California Marine Life Protection Act Initiative North Central Coast Project

Side-by-Side Comparison of Regional Proposal 0 and Draft MPA Proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A

Subregion 1: Alder Creek to Horseshoe Point MLPAMLPA NorthNorth CentralCentral CoastCoast StudyStudy Region:Region: SubregionSubregion 11 PointPoint ArenaArena toto HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint

S S S t N t N t N 39° 05' a 39° 05' a 39° 05' a t a t a t a e E G e E G e E G lk r v Cn lk r v Cn lk r v Cn H e a r H e a r H e a r e r N dia e r N dia e r N dia i C n r n i C n r n i C n r n g r w o a I g r w o a I g r w o a I h o v h o v h o v w od R a w od R a w od R a a Cr r a Cr r a Cr r y y y ro ro ro 1 Proposal 0 Draft Proposal1 1 (EC) Draft 1Proposal 2 (JD) ProposalR A 0 Draft Proposal 1 (EC)R A Draft Proposal 2 (JD)R A n n n de de de rs rs rs Manchester on on on Va Va Va Mallo Pass Creek Vista Point lle Mallo Pass Creek Vista Point lle Mallo Pass Creek Vista Point lle and Arena y y y Rock SMCA Pt Arena Pt Arena Pt Arena 39° 00' SM CA Pt Arena SM CA SM R SM R A A A ld ld ld e e e r r r C C C Manchester r Manchester r Manchester r PointPoint ArenaArena PointPoint ArenaArena PointPoint ArenaArena Point Arena Lighthouse Point Arena Lighthouse Point Arena Lighthouse

G MENDOCINO G MENDOCINO G MENDOCINO arcia R arcia R arcia R COUNTY COUNTY COUNTY 38° 5 Fork 38° 5 Fork 38° 5 Fork 5' Arena Cove rth Ga 5' Arena Cove rth Ga 5' Arena Cove rth Ga No rcia R No rcia R No rcia R Point Arena iver Point Arena iver Point Arena iver Saunders Reef Bowling Ball Beach Bowling Ball Beach Bowling Ball Beach Saunder's Reef Offshore SMCA Moat Creek Access inshore SMCA Moat Creek Access Moat Creek Access

Schooner Gulch Schooner Gulch Schooner Gulch

38° 50' k 38° 50' k 38° 50' k ee ee ee Cr Cr Cr

y y y r r r

D D D

' ' ' Saunders Reef 6 6 Saunder's Reef 6 4 4 4 Inshore SMCA ° ° offshore SMCA °

3 3 3

2 Collins Landing 2 Collins Landing 2 Collins Landing

1 1 1

- - -

Gualala Gualala Gualala 38° 45' 38° 45' 38° 45' Salal Trail Salal Trail Salal Trail Sea Ranch Blufftop Trail Del Mar Sea Ranch Blufftop Trail Sea Ranch Blufftop Trail

' ' Landing '

1 Sea Ranch Public Access Trails 1 Sea Ranch Public Access Trails 1 Sea Ranch Public Access Trails

4 4 SM P 4 ° Del Mar ° °

3 Sea Ranch 3 Sea Ranch 3 Sea Ranch

2 Landing 2 2

1 1 1 - SM P Sea Ranch Public Acc - Sea Ranch Public Acc - Black Sea Ranch Public Acc Point 38° 40' Sea Ranch Public A 38° 40' ' Sea Ranch Public A 38° 40' SM CA Sea Ranch Public A

36'

123° - SONOMA -123° 36 SONOMA Black SONOMA

' COUNTY ' COUNTY ' COUNTY 6 Point

1 1 1

3 3 3

° SM R

° ° °

3 3 3

2 2 2

1 1 1

- - HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint Nor - HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint Nor - HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint Nor Kr Kr Kr

38° 35' ' 38° 35' 38° 35'

1 Salt

2 1 Point °

Salt 3

2 SM P

Point 1 1 - Sea Ranch 2

SM CA - to Salt ° Miles 3 Point SMR 2

Salt 1 02.55 - Poin SM P

Draft MPA Proposals 0, 1 and 2 Proposal 0 illustrates the existing California state marine protected areas (MPAs) Draft MPA Proposals 0, 1 and 2 in the Marine Life Protection Act (MLPA) North Central Coast Study Region. Draft State Marine State Marine North Central MPA proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A are under review through the MLPA State Marine State Marine Recreational Public Prepared by DFG Conservation Coast Study Initiative and are expected to be further revised in March 2008. These are not Park (SMP) Reserve (SMR) Management Lands Marine Region GIS Area (SMCA) Area (SMRMA) Region MPA proposals for adoption by the California Fish and Game Commission. 1/24/2008 MLPAMLPA NorthNorth CentralCentral CoastCoast StudyStudy Region:Region: SubregionSubregion 11 AlderAlder CreekCreek toto HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint

S S S t N t N t N 39° 05' a 39° 05' a 39° 05' a t a t a t a e E G e E G e E G lk r v Cn lk r v Cn lk r v Cn H e a r H e a r H e a r e r N dia e r N dia e r N dia i C n r n i C n r n i C n r n g r w o a I g r w o a I g r w o a I h o v h o v h o v w od R a w od R a w od R a a Cr r a Cr r a Cr r y y y ro ro ro Draft Proposal1 3 (TC) Draft 1 Proposal 4 (JC) External1 Proposal A Draft Proposal 3 (TC)R A Draft Proposal 4 (JC)R A External ProposalR A A n n n de de de rs rs rs on on on Va Va Va Mallo Pass Creek Vista Point lle Mallo Pass Creek Vista Point lle Mallo Pass Creek Vista Point lle y Point y Arena y Point Arena Rock Arena SM CA SM CA SM CA 39° 0 39° 00' Arena 0' Point Point 39° 00' Rock SMR Arena SMR Arena SMR A A A ld ld ld e e e r r r C C C Manchester r Manchester r Manchester r PointPoint ArenaArena PointPoint ArenaArena PointPoint ArenaArena Point Arena Lighthouse Point Arena Lighthouse Point Arena Lighthouse

G MENDOCINO G MENDOCINO G MENDOCINO arcia R arcia R arcia R COUNTY COUNTY COUNTY 38° 55' Arena Cove Fork Sea Lion Arena Cove Fork 38° 55' Arena Cove Fork orth Gar orth Gar orth Gar N cia R Cove SMR N cia R N cia R Point Arena iver Point Arena iver Point Arena iver

Bowling Ball Beach Bowling Ball Beach Bowling Ball Beach

Moat Creek Access Moat Creek Access Moat Creek Access Saunders Schooner Gulch Schooner Gulch Reef SMCA Schooner Gulch

38° 50' k 38° 50' k 38° 50' k Saunder's Reef ree Saunders Reef ree ree offshore SMCA Saunder's Reef C Offshore SMCA C C y y y inshore SMCA r r r D D D

' ' '

6 6 6

4 4 4

° ° °

3 3 3

2 Collins Landing 2 Collins Landing 2 Collins Landing

1 1 1

- - -

SONOMA Gualala Gualala Gualala 38° 45' COUNTY 38° 45' 38° 45' Salal Trail Salal Trail Salal Trail Sea Ranch Blufftop Trail Sea Ranch Blufftop Trail Sea Ranch Blufftop Trail Del Mar Del Mar ' Landing ' ' 1 Sea Ranch Public Access Trails 1 Landing Sea Ranch Public Access Trails 1 Sea Ranch Public Access Trails 4 SM P 4 4 ° ° SM R °

