20100913-NEWS--0001-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/10/2010 6:34 PM Page 1
®
www.crainsdetroit.com Vol. 26, No. 38 SEPTEMBER 13 – 19, 2010 $2 a copy; $59 a year
©Entire contents copyright 2010 by Crain Communications Inc. All rights reserved
Page 3 Bill doesn’t unite sides Path opened for road funds on Detroit River crossing Budget deal would yield match for federal money BUDGET HIGHLIGHTS Yankee Air Museum rises Gov. Jennifer Granholm and BY AMY LANE gins Oct. 1. fund, cuts at state welcome centers legislative leaders last week struck from ashes in Ypsilanti CAPITOL CORRESPONDENT As discussed late last week, but no closings, and use of so-called a fiscal 2011 budget agreement, nearly half of “toll credits,” said state Rep. Lee with many pieces still requiring LANSING — Michigan might the $84 million Gonzales, D-Flint, chairman of the yet dodge a road-funding bullet. legislative approval. Elements Health Care Extra would come House Appropriations Committee’s include: A budget agreement being final- from a bond of subcommittee on transportation. ized in the Capitol is designed to Ⅲ A state worker early retirement around $40 mil- The office of his Senate counter- package that also requires produce the $84 million that Michi- lion that the part on the MDOT budget — Sen. employee contributions for retiree gan needs to avoid leaving state would is- Bill Hardiman, R-Kentwood — con- health care costs. $475 million in federal highway sue and would firmed the details Friday but said Ⅲ Budget cuts of 3 percent in funds on the table in Washington. need to repay in the bond piece still could change. state departments. Without the funding, Michigan one year, ac- Kelly Bartlett, Hardiman’s leg- would have faced major cuts next Ⅲ A tax amnesty program waiving cording to indi- islative aide, said Hardiman has penalties for delinquent business year in road and bridge projects — Gonzales viduals working been “more wary of the bonding and individual taxes. and the jobs that go with them. on the Michigan Department of Trans- proposal and the fact that it’s The agreement could be acted on Ⅲ Funding for an $84 million state portation budget. something we have to pay back in match that Michigan needs to draw this week as lawmakers speed to Additional elements include a year,” and is exploring greater $475 million in federal highway Health care advertising approve bills enacting a new state $12 million from the state trans- funds. tailored for ROI, Page 11 budget for the fiscal year that be- portation economic development See Budget deal, Page 24
Crain’s List Largest Wayne County Project unfinished, employers, Page 16 Startup creates device ‘like a GPS’ for diabetic patients This Just In parties in court GlobalHue CEO takes on Hygieia asks FDA for sales OK Dearborn BY JAY GREENE effective way for patients to new role in two offices Judge’s order: Michigan Howard 12 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS manage diabetes. Don Coleman is taking So in 2008, Hodish and more direct control of Global- Construction Disputed Eran Bhashan was an engi- Bhashan formed Hygieia Inc., a Hue, the Southfield-based Tenny site neering doctoral student in startup medical device compa- multicultural advertising 2007 at the University of Michigan ny based at Spark Central, the agency he founded in 1988. starts Oct. 1 W. Village when he learned from UM en- Ann Arbor business incuba- Coleman, the company’s docrinologist Israel Hodish, tor, to develop an innovative CEO, has taken on the new BY DANIEL DUGGAN M.D., that most diabetic pa- glucose meter with a calcula- role of general manager at CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Parking tients fail to adequately treat tor for a brain. garages the Southfield and New York At the 2003 groundbreaking for and manage their disease, Called a Diabetes Insulin Railroad tracks offices. He assumes the office the redevelopment of a former Ja- Park leading to poorer health and Guidance System, the device oversight role that was previ- cobson’s store site in Dearborn, JEFF JOHNSTON/CDB higher health care costs. uses innovative software to an- ously that of Vice Chairman city officials saw the project as the Because blood-sugar levels alyze blood-sugar levels and Allen Pugh, who retains that future of the city. change regularly — and some- tell patients how much insulin title but is now CEO of the Now, as lawsuits, bankruptcies It’s becoming times dramatically — between they should give themselves sister companies that service and scathing public comments fly, “ physician office visits, based on body chemistry. the agency. the West Village Commons devel- common to see ... Bhashan and Hodish, both Bhashan, Hygieia’s CEO, GlobalHue shifted several opment represents yet another originally from Tel Aviv, other executives as part of conflict created by the region’s re- where cities took on a thought there must be a more See Hygieia, Page 25 the changes. cession. The agency won the entire A court has ordered construc- lot of risk and are Israel Hodish, M.D., (left) and Eran $50 million Jeep account tion to begin next month on two from Chrysler LLC last year Bhashan of Hygieia Inc. have high hopes midrise buildings planned in Dear- now stuck holding for their Diabetes Insulin Guidance System. and is using that victory as a born’s west downtown. springboard to seek more Meanwhile, the developers filed the bag. full-assignment work. Other bankruptcy for the business enti- ” clients include MGM Grand ties involved with the project to Robert Gibbs, Gibbs Planning Group Detroit, Verizon, Wal-Mart, U.S. cope with mounting court fines set of two parking decks with new Census Bureau and U.S. Navy and defaulted loans. tax revenue from the developments, And the city of Dearborn, which See This Just In, Page 2 is now stuck making payments on set up a deal to pay for a $12 million them out of the general fund. “It’s becoming common to see sit- uations like this where cities took on a lot of risk and are now stuck holding the bag,” said Robert Gibbs, director of Birmingham-based Gibbs Planning Group, which provides de- velopment consulting services across the country. NEWSPAPER See Project, Page 25 ALAN WARREN 20100913-NEWS--0002-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/10/2010 6:03 PM Page 1
Page 2 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 13, 2010
