LISTING OF CITATIONS - VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE

Hearing on 19th September 2018 at 10.00 am in Committee Room 4, Woodhill House, Westburn Road,

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

1 53524/52390 WAREHOUSE ETC BALFINGER SALAMIS UK LTD T 92,500 92,500 TAMALA BURNSIDE WHITECAIRNS ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

2 85961/52386 WORKSHOP ETC BILFINGER SALAMIS T 32,500 32,500 UNIT 1 TAMALA BURNSIDE WHITECAIRNS RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

3 87871/52335 YARD ETC ASCO UK LTD O 25,500 25,500 TAMALA BURNSIDE WHITECAIRNS ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

4 49256/52556 WAREHOUSE ETC RAITHS FARM PROPERTIES LIMITED P 57,500 57,500 BAY 3 GOURDIEBURN RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

5 49256/59353 WAREHOUSE ETC ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL T 57,500 57,500 BAY 3 PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM GOURDIEBURN POTTERTON RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

6 50193/52554 WAREHOUSE RAITHS FARM PROPERTIES LIMITED P 35,250 35,250 BAY 1A GOURDIEBURN POTTERTON RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

7 50194/52555 WAREHOUSE ETC RAITHS FARM PROPERTIES LIMITED P 91,500 91,500 BAY 1B & 2 GOURDIEBURN POTTERTON RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

8 82795/52423 WORKSHOP WILLIAM FRASER P 19,500 19,500 GOURDIEBURN POTTERTON ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

9 82798/52427 WORKSHOP WILLIAM FRASER P 14,250 14,250 GOURDIEBURN POTTERTON ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

10 82800/52430 WAREHOUSE ETC WILLIAM FRASER P 35,500 35,500 GOURDIEBURN POTTERTON ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

11 83484/52429 WORKSHOPS ETC WILLIAM FRASER P 46,000 46,000 GOURDIEBURN POTTERTON ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

12 87494/52428 STORE WILLIAM FRASER P 52,500 52,500 GOURDIEBURN POTTERTON ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

13 17316/62387 YARD ETC AUGEAN NORTH SEA SERVICES LTD T 69,000 69,000 SITE B INDUSTRIAL CENTRE MURCAR RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

04/06/2018 Page 1 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

14 44890/62379 GARAGE AUGEAN NORTH SEA SERVICES LTD T 14,000 14,000 SITE B BLACKDOG INDUSTRIAL CENTRE MURCAR RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

15 17317/55519 WAREHOUSE ETC WELL OPS UK LTD T 127,000 127,000 SITE D STRABATHIE GARAGE MURCAR CBRE LTD A BRIDGE OF DON

16 33691/52357 YARD EXPRO NORTH SEA LTD T 39,250 39,250 SITE E UNIT 1 BLACKDOG INDUSTRIAL CENTRE MURCAR RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

17 80679/52396 YARD MICHAEL GALL TRANSPORT O 18,250 18,250 SITE E2 & E3 BLACKDOG INDUSTRIAL CENTRE MURCAR SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A BRIDGE OF DON

18 86366/62380 YARD ETC AUGEAN NORTH SEA SERVICES LTD T 34,000 34,000 SITE G BLACKDOG INDUSTRIAL CENTRE MURCAR RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

19 17322/62542 STORES ETC ARCHER MARKETING O 17,750 17,750 HAREBURN TERRACE BLACKDOG BRIDGE OF DON

20 17324/54075 WORKSHOP ETC THOMAS J MCCAUL P 88,500 88,500 SITE C STRABATHIE GARAGE MURCAR A B ROBB A BRIDGE OF DON

21 17548/62561 WORKSHOP ETC MCINTOSH PLANT HIRE (ABDN) LTD P 1,480,000 1,480,000 BIRCHMOSS ECHT WESTHILL

22 86547/62562 WORKSHOP MCINTOSH PLANT HIRE (ABDN) LTD P 222,000 222,000 UNIT 14-15 BIRCHMOSS ECHT WESTHILL

23 84246/62564 WORKSHOP MCINTOSH PLANT HIRE (ABDN) LTD P 226,000 226,000 BIRCHMOSS ECHT WESTHILL

24 89890/62563 WORKSHOPS ETC MCINTOSH PLANT HIRE (ABDN) LTD P 515,000 515,000 UNIT 1 & 3 BIRCHMOSS ECHT WESTHILL

25 89888/62567 WORKSHOP MCINTOSH PLANT HIRE (ABDN) LTD P 77,500 77,500 UNIT 8 BIRCHMOSS ECHT WESTHILL

26 17671/52447 WORKSHOP ETC MTM CONSTRUCTION P 90,000 90,000 BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD BLACKBURN RYDEN LLP A

27 35435/53507 WORKSHOPS ETC MICRON EAGLE HYDRAULICS LTD P 94,000 94,000 BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD BLACKBURN SAVILLS A

04/06/2018 Page 2 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

28 49177/53198 WAREHOUSE ANDREW S SYKES HIRE LTD T 8,300 8,300 UNIT 2 BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD WYMRE A BLACKBURN

29 49177/60324 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 8,300 8,300 UNIT 2 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD RYDEN LLP A BLACKBURN

30 87710/61434 WORKSHOPS THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 11,000 11,000 UNIT 11 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD RYDEN LLP A BLACKBURN

31 17680/57306 WAREHOUSE ANDREWS SYKES HIRE LTD T 9,700 9,700 UNIT 1 BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD WYMRE A BLACKBURN

32 17680/60325 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 9,700 9,700 UNIT 1 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD RYDEN LLP A BLACKBURN

33 17681/60326 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 8,400 8,400 UNIT 3 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD RYDEN LLP A BLACKBURN

34 46503/60327 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 11,250 11,250 UNIT 4 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD RYDEN LLP A BLACKBURN

35 17683/54011 WORKSHOPS ETC CREMANT HOLDINGS LTD T 18,500 18,500 UNIT 5 & 6 T/A BICKIEPEGS BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD BLACKBURN

36 17683/61435 WORKSHOPS ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 18,500 18,500 UNIT 5 & 6 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD RYDEN LLP A BLACKBURN

37 17685/60328 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 12,750 12,750 UNIT 7 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD RYDEN LLP A BLACKBURN

38 17686/60329 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 14,000 14,000 UNIT 8 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD RYDEN LLP A BLACKBURN

39 17688/61436 WORKSHOPS ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 23,500 23,500 UNIT 9 & 10 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD RYDEN LLP A BLACKBURN

40 17689/60330 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 7,500 7,500 UNIT 12 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD RYDEN LLP A BLACKBURN

41 17691/60331 STORE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 13,750 13,750 UNIT 13 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD RYDEN LLP A BLACKBURN

04/06/2018 Page 3 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

42 17692/60332 BAKERY THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 15,750 15,750 UNIT 14-15 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOODBURN ROAD RYDEN LLP A BLACKBURN

43 83922/53513 WORKSHOP ETC HANS ANDREAS NAGEL P 44,500 44,500 WOODBURN ROAD BLACKBURN SAVILLS A

44 39116/54958 WORKSHOP ETC J C E GROUP (UK) LTD P 109,000 109,000 BLACKBURN BUSINESS PARK WOODBURN ROAD BLACKBURN J & E SHEPHERD A