3 Sea Ranch 3 Sea Ranch 3 Sea Ranch

2 2 2

1 1 1

- - - Black Sea Ranch Public Acc Sea Ranch Public Acc Sea Ranch Public Acc Point SM CA 38° 40' Sea Ranch Public A 38° 40' Sea Ranch Public A 38° 40' Sea Ranch Public A

6' Black

-123° 36' -123° Point SM R 36' -123° SONOMA SONOMA

123° 3 Black Black COUNTY - COUNTY Black Point Salt to Salt SM R SM CA Point SM R

' '

3 1 HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint Nor 1 HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint Nor HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint Nor

3 3 °

3 ° Kr ° Kr Kr

3 3

2 2 38° 35 38° 35 38° 35 - ' 1 ' 1 '

- -

° ' ' 2

1 1

2 - 2

° Salt ° Salt 3 3 Miles 2 Point 2 Point 1 1

- - 036 SM P SM P

Draft MPA Proposals 3, 4 and External Proposal A Proposal 0 illustrates the existing California state marine protected areas (MPAs) Draft MPA Proposals 3, 4 and External Proposal A in the Marine Life Protection Act (MLPA) North Central Coast Study Region. Draft State Marine State Marine North Central MPA proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A are under review through the MLPA State Marine State Marine Recreational Public Prepared by DFG Conservation Coast Study Park (SM P) Reserve (SMR) Management Lands Initiative and are expected to be further revised in March 2008. These are not Marine Region GIS Area (SMCA) Region Area (SMRMA) MPA proposals for adoption by the California Fish and Game Commission. 1/24/2008 California Marine Life Protection Act Initiative Comparison of Proposed Regulations in Draft MPA Proposals for the North Central Coast Study Region Revised February 1, 2008

Point Arena State Marine Salmon trolling only, commercial and Point Arena State Marine Salmon trolling, anchovy, sardine, herring, Conservation Area recreational Conservation Area dungeness crab (All applies to commercial (Moderate high) (Moderate high) and recreational)

Saunders Reef Inshore Commercial urchin, abalone, shore-based Saunders Reef Inshore Salmon trolling, anchovy, sardine, herring, State Marine Conservation finfish State Marine Conservation dungeness crab, urchin, abalone, shore- Area (Moderate low) Area (Moderate low) based hook and line angling (All applies to commercial and recreational)

Saunders Reef Offshore Salmon trolling only, commercial and Saunders Reef Offshore Salmon trolling, anchovy, sardine, herring, State Marine Conservation recreational State Marine Conservation dungeness crab (All applies to commercial Area (High) Area (Moderate high) and recreational)

Del Mar Landing State No take EXCEPT recreational take of Del Mar Landing State No take EXCEPT Recreational finfish by Marine Park (Moderate finfish by hook and line or spear Marine Park (Moderate hook and line or spear low) low) Sea Ranch to Salt Point No take Black Point State Marine No take

Subregion 1: Point Arena to Horseshoe Point State Marine Reserve Reserve (Very high) (Very high) Black Point State Marine Salmon trolling, anchovy, sardine, herring, Conservation Area dungeness crab (All applies to commercial (Moderate high) and recreational)

SMCA = state marine conservation area, SMP = state marine park, SMR = state marine reserve, SMRMA = state marine recreational management area California Marine Life Protection Act Initiative Comparison of Proposed Regulations in Draft MPA Proposals for the North Central Coast Study Region Revised February 1, 2008

Point Arena State Marine Salmon trolling only, commercial and Point Arena State Marine Salmon trolling only, commercial and Arena Rock State Marine Salmon trolling only, commercial and Conservation Area (High) recreational Conservation Area (HIgh) recreational Conservation Area (High) recreational

Sea Lion Cove State No take Marine Reserve (Very high) Saunders Reef Inshore Urchin and abalone Saunders Reef Inshore Urchin, commercial State Marine Conservation State Marine Conservation Area (Moderate low) Area (Moderate low)

Saunders Reef Offshore Salmon trolling only, commercial and Saunders Reef Offshore Salmon trolling only, commercial and State Marine Conservation recreational State Marine Conservation recreational Area (High) Area (Moderate high)

Del Mar Landing State No take EXCEPT Recreational finfish by Del Mar Landing State No take Marine Park (Moderate hook & line or spear Marine Reserve (Very low) high) Black Point State Marine No take Black to Salt Point State No take Black Point State Marine No take

Subregion 1: Point Arena to Horseshoe Point Reserve (Very high) Marine Reserve (Very Reserve (Very high) high) Black Point to Salt Point Salmon trolling and dungeness crab trap, Black Point State Marine Salmon trolling and dungeness crab, Marine Conservation Area commercial and recreational Conservation Area commercial and recreational (Moderate high) (Moderate high) Salt Point State Marine All recreational harvest allowed Park (Low)

SMCA = state marine conservation area, SMP = state marine park, SMR = state marine reserve, SMRMA = state marine recreational management area

California Marine Life Protection Act Initiative North Central Coast Project

Side-by-Side Comparison of Regional Proposal 0 and Draft MPA Proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A

Subregion 2: Horseshoe Point to Bodega Head MLPAMLPA NorthNorth CentralCentral CoastCoast StudyStudy Region:Region: SubregionSubregion 22 HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint toto BodegaBodega HeadHead

Sea Ranch Public Access Trails Sea Ranch Public Access Trails Sea Ranch Public Access Trails

Sea Ranch Public Access Trails Sea Ranch Public Access Trails Sea Ranch Public Access Trails 3 Proposal 0 Draft3 Proposal 1 (EC) 38° Draft Proposal 2 (JD) 8° 40' Proposal 0 Draft8° 40' Proposal 1 (EC) 4Draft0' Proposal 2 (JD)

Stewarts Point Stewarts Point Black Stewarts Point Point SMR

HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint North Horseshoe Cove HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint North Horseshoe Cove HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint North Horseshoe Cove Kruse Ranch Kruse Ranch Kruse Ranch Fisk Mill Cove SONOMA Fisk Mill Cove SONOMA Fisk Mill Cove SONOMA 38° 35' COUNT Y 38° 35' COUNTY 38° 35' Salt COUNTY Stump Beach Gerstle Stump Beach Point Stump Beach Salt Gerstle Cove SMCA SMP Cove SMR Point Sea Ranch SMCA Ocean Cove Reserve to Salt Ocean Cove Reserve Ocean Cove Reserve Point SMR Salt Stillwater Cove Regional Park (Sonoma County) Stillwater Cove Regional Park (Sonoma County) Stillwater Cove Regional Park (Sonoma County) Timber Cove Campground and Boat Landing Point Timber Cove Campground and Boat Landing Timber Cove Campground and Boat Landing SMP Fort Ross State Historic Park Fort Ross State Historic Park Fort Ross State Historic Park 38° 30' 38° 30' 38° 30' Fort Ross Reef Campground Fort Ross Reef Campground Fort Ross Reef Campground

' Fort Vista Trail (Sonoma Count ' Vista Trail (Sonoma Count ' Vista Trail (Sonoma Count 6 6 6

