No. 2 3
House of Commons Wednesday 19 May 2010 Votes and Proceedings
The House met at 3.10 pm. 1 The Speaker Elect The Speaker Elect took the Chair.
2 Message to attend the Lords Commissioners Message from the Lords Commissioners delivered by the Yeoman Usher of the Black Rod: Mr Speaker Elect, The Lords, authorised by virtue of Her Majesty’s Commission, desire the immediate attendance of this Honourable House in the House of Lords.
3 Attendance in the House of Lords The Speaker Elect, with the House, went up to the House of Lords. The Speaker Elect was presented to the Lords Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Royal Approbation. The Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster and Leader of the House of Lords, one of the Lords Commissioners, signified Her Majesty’s Approbation of the Speaker Elect. The House returned.
4 The Speaker The Speaker reported, That the House had been in the House of Lords, where Her Majesty was pleased by Her Majesty’s Commissioners to approve the choice the House had made of him to be its Speaker and that he had in its name and on its behalf by humble Petition to Her Majesty made claim to all its ancient and undoubted Rights and Privileges, particularly to freedom of speech in debate, freedom from arrest, freedom of access to Her Majesty whenever occasion may require, and that the most favourable construction should be placed upon all its proceedings; which he said Her Majesty, by Her Commissioners, had been pleased to allow and confirm to it in as ample a manner as they have ever been granted or confirmed by Her Majesty or any of Her Majesty’s Royal Predecessors. The Speaker repeated his very respectful acknowledgements and grateful thanks to the House for the great honour it had conferred upon him, and renewed the assurance of his entire devotion to the service of the House. The Speaker reminded the House that the first thing to be done was to take and subscribe the Oath required by law.
5 Making of the Affirmation: the Speaker The Speaker first, alone, standing on the upper step of the Chair, made and subscribed the Affirmation required by law.
6 Taking of the Oath or making of the Affirmation The following Members took and subscribed the Oath, or made and subscribed the Affirmation required by law: 4 Votes and Proceedings: 19 May 2010 No. 2
Sir Peter Hannay Bailey Tapsell for Louth and Horncastle Right honourable David William Donald Witney Cameron Right honourable Nicholas William Peter Sheffield, Hallam Clegg Right honourable William Jefferson Hague Richmond (Yorks) Right honourable George Gideon Oliver Tatton Osborne Right honourable David Anthony Laws Yeovil Right honourable Liam Fox North Somerset Right honourable Eric Jack Pickles Brentwood and Ongar Right honourable Kenneth Harry Clarke Rushcliffe Right honourable Andrew David Lansley South Cambridgeshire Right honourable Christopher Murray Paul Eastleigh Huhne Right honourable Jeremy Richard Streynsham South West Surrey Hunt Right honourable Philip Hammond Runnymede and Weybridge Right honourable Michael Andrew Gove Surrey Heath Right honourable Oliver Letwin West Dorset Right honourable Caroline Alice Spelman Meriden Right honourable Francis Anthony Aylmer Horsham Maude Right honourable George Iain Duncan Smith Chingford and Woodford Green Right honourable Sir George Samuel North West Hampshire Knatchbull Young Right honourable Dominic Charles Roberts Beaconsfield Grieve Right honourable Patrick Allen McLoughlin Derbyshire Dales Right honourable David Wright Miliband South Shields Right honourable Alistair Maclean Darling Edinburgh South West Right honourable Harriet Harman Camberwell and Peckham Right honourable Alan Arthur Johnson Kingston upon Hull West and Hessle Right honourable Hilary James Benn Leeds Central Right honourable Yvette Cooper Normanton, Pontefract and Castleford Right honourable Robert William Ainsworth Coventry North East Right honourable John Yorke Denham Southampton, Itchen Right honourable Benjamin Peter James Exeter Bradshaw Right honourable Shaun Anthony Woodward St Helens South and Whiston Right honourable Dawn Primarolo Bristol South Right honourable Sadiq Aman Khan Tooting Right honourable John Healey Wentworth and Dearne