2008 with $300 million in state Affolter-Caine led the April Community Central Bank in Mt. THIS JUST IN The way it was: 2003 pension fund money. 2009 launch of the website Clemens, Fidelity Bank of Dearborn, — Tom Henderson interninmichigan.com, which First National Bank in Howell, Michi- ■ From Page 1 Throughout our 25th-anniversary sought to connect students with gan Commerce Bank in Ann Arbor, year, Crain’s will use this space Small-biz awards seek nominees 25,000 internship opportunities Oxford Bank, Paramount Bank in to look at interesting items from in the state by 2014. Farmington Hills and Peoples State multicultural accounts. past issues. Nominations for Michigan Cel- Thelma Castillo, executive vice Bank in Madison Heights. With an estimated $123.8 mil- ebrates Small Business awards president, will oversee the pro- Twelve of the 137 banks in the lion in 2008 revenue, the agency will open on Oct. 1. gram’s day-to-day operations un- state got zero ratings based on is the eighth-largest advertising The expec- The contest — founded by the til a replacement is found. data filed with federal regulators and marketing firm in metro De- “ U.S. Small Business Administration, The chamber is working with for the quarter that ended June troit, according to Crain’s annu- tations were the Small Business Association of the program’s grantors, the New 30, compared to 14 that got zero al Book of Lists. that we’d never Michigan, the Michigan Economic De- Economy Initiative and W.K. Kellogg stars the previous quarter. In 2007, GlobalHue began a velopment Corp., the Michigan Small Foundation, to determine a time- Twenty-six banks got five-star $4 million organizational restruc- go to a restaurant again. We’d Business & Technology Development line for a replacement, said Sandy ratings statewide, up from 25. turing that includes a 40,000- Center and the Edward Lowe Founda- Baruah, the chamber’s president Three metro Detroit banks got square-foot office in New York never buy a car again. We’d be tion — honors Michigan’s small and CEO. five stars, all repeats from last City’s financial district. Global- businesses in three broad cate- Affolter-Caine is seeking op- quarter — Auto Club Trust FSB of Hue has become a holding compa- glued to MSNBC and CNN. gories including Small Business portunities in higher education, Dearborn, First Michigan Bank of ny for four units aimed at African- ” Awards and Small Business she said. Troy and Shelby State Bank. American, Hispanic, Asian and Champion Awards. The Michigan — Dustin Walsh Bauer Financial evaluates cap- emerging youth markets. David Sowerby, 50 Companies To Watch, which ital-to-debt ratios, profit and loss Coleman founded the agency as Loomis, Sayles & Co., Birmingham recognizes fast-growing second- trends, delinquent loans and Don Coleman and Associates, an From an April 7, 2003, article stage companies across the state, 8 area banks rated with no stars charge-offs, historical data, liq- African-American agency. Acqui- about the local economy being soft is also part of the contest. Florida-based Bauer Financial uidity, community reinvestment sition of two other agencies led to but faring better than some To learn more about award cat- Inc. released its quarterly ratings ratings and market versus book the creation of GlobalHue in 2000. expected since the U.S. had gone egories or to sign up for a nomi- of the nation’s banks Friday, and value. — Bill Shea to war with Iraq in March. On Aug. 31, President Barack Obama nation alert, visit www.michigan the eight Southeast Michigan Bankers say the ratings are marked the end of U.S. combat celebrates.biz. There is no cost to banks getting the lowest rating of simplistic and not always a re- Lithium-ion battery developer operations in Iraq. apply, and companies may self- zero stars remained the same. flection of health. nominate. They were: Clarkston State Bank, — Tom Henderson Sakti3 wins new funding round of California and Farmington Awards will be presented April Sakti3 Inc., a University of Michi- Hills-based Beringea LLC, which 28 at a dinner in Lansing. gan spinoff developing lithium- announced in April they had in- — Nancy Kaffer CORRECTIONS ion batteries for electric vehicles, vested $7 million in the company. Ⅲ A story on Page 21 of the Aug. 30 edition incorrectly named the announced Friday it has received Beringea’s investment was from Hampton Inn Detroit Metro Airport as being behind on its loan and under a $4.2 million round of funding the $185 million Growth Capital Intern in Michigan director leaves contract to be sold. The Lexington Hotel, which previously was named from General Motors Ventures and Fund it co-manages with New Britany Affolter-Caine, director of Hampton Inn Detroit Metro Airport, until 2008, should have been Itochu Technology Ventures of York-based Credit Suisse. the Detroit Regional Chamber’s In- named instead. Japan. The Growth Capital Fund is tern in Michigan program, has Ⅲ A news brief and a headline published on Page 2 of the Sept. 6 edi- The two new investors join two part of the state’s InvestMichigan announced her resignation from tion contained an error in the name of a logistics company based in previous investors, Kosla Ventures program, which was founded in the post. Her last day is Friday. Romulus. The company’s name is W.F. Whelan Co. Contract Experience Three In Your Corner. Great Events Wednesday, Sept. 29 in Sept. Visit www.regonline.com/2010houseparty to register and to learn more about Detroit House Party and Design in Detroit
Dennis Schultz [email protected] sponsored by Detroit Creative Corridor with creative support by the Detroit Design Center
facebook.com/designindetroit To register visit www.surveymonkey.com/s/2010DRWPreview. Visit DetroitRestaurantWeek.com for more details 866-4VARNUM www.varnumlaw.com I Novi I Grand Rapids I Kalamazoo I Grand Haven I Lansing 20100913-NEWS--0003-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/10/2010 6:33 PM Page 1
September 13, 2010 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 3 Stem cell Inside funding fight Bill doesn’t unite sides now key topic on Detroit River span for summit Oversight, limits on P3 agreements stir waters Court rulings cloud BY BILL SHEA Gilbert’s office began drafting CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS revised legislation in July when Legislative it became obvious the previous RV rentals paying off at MIS, research projects Revised draft legislation made “ bill, approved by the House in public last week that would oversight is May, was a non-starter among Re- Page 20 BY TOM HENDERSON permit the Michigan Depart- publicans on his committee and CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS ment of Transportation to en- important, in the Senate. Many expressed ter into a public-private worry the original bill gave Federal funding of embryonic partnership to build and but if it goes stem cell research has become a MDOT a dangerous amount of un- operate a new Detroit Riv- supervised ability to enter into Company index major focus of the upcoming World er bridge is getting mixed too far Stem Cell Summit in Detroit, follow- public-private partnerships, or P3 These organizations appear in this week’s Crain’s reviews. agreements, and create toll roads ing recent decisions by federal “The draft legislation is investors will Detroit Business: courts that have put about $75 mil- and bridges. an excellent point from B&D Cold Heading ...... 