2 Ross 2 2 ° Russian Gulch (Sonoma ° Russian Gulch (Sonoma ° Russian Gulch (Sonoma 3 SMCA 3 3 Russian

2 2 2

1 1 1

- - - River Jenner Jenner SMCA Jenner Russian Bridgehaven River Bridgehaven Bridgehaven 38° 25' 38° 25' SMR 38° 25' Russian Shell Beac Shell Beac Shell Beac River SMR Wright's B Wright's B Wright's B

' Duncans ' Bodega Duncans ' Duncans ' ' '

1 1 1

6 6 6

2 2 2

1 1 Head SMR 1

° ° °

° ° ° 3 Sonoma 3 3 Bodega

3 3 3

2 2 2

1 1 1

- 1 Coast - 1 - 1 Head SMR - SMCA - -

' Sa Bodega Sa 1 Sa 1

Head SMCA °

38° 20' 38° 20' 38° 20' 2 '

-123° 11' -

MusselMussel PointPoint ° MusselMussel PointPoint MusselMussel PointPoint

Bode 1 Bode Bode Bodega -

' '

SMR 6 6

B 0 B 0 B

° °

3 3

2 2

1 1

- -

- 38° 15' 38° 15' 38° 15' Bodega Head SMCA Miles 024 C Is Draft MPA Proposals 0, 1 and 2 Proposal 0 illustrates the existing California state marine protected areas (MPAs) Draft MPA Proposals 0, 1 and 2 in the Marine Life Protection Act (MLPA) North Central Coast Study Region. Draft State Marine State Marine North Central MPA proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A are under review through the MLPA State Marine State Marine Recreational Public Prepared by DFG Conservation Coast Study Initiative and are expected to be further revised in March 2008. These are not Park (SMP) Reserve (SMR) Management Lands Marine Region GIS Area (SMCA) Area (SMRMA) Region MPA proposals for adoption by the California Fish and Game Commission. 1/24/2008 MLPAMLPA NorthNorth CentralCentral CoastCoast StudyStudy Region:Region: SubregionSubregion 22 HorseshoeHorseshoe PointPoint toto BodegaBodega HeadHead

Sea Ranch Public Access Trails Sea Ranch Public Access Trails Sea Ranch Public Access Trails

Sea Ranch Public Access Trails Sea Ranch Public Access Trails Sea Ranch Public Access Trails 3Draft Proposal 3 (TC) 3 Draft Proposal 4 (JC) 3 External Proposal A Draft8° 40' Proposal 3 (TC) 8°Draft40' Proposal 4 (JC) 8° 40' External Proposal A Black Point SMR Stewarts Point Stewarts Point

Salt Ocean Cove Reserve Salt Ocean Cove Reserve Ocean Cove Reserve Point Point Stillwater Cove Regional Park (Sonoma County) Stillwater Cove Regional Park (Sonoma County) Stillwater Cove Regional Park (Sonoma County) SMP SMP Timber Cove Campground and Boat Landing Timber Cove Campground and Boat Landing Timber Cove Campground and Boat Landing Gerstle Cove SMCA Fort Ross State Historic Park Fort Ross State Historic Park Gerstle Fort Ross State Historic Park Cove SMR 38° 30' 38° 30' 38° 30' Fort Ross Reef Campground Fort Ross Reef Campground Fort Ross Reef Campground

' Vista Trail (Sonoma Count ' Vista Trail (Sonoma Count ' Vista Trail (Sonoma Count 6 6 6

2 2 2

° Russian Gulch (Sonoma ° Russian Gulch (Sonoma ° Russian Gulch (Sonoma

3 3 3

2 2 2

1 1 1 - - Russian - Jenner Jenner Jenner Russian River SMR Russian River SMR River Bridgehaven Bridgehaven Bridgehaven 38° 25' SMCA 38° 25' 38° 25' Shell Beach Shell Beach Shell Beach Wright's B Wright's B Wright's B

' Duncans ' Duncans ' Duncans ' ' '

1 1 1

6 Charter 6 6

2 2 2

1 1 1

° ° °

3 Beach SMCA 3 3

3 3 3

2 2 2

1 1 1

- 1 - 1 - 1

- - Bodega - Bodega SMR Bodega Sa Sa Head SMR Sa Head SMR

38° 20' 38° 20' 38° 20' 1 '

° Mussel Point Mussel Point Mussel Point Mussel Point Mussel Point 2 Mussel Point

-123° 11'

1 Bode Bode Bode

' ' '

6 6 6

Bodega 0 B Bodega 0 B 0 B ° ° Bodega ° Head SMCA 3 3 3 2 SMCA 2 2

1 1 Head SMCA 1

- - -

° 38° 15' 38° 15' 38° 15'

Miles Este Estero S 036 De S Antonio S Antonio

Proposal 0 (Existing MPAs) Draft Proposal 1 (EC) (12/12/07 version) Draft Proposal 2 (JD) (12/12/07 version) MPA Name MPA Name MPA Name Proposed Regulations Proposed Regulations Proposed Regulations (Level of Protection ) (Level of Protection ) (Level of Protection ) Salt Point State Marine RECREATIONAL: finfish, red abalone, chitons, clams, Salt Point State Marine No take EXCEPT recreational abalone and Salt Point State Marine recreational abalone and finfish Conservation Area (Low) cockles, rock scallops, native oysters, crabs, lobsters, Park (Moderate low) finfish Park (Moderate-low) ghost shrimp, urchins, mussels, & marine worms, except that no worms may be taken in any mussel bed unless taken incidentally to the take of mussels. COMMERCIAL: finfish, crabs, ghost shrimp, jackknife clams, urchins, algae (except giant & bull kelp) and worms except that no worms may be taken in any mussel bed, nor may any person pick up, remove, detach from the substrate any other organisms, or break up, move or destroy any rocks or other substrate or surfaces to which organisms are attached. ga Head Gerstle Cover State No take EXCEPT commercial take of finfish and algae Gerstle Cove State Marine No take Marine Conservation Area (except giant and bull kelp). Reserve (Very high) (Moderate low) Fort Ross State Marine No recreational take of living or non-living marine Conservation Area (Low) resources is allowed EXCEPT: finfish, red abalone, chiones, clams, cockles, rock scallops, native oysters, Point to Bode crabs, lobsters, ghost shrimp, sea urchins, mussels, and marine worms. Russian River State No take Russian River State No take Marine Reserve (Very Marine Reserve (Very high) high) Russian River State All commercial and recreational take allowed Marine Conservation Area EXCEPT salmon (Moderate low) Sonoma Coast State No recreational take of living or non-living marine Marine Conservation Area resources is allowed EXCEPT: finfish, red abalone, Subregion 2: Horseshoe (Low) chitons, clams, cockles, crabs, ghost shrimp, mussels, native oysters, rock scallops, urchins, & marine worms

Bodega Head State Marine No take Bodega Head State Marine No take Bodega Head State Marine No take Reserve (Very high) Reserve (Very high) Reserve (Very high)

Bodega Head State Marine Salmon trolling only, commercial and Bodega Head State Marine Salmon trolling, anchovy, sardine, herring, Conservation Area (High) recreational Conservation Area dungeness crab (All applies to commercial (Moderate high) and recreational)

Draft Proposal 3 (TC) (12/12/07 version) Draft Proposal 4 (JC) (12/12/07 version) Draft External Proposal A (01/02/08 version) MPA Name MPA Name MPA Name Proposed Regulations Proposed Regulations Proposed Regulations (Level of Protection ) (Level of Protection ) (Level of Protection ) (see Subregion 1) Salt Point State Marine RECREATIONAL: finfish, red abalone, chitons, clams, Park (Low) cockles, rock scallops, native oysters, crabs, lobsters, ghost shrimp, urchins, mussels, & marine worms, except that no worms may be taken in any mussel bed unless taken incidentally to the take of mussels. COMMERCIAL: finfish, crabs, ghost shrimp, jackknife clams, urchins, algae (except giant & bull kelp) and worms except that no worms may be taken in any mussel bed, nor may any person pick up, remove, detach from the substrate any other organisms, or break up, move or destroy any rocks or other substrate or surfaces to which organisms are attached.

