Nelson Cook Carlin Mager Ross Kraft vyn Martin Stalzer Cook Renico Gilbert McDougall Klingensmith Lopez Brogger Mclogan Kusterer No Name Nowak Deane Katckos Bacher Smith Moldovan Anderson Cataldo Naberhaus lllegible Smith Landolt Fike Schneider Bruce Haberkamp Comai Hughes Manley No Name Turner Simon Naberhaus Illegible Zamm Forester Lock Illegible Lawrence Sidner Kulback Illegible Burton Mankel Litton Illegible Satanski Miskiewicz Hrigora Sidner Andresen lllegible Wandruff Beni Fangboner lllegible Peak Hughes Klingensmith Farris Stanton Dillon Energy Services Flanigan Davis Nowak Milis Katikos Jensen Berryman Newburg Johnson Snec Balan Laug Anderson Cremonte Davis Brozovich Wachner McCarthy Massuch Cook Hornbeck Dear Mr. Robert Nelson

I write concerning cleaner, more affordable sources of energy; in particular, cases U-14031 and U-13808. Wind is an ever present source of energy. Harnessing it's raw power will not only promote cleaner, more efficient, less expensive energy use, but will also stop the ravaging of our land in the quest for more fossil fuels. Oil and coal have already been identified as pollutants. They are also in diminishing supply. Wind and sun, however, are a constant. This nation has always held the promise of a better tomorrow, of the freedom to work hard, to learn and to grow. Let's not stifle that fkeedom, but encourage it, through tax incentives to companies to promote cleaner, safer, more eficient means of energy. Encourage the support of 9' 9' corn-by l~~the~signupfhd&reenper _- - I-__I__ Let's work together to make this nation a stronger, cleaner and better place to live, for us, for our children and for future generations.

Thank you,

Nicholas & Kelley Nelson 3424 Tecumseh River Road Lasing MI 48906 Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson:

I am writing to strongly urge you to work diligently to make renewable energy more available and more affordable in Michigan. Toward this end, I advocate two specific actions on the part of the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC).

First, in Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordablewind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

And second, in Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

These two initiatives are vital in moving Michigan consumers from their dependence on polluting fossil fuels to making good use of renewable, clean energy solutions such as wind energy. Such actions only make sense, as the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising. .

Please do not hesitate in takinv these very necessary actions!

I appreciate your time and consideration in regard to this very important matter. I would also appreciate a reply to my letter.

1813 Derby Birmingham, MI 48009 (248) 644-3374 James 6. Ross 3316 Summit Ridge Dr. Rochester Hills, MI 48306

October 20,2004

MPSC P. 0.Box 30221 - " LansWg; MI 48909

Attn. Mr. Robert Nelson

Dear Sir:

In Case U -13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

It is my understanding that the price of wind power is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it essential that utilities invest in wind power.

I appreciate your attention to my appeal on this matter and I am anxious to know what action you will take. *-a -

James B. Ross

October 26,2004

Dear Member of the Michigan Public Service Commission,

I am writing in support of the MPSC to enspre that we receive affordable, clean power. I support Case U- 13808, which states the MPSC should order DTE to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for the "green power" by lowering the price. I also support Case U-1403 1, which states the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.

Please make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. Thank you f ~m,%R ;-' u ~LIC s GR~I c t Please reply as to what may be happening. Thank you. T-I "nIIMISSl0N Kathleen Renico 1233 Gettysburg Ct. Rochester Hills, MI 48306 Mrs. RUM E. McOougall Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson:

I am writing to strongly urge you to work diligently to make renewable energy more available and more affordable in Michigan. Toward this end, I advocate two specific actions on the part of the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC).

First, in Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. - -. And second, in Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

These two initiatives are vital in moving Michigan consumers from their dependence on polluting fossil fuels to making good use of renewable, clean energy solutions such as wind energy. Such actions only make sense, as the,price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising.

Please do not hesitate in takiny these very necessary actions!

I appreciate your time and consideration in regard to this very important matter. I would also apprecij@a reply to my letter.

@&1813 Der y Birmingham, MI 48009 chris [email protected] (248) 644 - 3374 --- October 25,2004

Dear Ms. Chappelle,

In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage costumers to signjg-for "green power" by lowering the price. The - price of wind energy is getting lower, and the price of fossil fuels is climbing. Please help conserve our resources and save our environment.

Thank you for your time.

