DOCSLIB.ORG

Knowsley Renewable and Low Carbon Energy Options Study

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Knowsley Renewable and Low Carbon Energy Options Study KNOWSLEY RENEWABLE AND LOW CARBON ENERGY OPTIONS Knowsley Metropolitan Borough Council CONTENTS 1 INTRODUCTION 1 APPENDICES Appendix A Scope of Study 36 2 SUMMARY OF FINDINGS 2 Appendix B Policy Review 38 3 STRATEGIC ASSESSMENT 6 Appendix C Policy Implications for Locations and Targets for Renewable Energy in Knowsley 45 4 TECHNOLOGY OPTIONS REVIEW 12 Appendix D Review of Local Authority Renewable 5 OPTIONS APPRAISAL 28 Energy Policies 50 Appendix E Renewable Energy Industry in the 6 DELIVERING RENEWABLE ENERGY IN KNOWSLEY: North West 57 RECOMMENDATIONS 30 Appendix F Economic, employment and skils profile for Knowsley 60 Appendix G Consultation with Local Businesses in Knowsley 67 Appendix H Intervention for Renewable Energy Industry in Knowsley 75 Appendix I Knowsley Energy Profile, Energy and Constraints Mapping 81 Appendix J Renewable Energy Technologies Overview 112 Appendix K Renewable Energy Assessment of Knowsley Industrial Park 132 Appendix L Glossary 140 Knowsley Renewable and Low Carbon Energy Options Ove Arup & Partners Ltd July 09 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 BACKGROUND TO THE STUDY 1.2 APPROACH FOR RENEWABLE ENERGY Knowsley Metropolitan Borough Council (KMBC) OPTIONS IN KNOWSLEY has made formal commitments to address climate To deliver the project, a Strategic Assessment to change within the Borough through signing the North identify the most relevant national and regional West Climate Change Charter and the Nottingham Renewable Energy policies has been completed. Declaration on Climate Change. Opportunities and constraints associated with delivering Renewable Energy solutions to the Knowsley Council have been quick to recognise Borough, inclusive of technological and material the benefits of taking both a proactive and realistic planning considerations have been identified. approach to environmental and sustainability issues and has commissioned Arup to investigate the An Integrated Risk Management (IRM) tool along practical and realistic options for increasing the with a complementary planning appraisal have been production of renewable and low carbon energy used to assess the relevant options applicable to the within the Borough. Borough. To help test opportunities and constraints an assessment of Knowsley Industrial Park (KIP) A critical issue for this study is how KMBC and has been undertaken along with discussions with businesses in the Borough address the requirements key private sector businesses. This has helped test of the Carbon Reduction Commitment (CRC) and the the potential for Renewable Energy in the Borough implications this will have on delivering renewable, and provide a steer on some of the key issues the low and zero carbon energy in Knowsley. KMBC Borough will face when delivering Renewable Energy already has experience of exploring renewable energy in short, medium and long term for the existing built solutions for the Borough, however on each occasion environment and future development proposals. it has been identified that potential schemes have not been viable. Consequently this provides the backdrop Consultation with a number of stakeholders, notably to this study and the recommendations have been local businesses in Knowsley was a key part of developed to assist Knowsley on a range of issues to the project. The findings of the consultations are help deliver renewable energy technologies that may set out in Appendix G, touched upon throughout otherwise not have been deliverable. the discussions in this report and reflected in our recommendations. For details on the scope of this study please refer to Appendix A. To inform future developments, recommendations with respect to the Borough’s specific Renewable Energy generation potential and more strategic planning and economic policy consideration and next steps have also been presented. Knowsley Renewable and Low Carbon Energy Options 1 Ove Arup & Partners Ltd July 09 2. SUMMARY OF FINDINGS 2.1 KNOWSley’S ENERGY PROFILE sub regional renewable energy targets set out in the Knowsley presently has a heavily gas-led energy North West Regional Spatial Strategy (RSS). These balance. Much of this can be attributed to industry are set out in the table below which indicates the and process-driven energy requirements, plus space- maximum number of potential schemes that could heating and hot water provision to around 64,000 be delivered across Merseyside and specifically in households and more than 1,000 businesses based Knowsley. The table also indicates the optimum within the Borough. amount of energy produced in Mega Watts (MW) if each scheme was delivered and operated to Whilst electricity consumption within Knowsley maximum efficiency. represents 15-20% of total energy usage, the associated carbon emissions of this level of grid 2010 2015 2020 2010 TO 2020 supplied electricity actually represents closer to NWRSS NWRSS NWRSS IDENTIFIED 35% of the Borough’s total CO emissions, when NUMBER NUMBER NUMBER KNOWSLEY 2 OF OF OF calculated using the NI185 methodology. SCHEMES SCHEMES SCHEMES (MW) (MW) (MW) 2.2 KEY FINDINGS Single large 6 (9 MW) 10 (15 MW) 10 (15 MW) 3 - 6 wind turbines (6 MW) The study identifies that Knowsley already has a Small stand- 8 (0.24 12 (0.36) 12 (0.36) Est 3 growing and thriving Renewable Energy sector. This alone wind MW) (0.08 MW) is still in its infancy but with effective and timely turbines support there is considerable scope to ensure Bldg.