Gerstle Cove State Marine No take EXCEPT commercial finfish & algae Gerstle Cove State Marine No take Gerstle Cove State Marine No take Conservation Area (except giant & bull kelp) Reserve (Very high) Reserve (Very high) (Moderate low)

Russian River State Dungeness crab trap allowed, commercial Russian River State No take Russian River State No take Marine Conservation Area and recreational Marine Reserve (Very Marine Reserve (Very (Moderate high) high) high)

Charter Beach State No recreational take of living or non-living

Subregion 2: Horseshoe Point to Bodega Head Horseshoe Point to Bodega Subregion 2: Marine Conservation Area marine resources is allowed EXCEPT: (Low) finfish, red abalone, chitons, clams, cockles, crabs, ghost shrimp, mussels, native oysters, rock scallops, urchins, & marine worms

Bodega Head State Marine No take Bodega Head State Marine No take Bodega Head State Marine No take Reserve (Very high) Reserve (Very high) Reserve (Very high)

Bodega Head State Marine Salmon trolling and dungeness crab trap, Bodega Head State Marine Salmon trolling only, commercial and recreational Bodega Head State Marine Salmon trolling and dungeness crab, Conservation Area commercial & recreational Conservation Area (High) Conservation Area commercial and recreational (Moderate high) (Moderate high)

SMCA = state marine conservation area, SMP = state marine park, SMR = state marine reserve, SMRMA = state marine recreational management area

California Marine Life Protection Act Initiative North Central Coast Project

Side-by-Side Comparison of Regional Proposal 0 and Draft MPA Proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A

Subregion 3: Bodega Head to Double Point MLPAMLPA NorthNorth CentralCentral CoastCoast StudyStudy Region:Region: SubregionSubregion 33 BodegaBodega HeadHead toto DoubleDouble PointPoint

Sonoma Salmon Creek Beach Salmon Creek Beach Salmon Creek Beach Coast Creek Creek Creek s s s a a a SMCA Proposali 0 Draft Proposali 1 (EC) Draft Proposali SONOMA 2 (JD) Proposalb 0 Draft38° 20' Proposalb 1 (EC) Draft38° 20' Proposalb 2 (JD) 38° 20' a 38° 20' a 38° 20' a Bodega Bay b Bodega Bay b Bodega Bay b COUNTY MusselMussel PointPoint E SONOMA MusselMussel PointPoint E MusselMussel PointPoint E COUNT Y Estero de Bodega Marine Laboratory Bodega Marine Laboratory Americano SONOMA Bodega Marine Laboratory Estero Bodega COUNTY SMR SMRMA Americano Bodega Head Bodega Head Bodega Head SMR Estero De San Bodega Bodega Antonio SMRMA Estero Head SMCA Head SMR de San 38° 15' 38° 15 38° 15' Antonio SMR Dillon Beach ' Dillon Beach Dillon Beach Creek Creek eys eys Bodega K MARIN K Bodega MARIN Lawson's Landing COUNTY Lawson's Landing Head SMCA Head SMR Lawson's Landing COUNTY Clam Walker Creek Delta Island Walker Creek Delta Walker Creek Delta Miller Park Launching Facility SMRMA Miller Park Launching Facility Miller Park Launching Facility

McClures Beach McClures Beach McClures Beach 38° 10' 38° 10' 38° 10' 38° 10' 38° 10' 38° 10' Cypress Grove Cypress Grove Cypress Grove Lairds Landing Lairds Landing Lairds Landing

' ' '

' ' ' 6 Marconi Conference Ce 6 MarconiTom Conference al es Ba y Ce 6 Marconi Conference Ce 1 1 1

0 0 0

° ° °

° ° South SMRMA ° 3 Tomales Bay State Park 3 Tomales Bay State Park 3 Tomales Bay State Park

3 3 3

2 2 2

1 1 1 - 1 Abbotts Lagoon - 1 Abbotts Lagoon - 1 Abbotts Lagoon - - - Millerton Millerton

' ' MARIN ' Tom al es 6 Inverness 6 6 Inverness

5 Tom al es 5 COUNT Y 5 38° 05' ° 38° 05' ° 38° 05' Drakes ° Bay SMP 2 Bay SMP Bivalve 2 Bivalve 2 Bivalve

2 2 2

1 1 Bay SMR 1 - Drakes - - - North Beach (Point Reyes) Limantour North Beach (Point Reyes) North Beach (Point Reyes) Estero SMR Drakes Estero Olema Ma Drakes Estero Olema Ma Drakes Estero Olema Ma

Point Reyes HostelPoint Point Reyes HostelPoint Point Reyes HostelPoint South Beach (Point Reyes) South Beach (Point Reyes) South Beach (Point Reyes) Limantour Estero Reserve Limantour Estero Reserve Pt Reyes Limantour Estero Reserve Drakes Beach Drakes Beach SMR Drakes Beach

Limantour Beach Limantour Beach Limantour Beach

k k

e e

38° 00' r 38° 00' 38° 00' C

Point Reyes Headlands 38° 00' C Point Reyes Headlands 38° 00' Point Reyes Headlands 38° 00' t Double t s s a a o Point Reyes Point SMCA o Estero de C Point Reyes C Headland Headland SMR Pt Reyes

' Limantour '

6 1 SMCA 1

' 5 SMCA 0 ' 0

SMCA 6 Po

° °

6 Point Reyes 2 0

3 3

2 ° 2

1 1

3 Headlands - Double Point 1 Double Point 1 Double Point 1 - Double Point 1 2 Double Point 1 - Double Point 1 2

- SMCA 1

' ' '

Miles 6 6 6

4 4 4

37° 5 ° 37° 5 ° 37° 5 ° 024 5' 2 5' 2 5' 2

2 2 2

1 1 1

- - -

Draft MPA Proposals 0, 1 and 2 Proposal 0 illustrates the existing California state marine protected areas (MPAs) Draft MPA Proposals 0, 1 and 2 in the Marine Life Protection Act (MLPA) North Central Coast Study Region. Draft State Marine State Marine North Central MPA proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A are under review through the MLPA State Marine State Marine Recreational Public Prepared by DFG Conservation Coast Study Initiative and are expected to be further revised in March 2008. These are not Park (SMP) Reserve (SMR) Management Lands Marine Region GIS Area (SMCA) Area (SMRMA) Region MPA proposals for adoption by the California Fish and Game Commission. 1/24/2008 MLPAMLPA NorthNorth CentralCentral CoastCoast StudyStudy Region:Region: SubregionSubregion 33 BodegaBodega HeadHead toto DoubleDouble PointPoint

