANS A

115 49979/52483 SHOPS SPECSAVERS T 45,000 45,000 UNITS 4 & 5 STATION ROAD INVERURIE GERALD EVE LLP A

116 84381/61817 SHOP CRAIGDON MOUNTAIN SPORTS P 15,500 15,500 4 VICTORIA STREET INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

117 18062/63116 BETTING OFFICE WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD T 26,000 26,000 3 WEST HIGH STREET PROPERTY DEPARTMENT INVERURIE G L HEARN LIMITED A

118 18063/57308 SHOP I N V (EDINBURGH) LTD O 14,000 14,000 9 WEST HIGH STREET T/A SUBWAY INVERURIE WYMRE A

119 18069/52401 SHOP AYHAN YILDIRIM T 17,000 17,000 17 WEST HIGH STREET T/A THE PHONE BOX INVERURIE SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

120 18073/57884 POST OFFICE R I K RETAIL LTD P 36,000 36,000 33 WEST HIGH STREET INVERURIE J & E SHEPHERD A

121 18075/55024 SHOP ETC WILL CHEMISTS (INVERURIE) LTD P 44,000 44,000 35 WEST HIGH STREET INVERURIE J & E SHEPHERD A

122 18080/53974 SHOP M A S (INVERURIE) LTD T 16,500 16,500 47 WEST HIGH STREET INVERURIE

123 18081/62764 OFFICE ATHOLL SCOTT LTD T 23,500 23,500 57 WEST HIGH STREET CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

124 18086/52340 SHOP DOLCE VITA FLOWERS LTD T 9,600 9,600 70 WEST HIGH STREET INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

125 18089/63608 SHOP ETC COLIN FORBES T 43,500 43,500 54 WEST HIGH STREET T/A C FORBES FLOORING INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

02/02/2018 Page 9 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

126 18089/63609 SHOP ETC THOMAS MCPHEE P 43,500 43,500 54 WEST HIGH STREET T/A WEST HIGH STREET GARAGE INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

127 18096/53985 SHOP SHILU MIAH T 29,500 29,500 36 WEST HIGH STREET T/A SM (SCOTLAND} LTD INVERURIE

128 18097/55503 BANK TSB BANK PLC T 35,000 35,000 32B WEST HIGH STREET C/O CBRE PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT INVERURIE TSB TEAM CBRE LTD A

129 18099/58919 BANK CB SCOTSNORTH LTD P 46,750 46,750 26 WEST HIGH STREET INVERURIE CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

130 33979/57376 SHOP E WISEMAN P 30,750 30,750 24 WEST HIGH STREET INVERURIE F G BURNETT LTD A

131 18102/56830 SHOP BRITISH HEART FOUNDATION T 33,500 33,500 12 WEST HIGH STREET INVERURIE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

132 86215/52404 SHOP BOOTH SCOTLAND LTD P 68,500 68,500 5 BURN LANE INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

133 18104/59045 SHOPS PATRICK SERRELL O 20,750 20,750 8-10 WEST HIGH STREET T/A KILTED FROG DELICATESSEN LTD INVERURIE

134 18148/62383 SHOP R SLOAN P 18,000 18,000 129 HIGH STREET INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

135 18158/62375 SHOP ELLEN STEWART T 28,750 28,750 28A HIGH STREET T/A INTERIORS UNLIMITED INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

136 18165/63854 INFORMATION CENTRE VISIT SCOTLAND P 17,000 17,000 18 HIGH STREET PER MARGARET CRAWFORD INVERURIE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

137 18181/53986 SHOP LIVE LOVE CRAFT LTD O 15,500 15,500 70 MARKET PLACE INVERURIE

138 18189/62382 SHOP SLOANS INTERNATIONAL P 39,250 39,250 44 MARKET PLACE T/A WATSONS INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

139 18193/62336 SHOP ETC PATRICK D MITCHELL KEITH A WHYTE & P 79,000 79,000 20 MARKET PLACE JUDY M WHYTE INVERURIE T/A MITCHELLS

02/02/2018 Page 10 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

140 40309/52360 OFFICE PETERKINS T 14,250 14,250 INVER HOUSE MARKET PLACE INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