No. 2 Votes and Proceedings: 19 May 2010 5
Right honourable Rosalie Winterton Doncaster Central Right honourable Nicholas Hugh Brown Newcastle upon Tyne East Right honourable Daniel Grian Alexander Inverness, Nairn, Badenoch and Strathspey Alexander Morrison Carmichael Orkney and Shetland Right honourable Sir Alan James Beith Berwick-upon-Tweed Right honourable Keith Anthony Vaz Leicester East Right honourable Thomas Clarke Coatbridge, Chryston and Bellshill Right honourable Charles Peter Kennedy Ross, Skye and Lochaber Right honourable Anne Catherine McGuire Stirling Right honourable David George Hanson Delyn Right honourable Margaret Mary Beckett Derby South Right honourable Sir Walter Menzies North East Fife Campbell Right honourable Malcolm Gray Bruce Gordon Right honourable Andrew David Smith Oxford East Right honourable Caroline Louise Flint Don Valley Right honourable Ann Clwyd Cynon Valley Right honourable Sir John Paul Stanley Tonbridge and Malling Right honourable Sir Alan Gordon Saffron Walden Barraclough Haselhurst Right honourable George Edward Howarth Knowsley Right honourable Alun Edward Michael Cardiff South and Penarth Right honourable Paul Peter Murphy Torfaen Right honourable John Francis Spellar Warley Right honourable Frank Gordon Dobson Holborn and St Pancras Right honourable Paul Gerard Goggins Wythenshawe and Sale East Right honourable Denis MacShane Rotherham Alistair James Hendrie Burt North East Bedfordshire Edward Henry Garnier Harborough Damian Howard Green Ashford Alan James Carter Duncan Rutland and Melton David Roy Lidington Aylesbury Jeremy Richard Browne Taunton Deane Timothy Paul Loughton East Worthing and Shoreham Crispin Jeremy Rupert Blunt Reigate Charles Hendry Wealden Robert James MacGillivray Neill Bromley and Chiselhurst Nicolas John Gibb Bognor Regis and Littlehampton James Gerald Douglas Howarth Aldershot David Julian Winnick Walsall North Richard Charles Scrimgeour Shepherd Aldridge-Brownhills
6 Votes and Proceedings: 19 May 2010 No. 2
Simon Henry Ward Hughes Bermondsey and Old Southwark Catharine Letitia Hoey Vauxhall Brian Harold Donohoe Central Ayrshire James Dolan Cunningham Coventry South Michael Cathel Fallon Sevenoaks Michael Alan Penning Hemel Hempstead David Gordon Mundell Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale Theresa Anne Villiers Chipping Barnet Andrew Peter Miller Ellesmere Port and Neston Richard Haines Burden Birmingham, Northfield Mark James Harper Forest of Dean John David Penrose Weston-Super-Mare Roger James Gale North Thanet Eric Evelyn Illsley Barnsley Central Gregory Leonard George Barker Bexhill and Battle James Whiteside Gray North Wiltshire Michael Louis David Fabricant Lichfield Alexander John Randall Uxbridge and South Ruislip Right honourable Malcolm Hunt Wicks Croydon North Mark James Hunter Cheadle Lee Scott Ilford North Gregory William Hands Chelsea and Fulham Shailesh Lakhman Vara North West Cambridgeshire Charles Ashley Rupert Walker Broxbourne William Nigel Paul Cash Stone Stephen Pelham Pound Ealing North Jeremy Paul Wright Kenilworth and Southam Stephen Crabb Preseli Pembrokeshire William David Wiggin North Herefordshire Philip Martin Dunne Ludlow Peter William Bone Wellingborough Henry Campbell Bellingham North West Norfolk Maria Frances Lewis Miller Basingstoke Angela Eileen Watkinson Hornchurch and Upminster Philip Thomas Hollobone Kettering Robert Goodwill Scarborough and Whitby Jeremy Bernard Corbyn Islington North Sir Alexander Paul Beresford Mole Valley Robert Andrew Raymond Syms Poole Gerard Sutcliffe Bradford South