Salmon Creek Beach Salmon Creek Beach Salmon Creek Beach Creek Creek Creek s s s a a a Draft Proposali 3 (TC) Draft Proposali 4 (JC) External Proposali A Draft38° 20' Proposalb 3 (TC) Draft38° 20' Proposalb 4 (JC) 38° 2External0' Proposalb A 38° 20' a 38° 20' a 38° 20' a Bodega Bay b Bodega Bay b Bodega Bay b MusselMussel PointPoint E SONOMA MusselMussel PointPoint E SONOMA MusselMussel PointPoint E SONOMA COUNTY COUNTY COUNTY Bodega Marine Laboratory Bodega Marine Laboratory Bodega Marine Laboratory

Bodega Head Bodega Head Bodega Head Estero Estero de Americano Americano SMR SMR

38° 15' 38° 15' 38° 15' Dillon Beach Dillon Beach Dillon Beach s Creek s Creek s Creek Key Key Key Estero Lawson's Landing Lawson's Landing Estero San Lawson's Landing De San Antonio SMR Antonio SMR Walker Creek Delta Walker Creek Delta Walker Creek Delta Miller Park Launching Facility Miller Park Launching Facility Miller Park Launching Facility

McClures Beach McClures Beach McClures Beach 38° 10' 38° 10' 38° 10' 38° 10' 38° 10' 38° 10' Cypress Grove Cypress Grove Cypress Grove

' '

1 Lairds Landing 1 Lairds Landing Lairds Landing

0 0

° ° Tom al es

3 3

2 2

' ' '

' 6 1 Marconi Conference Ce 6 1 MarconiBay Conference SMRMA Ce 6 Marconi Conference Ce

- -

0 0 0

° ° °

3 Tomales Bay State Park 3 Tomales Bay State Park 3 Tomales Bay State Park

2 2 2

1 1 1 - Abbotts Lagoon - Drakes Abbotts Lagoon - 1 Abbotts Lagoon Drakes - Estero Estero Millerton Millerton ' MARIN SMR ' MARIN ' MARIN SMR 6 6 6 Inverness

5 COUNTY Tom al e 5 COUNTY 5 COUNTY 38° 05' ° 38° 05' ° 38° 05' ° 2 Bay 2 Bivalve 2 Tom al e 2 2 2

1 1 1 Bay SM - - - North Beach (Point Reyes) North Beach (Point Reyes) Drakes North Beach (Point Reyes) Drakes Estero Olema Ma Drakes Estero Olema Ma Bay SMCA Drakes Estero Olema Ma

Point Reyes HostelPoint Point Reyes HostelPoint Point Reyes HostelPoint South Beach (Point Reyes) South Beach (Point Reyes) South Beach (Point Reyes) Limantour Estero Reserve Limantour Estero Reserve Limantour Estero Reserve Drakes Beach Drakes Beach Drakes Beach

Point Limantour Beach Limantour Beach Limantour Beach

k k

Reyes SMR k

e e e

r r

38° 00' r 38° 00' Point 38° 00' C C

Point Reyes Headlands 38° 00' C Point Point Reyes Headlands 38° 00' Point Reyes Headlands Limantour t t Reyes SMR t s s SMR s a Reyes SMR a a o o ' o

C C 6 C

' '

' ' '

6 6

1 1 1

5 5 -

0 Point 5 5 5 '

° °

° ° °

2 2

0 2 2 2

' Reyes 2 2 2

2 2 2

° 1 Point 1 1

1 - 1 Double Point - 1 Double Point 1 Double Point - 3 Double Point 0 Double Point Double Point SMCA - Point - - ° 2 ° Reyes

3 - Reyes

2 ' Double ' SMCA ' 1 6 SMCA - 6 6 Miles 4 Point 4 4 37° 5 ° 37° 5 ° 37° 5 ° 5' 2 5' 2 5' 2

036 2 SMCA 2 2

1 1 1

- - -

Estero de San Antonio No take Estero de San Antonio No take State Marine Recreational State Marine Reserve Management Area (Very (Very high) high)

Clam Island State Marine No take Recreational Management Area (Very high)

Tomales Bay State Marine No take EXCEPT recreational hook & line South Tomales Bay State No take Tomales Bay State Marine No take EXCEPT recreational hook and Park (Moderate low) species (but not marine aquatic plants). Marine Recreational Park (Moderate low) line species other than marine aquatic Only lightweight, hand-carried boats may Management Area (Very plants. Only lightweight, hand-carried be launched/ operated in SMP. high) boats may be launched or operated within the Park. Point Reyes Headlands No take EXCEPT commercial take of Point Reyes State Marine No take Point Reyes State Marine No take State Marine Conservation finfish and algae (except giant and bull Reserve (Very high) Reserve (Very high) Area (Moderate low) kelp).

Point Reyes State Marine Salmon trolling and crab pots, commercial Point Reyes State Marine Salmon trolling, anchovy, sardine, herring,

Subregion 3: Bodega Head to Double Point to Double Head Bodega 3: Subregion Conservation Area and recreational Conservation Area dungeness crab, squid (applies to (Moderate high) (Moderate high) commercial and recreational)

Estero de Limantour State No take EXCEPT commercial take of Drakes- Limantour Estero No take Drakes Estero State No take Marine Conservation Area finfish and algae (except giant and bull State Marine Reserve Marine Reserve (Very (Moderate low) kelp). (Very high) high)

Estero de San Antonio No take Estero de San Antonio No take State Marine Reserve State Marine Reserve (Very high) (Very high)

Tomales Bay State Marine No take Tomales Bay State Marine No take of marine species. Allows duck Tomales Bay State Marine No take Reserve (Very high) Recreational Management hunting w/ intent to phase out via separate Reserve (Very high) Area (Very high) regulatory process.

Point Reyes State Marine No take Point Reyes State Marine No take Point Reyes State Marine No take Reserve (Very high) Reserve (Very high) Reserve (Very high)

Point Reyes State Marine Salmon trolling and crab pots, commercial Point Reyes State Marine Salmon trolling and dungeness crab, Point Reyes State Marine Salmon trolling, anchovy, sardine, herring,

Subregion 3: Bodega Head to Double Point to Double Head Bodega 3: Subregion Conservation Area and recreational Conservation Area commercial and recreational Conservation Area dungeness crab trap, squid (commercial & (Moderate high) (Moderate high) (Moderate high) recreational)

Drakes Estero State No take Drakes Estero State No take Drakes Bay State Marine Oyster aquaculture only Marine Reserve (Very Marine Reserve (Very Conservation Area high) high) (Moderate)

Limantour State Marine No take Reserve (Very high)

SMCA = state marine conservation area, SMP = state marine park, SMR = state marine reserve, SMRMA = state marine recreational management area

California Marine Life Protection Act Initiative North Central Coast Project

Side-by-Side Comparison of Regional Proposal 0 and Draft MPA Proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A

Subregion 4: Double Point to Point San Pedro MLPAMLPA NorthNorth CentralCentral CoastCoast StudyStudy Region:Region: SubregionSubregion 44 DoubleDouble PointPoint toto PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro

Limantour Beach Mille Limantour Beach Mille Limantour Beach Mille Miller Cr rCr Miller Cr rCr Miller Cr rCr Samuel P. Taylor State Park Samuel P. Taylor State Park Samuel P. Taylor State Park 38° 00' Five Brooks Trailhead ProposalProposal 00 3DraftDraft8° 00' ProposalProposalFive Brooks Trailhead 11 (EC)(EC) 38°DraftDraft00' ProposalProposalFive Brooks Trailhead 22 (JD)(JD) P P i i ne ne Double G MARIN MARIN G MARIN u Point SMR u lc COUNTY C COUNTY C lc COUNTY C h o o h o r r r C Bolinas C DoubleDouble PointPoint 11 te DoubleDouble PointPoint 11 te DoubleDouble PointPoint 11 te r r e Ma Lagoon SMR Ma e Ma e der der e der k aCr aCr k aCr k k k e e e Point Reyes Bird Observatory Larkspure Point Reyes Bird Observatory Larkspure Point Reyes Bird Observatory Larkspure Duxbury r r r 37° 55' C 37° 55' C 37° 55' C Reef SMCA Bolinas Lagoon Nature Preserve Bolinas Lagoon Nature Preserve Bolinas Lagoon Nature Preserve Bolinas 37° 55' Bolinas 37° 55' Bolinas 37° 55' Stinson Beach Stinson Beach Stinson Beach

Steep Ravine Beach Steep Ravine Beach Steep Ravine Beach Slide Ranch Slide Ranch Slide Ranch Double Duxbury Point SMCA Muir Beach Reef SMCA Muir Beach Muir Beach

37° 50' 37° 50' 37° 50' 37° 50' 37° 50' 37° 50' Point Bonita Ligh Point Bonita Ligh Point Bonita Ligh Fo Fo Fo

Bake Bake Bake

' ' '

1 1 1

5 5 5

° Golden ° Golden ° Golden 2 2 2

2 SAN 2 SAN 2 SAN 1 1 1

- 37° 45' - 37° 45' - 37° 45' FRANCISCO FRANCISCO FRANCISCO COUNTY COUNTY COUNTY

' ' '

6 ' 6 ' 6 '

' ' '

1 1 1

4 6 4 6 4 6

1 1 1

4 4 4

3 3 3

° ° °

3 3 3

° ° °

2 ° Fort Funst 2 ° Fort Funst 2 ° Fort Funst 2 ° 2 ° 2 °

2 2 2 2 2 2

2 2 2

1 1 1

1 2 1 2 1 2

- - -

1 1 1

- - -

1 1 1

- - - - Thornton - Thornton - Thornton

37° 40' 37° 40' 37° 40' Mussel R Mussel R Mussel R

Sharp Pa Sharp Pa Fitzgerald Sharp Pa Mori Point Mori Point SMR Mori Point PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro Pedro Point Hea Pedro Point Hea Pedro Point Hea 37° 35' 37° 35' Devil's 37° 35' SAN MATEO Slide SAN MATEO SAN MATEO COUNTY COUNTY Fitzgerald COUNTY SMCA SMCA '

Gray Whale Co Gray Whale Co 1 Gray Whale Co

James V. ° 3

Fitzgerald Montara State Fitzgerald Montara State 1 Montara State Miles 31' -122° 31' -122° - SMP SMR 02.55 James V. Fitzge James V. Fitzge James V. Fitzge

Draft MPA Proposals 0, 1 and 2 Proposal 0 illustrates the existing California state marine protected areas (MPAs) Draft MPA Proposals 0, 1 and 2 in the Marine Life Protection Act (MLPA) North Central Coast Study Region. Draft State Marine State Marine North Central MPA proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A are under review through the MLPA State Marine State Marine Recreational Public Prepared by DFG Conservation Coast Study Initiative and are expected to be further revised in March 2008. These are not Park (SMP) Reserve (SMR) Management Lands Marine Region GIS Area (SMCA) Area (SMRMA) Region MPA proposals for adoption by the California Fish and Game Commission. 1/24/2008 MLPAMLPA NorthNorth CentralCentral CoastCoast StudyStudy Region:Region: SubregionSubregion 44 DoubleDouble PointPoint toto PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro

Limantour Beach Mille Limantour Beach Mille Limantour Beach Mille Miller Cr rCr Miller Cr rCr Miller Cr rCr Samuel P. Taylor State Park Samuel P. Taylor State Park Samuel P. Taylor State Park 38° 00' Five Brooks Trailhead MARIN 38° 00' Five Brooks Trailhead Limantour Five Brooks Trailhead DraftDraft ProposalProposal COUNTY33 (TC)(TC) DraftDraft ProposalProposal 44 (JC)(JC) SMR ExternalExternal ProposalProposal AA P i ne

G MARIN Duxbury Double u C C lc COUNTY C Bolinas o o h o SMR r Point SMR r r DoubleDouble PointPoint Lagoon te DoubleDouble PointPoint MARIN te DoubleDouble PointPoint C te r Ma Ma e Ma SMR der COUNTY der e der aCr aCr k aCr k k k e e e Point Reyes Bird Observatory Larkspurre Point Reyes Bird Observatory Larkspurre Point Reyes Bird Observatory Larkspurre 37° 55' Bolinas Lagoon Nature Preserve C 37° 55' Bolinas Lagoon Nature Preserve C 37° 55' Bolinas Lagoon Nature Preserve C Bolinas Bolinas Bolinas Duxbury Stinson Beach Stinson Beach Bolinas Stinson Beach SMCA Lagoon Steep Ravine Beach Steep Ravine Beach SMR Steep Ravine Beach Slide Ranch Duxbury Slide Ranch Slide Ranch SMCA Muir Beach Muir Beach Muir Beach

37° 50' 37° 50' 37° 50'

Point Bonita Ligh Point Bonita Ligh Point Bonita Ligh Fo Fo Fo

Bake Bake Bake

' ' '

1 1 1

5 5 5

° Golden ° Golden ° Golden 2 2 2

2 SAN 2 SAN 2 SAN 1 1 1

- 37° 45' - 37° 45' - 37° 45' FRANCISCO FRANCISCO FRANCISCO COUNTY COUNTY COUNTY

' ' '

1 1 1

6 6 6

1 1 1

4 4 4

3 3 3

° ° °

° Fo rt Fu nst ° Fo rt Fu nst ° Fo rt Fu nst 2 ° 2 ° 2 °

2 2 2

1 2 1 2 1 2

-122° 46' -122° 46' -122° 46' -122°

1 1 1

- - -

1 1 1

- - - - Th orn to n - Th orn to n - Th orn to n

37° 40' 37° 40' 37° 40' Mussel R Mussel R Mussel R

Sharp Pa Sharp Pa Sharp Pa Mori Point Mori Point Mori Point

PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro 37° 35' Pedro Point Hea 37° 35' Pedro Point Hea 37° 35' Pedro Point Hea SAN MATEO SAN MATEO SAN MATEO Fitzgerald Moss COUNTY COUNTY COUNTY

' - Devils ' ' Beach 1 Gray Whale Co 1 Gray Whale Co Fitzgerald 1 Gray Whale Co ° 3 Slide SMR 3 3 SMR ° ° SMR °

2 2 2

1 Montara State 1 Montara State 1 Montara State

- - - Miles Fitzgerald 036 James V. Fitzge - Devils James V. Fitzge James V. Fitzge Slide SMCA

Double Point State Marine Salmon trolling and crab pots, commercial Conservation Area and recreational (Moderate high)

