arXiv:astro-ph/0610953v1 31 Oct 2006 trH 47 A u,V=60,ahg rprmo- proper high a 6.0), = V O9.5V Aur, the ( by (AE tion illuminated 34078 is HD It star 1999). 1958, (Herbig riga 5 c h ihln oH 47 scnieal red- considerably is of 34078 distance HD a to at optical sightline 1958; ( dened 2005), The the (Herbig al. and Boiss´e present pc. et 450 2004; star at al. The cospatial et a France roughly in 2001). are region al. nebula et star-forming (Bagnuolo Orion years ago million 2.5 the approximately interaction from binary-binary ejected star hsc,Uiest fTrno 0S.Gog tet Toron Street, George St. 3H8 60 M5S Toronto, of University physics, ( violet-blue the molec- in and variation. observations atomic tar- line of line years a geometric absorption ular fifty sightline interstellar combines present (1999) of 34078 The Herbig studies HD for the material interacts. get made nebular now has the it configuration encountered which recently with only has fore- of it free 2004). be al. to et (France appear attenuation regions ground nebular extended the aoaoy aionaIsiueo ehooy ne co a under Technology, NASA. of with Institute California Laboratory, sub- elescope T CN Space of and vari- Spitzer scale CH recently, interstellar length More of AU. the density 1450 column on the of limit in ISM ations upper the an in structure set to A) ˚ 2 rpittpstuigL Journal using Astrophysical typeset the Preprint in appear To C45i neiso/eeto euai Au- in nebula emission/reflection an is 405 IC h ag rnvrevlct ftesa niae that indicates star the of velocity transverse large The 1 OEAYBWSOKADMDIFAE MSINVRAIN R VARIATIONS EMISSION MID-INFRARED AND SHOCK BOW COMETARY A urn drs:Cnda nttt o hoeia Astro Theoretical for Institute Canadian Address: Current ae npr nosrain aewt h the the with made observations on part in Based ≈ E otiuin,soigsvrlaoai msinbnsbten6 between bands emission aromatic several showing contributions, ()pr oainleiso ie fH of lines emission rotational pure S(1) ujc headings: Subject h eua mgn eel httemrhlg sbn dependent, H band is features, morphology emission the that aromatic reveals imaging nebular The ue lmns rvdn vdnefreeae uttemperatur dust 70 elevated betwee for to evidence interaction 24 providing the at filaments, by emission outer created of 34078, ratio HD The star, O9.5V runaway (8.0 IRAC 70 The and filaments. (24 bands MIPS elescope two T Space Spitzer o h rmtcifae etrs H state ionization features. infrared the aromatic on the constraints for provide spectra low-dispersion pcrm bandwith obtained spectrum, eemndfo h bevdln tegh.A vrg T(H average An strengths. line observed the from determined o diinlnnuiomectto yU htn nteitner intense measureme the direct in by photons supported UV is hypothesis by photoexcitation excitation The non-uniform additional for 0msy;Bau ogn15)runaway 1954) Morgan & Blaauw mas/yr; 40 ( B epeetnwifae bevtoso h msinrflcinn emission/reflection the of observations infrared new present We − V .3 adlie l 99 however, , 1989) al. et Cardelli 0.53; = ) 1. A Rcie 06Ags 1 eie 06Otbr1;Accepted 18; October 2006 Revised 31; August 2006 (Received hc soeae yteJtPropulsion Jet the by operated is which , INTRODUCTION T E tl mltajv 6/22/04 v. emulateapj style X ut—IM oeue S:idvda I 0)—rflcinnble— nebulae reflection — 405) (IC individual ISM: — molecules ISM: — dust ei France Kevin ISM eateto hsc n