141 18231/54832 SHOP THE FOUNTAIN (SCOTLAND) LTD SSAS P 15,250 15,250 LADESIDE ROAD PORT ELPHINSTONE J & E SHEPHERD A

142 87636/55528 SUPERMARKET SAINSBURY'S SUPERMARKETS LTD T 49,750 49,750 UNIT 3 PER G L HEARN MIDMILL PARADE KINTORE CBRE LTD A

143 87731/53228 SURGERY WILLIAM DOCHERTY T 25,000 25,000 UNIT 4 & 5 T/A KINTORE DENTAL PRACTICE MIDMILL PARADE KINTORE WYMRE A

144 30553/54874 OFFICE A C MORRISON & RICHARDS T 1,000 1,000 SALES BOOTH 27A & 27B THAINSTONE CENTRE THAINSTONE F G BURNETT LTD A

145 30554/56807 OFFICE CLOSE BROTHERS LTD T 1,000 1,000 SALES BOOTH 27C & 27D THAINSTONE CENTRE THAINSTONE GERALD EVE LLP A

146 30557/57052 SHOP HARBRO LTD T 21,000 21,000 UNIT 1 GROUND FLOOR THAINSTONE CENTRE THAINSTONE DM HALL LLP A

147 31352/64023 SHOP AGRIPARTS LTD T 24,750 24,750 UNIT 3 GROUND FLOOR THAINSTONE CENTRE THAINSTONE

148 30558/58926 BANK CLYDESDALE BANK PLC T 49,750 49,750 UNIT 4-5 GROUND FLOOR PER DTZ THAINSTONE CENTRE THAINSTONE CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

149 31355/52450 SHOP LEDINGHAM CHALMERS LLP T 14,000 14,000 UNIT 1 1ST FLOOR THAINSTONE CENTRE THAINSTONE RYDEN LLP A

150 31356/52579 OFFICES SAC T 31,250 31,250 UNIT 2-3 1ST FLOOR PROPERTY & ESTATES GROUP THAINSTONE CENTRE THAINSTONE GERALD EVE LLP A

151 18381/52397 SHOWROOM DAVID V MOAR P 18,500 18,500 16 FOREST ROAD T/A MOAR HOUSE FURNISHERS KINTORE SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

152 36228/57043 SUPERMARKET THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD T 42,500 42,500 NORTHERN ROAD C/O RATE ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT KINTORE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL RATE UK LLP COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

153 18572/63865 SHOP ERIC W G NEIL (BAKERS) LTD P 7,000 7,000 KIRKTON DAVIOT KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

02/02/2018 Page 11 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

154 18659/53900 OFFICES THE PROPERTY MANAGEMENT CO T 24,500 24,500 MARKET SQUARE OLDMELDRUM

155 18664/58164 SHOP J G ROSS (HOLDINGS) LTD P 23,500 23,500 26 MARKET SQUARE C/O J G ROSS OLDMELDRUM F G BURNETT LTD A

156 18666/58163 SHOP J G ROSS (HOLDINGS) LTD P 14,500 14,500 30 MARKET SQUARE C/O J G ROSS OLDMELDRUM F G BURNETT LTD A

157 68203/60100 CAFE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 5,500 5,500 TOWN HALL PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES MARKET SQUARE OLDMELDRUM RYDEN LLP A

158 18694/58254 SHOP MRS JACQUELINE ALLEN P 7,200 7,200 2 URQUHART ROAD OLDMELDRUM

159 18820/57055 SUPERMARKET THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP FOOD LTD T 34,750 34,750 38 COMMERCE STREET COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

160 18838/58006 SHOP MARTIN THE NEWSAGENT LTD T 21,750 21,750 1 HIGH STREET INSCH GERALD EVE LLP A

161 18840/55511 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 6,600 6,600 11 HIGH STREET C/O CBRE PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT INSCH TSB TEAM CBRE LTD A

162 36357/60283 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 2,000 2,000 INSCH STATION PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES INSCH RYDEN LLP A

163 45022/58355 SHOP MCCOLL'S RETAIL GROUP P 11,000 11,000 UNIT 2 1 PROVOST DAVIDSON DRIVE ELLON GERALD EVE LLP A

164 19187/55999 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP P 24,500 24,500 15 BRIDGE STREET PER NELSON BAKEWELL ELLON GVA A

