, ,

, ,

ﺪﺍﺩ ﺃﻣﻴﺮﻱ ﺗﺮﺟﻤﺔ: ﺃﺳﻌﺪ ﻣﻨﺪﻱ ﺍﻟﻜﻌﺒﻲ ـﻘـﺪ ﻣ ﻣ ـﻤـ ﻦ: ﻣﺤ @ @ @ @

òîiŠÌÛa@tìzjÛa@¿@ᎁ@Ší†Ë , ـﺪﻭﻳ òíŒîܬüa@òÌÜÛbi@òã놽a , ﺗ

■ ■

ﺍﻟﺒﺤﺚﻣﻘﺪﻣﺔ ﺍﻟﺒﺤﺚ

;

9

9 , ,

, ,

, , , ,

,

,

;

, , , ,

9

, ,

, ,

9 ,

, ,

, ,

7

, ,

:

,

,

,

, , , , :

,

9 , , ,

9

,

9

, ,

; ;

, , , ,

: , , :

: ,

, ,

, , , , , , , , , , ,

, , , , , , , , : 9 , ,

9 , , ,

, ,

9 , , , , , : : ,

, : ,

, , ,

,

: : : :

9

, ,

9

7

, , , , , , , , : 7

, ,

: 9

9 , , ,

:

! , ,

: , :

− −

,

−

,

, ,

9

:

,

, , , , ,

, ,

, ,

, , : ﺍﻟﻐﺮﺑﻴﺔﻓﻲ ﺍﻟﺪﺭﺍﺳﺎﺕ ﺍﻟﻐﺮﺑﻴﺔ

,

, ,

9

ﺧﻼﻓﺔ ﺍﻟﻨﺒﻲﻣﺤﻤﺪ

■ ,

, ,

? , , 9 , ,

9 , , , ,

7

7 , ,

,

: : ?

; 9

7

, , , :

9

, , , ? , 9

, , 9 , , , ,

7

,

, ,

7

,

9 ,

, ,

; ; ,

, ; ; , ,

, , , , ,

7

, ,

9

7

: , , :

: , :

, 7 ? ?

: , , 9 ,

9

ﺍﻟﻐﺮﺑﻴﻴﻦ ﺎﺣﺜﻴﻦ ﺍﻟﻐﺮﺑﻴﻴﻦ , , , ,

, , 9 , ,

ﺍﻟﺒ ﻧﻈﺮ ﻭﺟﻬﺔ ﻣﻦ ﺍﻟﺴﻴﺮﺓ ﻟﻤﺼﺎﺩﺭ ﺍﻟﻤﻌﺮﻓﻴﺔ ﺍﻟﻘﻴﻤﺔ ﺍﻟﻤﻌﺮﻓﻴﺔ ﻟﻤﺼﺎﺩﺭ ﺍﻟﺴﻴﺮﺓ ﻣﻦ ﻭﺟﻬﺔ ﻧﻈﺮ ﺍﻟﺒ

:

: ﺍﻋﺘﻤﺪﻭﻩ ﺍﻟﺬﻱ ﺍﻟﺒﺤﺚ ﻭﺃﺳﻠﻮﺏ ﺍﻟﺒﺤﺚ ﺍﻟﺬﻱ ﺍﻋﺘﻤﺪﻭﻩ , , ,

, : , , ,

■

, , ,

7 , , , , ,

, ,

, ,

,

, , , , , , , , ,

, ,

, , , :

, , , : ﻏﺪﻳﺮ ﻭﺍﻗﻌﺔ ﺷﻬﺮﺓ ﺍﻟﻤﺠﺘﻤﻊ ﺍﻹﺳﻼﻣﻲ ﻓﻲﺧﻢ ﺍﻷﻭﻝ , , , ; , ,

9 :

■

:

, , ,

, 7 , ,

9

, , ,

, ,

: , , : 7

,

7 , ,

9

, : : , , , 9

, ,

7 , : ? ?

, : : !?

: 9 : , 9

, : , , , , ,

7 , ,

:

7 : ,

9 ?