Sincerely,

Emily Mclogan

NQV 0 8 2001

I ------he* b *,24%&&5-~aawiM;a October 20,2004

Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC PO Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

1. In Case U- 13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

2. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

3. Point out that the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power fiom fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.

Thank you for your response.

Shelly Deane

NOV 0 8 2004 October 25,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson

MPSC

P.O. Box 3022 1

Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Mr. Lark,

Please help make renewable energy more available in Michigan.

In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and

encourage customers to sign up fer "green me-' by-lowwing the price. -*

In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its' use of wind

Energy and lower the cost of its "'green power" program.

The price of wind energy is dropping, while the cost of power fiom fossil fuels is rising, , making it vital that utilities invest in winf power. , ,= H, c i

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

October 25,2004

Dear Mr. Nelson,

As a resident of Michigan I am writing to express my concern about energy use in our state. We all know we are much too dependent on non-renewal sources of energy, and ---- @t tk_sooner we thkpaiblem+ihehitm&mr~~- - Even my 13 year old daughter does not understand why we are not doing more to encourage renewable ideas. How could something so clear to a child be so difficult for adults to agree on? Historically nobody remembers the guy that just follows along; it's the true leaders that make the history books and shape our htute. I urge you to become a leader on this issue. I

I specifically urge you to consider the following:

In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

, \L. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power fiom fossil fuels is _ rising, making it important that utilities invest in wind power.

As non-renewable energy supplies run lower and lower, prices are going to rise exponentially. If we already have a successful alternative why not use it at the same time increase the air quality in our state. Seems simple enough, but sometime it takes a leader to get people to do the right thing for ourselves and for our hture generation.

Thank you and I look forward to your reply,

Mary Cataldo \

P J Peter Clark, Chairman MPSC PO Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

In Case U-13808, the MPSG should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumer's Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power''progmn. Thank you for your consideration in this matter. I Sincerely,

Victoria Landolt b

Dear Laura Chappelle,

I am writing to address the issue of Michigan's need to find and make a conscious effort to find renewable sources for our energy needs. The earth has already reached our peak production of oil and the demand is increasingly exceeding the supply year after year. There are countless ways to obtain other energy sources but it must become a priority of those who are our voices in legislature to make this happen. The costs of such sources as wind are going down while fossil fuels keep rising and we need to get in now and make a change in the way we get our energy. The earth will not provide fossil fuels forever and it is necessary to either order DTE to invest in lower costs renewable energy or loose our energy forever. Please let me know the ways in which you plan to find and save cost on energy, this is a topic that can not be avoided!! ,------_--.------r__ ._A ------I------i- -. - - - -- Jennifer Schneider November 5,2004

Dear Mr. Robert Nelson, tmdcpp F Please make renewable energy more available and af df able n Michigan. I feel that it is very important for us to find other ways to provide energy. Our resources will not always be there, if we continue using them at the same rate that we are today. We need to make sure that our younger generation has the same opportunities and resources that we do. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. Also, in Case U- 14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of it's "green power'' program. I am aware that the price of wind is dropping while the cost of power fkom fossil fuels is rising, therefore I think it is vital that the utilities invest and research wind power.

Thank you and Sincerely,

~o~lieHaberkamp October 27,2004

J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC PO Box 3022 1 Lansing, Michigan 48909

Mr. Lark:

I would like to make you aware of my feelings that the MPSC, in case U-13808, should order Detroit Edison(DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

--- I also would like to make you aware of my feeling that the MPSC, in case U-1403 1, should order Consumers ~nerg~to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost 'of its- -'-- "green power" program.

My research shows that the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of fossil fuel power is rising.

Thank you and good luc Meredith Hughes A

In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the wst of its "green power" program.

COMMISSION NC!~n e a5c4

PrLcb m- - -7. . "",, - , '

FORESTER

- w 3,-L( Ms. (am C.hpqelle N\QSC Q.~.B~x3ma\ m5rq r wx cleqoq ~)ear.wdrfv\:

Please consider these points:

In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. -

In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Enetgy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

/ The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in mind power.

Thank you for your consideration

RA*iz Sidner

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P. 0.Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Sir,

I am writing to ask you to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program I believe that this would benefit Michigan greatly since the cost of power fiom fossil fuels is rising but the cost of wind energy is dropping which makes it vital that utilities invest in wind power. Thank you for considering this important information.

Jennifer Mankel

Dear Sir:

- Please consider these points: -- - -

In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Enetgy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power fiom fossil fbels is rising, / making it vital that utilities invest in mind power.