165 31062/62096 SHOP GEORGE DONALD (WAREHOUSEMAN) LTD P 35,000 35,000 49 BRIDGE STREET ELLON F G BURNETT LTD A

166 31066/56834 SHOP TUI UK LTD T 9,400 9,400 UNIT 6 33 BRIDGE STREET ELLON COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

167 87473/62762 SHOP MOUNTVIEW T 8,600 8,600 GROUND FLOOR T/A STONEHOUSE LETTINGS 23 BRIDGE STREET ELLON G L HEARN LIMITED A

02/02/2018 Page 12 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

168 19202/56808 SHOP MRS MURIEL DUNCAN T 18,500 18,500 40 BRIDGE STREET T/A BEST WISHES ELLON J & E SHEPHERD A

169 19204/55499 BANK TSB BANK PLC T 22,750 22,750 36 BRIDGE STREET C/O CBRE PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT ELLON TSB TEAM CBRE LTD A

170 19205/57889 SHOP FORBUOYS PLC T 15,000 15,000 32 BRIDGE STREET ELLON GERALD EVE LLP A

171 30177/54899 SHOP LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 12,000 12,000 2A BRIDGE STREET ELLON MONTAGU EVANS A

172 19248/57037 SUPERMARKET THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD T 51,000 51,000 ESSLEMONT CIRCLE C/O RATE ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT ELLON COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL RATE UK LLP COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

173 19280/58917 BANK CLYDESDALE BANK PLC T 37,000 37,000 28 MARKET STREET PER DTZ ELLON CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

174 19300/52361 SHOP THE ASHVALE CHIP SHOP LTD P 9,200 9,200 3 SQUARE ELLON RYDEN LLP A

175 19301/55544 BANK BANK OF SCOTLAND P 20,250 20,250 5 SQUARE PER CBRE ELLON CBRE LTD A

176 19303/57386 OFFICES RAEBURN CHRISTIE CLARK & WALLACE P 19,000 19,000 7 SQUARE ELLON F G BURNETT LTD A

177 19304/62959 SUPERMARKET COSTCUTTER SUPERMARKETS GROUP LTD T 73,250 73,250 SQUARE ELLON SANDERSON WEATHERALL LTD A

178 19379/52436 SHOWROOM FRASERS HOUSE FURNISHERS P 30,750 30,750 YTHAN VILLA (ELLON) LTD YTHAN TERRACE ELLON RYDEN LLP A

179 19384/53196 SURGERY DR J MARK DONALDSON BDS P 6,500 6,500 UNIT 2 T/A YTHAN BRIDGE DENTAL CENTRE YTHAN TERRACE ELLON WYMRE A

180 85444/60561 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 1,200 1,200 SMUGGLERS CONE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BEACH SHELTER LOW TOWN RYDEN LLP A COLLIESTON

181 19547/53269 SURGERY HADDO MEDICAL GROUP T 2,700 2,700 THE OLD BAKERY METHLICK ELLON WYMRE A

02/02/2018 Page 13 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

182 19640/55401 SUPERMARKET C J LANG & SON LTD P 18,750 18,750 13 THE SQUARE J & E SHEPHERD A

183 19728/57038 SUPERMARKET THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD P 19,500 19,500 WESTVIEW C/O RATE ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL RATE UK LLP ELLON COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

184 35742/60577 INFORMATION CENTRE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 7,700 7,700 CRATHIE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES RYDEN LLP A

185 19888/55565 BANK BANK OF SCOTLAND P 2,800 2,800 7 INVERCAULD ROAD PER CBRE CBRE LTD A

186 33265/60584 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 5,400 5,400 UNIT 1 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES THE MEWS MAR ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRAEMAR

187 33263/61216 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 5,300 5,300 UNIT 2 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES THE MEWS MAR ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRAEMAR

188 33264/60585 INFORMATION CENTRE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 6,300 6,300 UNIT 3 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES THE MEWS MAR ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRAEMAR

189 33264/63850 INFORMATION CENTRE VISIT SCOTLAND T 6,300 6,300 UNIT 3 PER MARGARET CRAWFORD THE MEWS MAR ROAD GRAHAM & SIBBALD A BRAEMAR

190 33301/60586 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 16,000 16,000 UNIT 4 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES THE MEWS MAR ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRAEMAR

191 19910/57041 SUPERMARKET ALLDAYS STORES LTD T 20,000 20,000 14 MAR ROAD PER HILARY WITTS BRAEMAR RATING MANAGER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

192 20027/54231 SHOP HELLISTER LTD P 3,300 3,300 2 BRAEMAR ROAD PER AB ROBB LTD BALLATER A B ROBB A

193 20039/55546 BANK BANK OF SCOTLAND P 16,750 16,750 9 BRIDGE STREET PER CBRE BALLATER CBRE LTD A

194 20047/64249 RESTAURANT ETC BRAEMAR MOUNTAIN SPORTS LTD P 23,500 23,500 THE ROWAN TREE RESTAURANT 43 BRIDGE STREET BALLATER

195 20058/55518 SHOP WALTER DAVIDSON & SONS P 10,750 10,750 10 BRIDGE STREET CHEMISTS BALLATER J & E SHEPHERD A

02/02/2018 Page 14 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

196 20079/57056 SUPERMARKET CO-OPERATIVE GROUP FOOD LIMITED T 99,500 99,500 GOLF ROAD BALLATER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

197 20100/60596 SHOP ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 4,100 4,100 CENTRAL FILLING STATION PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STATION SQUARE BALLATER RYDEN LLP A

198 20230/56759 SUPERMARKET SCOTMID T 43,000 43,000 CRAIGOUR ROAD PROPERTY & BUILDING SERVICES DEPT RYDEN LLP A

199 20263/61857 SHOP KINCARDINE ESTATE P 2,300 2,300 27 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD PER STRUTT & PARKER KINCARDINE O'NEIL STRUTT & PARKER A

200 20264/61856 SHOP KINCARDINE ESTATE P 2,300 2,300 29A NORTH DEESIDE ROAD PER STRUTT & PARKER KINCARDINE O'NEIL STRUTT & PARKER A

201 38096/62453 SHOP ETC KINCARDINE ESTATE P 4,700 4,700 THE OLD SMIDDY PER STRUTT & PARKER NORTH DEESIDE ROAD KINCARDINE O'NEIL STRUTT & PARKER A

202 20390/55517 SHOP WALTER DAVIDSON & SONS P 11,250 11,250 ALFORD HOUSE CHEMISTS BALLATER ROAD J & E SHEPHERD A

203 81747/52446 OFFICE MACKINNONS T 19,500 19,500 UNIT A BALLATER ROAD ABOYNE RYDEN LLP A

204 20392/55505 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 11,250 11,250 BALLATER ROAD C/O CBRE PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT ABOYNE TSB TEAM CBRE LTD A

205 20393/61538 SHOP TSB PLC P 4,800 4,800 BALLATER ROAD ABOYNE CBRE LTD A

206 20397/58924 BANK CLYDESDALE BANK PLC T 8,800 8,800 BALLATER ROAD PER DTZ ABOYNE CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

207 20479/61242 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 5,300 5,300 UNIT 1 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STATION BUILDINGS STATION SQUARE RYDEN LLP A ABOYNE

208 20480/60643 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 6,800 6,800 UNIT 2 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STATION BUILDINGS STATION SQUARE RYDEN LLP A ABOYNE

209 20481/60644 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 7,500 7,500 UNIT 3 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STATION BUILDINGS STATION SQUARE RYDEN LLP A ABOYNE

02/02/2018 Page 15 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

210 20482/60645 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 2,900 2,900 UNIT 4 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STATION BUILDINGS STATION SQUARE RYDEN LLP A ABOYNE

211 52233/61243 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 3,800 3,800 UNIT 5 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STATION BUILDINGS STATION SQUARE RYDEN LLP A ABOYNE

212 20484/60646 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 5,300 5,300 UNIT 6 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STATION BUILDINGS STATION SQUARE RYDEN LLP A ABOYNE

213 20486/60647 HAIRDRESSING SALON THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 3,800 3,800 UNIT 9 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STATION SQUARE ABOYNE RYDEN LLP A

214 20487/61244 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 2,600 2,600 UNIT 10 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STATION SQUARE ABOYNE RYDEN LLP A

215 34749/60655 SURGERY THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 5,100 5,100 SHAWS COURT PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BRIDGE STREET RYDEN LLP A