20 lion of near-term funding at risk not risk the Gilbert’s bill attempts to quell which to restart the con- those fears by limiting the P3 to Barbara Ann Karmanos Cancer Institute ...... 12 and left researchers in limbo. versation of public-private part- The sixth annual summit will be funds. DRIC. Body and Mind Fitness ...... 22 nerships and a new bridge to Others, such as Sen. Alan held Oct. 4-6 at the Detroit Marriott ” Burton-Katzman Development ...... 25 Canada,” said Sarah Hubbard, se- Cropsey, R-DeWitt, are staunch Renaissance Center. Sarah Hubbard, nior vice president of govern- advocates of Ambassador Bridge CareTech Solutions ...... 12 It is expected to draw some 1,200 Detroit Regional Chamber ment relations at the Detroit Re- Children’s Hospital of Michigan ...... 13 scientists, government officials owner Manuel “Matty” Moroun’s gional Chamber, which backs the plan to build a second span for his City Year Detroit ...... 8 and representatives from life sci- $5.3 billion Detroit River Internation- private partnership legislation — ence companies from more than 30 crossing without public funding CoachMeFit ...... 22 al Crossing project. “It’s clear Sen. MDOT’s preferred financial — a $1 billion project stalled by countries. (Jud) Gilbert aims to protect the arrangement to build and run the Communities in Schools of Detroit ...... 8 The summit’s agenda has been Canadian opposition and prefer- best interests of Michigan taxpay- bridge — to only the proposed Compuware ...... 12 revised to focus on stem cell re- ence for DRIC. ers through his approach.” new public span. DRIC’s backers are happy the Covenant House Michigan ...... 8 search and related policy issues, Gilbert, an Algonac Republi- Her worry with the new lan- legislation could see action this Detroit Housing Commission ...... 4 particularly the possible shut-off guage, however, is that MDOT can, is chairman of the state Sen- of federal funding and its ramifica- fall. Detroit Medical Center ...... 12 will be too regulated by Lansing. ate Transportation Committee “The supporters of the DRIC tions. “Legislative oversight is im- and his office drafted the revised Detroit Public Schools ...... 8 Agenda items focusing on em- are pleased that Sen. Gilbert has portant, but if it goes too far in- bill (HB 4961). He began circulat- Detroit Regional Chamber ...... 3 bryonic stem cell issues include: drafted a bill that just focuses on vestors will not risk the funds,” ing it last week, and it could see the DRIC project. Some of the oth- Diplomas Now ...... 8 Ⅲ A keynote address to open the revision before it’s eventually in- she said. “Political risk is real. er P3 issues were distracting, and EBuy Media ...... 20 conference Monday by U.S. Sen. Requiring final approval by the troduced in the committee for de- Carl Levin. this allows everyone to focus on Henry Ford Health System ...... 11 Ⅲ Legislature of the final agreement bate. moving the DRIC project for- The science keynote address will scare off investors. It has in No date for debate has been Gibbs Planning Group ...... 1 at 11 a.m. Monday by Sean Morri- ward,” wrote DRIC spokesman other states.” scheduled. Hygieia ...... 1 son, director of the University of Tom Shields, president of Lans- MDOT needs Lansing’s permis- The revised bill basically out- ing-based public relations and Kandu Capital ...... 9 Michigan’s Center for Stem Cell Bio- lines the creation of an authority sion to move forward on the lobbying firm Marketing Resource Lambert Edwards & Associates ...... 11 logy. $5.3 billion DRIC project, and the to oversee the construction and Marketing Resource Group ...... 3 See Stem cell, Page 24 revised bill would narrow public- operation of a new bridge. See Bridge, Page 24 Michigan Aerospace Foundation ...... 23 Michigan Department of Transportation ...... 1 Michigan Infrastructure & Transportation Assn. . . . 24 Michigan International Speedway ...... 20 Oakwood Healthcare ...... 12 Yankee Air Museum ready for takeoff O’Keefe & Associates ...... 9 Productions Plus-The Talent Shop ...... 4 “We have not been able to admit the public to our Skillman Foundation ...... 8 New home, new direction: Gala facilities since the building burned down in 2004,” St. John Providence Health System ...... 12 said Executive Director Randy Trinity Senior Living Communities ...... 9 Hotton. celebrates reopening after fire ETAILS University of Michigan School of Public Health . . . 12 D “This is a facility we can open Vanguard Health Systems ...... 13 BY SHERRI WELCH Gala and open ... for paid admissions to ... tell West Village Commons ...... 25 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS house: Find out our story about the Willow Run about tickets, Bomber Plant and airport, U.S. Westminster Homes ...... 25 Page 23 The Yankee Air Museum plans to reopen Oct. 9 and mobilization prior to World War William Beaumont Hospitals ...... 11 10 with a gala and open house at Willow Run Airport II ... and (to) experience where we COURTESY OF YANKEE AIR MUSEUM Yankee Air Museum ...... 3 in Ypsilanti, six years after a fire destroyed the his- want to go in the future.” YMCA of Metropolitan Detroit ...... 8 toric hangar that once housed it. The museum, founded in 1981 by a group In the midst of a multiyear ef- calling itself Yankee Air Force Inc., is tran- Youth Vision Solutions ...... 8 fort to raise $10 million to build a sitioning from a membership club to new home for the museum, a a director-driven formal museum, building on the east side of the with assistance from Ann Arbor- Department index airport came on the market late Nonprofit Enterprise at Work Inc based . BANKRUPTCIES ...... 24 last year. Over the past couple of years, the The museum acquired the museum has worked with the Pren- BUSINESS DIARY ...... 18 40,000-square-foot building from tice Co., based in Chicago, to develop a CALENDAR ...... 17 the Michigan Institute of Aviation long-term $45 million plan to construct a CAREERWORKS ...... 19 and Technology for $1.8 million in new home for the museum, a new hangar for its CLASSIFIED ADS ...... 20 Hotton December. historic flyable aircraft and a visitor center. KEITH CRAIN...... 6 It’s now moving its operations from Hangar 2 at The membership governance, however, was bog- Yankee Air Museum’s the airport — which recently was condemned — to new building (top) MARY KRAMER ...... 7 the new site. See Yankee, Page 23 and its B-17 bomber. OPINION ...... 6 OTHER VOICES ...... 6 Know the news when we do Keep up with local restaurant news PEOPLE ...... 19 THIS WEEK @ Follow us on Twitter Check out Nathan Skid's Table Talk RUMBLINGS ...... 26 @crainsdetroit blog, crainsdetroit.com/skid WWW.CRAINSDETROIT.COM STAGE TWO STRATEGIES ...... 4 WEEK ON THE WEB ...... 26 20100913-NEWS--0004-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/10/2010 4:56 PM Page 1