No. 2 Votes and Proceedings: 19 May 2010 7
Fabian Hamilton Leeds North East Ronald Campbell Blyth Valley David Anderson Blaydon Gregory Lloyd Campbell East Londonderry Helen Mary Jones Warrington North John Derek Twigg Halton Elfyn Llwyd Dwyfor Meirionnydd David Anthony Andrew Amess Southend West Robert Thomas William McCrea South Antrim Nigel Alexander Dodds Belfast North Kevin Denis Brennan Cardiff West Lindsay Harvey Hoyle Chorley David Anthony Crausby Bolton North East David Leonard Watts St Helens North David Lindsay Willetts Havant Mark Michael Prisk Hertford and Stortford Justine Greening Putney Mark Gerard Hoban Fareham Nicholas Richard Hurd Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner Adrian Mark Sanders Torbay Nicholas Barton Harvey North Devon Sarah Louise Teather Brent Central Right honourable John Vincent Cable Twickenham Barry John Sheerman Huddersfield Valerie Vaz Walsall South David Michael Gauke South West Hertfordshire Michael Connarty Linlithgow and East Falkirk Right honourable Michael Hugh Meacher Oldham West and Royton Sandra Currie Osborne Ayr, Carrick and Cumnock Kevan David Jones North Durham Brian Arthur Roland Binley Northampton South Stewart Hosie Dundee East John Flasby Lawrance Whittingdale Maldon William James Clappison Hertsmere Antony Brian Baldry Banbury Hugh Bayley York Central Joan Lorraine Walley Stoke-on-Trent North Julian William Hendy Brazier Canterbury Right honourable John Alan Redwood Wokingham Anthony Joseph Lloyd Manchester Central Glenda May Jackson Hampstead and Kilburn
8 Votes and Proceedings: 19 May 2010 No. 2
Maria Eagle Garston and Halewood Right honourable David Michael Davis Haltemprice and Howden David Wright Telford Andrew John Turner Isle of Wight Right honourable Douglas Garven Alexander Paisley and Renfrewshire South Sir Robert Hill Smith West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine John Webster Robertson Glasgow North West Alan Keen Feltham and Heston Andrew Henry George St Ives Margaret Ann Coffey Stockport Marek Jerzy Lazarowicz Edinburgh North and Leith Martin Phillip Caton Gower Edward Jonathon Davey Kingston and Surbiton Michael Kevin Moore Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk Ifor Huw Irranca-Davies Ogmore Virendra Kumar Sharma Ealing, Southall Alan Campbell Tynemouth Angela Eagle Wallasey Joseph Edward Benton Bootle Ian Colin Lucas Wrexham Alasdair McDonnell Belfast South William Thomas Bain Glasgow North-East Christopher Michael Leslie Nottingham East Paul Phillip Flynn Newport West Austin Vernon Mitchell Great Grimsby Christopher Paul Farrelly Newcastle-under-Lyme Roger Hugh Williams Brecon and Radnorshire Mark Fraser Williams Ceredigion Stephen Roy Williams Bristol West Simon Hugh McGuigan Burns Chelmsford Thomas Anthony Cunningham Workington Thomas Anthony Brake Carshalton and Wallington Arthur Nicholas Winston Soames Mid Sussex Andrew Robert George Robathan South Leicestershire Catherine McKinnell Newcastle upon Tyne North John David Cairns Inverclyde Mark Christopher Field Cities of London and Westminster John Mark Durkan Foyle Martin Charles Horwood Cheltenham Julian Leon Huppert Cambridge Fiona Margaret Mactaggart Slough
No. 2 Votes and Proceedings: 19 May 2010 9
Madeleine Moon Bridgend Meg Hillier Hackney South and Shoreditch Hywel Williams Arfon Mike Wood Batley and Spen Siân Catherine James Swansea East Helen Catherine Goodman Bishop Auckland James Fitzpatrick Poplar and Limehouse Steven John Webb Thornbury and Yate Patrick John Mercer Newark Angus Struan Carolus Robertson Moray Joan Mary Ruddock Lewisham, Deptford Francis Doran Aberdeen North Sylvia Eileen, Lady Hermon North Down Mark Phillip Hendrick Preston Albert Owen Ynys Môn Clive James Charles Betts Sheffield South East Right honourable Patrick Bosco McFadden Wolverhampton South East Jessica Elizabeth Morden Newport East Peter Wishart Perth and North