William J. Robinson Electronics/Computer Patent Cases

Year Filed Court Case Name Technology

(underlined party is represented party) 2018 E.D. Tx. Tex. Adv. Opto. Sol. v. Renesas Elecs. Am. Sensors 2016 E.D. Tx. Marking Object Virtualization v. , Ltd. et al. Digital Watermarking 2016 E.D. Tx. Dynavair v. Intersil Corp. Battery Equalization 2016 N.D. Cal. Software Research, Inc. v. Developer Express, Inc. Web Testing 2015 E.D. Tx. Graham Springs v. Provide Commerce Printing 2014 E.D. Tx. Mobile Telecom. Tech. v. Leap Wireless & Cricket Cellular Communications Comm. 2014 D. Del. Messaging Gateway Systems v. mBlox Text Messaging Gateways 2014 E.D. Tx. eDekka, Inc. v. FTD.com On-line Purchasing Software 2014 C.D. Cal. Modern Telecom Systems v. NetZero, Juno Modems 2014 E.D. Tx. Phoenix Licensing v. Sallie Mae, UPromise Electronic Marketing 2013 N.D. Cal. Essai, Inc. v. Delta Design, Inc. Semiconductor Test Equipment 2013 N.D. Ill. Unified Messaging Solutions v. United Online et al Email 2013 D. Del. Princeton Digital v. FTD Group et al. JPEG Imaging 2012 D. Del. Griffin Technologies v. NetZero Cellular Data Transmission 2012 C.D. Cal. Harman Int’l Ind. v. TC Group, et al Harmony Generators 2012 E.D. Tx E-Contact Technologies v. United Online Email 2012 ITC Beacon Navigations Sys. v. BMW GPS Navigation Systems 2011 N.D. Cal. Tessera Inc. v. Corp. Semiconductors 2011 D. Del. Fotomedia v. Memory Lane et al. Photo-sharing 2010 N.D. Cal. EIT Group v. Classmates, et al. On-Line Advertising 2010 N.D. Cal. FormFactor v. MicroProbe Probe Cards 2010 C.D. Cal. KYE America v. Primax Electronics Computer Mice 2010 E.D. Tx. PACID Group v. United Technologies Corp. et al. Data Encryption Keys 2010 C.D. Cal. Primax Electronics v. KYE Systems Computer mice 2010 D. Or. FormFactor v. Phicom et al. Probe Cards 2010 E.D. Tx. Stragent, LLC v. Classmates Online, United Online, Packet Radio

1 4841-3829-6843.4

Year Filed Court Case Name Technology

(underlined party is represented party) et al 2010 E.D. Tx. Gildersleeve v. Classmates Media, et al. Relational Database 2009 D. Ark Shared Memory Graphics v. et al Video Graphics Hardware 2009 E.D. Tx Clear With Computers v. MASCO et. al. On-line Purchasing Software 2008 E.D. Tx. LML Patent Corp. v. Northern Trust et al. Check Processing Software 2008 C.D. Cal. Guardian Media Techs. v. Nintendo et al. Video Parental Control 2008 C.D. Cal. Nichia Inc. v. Seoul Semiconductor LEDs 2007 C.D. Cal Yokohama Rubber Ltd. v. Stamford Tire Automobile Tires 2007 S.D. Cal TransCore v. Neology, Inc. Radio Frequency ID Systems 2006 N.D. Cal. Intergraph Sys. v. Corp. Microprocessors 2006 AAA TransCore v. Intermec Radio Frequency ID Systems 2006 C.D. Cal Universal Elec. v. Remote Technologies Remote Controls 2006 N.D. Cal & Formfactor v. Micronics Wafer Probe Cards ITC 2006 E.D. Tx Orion v. Briggs & Stratton On-Line Purchasing Systems 2006 E.D. Tx Orion v. Yokohama Tire On-Line Purchasing Systems 2005 C.D. Cal. In Re Acacia Video streaming 2005 D. Del Hitachi Ltd. v. BorgWarner, Inc. Variable Camshaft Timing Systems for Automobiles 2005 S.D. Tx TransCore v. ETC Radio Frequency ID Systems 2004 C.D. Cal Science Applications Int’l Corp. v. Rapiscan Gamma Ray Vehicle Inspection Systems 2004 S.D.Cal TransCore v. SCS Radio Frequency ID Systems 2004 E.D. Tx MyMail v. NetZero, et al. Internet Communications 2004 D. Fla. Falcon v. Kye Electronics Mice