Duxbury Reef State Marine RECREATIONAL: red abalone, dungeness Duxbury Reef State Marine salmon trolling & dungeness crab pots Conservation Area crab, rock crab, rockfish (Scorpaenidae), Conservation Area (both commercial and recreational), halibut (Moderate low) lingcod, cabezon, surfperch (Moderate) commercial by boat, recreational finfish (Embiotocidae), halibut, flounder, sole, fishing from shore. turbot, salmon, kelp greeningling, striped bass, steelhead, monkeyface eel, wolf eel, smelt and silversides COMMERCIAL: take of species other than giant & bull kelp is allowed

Bolinas Lagoon State No take

Subregion 4: Double Point to Point San Pedro Point to Point San Double 4: Subregion Marine Reserve (Very high)

Duxbury State Marine Salmon trolling and crab trap, commercial Double Point State Marine Salmon trolling and crab traps, commercial Conservation Area and recreational Conservation Area and recreational (Moderate-high) (Moderate high)

Duxbury Reef State Marine salmon trolling & dungeness crab traps Conservation Area (both commercial & recreational), (Moderate) commercial halibut by boat, recreational finfish shorefishing

Bolinas State Marine No take Bolinas Lagoon State No take

Subregion 4: Double Point to Point San Pedro Point to Point San Double 4: Subregion Reserve (Very high) Marine Reserve (Very high)

SMCA = state marine conservation area, SMP = state marine park, SMR = state marine reserve, SMRMA = state marine recreational management area

California Marine Life Protection Act Initiative North Central Coast Project

Side-by-Side Comparison of Regional Proposal 0 and Draft MPA Proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A

Subregion 5: Point San Pedro to Pigeon Point MLPAMLPA NorthNorth CentralCentral CoastCoast StudyStudy Region:Region: SubregionSubregion 55 PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro toto PigeonPigeon PointPoint

' ' '

1 1 1

2 2 2

° ° °

2 2 2

PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro 2 PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro 2 PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro 2 Pedro Point Headlands 1 Pedro Point Headlands 1 Pedro Point Headlands 1 - - - 37° 35' Proposal k0 Draft37° 35' Proposal 1 (EC)k Draft37° 35' Proposal 2 (JD)k Proposalre e 0 Draft Proposal 1 (EC)ree Draft Proposal 2 (JD)ree C C C z z z e e e h h h c c c n n n ' a ' a ' a

1 Gray Whale Cove State Beach S 1 Gray Whale Cove State Beach S 1 Gray Whale Cove State Beach S 3 ek 3 ek 3 ek ° re ° re ° re James V. 2 Co Devil's 2 Co 2 Co 2 e 2 e 2 e t r t r t r 1 e 1 e 1 e Fitzgerald - Montara State Beach a g Slide - Montara State Beach a g - Montara State Beach a g un un un SAN MATEO M Yo SAN MATEO M Yo SAN MATEO M Yo

SMP r r r n SMCA n n COUNTY u COUNT Y u COUNTY u a a a h h h t t t

S r S r S r

James V. Fitzgerald Marine Reserve A James V. Fitzgerald Marine Reserve A James V. Fitzgerald Marine Reserve A

J J J Fitzgerald 37° 30' 37° 30' Pillar Point Harbor SMR Pillar Point Harbor 37° 30' Pillar Point Harbor

Dunes Beach (San Mateo County) Dunes Beach (San Mateo County) Dunes Beach (San Mateo County) Fitzgerald Fitzgerald SMCA SMR Half Moon Bay Half Moon Bay Half Moon Bay Overlook (Francis Beach, San M Overlook (Francis Beach, San M Overlook (Francis Beach, San M Ar Ar Ar ro ro ro y on y on y on o Le o Le o Le

37° 25' Cowell Ranch Beach 37° 25' Cowell Ranch Beach 37° 25' Cowell Ranch Beach

r r r C C C

s s s o o o ' it ' it ' it

6 b 6 b 6 b

3 o 3 o 3 o L L L

° ° °

2 2 2

2 Martins Beach 2 Martins Beach 2 Martins Beach

1 1 1 - k - k - k ree ree ree Dry C Dry C Dry C

' ' '

1 1 1

3 3 3

° ° ° 37° 20' 2 37° 20' 2 37° 20' 2 2 San Gregorio Private B 2 San Gregorio Private B 2 San Gregorio Private B

1 1 1

- - - San Gregorio State Be San Gregorio State Be San Gregorio State Be

' ' '

6 6 6

2 2 2

° ° °

2 Pomponio State Beach 2 Pomponio State Beach 2 Pomponio State Beach

2 2 2

1 1 1

- - -

37° 15' Pescadero 37° 15' Pescadero 37° 15' Pescadero

Pebble Beach (San Mateo Pebble Beach (San Mateo Pebble Beach (San Mateo Bean Hollow State Beach Bean Hollow State Beach Bean Hollow State Beach

Pigeon Point Pigeon Point Pigeon Point Miles Pigeon Point Pigeon Point Lighthou Pigeon Point Pigeon Point Lighthou Pigeon Point Pigeon Point Lighthou 02.5537° 10' 37° 10' 37° 10' Gazos Creek Gazos Creek Gazos Creek

Draft MPA Proposals 0, 1 and 2 Proposal 0 illustrates the existing California state marine protected areas (MPAs) Draft MPA Proposals 0, 1 and 2 in the Marine Life Protection Act (MLPA) North Central Coast Study Region. Draft State Marine State Marine North Central MPA proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A are under review through the MLPA State Marine State Marine Recreational Public Prepared by DFG Conservation Coast Study Initiative and are expected to be further revised in March 2008. These are not Park (SMP) Reserve (SMR) Management Lands Marine Region GIS Area (SMCA) Area (SMRMA) Region MPA proposals for adoption by the California Fish and Game Commission. 1/24/2008 MLPAMLPA NorthNorth CentralCentral CoastCoast StudyStudy Region:Region: SubregionSubregion 55 PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro toto PigeonPigeon PointPoint

PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro PointPoint SanSan PedroPedro Pedro Point Headlands Pedro Point Headlands Pedro Point Headlands Draft37° 35' Proposal 3 (TC)k Draft Proposal 4 (JC)k External37° 35' Proposal Ak Draft Proposal 3 (TC)ree Draft Proposal 4 (JC)ree External Proposal reAe C C C z 37° 35' z z e e e h Fitzgerald h h c c c Moss n n n ' a - Devils ' a ' a

1 Gray Whale Cove State Beach 1 Gray Whale Cove State Beach 1 Gray Whale Cove State Beach Beach S S Fitzgerald S 3 ek Slide SMR 3 ek 3 ek ° re ° re ° re SMR 2 Co 2 Co SMR 2 Co 2 e 2 e 2 e t r t r t r 1 e 1 e 1 e - Montara State Beach a g - Montara State Beach a g - Montara State Beach a g un un un SAN MATEO M Yo SAN MATEO M Yo SAN MATEO M Yo

n r Fitzgerald n r n r COUNTY u COUNTY u COUNTY u a a a h h h t t t S r - Devils S r S r

James V. Fitzgerald Marine Reserve A James V. Fitzgerald Marine Reserve A James V. Fitzgerald Marine Reserve A

J J Slide SMCA J Moss 37° Beach 37° 30' Pillar Point Harbor 37° 30' Pillar Point Harbor 30' Pillar Point Harbor SMCA Fitzgerald Dunes Beach (San Mateo County) Dunes Beach (San Mateo County) SMCA Dunes Beach (San Mateo County)

