DOCSLIB.ORG

The Democracy for America Movement Noah Porter University of South Florida

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Democracy for America Movement Noah Porter University of South Florida University of South Florida Scholar Commons Graduate Theses and Dissertations Graduate School 2007 Real challenges, virtual challengers: The Democracy for America movement Noah Porter University of South Florida Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd Part of the American Studies Commons Scholar Commons Citation Porter, Noah, "Real challenges, virtual challengers: The eD mocracy for America movement" (2007). Graduate Theses and Dissertations. http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd/2325 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Real Challenges, Virtual Challengers: The Democracy for America Movement by Noah Porter A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Anthropology College of Arts and Sciences University of South Florida Major Professor: S. Elizabeth Bird, Ph.D. Susan Greenbaum, Ph.D. Michael Angrosino, Ph.D. James Cavendish, Ph.D. Navita Cummings James, Ph.D. Date of Approval: April 30, 2007 Keywords: Internet, social movements, politics, elections, Howard Dean © Copyright 2007, Noah Porter Note to Reader: The original of this document contains color that is necessary for understanding the data. The original dissertation is on file with the USF library in Tampa, Florida. Dedication I dedicate this dissertation to my friends, family, and my girlfriend, Jessica Torres, whose love, support, and encouragement kept me going. Thank you. Acknowledgements I owe a debt of gratitude to many people who have directly or indirectly made this dissertation possible. First, I would like to thank Gregory Reck, Diane Mines, Susan Keefe, and Kevin Yelvington, who each served on committees for previous major research projects, which were invaluable experiences in conducting my doctoral research. Second, I would like to thank Susan Greenbaum, Michael Angrosino, James Cavendish, and Navita Cummings James for serving on my doctoral committee, and whose teachings prepared me for this undertaking. Third, I would like to thank Elizabeth Bird for serving as my Major Professor for both my thesis and dissertation research at USF. Fourth, I would like to thank the DFA organizers who allowed me to be a part of their groups, and the members who took time away from their busy schedules to talk to me. Fifth, I would like to thank Alvin Wolfe for his proofreading assistance. Finally, I would like to thank everyone who gave me permission to reprint their images in this dissertation, including: Matthew Kerbel, Ellen Salvador, Stephanie Robinett, Rob Suls, Joanna Raczkiewicz, Eric Compas, Tara Liloia, Matthew Daly, Keri Carpenter, Pamela Corn, Byron LaMasters, Jim Brayton, David Iozzi, Gail Bondi, Lada Adamic, Deborah Cotton, Tracy Van Slyke, and David Sifry. Table of Contents List of Figures.................................................................................................................................... iv List of Tables .................................................................................................................................... vii Abstract............................................................................................................................................ viii Introduction......................................................................................................................................... 1 Chapter 1: Scholarship on Social Movements: Three Historical Strands ........................................ 10 Social Movements across Time and Disciplines.................................................................. 10 Definition of a Social Movement......................................................................................... 11 A History of Social Movement Theory in Sociology .......................................................... 14 Anthropology and Social Movements ................................................................................. 22 Applied Anthropology and Social Movements.................................................................... 32 Discussion/Conclusions....................................................................................................... 40 Chapter 2: Ethnographic Study of a Social Movement: A Few Words on Methodology................. 45 Introduction.......................................................................................................................... 45 Defining Culture .................................................................................................................. 46 Studying Culture: Problems of Heterogeneity and Scale..................................................... 49 A Methodology for the Study of DFA................................................................................. 55 Traditional Ethnography and Social Movements................................................................. 57 Virtual Ethnography and Social Movements....................................................................... 59 Archival Research: Social Movements and Media.............................................................. 64 Archival Research: Social Movements and Finances.......................................................... 67 Text Analysis ....................................................................................................................... 