2 4841-3829-6843.4

Year Filed Court Case Name Technology

(underlined party is represented party) 2004 C.D. Cal. Grant v. Click2Learn Graphics Software 2003 N.D. Cal. IP Learn v. Click2Learn Electronic Learning Software 2003 E.D. Cal Rosen v. Epsilon Electronics LCD Screens 2003 C.D. Cal. Acacia v. International Web Technologies Streaming Video 2002 L.A.Supr. Lewis v. Lubitz (Malpractice action re patent suit on Disk Drives HP, Maxtor and Quantum disk drives) 2002 S.D. Cal. X-Cyte v. TransCore Automatic Vehicle ID 2002 S.D. Tex IP Innovation v. Docent, Inc. Graphics Technologies 2002 N.D. Cal. Pickholtz v. Rainbow Technologies PseudoRandom Number Generators 2002 N.D. Cal. IP Learn LLC v. Docent, Inc. Electronic Learning Software 2002 C.D. Cal. Turn-Key Tech. v. Krauss Maffei, et al. DVD/CD Manufacturing 2001 D. Utah Wilson Electronics v. BarJan Ent. Cellular Antennas 2001 C.D. Cal. NetZero v. Juno Advertising Software for ISP. 2001 C.D. Cal. NetZero v. AT&T Advertising Software for ISP. 2001 C.D. Cal. NetZero v. Blue Light Advertising Software for ISP. 2000 D. Az. Lemelson v. SAIC Bar Code Readers 2000 C.D. Cal. Cybiotronics v. Golden Source Telephones 1999 N.D. Cal. Oacis v. Allcare Automated Healthcare Systems 1999 S.D. Cal. TransCore v. Mark IV Ind. Automatic Vehicle Identification Systems 1999 N.D. Tex. Allcare v. SAIC Automated Healthcare Systems 1999 C.D./E.D. Trimble Navigation v. Likkuuva Ltd. Et al. GPS Receivers Cal. 1998 C.D. Cal. Electric v. Zenith Electronics TV Tuners

3 4841-3829-6843.4

Year Filed Court Case Name Technology

(underlined party is represented party) 1998 C.D. Cal. v. Nukote Int’l Ink Jet Printers 1997 C.D. Cal. Japan Cash Machine v. Diversified Systems Image Recognition Technology 1996 C.D. Cal. L.A. Gear v. Orlaford, et al. Lighted Shoes 1996 USPTO Lights of America Lighting Fixtures [Public Use Proceedings] 1996 Sup. Ct. Energy Conversions v. Lights of America Lighting Fixtures Santa Clara 1996 C.D. Cal. Lights of America v. SK America Fluorescent Lamps

1995 C.D. Cal. Yamaha Corp. v. ESS Technology FM Synthesis Chips used in multimedia boards 1995 E.D. Va. Odetics v. Storage Technology Computer Tape Libraries 1995 S.D. Fla. Dana v. L.A. Gear Lighted Shoes 1995 C.D. Cal., Seiko Epson v. Nukote Int’l – included companion Ink Jet Printer Cartridges Japan, cases in Germany and Japan on foreign patents Germany 1994 C.D. Cal. Yamaha Corp. v. Laser Digital, et al FM Synthesis Chips used in multimedia boards 1994 C.D. Cal. L.A. Gear v. Ratcliffe Shoe Circuitry 1994 C.D. Cal. L.A. Gear v. Kany Trading Lighted Footwear 1994 C.D. Cal. Wellcome v. Chadwick-Miller Electric Sealers 1993 N.D. Cal. ExperVision v. Frossel (DJ action) Optical Character Reading (OCR) 1993 E.D. Ill. Arachnid v. DAK Ind. Electronic Dartboards 1993 C.D. Cal. ADL v. Chaparral Communications, Inc. Satellite Feedhorns (3 cases) 1992 C.D. Cal. Baxter, Inc. v. AVL Scientific Corp. Blood Culture Instruments

1992 S.D. Cal. Xscribe v. Stenograph (DJ action) Computerized Stenographic Machines

4 4841-3829-6843.4

Year Filed Court Case Name Technology

(underlined party is represented party) 1991 D. Nev. Lemelson v. Nissei Plastics, Nissei America Computerized Injection Molding Machines 1990 C.D. Cal. Boman v. O’Rourke Bros. Satellite Feedhorns 1990 C.D. Cal. Driori v. Nutek Car Alarms 1990 C.D. Cal. Beckman v. Hi-Chem, Inc. Blood Analysis Machines 1989 C.D. Cal. Leviton v. Lights of America, Inc. Motion Detector Lights 1987 C.D. Cal. Chaparral Communications v. ADL Labs. Satellite Feedhorns 1987 C.D. Cal. Chaparral Communications v. Bowman Ind. Satellite Feedhorns

1987 C.D. Cal. Refac v. Hitachi et al. (DAK Ind., Kawasaki Motors) LCD Watch Circuitry 1987 N.D. Cal. Fluidmaster, Inc. v. EDC Computerized Boiler Controllers 1986 N.D. Cal. Fluidmaster, Inc. v. Pulstat Computerized Boiler Controllers 1984 C.D. Cal. BBC Brown Boveri v. PESCO, Inc. Power Station Circuit Breakers 1984 C.D. Cal. Stenograph v. Xscribe Computerized Stenographic Machines 1982 D. Miss. Perkins Co. v. Parkway Co. Telephone Test Equipment 1978 C.D. Cal. Sunstrand v. Litton, Ind. Computerized Ground Warning Devices for airplanes

5 4841-3829-6843.4