Thank you for your consideration

Liz Sidner

October 27, 2004

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC PO Box 3022 1 Lansing, Michigan 48909

Mr. Nelson: I

I would like to make you aware of my feelings that the MPSC, in case U-13808, should order Detroit Edison(DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

I also would like to make you aware of my feeling that the MPSC, in case U-1403 1, - - " should order Consumers Energy to expand it5 use of wind energy and lowerthe cost-of its "green power" program.

My research shows that the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of fossil fuel power is rising. Dear Michigan Public Service Commission:

In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green Power" by lowering the price.

In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil kels is rising, making-it-viblthat utilities invesLi~windpower, --- . - a- - . -J*- D(h, ONENERGY SERVICES 2 1312 Mack Avenue Grosse Pointe Woods, MI 48236 OCT 26 2004 313.885.4299 Fax 313.885.4720 \I

October 19,2004

Honorable Commissioner Robert Nelson Michigan Public Service Commission P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, Michigan 48909

-- -. . -& A - . -- -- ? ..- . . ------

Dear Commissioner Nelson,

Over the last 18 years of my involvement in Michigan's deregulated natural gas industry and more recently electric industry, I have developed a respect for the MPSC and its workings.

Having had the experience of being an intervener and witness in U-10755 in 1996, (Consumers Power, 'natural gas), I can appreciate the complexity of the issues currently facing the commission in 13808. This current electric case is substantially more challenging than U- 10755.

There are a few observations that I would like to make.

1. February's interim order in 13808 effectively reversed the economics for the primary account customers on Electric choice, causing most of them to now pay more that they would have paid on their prior tariff rates. Hopefully, this will be corrected in the final order.

2. After U-10755, Consumers Energy went through a series of restructuring initiatives in an effort to improve corporate efficiency and reduce costs. By comparison, DTE appears to be unwilling to do the obvious and reduce overhead; rather, they seek to pass their inefficiencies off

- L on their customers through tiiis rate case and their legislatiVi-initiativzs. -All-ofZs +inMich-igan would be better off had DTE used the money that it is spending on its misleading TV and radio campaign to hire efficiency experts to help DTE become more efficient and competitive. ~ 3. Michigan will continue to have some of the highest rates in the Midwest until DTE becomes more competitive. Perhaps competition is the only market force capable of re-directing DTE's senior management, who continue to receive generous bonuses for perpetuating business as usual, to reduce expenses so that DTE can lower its rates.

4. Why should every school, church, industrial and commercial enterprise on DTE's system, who is trying to reduce their operating costs, be penalized because DTE refuses to make changes that would lead to a reduction of its rates? Page 2 Commissioner Nelson October 19,2004

5. Where is the incentive for DTE to become more competitive? Perhaps this should be a prerequisite before DTE is granted any further rate increases?

2 - <-I------,- -s ------6. When is enough, enough?

Just as the MPSC did in U-10755 with Consumers Power, this commission has the opportunity to force DTE to become more competitive.

I hope you make the tough choices. 30556 Greenland Livonia, Michigan 48154

SEP

August 26,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson VIPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

- ,- Re: Case U-13808 and Case U-14031

Dear Mr. Nelson,

Iam writing to you today regarding the importance of making renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan.

As you are aware, Michigan residents use mostly electricity from power plants that use fossil fuels. These fuels are in limited supply, the prices are increasing dramatically, and we will be required to spend billions of dollars to decrease pollution from these very same power plants that are producing our electricity.

Wind power holds great promise and advantages for Michigan. It is estimated that wind power could provide 11% of the electricity in Michigan at rates that are competitive now, and the price of electricity produced by wind is on the decline as the equipment improves. The best part for everyone is that the cost of wind itself is free, and it produces no pollution.

Iask that you please commit to meet our electric needs with clean, affordable wind power. I would like to know your decision on this very important matter, as Michigan's future is at stake.

Thank you in advance.

Sincerely,

Carolyn Davis Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P. 0.Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Mr. Nelson,

I urge you to support these 2 items.

Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison @TE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

And - - Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

Thank you for your consideration on these issues;

Sandy Milis Livonia, MI 48 154 Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

August 26,2004 Dear Mr. Nelson,

I am concerned was recently in Germany and took note of the multitude of high efficiency windmills all along the countryside. They were actually very interesting to look at. It is a proven fact that wind can efliciently provide a significant energy source for Michiganders.

In Case U- 13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customer to sign up for "green power7' by lowering the price.