, : :

, ,

: , : 9 ? : : , , 9 , , , : , : , ? : 9 : : : , : , ,

7

,

, , 7

, , ,

7 :

, ,

, ,

, ,

, , , 7 , ,

; 7

7

7

, , , , ,

: : 9

9

7

, ,

, ,

9 ,

9

9

, : , ,

9 ; ;

9

, ,

; ; , , ,

, ,

7 ,

, , , , , , , , , , , , , : , , :

;

, ; ;

9

; , ; , , , , : , : , : ﺍﻟﻐﺪﻳﺮ ﻭﺍﻟﺤﺪﻳﺚ ﻟﺤﺪﻳﺚ ﺍﻟﺘﺄﺭﻳﺦ ﻣﺴﺘﻮﻯ ﻣﺼﺎﺩﺭﺗﻐﻄﻴﺔ ﻣﺼﺎﺩﺭ ﺍﻟﺘﺄﺭﻳﺦ ﻭﺍﻟﺤﺪﻳﺚ ﻟﺤﺪﻳﺚ ﺍﻟﻐﺪﻳﺮ −

7

− , , ,

−

,

■

, , ,

, , , ,

,

, , , ;

, ,

, ,

, : ,

, ,

, , , ,

,

! :

, ,

, , , , , , , , , ,

: , , , ,

,

,

,

, ,

,

!

, ,

: , :

: :

9

,

, , , , , , , , , ,

, , ,

, ,

, , , ,

,

:

:

, , , ,

: ﺍﻟﻐﺪﻳﺮ , ,

, ,

ﺍﻟﺸﻴﻌﺔﺗﻔﺴﻴﺮ ﻟﺤﺪﻳﺚﻭﺍﻟﺴﻨﺔ ﻟﺤﺪﻳﺚ

, , ,

: : :

7

■

, , , ,

: , : , , , , , ,

9 ) : : : ,

: , :

7 ,

( ) : ,

(

: :

, (

, ) : :

,

, : : , , , , : , , : , : :

9

9

: : : :

, , ,

9

, , : , ,

?

, , , ,

, ,

7

, , , , , , , : : ; ;

; , : , : ,

;

9

− ,

−

; ;

, , , ,

: , : , , ,

, ,

, ,

7

: , , : , , : , , , , , ,

: , :

, , , , , , ,

? , 7

7

,

, , 7 : : , ,

: :

9

9

:

; ; 3

9

, 7 7 ,

: , ,

,

,

, , 9

7 ,

, 7

, ,

9 9

, ,

7 ,

: , , : , , , , , ,

7

: , :

!?

, , , ,

7 , ,

, , , , ,

, : : : , , :

9

:

9

7

,

,

, , , − , 9 ? ?

−

7 , , ,

9

! :

9 ,

: , , : : ﺍﻟﻐﺪﻳﺮ ﺣﺪﻳﺚ ﺗﺤﺮﻳﻒ ﺣﺪﻳﺚ ﺍﻟﻐﺪﻳﺮ

7 : : ,

7

:

9 ■

:

, :

, , 7

: , : , , , , : : 9 , , ,

, , , , − , , − :

9

, , , , , : , : , , , : : , ,

, ,

9 , , ; ; , , , : : , ,

, ,

, ,

: ,

, , 9 : ?

: ? ? , :

, 7

, : , ? , : , ,

,

: ; ; , , , : :

, , , ,

, ,

, , , , , , ; , :

7

: ﻧﺘﻴﺠﺔ ﺍﻟﺒﺤﺚ , ,

, , :

: :

■

, , , , , , , , , ,

, ,

,

7

, , , ,

, , ,

, 5 Brockelmann. 5 Von Carl. Of Heart The 4 phenomenological 3 historicism. 2 ـ nuig aus o Humanit fo Values Enduring ـ h Hat f sa Islam Shi`a to Introduction (An ـ The History and D and History The ـ An Introduction to Shi`a Islam)

, , Nasr, NewNasr,York. 2002,Preface. viii. P. Shi`ism.United UniversityStates,Yale 1985. Press. , , "

, ,

7

* * * , , , , , , :

" : : octrines of of octrines : .(15ـ pp. 11 9 , ayd Hossein Sayyed y, 9

: : 9 −

, : .WorldEncyclopedia Reli of . 25 W.Montgomery 24 Watt. Muhammad:and statesman23 prophet W.Montgomery 22 Watt. Muhammad Madina.21 at Karen 20 Armstrong. Encyclopedia2nd19 ofEdition.Religion, Muhammad. 18 Uri 17 Rubin. 16 Encyclopedia Qur`an. ofthe Muhammad. 15 Brockelmann. Carl. 14 VonـEncyclopedia edition. ofIslam,2nd 29 b.Abi Talib. Karen 28 Armstrong. Muhammad: A27 Biography Prophet. of the Merriam 26 Webster`s 30 30 6 Geschichte 6 derislamischen Volkerund Staaten. 13 Brockelmann. Von. Carl, Geschichte der islamis der Geschichte Carl, Von. Brockelmann. 13 R.Part. 12 R.MuhammadParet, 11 Koran,1975. der und M. Rodinson. 10 Rodinson, M. Paris,Mahomet,9 1961 Staaten, 1939. Staaten,