Half Moon Bay Half Moon Bay Half Moon Bay Overlook (Francis Beach, San M Overlook (Francis Beach, San M Overlook (Francis Beach, San M Ar Ar Ar ro ro ro y on y on y on o Le o Le o Le

37° 25' Cowell Ranch Beach 37° 25' Cowell Ranch Beach 37° 25' Cowell Ranch Beach

r r r C C C

s s s o o o ' it ' it ' it

6 b 6 b 6 b

3 o 3 o 3 o L L L

° ° °

2 2 2

2 Martins Beach 2 Martins Beach 2 Martins Beach

1 1 1 - k - k - k ree ree ree Dry C Dry C Dry C

' '

1 1

3 3

° ° 37° 20' 2 37° 20' 37° 20' 2 2 San Gregorio Private B San Gregorio Private B 2 San Gregorio Private B 1 San 1

- - San Gregorio State Be Gregorio San Gregorio State Be San Gregorio State Be SMR

' ' '

6 6 6

2 2 2

° ° °

2 Pomponio State Beach 2 Pomponio State Beach 2 Pomponio State Beach

2 2 2

1 1 1

- - Pescadero - - Estuary SMR 37° 15' Pescadero 37° 15' Pescadero 37° 15' Pescadero

Pebble Beach (San Mateo Pebble Beach (San Mateo Pebble Beach (San Mateo Bean Hollow State Beach Bean Hollow State Beach Bean Hollow State Beach ° PigeonPigeon PointPoint PigeonPigeon PointPoint PigeonPigeon PointPoint Miles Pigeon Point Lighthou Pigeon Point Lighthou Pigeon Point Lighthou 02.5537° 10' 37° 10' 37° 10' Gazos Creek Gazos Creek Gazos Creek

Devils Slide State Marine Salmon trolling & crab (both commercial Fitzgerald State Marine Salmon trolling, anchovy, sardine, herring, Conservation Area and recreational), wetfish (including squid) Conservation Area dungeness crab (All applies to commercial (Moderate high) (Moderate high) and recreational) Subregion 5: Point San Pedro to Pigeon Point to Pigeon Pedro Point San 5: Subregion

Moss Beach State Marine Salmon trolling, crab, and squid, Fitzgerald- Devils Slide Salmon trolling, crab, coastal pelagics, Fitzgerald State Marine Salmon trolling, anchovy, sardine, herring, Conservation Area commercial and recreational State Marine Conservation and squid (commercial & recreational Conservation Area dungeness crab (All applies to commercial (Moderate high) Area (Moderate high) (Moderate high) & recreational)

San Gregorio State Marine No take Reserve (Very high)

Pescadero Estuary State No take Marine Reserve (Very

Subregion 5: Point San Pedro to Pigeon Point to Pigeon Pedro Point San 5: Subregion high)

SMCA = state marine conservation area, SMP = state marine park, SMR = state marine reserve, SMRMA = state marine recreational management area

California Marine Life Protection Act Initiative North Central Coast Project

Side-by-Side Comparison of Regional Proposal 0 and Draft MPA Proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A

Subregion 6: Farallon Islands MLPAMLPA NorthNorth CentralCentral CoastCoast StudyStudy Region:Region: SubregionSubregion 66 FarallonFarallon IslandsIslands ProposalProposal 00 DraftDraft ProposalProposal 11 (EC)(EC) DraftDraft ProposalProposal 22 (JD)(JD)

' ' '

1 1 1

° ° °

3 3 3

' ' '

2 2 2

6 6 6 1 3 1 37° 5 1 37° 5 - 0 7° 50' - 0 0' - 0 0'

° ° °

3 3 3

2 2 2

1 1 1

- - -

N Farallon Island SMR

Farallon Islands 37° 45' 37° 45' 37° 45' South East SMCA Farallon SE Farallon Island SMR SMR

' ' '

1 1'

6 6 6

5 5 5

° ° °

3 3° 0

2 2 2

- -12

1 1 1

- - -

Farallon - SE Farallon South East Islands Farallon SMCA SMCA

' Island SMCA

3 6 3 ' 7° 40' 7° 40' 37° 40'

2 -

Miles 37° 35' 37° 35' 37° 35' 012

Draft MPA Proposals 0, 1 and 2 Proposal 0 illustrates the existing California state marine protected areas (MPAs) Draft MPA Proposals 0, 1 and 2 in the Marine Life Protection Act (MLPA) North Central Coast Study Region. Draft State Marine State Marine North Central MPA proposals 1, 2, 3, 4 and External A are under review through the MLPA State Marine State Marine Recreational Public Prepared by DFG Conservation Coast Study Initiative and are expected to be further revised in March 2008. These are not Park (SMP) Reserve (SMR) Management Lands Marine Region GIS Area (SMCA) Area (SMRMA) Region MPA proposals for adoption by the California Fish and Game Commission. 1/24/2008 MLPAMLPA NorthNorth CentralCentral CoastCoast StudyStudy Region:Region: SubregionSubregion 66 FarallonFarallon IslandsIslands DraftDraft ProposalProposal 33 (TC)(TC) DraftDraft ProposalProposal 44 (JC)(JC) ExternalExternal ProposalProposal AA

' ' '

1 1 1

° ° °

3 3 3

' ' '

2 N Farallon SMR 2 2

6 6 6 1 37° 50' 1 37° 5 1 37° 50' - 0 - 0 0' - 0

° ° °

3 3 3

2 2 North 2

1 1 1 - - Farallon - N Farallon SMR SMCA

Southeast Farallone SMR 37° 45' 37° 45' Southeast 37° 45' Farallones Farallon SMCA SMR

' ' '

1 1'

6 6 6

5 5 5

° ° 0

° ° °

2 2 2

2 23

2 2 2

- -1

1 1 1

- - -

37° 40' 3 37° 40' Southeast 37° 40'

1 - Farallone SE Farallon SMCA SMCA

' '

6 6

0 Southeast 0

° °

3 3

2 2

1 Farallon 1 - SE Farallon - SMR SMCA °

Miles 37° 35' 37° 35' 37° 35' 012

SE. Farallon State Marine No take Southeast Farallon Island No take Reserve (Very high) State Marine Reserve (Very high)

Subregion 6: Farallon Islands Farallon 6: Subregion SE. Farallon State Marine Salmon trolling, commercial and Southeast Farallon Island Salmon trolling, commercial and Conservation Area (High) recreational State Marine Conservation recreational Area (High)

North Farallon State Salmon trolling, commercial and Marine Conservation Area recreational (High)

Farallons State Marine No take of sardine, anchovy, or squid Conservation Area (Moderate low)

SE Farallon State Marine No take Southeast Farallon State No take Southeast Farallon State No take Reserve (Very high) Marine Reserve (Very Marine Reserve (Very high) high)

Subregion 6: Farallon Islands Farallon 6: Subregion SE Farallon State Marine Salmon trolling, commercial and Southeast Farallon State Salmon trolling, commercial and Southeast Farallon State Salmon trolling, commercial and Conservation Area (High) recreational Marine Conservation Area recreational Marine Conservation Area recreational (High) (Moderate high)

SMCA = state marine conservation area, SMP = state marine park, SMR = state marine reserve, SMRMA = state marine recreational management area