In Case U- 14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" Program. The cost of power &om fossil fuels continues to rise. I am in full support of using lower cost-wind energy in Michigan.

Please reply back to me on the MPSC's part in making renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan.

Thank You,

Linda A Jensen aR--**- BI-

(~7~3G .c---i--z w +b August 25,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson,

I am writing in reference to Case U-13808. The MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

In addition, in reference to Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

With oil prices rising, it is important to look at other sources of energy. Wind power seems a natural and viable choice.

I look forward to hearing from you as to your position on these Cases.

MICHlwl\r rutrul; btHVlCF Wlh/l AlCClnhl 7590 Kilkenny Drive Brighton, MI 481 16 SEP O 8 'Cbc+f Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson, August 25,2004

Current utility bills are outrageous. It is difficult to run a household with children and make ends meet. My husband and I both work to be able to afford simple luxuries for our family. Electricity, heat & air conditioning should not be considered a LUXURY in this day & age. It should be an affordable utility for house holds in the state of Michigan.

It is imperative that other options be considered in order to lower these outrageous and damaging costs. Average families are feeling the pinch of the high costs. What about less fortunate & the elderly on fixed incomes? What are their options? If they are unable to afford utilities they either do without or must rely on charity fiom the state. The charity option is actually charging tax payers, AKA the average family, TWICE.

In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

In Case U-1403 1, The MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand it's use of wind power energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

It seems that wind power in Michigan should be in abundance considering the open areas relating to the Great Lakes. Why not harness and use this natural resource when it is far less costly than the curkent use of fossil fuels?

I look forward to your reply in this matter.

Mrs. Therese Cremonte L/ 7735 So. Kilkenny SEP 0 8 ?is.4 Brighton, MI 48 116 7674 S. Kilkenny Brighton, Michigan, 48 116

Mr. Robert Nelson Michigan Public Service Commission P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, Mi. 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson,

Please make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan., We are a retired couple trying to manage on a fixed income, and find that rising prices are a serious problem for us. Case U-13808 and Case U - 14031 Require your serious attention. Michigan needs all the help it can get, in these times when the State Budget is in such dire straits.

Tlqard( you for your consideration, AUGUST 20,2004

MICHAEL W. MCCARTHY 34226 MUNGER LIVONLG MI 48154

MR ROBERT NELSON,

AS A CITIZEN OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN AND BEING CONCERNED ABOUT THE FUTURE OF RISING COSTS OF OUR ENERGY SUPPLIES, I AM WRITING THIS LETTERASKING YOU TO ORDER DTE TO INVEST IN AFFORDABLE WIND ENERGY ( CASE U-13808 1. ALSO, I WOULD LIKE TO ORDER CONSUMERS ENERGY TO EXPAND ITS USE OF WIND ENERGY ( CASE U-14031). BOTH OF THESE EFFORTS BY THE UTILITIES WOULD CERTAINLY HELP IN REDUCING OUR ENERGY COSTS AND REDUCE OURUSE OF FOSSIL FUELS. I WOULD APPRECIATE YOUR PERSONAL ATTENTION THIS IMPORTANT MATTER

SINCERELY, August 13,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, Michigan 48909

Re: Renewable Energy

Dear Mr. Nelson:

This letter is to show my support for the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) to vote to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Energy (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consutners Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.

Therefore, please vote yes in support of Case U-13808 and Case U-1403 1.

Sincerely,

Mary Beth Cook 33 160 Rayburn Livonia, Michigan 48 154 August 13,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, Michigan 48909

Re: Renewable Energy

Dear Mr. Nelson:

This letter is to show my support for the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) to vote to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. In Case U- 13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Energy (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, makmg it vital that utilities invest in wind power.

Therefore, please vote yes in support of Case U- 13808 and Case U-1403 1.

Russell A. Cook 33 160 Rayburn Livonia, Michigan 48154 Mr. Robert Nelson SEP O P / MPSC P.0 BOX30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson

I am writing today to ask the Michigan Public Service Commission to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan.

I. In Case U-13808,the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign upfor u ------" --I+ -I I A-8 2. A-8 order Consumers Energy to expand its use of the wind energy and lower the cost of its "greenpower" program. 3. Point out that the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of powerfiom fossilfuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.

Renewable Energy is something that should concern everyone.

Sincerely,

Elva Mager 11022 Shadow Woods Whitmore Lake, MI 481 8 August 20,2004 SFD ll.t(.l.