Page 4 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 13, 2010
StageTwo Strategies A weekly look at problem-solving by growing companies. PRODUCTIONS PLUS-THE TALENT SHOP Location: Bingham Farms “It was a difficult decision to Description: Talent and casting lose our reserves in such difficult agency economic times,” Caruso said. CEO: Margery Krevsky “But we knew the cash reserves Founded: 1981 wouldn’t be depleted for very Employees: 36 long.” Revenue: $20 million in 2009, Expert opinion: Brad Coulter, di- with $23 million projected for rector at Bloomfield Hills-based 2010. O’Keefe & Associates, deals with Business decision: During good lots of businesses that have to times, the Productions Plus team Krevsky Caruso choose between losing the safety lived below its means, hoarding net and growing the business. cash whenever possible. Shop, however, worked primarily “Before you put in money, you When the recession hit, the in film. have to ask yourself, ‘Can I afford company had a “war chest” to fall “When we evaluated the poten- to lose this money if this goes back on. tial business that (The Talent south?’ Too often, companies fly But in 2008, CEO Margery Shop) could bring in, it definitely by the seat of their pants,” he Krevsky was approached by The outweighed the risk because we said. Talent Shop, one of her biggest were only bringing over the rela- And it’s not just about the ini- competitors. The Bingham tionships and key players from tial cost, Coulter said. A business Farms-based firm was in the mar- that business,” Caruso said. owner must know how much is ket for a new owner. Productions Plus’ satellite of- needed to run the new endeavor. fices in Chicago and Los Angeles Solution: While hesitant to tap “Do I need working capital the safety net, “We figured that got a big boost with the larger loans or do I have enough money an acquisition would be more ad- staff and the Hollywood connec- to fund payroll and buying prod- vantageous for us, based on how tions. uct and everything else?” Coulter quickly we could fold that busi- And the new company, Produc- said. “Even if the (acquired) com- ness into ours,” said Sal Caruso, tions Plus-The Talent Shop, became pany is profitable, what’s it going executive vice president and the largest Screen Actors Guild- to cost to support it?” CFO. certified talent agency in Michi- Whether a business uses its With extra cash on hand, Pro- gan. own money or the bank’s money, ductions Plus was able to com- It would’ve taken years to get it still has bills to pay. plete the 2009 purchase without what Productions Plus received, bank financing. had it not bought The Talent “Either way, they’re at risk,” Risks and considerations: Before Shop, Caruso said. Coulter said. “You might be in- the acquisition, Productions Plus “The money and the time that curring a little more risk by using mainly handled automotive prod- would’ve been invested would’ve the bank’s money versus your uct demonstration, event and cos- far outweighed what we paid for own.” metics marketing. The Talent the acquisition,” he said. — Shawn Wright If your company has recently made a tough business decision, contact Jennette Smith, assistant managing editor/Focus, at [email protected]. For more news and information, visit crainsdetroit.com/getemail to re- ceive Crain’s twice-monthly e-mail dedicated to growing companies. Housing commission’s independence delayed, still on track, says director BY NANCY KAFFER ment Program and its Public CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Housing Assessment System We had to get new weren’t meeting required metrics. The completion of a review that “ Jones said his team has sub- could release the Detroit Housing members mitted the agency’s new metrics Commission from the U.S. Depart- to HUD and is awaiting the com- ment of Housing and Urban Develop- and had to pletion of a review that will de- ment’s “troubled” list has been termine if it has improved suffi- pushed back to January 2011. get Mayor ciently to leave the troubled list. Self-Employed? Eugene Jones, executive direc- During Jones’ tenure, the tor of the commission since 2008, Dave Bing housing commission’s opera- Affordable Insurance had hoped the panel would be free tions and management have im- of federal oversight this summer, to bless proved, according to officials in but he said two resignations from them. HUD’s Washington, D.C., head- the commission’s advisory board ” quarters. have slowed the process. Eugene Jones, Most notably, Jones has pushed Life “We had advisory committee Detroit Housing Commission progress at the former Herman members we had trained, we had a Gardens housing project, a rede- Health couple resign, and we had to get housing commission — which has velopment now renamed Garden- new members and had to get May- an annual operating budget of view Estates. Retirement or Dave Bing to bless them,” Jones roughly $71 million — was taken The first two phases of construc- said. over by HUD in 2005. tion at the site — mixed subsidized Long-Term Care By January, he said, the new Numerous federal audits and market-rate housing units — commission board members will showed the commission had inap- are complete, and for-sale proper- be fully trained. propriately spent millions in fed- ties are next on the agenda. All (800) 987-0290 Having properly trained em- eral funds, that city leadership un- units are full, and there’s a waiting ployees and advisory board mem- der then-Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick list, Jones said. bers, Jones has said, is essential to wasn’t able to properly manage the Most recently, Jones said, the Zayti Agency the housing commission’s future. department, and that Kilpatrick commission is preparing to break If it’s released from federal con- had made appointments to the ground at Cornerstone Estates, an IIS000320 trol, the commission must have commission without regard to extension of the Woodbridge Es- the right personnel and oversight ability or qualification. tates project. Call your local Insphere office for a FREE quote today! to remain independent. In addition, the department’s Nancy Kaffer: (313) 446-0412, Mismanaged for decades, the Section 8 Management Assess- [email protected] DBpageAD.qxd 9/7/2010 10:21 AM Page 1
Wealth management isn’t about being in the market. It’s about being in the know.