, ,

L. veccia Vaglieriveccia L. , chen Volker und und Volker chen gions. gions. , Naples − − −

, ; ,

47 Journal of the American Oriental Society, Vol. Society, Oriental American the of Journal 47 didHow 46 become early theShi`a Sectarian. Ahmad45 Moussalli. Hamid 44 Dabashi. Syed43 Hussein Jafri. M. Joseph42 A.Kechichean. TheEncyclopediaOxford41 World. Islamicofthe ShI`I40Islam. Karen 39 Armstrong. History. Islam.A.Short 38 Devin Stewart.37 J. 36 Encyclopedia ofQur`an. 35 Farewell Pilgrimage. Asani. 34 AliS. Encyclopedia33 ofQur`an. Ali 32 b.Abi Talib. 52 TheUnifying52 Arabs. Of The .WorldEncyclopedia Reli of Shi`ate49 Hodgson. Marshall48 S. Gـ Merriam50 Webster`s 50 ـ ,.Mar., 1955)pp.1 13. Mar , , , , , , : : , , , , : , , : , , : ,

, , , , , : , , , , , , , , , ,, , , , .Jan 1. No. 75) ـ No. 1. (Jan .75 , gions. gions.

9 , , − − − − −

; 686 Shi’ism. Kohlberg. 85 E. 84 Shi’ism. 83 Earlyinand HistoryShi'ism Research. Kohlberg. 82 E. 81 Shia. TheofEvolutionthe Hodgson. 80 MarshallS. G. 9 79 78 MaryHegland. Elaine 77 TheEncyclopediaOxfordWorld. Islamicofthe 76 Ahl alBayt. 75 WorldEncyclopedia MerriamWebster’s ofRelig 74 Ali. Kohlberg. 73 E. 72 SomeSahaba.ImamiShi'ithe Views on 71 AbdulazizSachedina. 70 TheEncyclopediaOxfordWorld. Islamicofthe b.Abi69 Ali Talib. M. Gleave. 68 Robert 67 EncyclopediaEdition. d ofIslam, 3 b.Abi66 Ali Talib. 65 WilferdMadelung. Muòhammad:64 The to Succession ofA the Study E 63 Antony Black. 2fro thought: political Islamic of history The 62 61 TheMuhammad.Mission of Ehlert. Trude 60 Encyclopedia59 ndofIslam, 2 Edition. Muhammad.58 h Vnue f sa: osine n Hsoy n a in History and Conscience Islam: of Venture The present. present. Civilization. , , , ; , ,

, , , , , , m the Prophet to the to Prophet the m , , ,

ions. arly . arly Caliphate. World World −

1 intoResearch119 Recent Historythe ofEarly Sh 118 Lalani. Arzina R. 117 TheQuran:Encyclopedia. an Shi’a.116 115 Donaldson. 114 TheShi'ite Religion. 113 TheQuestion ofSuccession. 112 RezaShahKazemi. nd111 Encyclopedia2 Edition. of Religion, b.Abi110 Ali Talib. K.Poonawala. 109 I. Kohlberg. 108 E. 107 Encyclopedia Iranica. b.Abi106 Ali Talib. 105 Abdulaziz Sachedina. 104 TheEncyclopediaOxfordWorld Islamicofthe 103 Imāma. M. Gleave. 102 Robert 101 Muslim EncyclopediaWorld.the andof Islam Shi’a.100 99 WilferdMadelung. 98 Encyclopedia2nd ofEdition. Religion, 97 Imāma. 96 WilferdMadelung. 95 Encyclopedia ndofIslam, 2 Edition. 94 Imāma. 93 WilferdMadelung. 92 Encyclopedia ndofIslam, 2 Edition. 91 Shi’a. 90 WilferdMadelung. 89 Encyclopedia2nd ofEdition. Religion, 88 Shi’ism. 87 Halm. Heinz i'ism. i'ism.

. .