- 190 (0.19 1,900 (1.9 3,800 (3.8 Unknown mounted MW) MW) MW) Knowsley is one of the key areas in the region for micro-wind employment for this sector. turbines Biomass- 1.4 2 (9 MW) 2 (9 MW) 4 (6.8 MW) The study identified that the local business fuelled CHP/ electricity community is one of the main drivers to help ensure schemes effective delivery and make Knowsley self sufficient in Solar 190 (0.38 4,750 (9.5 9,500 (10 Unknown its energy needs in the long term. There are existing photovoltaics MW) MW ) MW) businesses in Knowsley that are already producing Energy from - - - 1 (18 MW) Renewable Energy technologies/ component waste parts and fuels. Equally there is an established Other KMBC Study infrastructure and labour force with transferable skills Options: to deliver Renewable Energy technologies in the CHP with - - - 4 (10 MW) Borough. District heating The study identifies that in planning terms, Knowsley Total KMBC 15 (40.8 MW) is relatively unconstrained for delivering Renewable Study Prospect Energy technologies. The key issues are visual impact and potential loss of agricultural and Greenbelt The table demonstrates that Knowsley has the land, however based on the approach used for this potential to make a significant contribution to the study we consider there are limited circumstances sub regional targets, particularly with respect to were Renewable Energy development cannot be Biomass, on shore wind farms and single large implemented and in the majority of cases appropriate wind turbines. This provides an indication only, mitigation can be achieved. however it has been used to provide an initial target for renewable energy production that KMBC should Following our analysis we have compared the consider when developing Renewable and Low/ Renewable Energy potential in Knowsley against the Zero carbon technologies. In order to have a more Knowsley Renewable and Low Carbon Energy Options 2 Ove Arup & Partners Ltd July 09 accurate understanding of viable schemes and the In addition to the two immediate options there are two amount of energy they can produce in Knowsley, further options that KMBC must consider to ensure KMBC will need to undertake more detailed work and that it optimises the potential in the borough. enter discussion with its sub regional neighbours. These issues are addressed in the recommendation Option 3: Where distributed energy options presented in this study. are not suitable or viable - the performance and economics of building integrated andmicro-generation 2.3 THE BEST RENEWABLE ENERGY OPTIONS are considered on site/ building by site/ building FOR KNOWSLEY basis. Following the completion of this study Arup have Option 4: Biomass Hub – the borough has identified that there are immediate opportunities for significant potential to become a location for the distributed energy generation within Knowsley. In production, storage, distribution and consumption of terms of immediate options there are two main biomass fuels and energy. Renewable Energy technologies that KMBC must consider: Option1: District heating – a heat mapping exercise has been used to identify a number of key sites, with high-level predictions of associated energy outputs and emissions reduction potential calculated. Distributed Energy consists of medium-large scale devices installed in a central location in conjunction with site-wide distribution network(s) as appropriate. Generated energy supplied to buildings via site-wide distribution networks. Most suited to large-scale, mixed use developments with single ownership of buildings. Option 2: Large-scale wind – in combination with a constraints mapping exercise, key potential sites have been identified. Knowsley Renewable and Low Carbon Energy Options 3 Ove Arup & Partners Ltd July 09 RECOMMENDATION DESCRIPTION ACTIONS FUNDING TIMESCALE Key Next Steps: Delivery of Renewable Energy, Low and Zero Carbon Technologies in Knowsley To gain a detailed The main distributed energy Identify potential private sector partners Carbon Trust - Applied Research Short Term view of technical, options are large scale wind, and funding streams for projects. Grant.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • POWER GENERATION Kohler Power President Talks About Liebherr, Clarke Energy, What's Ahead for the Global Generator and Engine