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O.Box ,3022 1 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson,

1. In case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. 2. In Case U-14031, the MPSC shouId order ~onswnmEmgy to axpmd its use of wind energy and Iowq the cast of its bbgreenpower" program. 3. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power fran fossil fhels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.

Your response to this matter would be greatly appmiated.

Sincerely,

Janice Kraft 34302 Munger Livonia, MI 48154 734.464.0659 August 25,2004

Jennifer Martin P.O. Box 602 10858 Hamburg Road Hamburg, MI 48139 SEP 0 8 ;/t~trli

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909 - Dear Mr. Nelson,

As the war presses on in Iraq, I am amazed at the continued belief that oil is the only inexpensive and efficient fuel. The cost of fossil fuels is rising, not only in the price per barrel, but also in the cost of American lives in the Middle East.

More now than ever, I feel it is important to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. In Cases U-13808 and U-14031, the MPSC should order DTE Energy and Consumers Energy to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to participate in those programs by lowering the price for "green power".

As I was sitting on the shores of Lake Michigan last week, in awe of its beauty, I couldn't help thinking about how much mercury and other pollutants were present. Please help clean up our environment so future generations can experience the beauty of our state.

I would like receive notice of any developments involving cases U-13808 and U-14031. August 13,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson hiipsc P.O. Box 3022 1 Lansing, Michigan 48909

Re: Renewable Energy

Dear Mr. Nelson:

This letter is to show my support for the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) to vote to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Energy (DTE) to invest in &ordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.

Therefore, please vote yes in support of Case U- 13808 and Case U-1403 1.

Sincerely,

Donna J. Cook 1 .. 33 160 Rayburn Livonia, Michigan 48 154 --". SEP r' I t 4

Heidi Brogger P.O. Box 307 Hamburg, MI 48139

August 25,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson,

I am writing with my concerns about fossil fuel use for the production of power. My concerns lie with the unnecessary depletion of one of our natural resources when a cheaper, more environmentally sound choice is within our grasp.

I am requesting that the MPSC order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage their customers to utilize "green power" by lowering utilization costs. (Case U-13808).

In a similar case (Case U-14031), I also request that the MPSC order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

Due to the fact that the price of wind energy continues to drop while the cost of fossil fuels is rising, I feel that these requests are warranted and appropriate. They are prudent actions in the best interests of economic and environmental responsibility.

The favor of a reply is requested. Thank you for your time and attention.

Sincerely,

Heidi Brogger Mr. Robert Nelson SEP O F (uL:.:.; MPSC P.O.box30221 Lansing, MI 48909

We are very interested in the idea of making renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan.

In Case-U-I 3808, the MPSG-should-order Detroit -Edison (DTE) to - -- invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order consumers energy to expand it's use of wind energy and lower the cost of it's "green power" program.

The price of wind evergy is dropping while the cost of fossile fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.

Thank you for your time and concerns. I am looking forward to your reply.

Thank You again,

MuL! C

A -". Mr. Nelson,

1. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. 2. In Case U- 14031, the MPSC sshould order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. Please reply to my responses when you have a chance.

Sincerly,

Rob ~owak~,

Mr. Robert Nelson

---- P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Thursday, August 26,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson,

I am writing today, asking you to help make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. The Michigan Public Service Commission has the power to make beneficial changes in renewable energy and energy conservation which will positively impact the citizens of Michigan.

In your role as a member of the MPSC, please consider:

In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to-sign up-for "green power" by lowering the price.

In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

I thank you for listening to my concerns and I would appreciate a response to this pressing matter.

Thank You,

Cassandra C. Smith

28940 Broadmoor - -&i*-& ------_ _ _ ------August 26,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P. 0.Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Mr. Nelson:

I am writing to today concerning the use of fossil fuels. I would like to see our country using more renewable energy sources such as wind and solar energy.

- In Case U-1,380,LI would like to see the W-SC order DTE to invest in affordable \?rind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power77by lowering the price.

In Case U-14301, I would like to see the MPSC order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

I would also like to point out that the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.

I would appreciate a reply to this letter stating what Michigan's government is doing to help lower our costs and promote renewable fuel sources.

Thank you,

Carol Anderson August 26,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 3022 1 Lansing, MI 48909 I

Dear Ms. Nelson:

I believe that it is critical that our utilities should invest in wind power. The price of fossil hels is rising, while the price of wind energy is dropping, and developing greater energy self-sufficiency is in our national best interest. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order DTE to encourage support of green power by its customers, and invest in wind energy. In Case U-14031, Consumers Energy should be ordered to lower the cost of its green power program.