Everyone wants to be in the know. But what strategy—and not just the moment’s emotion— does that mean for an investor? For clients will form the basis of critical decisions. It means of Greenleaf Trust, at least, it means a taking the splintered assets that often comprise comprehensive and smartly constructed wealth one’s wealth and giving them a purposeful, management plan that has both the fundamental synergistic direction. So don’t just be in the soundness for long-term growth and the liquidity market; be in the competent, client-centric and flexibility for short-term tactical shifts. hands of Greenleaf Trust. It’s a better place Financial Security from Generation to Generation It means insightful analysis and intelligent to be. Call us, and we’ll help you get there.
34977 woodward avenue, suite 200 birmingham, mi 48009 www.greenleaftrust.com 248.530.6200 877.530.0555 20100913-NEWS--0006-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/10/2010 4:54 PM Page 1
Page 6 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 13, 2010 OPINION OTHER VOICES Outgoing leaders can Covering autism saves kids, money Some 15,000 Michigan make that change, as 23 Behavioral, occupational, physi- children have autism, but other states already have cal and speech therapies can help only about 20 percent of done. nearly all children with autism, but them receive treatment It’s estimated that if they can cost as much as $50,000 an- still take bold action because Michigan health Michigan insurers provid- nually — far beyond the financial insurers aren’t required ed autism coverage, state reach of most Michigan families. ere’s an interesting scenario: Michigan’s top three po- to cover it. taxpayers would save $14 That’s why insurance coverage Like me, most people in billion in lifetime costs for is needed. With treatment, nearly litical leaders — governor, House speaker and Senate Michigan are probably the current population of half of all children receiving early, H majority leader — will all leave office Dec. 31, 2010. shocked by that — which kids with autism. appropriate treatment experience Could they accomplish in the next 15 weeks what partisan is why DTE Energy Co. Public hearings are un- improvements in functioning and wrangling prevented over the past eight years? voluntarily offers plans Anthony Earley der way across the state to IQ. That in turn saves money for Michigan voters have already spoken: They want change, with autism coverage to our 10,000 consider how to ease the crushing taxpayers, who otherwise would employees. financial and emotional burden have to foot the bill for the lifetime and they’re sick of partisanship. We could argue that it’s simply faced by Michigan families deal- costs of caring for people with un- So, we issue the challenge to Gov. Jennifer Granholm, the right thing to do, but it also ing with autism. The hearings are treated autism. House Speaker Andy Dillon and Senate Majority Leader Mike makes good economic sense. If our a bipartisan effort being led by Michigan lawmakers need to act Bishop: Dare to be great. employees can get early, medically Sens. Randy Richardville, R-Mon- on this issue, as a growing number The budget agreement announced last week has no tax in- proven treatments for their chil- roe, and Tupac Hunter, D-Detroit. of companies with self-funded in- dren with autism, the complex neu- They have been held in Detroit, surance plans already have, in- creases, amid a 3 percent across-the-board budget cut and an ear- robiological condition is much bet- Ypsilanti and Grand Rapids, and cluding Microsoft Corp., The ly retirement package for state workers that the Detroit Region- ter controlled. When that happens, will soon be scheduled in Lansing. Home Depot, Eli Lilly and Co. and al Chamber and other business groups have endorsed. That DTE benefits because our employ- Autism impairs a child’s ability Time Warner Inc., as well as insti- package will also require workers to make contributions to help ees are more likely to be at work to communicate, learn and relate to tutions such as Ohio State Univer- pay for retiree health care costs, phased in over five years. and more likely to be fully produc- others. It is the fastest-growing de- sity, the University of Minnesota tive due to reduced stress at home. velopmental disability in the coun- and the Mayo Clinic. Also, as Amy Lane reports on Page 1, officials are near to find- The human benefits that come try, affecting one in every 110 chil- To be financially viable, govern- ing a way to cough up $84 million as a state match for nearly $500 with autism treatment cannot be dren, according to the U.S. Centers ment and business alike must million in federal highway funds. There is also a tax amnesty pro- overstated, but the economic bene- for Disease Control and Prevention. make prudent investments to keep posal and other elements to produce revenue and savings. fits seal the case for reforming Boys are four times more likely costs down. Reforming Michigan’s All of those proposals are a great start. Michigan’s insurance law to cover than girls to have autism. More insurance law to cover autism is autism. That’s why I’m among the children will be diagnosed with just such an investment. You wonder why it couldn’t have happened sooner, but at growing group of Michigan resi- autism this year than with AIDS, Anthony Earley is chairman and least it should be ready for the start of the Oct. 1 budget year. dents urging state lawmakers to diabetes and cancer combined. CEO of DTE Energy Co. What can these elected leaders do for an encore? Traffic-tax proposal a good idea Count on Oakland County’s L. Brooks Patterson to offer a TALK ON THE WEB pragmatic response to a business calamity. Patterson proposed last week legislation to reduce proper- From www.crainsdetroit.com entry fee. I ate less and bought less ty taxes up to 50 percent for businesses affected by a construc- Re: $16.2M diabetes grant Reader responses to stories and as a result of the unexpected costs. tion project that lasts more than three months in its first year. As someone who works in pub- blogs that appeared on Crain’s lic-sector health care, I think this MsSunshine Many businesses, particularly retailers, know the pain of Web site. Comments may be grant will go a long way in pre- summer road construction. venting diabetes within the re- edited for length and clarity. Re: Chelios takes job with Wings This year, the pain has been particularly acute on major gion. It is also great to see that this Glad to see he will stay with the state thoroughfares: Southfield Road south of I-94 in Allen grant will help foster collaboration You can bet this isn’t