    POWER GENERATION Kohler Power president talks about Liebherr, Clarke Energy, what’s ahead for the global generator and engine manufacturer. By Mike Brezonick ne of the key architects of the company’s growth strategy is Tom Cromwell, Opresident of Kohler Power. A vice president at heat transfer specialist Modine Manufacturing before coming to Kohler in 2009, Cromwell served as president of gasoline and then global engine business before assuming leadership of the company’s development standpoint specific to overall engine and power generation segments in 2009. Diesel Progress recently talked G-drive engines. If you think about with Cromwell in his office in Kohler, Wis. most generator applications, it uses an engine that was developed for something In 2016, Kohler partnered these units. They’ve continued to add else and at some point, the engine is with Liebherr on a new range more and more capacity into both the retrofitted to be an acceptable generator of generator drive engines Bulle and Colmar facilities to support engine? and then launched the KD our growth. Everything that has been launched by series generator sets based They’ve done the engine development Liebherr so far for these large platform on those engines. Where work on the mining and construction engines has been for generators. might that relationship go in application for those engines and We changed where the turbos are the future? we’ve helped them from an engine configured and a lot about the base Liebherr’s capability, from a development standpoint, has been outstanding. They have strong “With the KD series, engineering capabilities; strong technical capabilities and they’ve invested a lot Kohler owns every into the partnership.
    [Show full text]
  • NW Regional Technical Advisory Body 3Rd
    North West Regional Technical Advisory Body 3rd Waste Management Monitoring Report Working towards sustainable waste management in the North West August 2007 Contents Foreword . .2 Executive summary . .3 1. Introduction . .4 2. Municipal waste . .7 3. Commercial and industrial waste . .15 4. Construction, demolition and excavation waste . .19 5. Management of waste at facilities and sites . .20 6. Fly-tipping and enforcement . .27 7. Special waste . .29 8. Agricultural waste . .32 9. Radioactive waste . .33 10. Identification of waste management facilities of national, regional and sub-regional significance . .34 Glossary . .35 Abbreviations . .36 Technical Appendices 1. Additional tables and figures . .38 2. Progress report on implementation of the North West Regional Waste Strategy Action Plan . .44 Photo credits Front cover top: Merseyside Objective 1Programme Front cover bottom: Envirolink Northwest Back cover top: David Jones Photography/Merseyside Waste Disposal Authority 3rd Annual Monitoring Report – Working towards sustainable waste management in the North West 1 August 2007 Foreword The North West Regional Technical Advisory Body (NWRTAB) is (Environment Agency). This has produced a report with broader publishing its 3rd Annual Monitoring Report. This year we have scope and hopefully a better read. sought to broaden the appeal of the document and extend its scope The report covers a period of considerable activity on both policy to encompass matters wider than just core statistics about waste making and development and practical waste management, which activity in the North West. includes: The core purpose of the NWRTAB is to collect, collate and interpret o Movement of the draft Regional Spatial Strategy (RSS) through its data and other information about waste activity in the region.
    [Show full text]
  • WORKING TOGETHER Clarke's 2015 Sustainability Report
    WORKING TOGETHER Clarke's 2015 Sustainability Report ii G4-1, G4-2 It is my pleasure to introduce our seventh Sustainability Report. This report highlights our work in 2015 and measures our progress toward our 2020 Sustainability Goals. 2015 was a year of working together. It was a year of collaboration and partnership— throughout all areas of our business and in all of our endeavors. Employees came together to share stories of their successes and to explore solutions to their challenges. Suppliers and partners helped us to eliminate unnecessary waste and improve efficiencies in our service operations and manufacturing processes. Our scientific and regulatory teams articulated a “road map” to guide the discovery, development and commercialization of our greener chemistry, Next Gen products. Those same teams partnered with local schools to educate and inspire the next generation of environmental and sustainability minded scientists. We worked with and within our local communities to give back and to demonstrate our care for people and for the planet. In 2015, we engaged with our stakeholders—employees, customers, suppliers, and partners—to identify the issues and opportunities that matter most. And with this insight, we are able to refine our focus and concentrate our efforts on providing high quality, innovative and effective products and services that address public health issues and improve the quality of inland waterways. As the year came to a close, the importance of our work was reinforced with the emergence of new mosquito-borne diseases throughout the world. These emerging new threats remind us of the profound obligation—and the challenge—that we have to take steps today to ensure a sustainable future for our environment, our employees and our business, and for our global community.