45 50863/62098 WORKSHOP ETC SUB-ATLANTIC SSAS P 98,000 98,000 BLACKBURN BUSINESS PARK WOODBURN ROAD BLACKBURN RYDEN LLP A

46 81276/54992 WORKSHOPS ETC WIRELINE ENGINEERING LTD P 164,000 164,000 BLACKBURN BUSINESS PARK WOODBURN ROAD BLACKBURN F G BURNETT LTD A

47 87672/58179 WORKSHOP ETC RACCORTUBI NORSK LTD T 118,000 118,000 BLACKBURN BUSINESS PARK WOODBURN ROAD BLACKBURN F G BURNETT LTD A

48 61203/54644 WORKSHOP ETC KINNON MECHANICAL SERVICES LTD T 23,000 23,000 ARNHALL MOSS WESTHILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ENTERPRISE DRIVE

49 30802/62750 WORKSHOP ETC GPH BUILDERS MERCHANTS LTD P 39,000 39,000 ARNHALL MOSS WESTHILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ENTERPRISE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A

50 84026/56816 STORES ROBERT SIMPSON P 9,700 9,700 WESTHILL FILLING STATION BROADSTRAIK ELRICK GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

51 84158/56821 WORKSHOP ROBERT SIMPSON P 25,000 25,000 WESTHILL FILLING STATION BROADSTRAIK ELRICK GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

52 17739/56814 WORKSHOP WESTHILL GARAGE LTD P 113,000 113,000 WESTHILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ENTERPRISE DRIVE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

53 83847/56813 WORKSHOP WESTHILL GARAGE LTD T 42,500 42,500 WESTHILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ENTERPRISE DRIVE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

54 17740/62695 WORKSHOPS CITY ANGEL LTD P 86,000 86,000 UNIT 1-3 WESTHILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ENTERPRISE DRIVE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

55 69163/53799 WORKSHOP ETC ELMAR, A VARCO COMPANY T 72,500 72,500 UNIT 4 & 5 WESTHILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ENTERPRISE DRIVE SAVILLS A

04/06/2018 Page 4 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

56 69163/55649 WORKSHOP ETC JFD LTD O 72,500 72,500 UNIT 4 & 5 WESTHILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ENTERPRISE DRIVE CBRE LTD A

57 69163/62696 WORKSHOP ETC CITY ANGEL LTD P 72,500 72,500 UNIT 4 & 5 WESTHILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ENTERPRISE DRIVE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

58 17743/62084 SORTING OFFICE ROYAL MAIL GROUP PROPERTY T 25,750 25,750 UNIT 7 WESTHILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ENTERPRISE DRIVE G L HEARN LIMITED A

59 17748/55651 WORKSHOPS JFD LTD T 94,500 94,500 UNIT 11-14 WESTHILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ENTERPRISE DRIVE CBRE LTD A

60 17754/55840 WORKSHOP ETC AIR PRODUCTS PLC P 154,000 154,000 WESTHILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ENTERPRISE DRIVE MUA PROPERTY SERVICES LTD A

61 51637/61549 WAREHOUSE ETC GPH BUILDERS MERCHANTS LTD T 104,000 104,000 6 PROSPECT PLACE WESTHILL IND. ESTATE RYDEN LLP A

62 90017/55826 TRAINING CENTRE KNIGHT PROPERTY GROUP PLC P 177,000 177,000 UNIT 3 KINGSHILL COMMERCIAL PARK EAST VENTURE DRIVE CBRE LTD A ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK

63 90019/55845 WORKSHOP KNIGHT PROPERTY GROUP PLC P 180,000 180,000 UNIT 4 KINGSHILL COMMERCIAL PARK EAST VENTURE DRIVE CBRE LTD A ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK

64 49727/61439 OFFICE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 13,500 13,500 UNIT 1 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES ENDEAVOUR DRIVE ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A

65 48996/60337 OFFICE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 15,000 15,000 UNIT 2 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES ENDEAVOUR DRIVE ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A

66 49001/60338 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 17,500 17,500 UNIT 3 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES ENDEAVOUR DRIVE ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A

67 49003/60339 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 20,750 20,750 UNIT 4 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES ENDEAVOUR DRIVE ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A

68 49006/53997 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 19,000 19,000 UNIT 5 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES ENDEAVOUR DRIVE ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL A

69 49006/61440 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 19,000 19,000 UNIT 5 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES ENDEAVOUR DRIVE ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A

04/06/2018 Page 5 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

70 49884/60340 WORKSHOP ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 14,250 14,250 UNIT 6 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES ENDEAVOUR DRIVE ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A

71 49007/60341 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 23,250 23,250 UNIT 7-8 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES ENDEAVOUR DRIVE ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A

72 80865/55579 WORKSHOP ETC RED SPIDER TECHNOLOGY LTD T 221,000 221,000 PEREGRINE ROAD WESTHILL BUSINESS PARK CBRE LTD A

73 83761/52407 WAREHOUSE ETC SUB DRILL SUPPLY LTD P 157,000 157,000 ENDEAVOUR DRIVE ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A

74 84626/57992 WORKSHOP ETC SWAGELOK P 187,000 187,000 SILVERTREES DRIVE SILVERTREES BUSINESS PARK KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

75 86574/58930 WORKSHOP ETC OILENCO P 121,000 121,000 SILVERTREES DRIVE SILVERTREES BUSINESS PARK WYMRE A

76 86852/63820 WORKSHOP ETC ROVPROP LTD P 226,000 226,000 SILVERTREES DRIVE SILVERTREES BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A

77 87175/56023 WORKSHOP ETC SPECIALIST VALVE SERVICES LTD P 174,000 174,000 SILVERTREES DRIVE SILVERTREES BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A

78 86131/52479 WORKSHOP ETC IKM TESTING UK LTD T 250,000 250,000 PEREGRINE ROAD WESTHILL BUSINESS PARK GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

79 86131/67067 WORKSHOP ETC LOCAL AUTHORITIES MUTUAL INVESTMENT P 250,000 250,000 PEREGRINE ROAD TRUST, PER CCLA INVESTMENT WESTHILL BUSINESS PARK MANAGEMENT LTD BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE A

80 54390/54642 WAREHOUSE ETC L F F (SCOTLAND) LTD P 213,000 213,000 SITE 6 PEREGRINE ROAD WESTHILL BUSINESS PARK A B ROBB A

81 86472/58007 WAREHOUSE ETC FORUM ENERGY TECHNOLOGIES (UK) LTD T 545,000 545,000 PEREGRINE ROAD WESTHILL BUSINESS PARK F G BURNETT LTD A

82 53969/54879 WAREHOUSE ETC BIBBY OFFSHORE LTD T 258,000 258,000 THE HANGER PEREGRINE ROAD WESTHILL BUSINESS PARK F G BURNETT LTD A

83 17831/60369 DEPOT THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 27,250 27,250 WELLGROVE ROAD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES WESTHILL RYDEN LLP A

04/06/2018 Page 6 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

84 17846/60373 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 13,500 13,500 UNIT 1 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

85 17847/60374 FACTORY THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 13,500 13,500 UNIT 2 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

86 17848/53805 WAREHOUSE WOLSELEY CENTERS LTD T 10,000 10,000 UNIT 3 BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

87 17848/61288 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 10,000 10,000 UNIT 3 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

88 33662/60375 OFFICE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 16,000 16,000 UNIT 4 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