4 147 TheCharismaticCommunity: IdentityShi’ite 2 History The Islam: Shi’i to Introduction An 122 M. Gleave 121 Robert . 120 Muslim EncyclopediaWorld.the andof Islam 4 145 Maria MassiDakake. 144 TheCharismaticCommunity: IdentityShi’ite 3 135 Kazemi134 Ahmad Moussavi. 133 Encyclopedia Iranica. Khumm.132 Ghadir 131 Maria MassiDakake. 130 Encyclopedia Iranica. Khumm.129 Ghadir 128 Lalani. Arzina R. 127 teachings Earlythe ImamM Shi'i thought: of 126 Hermann Landolt. 125 TheQuran:Encyclopedia. an 124 Walayah. 123 MoojanMomen. 4 143 veccia 142 L. Vaglieri. 141 Encyclopedia ndofIslam, 2 Edition. Khumm.140 Ghadir 139 AsmaAfsaruddin. 138 TheQuran:Encyclopedia. an Khumm.137 Ghadir 136 Paula Sanders. Distinctions of Ali b.AbiDistinctionsof Ali Talib. Twelver Shi’ism. TwelverShi’ism. HistoriographyFatimidin Late gypt. liig h ps: hdr hm ad h Rs o H of Rise the and Khumm Ghadir past: the Claiming h Gai Kum rdto: aaa ad h Spiri the and Walayah Tradition: Khumm Ghadir The

Maria Massi Dakake Massi Maria uhammad alir.uhammad in Early Islam. inIslam.Early in Early Islam. inIslam.Early and Docuines of of Docuines and

− afizi afizi tual tual

6 162 6 Mu to SuccessionThe‘‘ReviewMattson, of I. 161 5 the into Research Recent M., Robert Gleave 155 Cambridge1996) University Press, 6 160 the into Research Recent M., Robert Gleave 157 5 153 152 WilferdMadelung. Muhammad.151 The to Succession intoResearch150 Recent Historythe ofEarly Sh 4 148 5 to Succession The of ‘‘Review Graham, A. W. 159 Mu to Succession The of ‘‘Review Morony, M. 158 of Religion, 78.2 (1998): 321.(1998): of Religion, 78.2 Literary Supplement, 4897 (7 Feb,28.4897 Literary (7 1997): Supplement, Middle East Journal, 52.3 Journal,471.52.3 (1998):Middle East (1992): 81–104 (1992): the and Stu Egypt’’, Fatimid late in .Historiography Hafizi Khumm Ghadır Past: the ‘‘Claiming Sanders, Shi’ism” Early of History thi into Research Recent Shi’ism, in: History Compass 7/6, 2009,pp.1593–16in: Shi’ism, 7/6, CompassHistory Caliphate. (Cambridge: Caliphate. Distinctions of Ali b.AbiDistinctionsof Ali Talib. Study of the Early Caliphate’’, MuslimStudyEarlyWorld,of the Caliphate’’, 89.2 2009,pp.1593–16in: Shi’ism, 7/6, CompassHistory Study of the Early Caliphate’’,JNES, 59.2(2000): StudyEarly1 ofthe Caliphate’’,JNES, P. Crone ‘‘Review of The Succession to Muammad’’, to Succession The of ‘‘Review Crone P. . . ail ‘Rve o Te ucsin o Muamm to Succession The of ‘‘Review Daniel, L. E. h Sceso t Mòamd A td o te Earl the of Study A Muòhammad: to Succession The h Gai Kum rdto: aaa ad h Spiri the and Walayah Tradition: Khumm Ghadir The

7

: :

, , Robert M. Gleave M. Robert i'ism. i'ism. ammad’’, Journal ammad’’, History of Early Early of History History of Early Early of History dia Islamica, 75 Islamica, dia 53. 53. Muammad: A Muammad: (1999): 194.(1999): 05. 05. 05. p10) P. p.1603): , ma: A ammad: Rise of of Rise Times − − − ad’’, ad’’, tual tual

y

6 167 the of StudyMuhammad:A to Succession The 6 165 7 173 Khumm.172 Ghadir veccia 171 L. Vaglieri. 253.Ibid, 170 p. p.18. 169 Ibid, 35. p. 168 Ibid, 7 175 174 Maria MassiDakake. 6 Wlim otoey at Ery sa: Colle Islam: Early Watt, Montgomery William 164 Caetani,163 L. AnnaliMilan:Ho dell’Islam, U. 7 178 177 Jacob“TheAbbasidLassner,Shaping of Rule” 176 Jacob Lassner. 8 181 Thethe Muhammad:BiographyTheIssue of of 180 TheMuhammad:BiographyThe Issue of of the 179 Harald Motzki. 8 184 Ibid.183 182 Ibid. by: Harald Motzki, Leidin, Brill, 2000, Introductioby:Harald Leidin,2000, Motzki, Brill, Shi’ism, in: History Compass 7/6, 2009,pp.1593–16in: Shi’ism, 7/6, CompassHistory Edinburgh: Edinburgh1990. Press, University 1997, Cambridge18. 1997, p. University Press, Islam, 2nd ed., vol. 2, Brill,vol. Islam,1991.2nd2, ed., Leiden, Identity in Early Islam, pp. 3637. Identity in pp. Islam, Early Identity in Early Islam, p. 38.Identity inp. Islam, Early Identity in Early Islam, Chapter II,pp.4748. Identityin Chapter Islam, Early Gleave Robert M., Recent Research into the Histor the into Research Recent M., Robert Gleave eca alei . “hdr hm” n Encycloped in: Khumm” “Ghadir L., Vaglieri Veccia aae ai Msi Te hrsai Cmuiy Sh Community: Charismatic The Massi, Maria Dakake aae ai Msi Te hrsai Cmuiy Sh Community: Charismatic The Massi, Maria Dakake aae ai Msi Te hrsai Cmuiy Sh Community: Charismatic The Massi, Maria Dakake , ,