    [Show full text]
  • Landfill Gases Landfill Gases Landfill Gas Landfill Gas Collection
    Landfill Gases Landfill Gases Landfill Gas Landfill Gas Collection Landfill gas is created during the For a landfill restoration that prevents Clarke Energy is the authorised distributor and service anaerobic decomposition of organic greenhouse gas from migrating partner for GE Energy’s gas engine division in a growing substances in municipal solid waste into the atmosphere while avoiding number of countries across the world. In addition to (MSW), commercial and industrial offensive smells and smouldering providing high-efficiency, reliable gas engines we combine (C&I) wastes and other fires, the gas must be continuously biodegradable waste streams. extracted under controlled conditions. this with the expertise and resources to deliver unbeatable Depending upon the landfill design Perforated tubes are drilled into the product support. and its management, as well as landfill body and interconnected by waste composition, compaction, a pipework system. Using a blower, Whether your requirement is for the supply of a single gas moisture and several other factors, the gas is sucked from the landfill. engine generator or a complete turnkey power generation thousands of landfills are available A well-designed gas collection facility, we can meet that need. Our ability to add value by worldwide to collect and utilise this system will flexibly capture the gas valuable renewable energy source from various spots and handful high offering an end-to-end service, from initial proposal to for power generation. If landfill gas is temperatures, leachate, condensates reliable long-term maintenance, has led to us becoming a allowed to escape to atmosphere, and air content – thus ensuring a multi-national company with operations in ten countries methane contained within it is a cost-efficient collection as well as across the globe.
    [Show full text]
  • Clarke Energy and INNIO Delivering Flexible Generation to Nova Power & Gas in Romania
    PRESS RELEASE: Clarke Energy and INNIO Delivering Flexible Generation to Nova Power & Gas in Romania • Clarke Energy supplies 4 INNIO Jenbacher J620 gas engines to the peaking station project. • Construction is ongoing at power plant located in Campia Turzii, Cluj County. • The project will improve efficiency and stability of power to the Reif Industrial Park. Bucharest, Romania — April 16th 2021 — Construction has begun in Campia Turzii, where Clarke Energy and INNIO are delivering a natural-gas fuelled flexible generation plant to Nova Power & Gas SRL, part of the E-INFRA Group The innovative peaking station project consists of 4 INNIO Jenbacher J620 natural gas engines with a total electric power of 13.4 MW. Two of the engines installed with “fast start” capabilities will be utilised for electricity peaking, designed to help balance the fluctuating power requirements of the electricity grid. This peaking plant will provide balancing services at the request of the Transport and System Operator at times of peak demand. The remaining two engines supplied will deliver electricity to the Reif Industrial Park and will provide improved energy efficiency and stability in the area. The project was an important first sales win for Clarke Energy’s Romanian team following the company’s entry into the market through the acquisition of TEB Energy Business in November 2019. With two existing customers who have previously switched from cogeneration to peaking plants, Nova Power & Gas SRL is now the third natural-gas fuelled peaking station in Romania, all equipped with INNIO Jenbacher gas engines. Mircea Bica, CEO of Nova Power & Gas commented “Câmpia Turzii project is our first investment in next-generation power plant based on natural gas with increased efficiency and high operational flexibility.
