HISTORY www.ohiohistory.org/publications/ohiohistory Volume 111/Summer-Autumn 2002

H EDITORIAL STAFF Robert L. Daugherty, Editor Patricia Walsh, Publications Production Editor

EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD Randall Buchman, Defiance College Frank L. Byrne, Kent State University George W. Knepper, University of Akron Robert M. Mennel, University of New Hampshire Zane Miller, University of Marian J. Morton, John Carroll University Larry L. Nelson, Ohio Historical Society, Fort Meigs Harry Scheiber, University of California, Berkeley Mary Young, University of Rochester

Ohio History was established in June 1887 as the Ohio Archaeological and Historical Quarterly. It is now an online publication of the Ohio Historical Society. The primary purpose of the journal is to publish articles, documents, notes, and reviews concerning the political, military, social, economic, and cultural and the Middle West. The editors welcome studies in general fields of American history if they possess obvious relevance to Ohio and the Middle West. Authors are asked to submit two double-spaced typed copies of their manuscripts. Footnotes should be double-spaced and placed at the end of the article. Upon acceptance for publication, please check with editor concerning submission of computer disk to speed typesetting. Contributions should be addressed to the Editor, Ohio History, Ohio Historical Center, 1982 Velma Avenue, Columbus, Ohio 43211-2497. The society accepts no responsibility for facts and opinions expressed by the authors. Articles appearing in this journal are abstracted and indexed in Historical Abstracts, America: History and Life, Abstracts of Popular Culture, Recently Published Articles, and The Journal of American History. Back issues, reprints, and microfilm editions are available through the Ohio Historical Society and University Microfilms. Copyright © 2002 by the Ohio Historical Society. All rights reserved. OHIO HISTORICAL SOCIETY 2002Ð2003 BOARD OF TRUSTEES

OFFICERS Grant L. Douglass, President Nancy S. Dix, Vice President Elaine H. Hairston, Vice President Robert H. Jeffrey, Treasurer Shirley T. Duncan, Secretary

TRUSTEES Marnie C. Black, Cincinnati John J. Kulewicz, Columbus Joyce E. Brown, Urbana John D. Lee, Columbus Nancy S. Dix, Hebron Ann K. Lowder, Columbus Grant L. Douglass, Columbus Charles B. Nuckolls, Jr., Cincinnati Shirley T. Duncan, Columbus Lucy McKewen Porter, Bexley Patricia S. Eldredge, Hudson Ralph E. Ramey, Westerville Elaine H. Hairston, Pataskala Roy L. Ray, Cleveland Thomas E. Huenefeld, Cincinnati Richard Sisson, Columbus Robert H. Jeffrey, Columbus Marian J. Vance, Delaware Alan S. Katchen, Columbus Marilyn Van Voorhis Wendler, Maumee George P. Kulchytsky, Parma

EX OFFICIO Bob Taft, Governor of Ohio Richard H. Finan, President, Ohio Senate Greg L. DiDonato, Minority Leader, Ohio Senate Larry Householder, Speaker, Ohio House of Representatives Dean E. DePiero, Minority Leader, Ohio House of Representatives Susan Tave Zelman, Superintendent of Public Instruction Roderick G. W. Chu, Chancellor, Ohio Board of Regents Bill Lawson, President, Ohio Association of Historical Societies and Museums William D. Jenkins, President, Ohio Academy of History William D. Hummon, President, Ohio Academy of Science Robert F. Goldberg, Chairman, Ohio Historical Society Development Council Louis Mitchell, Chairman, Ohio Historical Society Foundation Bruce E. Johnson, Director, Ohio Department of Development

EMERITI John J. Chester, Columbus Dixie S. Miller, Bexley Robert F. Ebinger, Columbus Phillip R. Shriver, Oxford Rex E. Haecker, Circleville Robert Burns Smith, Columbus George W. Knepper, Munroe Falls OHIO HISTORY Volume 111/Summer-Autumn 2002 Contents

ARTICLES

Visions of America, 1787Ð1788: The Ohio 101 of Reverend Manasseh Cutler by Louis W. Potts

The Political Judge: Justice John McLean’s 121 Pursuit of the Presidency by Thomas E. Carney

Poor Men But Hard-Working Fathers: 145 The Cincinnati Orphan Asylum and Parental Roles in the Nineteenth-Century Working Class by M. Christine Anderson and Nancy E. Bertaux

From New Womanhood to Companionate 183 Marriage in the Progressive Era: The Case of Frances Cochran MacDaniels by Douglas Slaybaugh

IN MEMORIAM

Frank L. Byrne: A Gifted Civil War Historian 198 by Leonne M. Hudson

NOTES AND QUERIES 200

BOOK REVIEWS

Cayton, Andrew R. L. and Susan E. Gray, editors, The American 202 Midwest: Essays on Regional History. Reviewed by Terry A. Barnhart. Baldwin, Neil, Henry Ford and the Jews: the Mass Production of 204 Hate. Reviewed by Terry A. Cooney. Korman, Richard, The Goodyear Story: An Inventor’s Obsession 206 and the Struggle for a Rubber Monopoly. Reviewed by K. Austin Kerr. Goldfield, David. Still Fighting the Civil War: The American 208 South and Southern History. Reviewed by Brian R. Dirck. Remini, Robert V., Andrew Jackson and His Indian Wars. 209 Reviewed by Alfred A. Cave. Blight, David W., Race and Reunion: The Civil War in American 211 Memory. Reviewed by Christopher Phillips. Noe, Kenneth W., Perryville: This Grand Havoc of Battle. 212 Reviewed by Maj. Charles Bowery Sparks, Elder John, The Roots of Appalachian Christianity: The 214 Life & Legacy of Elder Shubal Stearns. Reviewed by James S. Baugess. Burton, David H.,editor, The Collected Works of William Howard 216 Taft,Volume II, Political Issues and Outlooks: Speeches Delivered Between August 1908 and February 1909. Reviewed by Clarence E. Wunderlin, Jr. Holloway, Jonathan Scott, Confronting the Veil: Abram Harris, Jr., 217 E. Franklin Frazier, and Ralph Bunche, 1919Ð1941. Reviewed by Abel A. Bartley. Livingston, Jeffrey C., Swallowed by Globalism: John M. Vorys 219 and American Foreign Policy. Reviewed by John T. McNay. Hixson, Walter L., Murder, Culture, and Injustice: Four 221 Senstaional Cases in American History. Reviewed by Kenneth J. Bindas. Carter, George E., editor, The Story of Joshua D. Breyfogle, 222 Private, 4th Ohio Infantry (10th Ohio Cavalry) and the Civil War. Reviewed by Robert Patrick Bender. Robinson, Greg, By Order of the President: FDR and the 224 Internment of Japanese Americans. Reviewed by Allan W. Austin. Stephenson, Darl L., Headquarters in the Brush: Blazer’s 225 Independent Union Scouts. Reviewed by Damon R. Eubank. Kusmer, Kenneth L., Down and Out, On the Road: The Homeless 227 in American History. Reviewed by Robert H. Bremner.

INDEX AND CONTENTS TO VOLUME 111 229