an isolated Red Wings. Great guy. Park in Wayne County and a 16-mile stretch of Telegraph and sharing of information among oth- incident. The current and former Car Nut Road, from the city of Southfield through Bloomfield Town- erwise competing hospitals. school board members, the former F. Masha Olaniran ship in Oakland County. school superintendents and any Re: Where have moderates gone? other adult who aided and abetted Under which tree have you been Traffic crawls, motorists avoid the congestion and the ef- the theft of an education from sev- Re: Four to face charges sleeping, Rip Van Crain? Haven’t fect on businesses is compounded because so few median eral generations of DPS students in DPS embezzlement case you heard of the Party of “No”? crossovers are available. should be put behind bars for a seri- (Those four) should be proud of criticatlarge ously long time. Business owners have complained of cash registers ringing their education. After all, they jg48386 in 20 percent to 50 percent lower sales since construction began. learned that it was profitable to Re: Ferguson felony charges Detroit Regional Chamber CEO Sandy Baruah and state steal from the disempowered. … It Re: Arts Beats & Eats in Royal Oak No one is surprised about this Senate Majority Leader Mike Bishop back the Oakland County wasn’t enough to have a job and/or indictment. It is but another full- a position of authority — they had My excitement (over the move) executive’s plan. Such a bill would help businesses across the employment indictment for the lo- to pad their pockets, too. quickly ended with the excessive region and state. It’s a good idea. Timothy Dinan $15 local parking fees and the $3 See Talk, Page 7 KEITH CRAIN: Mayor’s huge plan needs business support Last week, Mayor Dave Bing an- If this is successful, it There can be a ratio- ment for a new plant or other pro- risks it may face for speaking up. nounced a revolutionary plan for could become the model nal plan to redevelop ject. The opportunities the mayor is restructuring the city of Detroit. for the entire nation. much of the city and, Trying to serve the citizens with discussing are dramatic. But they He’s looking for residents to par- There are plenty of ur- with some redistribu- water, electricity — let alone police will take a long time and create ticipate in several town hall meet- ban cities that need to tion of population, end and fire protection — is almost im- lots of anger and controversy be- ings. At best, those meetings are go through the same up with a city far more possible when people, homes and fore they’re finished. going to be difficult. At worst, they process Detroit is begin- viable that it is today, businesses are scattered randomly To do nothing would lead the will deteriorate into chaos. ning. with opportunities for over 140 square miles.Mayor Bing city into further decay. That is But he is looking for public in- It simply doesn’t business development is embarking on a historic and im- simply not an option. put. We’ll see what happens. make sense to have so and residential develop- portant mission. It is incumbent on I hope the discussions the mayor The implications of what he is much vacant land and ment as well. the business community to stand plans remain orderly and thought- discussing have tremendous im- so many abandoned It is difficult, perhaps up and support his efforts. I have ful. We need input from voters and pact on not only the citizens of De- homes and factories. It impossible, to try to put been quite disappointed in the lack investors. troit but the residents of the entire is impossible to serve the residents together any sort of land packages of business support for the mayor’s It’s a perilous journey he has be- region. and the businesses when they are for business or industrial use to- endeavors. gun. But it is a journey that must The business community will be so scattered throughout the com- day. It’s impossible to locate own- The business community cannot be made. The alternatives are not impacted greatly, as well. munity. ers to secure land for develop- remain silent, regardless of any acceptable. 20100913-NEWS--0007-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/10/2010 4:52 PM Page 1
September 13, 2010 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 7 MARY KRAMER: Biz could help ease DSO contract discord
Come October, I hope I’ll be sit- $30 million), to balance debt service on the Or- normal,” says it now connects Recently, Eastern Michigan Uni- ting in my usual season seat on the the books. chestra Hall expansion. fundraising with marketing under versity — known for its labor dis- aisle at Orchestra Hall, watching With the economic Musicians argue that Executive Vice President Paul putes and faculty strikes — settled a Detroit Symphony Orchestra mu- meltdown, the DSO lost management hasn’t Hogle, who came to the DSO this new contract that was calibrated to sicians perform on stage — and not more than 20 percent in done a good job of rais- year from Atlanta. But cultivating reward faculty if EMU reached spe- as buskers on a picket line. ticket sales and ing money, pointing to donors takes time. cific goals. That was remarkable, Contract negotiations between $2.5 million a year in four development di- How would you save the orches- given EMU’s labor history. the orchestra and its musicians government and corpo- rectors in four years tra? Let’s hope the DSO and its musi- are stalled. And rancorous. rate gifts and grants. It and a decline in the What about gain-sharing? Why cians can reach a similar Musicians have offered to take a also lost handsome fi- donor base. shouldn’t orchestra members be “a-chord.” pay cut of 22 percent in the first nancial returns on its “How can you have a part of the pitch to donors? year but get some of that back in lat- invested endowment long-term relationship What if 85 new donor companies Mary Kramer is publisher of er years. Management wants to cut money — returns that with donors with that “adopted” a DSO musician, chip- Crain's Detroit Business. Catch her more over three years, halt the no- hit as high as 17 percent turnover?” asked Haden ping in $5,000 to $10,000 apiece to take on business news at 6:10 a.m. tion of 52-week compensation (in- in Anne Parsons’ seven-year McKay, a musician spokesman and bridge the economic gap? And Mondays on the Paul W. Smith show cluding nine weeks of vacation), tenure as CEO. Those losses hob- cellist of 27 years with the orchestra. what if the musician in turn per- on WJR AM 760 and in her blog at change benefits (including a switch bled the plans hatched in 2000 to Management, which says its formed at a company, in a lunch- www.crainsdetroit.com/kramer. to defined contribution pensions) use investment gains to pay the musicians must adapt to “the new room or holiday potluck? E-mail her at [email protected]. and adopt new job descriptions. The orchestra’s business model collapsed with the economy. Its op- erating loss for the year that ended Aug. 31 is $6.5 million. And debt service on construction of “The Max” addition is on top of that. So it’s taking money from its unre- stricted endowment, now $21 mil- lion (and formerly more than