89 50028/55001 STORE MCCORMICKS (COMMERCIAL) LTD R B S P 67,500 67,500 BURGHMUIR CIRCLE F G BURNETT LTD A

90 17849/60376 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 8,200 8,200 UNIT 5 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

91 35458/61289 STORE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 6,500 6,500 UNIT 6 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

92 35463/60377 STUDIO THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 8,700 8,700 UNIT 7 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

93 17852/60378 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 7,000 7,000 UNIT 8 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

94 17853/61290 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 7,100 7,100 UNIT 9 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

95 30468/60379 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 14,750 14,750 UNIT 10 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

96 38095/60380 YARD ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 8,100 8,100 UNIT 10A PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

97 17855/61291 WAREHOUSE ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 12,000 12,000 UNIT 12 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

04/06/2018 Page 7 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

98 50230/60382 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 10,250 10,250 UNIT 13 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

99 33933/60383 FACTORY THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 88,000 88,000 BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BURGHMUIR CIRCLE RYDEN LLP A

100 33933/63604 FACTORY SCOTBEEF INVERURIE LTD T 88,000 88,000 BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

101 42292/61827 CAFE CRAIGDON MOUNTAIN SPORTS P 26,250 26,250 UNIT 2 ADVERTISING HOUSE BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE RYDEN LLP A BURGHMUIR CIRCLE

102 32615/62395 WAREHOUSE TECHNICAL SERVICES LTD T 94,000 94,000 INVERURIE FOOD PARK BURGHMUIR PLACE INVERURIE F G BURNETT LTD A

103 52564/62377 WAREHOUSE BUCHAN TECHNICAL SERVICES LTD P 44,250 44,250 BAY 1 (2002) PENSION FUND INVERURIE FOOD PARK BURGHMUIR PLACE F G BURNETT LTD A INVERURIE

104 82796/55992 WORKSHOP ETC STATS GROUP T 103,000 103,000 BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR PLACE INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

105 83303/53243 WORKSHOPS COMPLETION PRODUCTS LTD T 65,000 65,000 FORMER SCOTTISH WATER DEPOT PER SANDY MURRAY BURGHMUIR PLACE INVERURIE WYMRE A

106 31501/53961 FACTORY SAFELIFT OFFSHORE LTD T 79,000 79,000 FOOD TECHNOLOGY PARK BURGHMUIR PLACE INVERURIE

107 32611/61292 STORE ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 92,500 92,500 FOOD TECHNOLOGY PARK PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BURGHMUIR PLACE INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

108 31230/60384 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 22,750 22,750 UNIT 3-4 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES FOOD TECHNOLOGY PARK BURGHMUIR PLACE RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

109 31230/62570 WORKSHOP HARRY FRASER T 22,750 22,750 UNIT 3-4 T/A HARRY FRASER FOOD TECHNOLOGY PARK CATERING SERVICES LTD BURGHMUIR PLACE INVERURIE

110 33258/53802 STORES ETC WILLIAM WILSON LTD T 39,250 39,250 UNIT 1-2 FOOD TECHNOLOGY PARK BURGHMUIR PLACE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A INVERURIE

111 33258/60385 STORES ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 39,250 39,250 UNIT 1-2 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES FOOD TECHNOLOGY PARK BURGHMUIR PLACE RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

04/06/2018 Page 8 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

112 66583/56745 WORKSHOP ETC MALCOLM ALLAN HOUSEBUILDERS LTD P 11,000 11,000 HIGHCLERE BUSINESS PARK BLACKHALL ROAD INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

113 68803/61548 WORKSHOP ETC GPH BUILDERS MERCHANTS LTD T 147,000 147,000 HIGHCLERE BUSINESS PARK BLACKHALL ROAD INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

114 79803/58160 BAKERY J G ROSS (HOLDINGS) LTD P 295,000 295,000 HIGHCLERE BUSINESS PARK C/O J G ROSS BLACKHALL ROAD INVERURIE F G BURNETT LTD A

115 17867/54991 WORKSHOP ETC I & K MOTORS LTD T 66,000 66,000 BURGHMUIR WAY INVERURIE F G BURNETT LTD A

116 17879/55521 STORE ETC JOHN RHIND LTD T 17,500 17,500 4 CHURCH TERRACE INVERURIE SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

117 17887/62085 SORTING OFFICE ROYAL MAIL GROUP PROPERTY P 41,250 41,250 CONSTITUTION STREET INVERURIE G L HEARN LIMITED A

118 17898/62102 WORKSHOP ETC MR & MRS S FERGUSON P 191,000 191,000 HARLAW DRIVE C/O JAMES SCULLION INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

119 17932/61294 DEPOT THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 55,500 55,500 CONSTRUCTION DEPOT (OFF) PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW DRIVE INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

120 17900/60388 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 305,000 305,000 HARLAW ROAD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

121 17901/52489 FACTORY SCHLUMBERGER OILFIELD UK LTD P 240,000 240,000 HARLAW ROAD INVERURIE KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

122 45438/54999 YARD DONALD RUSSELL LTD T 1,250 1,250 HARLAW BUSINESS CENTRE HARLAW ROAD INVERURIE

123 17907/56889 WORKSHOP TRAVIS PERKINS TRADING CO LTD T 102,000 102,000 UNIT 10-12 HARLAW BUSINESS CENTRE HARLAW ROAD DTZ A INVERURIE

124 17909/55834 WORKSHOP J M S COATINGS LTD T 58,000 58,000 UNIT 8-9 HARLAW BUSINESS CENTRE HARLAW ROAD RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

125 17911/60389 DEPOT THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 129,000 129,000 HARLAW WAY PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

04/06/2018 Page 9 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

126 87814/61295 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 16,250 16,250 UNIT 4 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

127 17914/53968 FACTORY SAFELIFT OFFSHORE LTD T 55,500 55,500 HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY INVERURIE

128 17914/60390 FACTORY THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 55,500 55,500 HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW WAY INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

129 17917/60391 WORKSHOP ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 15,000 15,000 HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW WAY INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

130 87423/61296 WORKSHOP ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 14,000 14,000 HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW WAY INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

131 17922/60392 FACTORY THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 37,250 37,250 UNIT 5 & 6 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

132 17922/62742 FACTORY INITIAL WASHROOM SERVICES O 37,250 37,250 UNIT 5 & 6 HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON A INVERURIE

133 17923/52406 FACTORY P P S GLASSFIBRE LTD P 81,000 81,000 HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

134 17925/57903 WAREHOUSE ETC HOWDEN JOINERY PROPERTIES LTD T 59,000 59,000 HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY INVERURIE FISHER WILSON A

135 31056/60393 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 22,500 22,500 UNIT 7 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

136 36263/60394 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 12,000 12,000 UNIT 9 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

137 38241/61297 STORE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 7,000 7,000 UNIT 10 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

138 87754/61298 WORKSHOP ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 22,000 22,000 UNIT 8 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

139 36905/60395 STORE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 7,000 7,000 UNIT 11 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

04/06/2018 Page 10 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

140 36649/60396 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 10,000 10,000 UNIT 12 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

141 89921/61299 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 8,100 8,100 UNIT 13 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HARLAW INDUSTRIAL ESTATE HARLAW WAY RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