70 Discussion/Conclusions....................................................................................................... 71 Chapter 3: A History of American Democracy, and Democracy for America................................ 75 Voting In America ............................................................................................................... 78 A Knowledge Society? ........................................................................................................ 92 Putting DFA in Context ..................................................................................................... 102 DFA: The First Internet Political Campaign?.................................................................... 103 DFA History: The Rise of Dean for America.................................................................... 108 DFA History: The Collapse of Dean For America ............................................................ 120 DFA History: Democracy for America............................................................................. 127 Discussion/Conclusions..................................................................................................... 133 Chapter 4: What are DFA’s Beliefs? .............................................................................................. 136 Prognosis, Diagnosis and Rationale for Change................................................................ 137 Locus and Amount of Change ........................................................................................... 144 Adversary versus Exemplary ............................................................................................. 147 i Degree Totalistic................................................................................................................ 148 Substantive and Institutional Content ................................................................................ 153 Aggregate Versus Adversary Frames ................................................................................ 157 Foundations for DFA Beliefs............................................................................................ 160 Collective Identity in Cultural Context.............................................................................. 163 Discussion/Conclusion....................................................................................................... 168 Chapter 5: The Role of the Internet in SMO Organization............................................................ 173 Individual-Organizational Members.................................................................................. 173 Formalization and Centralization....................................................................................... 174 Member Absorption........................................................................................................... 184 Scale, Form Diversity and Complexity.............................................................................. 190 Frequencies and Magnitudes.............................................................................................. 193 Financing ........................................................................................................................... 197 Internet Advantages ........................................................................................................... 198 Internet Problems............................................................................................................... 208 Discussion/Conclusion....................................................................................................... 215 Chapter 6: What are causes of DFA?............................................................................................. 218 Sociopolitical Conditions and Opportunities ....................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Journalism's Backseat Drivers. American Journalism
    V. Journalism's The ascendant blogosphere has rattled the news media with its tough critiques and nonstop scrutiny of their reporting. But the relationship between the two is nfiore complex than it might seem. In fact, if they stay out of the defensive crouch, the battered Backseat mainstream media may profit from the often vexing encounters. BY BARB PALSER hese are beleaguered times for news organizations. As if their problems "We see you behind the curtain...and we're not impressed by either with rampant ethical lapses and declin- ing readership and viewersbip aren't your bluster or your insults. You aren't higher beings, and everybody out enough, their competence and motives are being challenged by outsiders with here has the right—and ability—to fact-check your asses, and call you tbe gall to call them out before a global audience. on it when you screw up and/or say something stupid. You, and Eason Journalists are in the hot seat, their feet held to tbe flames by citizen bloggers Jordan, and Dan Rather, and anybody else in print or on television who believe mainstream media are no more trustwortby tban tbe politicians don't get free passes because you call yourself journalists.'" and corporations tbey cover, tbat journal- ists tbemselves bave become too lazy, too — Vodkapundit blogger Will Collier responding to CJR cloistered, too self-rigbteous to be tbe watcbdogs tbey once were. Or even to rec- Daily Managing Editor Steve Lovelady's characterization ognize what's news. Some track tbe trend back to late of bloggers as "salivating morons" 2002, wben bloggers latcbed onto U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Guide to Politics, Media & Elections Campaign Politics