Perthshire Alan Reid Argyll and Bute Nia Rhiannon Griffith Llanelli James Edward Thornton Paice South East Cambridgeshire Anne Begg Aberdeen South Robert Ben Lobban Wallace Wyre and Preston North Christopher Stephen Grayling Epsom and Ewell Mark Gino Francois Rayleigh and Wickford Right honourable Theresa Mary May Maidenhead Richard Henry Ronald Benyon Newbury Rory Stewart Penrith and The Border Desmond Angus Swayne New Forest West Robert Alexander Stewart Beckenham John Alexander Melvin Hemming Birmingham, Yardley Christopher Heaton-Harris Daventry Hugh Michael Robertson Faversham and Mid Kent Iain Aitken Stewart Milton Keynes South Frank Roy Motherwell and Wishaw Julian Murray Lewis New Forest East Andrew James Bridgen North West Leicestershire Nigel John Mills Amber Valley Anne Frances Milton Guildford Right honourable David Lindon Lammy Tottenham
10 Votes and Proceedings: 19 May 2010 No. 2
Jonathan Simon Djanogly Huntingdon Neil Quentin Gordon Parish Tiverton and Honiton Giacomo Lopresti Filton and Bradley Stoke Jonathan Neil Reynolds Stalybridge and Hyde Pat Glass North West Durham Simon Anthony Hart Carmarthen West and South Pembrokeshire Michael Fraser Weir Angus Paul Kenneth Burstow Sutton and Cheam John David Pugh Southport Angela Christine Smith Penistone and Stocksbridge Martin John Vickers Cleethorpes Edward Julian Egerton Leigh Gainsborough Geraint Richard Davies Swansea West Graham Stuart Brady Altrincham and Sale West Stephen Hepburn Jarrow Norman Peter Lamb North Norfolk David Arthur Stephen Tredinnick Bosworth John Robert Cryer Leyton and Wanstead Phillip James Woolas Oldham East and Saddleworth Richard Michael Bacon South Norfolk Priti Patel Witham Charles Brett Anthony Elphicke Dover Robert Wilson Reading East Alec Shelbrooke Elmet and Rothwell Nigel Adams Selby and Ainsty Charlotte Ann Leslie Bristol North West Keith Robert Simpson Broadland Samuel Phillip Gyimah East Surrey Melvyn John Stride Central Devon Wayne David Caerphilly John Leech Manchester, Withington Lyn Carol Brown West Ham Kerry Gillian McCarthy Bristol East John Archibald Thurso Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross Iain David Wright Hartlepool Dennis Edward Skinner Bolsover Barbara Mary Keeley Worsley and Eccles South James Sheridan Paisley and Renfrewshire North Mary MacLeod Brentford and Isleworth
No. 2 Votes and Proceedings: 19 May 2010 11
Stephen James Mosley City of Chester Mark Jonathan Mortlock Simmonds Boston and Skegness Claire Louise Perry Devizes Damian Patrick George Hinds East Hampshire Guto ap Owain Bebb Aberconwy Right honourable Andrew Murray Burnham Leigh Gregg McClymont Cumbernauld, Kilsyth and Kirkintilloch East Daniel John Rogerson North Cornwall Margaret Patricia Munn Sheffield, Heeley Gordon Raymond Banks Ochil and South Perthshire Duncan John Hames Chippenham Ian Graham Davidson Glasgow South West Andrew Richard Rosindell Romford Mark Andrew Pritchard The Wrekin
The Speaker suspended the House until 6.40 pm. The following Members took and subscribed the Oath, or made and subscribed the Affirmation required by law: Anna Mary Soubry for Broxtowe Mark Steven Spencer Sherwood Right honourable Tessa Jane Helen Douglas Dulwich and West Norwood Jowell Right honourable Frank Field Birkenhead Geoffrey Robinson Coventry North West Lindsay Allan Roy Glenrothes Ian Lavery Wansbeck Grahame Mark Morris Easington Ian Mearns Gateshead Richard Harrington Watford Sajid Javid Bromsgrove Robert Henry Halfon Harlow John Philip Glen Salisbury Andrew James Griffiths Burton Alexander Jesse Norman Hereford and South Herefordshire David Morris Morecambe and Lunesdale Richard Grosvenor Plunkett-Ernle-Erle-Drax South Dorset Robert John Blackman Harrow East Mark Richard Tami Alyn and Deeside Fiona Claire Bruce Congleton Angie Bray Ealing Central and Acton Esther Louise McVey Wirral West
12 Votes and Proceedings: 19 May 2010 No. 2