142 80614/52452 WORKSHOPS ETC TAWSE TYRE CO LTD P 90,000 90,000 HARLAW WAY PER GRAHAM TAWSE INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

143 33252/53515 WORKSHOP ETC SCOTFRAME TIMBER ENGINEERING LTD T 313,000 313,000 UNIT 1 INVERURIE BUSINESS PARK SOUTERFORD AVENUE SAVILLS A INVERURIE

144 33926/53508 WAREHOUSE ETC SCOTFRAME TIMBER ENGINEERING LTD T 86,500 86,500 UNIT 7 INVERURIE BUSINESS PARK SOUTERFORD AVENUE SAVILLS A INVERURIE

145 33926/53520 WAREHOUSE ETC DENHOLM MACNAMEE LTD O 86,500 86,500 UNIT 7 INVERURIE BUSINESS PARK SOUTERFORD AVENUE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A INVERURIE

146 38108/57909 STORES ETC REMBRAND TIMBER LTD T 107,000 107,000 UNIT 9-9A INVERURIE BUSINESS PARK SOUTERFORD AVENUE ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES A INVERURIE

147 31899/52405 WORKSHOP ETC A M MACKIE LTD P 36,250 36,250 UNIT 10 T/A BOOTH ELECTRICAL SERVICES INVERURIE BUSINESS PARK SOUTERFORD DRIVE RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

148 33810/53506 WORKSHOP ETC SCOTFRAME TIMBER ENGINEERING LTD P 55,000 55,000 UNIT 11 INVERURIE BUSINESS PARK SOUTERFORD DRIVE SAVILLS A INVERURIE

149 48312/52403 YARD ETC BOOTH SCOTLAND LTD P 7,800 7,800 UNIT 10 (REAR) A M MACKIE LTD INVERURIE BUSINESS PARK SOUTERFORD DRIVE RYDEN LLP A INVERURIE

150 18203/61308 REFUSE DISPOSAL WORKS THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 144,000 144,000 SOUTERFORD ROAD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

151 18204/62456 GARAGE ETC THOMAS MCPHEE P 64,500 64,500 ROAD T/A WEST HIGH STREET GARAGE INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A

152 85879/63678 WORKSHOPS ETC PRECISION OIL TOOLS LTD T 87,000 87,000 SHERIFFBURN HOUSE WEST BROOMHILL KINTORE INVERURIE

153 80724/63833 WORKSHOP ETC MAN DIESEL & TURBO UK LTD P 97,000 97,000 SITE 1A KINTORE BUSINESS PARK KINTORE KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

04/06/2018 Page 11 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

154 18308/64075 GARAGE ETC NIXON PLANT HIRE T 58,500 58,500 UNITS 1-5 PER JOHN NIXON LTD THE WOODLANDS KINTORE BKS PROPERTY CONSULTANTS A INVERURIE

155 87502/52369 WORKSHOP MSIS GROUP T 106,000 106,000 BUILDING 8 KIRKWOOD COMMERCIAL PARK THAINSTONE RYDEN LLP A

156 84475/57401 WORKSHOP KIRKWOOD COMMERCIAL PARK LTD P 118,000 118,000 UNIT 1 KIRKWOOD COMMERCIAL PARK THAINSTONE KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

157 84720/58052 WORKSHOP ETC ELLIOT GROUP LIMITED T 226,000 226,000 UNIT 2 KIRKWOOD COMMERCIAL PARK THAINSTONE J D CONSULTANCY LTD A

158 85108/57398 YARD ETC KIRKWOOD COMMERCIAL PARK LTD P 64,500 64,500 UNIT 4 KIRKWOOD COMMERCIAL PARK THAINSTONE KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

159 85518/57399 STORES KIRKWOOD COMMERCIAL PARK LTD P 710,000 710,000 UNIT 5 - 7A & 9 - 12 KIRKWOOD COMMERCIAL PARK THAINSTONE KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

160 88423/57403 WORKSHOPS ETC KIRKWOOD COMMERCIAL PARK LTD P 357,000 357,000 SITE 16 KIRKWOOD COMMERCIAL PARK THAINSTONE KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

161 84497/61820 YARD BLUE MANTA INTERNATIONAL LTD P 34,750 34,750 NORTH LODGE INVERURIE MILLS INVERURIE KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

162 18326/57904 WORKSHOP ETC BRISTOW TECHNICAL SERVICES LTD T 148,000 148,000 SITE E KINTORE BUSINESS PARK KINTORE F G BURNETT LTD A

163 38971/52419 WORKSHOP GARAGE DOOR & GATE CO (NE) LTD T 18,000 18,000 UNIT 1 (NEW) KINTORE BUSINESS PARK KINTORE SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

164 75723/52478 WORKSHOP ETC KINTORE ASSETS LTD P 94,500 94,500 SITE 2A C/O DAVID SAMUEL KINTORE BUSINESS PARK ASSET MANAGEMENT LTD KINTORE RYDEN LLP A

165 65925/53989 WORKSHOP ETC SAFELIFT OFFSHORE LTD T 35,000 35,000 MIDMILL KINTORE

166 30527/55751 WORKSHOPS ETC CALEDONIAN LOGISTICS LTD P 163,000 163,000 MIDMILL KINTORE J & E SHEPHERD A

167 59043/56724 WORKSHOP UPPERMILL FARMS LTD P 7,300 7,300 MIDMILL BUSINESS PARK TUMULUS WAY RYDEN LLP A

04/06/2018 Page 12 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

168 72283/56728 WORKSHOP UPPERMILL FARMS LTD P 4,300 4,300 MIDMILL BUSINESS PARK TUMULUS WAY RYDEN LLP A

169 84391/56718 WORKSHOP UPPERMILL FARMS LTD P 10,000 10,000 MIDMILL BUSINESS PARK TUMULUS WAY RYDEN LLP A

170 81790/53990 YARD ETC JIM REID VEHICLE SALES T 33,000 33,000 UNIT 5 CRAIGEARN BUSINESS PARK MORRISON WAY KINTORE

171 81809/57377 WORKSHOPS CABLE SOLUTIONS WORLDWIDE LTD T 44,500 44,500 UNIT 3 & 4 CRAIGEARN BUSINESS PARK MORRISON WAY F G BURNETT LTD A KINTORE

172 81916/53991 WORKSHOP JIM REID SERVICE CENTRE T 24,250 24,250 UNIT 1 CRAIGEARN BUSINESS PARK MORRISON WAY KINTORE

173 81054/64522 WORKSHOP ETC PDC SYSTEMS LTD P 45,000 45,000 SCARBOROUGH HOUSE CRAIGEARN BUSINESS PARK MORRISON WAY KINTORE

174 49835/60429 STORE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 7,400 7,400 UNIT 1 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CRAIGEARN BUSINESS PARK MORRISON WAY RYDEN LLP A KINTORE

175 49064/60430 STORE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 7,400 7,400 UNIT 2 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CRAIGEARN BUSINESS PARK MORRISON WAY RYDEN LLP A KINTORE

176 49525/61315 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 7,400 7,400 UNIT 3 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CRAIGEARN BUSINESS PARK MORRISON WAY RYDEN LLP A KINTORE

177 50029/60431 WORKSHOP ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 7,400 7,400 UNIT 4 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CRAIGEARN BUSINESS PARK MORRISON WAY RYDEN LLP A KINTORE