216 20649/61818 SHOP ORVIS CO INC T 55,000 55,000 2 BRIDGE STREET BANCHORY AITCHISON RAFFETY A

217 35962/61250 AMUSEMENT CENTRE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 3,950 3,950 BELLFIELD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES DEE STREET BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

218 20683/53962 SHOP ETC DUNCANS OF BANCHORY P 38,500 38,500 2 DEE STREET BANCHORY

219 20698/58914 SHOP W H SMITH LTD T 35,250 35,250 33 HIGH STREET BANCHORY GERALD EVE LLP A

220 20699/57068 SHOP ALLDAYS STORES LTD T 37,250 37,250 37 HIGH STREET PER HILARY WITTS BANCHORY RATING MANAGER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

221 20706/56006 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP P 35,000 35,000 59 HIGH STREET PER NELSON BAKEWELL BANCHORY GVA A

222 20707/55516 SHOP WALTER DAVIDSON & SONS T 30,750 30,750 61 HIGH STREET BANCHORY J & E SHEPHERD A

223 20709/55066 SHOP INGASETTER LTD P 21,000 21,000 67 HIGH STREET T/A CHARLES MICHIE, CHEMISTS BANCHORY F G BURNETT LTD A

02/02/2018 Page 16 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

224 20714/57385 OFFICE RAEBURN CHRISTIE CLARK & WALLACE P 35,000 35,000 UNIT 2 - 4 75 HIGH STREET BANCHORY F G BURNETT LTD A

225 20717/53966 SHOP PARK LANE ESTATES P 14,750 14,750 UNIT 6 75 HIGH STREET BANCHORY A B ROBB A

226 20723/55510 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 22,750 22,750 82 HIGH STREET C/O CBRE PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT BANCHORY TSB TEAM CBRE LTD A

227 20727/54656 SHOP DEEDREAM LIMITED P 11,750 11,750 78 HIGH STREET C/O TAYLOR INDUSTRIAL SERVICES BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

228 20729/54658 SHOP DEEDREAM LIMITED P 37,000 37,000 72 HIGH STREET C/O TAYLOR INDUSTRIAL SERVICES BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

229 20729/57881 SHOP MCCOLL'S T 37,000 37,000 72 HIGH STREET BANCHORY GERALD EVE LLP A

230 36359/54660 BANK DEEDREAM LIMITED P 24,250 24,250 70 HIGH STREET C/O TAYLOR INDUSTRIAL SERVICES BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

231 36359/55561 BANK BANK OF SCOTLAND T 24,250 24,250 70 HIGH STREET PER CBRE BANCHORY CBRE LTD A

232 20732/56831 SHOP CANCER RESEARCH UK T 21,250 21,250 64 HIGH STREET C/O COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL BANCHORY COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

233 20733/57305 SHOP SSE RETAIL LTD P 31,250 31,250 62 HIGH STREET FAO ESTATES SURVEYOR BANCHORY SSE LTD ESTATES SURVEYOR A

234 20734/54830 SHOP CHALMERS BAKERY LTD T 13,250 13,250 56 HIGH STREET BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

235 20734/56754 SHOP BAMMA PROPERTIES LTD P 13,250 13,250 56 HIGH STREET PER RYDEN BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

236 35391/56748 SHOP BAMMA PROPERTIES LTD P 9,500 9,500 UNIT 8-9 PER RYDEN SCOTT SKINNER SQUARE 56 HIGH STREET RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

237 35390/56749 SHOP BAMMA PROPERTIES LTD P 7,700 7,700 UNIT 7 PER RYDEN SCOTT SKINNER SQUARE 56 HIGH STREET RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

02/02/2018 Page 17 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

238 35389/56753 SHOP BAMMA PROPERTIES LTD P 11,750 11,750 UNIT 5-6 PER RYDEN SCOTT SKINNER SQUARE 56 HIGH STREET RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

239 49009/56750 SHOP BAMMA PROPERTIES LTD P 6,100 6,100 UNIT 4 PER RYDEN SCOTT SKINNER SQUARE 56 HIGH STREET RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

240 48358/56751 SHOP BAMMA PROPERTIES LTD P 5,000 5,000 UNIT 3 PER RYDEN SCOTT SKINNER SQUARE 56 HIGH STREET RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

241 35387/56752 HAIRDRESSING SALON BAMMA PROPERTIES LTD P 10,250 10,250 UNIT 2 PER RYDEN SCOTT SKINNER SQUARE 56 HIGH STREET RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