epli, 1905. , Princeton, 0. Princeton, , n, pp. xivxv. n,pp. Sources ,edited Sources Early Caliphate, Caliphate, Early Sources Sources 05. 05. cted Articles, Articles, cted y of Early Early of y − − ia of of ia i’ite i’ite i’ite

; , , , , 8 186 8 pp.4143. 188 Ibid, 187 Ibid. " , , , ; , , Identity in Early Islam, Chapter II, pp.4344.Identityin II, Chapter Islam, Early aae ai Msi Te hrsai Cmuiy Sh Community: Charismatic The Massi, Maria Dakake " , , " : : , ,

, , , " : : " : , , , ,

" : : " ,, : : , ,, " " −

,

, , , , , , , , , , , , , "

" : :

, , , " − − − i’ite ١٩١

, , ; , , , , ; ,

; : : , 0 200 0 p.37. 204 Ibid, p.38. 203 Ibid, pp.3637. 202 Ibid, p.36. 201 Ibid, ;

Identity in Early Islam, Chapter II,p.36. Identityin Chapter Islam, Early aae ai Msi Te hrsai Cmuiy Sh Community: Charismatic The Massi, Maria Dakake , , ; , , , , " : : , ; , , , , , , , , " ,

, , , , , , , , , : , , , , , , , , , , ;, , , , ,

, , , , ,

" , , , , , , : , , : , ,

7

,

7 " − − − − − − − − i’ite ١٩٣ ١٩٧ ١٩٢ ١٩٤ ١٩٥ ١٩٦ ١٩٩ ١٩٨

, , , , , , 1 210 0 event, the ignored authorities Sunni most … 208 207 Paula Sanders. 0 209 0 206 pp.3738. 205 Ibid, 1 216 the of StudyMuhammad:A to Succession The 1 219 p.18. 218 Ibid, 35. p. 217 Ibid, 1 215 pp.78. 214 Ibid, pp.78. 213 Ibid, 2 pp.4344. 221 Ibid, p.42. 220 Ibid, 1 212 Baqir. Islam, 2nd ed., vol. 2, Brill,vol. Islam,1991. 2nd2, ed., Leiden, Islam, 2nd ed., vol. 2, Brill,vol. Islam,1991 2nd2, ed., Leiden, hm ad h Rs o Hfz Hsoigah i Late in in:(1992), p.88).Egypt” No.75 Studia Islamica, Historiography Hafizi of Rise the and Khumm t “Claiming Paula, (Sanders interpretation. Shi'i natura fact historical an as event the accepted who Caliphate. Caliphate. 1997, Cambridge18. 1997, p. University Press, 2004, p.5. 2004, E Press, Universiry Edinburgh Hill, Marian & Watson Identity in Early Islam, Chapter II,pp.4446. Identityin Chapter Islam, Early al Sii huh: h tahns f mm Muhamm of teachings the thought: Shi'i Early eca alei . “hdr hm” n Encycloped in: Khumm” “Ghadir L., Vaglieri Veccia eca alei . “hdr hm” n Encycloped in: Khumm” “Ghadir L., Vaglieri Veccia aae ai Msi Te hrsai Cmuiy Sh Community: Charismatic The Massi, Maria Dakake h Sceso t Mòamd A td o te Early the of Study A Muòhammad: to Succession The am en, h’s, Scn Eiin, translated Edition), (Second Shi’ism, Heinz, Halm

7

, , , and those Sunnis those and Early Caliphate, Caliphate, Early he past: Ghadir Ghadir past: he lly rejected the rejected lly by: Janet Janet by: dinburgh, Fatimid d al ad ia of of ia ia of of ia − − i’ite ٢١١

, : : , , ; , , : : ,

, , , , ; 2 229 , , , , , , : : , , , , ; , , , , , Identity in Early Islam, Chapter II,p.35. Identityin Chapter Islam, Early , , aae ai Msi Te hrsai Cmuiy Sh Community: Charismatic The Massi, Maria Dakake