    http://www.ithaca.edu/library/research/elect.html Ask a Librarian Talk Back! Search Home Research Services Library Info Help Guide to Politics, Media & Elections Below the fold: Blogs | Polls | Media Issues | Voter Guides | The Party Line | Campaign Finances Campaign Politics Resources with the most direct focus on it. Only selective articles available for resources marked with $ Hotline & Wake-up CQWeekly$'s Taegan Goddard's Ron Gunzburger's Call provide daily CQPolitics covers Political Wire & Politics1.com -- briefings on politics top stories and Political Insider for short news & "by from The National hosts several campaign news. the numbers." Journal$. campaign bloggers. ElectionCentral, Daily Kos (the most Politico & Conservative Real from Josh visited lefty blog) Washington Clear Politics links Marshall's has strong coverage Independent to news & opinion investigative (& of campaign exemplify from various liberal) Talking politics. independent media. viewpoints. Points Memo. PoliticsHome & Dem Swing State Crooks & Liars is Arianna's Huffington memeorandum Project for best known for Post for lefty news auto-generate congressional political video clips. analysis. political news. races. Political News & Opinion from Main Stream Media Only selective articles available for resources marked with *. Others may require free registration. (The interconnectedness of some can be viewed at Big Ten Conglomerate) TV & Radio: NPR: Politics & Political Newspapers & News Magazines: Junkie | Public NewsRoom, via WEOS Washington Post: Politics & Columnists
    [Show full text]
  • Pace University) Political Journalism 374-001 Fall Semester 2008 Thursday 1:30-4:15 P.M
    1 George Mason University (in collaboration with C-SPAN, the University of Denver, The Cable Center and Pace University) Political Journalism 374-001 Fall Semester 2008 Thursday 1:30-4:15 p.m. (14 sessions) 328 and 455 Innovation Hall Instructor: Steve Klein (with Steve Scully and Chris Malone) POLITICS & THE AMERICAN PRESIDENCY A comprehensive course focusing on the 2008 presidential campaign & the presidency Websites: http://www.C-SPAN.org/Distance_Learning/ http://mason.gmu.edu/~sklein1/ http://webpage.pace.edu/cmalone/ 2 “For most Americans the president is the focal point of public life. Almost every day, they see the president on television newscasts interpreting current events, meeting with foreign dignitaries, proposing policy, or grappling with national problems. This person appears to be in charge, and such recurrent images of an engaged leader are reassuring. But the reality of the presidency rests on a very different truth: presidents are seldom in command and usually must negotiate with others to achieve their goals….Those who invented the presidency in 1787 did not expect the office to become the nation’s central political institution…Students of the presidency commonly divide the office’s developments into two major periods: traditional and modern. In the traditional era, presidential power was relatively limited, and Congress was the primary policymaker. The modern era, on the other hand, is typified by the presidential dominance in the policymaking process and a significant expansion of the president’s powers and resources.” Joseph A. Pika Anthony Maltese Co-Authors, “The Politics of the Presidency” When the Framers sat down in Philadelphia in the summer of 1787 to draft the Constitution, they had little idea of how they were going to design the office of the presidency.
    [Show full text]
  • American Forces Network Radio Programming Decisions (D-2006-117)
    September 27, 2006 Information Technology Management American Forces Network Radio Programming Decisions (D-2006-117) Department of Defense Office of Inspector General Quality Integrity Accountability Additional Copies To obtain additional copies of this report, visit the Web site of the Department of Defense Inspector General at http://www.dodig.mil/audit/reports or contact the Secondary Reports Distribution Unit at (703) 604-8937 (DSN 664-8937) or fax (703) 604-8932. Suggestions for Future Audits To suggest ideas for or to request future audits, contact the Office of the Deputy Inspector General for Auditing at (703) 604-8940 (DSN 664-8940) or fax (703) 604-8932. Ideas and requests can also be mailed to: ODIG-AUD (ATTN: Audit Suggestions) Department of Defense Inspector General 400 Army Navy Drive (Room 801) Arlington, VA 22202-4704 Acronyms AFIS American Forces Information Service AFN American Forces Network AFRTS American Forces Radio and Television Service AFN-BC American Forces Network - Broadcast Center ASD(PA) Assistant Secretary of Defense (Public Affairs) OIG Office of Inspector General Department of Defense Office of Inspector General Report No. D-2006-117 September 27, 2006 (Project No. D2006-D000FI-0103.000) American Forces Network Radio Programming Decisions Executive Summary Who Should Read This Report and Why? This report will be of interest to DoD personnel responsible for the selection and distribution of talk-radio programming to overseas U.S. Forces and their family members and military personnel serving onboard ships. The report discusses the controls and processes needed for establishing a diverse inventory of talk-radio programming on American Forces Network Radio.