You support regarding this critical issue will be greatly appreciated.

Sincerely, n

Livonia Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC ~ll~niun~ufun~~b ~~HUICF P.O.Box 30221 'WlAR/I@CIAhI Lansing, MI 48909 SGQ

Thursday, August 26,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson,

I am writing today, asking you to help make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. The Michigan Public Service Commission has the power to make beneficial changes in renewable energy and energy conservation which will positively impact the citizens of Michigan.

In your role as a member of the MPSC, please consider:

In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

I thank you for listening to my concerns and I would appreciate a response to this pressing matter.

Thank You,

Bradley ~Aith

28940 Broadmoor Livonia, MI 48 154 John and Bonita Fike 7900 Breezewood Court Ypsilanti, MI 481 97

August 24,2004

SF i' Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC PO Box 3022 1 Lansing, NZI 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson:

We would like to ask the Michigan Public Service Commission to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan.

In Case U- 13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power'? program.

The cost of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.

I would appreciate a reply and notification of the decision of MPSC in both Cases.

Bonita Fike 734-484-2 166 phone 734-484-2 177 fax [email protected] 29218 Broadmoor Street Livonia, MI 48154 August 25, 2004

Mr. Robert Nelsorl MPSC P.O.Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Sir:

I am corlcerned about the energy cost i11 Michigan. I have long thought that the way to go was Wind Power. In Case U-13808, IYTE (Detroit Edisorl) should be ordered to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage its custmers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

In Case U-14031 kthe MPSC should order Corlsumer Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

The cost of power from fossil fuels is rising. Alorlg with this our lakes are full of mercury and our air is getting worse every day.

It may also be a good idea to look irlto Federal funding for some of these riew ideas. The Federal Government has recently pushed auto changes that will cut down or1 gas use and air pollution in the future. We must employ all areas for future good air quality and affordable energy. August 24,2004

Dear member of the Michigan Public Sdrvice Commission:

Ijust heard of these case S U-13808 and U-14031. It is refreshing to hear that some people are at least trying to$nd cheaper ways of obtaining energy for consumers.

Isaw wind energy being used in California. It has to be cheaper than what it cost to obtainfossilfiels.

Please reply as to what you think about this?

%nk you,

Mrs. Rose Mary Comai 16542 Farmington Rd Livonia, 1W 48154 29QL Dana Pointe Wive mnckney, Rich, 4BL69 August 27tn, 20Q4

Dear Robert Nelson 2

I am writing to you today in regard to tna renewable resource - wind power as an alternative energy source for OUE nation. Since the e~stof fossil' fuels keep$ capidly rising,, and because thwe resources aDe finate, f am asking that you wi1Z brdas 5eksoit Edisont to start investing in wind power as a viable alternativa tm both ail and natural gas, 3: cite Case Vk-13808 my @Pea for this and, to als@) eneoumge energy custome~sto sign up for "gtzaen panuerr" by Bawering the price. I am alao citing Ca$seW-UikO3 in regard ta C@~SU~@KSEnergy to have it expand its use mf wind power and, to aLs~,law- the cost its gEeen powex program ta make it more affardable for Lts austorne~s,

31 feeU that wind mill ~aw-enrcan become the savior for oulc natim, f lh terms of energy produatiorub, slemllfness ffoz ax8 airc, and, ~hea~ez tti utiU8a@. E knw tha~tthe oil aompanies we ;?4pposad tdc this,? but, we must, think in te~rnsof what is the $reate god, for naut onLy an= society but bhe whole sb mankind in the future of our great @Paneti.,

S thank you for your time and would; greatly appseeiete ta hew from you on this very important issue,

Thomas Manley 2901 Dana Bointe Drive 1/ Binckney,, Mich, 48169 Mr. Robert Nelson Mr 8 #Im Chmrtes Turner DO78 Sea Breeze Dr msc Pinckney, MI 46180-8512 P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

In Case U-13808,the MPSC should order Detroit Edison @TE) to invest in affordable wind magy and encourage customere to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price,

In Case U-14031, the WSC should order consumers energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

- It is-vittal that utilities &vest in wind power because thepfrce ofwind energy isdropping_-_ -_ __ - A while the cost of power from fossil hels is rising.