9 , : , : , , , , :, , " : , , , : , : , , , , , , , , : , , , , , , , , , 9 , , , ,

, , ; , , ,

, , , 9

9 , , : : , , , , , − " , , , − , , , , , , , − − − − − − i’ite

, ;, , , ; , :

, , , ,

3 237 veccia 236 L. Vaglieri. 3 Encyclopedia in: “Imāma”, Wilferd, Madelung 231 pp.4647.230 Ibid, 3 234 233 TheQuran:Encyclopedia. an 232 AsmaAfsaruddin. " Islam, 2 nd ed., vol. 2, Brill,vol. nd2, Islam, 2 ed., 1991. Leiden, nylpda Eie b Oie Laa, oteg, L Routledge, Leaman, 2006. Oliver by Edited Encyclopedia, Academies, Leiden, E.J. Brill,Academies,E.J. Leiden,1986. Interna the of patronage the under 3, Vol. Edition, eca alei . “hdr hm” n Encycloped in: Khumm” “Ghadir L., Vaglieri Veccia faudn sa “hdr hm” n Te ua: an : The in: Khomm” “Ghadir Asma, Afsaruddin "

" " !? !? ,

: , : : , , " : , , , : , " " :

: , :, : " : , :

, " " ; : , , : " , ; , , ,

" "

, : , , : , " !? !? , , ; , ,

: : !? !? " , " , , " : , : , : : , , : " "

, ,

: , : , : " , , " : : : " : , " tional Union of of Union tional of Islam, 2 nd 2 Islam, of ,

" " !? ,

9 " ; ondon, ondon, − ia of of ia −

, , , , ,

, :

, : , , , 4 242 Ibid,pp.3839. 241 Ibid,p.38. 4 240 7 "

aae ai Msi Te hrsai Cmuiy Sh Community: Charismatic The Massi, Maria Dakake IdentityinEarlyIslam, Chapter II, p.34.

9

, , " , , : , : , : , " , : , , : : : , , " : " : "

, , , " , ,

,

, , ,, , , : " , , ,

, , , " :

, " " 9 , " : : : ,

,

: : i’ite " −

, , , , : , , , : , : , , , : , , , , , , , : , , , , , , , , : , , , , : p.47. 244 Ibid, 4 243 Shi’ite Identity in Early Islam, Chapter II, pp.39 Shi’itein II, IdentityIslam, Chapter Early Dakake Maria Massi, The Charismatic Community: Community: Charismatic The Massi, Maria Dakake : , , , , : , , , , , ,,, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

* , , ,, , , , , * , , , , , , , 40. , ,, , ,

* * * * * * * * * * * *

, , , , , , , , , : , : , , , , : , : , , , , : , , : , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , : , , , : , , , , , , , : , : : , , , , : : ,: , , , , , , , , ,, ,

, , ,

, : , : , , , , , , , , , ,, , , , , , , : , , , : , , , , , , , , * * * * * * * * * * * * *

, , , , , , , , , , • • • • • • • • • •

Newyorkpress,2007. n al eio: eyd osi Ns, State Nasr, Hossein Seyyed editor: Islam, Early in Shi' Community: Charismatic The Massi, Maria Dakake Dakake"GhadirMassi, Maria Khomm" in:Encyclopedia rn P, Rve o Te ucsin o uma" T , Muammad" to Succession supplement, TheLiterary (7 4897 Feb,1997): 28. of "Review P., Crone "TheMission Muhammad".of Routledge present, the to Prophet the fromthought: I of history The Antony, Black 2001, Leiden, Brill, Encyclopedia in: Talib", Abi b. "Ali S., Ali Asani Armstrong"IslamKaren , History",A Short 2002,Ne rsrn Krn "UAMD, n Eccoei of Encyclopedia America.of in: "MUHAMMAD", Lindsay Religion,2nd9, editorvol.ed., Jones,in Karen, Armstrong A fsaruddin Asma, "Ghadir Khomm" in: The Quran: an an Quran: The in: Khomm" "Ghadir Encyclopedia,Edited by OliverLeaman,Routledge, L Asma, fsaruddin A ese' Eccoei o wrd eiin, ed Do Wendy Religions, world (ConsulingMassachusetts.Ediror). of Me Encyclopedia in: Muhammad"webster's Editor), (Consulting wendy Doniger nylpda f ol Rlgos Wny oie (Con Doniger Wendy Editor),Massachusetts. Religions, world of Merria Encyclopedia in: "Ali" Editor), (Consulting wendy Doniger ese' Eccoei o wrd eiin, ed Do wendy Religions, Me world (ConsultingMassachusetts. Editor), in: of "SHI'ITE" Encyclopedia Editor), Webster's (Consulting wendy Doniger : , : , , , , , , , , , , chief, United States chief, of the Qurān, v.1, Qurān, the of , 2001, pp. 917:pp. 2001, , slamic political political slamic w york. ondon,2006. University, of of University, mwebster's lranica. ite ldentity ite