    [Show full text]
  • Won't Make Hundreds of Millions of Dollars While Their Employees Are Below the Poverty Line
    won't make hundreds of millions of dollars while their employees are below the poverty line. Hillary said "We are going to take things away from you for the common good." Goddess bless her. We need stations like WTPG to show the masses what we liberals Dlan to do to helD this countw. Jeff Coryell 44118 The progressive community in Columbus is vibrant and growing. More and more Ohioans are seeing through the empty right wing spin and coming around to the common-sense progressive agenda. They need a radio station that respects their point of view! ~oan Fluharty 43068 Sara Richman 01940 Progressive Talk Radio sserves an imponant for the public to hear another side of the issues. Talk radio is "lopsidedly" one sided and as we know, this is extremely dangerous in a democracy. Boston lost their Progressive Talk Radio and I feel as if I lost a friend. Out of habit, when I turn to the station in the car or in the kitchen, I get annoying rumba music. I wish a petition could be started to have another Boston station broadcast Progressive Talk. I khank you, Sara Richman Karl lKav 143232 IProqressive radio is imDonant in Central Ohio because someone has to tell They are more than willing to patronize any advenisers to the channel. arilyn eerman Franken and Schultz have reg Iavis 1230 since it started in Columbus in September 2004. On average, we e listened to AM1230 for eight to ten hours a day (my wife listens to it a 1230, as have many of our friends and acquaintances.
    [Show full text]
  • Pets Are Popular with U.S. Presidents
    Pets Are Popular With U.S. Presidents Most people have heard by now that President-elect Barack Obama promised his two daughters a puppy if he were elected president. Obama called choosing a dog a “major issue” for the new first family. It seems that pets have always been very popular with U.S. presidents. Only two of the 44 presidents -- Chester A. Arthur and Franklin Pierce -- left no record of having pets. Many presidents and their children had dogs and cats in the White House. President and Mrs. Bush have two dogs and a cat living with them -- the dogs are named Barney and Miss Beazley and the cat is India. But there have been many unusual presidential pets as well. President Calvin Coolidge may have had the most pets. NEWS WORD BOX He had a pygmy hippopotamus, six dogs, a bobcat, a goose, a donkey, a cat, two lion cubs, an antelope, and popular issue record wallaby a wallaby. President Herbert Hoover had several dogs pygmy hippopotamus and his son had two pet alligators, which sometimes took walks outside the White House. Caroline Kennedy, the daughter of President John F. Kennedy, had a pony named Macaroni. She would ride Macaroni around the White House grounds. Some pets also worked while at the White House. Pauline the cow was the last cow to live at the White House. She provided milk for President William Taft. To save money during World War I, President Woodrow Wilson brought in a flock of sheep to trim the White House lawn. The flock included a ram named Old Ike.
    [Show full text]
  • Kirkus Online 020115
    Featuring 364 Industry-First Reviews of Fiction, Nonfictionand Children's & Teen KIRKUSVOL. LXXXIII, NO. 3 | 1 FEBruARY 2015 REVIEWS FICTION NONFICTION The American The Intimate Bond People by Brian Fagan by Larry Kramer The author brings The writer and activist's consummate skill to this long-awaited fictional frequently horrifying study history of the AIDS era of humanity's interaction p. 22 with animals. p. 60 INDIE CHILDREN'S & TEEN Brian Kiley goes from Gone Crazy in Alabama late night to the by Rita Williams-Garcia printed page. Delphine and her sisters make a p. 146 welcome return to spend an eye-opening summer in Alabama with Big Ma. p. 135 on the cover David Duchovny may play cool characters on screen, but his debut novel, Holy Cow, reveals that he can also write like a sassy teenage girl (in the voice of a cow, no less). p. 14 from the editor’s desk: Chairman What to Watch for in February HERBERT SIMON BY ClaiBorne Smith # President & Publisher MARC WINKELMAN Chief Operating Officer MEG LABORDE KUEHN Photo courtesy Michael Thad Carter courtesy Photo Editors love to make neat lists of 10s: the 10 best books of the year, the 10 great- [email protected] est movies of all time. There are more than 10 notable books being published Editor in Chief CLAIBORNE SMITH this month (and more than the 16 I mention below), but these are the titles that [email protected] stand out to me. Included are the final lines of our reviews of these books. Managing/Nonfiction Editor ERIC LIEBETRAU Asali Solomon (Disgruntled, fiction, Feb.