    [Show full text]
  • Sustainable Municipal Waste Management in India
    Sustainable Municipal Waste Management in India White Paper on Removing Barriers to Sustainable Municipal Solid Waste Management using Anaerobic Digestion in India Delhi, India 1 Delhi, India CONTENTS Executive summary ............................................................................................................ 3 Authors ................................................................................................................................ 4 Table of acronyms .............................................................................................................. 5 Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 6 India’s power and energy sector – A Changing Landscape ............................................ 7 Waste and sustainable development goals ...................................................................... 9 Regulatory framework on waste management in india .................................................. 10 Challenges associated with use of bio methanation in treating municipal solid waste20 Policy and regulatory challenges ................................................................................. 20 Financial challenges ...................................................................................................... 21 Project and structural challenges ................................................................................. 22 Technology challenges ................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Key Drivers and Dependencies for V2G
    D1.1 – Key drivers and dependencies for V2G V2GB WP1 Literature review Dr Bilaal Hussain, Consultant – Insights and Evidence 13 November 2018 Key drivers and dependencies for V2G Contents Executive summary .............................................................................................................................................................. 1 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................................................ 3 Project Overview ........................................................................................................................................... 3 Introduction to Work Package 1 ............................................................................................................. 3 2. Identifying the drivers and dependencies ....................................................................................................... 5 3. Literature review ........................................................................................................................................................ 6 System requirements ................................................................................................................................... 6 Reserve power supply ............................................................................................................... 6 Time of use optimisation .........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Remote Power Remote Power Power Generation in Remote Areas Benefits
    Remote Power Remote Power Power Generation in Remote Areas Benefits In large sparsely populated countries — Reduced energy costs Clarke Energy is the authorised distributor and service the main electricity grid is typically — Reduced/eliminated partner for GE Energy’s gas engine division in a growing focused around the major centres of transmission losses number of countries across the world. In addition to habitation. This can cause challenges — Highly efficient technology with providing high-efficiency, reliable gas engines we combine for developers looking to build minimal de-rate in locations with facilities away from these localities. high ambient temperatures this with the expertise and resources to deliver unbeatable In those areas not serviced by a main — Turn-key service reduces product support. electricity grid, locally generated operation and maintenance electricity is ideally suited as a cost- expenses Whether your requirement is for the supply of a single gas effective way of meeting the — Standardised design allows engine generator or a complete turnkey power generation surrounding electricity demand rapid design, easy transportation facility, we can meet that need. Our ability to add value by while reducing significant network and flexible installation installation or upgrade costs. — Modular unit configurations allow offering an end-to-end service, from initial proposal to scalability of installed plant reliable long-term maintenance, has led to us becoming a Gas engine-based power plants capacity and cost-effective multi-national company with operations in ten countries generate stable base-load power redundancy levels for across the globe. Our company prides itself on integrity, locally to the remote installation.
    [Show full text]
  • Market Analysis for Gas Engine Technology in Algeria
    Market Analysis for Gas Engine Technology in Algeria Stéphane Michaut Master of Science Thesis KTH School of Industrial Engineering and Management Energy Technology EGI-2013-049MSC EKV951 Division of Heat & Power SE-100 44 STOCKHOLM Master of Science Thesis EGI-2013-049MSC EKV951 MARKET ANALYSIS FOR GAS ENGINE TECHNOLOGY IN ALGERIA Stéphane Michaut Approved Examiner Supervisor at KTH 2013-06-04 Prof. Torsten Fransson Miroslav Petrov Commissioner Contact person at industry CLARKE ENERGY Ltd., Algeria Didier Lartigue Abstract The objective of this diploma thesis is to investigate the potential of combined heat and power plants based on gas engine technology in Algeria. This market analysis has been performed in order to identify the key markets for the newly created French subsidiary of Clarke Energy Group to expand its business in North Africa. After analyzing the structure of the Algerian energy sector and the potential of each gas engine application, three key sectors were identified. For each sector, a technical and economical analysis was conducted in order to define its potential, its constraints, and the time frame under which they could become mature markets. With a potential of 300 MW, the first targeted sector is related to the national power utility Sonelgaz and consists in small scale power plants with a nominal power output < 20 MW, in which the use of gas engines instead of gas turbines could reduce up to 50% the price of kWh generated over the lifecycle of the plant. With a total of 450 MW, the second market representing a great potential for gas engines development in Algeria is the industrial sector and in particular brick factories, in which cogeneration plants become profitable within 4 years, can save up to 40% of primary energy and generate electricity whose cost of production is 30% lower than the average grid price.