srnm,JhsHpisUnivers Hopkins Johns Astronomy, and Physics of Department USE F nrrdiae ntefu RCbns(.,45 .,ad8.0 and 5.8, 4.5, (3.6, bands IRAC four the in images Infrared . µ BEVTOSO D308ADI 405 IC AND 34078 HD OF OBSERVATIONS )adMP mgn hw vdneo o hc soitdwt th with associated shock bow a of evidence shows imaging MIPS and m) µ 2 )aecmlmne yISsetocp 5–30 – (5 spectroscopy IRS by complemented are m) 40N hre tet atmr,M 21218 MD Baltimore, Street, Charles N. 3400 n uteiso.Nblrsetocp sue oqatf thes quantify to used is spectroscopy Nebular emission. dust and , . 2 tpa .MCnls,adRxn .Lupu E. Roxana and McCandliss, R. Stephan , oapa nteAtohsclJournal Astrophysical the in appear To λ µ 40–4900 – 3400 shge nteimdaevcnt fH 47 hni the in than 34078 HD of vicinity immediate the in higher is m 2 oainltmeaue ftetobih eua lmnsare filaments nebular bright two the of temperatures rotational 2 o ON to, n tmcfiesrcuelnso e ,adA.The Ar. and S, Ne, of lines structure fine atomic and , ntract ABSTRACT - 0 U oad D308(olnee l 03.A 2003). al. ( Explorer et using size (Rollinde 2005) set- Spectroscopic substructure al. 34078 sightline, (Boiss´e the et study HD this on similar towards on limit observed AU) upper been 200 smaller have a %) ting 20 – (10 yFac ta.(04.Te rsn spectroscopic a H present fluorescent and They scattering presented dust are far-UV (2004). of dust field study and al. gas et radiation nebular France UV the by the and 34078 between HD interaction of observa- the local Additional the of 2005). by al. tions (Boiss´e pumping et field fluorescent UV for stellar evidence are level) oe-hpd opc H produce can compact winds supersonically stellar comet-shaped, moves a radia- strong for star stellar a and/or host massive medium, pressure candidate interstellar a tion ambient a As an it through makes shock. 34078 bow HD of motion eua utgan a lobe eetdby detected been also has grains IRAS dust nebular nebula. the in lines sion oeua yrgnasrto ie maueet up (measurements lines to excited absorption of Detections hydrogen HD nebula. between molecular surrounding interaction the for and evidence 34078 find also They AU. of variation 98 a ue ta.19) 60 A McCray & Buren (van 1990). gas in al. et molecular Buren observed van shocked 1988; by nuprlmto h oeua yrgn(H hydrogen molecular the on limit upper an oig-rsoe l 97 dnie C45a a as 405 IC identifies region. shock 1997) bow potential al. et Noriega-Crespo vdnefritrcinbtentesa and star the between interaction for Evidence v 0, = vnBrne l 95.Tehg proper high The 1995). al. et Buren (van J 2 ) 1adtnaiedtcin pt the to up detections tentative and 11 = s(T es ≤ ∼ 14 – ftelremlclsresponsible molecules large the of % osriigtesaet e esof tens few a to scale the constraining 5%, to h a-VH far-UV the of nt h tradnblrmaterial. nebular and star the n IRAS 0 sifre,wt evidence with inferred, is K 400 bl C45otie ihthe with obtained 405 IC ebula ihvrigcnrbtosfrom contributions varying with d µ 06Otbr27) October 2006 & dainfil fH 34078. HD of field adiation 1 ,teS5,S3,S2,and S(2), S(3), S(5), the m, 0K ntesokregion. shock the in K) 90 ity, as(a ue ta.1995; al. et Buren (van maps ( USE F VAE IN EVEALED µ )o w nebular two of m) bevtoshsset has observations ) II 2 fluorescence einsurrounded region µ Infrared: rUltraviolet ar F )and m) PI ZER IT SP µ 2 excess m e e column ) 2 v emis- 2 = ≤ 2 France et al.