178 49841/60432 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 7,700 7,700 UNIT 5 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CRAIGEARN BUSINESS PARK MORRISON WAY RYDEN LLP A KINTORE

179 48818/61316 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 7,700 7,700 UNIT 7 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CRAIGEARN BUSINESS PARK MORRISON WAY RYDEN LLP A KINTORE

180 62163/60433 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 7,700 7,700 UNIT 6 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CRAIGEARN BUSINESS PARK MORRISON WAY RYDEN LLP A KINTORE

181 62203/60434 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 7,700 7,700 UNIT 8 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CRAIGEARN BUSINESS PARK MORRISON WAY RYDEN LLP A KINTORE

04/06/2018 Page 13 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

182 53233/60441 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL & T 2,900 2,900 UNIT 4 ENTERPRISE NORTH EAST TRUST THAINSTONE BUSINESS CENTRE THAINSTONE RYDEN LLP A

183 82255/60443 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL & T 2,900 2,900 UNIT 3 ENTERPRISE NORTH EAST TRUST THAINSTONE BUSINESS CENTRE THAINSTONE RYDEN LLP A

184 82364/61321 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL & T 2,900 2,900 UNIT 5 ENTERPRISE NORTH EAST TRUST THAINSTONE BUSINESS CENTRE THAINSTONE RYDEN LLP A

185 87003/60449 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL & T 2,900 2,900 UNIT 1 ENTERPRISE NORTH EAST TRUST THAINSTONE BUSINESS CENTRE THAINSTONE RYDEN LLP A

186 89104/60450 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL & T 2,900 2,900 UNIT 2 ENTERPRISE NORTH EAST TRUST THAINSTONE BUSINESS CENTRE THAINSTONE RYDEN LLP A

187 54382/54880 WORKSHOPS ETC JOHN BELL PIPELINE EQUIPMENT CO LTD T 299,000 299,000 UNIT 4 CAMIESTONE ROAD THAINSTONE F G BURNETT LTD A

188 64583/55014 WORKSHOPS ETC FILPUMPS LTD P 124,000 124,000 UNIT 10 CAMIESTONE ROAD THAINSTONE F G BURNETT LTD A

189 71183/63155 WORKSHOPS ETC A & L STRONACH LTD P 43,750 43,750 UNIT 15 & 16 CAMIESTONE ROAD THAINSTONE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

190 83079/63346 WORKSHOP ETC A J BELL TRUSTEES LTD & P 186,000 186,000 UNIT 18 NEIL J HARDIE CAMIESTONE ROAD THAINSTONE KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

191 81081/57640 WORKSHOP ETC DIACK AUTOS P 38,500 38,500 UNIT 19A T/A STATION GARAGE INVERURIE LTD CAMIESTONE ROAD THAINSTONE RYDEN LLP A

192 83037/63882 WORKSHOP ETC ALCHEMY OILFIELD SERVICES LTD P 71,000 71,000 UNIT 19D CAMIESTONE ROAD THAINSTONE KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

193 82247/54881 WORKSHOP ETC HUNTER CONSTRUCTION (ABERDEEN) LTD P 193,000 193,000 CENTAUR HOUSE CAMIESTONE ROAD THAINSTONE F G BURNETT LTD A

194 81793/52488 WAREHOUSE JAMES LAING & SONS LTD P 195,000 195,000 UNIT 7 CAMIESTONE ROAD THAINSTONE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

195 82209/55989 WORKSHOP ETC ZENITH OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY LTD T 150,000 150,000 UNIT 8 CAMIESTONE ROAD THAINSTONE GVA A

04/06/2018 Page 14 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

196 82209/57402 WORKSHOP ETC KIRKWOOD HOMES INVESTMENT LTD P 150,000 150,000 UNIT 8 CAMIESTONE ROAD THAINSTONE KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

197 81802/52439 WORKSHOPS ETC BALGOWNIE LTD P 104,000 104,000 UNIT 9 CAMIESTONE ROAD THAINSTONE RYDEN LLP A

198 81509/55991 WORKSHOPS ETC STATS GROUP P 423,000 423,000 STATS HOUSE TOFTHILLS WAY MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE RYDEN LLP A

199 84563/56722 WORKSHOP ETC UPPERMILL FARMS LTD P 157,000 157,000 MARINE TECHNICAL LIMITS TOFTHILLS AVENUE MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE RYDEN LLP A

200 84587/52374 WAREHOUSE ETC PETERSON (UK) LTD O 467,000 467,000 SITE C TOFTHILLS WAY MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE RYDEN LLP A

201 84587/56719 WAREHOUSE ETC UPPERMILL FARMS LTD P 467,000 467,000 SITE C TOFTHILLS WAY MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE RYDEN LLP A

202 84901/56721 YARD UPPERMILL FARMS LTD P 59,500 59,500 SITE D TOFTHILLS WAY MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE RYDEN LLP A

203 84901/63379 YARD PETERSON (UK) LTD T 59,500 59,500 SITE D TOFTHILLS WAY MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE RYDEN LLP A

204 85575/56717 WORKSHOPS ETC UPPERMILL FARMS LTD P 410,000 410,000 SITE F TOFTHILLS AVENUE MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE RYDEN LLP A

205 86980/55527 WORKSHOP ETC VP GROUP PLC P 232,000 232,000 SITE M1 TOFTHILLS AVENUE MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE GERALD EVE LLP A

206 89137/52372 YARD PETERSON (UK) LTD O 90,000 90,000 SITE E TOFTHILLS WAY MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE RYDEN LLP A

207 89137/56714 YARD UPPERMILL FARMS LTD P 90,000 90,000 SITE E TOFTHILLS WAY MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE RYDEN LLP A

208 50097/63679 WORKSHOPS ETC R.I.M. & E-BLAST P 1,080,000 1,080,000 MIDMILL BUSINESS PARK PER NEIL MCDONALD TUMULUS WAY

209 89013/56716 WORKSHOPS ETC UPPERMILL FARMS LTD P 305,000 305,000 SITE G TOFTHILLS AVENUE MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE RYDEN LLP A

04/06/2018 Page 15 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

210 89013/62758 WORKSHOPS ETC BALFOUR BEATTY GROUP LTD T 305,000 305,000 SITE G TOFTHILLS AVENUE MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE MATTHEWS & GOODMAN LLP A

211 49581/53519 WAREHOUSE ETC WALLACES OF AYR LTD T 125,000 125,000 MIDMILL BUSINESS PARK TUMULUS WAY GERALD EVE LLP A

212 56444/54960 WORKSHOP ETC PROSERV OFFSHORE LTD T 114,000 114,000 MIDMILL BUSINESS PARK TUMULUS WAY J & E SHEPHERD A

213 56444/57379 WORKSHOP ETC TECHNIP UK LTD O 114,000 114,000 MIDMILL BUSINESS PARK TUMULUS WAY F G BURNETT LTD A

214 18392/61324 STORE ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 5,900 5,900 OLD FIRE STATION PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES 42 NORTHERN ROAD KINTORE RYDEN LLP A

215 83482/60073 STORE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 3,600 3,600 OLD FIRE STATION PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES 42 NORTHERN ROAD KINTORE RYDEN LLP A

216 83595/57285 WORKSHOP BURNETT MANAGEMENT P 2,200 2,200 UNIT 1 BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL CENTRE BALMACASSIE J & E SHEPHERD A