Karl Ian McCartney Lincoln Kristan Frederick Hopkins Keighley Sarah James Wollaston Totnes John Mark Lancaster Milton Keynes North Andrew William Murrison South West Wiltshire Daniel Leonard James Poulter Central Suffolk and North Ipswich Tracey Elizabeth Anne Crouch Chatham and Aylesford Diane Julie Abbott Hackney North and Stoke Newington Gisela Gschaider Stuart Birmingham, Edgbaston Kelvin Peter Hopkins Luton North Katy Clark North Ayrshire and Arran Ann McKechin Glasgow North Mary Theresa Glindon North Tyneside Julie Elliott Sunderland Central Right honourable Edward Samuel Miliband Doncaster North Heather Kay Wheeler South Derbyshire Gregory David Clark Tunbridge Wells Peter Aldous Waveney James George Morris Halesowen and Rowley Regis Mark Robert Timothy Garnier Wyre Forest Geoffrey Nicholas de Bois Enfield North Pauline Elizabeth Latham Mid Derbyshire Chuka Harrison Umunna Streatham Ian Richard Liddell-Grainger Bridgwater and West Somerset Andrew Percy Brigg and Goole Simon Justin Reevell Dewsbury Lynne Choona Featherstone Hornsey and Wood Green Dominic Rennie Raab Esher and Walton Damian Noel Collins Folkestone and Hythe Caroline Fiona Ellen Nokes Romsey and Southampton North Caroline Julia Dinenage Gosport Lorraine Fullbrook South Ribble Conor Burns Bournemouth West Mark Andrew Menzies Fylde Roger Duncan Godsiff Birmingham, Hall Green Annette Lesley Brooke Mid Dorset and North Poole Eleanor Fulton Laing Epping Forest John Michael Howell Henley Philip Wilson Sedgefield Charles Geoffrey Cox Torridge and West Devon
No. 2 Votes and Proceedings: 19 May 2010 13
Chloe Rebecca Smith Norwich North Michael John Gapes Ilford South Andrew John Gwynne Denton and Reddish Natascha Engel North East Derbyshire Matthew Toby Perkins Chesterfield William Roffen Esterson Sefton Central Julie Ann Hilling Bolton West Yasmin Qureshi Bolton South East Daniel Robert Kawczynski Shrewsbury and Atcham Stewart James Jackson Peterborough Ian Richard Kyle Paisley North Antrim Graham Thomas Evans Weaver Vale Kate Green Stretford and Urmston Rachel Jane Reeves Leeds West Tobias Martin Ellwood Bournemouth East John Douglas Wilson Carswell Clacton Jonathan George Caladine Lord Woking Richard Quentin Fuller Bedford Julian Richard Smith Skipton and Ripon Michael Thomas Hancock Portsmouth South Lilian Rachel Greenwood Nottingham South Owen Smith Pontypridd Christopher James Evans Islwyn Catherine Mary Jamieson Kilmarnock and Loudoun James Stephen Wharton Stockton South John Henry Hayes South Holland and The Deepings Julian Charles Sturdy York Outer Craig Whittaker Calder Valley Therese Anne Coffey Suffolk Coastal Christopher James Skidmore Kingswood Adrian Edward Bailey West Bromwich West David Jonathan Edwards Carmarthen East and Dinefwr Jeremy John Elton Lefroy Stafford Jessica Katherine Lee Erewash David Thomas Charles Davies Monmouth James Hood Lanark and Hamilton East Andrew Guy Tyrie Chichester Christopher Pincher Tamworth Nicola Ann Morgan Loughborough Right honourable Wyvill Richard Nicolls Greenwich and Woolwich Raynsford
14 Votes and Proceedings: 19 May 2010 No. 2
Stephen James McCabe Birmingham, Selly Oak John Zak Woodcock Barrow and Furness Clive Stanley Efford Eltham Right honourable James Francis Murphy East Renfrewshire John Mann Bassetlaw George Freeman Mid Norfolk Gavin Shuker Luton South Bridget Maeve Phillipson Houghton and Sunderland South Christopher Robert Chope Christchurch George Edward Mudie Leeds East Robert Andrew Stunell Hazel Grove Graham William Allen Nottingham North Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown The Cotswolds Nicholas Desmond John Smith Blaenau Gwent David Henry Rutley Macclesfield Michael Richard Weatherley Hove Simon Gerard Kirby Brighton, Kemptown
7 Adjournment Resolved, That this House do now adjourn.—(Bill Wiggin.)
Adjourned at 7.51 pm until tomorrow.
______
John Bercow Speaker
The Speaker will take the Chair at 10.30 am.