In this paper, we present the first direct imaging of the 6.2 µm C – C feature (and more generally, the 6.2, 7.7, bow shock around HD 34078 with the Spitzer Space and 8.6 µm bands) is due to the dipole moment pro- Telescope-IRAC and MIPS. We also use MIPS data duced by a change in charge distribution during ioniza- to study the nebular dust emission, characterize the tion (Peeters et al. 2002). The carriers of the AEFs fall spectroscopic properties of aromatic emission features in the middle of the molecular mass distribution in reflec- (AEFs) and H2 using nebular observations made with tion nebulae and H II regions (which we will group under the Spitzer-IRS, and put these new observations in con- the broad heading of photodissociation regions; PDRs). text with existing studies of IC 405. §1.1 provides back- H2, residing at the lower limit of this distribution, ground information on the diagnostic properties of AEFs, makes up the majority of the molecular mass in these ob- H2, and dust in diffuse nebulae. In §2, we describe the jects (Hollenbach & Tielens 1997; Shaw et al. 2005). H2 new Spitzer data, and introduce supporting far-UV spec- is seen to emit from far-UV to the mid-IR wavelengths, troscopy from FUSE. An analysis of the infrared (IR) excited by both UV photons (i.e. - fluorescence) and imaging and spectroscopy is given in §3. In §4, we dis- thermal processes, such as collisions and shocks. Detec- cuss the structure of the bow shock region, present de- tion of the UV emission lines of H2 is one clear indication terminations of the H2 rotational and dust temperatures, of photoexcitation. H2 dissociates in environments with and analyze spatial variations in AEF carrier ionization temperatures corresponding to the excited electronic lev- across the nebular filaments. Our findings and a sum- els that give rise to the UV lines (Shull & Beckwith mary of the observations are presented in §5. 1982). The emission nebula IC 63 is the prototypical ob- ject for PDR studies of fluorescent H2. The far-UV spec- 1.1. AEFs, H2, and Dust Emission in Photodissociation trum has been well-studied (Witt et al. 1989; Hurwitz Regions 1998; France et al. 2005), confirming stellar continuum AEFs have been found to be ubiquitous in the mid-IR photons as the excitation source of the observed emis- spectra (3 – 20 µm) of reflection nebulae and H II regions sion. Far-UV H2 emission lines in IC 405 have been ob- (see van Dishoeck 2004 for a recent review). AEFs are served (France et al. 2004), and these observations will seen as broad bands in the ISO-SWS/ISO-CAM-CVF be discussed below. and Spitzer-IRS wavelength ranges, with lines com- Near-IR observations of the rovibrational emission plexes centered on 3.3, 6.2, 7.7, 8.6, 11.2, and 12.7 µm. lines of H2 can also be used to constrain the molec- These features are usually attributed to a superposition ular excitation mechanism. Collisional processes can of C – C and C – H vibrational modes in a distribu- populate the lowest excited vibrational states of the tion of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) consist- molecule (v = 1 and 2), but the fluorescent cascade ing of tens to hundreds of C-atoms (Schutte et al. 1993; associated with the electronic excitation of H2 by UV van Dishoeck 2004). However, discrepancies between as- photons is the only mechanism (ignoring excitation by tronomical emission features and laboratory PAH spectra non-thermal electrons) available to populate higher vi- exist, preventing a conclusive identification of the exact brational states (v > 2) as the molecules dissociate carrier of the AEFs (Gordon et al. 2006 and references at kinetic temperatures proportional to these higher therein). The carrier population that gives rise to the vibrational levels (Shull & Beckwith 1982). Ratios of observed mid-IR bands (also called Aromatic Infrared these excited vibrational states can be compared with Bands; Verstraete et al., 2001) spans a range of sizes model predictions to determine the excitation mecha- and ionization states. The size distribution is thought nism (Black & van Dishoeck 1987). Near-IR line ra- to be regulated by the hardness of the illuminating ra- tios indicate UV excitation in IC 63 (Luhman et al. diation field (Verstraete et al. 2001) while the aromatic 1997), the bright reflection nebulae NGC 2023 and NGC molecule ionization balance is controlled by the strength 7023 (Martini et al. 1999; Takami et al. 2000), and on of the ultraviolet (UV) radiation field and the electron larger scales in molecular clouds (Luhman & Jaffe 1996). density (Bakes et al. 2001; Bregman & Temi 2005). The Collisions contribute to the rovibrational excitation of relative strengths and spectral profiles of the major AEFs H2 in dense molecular clouds (Kristensen et al. 2003) reflect the physical state of the carrier population in a and regions where shocks play an important role, such given environment. as planetary nebulae (Kastner et al. 1996; Lupu et al. Variations in the spectral features of the AEFs 2006). The pure rotational emission lines of H2, ac- can be used to quantify the response of the carrier cessible only in the mid-IR, give diagnostic information molecules to different radiation and density environ- about the molecular gas temperature in PDRs. Ra- ments (Bakes et al. 2001). These variations can be stud- tios