    [Show full text]
  • How Businesses Could Feel the Bern
    HOW BUSINESSES COULD FEEL THE BERN A PRIMER ON THE DEMOCRATIC FRONT-RUNNER February 2020 www.monumentadvocacy.com/bizfeelthebern THE FRONT-RUNNER BERNIE 101 As of this week, Senator Bernie Sanders is leading national Democratic THE APPEAL: WHAT POLLING TELLS primary polls, in some cases by double-digit margins. After another early US ABOUT BERNIE’S MOVEMENT state victory in Nevada, he is the betting favorite to become the nominee. Regardless of what comes next in the primary, the grassroots fundraising prowess and early state successes Bernie has shown means he will remain a ANATOMY OF A STUMP SPEECH: formidable force until the Democratic Convention. Dismissed no more than THE CAMPAIGN PROMISES & POLICIES five years ago as a bombastic socialist from a state with fewer than 300,000 voters, Bernie is now leading a national movement that has raised more small dollar donations than any campaign in history, including $25 million in January alone. PROMISES & PAY-FORS: THE BIG- Not unlike President Trump, Bernie uses his massive and loyal following, as TICKET PROPOSALS & WHO WOULD well as his increasingly formidable digital bully pulpit, to target American PAY businesses and announce policies that could soon be the basis for a potential Democratic platform. As businesses work to adjust to the rapidly changing primary dynamics that TARGET PRACTICE: BERNIE’S TOP have catapulted Bernie to frontrunner status, we wanted to provide the basics CORPORATE TARGETS & ATTACKS - a Bernie 101 - to help guide business leaders in understanding the people, organizations and experiences that guide Bernie’s policies and politics. This basic primer also includes many of the Vermont Senator’s favorite targets, ALLIES & ADVISORS: THE ORGS, from companies to institutions to industries.
    [Show full text]
  • Progressive Strategy Summit 2019 - Building Power for the Rest of Us!
    20 19 BUILDING POWER FOR THE REST OF US OCTOBER 24-25 • HYATT REGENCY WASHINGTON ON CAPITOL HILL 400 New Jersey Avenue N.W. Washington, DC 20001 OUR TEAM 2 WELCOME TO OUR PROGRESSIVE COMMUNITY: Thank you for joining us for our Progressive Strategy Summit 2019 - Building Power for the Rest of Us! We are coming together because we believe that even in the midst of a constitutional crisis, there is nothing more powerful than people power. We know that real change won’t come to Washington unless and until we listen to people fighting in Shakopee, Minnesota for Amazon to accommodate workers observing Ramadan, in Kansas City, Missouri for fair, safe and affordable housing, and in Orlando, Florida for living wages. That’s why this Summit includes grassroots activists from all across our great nation, national advocates and strategists, and representatives from the over 100 member-strong Congressional Progressive Caucus. It’s unique to have a caucus co-chaired by a union member, Congressman Mark Pocan, and a grassroots organizer, Congresswoman Pramila Jayapal. We’ll hear from people fighting for change on the front lines and people fighting for change in the halls of Congress. We’ll kick off with a town hall cosponsored by She the People and the Progressive Caucus Action Fund in which women of color grassroots leaders will come together with women of color leaders in Congress to discuss the work ahead to achieve racial, gender, economic, health, LGBTQ and climate justice. We’ll give awards to outstanding progressive grassroots champions and lawmakers. And we’ll keep rolling from there into important discussions about saving our democracy, building a powerful labor movement, listening to black voters, what it takes to win, and so much more.