TALK CONTINUED ■ From Page 6 cal criminal defense bar. The follow- ing civil and forfeiture proceedings should be equally interesting. Timothy Dinan
Re: WVMV FM 98.7 to switch formats I always looked forward to get- ting ready for work listening to my favorite songs, and now I have nothing that even compares to this station. Very shocked
CELEBRATE THE D AND DESIGN The popular event that celebrates Detroit and offers a chance to experience a night in the D — the Crain’s Detroit House Party — is back for its fifth act. Plus, this year’s party features a Detroit design show. The Sept. 29 event, planned in conjunction with Crain’s recent “Living and investing in the D” supplement, offers attendees the opportunity to visit one of 26 lofts, apartments, condos and historic We’ve multiplied our doctors and hospitals. homes in Detroit for cocktails and a tour, followed by an afterglow at the College for Creative Studies’ A. We’ve subtracted the referrals for specialists. Alfred Taubman Center for Design Education. The afterglow includes cocktails, With HAP, your employees will have access to over 18,000 area doctors and their strolling dinner and “Design in Detroit,” a first-time show featuring choice of the leading hospitals. Plus access to a range of specialists—most without furniture and fine art made by a mix of metro Detroit-based referrals—preventive care, personalized wellness programs, and award-winning designers, including established shops and up-and-comers. customer service. The right plan will also help you control costs. Isn’t it time you The presenting sponsor is the Michigan State Housing took another look at HAP? Contact your agent or call HAP at 800-HAP-PLUS today. Development Authority. Cocktail parties will run 5-6:30 p.m., and the afterglow will run 7-10 p.m. Tickets are $50 a person and include a one-year Improving health. Enhancing lives. subscription to Crain’s. Tickets for the afterglow only are $45. hap.org For more information or to register, go to crainsdetroit.com/events. 20100913-NEWS--0008-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/10/2010 4:58 PM Page 1
Page 8 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 13, 2010 Nonprofits launch efforts to reach high-risk students
BY SHERRI WELCH nical assistance fund administered City Year and Communities in CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS by Ann Arbor-based think tank Schools have been working in This is not just business. ... Michigan Future Inc. schools for years. City Year pro- Communities in Schools of Detroit “ In August, the U.S. Department of vides year-round in-class tutoring and City Year Detroit are working We are in business to help Education awarded Diplomas Now a and afterschool programming. with Baltimore-based Johns Hop- $30 million grant to open 60 middle Communities in Schools works kins University to open a new Detroit kids. schools and high schools in 14 dis- with parents and staff on whatever Public Schools high school next fall, ” tricts around the U.S., including De- else it takes to make students suc- based on a model its affiliates have Stan Childress, Covenant House Michigan troit. That followed a $6 million cessful, from health centers to used in schools in other low-per- grant from the PepsiCo Foundation. playgrounds to social workers. forming areas of the country. lack of shoes, food, school supplies, young people in high-risk environ- With a curriculum shaped by But Communities in Schools, City The new school will follow work health/social issues or conflicts at ments where they are surrounded Johns Hopkins in place, the three Year and Johns Hopkins coming to- started by the collaborative Diplo- home, said Communities in by so many problems. … But if organizations meet regularly to gether “allows us to go to the next mas Now this year at Bow and Schools CEO Charlie Anderson. those needs aren’t taken care of, discuss the highest-risk students level, more powerfully,” said Penny Emerson schools. “In high-poverty districts, they can’t focus on education.” so they can succeed in school and Bailer, executive director of Com- The idea is to help solve prob- 50 percent or more of the students The collaborative is among four avoid three drop-out indicators: munities in Schools. lems that get in the way of learn- are high-need,” he said. finalists in line for a grant through low attendance, poor behavior, Seeing the value of wrap-around ing for at-risk students, such as “It is expensive to deal with the $13 million school startup/tech- and failure in English or math. services to students, other non- profits are stepping up their in- volvement in Detroit education. Covenant House Michigan recently formed a nonprofit charter manage- ment company, Youth Vision Solu- tions, to oversee about 350 students at each of its three Detroit charter high schools for high school dropouts and at-risk youths. When it looked at its poor reten- tion rates and talked with stu- dents, Covenant House realized the computer-aided model that Akron-based White Hat Manage- ment LLC was using at the schools offered little or no opportunity to provide extra services to students who needed them, said Superin- tendent of Schools Stan Childress. Youth Vision still uses a com- puter-aided lesson model, but it is flexible enough to allow teachers to give students extra help when they need it, Childress said. As a nonprofit, Youth Vision can reinvest any profits into the schools, starting this year with pay increases to teachers and adminis- trators of 7 percent to 10 percent. “This is not just business. … We are in business to help kids,” Chil- dress said. After managing the Detroit Service Learning Academy for 10 years before it began operating independent of its charter in 2006, YMCA of Metropol- itan Detroit this year opened a char- ter school on Detroit’s far west side. Detroit Leadership Academy, which opened last week with 170 students in K-5, is the first of “a constellation” of new charter schools YMCA has planned for De- troit over the next few years, said Scott Landry, executive vice presi- dent for strategic development. “These children need an incred- ibly holistic