Sincerely, Paulette Turner August 26,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Deaf. Ms. Nelson:

The price of fossil fuels is rising, while the price of wind energy is dropping. I believe that this makes it vital that our utilities should invest in wind power. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order DTE to encourage support of green power by its customers, and invest in wind energy. In Case U-1403 1, Consumers Energy should be ordered to lower the cost of its green power program.

Your support regarding this critical issue will be greatly appreciated.

Sincerely,

Brad Naberhaus Livonia SF" ;

-- -.--- C_- \ / --- /-- S-J~.-Dy Jew & Lids Lock I 8332 ~~~w~~~ \ pinckney, YJ481~9 I, August 26,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Please take a look at the possibility of making renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan.

To help make your decision consider these points:

In case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

In case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumer's Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

Thank you for your$ - . - && .- - -

Christine Lawrence ___.^ ___C_,. -- ". _ - -

, - & ------Priscilla R. Kulback 5758 Big Pine Dr. Ypsilanti, MI 48 197-7 182 I Sf*3 1'. ' ;7n h August 30,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30222 Lansing, M1 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson,

I am writing to let you know that I am concerned about the use of high-cost, non- renewable, polluting fossil hels in Michigan when a cleaner, less expensive alternative power source - wind - can be used instead.

The MFS@ should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price (Case Um13808).

The MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lawer the cost of its "green power" program (Case U-1403 1).

It is important for utilities to invest in wind power since the cost of it is dropping while the cost of power fram fossil fuels is rising.

I am hoping that you will work to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. -- -

Sincerely, ~kn, Mary rton Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P. 0.Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson:

1. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

2. In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its ------use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. I just returned from the Upper Peninsula and noted the three wind turbine generators in use. Driving on to the bridge, one can but note the constant force of nature's most plentiful energy - wind.

3. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest hi wind power.

I look forward to your response.

Paul E. Litton 78 17 Lake Crest Ct. Ypsilanti, MI 48 197 734-485-4592 Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson,

I am writing you concerning wind energy. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power fiom fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power. Ifi Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. I look forward to hearing fiom you on this issue.

Thank you,

Laurie Satanski $698 Princeton P1 Ypsilanti, MI 48 197 August 30,2004

Jason Hrigora 7936 Briarbrook Dr. Ypsilanti, MI 48 197

MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear SirIMadarne,

I am writing about my concerns about our curpent energy issues in Michigan. We need to start moving towards renewable energy sources and away fiom fossil fuels. The investment in change would greatly benefit our nations' future as well as help preserve the environment. My recommendations for the following two cases are:

1. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.

2. In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower costs of its "green power" program.

The price of wind energy is dropping while the costs of power fiom fossil fuels is rising, making the only rational and vital choice being to invest in wind power.

Thank you for your time and consideration of my opinions and I will be looking forward to a reply.

Sincerely, 5742 Princeton Place Ypsilanti, MI 48197 August 30,2004

Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Mr. Nelson,

As an individual concerned about our resources and environment, I am requesting that you strongly consider asking DTE and Consumers Energy to make renewable energy more available and affordable within our state. In Case U-13808 I believe that the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest resources in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for such power by lowering the price. The same concerns are expressed in Case U-1403 1. Consumers Energy should be ordered by MPSC to expand their use of wind energy and lower the cost of its program to consumers.

It is within MPSC's ability to require these actions. I would appreciate a reply regarding these concerns. Thank you in advance for your response.

Sincerely, rr 07

Sandra A. Andresen

Amy T. Fangboner 32726 Raybum Livonia, MI 481 54

August 13,2004

Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Mr. Lark,

I urge you and the other members of the Michigan Public Service Commission to consider new alternatives that provide affordable, clean electric power to Michigan Residents. In particular, I urge the MPSC to:

I.In Case U-13808: Order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. 2. In Case U-14031: Order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wDnd energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

Public utilities have a responsibility to provide for Michigan's electric needs in the future. The only way to ensure this commitment is to explore other sources such as wind power. Please note that Michigan residents would support ANY action that provides a cheaper, cleaner, renewable energy source for the future. Please send a reply so that I know you recei letter. Thank you for your consideration.