    [Show full text]
  • Digital Media and the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election Diana Owen Georgetown University
    Digital Media and the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election Diana Owen Georgetown University December 16, 2016 @Meiji University Sponsored by International Exchange Fund Program 1 Outline of Talk • Evolution of new media in American elections • Digital media in the 2016 presidential election • Thoughts about the future of political communication in the U.S. 2 The Advent of the New Media Era • Late 1980s: Entertainment media takes on new political roles • 1992: The Clinton campaign launches the first presidential campaign website, and it is hardly noticed • 1996: Campaigns experiment with “brochureware” style websites, email outreach to voters, and basic discussion boards • 2000: All major and minor presidential candidates have websites, but campaigns are reluctant to make use of the interactive features of the Internet 3 New Media in 2004 • Candidates embrace the interactive features of the web • Blogs proliferate • Citizen journalists become prominent • Howard Dean changed the dynamics of campaigns by using digital media for fundraising and meet-ups • Dean’s campaign was derailed when a video of “The Dean Scream” made during a pep talk to campaign workers after a disappointing result in the Iowa causes went viral on television news • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDwODbl3muE 4 2008: A Landmark New Media Election • Obama’s social media strategy was radical • Developing a candidate’s brand is important. • Obama’s logo: An O representing a rising sun • Obama’s slogan: “Change We Can Believe In” • Donald Trump’s slogan: “Make America Great Again”
    [Show full text]
  • 11 the Lessons of Generation Dean
    11 The Lessons of Generation Dean Amanda Michel Amanda Michel had recently graduated from college when she joined the Dean campaign. She turned out to play a central role in the development of Generation Dean, the official youth outreach arm of the Dean campaign and the most successful campaign effort to organize young people since the McGovern campaign more than thirty years previous to it. Although the story of Generation Dean has not received much broad public attention, it has affected subsequent efforts, helping to transform the tactics and tone of college Democrats and shaping the sensibilities of a generation of future political activists. The story of Generation Dean is a quintessential example of the tactics and techniques that made up the grassroots character of the campaign, welcoming outside efforts and self-presentation on the web as distinct individuals, not as a nameless organization. Another key move Amanda and her coworkers made was to redefine the effort as youth outreach instead of student outreach, thereby greatly expanding the possible audience beyond the traditional groups of students at elite colleges and universities. Amanda Michel, who is now the director of “Off the Bus,” a new media collaboration between the Huffington Post and NewAssignment.Net, emphasizes how the complex if often creative tension between the inside and the outside efforts and events—es- pecially chaotic growth—presented novel organizational challenges of which those planning future campaigns should take heed. Finally, she tells how her experiences on the ground in Iowa gave her a sense of how important non–Internet-based activities remain in political campaigning.
    [Show full text]
  • The Internet and Campaign 2004
    The Internet and Campaign 2004 The internet was a key force in politics last year as 75 million Americans used it to get news, discuss candidates in emails, and participate directly in the political process Embargoed for release at 4pm Eastern, March 6, 2005 Lee Rainie, Director Michael Cornfield, PhD, Senior Research Consultant John Horrigan, PhD, Director of Research PEW INTERNET & AMERICAN LIFE PROJECT 1615 L STREET NW – SUITE 700, WASHINGTON, D.C. 20036 202-419-4500 http://www.pewinternet.org/ Summary of Findings The internet became an essential part of American politics in 2004. Last year was a breakout year for the role of the internet in politics. Fully 75 million Americans – 37% of the adult population and 61% of online Americans – used the internet to get political news and information, discuss candidates and debate issues in emails, or participate directly in the political process by volunteering or giving contributions to candidates. The online political news consumer population grew dramatically from previous election years (up from 18% of the U.S. population in 2000 to 29% in 2004), and there was an increase of more than 50% between 2000 and 2004 in the number of registered voters who cited the internet as one of their primary sources of news about the presidential campaign. The audience for politics online grows… Asked of internet users: Did you ever go online to get news or information about the elections? 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 General public 4% 6% 18% 13% 29% Internet users 22% 15% 33% 22% 52% Source: Pew Research Center for The People & The Press and Pew Internet & American Life Project surveys.
    [Show full text]