General Aspects of Law GALA DEAN’S SEMINAR ROOM (215 BOALT HALL) THURSDAY FEBRUARY 23, 2012 4:10 – 6:00 PM “ANOTHER REALISM: THE POLITICS OF GHANDIAN NONVIOLENCE” By Karuna Mantena ASSISTANT PROFESSOR OF POLITICAL SCIENCE YALE UNIVERSITY NOTE The GALA speaker will offer some brief introductory background remarks about the paper and the remainder of the time will be devoted to discussion. Participants are expected to read the paper in advance. Papers are distributed to those on our mailing list or electronically when available at the GALA website: < http://www.law.berkeley.edu/9264.htm>. Others may obtain copies from Ms. Amatullah Alaji-Sabrie at 510.642.3627 or
[email protected]. Copies can be made available in an alternate format upon request. GALA events are wheelchair accessible. For any disability-related accommodations advance notice is requested. Another Realism: The Politics of Gandhian Nonviolence Karuna Mantena I. Introduction Political realism typically includes two interconnected claims: a view of politics in which power and conflict are taken to be constitutive and a suspicion of doctrines and theories that elide this fact as carelessly idealist or utopian. Realism is often equated with a kind of Machiavellianism, a hard-nosed insistence that norms of ordinary, individual, and/or legal morality have to be relaxed or superceded in the face of the contingency of political conflict or the intractability of ideological struggle.1 Here, realism reaches its denouement in the defense of power politics, reason of state, or