Sincerely, & 7- &J*+ Amy T. Fangboner 10450 Livingston fill YVDLII, o~HVJCE MS Laura Chappelle -PIIA~IICIOIAAI MPSC sco f PO Box 30221 Lansing, M 1 48909

Dear Ms Chappelle, Please, I think it is important to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. - In Case U-13808, The MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest ir~ affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power' by lowering the price . In Case U-14031, The MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program . The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, niaking it vital that utilities invest in wind power. I would like a reply to this. Thank you so much for your time. Diane Pear

1 1786 Rebecca Ln Whitmore Lake, MI 48 189 August, 25,2004

Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC P.O. Box 3022 1 Lansing, MI 48909

Dear Ms. Chappelle,

I am writing to voice my cotlcern about the need for renewable energy in Michigan. Fossile hels are not endless, and as the supply dwindles, prices will inevitably sky rocket. In brder to prepare for this, energy sources such as wind power should be invested in and encouraged by out local and state governments. Two cases in point ar U-13808 and U1403 1 which encourage Detroit Edison and Consumer's Energy respectively to invest in affordable wind energy and to encourage their curstomers to use "green power" by lowering the price. Thank you for yow time. I look forewat'd to your reply.

Sincerely,

Michelle Stanton Bernadette Flanigan August 13,2004 15760 Woodring Livonia, Mi. 481 54

Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, Mi. 48909

Dear Mr. Lark

It is very important in Michigan today to find ways to keep the high cost of energy to customers down. In Case U- 13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to Sing up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

I would like a reply on how you are going to vote in September and why.

Thank you for your consideration in this matter.

Sincerely,

Bernadette Flanigan lY Ms. Laura Chappelle /Z~OWAK MPSC 5263 /"~~~czl04D P.O. Box 30221 f /flWY/@ Lansing, MI 48909 4' f.6 '7 Date: 8/27/04

Ms. Chappelle,

1. In Case U-13808, the WSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. 2. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. Please reply to my responses when you have a chance.

Sincerly, e~baa Rob Nowak

Constantin Balan 15980 Sunbury Livonia, MI 48154

August 26,2004

Ms. Laura Chappelle NIPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

RE: Case U-13808; Case U-1403 1

------ALL._ ------Deaf Ms. Chappelle, This letter is to bring to you attention some changes that MPSC should make regarding cases U- 13808 and U- 14031 relating to the fact that the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utility companies invest in wind power. In case U-13808 MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and to encourage customers to sign up for "green power7' by lowering the price. In case U- 14031 MPSC should order Consumer Energy to expand its use of wind energy and to lower the cost of its "green power" program. Please respond to my letter at your earliest convenience. Thank you very much for your time and consideration. Sincerely,

Constantin Daniel Balan August 26,2004

Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC P. 0.Box 3022 1 Lansing, MI 48909

Ms. Chappelle:

I am writing to today concerning the use of fossil fuels. I would like to see our country using more renewable energy sources such as wind and solar energy.

In Case U-13808, I would like to see the MPSC order DTE to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. - A In Case U-1430 1, I would like to see the MPSC order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.

I would also like to point out that the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.

I would appreciate a reply to this letter stating what Michgan's government is doing to help lower our costs and promote renewable fuel sources.

Thank you,

Carol Anderson 30556 Greenland Livonia, Michigan 48154

& &'&. lzzzL@& 30556 Greenland August 26,2004 Livonia, MI 48154

a,_^ I* * it

Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909

Re: Case U-138083ndCa3e U-r4031 -

Dear Ms. Chappelle,

Iam writing to you today regarding the importance of making renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan.

As you are aware, Michigan residents use mostly electricity from power plants that use fossil fuels. These fuels are in limited supply, the prices are increasing dramatically, and we will be required to spend billions of dollars to decrease pollution from these very same power plants that are producing our electricity.

Wind power holds great promise and advantages for Michigan. It is estimated that wind power could provide 11% of the electricity in Michigan at rates that are competitive now, and the price of electricity produced by wind is on the decline as the equipment improves. The best part for everyone is that the cost of wind itself is free, and it produces no pollution.

Iask that you please commit to meet our electric needs with clean, affordable wind power. I would like to know your decision on this very important matter, as Michigan's future is at stake.

Thank you in advance.

Sincerely,

Carolyn ~avis 3 172 Shadow Brook LN. Pinckney Mi. 48169 August 27,2004 Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC P.O.box 30221 Lansing, Michigan 48909 Dear J. Peter Lark: I am writing to you in the hopes that you would make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. In the case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green pow& by lowering the price. In case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of fossil fuels is rising, making it in the best interest of the people of Michigan for the utilities to invest in wind power. I look forward to hearing from you regarding this matter. Thank you in advanced.

Sincerely, Gerald A. Wachner