217 85208/56836 WORKSHOPS BREWDOG PLC O 16,500 16,500 BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL CENTRE BALMACASSIE RYDEN LLP A

218 53868/57296 STORE BURNETT MANAGEMENT P 2,350 2,350 UNIT 2 BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL CENTRE BALMACASSIE J & E SHEPHERD A

219 53867/57282 WORKSHOP BURNETT MANAGEMENT P 6,400 6,400 UNIT 12 BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL CENTRE BALMACASSIE J & E SHEPHERD A

220 53865/57283 STORES ETC BURNETT MANAGEMENT P 19,500 19,500 UNIT 14-17 BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL CENTRE BALMACASSIE J & E SHEPHERD A

221 90049/57293 WORKSHOP BURNETT MANAGEMENT P 6,700 6,700 UNIT 13 BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL CENTRE BALMACASSIE J & E SHEPHERD A

222 90074/57294 WORKSHOP BURNETT MANAGEMENT P 8,500 8,500 UNIT 11 BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL CENTRE BALMACASSIE J & E SHEPHERD A

223 85673/55389 STORES ETC NICK CHILD PROPERTY P 99,500 99,500 UNIT E G H & J ESSLEMONT INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ELLON RYDEN LLP A

04/06/2018 Page 16 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

224 85673/55390 STORES ETC DUOTOOL DIRECT LTD T 99,500 99,500 UNIT E G H & J ESSLEMONT INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ELLON RYDEN LLP A

225 85674/55387 WORKSHOPS ETC NICK CHILD PROPERTY P 6,300 6,300 UNIT A B & C ESSLEMONT INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ELLON RYDEN LLP A

226 19155/55391 STORE NICK CHILD PROPERTY P 71,000 71,000 UNIT K ESSLEMONT INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ELLON RYDEN LLP A

227 83982/55063 WORKSHOPS ETC POWER JACKS LIMITED P 399,000 399,000 BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL PARK BALMACASSIE DRIVE F G BURNETT LTD A

228 83883/60111 CIVIC AMENITY SITE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 50,500 50,500 WASTE RECYCLING CENTRE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL PARK BALMACASSIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A

229 88291/52440 YARD BREWDOG PLC T 4,200 4,200 BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL PARK BALMACASSIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A

230 88291/60112 YARD THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 4,200 4,200 BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL PARK PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BALMACASSIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A

231 84840/52336 BREWERY BREWDOG PLC P 815,000 815,000 SITE 1 - 3 BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL PARK BALMACASSIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A

232 86422/60113 WASTE RECYCLING CENTRE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 121,000 121,000 BULKING POINT PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BALMACASSIE COMMERCIAL PARK BALMACASSIE WAY RYDEN LLP A

233 35972/56822 WORKSHOP ETC FULMOR LTD P 64,500 64,500 UNIT 1 BROOMIESBURN ROAD ELLON RYDEN LLP A

234 35972/57901 WORKSHOP ETC HOWDEN JOINERY PROPERTIES LTD T 64,500 64,500 UNIT 1 BROOMIESBURN ROAD ELLON FISHER WILSON A

235 48375/53905 WORKSHOP ETC STOPSAVE LTD T 45,750 45,750 UNIT 2 BROOMIESBURN ROAD ELLON

236 36902/52434 FACTORY ABERDEENSHIRE LARDER P 71,500 71,500 UNIT 3 BROOMIESBURN ROAD ELLON RYDEN LLP A

237 34879/61173 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 101,000 101,000 CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

04/06/2018 Page 17 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

238 19222/57418 FACTORY SHAWCOR UK LTD T 227,000 227,000 SITE 2 CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET GVA A

239 19222/60534 FACTORY THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 227,000 227,000 SITE 2 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

240 19223/52437 WAREHOUSE FRASERS HOUSE FURNISHERS P 42,750 42,750 SITE 7 (ELLON) LTD CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

241 39915/62097 WORKSHOPS ETC AUBIN LTD P 114,000 114,000 SITE 1 UNIT 1 CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

242 19225/52422 WAREHOUSE NATHAN M JONES P 16,500 16,500 SITE 3 BLOCK 1 UNIT 1 T/A CASTLEPARK GARAGE CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

243 19226/52420 WORKSHOP ETC JAZTEK INTERNATIONAL T 21,750 21,750 SITE 3 BLOCK 1 UNIT 2 CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

244 19228/60117 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 11,500 11,500 SITE 5 UNIT 1 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

245 31297/60118 STORE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 11,250 11,250 SITE 5 UNIT 4 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

246 31297/61863 STORE BROWN & TAWSE STEELSTOCK LTD T 11,250 11,250 SITE 5 UNIT 4 CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

247 19229/61174 WORKSHOP ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 9,600 9,600 SITE 5 UNIT 5 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

248 31708/57414 AMBULANCE STATION SCOTTISH AMBULANCE SERVICE P 22,000 22,000 CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET GERALD EVE LLP A

249 19230/60119 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 6,300 6,300 SITE 5 UNIT 6 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

250 38889/60120 WORKSHOP ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 10,250 10,250 SITE 5 UNIT 2 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

251 19231/61175 WORKSHOPS ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 20,000 20,000 SITE 5 UNIT 7-8 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

04/06/2018 Page 18 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

252 87345/60121 WORKSHOP ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 11,250 11,250 SITE 5 UNIT 3 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

253 19233/60122 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 12,750 12,750 SITE 4 UNIT 9 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

254 36997/60123 STORE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 8,000 8,000 SITE 4 UNIT 12 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

255 19235/61176 WORKSHOP ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 11,750 11,750 SITE 4 UNIT 11 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

256 81138/60124 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 9,600 9,600 SITE 4 UNIT 10 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET RYDEN LLP A

257 66685/52497 WORKSHOP ETC CASTLEPARK AUTOBODY LTD T 18,000 18,000 UNIT 20 CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

258 30541/63598 WORKSHOP ETC SULZER WOOD LTD O 269,000 269,000 SITE 8 CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET WYMRE A

259 33056/62572 WAREHOUSE ETC ICR INTEGRITY LTD O 67,500 67,500 UNIT 13 CASTLE WAY ELLON

260 33056/63616 WAREHOUSE ETC CRESCENT TRUSTEES LTD T 67,500 67,500 UNIT 13 C/O POINTON YORK HOUSE CASTLE WAY ELLON RYDEN LLP A

261 33261/60125 YARD THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 2,150 2,150 CASTLE ROAD INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES CASTLE WAY ELLON RYDEN LLP A

262 35954/52425 STORE NEIL R PHILIPS (SIGNWRITER) T 16,000 16,000 UNIT 3 PREMIER INDUSTRIAL UNITS CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A CASTLE STREET

263 35549/53907 WORKSHOP PIT-LANE (ELLON) LTD T 17,500 17,500 UNIT 2 PREMIER INDUSTRIAL UNITS CASTLEPARK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE CASTLE STREET

264 81030/54868 WAREHOUSE ETC WHITESALES LTD P 92,500 92,500 CASTLE POINT CASTLE WAY ELLON GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

265 19250/58240 WORKSHOP KAIRDSON TYRES LTD T 21,750 21,750 KAIRDSON HOUSE HOSPITAL ROAD ELLON

04/06/2018 Page 19 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

266 19250/60127 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 21,750 21,750 KAIRDSON HOUSE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HOSPITAL ROAD ELLON RYDEN LLP A

