211

Planning Committee

2nd April, 2014

(2.00 p.m.)

PRESENT:- Councillor S. Chaytor (Chair), Councillor A. Clark (Deputy Chair), Councillor P. Allen, Councillor S. Baker, Councillor J. L. Fareham, Councillor A. D. Gardiner, Councillor D. W. Gemmell, Councillor T. J. McVie and Councillor L. M. Petrini. IN ATTENDANCE:- A. Codd (City Planning Manager), D. Harris (Development Manager), G. Hall (Assistant Head of Service, Transport and Asset Management), N. Chester (Legal Services) and P. Rawcliffe (Democratic Services Officer). APOLOGIES:- Councillor D. Brown, Councillor N. Fudge, Councillor J. Hornby, Councillor R. M. Jones, Councillor T. E. Keal, Councillor D. Kirk and Councillor E. Mann.

Minute Description/Decision Action No. By/Deadline PROCEDURAL ITEMS 270 DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST

Councillor Gemmell declared a personal interest in minute 283 insofar as he had connections with this site through his involvement with the Deep, and did not speak or vote.

271 MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON WEDNESDAY, 5TH MARCH, 2014

Agreed - That the minutes of the meeting of this Committee, held at 10.00 a.m. on 5th March, 2014, having been printed and circulated, be taken as read and correctly recorded and be signed by the Chair.

272 MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON WEDNESDAY, 5TH MARCH, 2014

Agreed - That the minutes of the meeting of this Committee, held at 2.00 p.m. on 5th March, 2014, having been printed and circulated, be taken as read and correctly recorded and be signed by the Chair. 212

NON-EXEMPT ITEMS 273 ST. CATHERINE’S RESIDENTIAL HOME FOR THE City ELDERLY, 146 LANE, KINGSTON Planning UPON HULL, HU9 3AJ Manager

17206N

Fell Sycamore.

St. Catherine’s Residential Home For The Elderly

Moved be Councillor Chaytor and seconded by Councillor Gemmell:

That the above application be approved as detailed in the Planning Schedule.

Moved be Councillor Fareham and seconded by Councillor Baker as an amendment:

That the application be refused.

Amendment lost. Motion carried.

274 37 CHANTERLANDS AVENUE, KINGSTON UPON City HULL, HU5 3SS Planning Manager 12136L

1) Change of use from shop (A1 use) to restaurant (A3 use) (ground floor only). 2) External alterations to side (south) elevation. 3) Installation of new velux roof lights to rear building to serve new toilets (revised resubmission).

Mr. Chris Lee

Moved be Councillor Fareham and seconded by Councillor McVie:

That the above application be approved as detailed in the Planning Schedule.

Motion carried.

(Councillor Nicola (ward councillor); Mr. Lee (applicant), and Mr. Jennings (agent) addressed the Committee on this application.) 213

275 92 NEWLAND AVENUE, , City HU5 3AB Planning Manager 13005F

Change of use from cafe (A3) to mixed use cafe bar (A3/A4) with opening hours until 23.30.

Mrs I. Naama

Moved be Councillor Fareham and seconded by Councillor McVie:

That the above application be delegated to the City Planning Manager for approval once the flooding issues are resolved.

Motion carried.

276 22 TRAIN AVENUE, KINGSTON UPON HULL, HU6 City 7BN Planning Manager 32359

Erection of single storey extension to side (to provide accommodation for additional resident and carer) (8.4 long x 7.3m wide x max 5m high; 27'6" x 23'11" x16'5").

Mr. Lacey Andrew

Moved be Councillor Chaytor and seconded by Councillor Fareham:

That the above application be deferred for one month to allow the City Planning Manager to discuss the layout of the site with the applicant.

Motion carried.

277 LAND AT HOLDERNESS ROAD/COURTNEY City STREET/BURLEIGH STREET, KINGSTON UPON Planning HULL Manager

31138B

Erection of retail units (use classes A1/A3/A5) with new site access, associated car parking, hard and soft landscaping, lighting columns and fencing. 214

Mount Pleasant Urban Regeneration Limited

Moved be Councillor Chaytor and seconded by Councillor A. Clark:

That the above application be approved as detailed in the Planning Schedule, with the deletion of condition 5 (relating to delivery times) and the amendments to the following condition:

30) The use hereby permitted shall be operated and managed in accordance with a site management plan (which shall include details such as access and egress arrangements, revised layout at service yard access, signage information [form and location]) details of the plan shall be submitted to and agreed in writing with the Local Planning Authority before the first use occurs and the uses shall thereafter comply with the approved site management plan, unless otherwise agreed in writing beforehand with the Local Planning Authority (in the interests of amenity and public safety and to comply with policy M29 of the Local Plan).