242 35393/56755 SHOP BAMMA PROPERTIES LTD P 11,000 11,000 UNIT 1 PER RYDEN SCOTT SKINNER SQUARE 56 HIGH STREET RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

243 20739/58921 BANK CLYDESDALE BANK PLC T 34,000 34,000 38 HIGH STREET PER DTZ BANCHORY CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

244 83218/61253 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 6,700 6,700 1 RAEMOIR ROAD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

245 20768/60666 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 3,000 3,000 1A RAEMOIR ROAD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

246 36592/54659 SHOP DEEDREAM LIMITED P 9,000 9,000 11 SCOTT SKINNER SQUARE C/O TAYLOR INDUSTRIAL SERVICES BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

247 38408/54657 SHOP DEEDREAM LIMITED P 5,600 5,600 13 SCOTT SKINNER SQUARE C/O TAYLOR INDUSTRIAL SERVICES BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

248 20796/55913 SHOP SCOTTISH MIDLAND CO-OPERTATIVE P 14,000 14,000 TILLYBRAKE ROAD SOCIETY LTD BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

249 20808/52355 SHOP THE ASHVALE P 8,200 8,200 4 WATSON STREET BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

250 37042/63959 SHOP BANCHORY TRUST P 11,250 11,250 MILTON PER STRUTT & PARKER CRATHES BANCHORY STRUTT & PARKER A

251 20900/57774 SHOP THE EDINBURGH T 20,000 20,000 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD WOOLLEN MILL (GROUP) LTD BANCHORY WYMRE A

02/02/2018 Page 18 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

252 38442/55065 SHOP INGASETTER LTD T 13,750 13,750 MEDICAL CENTRE T/A CHARLES MICHIE (CHEMIST) OLD PORTLETHEN ROAD PORTLETHEN F G BURNETT LTD A

253 52699/55596 SHOP F N C (ABERDEEN) LTD T 31,000 31,000 UNIT 1-2 MUIREND COURT PORTLETHEN RYDEN LLP A

254 59543/57312 SHOP PL ABERDEEN LTD O 19,250 19,250 UNIT 5 MUIREND COURT PORTLETHEN WYMRE A

255 21210/58357 SUPERMARKET MCCOLL'S RETAIL GROUP T 27,500 27,500 UNIT 1 ROWANBANK COURT COOKSTON ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A

256 21211/62765 BETTING OFFICE CORAL RACING LTD P 13,000 13,000 UNIT 2 CORAL GALA GROUP ROWANBANK COURT COOKSTON ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A

257 88578/53988 SHOP D P K FOODS LTD O 20,500 20,500 UNIT 3 HILLSIDE COURT PORTLETHEN

258 88476/57048 SUPERMARKET THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD T 55,000 55,000 UNIT 5 C/O RATE ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT HILLSIDE COURT COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL RATE UK LLP PORTLETHEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

259 31573/58358 SUPERMARKET MCCOLL'S RETAIL GROUP T 28,000 28,000 UNIT 3-5 THE GREEN BERRYMUIR ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A

260 38440/53227 SURGERY ANJUM SHAIKH T 17,500 17,500 UNIT 16-17 THE GREEN BERRYMUIR ROAD WYMRE A

261 21617/54007 HAIRDRESSING SALON MRS KATHLEEN M DAVIDSON P 4,100 4,100 OLD BROTHERTON MILL NEW ROAD

262 21750/54981 SHOP INGASETTER LTD P 10,250 10,250 57 KING STREET T/A CHARLES MICHIE, CHEMISTS F G BURNETT LTD A

263 21764/56757 SUPERMARKET SCOTMID P 44,750 44,750 56 KING STREET PROPERTY & BUILDING SERVICES DEPT INVERBERVIE RYDEN LLP A

264 21780/57388 SHOP GRAHAM WALKER P 16,000 16,000 MARKET SQUARE INVERBERVIE

265 21906/57309 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP T 10,000 10,000 19 HIGH STREET PER NELSON BAKEWELL GVA A