267 19254/60128 DEPOT THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 111,000 111,000 HOSPITAL ROAD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES ELLON RYDEN LLP A

268 87322/60130 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 11,750 11,750 MEN'S SHED PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES HOSPITAL ROAD ELLON RYDEN LLP A

269 30280/62122 SORTING OFFICE ROYAL MAIL GROUP PROPERTY P 28,500 28,500 HOSPITAL ROAD ELLON G L HEARN LIMITED A

270 19321/62108 WAREHOUSE ETC BEAVER HEALTHCARE EQUIPMENT P 36,500 36,500 BEAVER HOUSE STATION BRAE ELLON GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

271 20791/60669 GARAGE ETC THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 18,000 18,000 OLD STATION YARD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES STATION ROAD RYDEN LLP A

272 20800/60670 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 5,900 5,900 UNIT 1 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES TILLYBRAKE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE TILLYBRAKE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

273 20801/61256 STORE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 5,200 5,200 UNIT 2 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES TILLYBRAKE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE TILLYBRAKE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

274 20802/60671 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 5,200 5,200 UNIT 3 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES TILLYBRAKE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE TILLYBRAKE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

275 20803/60672 STORE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 5,300 5,300 UNIT 4 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES TILLYBRAKE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE TILLYBRAKE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

276 20804/60673 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 10,000 10,000 UNIT 5 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES TILLYBRAKE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE TILLYBRAKE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

277 40757/61257 FITNESS CENTRE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 10,250 10,250 UNIT 6 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES TILLYBRAKE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE TILLYBRAKE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BANCHORY

278 31918/60674 SORTING OFFICE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 21,750 21,750 TILLYBRAKE ROAD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

279 31918/62121 SORTING OFFICE ROYAL MAIL GROUP PROPERTY T 21,750 21,750 TILLYBRAKE ROAD BANCHORY G L HEARN LIMITED A

04/06/2018 Page 20 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

280 20875/55405 WORKSHOP ETC STAGECOACH BLUEBIRD P 14,250 14,250 DYKEHEAD GARAGE BLACKHALL BANCHORY MONTAGU EVANS A

281 20904/60677 DEPOT THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 53,500 53,500 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A

282 35529/53528 WORKSHOP ETC ONESUBSEA UK LTD T 326,000 326,000 BADENTOY ROAD KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

283 31611/54875 DEPOT C E B O (UK) LTD T 121,000 121,000 UNIT B BADENTOY ROAD PORTLETHEN F G BURNETT LTD A

284 32664/54876 WAREHOUSE ETC SPRINGDON LTD P 186,000 186,000 UNIT C PER PAULL & WILLIAMSON BADENTOY ROAD PORTLETHEN F G BURNETT LTD A

285 54136/53217 WORKSHOPS ETC PALMARIS PLANT HIRE LTD T 48,750 48,750 BADENTOY AVENUE PORTLETHEN WYMRE A

286 38701/53526 WORKSHOP ETC SMITH INTERNATIONAL (NORTH SEA) LTD T 399,000 399,000 BADENTOY AVENUE PORTLETHEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

287 33397/63618 WORKSHOP ALEXANDER ADAM & JAMES ADAM P 96,000 96,000 UNIT F BADENTOY AVENUE PORTLETHEN RYDEN LLP A

288 49488/63602 WORKSHOP ALEXANDER ADAM & JAMES ADAM P 53,000 53,000 UNIT E BADENTOY AVENUE PORTLETHEN RYDEN LLP A

289 39414/52491 WORKSHOP ETC SMITH INTERNATIONAL (NORTH SEA) LTD T 550,000 550,000 BADENTOY AVENUE PORTLETHEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

290 39414/62325 WORKSHOP ETC C O I F NOMINEES LTD P 550,000 550,000 BADENTOY AVENUE PORTLETHEN BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE A

291 48247/57886 WORKSHOP ETC CHUBB FIRE LTD T 198,000 198,000 BADENTOY CRESCENT PORTLETHEN CBRE LTD A

292 49951/58180 DEPOT WARBURTONS LTD T 104,000 104,000 DISTRIBUTION DEPOT BADENTOY CRESCENT PORTLETHEN JONES LANG LASALLE A

293 56003/55595 WORKSHOP ETC AKER OFFSHORE PARTNERSHIP LTD T 109,000 109,000 UNIT B BADENTOY AVENUE PORTLETHEN CBRE LTD A

04/06/2018 Page 21 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

294 35010/58937 WAREHOUSE SAFETY & TECHNICAL HYDRAULICS LTD T 45,750 45,750 UNITS 1 - 4 BADENTOY PLACE PORTLETHEN CBRE LTD A

295 35010/61182 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 45,750 45,750 UNITS 1 - 4 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BADENTOY PLACE PORTLETHEN RYDEN LLP A

296 35011/60137 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 12,000 12,000 UNIT 5 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BADENTOY PLACE PORTLETHEN RYDEN LLP A

297 36029/60138 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 11,000 11,000 UNIT 6 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES PIPER ALPHA CENTRE BADENTOY PLACE RYDEN LLP A PORTLETHEN

298 36251/60139 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 11,000 11,000 UNIT 7 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES PIPER ALPHA CENTRE BADENTOY PLACE RYDEN LLP A PORTLETHEN

299 36105/61183 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 10,750 10,750 UNIT 8 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES PIPER ALPHA CENTRE BADENTOY PLACE RYDEN LLP A PORTLETHEN

300 36560/58936 WAREHOUSE SAFETY & TECHNICAL HYDRAULICS LTD T 11,500 11,500 UNIT 9 PIPER ALPHA CENTRE BADENTOY PLACE CBRE LTD A PORTLETHEN

301 36560/60140 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 11,500 11,500 UNIT 9 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES PIPER ALPHA CENTRE BADENTOY PLACE RYDEN LLP A PORTLETHEN

302 60643/60141 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 12,000 12,000 UNIT 10 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES PIPER ALPHA CENTRE BADENTOY PLACE RYDEN LLP A PORTLETHEN

303 36030/61184 WAREHOUSE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 12,250 12,250 UNIT 11 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES PIPER ALPHA CENTRE BADENTOY PLACE RYDEN LLP A PORTLETHEN

304 35535/54896 WORKSHOP ALTUS INTERVENTION LTD T 125,000 125,000 S P M HOUSE BADENTOY CRESCENT PORTLETHEN J & E SHEPHERD A

305 40121/63054 WORKSHOP ETC COIL SERVICES (NORTH SEA) LTD T 104,000 104,000 BADENTOY CRESCENT A DIVISION OF PORTLETHEN NATIONAL OILWELL VARCO UK LTD BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE A

306 39386/53518 YARD RAMCO TUBULAR SERVICES LTD T 47,500 47,500 BADENTOY 4 T/A TAMCO OIL SERVICES LTD BADENTOY CRESCENT PORTLETHEN RYDEN LLP A

307 84433/53532 YARD RAMCO TUBULARS LTD O 94,000 94,000 BOSWELL FACILITY BADENTOY CRESCENT PORTLETHEN RYDEN LLP A

04/06/2018 Page 22 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

308 82716/52415 WAREHOUSE ETC LOXLEY ABERDEEN LTD P 259,000 259,000 BADENTOY CRESCENT PER PETERKINS PORTLETHEN RYDEN LLP A