Motion carried.

(Mr. Ward (agent) addressed the Committee on this application.)

278 94 ALFRED GELDER STREET, KINGSTON UPON City HULL, HU1 2AN Planning Manager 9572N

Advertisement consent application for:- 1) The display of video projection (8m high x 14m wide; 26'3" x 46') onto north facing wall. 2) 6 x flags at balcony level.

Mr. Malcolm Scott

Moved be Councillor Chaytor and seconded by Councillor Petrini:

That the above application be approved as detailed in the Planning Schedule, with the deletion of conditions 2 and 3.

215

Motion carried.

(Mr. Scott (applicant) addressed the Committee on this application.)

279 681 ANLABY ROAD, KINGSTON UPON HULL, HU3 City 6UL Planning Manager 32244

Construction of vehicular access to front.

Mr. Richard Callaghan

Moved be Councillor Baker and seconded by Councillor Chaytor:

That the above application be refused as detailed in the Planning Schedule.

Motion carried.

280 101 NEWLAND AVENUE, KINGSTON UPON HULL, City HU5 2AA Planning Manager 13069E

1. Change of use to mixed use of hot food takeaway (A5) and restaurant/cafe (A3). 2. Installation of extraction flue.

Mr. Mustafa Bilgin Gerbaga

Moved be Councillor Fareham and seconded by Councillor McVie:

That the above planning application be refused for the following reasons:

01) The proposal would result in an over proliferation of food and drink outlets in the shopping centre which is likely to have an adverse impact on the vitality and viability of the centre contrary to policy S12 of the Local Plan.

02) The proposal would cause increased noise, disturbance, and odour impacts (particularly during evening hours), to the detriment of the amenity of neighbouring occupiers, and in particular 1 216

Edgecumbe Street and the flat above 101 Newland Avenue, contrary to policies S1 and S12 of the Local Plan.

Motion carried.

(Mr. Liang (neighbour) and Mr. Farrow (agent) addressed the Committee on this application.)

281 68 PARK AVENUE, PRINCES AVENUE, KINGSTON City UPON HULL, HU5 3ES Planning Manager 10715H

Fell 1 no. Silver Birch tree in rear garden (Tree Preservation Order 196).

Mr. Paul Harvie

Moved be Councillor Fareham and seconded by Councillor Gemmell:

That the above application be approved as detailed in the Planning Schedule

Motion carried.

282 PEARSON PARK HOTEL, 20 PEARSON AVENUE, City KINGSTON UPON HULL, HU5 2SX Planning Manager 19988B

Change of use of part of hotel to 7 bedroom house in multiple occupation (HIMO)

The above application was approved in February, 2014, subject to conditions. This item deals with a request to discharge Condition 5 of the application.

Mr. Grant Edmunds

Moved be Councillor Fareham and seconded by Councillor Chaytor:

That the above application be approved as detailed in the Planning Schedule, with the addition of a requirement that motion sensitive lights be used at the rear.

217

Motion carried.

283 LAND SOUTH OF STREET, EAST OF City QUEEN STREET, KINGSTON UPON HULL, HU1 Planning 1UT Manager

32273A

Erection of 2, 3 and 4 storey buildings to provide B1 office accommodation, laying out of landscaped central pedestrian square with partially underground plant room, cycle store and retail unit, formation of seating terrace within former dry dock for public performances or general public use.

The above application was approved in September, 2013, subject to conditions. This item deals with the reserved matters in Condition 4 of the application.

Watergate Developments Ltd/

(Councillor Gemmell declared a personal interest in minute 283 insofar as he had connections with this site through his involvement with the Deep, and did not speak or vote.)

Moved be Councillor Fareham and seconded by Councillor A. Clark:

a) That the above application be approved as detailed in the Planning Schedule, and

b) that the City Planning Manager writes to the relevant Portfolio Holders; Chief Executive; Chief Operating Officer, and Norfolk Property Services with a request from this Committee that, the importance of (i) the quality of design; (ii) the benefit of detailed pre-application discussions, and (iii) the timely submission of future applications of this nature, be passed on to developers.

Motion carried.

284 UPDATE SHEET

The City Planning Manager submitted additional representations that had been made in respect of applications 17206N (St. Catherine’s Residential 218

Home for the Elderly, Southcoates Lane); 12136L (37 Chanterlands Avenue); 13005F (92 Newland Avenue); 31138B (Land at Holderness Road/Courtney Street); 9572N (94 Alfred Gelder Street); 13069E (101 Newland Avenue); 19988B (20 Pearson Avenue), and 32273A (Humber Street).

Agreed - That the update sheet be noted.

Start: 2.00 p.m. Finish: 3.45 p.m.