02/02/2018 Page 19 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

266 21917/59062 OFFICE FAIRCLOUGH ACCOUNTANCY SERVICES LTD T 7,600 7,600 53 HIGH STREET LAURENCEKIRK

267 21921/54003 OFFICE A9 BOWER & SMITH P 5,200 5,200 75 HIGH STREET LAURENCEKIRK

268 54206/56758 SUPERSTORE SCOTMID P 84,000 84,000 104 HIGH STREET PROPERTY & BUILDING SERVICES DEPT LAURENCEKIRK RYDEN LLP A

269 21954/52418 SHOP ETC ANDREW OGILVIE P 25,250 25,250 64 HIGH STREET T/A MEARNS HARDWARE LTD LAURENCEKIRK SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

270 21964/54976 SHOP INGASETTER LTD T 12,250 12,250 24 HIGH STREET T/A CHARLES MICHIE CHEMISTS LAURENCEKIRK F G BURNETT LTD A

271 88475/57045 SUPERMARKET THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD T 53,500 53,500 ABERDEEN ROAD C/O RATE ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT LAURENCEKIRK COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL RATE UK LLP COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

272 22067/63677 SHOP GAVIN FARQUHAR P 4,100 4,100 ROADSIDE

273 22068/64257 FITNESS CENTRE GAVIN FARQUHAR P 9,900 9,900 ROADSIDE ST CYRUS

274 22072/57890 SHOP MARTIN MCCOLL LIMITED T 8,400 8,400 WAYSIDE SHOP ROADSIDE ST CYRUS GERALD EVE LLP A

275 80816/54867 SHOP ETC THE FIRM OF MURRAY T MITCHELL P 25,500 25,500 CASTLETON FARM SHOP FORDOUN LAURENCEKIRK GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

276 22194/54015 SHOP ETC FRED POWADA P 2,000 2,000 FORDOUN STATION FORDOUN

277 22352/58053 SHOP INDIGO SUN RETAIL LTD T 19,000 19,000 41 ALLARDICE STREET GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

278 22353/56756 SHOP SCOTTISH MIDLAND CO-OPERATIVE T 20,500 20,500 47 ALLARDICE STREET SOCIETY LTD STONEHAVEN PROPERTY DEPARTMENT RYDEN LLP A

279 22359/62124 SORTING OFFICE ROYAL MAIL GROUP PROPERTY P 28,750 28,750 78 ALLARDICE STREET STONEHAVEN G L HEARN LIMITED A

02/02/2018 Page 20 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

280 22360/56817 SHOP MACKAYS STORES LTD P 50,000 50,000 76 ALLARDICE STREET STONEHAVEN J & E SHEPHERD A

281 22362/60775 INFORMATION CENTRE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 7,300 7,300 66 ALLARDICE STREET PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

282 22362/63852 INFORMATION CENTRE VISIT SCOTLAND T 7,300 7,300 66 ALLARDICE STREET PER MARGARET CRAWFORD STONEHAVEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

283 22371/55400 SHOP C J LANG & SON LTD T 39,250 39,250 48 ALLARDICE STREET STONEHAVEN J & E SHEPHERD A

284 52575/63100 SHOP WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD T 18,750 18,750 UNIT 2 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT 30 ALLARDICE STREET STONEHAVEN G L HEARN LIMITED A

285 22381/58922 BANK CLYDESDALE BANK PLC T 15,750 15,750 18 ANN STREET PER DTZ STONEHAVEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

286 22427/60782 SHOP ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 12,500 12,500 THE PROMENADE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BEACH STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

287 22428/61486 PLAY CENTRE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 26,750 26,750 BEACH PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

288 54279/61533 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 8,100 8,100 PROMENADE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BEACH STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

289 62383/60783 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 6,200 6,200 PROMENADE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BEACH STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

290 22488/62386 SHOP GOODFELLOW & STEVEN GROUP LTD P 8,200 8,200 3 EVAN STREET STONEHAVEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

291 22504/57077 FUNERAL REST ROOM FAIRWAYS PARTNERSHIP P 3,900 3,900 57 EVAN STREET CO-OPERATIVE GROUP (CWS) LTD STONEHAVEN REG NO 525R COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

292 22512/60473 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 9,500 9,500 11 KINGS ROAD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

293 22513/60474 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 4,700 4,700 15 KINGS ROAD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

02/02/2018 Page 21 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

294 22514/61450 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 4,900 4,900 17 KINGS ROAD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