support system,” he said. “The school is certainly the center of it, but they also need af- ter-school programs and support services at almost every level.” The low-profit, limited liability company YMCA formed to manage the schools — YMCA Educational Ser- vices — operates at 3 percent of per- student state aid to run the school, versus 10 percent for the average for-profit operator, Childress said. Nonprofits are trying to fix prob- lems that come out of failing schools, like poor reading scores, behavioral problems, poor social- ization and poor economic condi- tions, said Tonya Allen, vice presi- dent of program at the Detroit-based Skillman Foundation. “The mission of many nonprof- its is very much in alignment with the mission of public education,” she said. “If we use money to pre- vent a problem, it’s a lot cheaper and a lot more cost-effective.” Sherri Welch: (313) 446-1694, [email protected] 20100913-NEWS--0009-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2010 4:46 PM Page 1
September 13, 2010 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 9 Cousins branch out from family biz, acquire senior living facilities
BY JAY GREENE the five senior centers from bank- out a bank loan to purchase a por- growing slowly and investing in re- chance of success than indepen- CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS rupt Sunwest Management in tion of the $4.5 million cost of the In- cently acquired properties to make dent facilities. Salem, Ore., a company that grew diana properties, Dubin said. them more appealing makes sense. “Systems will have a leg up in at- Bradley Dubin, director of ac- to 350 senior centers in 10 years. At Trinity Senior Living Communities “We are interested in extending tracting new patients,” he said. “It is quisitions and co-owner of Birm- “Sunwest literally went on buy- in Livonia, Kelly Gasior, vice presi- Trinity’s health network and hav- almost like a feeder system, where ingham-based Kandu Capital LLC, ing and were paying ridiculous dent of planning, marketing and ing assisted living near our hospi- you have (people) steering them to- wanted to do something different prices,” Dubin said. “They were public relations, said the 21 centers tals (in Oakland, Macomb and ward the assisted-living center.” with his life than his grandfather, over-leveraged, and then the credit Trinity operates in Southeast Washtenaw counties).” Kandu, which also operates satel- father and uncle did. markets got tight and the market Michigan have been upgrading Dubin said Kandu also is adopt- lite offices in Chicago and New All of them were in the nursing collapsed.” steadily over the past several years. ing a network strategy but without York, employs nine people in its home business for more than 40 For the five senior centers, Kan- Trinity Senior Living is part of hospitals and physician groups. Birmingham office and about 1,400 years. du paid $35,000 per unit, which is Novi-based Trinity Health, which op- “We see seniors moving from in- at the five centers, Dubin said. Three years significantly below replacement erates 12 hospitals in Michigan dependent living to assisted living “We probably will add people in ago, Dubin and cost of about $100,000, Dubin said. and 45 nationally. and having an Alzheimer’s-care fa- the next 12 months as we stabilize cousins Tony All the properties have positive “We are primed for growth and cility nearby to provide a continu- our operations,” Dubin said. “After and Scott Kantor cash flow. Some need capital im- we are trying to be ready for it, but um of care,” Dubin said. that point we plan to start aggres- decided to tap provements, he said. at the same time we are trying not Boudreau said health care orga- sively looking for acquisitions.” family resources Kandu paid cash for the South to overbuild,” Gasior said. nizations that take a networking Jay Greene: (313) 446-0325, and start acquir- Carolina and Ohio facilities. It took Gasior said Kandu’s strategy of approach stand a much better [email protected] ing independent- and assisted-liv- ing facilities, as Dubin well as care cen- ters for those with Alzheimer’s and dementia. Since January, Kandu has ac- quired five senior housing facilities in Indiana, Ohio and South Caroli- na with 306 total units for $10.75 mil- lion. “There is a shift toward assist- ed living from skilled nursing care,” Dubin said. “It is more mod- ern and less-expensive approach than skilled nursing care.” Experts predict a boom in the se- nior housing industry because the number of people age 65 and older will more than double to 87 million by 2030 from about 40 million to- day, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. Southeast Michigan’s popula- tion over age 65 also is expected to nearly double to 1.1 million, or 25 percent of the population, from 616,000, or 14 percent. “We are looking very hard for deals in Michigan, but no deals have presented themselves yet,” said Dubin, 34. “Because we use our own money, we are very selective. We are not into development. We are management and acquisition.” But another reason Kandu has purchased facilities outside of Michigan is that some states, in- cluding Indiana and Ohio, subsi- dize assisted-living care for people if they run out of money and quali- fy for Medicaid. Prices for residents at assisted- living facilities can range from $2,000 to $3,000 per month, Dubin said. Skilled-nursing homes can range from $5,000 to $8,000 per month. About 70 percent of nursing home residents are on Medicaid. “Most states, like Michigan, are private pay (for assisted living centers),” Dubin said. “Michigan doesn’t have Medicaid funding rules that helps to keep census and occupancy up.” Mike Boudreau, director of transactional financial consulting with Bloomfield Hills-based O’Keefe and Associates, said occu- pancy rates for senior living facili- ties have been flat the past 18 months because of the downturn in the economy and housing market. “When people retire, they sell their homes, tap into the equity and use cash to fund living in the centers,” Boudreau said. “With the real estate market down, equity has dried up and slowed new cus- tomers in senior living centers.” Boudreau said companies like Kandu are finding bargains as some companies have overbuilt and find themselves in financial trouble. For example, Kandu purchased DBpageAD.qxd 2/17/2010 12:32 PM Page 1 20100913-NEWS--0011-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2010 4:31 PM Page 1
September 13, 2010 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 11 Extra HEALTH CARE LEADERSHIP SUMMIT Second annual event will focus on implementing health care reform changes, Page 14
People