309 87768/60142 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 11,500 11,500 UNIT C PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BADENTOY BUSINESS CENTRE BADENTOY CRESCENT RYDEN LLP A PORTLETHEN

310 39072/60143 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 12,000 12,000 UNIT A PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BADENTOY BUSINESS CENTRE BADENTOY CRESCENT RYDEN LLP A PORTLETHEN

311 39073/60144 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 12,000 12,000 UNIT B PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BADENTOY BUSINESS CENTRE BADENTOY CRESCENT RYDEN LLP A PORTLETHEN

312 39379/61185 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 14,000 14,000 UNIT D PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BADENTOY BUSINESS CENTRE BADENTOY CRESCENT RYDEN LLP A PORTLETHEN

313 39274/60145 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 14,000 14,000 UNIT E PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BADENTOY BUSINESS CENTRE BADENTOY CRESCENT RYDEN LLP A PORTLETHEN

314 39074/60146 WORKSHOP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 14,000 14,000 UNIT F PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BADENTOY BUSINESS CENTRE BADENTOY CRESCENT RYDEN LLP A PORTLETHEN

315 69703/62489 WAREHOUSE ETC SDV LTD T 137,000 137,000 BADENTOY CRESCENT PORTLETHEN THE BEATTIE PARTNERSHIP A

316 39397/53536 YARD RAMCO OIL SERVICES PLC P 550,000 550,000 (ADJACENT TO VARCO) BADENTOY CRESCENT PORTLETHEN RYDEN LLP A

317 88542/54883 WAREHOUSE ETC KCA DEUTAG DRILLING LTD T 250,000 250,000 BADENTOY INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BADENTOY DRIVE F G BURNETT LTD A

318 89902/61186 CIVIC AMENITY SITE THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 62,500 62,500 BADENTOY INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BADENTOY DRIVE RYDEN LLP A

319 90090/57018 WAREHOUSE ETC BT PROPERTY T 138,000 138,000 BADENTOY INDUSTRIAL ESTATE RATING AND VALUATION BADENTOY DRIVE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

320 54605/54647 WORKSHOP ALAN MCCOMBIE T 19,250 19,250 UNIT 17 - 18 T/A B A MECHANICAL SERVICES BLACKHILL OF FINDON PORTLETHEN

321 31975/57304 YARD CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 15,500 15,500 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

04/06/2018 Page 23 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

322 88029/53258 YARD CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 850 850 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

323 88030/53248 YARD CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 220 220 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

324 88031/53257 YARD CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 1,600 1,600 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

325 87392/53261 WAREHOUSE CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 24,000 24,000 UNIT 3A CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN WYMRE A ABERDEEN

326 86121/53260 STORE ETC CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 55,500 55,500 UNIT 2 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN WYMRE A ABERDEEN

327 86121/63617 STORE ETC NATIONWIDE PLATFORMS T 55,500 55,500 UNIT 2 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN CVS A ABERDEEN

328 86236/53262 WAREHOUSE CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 17,250 17,250 UNIT 3 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN WYMRE A ABERDEEN

329 88027/53264 WAREHOUSE CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 122,000 122,000 UNIT 6 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN WYMRE A ABERDEEN

330 88027/64032 WAREHOUSE HSS HIRE SERVICE GROUP LTD T 122,000 122,000 UNIT 6 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN SAVILLS A ABERDEEN

331 90107/57023 WAREHOUSE CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 31,750 31,750 UNIT 8 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN WYMRE A ABERDEEN

332 90117/57021 YARD ETC CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 34,000 34,000 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

333 90119/57024 WAREHOUSE CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 97,500 97,500 UNIT 7 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN WYMRE A ABERDEEN

334 86239/53251 YARD CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 62,500 62,500 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

335 86239/58005 YARD JOHN CLARK MOTOR GROUP LTD T 62,500 62,500 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

04/06/2018 Page 24 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

336 86329/53256 WORKSHOP CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 31,250 31,250 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

337 86906/53253 YARD CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 7,100 7,100 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

338 87475/53249 YARD CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 2,250 2,250 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

339 87475/53511 YARD CONTAINER COMPANY (ABERDEEN) LTD T 2,250 2,250 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

340 86903/53252 YARD CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 7,100 7,100 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

341 86910/53255 WORKSHOP CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 55,000 55,000 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

342 86920/53254 YARD CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 58,000 58,000 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

343 86920/53510 YARD CONTAINER COMPANY (ABERDEEN) LTD T 58,000 58,000 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

344 87437/53259 YARD CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 5,800 5,800 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

345 87437/61822 YARD GREENWELL EQUIPMENT LTD T 5,800 5,800 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

346 86921/53263 WORKSHOP ETC CAIRNROBIN PROPERTY CO LTD P 66,000 66,000 UNIT 5 CAIRNROBIN PORTLETHEN WYMRE A ABERDEEN

347 90079/63242 WAREHOUSE ETC ERIKS INDUSTRIAL SERVICES LTD T 219,000 219,000 GATEWAY BUSINESS PARK MOSS ROAD NIGG CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

348 84826/52370 WORKSHOP CORETRAX LTD P 144,000 144,000 UNIT 5 GATEWAY BUSINESS PARK MOSS ROAD RYDEN LLP A NIGG

349 21180/58182 WAREHOUSE ETC VION FOOD SCOTLAND LTD - P 88,500 88,500 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE MCINTOSH DONALD BARCLAYHILL PLACE PORTLETHEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

04/06/2018 Page 25 of 26 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

350 21181/52494 WORKSHOP DRESSER-RAND (UK) LTD T 26,500 26,500 UNIT 1-1A PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE GERALD EVE LLP A PORTLETHEN

351 21181/58037 WORKSHOP HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL P 26,500 26,500 UNIT 1-1A PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE CBRE LTD A PORTLETHEN

352 21183/58039 WORKSHOP ETC HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL P 16,000 16,000 UNIT 3 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE CBRE LTD A PORTLETHEN

353 21186/58040 STORE HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL P 21,250 21,250 UNIT 6 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE CBRE LTD A PORTLETHEN

354 21188/57303 WAREHOUSE JOB WORTH DOING LTD T 16,250 16,250 UNIT 8 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE WYMRE A PORTLETHEN

355 21188/58036 WAREHOUSE HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL P 16,250 16,250 UNIT 8 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE CBRE LTD A PORTLETHEN

356 54391/57302 WAREHOUSE LYRECO T 15,500 15,500 UNIT 9 PER MRS SHARON LENG PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A PORTLETHEN

357 54391/58035 WAREHOUSE HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL P 15,500 15,500 UNIT 9 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE CBRE LTD A PORTLETHEN

358 89333/58041 STORE HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL P 16,500 16,500 UNIT 7 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE CBRE LTD A PORTLETHEN

359 21190/57368 CAR PARK BAKER HUGHES INTEQ P 31,750 31,750 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE PORTLETHEN F G BURNETT LTD A

360 21191/57360 WAREHOUSE ETC CLARK & ROSE LTD P 184,000 184,000 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE PORTLETHEN F G BURNETT LTD A

361 21197/57908 WORKSHOP ETC VOLVO GROUP UK LTD P 149,000 149,000 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE PORTLETHEN GVA A

04/06/2018 Page 26 of 26