of these lines have been used to derive temper- ied by comparing a sample of nebulae (Verstraete et al. atures in star-forming regions (Rosenthal et al. 2000; 2001), at different locations within a single ob- Allers et al. 2005), PDRs (Thi et al. 1999; Habart et al. ject (Verstraete et al. 1996; Hony et al. 2001), or in the 2004), and external galaxies (Valentijn & van der Werf diffuse interstellar medium (Boulanger et al. 2000). The 1999; Armus et al. 2004). C – H emission features at 3.3 and 11.2 µm are found Dust grains populate the upper end of the molecu- to be well correlated over a range of physical conditions, lar mass distribution in PDRs. Grains are observed however the relative strengths of the C – H and C – C fea- through their thermal emission in the mid/far-IR (Schnee tures are observed to vary with environment (Hony et al. et al. 2005 and references therein) and in the atten- 2001;van Dishoeck2004). TheratioofaC–CtoaC–H uation and scattering of ultraviolet and visible pho- feature (6.2/11.2 µm for example) reflects the ionization tons (Cardelli et al. 1989; Witt et al. 1993; Burgh et al. state as C – C band strengths are stronger in ionized 2002; Draine 2003). IRAS observations of PDRs find aromatic carriers while C – H bands display the oppo- that grain emission is spatially correlated with near-IR site behavior (Uchida et al. 2000). The increase in the H2 emission (Luhman & Jaffe 1996). Jansen et al. (1994, A Spitzer Study of IC 405 3
1200 B
1000 FUSE Pos4 1000 Pos4 IRAC − 8.0 µm 800 800
600 A* 600 A A** 400 FUSE Pos3 Arcseconds Arcseconds 400 Pos3 "Shell"
200 200
0 0 Pos2 Pos1 Pos2 Pos1
−400 −200 0 200 400 −400−300−200−100 0 100 200 Arcseconds Arcseconds
Fig. 1.— Left: Optical image of IC 405 from France et al. (2004). Right: Post-BCD 8.0 µm IRAC images of IC 405, scaled to highlight the rich nebular structure. The origin is the position of the illuminating, runaway O9.5 star, HD 34078. The main nebular regions studied in this work are labeled A and B. White overlays represent far-UV spectrograph apertures (the squares are the FUSE LWRS slit and the rectangles represent a rocket-borne spectrograph; France et al. 2004). At the cores of the bright filaments, discrete features contribute ≤ 40% of the nebular emission at 8 µm.
1995) present observations of IC 63, where dust emission sented in France et al. (2004), where H2 fluorescence was is coincident with the region of peak H2 emission (at UV observed above the level of dust scattered light (FUSE ′ ′′ and IR wavelengths) as well as CO and other molecules. Pos3: RA = 5h16m30.21s, δ = +34◦24 56.4 and FUSE ′ ′′ This correlation would be expected as dust grains are Pos4: RA = 5h16m18.64s, δ = +34◦32 25.2 , J2000; see thought to be the primary site of H2 formation in the also §2.2). The Infrared Array Camera (IRAC) observed interstellar medium (Cazaux & Tielens 2002, 2004). Ad- the nebula in mapping mode on 2005 September 23, with ditionally, photoelectric emission from small grains is an an exposure time of 12 seconds per frame, for a total important source of heating in PDRs (Abel et al. 2005). integration time approximately 825 seconds. Details of Habart et al. (2004) provide observational evidence for a the IRAC instrument can be found in Fazio et al. (2004). correlation between AEFs and H2, which they propose The IRAC pointings covered the northern nebula in all is related to H2 formation on PAHs. With the wealth of four bands (r16033792), with the 4.5/8.0 µm channel ac- observational evidence that these molecules are interre- quiring data of HD 34078 and the associated bow shock lated in PDRs, it follows naturally to study this group (r16033280, Figure 1). The images were reduced with as a whole. the data processing pipeline (S14.0.0) provided by the In this work, we further address the physical conditions Spitzer Science Center (SSC). Analysis was performed of the AEF carriers and their relationship with H2 and on the post-Basic Calibrated Data (BCD) products. dust grains by presenting new observations of the emis- Using the mapping mode on the Infrared Spectrograph sion/reflection nebula IC 405 made with Spitzer. We use (IRS, Houck et al. 2004), we obtained spectra clustered a combination of imaging and spectroscopy to constrain around previous FUSE observations Pos3 (r16033024) the variation in aromatic carrier properties with chang- and Pos4 (r16033536). IRS programs were carried out ing radiation and dust environment through the nebula. on 2006 March 17 and 19 with a total exposure time Our aim is to present new IR observational characteris- of ∼ 9600 seconds. Data at all IRS wavelengths were tics of large molecules, dust grains, and H2 in the unique acquired through both the high and low-resolution aper- PDR environment of IC 405, for comparison with previ- tures (SL, SH, LL, and LH). The spatial coverage of the ous far-UV observations. low-resolution aperture scan allows us to correlate spec- tral variations with nebular morphology, hence this work 2. OBSERVATIONS will focus on an analysis of the low-resolution (Short- 2.1. Spitzer Low, 5 – 15µm; R = 60 – 130) data. Short-High and Spitzer observations of IC 405 (Program ID 20434) Long-Low spectroscopic data were used as supporting were made at positions coincident with the UV data pre- observations. The post-BCD (pipeline version S13.2.0) 4 France et al.