sulting sulting rriam rriam niger niger imes * * *

• • • • • • • • • • • •

NawasEverettRowson, Brill,2011. sa(he) Eie b: urn rmr Dns Matr Encyclop Denis in: Kramer Talib", Gudrun Abi by: Edited b. Islam(Three), "Ali M., Robert Gleave, lae oet . Rcn Rsac it te History the into Shi'ism,in:History Compass2009.7/6, Research Recent M., Robert Gleave vol. 7,Brill,vol. Leiden, 1993. Islam of Encyclopedia : in"Muhammad" Trude, Ehlert tranica. Talib,,i Abi b. "Ali K., l. Poonawala Etan Kohlberg Press, 1995. Press, H DabashiO Esposito, L. John Chief: in Editor World,Islamic M. Husain Syed Encyc Oxford The in: lslam" "Shi'i Ahmad, Moussalli Jafri A. Joseph Kéchichian aei osai ha, Gai Kom i: Encyclope in: Khomm" lranica. "Ghadir Ahmad, Moussavi Kazemi JacobLassner,"The ShapingAbbasidof Ruld",princ Chicago,1974. C of University Civilization,The World a Consc in Islam: History of Venture The S., G. Marshall Hodgson ogo Mrhl G S, Hw i te al Sia be Shi'a Early (Jan. Mar.,1. 1955). the Did Socie Oriental American "How the of Journal Sectarian?", S., G. Marshall Hodgson h Ilmc ol. dtr n he: on . Esposit L. John Chief: in University1995.press, Editor world. Islamic the En Oxford The in: alBay""Ahl Elaine, Hegland Mary MarianHill, Edinburgh UniversityEdinburgh, Press, b translated Edition), (Second Shi'ism, Heinz, Halm ofthe EarlyCaliphate",Muslim (1999): 89.2 World, Muammad: to Succession The of "Review W.A., Graham

xford University xford 194. n: Encyclopedia n: y: Janet Watson Janet y: ty, Vol. 75, No. 75, Vol. ty, 2004. eton,1980. lopedia of the the of lopedia hicago Press, Press, hicago cyclopedia of of cyclopedia ,2nd Edition, ,2nd , Oxford o, ience and and ience ingeJohn ei of aedia of Early Early of A Study A come come amid dia

• • • • • • • • • • •

dto. o. 2 Lnsy oe eio i cif Un chief, America. in editor Jones Lindsay Re 12, of vol. Edition. Encyclopedia in: "Shi'ism", Wilferd. Madelung aeug ifr,Siai: nylpda f lslam,2 of Encyclopedia Edition,vol.9,Brill,Leiden.1997. Wilferd,"Shi'a"in: Madelung Leiden,Brill,E.J. 1986. Uni International the of patronage the under vol.3, Islam ofinEncyclopedia "Imāma", Madelung Wilferd, aeug ifr, IAAE i: nylpda of Encyclopedia in: in StatesAmerica.of editor: LindsayJones, "" 7, vol. Religion,2nd,ed,., Wilferd, Madelung emn lvr Eio) Tt Qrn a Encyclopedia Oliver Leaman,Routledge, an London,2006. Quran: Tlte (Editor), Oliver Leaman adl Hran "aaa" n Te ua: an Quran: The in: "Walayah" Encyclopedia,EditedOliverLeaman,by Hermann, Routledge, Lo Landolt OliverLeaman,Routledge, London,2006. Encyclo an Quran: "Shi'a"in:The R., ArzinaLalani ), ), TelAvivp.11 30.1985, Revolution and (protest hashi,i baislam mahpekha si'ato "HaShi'a: ( KramerMartin in1623,repro p. (1982), Zmanim8 as Hebrew Jer in The published (differenoriginally Shi'a", I art. 109126=BL, the p. (1983), of Quarterly27 Evolution Etan,"The Kohlberg SchoolofOrientalAfricanand Studies. press University Cambridge 1976), ( 3 No. 39, Vol. Studies,universi African and Oriental of school the i lthnā'ashariyya, to Imāmiyya From Etan, Kohlberg StudiesArabicinand Islamp.143175=BL(1984), 5 sahab the on views Shi'i Imami "Some Etan, Kohlberg Israel,2003. University Hebrew Shi'ism, (editor), Etan Kohlberg on of Academies, of on pedia, Edited by Editedby pedia, in Shf'ite Islam Islam Shf'ite in , IX., art. he, United chief, ed.), Meha'a u Meha'a ed.), ty of London, London, of ty td tts of Statcs ited ndon,2006. : ultn of Bulletin n: pagination). t f , of , 2ndEdition, , a", Jerusalem a", on behalf of of behalf on shel'All",in ,Edited by by ,Edited ligion,2nd usalem usalem nd