295 22525/57384 OFFICE RAEBURN CHRISTIE CLARK & WALLACE P 19,750 19,750 1 MARKET BUILDINGS STONEHAVEN F G BURNETT LTD A

296 22530/57065 SHOP ALLDAYS STORES LTD T 33,000 33,000 12 MARKET SQUARE PER HILARY WITTS STONEHAVEN RATING MANAGER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

297 22534/55998 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP P 25,000 25,000 22 MARKET SQUARE PER NELSON BAKEWELL STONEHAVEN GVA A

298 22535/55064 SHOP CHARLES MICHIE (CHEMIST) P 25,750 25,750 24 MARKET SQUARE STONEHAVEN F G BURNETT LTD A

299 22538/55555 BANK BANK OF SCOTLAND P 24,750 24,750 27 MARKET SQUARE PER CBRE STONEHAVEN CBRE LTD A

300 22541/56810 SHOP GREGGS BAKERS T 15,250 15,250 31 MARKET SQUARE STONEHAVEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

301 22544/52484 SHOP SPECSAVERS OPTICAL SUPERSTORES LTD T 19,250 19,250 33 MARKET SQUARE STONEHAVEN GERALD EVE LLP A

302 48796/54615 SHOP CARLTON ROCK LTD P 36,250 36,250 UNIT 1 REDCLOAK DRIVE STONEHAVEN A B ROBB A

303 48796/57059 SHOP THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD T 36,250 36,250 UNIT 1 C/O COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL REDCLOAK DRIVE RATING DEPARTMENT STONEHAVEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

304 49859/54616 SHOP CARLTON ROCK LTD P 18,250 18,250 UNIT 2 REDCLOAK DRIVE STONEHAVEN A B ROBB A

305 49859/57671 SHOP PIZZA THE ACTION LTD T 18,250 18,250 UNIT 2 REDCLOAK DRIVE STONEHAVEN WYMRE A

306 48982/52366 SHOP CHARLES A WATSON, LORRAINE WATSON & T 18,500 18,500 UNIT 3 MURRAY WATSON REDCLOAK DRIVE STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

307 48982/54638 SHOP CARLTON ROCK LTD P 18,500 18,500 UNIT 3 REDCLOAK DRIVE STONEHAVEN A B ROBB A

02/02/2018 Page 22 of 23 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

308 35552/63390 OFFICE JOHNSTON PUBLISHING LTD T 5,800 5,800 UNIT B 12 ANN STREET STONEHAVEN WYMRE A

309 22635/54885 SUPERMARKET DALCARNIE LTD P 30,000 30,000 1 BARCLAY STREET STONEHAVEN

310 22635/57877 SUPERMARKET FARMFOODS LTD T 30,000 30,000 1 BARCLAY STREET STONEHAVEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

311 22646/58166 SHOP J G ROSS (HOLDINGS) LTD P 6,600 6,600 18 BARCLAY STREET C/O J G ROSS STONEHAVEN F G BURNETT LTD A

312 22691/52444 RESTAURANT ROBERT P CLEAVER & JACKIE M CLEAVER P 26,500 26,500 20 CAMERON STREET T/A CARRON RESTAURANT LTD STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

313 22693/60486 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 5,600 5,600 26A EVAN STREET PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

314 22698/55506 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 22,500 22,500 8 EVAN STREET C/O CBRE PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT STONEHAVEN TSB TEAM CBRE LTD A

315 22700/52472 SHOP BOOTS UK LIMITED T 22,250 22,250 2 EVAN STREET PER GERALD EVE LLP STONEHAVEN GERALD EVE LLP A

316 22711/60490 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 4,000 4,000 32 HIGH STREET PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

317 22713/61457 SHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 2,800 2,800 28 HIGH STREET PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A

318 22722/63702 SHOP TRAVELCARE T 9,500 9,500 3 MARKET SQUARE PER CG PROPERTY STONEHAVEN WYMRE A

319 22724/58195 SHOP TOTE BOOKMAKERS LTD P 12,750 12,750 5 MARKET SQUARE C/O BETFRED STONEHAVEN HART COMMERCIAL SURVEYORS A

320 22728/52417 SHOP GRIGOR WAITE P 25,750 25,750 11 MARKET SQUARE T/A THE FIRM OF CHARLES MCHARDY STONEHAVEN SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

02/02/2018 Page 23 of 23