    [Show full text]
  • Sewage Gas Sewage Gases Sewage Gas to Renewable Power Benefits of Sewage Digestion
    Sewage Gas Sewage Gases Sewage Gas to Renewable Power Benefits of Sewage Digestion Wastewater professionals once — Generation of renewable energy Clarke Energy is a multinational specialist in distributed accepted the high costs of from a waste material power generation technology. Our scope ranges from the operating wastewater treatment — Reduction in carbon emissions supply of a gas or diesel fuelled power generation engine, facilities as a consequence of especially compared to aerobic through to the turnkey installation of a multi-engine power meeting their discharge permit sewage treatment requirements. As the cost of energy — Economical onsite electrical plant. Clarke Energy is an authorised distributor and rises and emphasis on renewable power production & reduced service provider for GE’s reciprocating gas engines. energy increases, local authorities transmission losses The business has a strong focus on aftersales support; and municipalities are seeking — Production of soil improver developing in-country resources to service and maintain solutions that save money and meet — Cost effective, proven our facilities, along with original equipment manufacturer renewable requirements. GE technology approved spare parts. Our aim is to provide high quality Energy’s Jenbacher gas engines provide a renewable energy solution products and installations supported by a reliable, that results in long-term savings for accountable and localised after-sales service. Integrity is a wastewater treatment plants core company value and Clarke Energy operates to the (WWTPs). highest international standards of compliance. Benefits of working with Clarke Energy — Quality products, balance of plant and installations products mean high technical and environmental performance hence maximum returns for our customers. — Our installations are backed up by the highest levels of localised aftersales support, meaning maximum reliability of the power generation assets we supply.
    [Show full text]
  • Biomass Task Force Report to Government • October 2005 Standing – Nikki Macleod, David Clayton, Rebecca Cowburn
    Biomass Task Force Report To Government • October 2005 Standing – Nikki MacLeod, David Clayton, Rebecca Cowburn. Seated – John Roberts CBE, Sir Ben Gill CBE, Nick Hartley FOREWORD by Sir Ben Gill The challenge set for the Task Force was to make proposals to optimise the contribution of biomass to a range of targets and policies set by the Government. In setting out the case for biomass we noted that the Energy White Paper contained clear aspirations about renewable energy, security of supply, competitiveness and fuel poverty. The Government also has the important objectives of sustainable development and sustainable farming, forestry and woodland management. Taken together, all of these aims can deliver environmental improvement and also economic benefit particularly in rural and other areas. Our work has shown that the potential of biomass is significant. We have taken the real contribution it can make to the climate change agenda as the primary driver. In putting in place a programme of actions to deliver biomass energy there is a critical need for a strategic approach by the Government to enable the potential to be exploited. We focus on the fact that in spite of more than one-third of primary energy being used for heat there has been a lack of recognition of the role of renewable heat in policy delivery. The approach could be characterised as - no targets; no concerted policy; no strategy; and, limited support for development. So far as DTI’s Energy White Paper is concerned there was a missed opportunity to develop targets for renewable heat and this has perpetuated an inconsistency of approach in Government and in the Regions.
    [Show full text]
  • SECTION 2.Cdr
    Tal IF THE BOFFINS, BRAIN QUESTIONS STILL NEE EDUCATION, TO COM CHALLENGES? IF WE T IN THE TECHNO-ADVA NEEDED TO BRING TH THE FRONT PAGES, FR PUT THESE QUESTION WORDS BY AMANDA WOOD talking technology stimulating science despite the northwest having excellent facilities, it’s time to pr research money is being poured into the south east. If necessity is the mot it makes absolutely no sense at all to do this. the UK putting enough in what is the wealthiest part of the country, housing is According to David Cl costly and therefore scientists’ wage costs are high. Engineering and Phys in the end it simply means that the money for research has yet to strengthen doesn’t go as far as it could do if it were located here.” tradition of funding re excellence across a w Geoffrey Piper,North West Business Leadership Team funding in mainstream is high, but the quantit Whilst high-tech indus refining their technolo to move too far away achieving funding for opportunity for the go But for Geoffrey Piper, Team, funds are being because of the geogra “Despite the Northwe for healthcare and me the South East,” he sa is the wealthiest part o wage costs are high. I doesn’t go as far as it As an example Geoffr of Manchester’s Chris into cancer treatment set-up and running co over Daresbury furthe “This is taxpayers’ mo *pic may change research across the b he added. 36 INDUSTRIAL EVOLUTION: THE SUSTAINABLE SCIENCE EDITION it’s time to pry open the public purse And this may be about to happen.
    [Show full text]