• • • • • • • • • • • • •

No. 75 (1992).No.75 ar eyd osi, h Hat f sanuig Va IslamEnduring of Heart The Hossein, Seyyed Nasr hhKzm Rz. Ai . b Tlb i: Encycloped in in: editor StatesAmerica.of Jones, Talib" Lindsay 1, Abi vol. ed.., b. Religion.2nd "Ali Reza. ShahKazemi theLeidin,Sources, Brill,2000. Muhammad:of Biography The (editor), Harald Motzki theEarlyCaliphate",59.2 (2000):JNES, 153. A Muhammad: to Succession The of"Review M., Morony otoey at ila, al Ilm Cletd Art Collected Islam: Early Edinburgh:UniversityEdinburgh 1990. Press, William, Watt Montgomery University1961. Press, statesman and prophet Muhammad: W., Watt Montgomery Press, 1956. Press, Univ Oxford . at Muhammad W., Watt Montgomery 1985. Un Yale States, United shi'ism, Hi Twelver of Docuines lslamThe Shi'i to Introduction An Moojan, Momen EarlyCaliphate,1997, Cambridge University Press. Stu A Muhammad: to Succession The Wilferd, Madelung aii itrorpy n ae aii Eyt i Stu in Egypt" Fatimid Late in Historiography Hafizi and Khumm Ghadir past: the "Claiming Paula, Sanders ahdn Adlzz "mmh i Ofr Encyclopedi ModernIslamic OxfordWorld,University 2007 Press, Oxford in "Imāmah" Abdulaziz. Sachedina f h llmc ol' dtr n he: on . Espo L. John University1995. Press, Chief: in Editor World' lslamic the of SachedinaAbiAbdulaziz.TheOxfor"Aliibn Talib", Leiden,2003. RubinUri."MUHAMMAD".in: Quran,vo ofEncyclopedia Humanity,NewYork, 2002.

d Encyclopediad he, United chief, 2011: iversity Press, Press, iversity i Islamica, dia sito, Oxford Oxford sito, The Issue of Issue The the Rise of Rise the story and and story Study of Study dy of the the of dy a of the the of a l 3, Brill, Brill, l3, , Oxford , lues for for lues a of ia ersity icles,

• • •

ed., vol. 2. Brill,vol.ed., 2. Leiden, 1991. Encyclopediain: Khumm" "Ghadir VecciaL., Vaglieri Edition,vol. l"Brill,Leiden, 1986. in:Encyclop Talib" Abi "Ali b. L., VecciaVaglieri twr Dvn . "aewl Plrmg" i: Encyc in: Pilgrimage", Quran,Brill. Leiden,1991 .vol.2, "Farerwell J., Devin Stewart

* *

* edia of lslam.2ndof edia of Islam.2nd Islam.2nd of oei of lopedia

and other issueunder like andAl-Ghadeerother ,theynot can make that text and human the on fact Allah is imam take it Shia explain Shia al- not canthe westernso researcher al- and Islam about researcher western and result of itbyand of.researcherresult western k must that Muslim of mind in place the and Ghadeer rpe ad h ohr at r nt o lGaer f Al-Ghadeer excelShia. al- so not the are part for other loyalty the and have Prophet one part two in s divided Shia nation al- importa and Shia the al- of is begin the event is and this history say can we so Muslim from p take and destiny the chose Prophet the that think

f e ae gnrl iw n h rsac ta b w be that research the in view general a have we If But the studies that western researcher about al-westernresearcher S studiesabout thethat But Al-Ghadeer is one of important event in Islamic his Islamic in event important of one is Al-Ghadeer Translate:Asad Alka'bi M. Write:Mohammed Amere M. Al-Ghadeer in western researcher researcher western in Al-Ghadeer write in English language language Englishin write *** ***

belief and imam ,the belief and stand it.stand ledge of allegiance allegiance of ledge ay in this day the the day this in ay imam for muslim for imam hia all about Al- hiaabout all or this years to to years this or her idea from from idea her now the studies the now family of the the of family tory al- Shia Shia al- tory t Islamic I nt itn by ritten