TABLE 1 Mid and far-IR photometry of bow shock region.
a b Position RA (2000) δ (2000) F8 F24 F70 Td ( h m s) (◦ ′ ′′) (Jy) (Jy) (Jy) (K)
SE 05 16 20.98 +34 18 52 0.508 ± 0.083 3.435 ± 0.229 1.945 ± 0.169 83.93 ± 2.06 SC 05 16 18.42 +34 18 58 0.805 ± 0.103 4.286 ± 0.255 1.904 ± 0.167 88.76 ± 2.24 SW 05 16 16.83 +34 18 48 0.675 ± 0.094 3.347 ± 0.225 1.805 ± 0.162 84.85 ± 2.16
aShock pointings were defined from analysis of the 24 µm MIPS data obtained near HD 34078. b Dust temperatures were derived from the ratio of 24 to 70 µm flux density, F24/F70. This temperature should be considered a lower limit due to the saturation of the 24 µm map. reduced one-dimensional spectra were tagged according to the central aperture position for registration with the TABLE 2 associated filaments observed in the imaging. As the “on- 8 µm IRAC photometry of nebular filaments. filament” nebular positions filled most of the Short-Low Position Program RA (2000) δ (2000) Fluxa aperture, analyzing the full-slit extraction at all point- ◦ ′ ′′ ( h m s) ( ) (Jy) ings yielded information about both the spectral charac- teristics and the slit-filling fraction. A r16033280 05 16 30.97 +34 25 04 0.466 ± 0.079 We also obtained mosaic maps of IC 405 in the three A∗ r16033280 05 16 19.84 +34 25 18 0.385 ± 0.072 bands of the Multiband Imaging Photometer for Spitzer A∗∗ r16033280 05 16 15.53 +34 23 57 0.573 ± 0.088 (MIPS). A description of the MIPS instrument is given B r16033792 05 16 16.88 +34 32 21 0.543 ± 0.085 in Rieke et al. (2004). The data (r16032768) were ob- tained on 2006 February 28. The post-BCD scan maps a (S13.2.0) at 24 and 70 µm (Figures 2 and 3) were used The 8.0 µm images contain contributions from AEFs, H2, to perform photometry of several nebular filaments and and [Ar II]. The 7.7 AEF contributes between 30 – 40% of the complement the imaging at shorter wavelengths. The 24 8.0 µm band flux in the region of peak filament brightness. and 70 µm maps are of high quality, but we note the inner 10 – 25′′ of the bow shock region near HD 34078 is likely saturated on the 24 µm Si:As array. The 160 µm the subregions of interest. A composite of the 8.0 µm map contains gaps that make measuring long-wavelength images is shown in Figure 1. These data provided a refer- photometry very challenging, we will focus on the shorter ence frame for all of the image and spectroscopic analysis wavelength MIPS channels here. The 24 and 70 µm scans ′ ′ ′ ′ described below. The overall morphology of the 8.0 µm covers roughly 8 × 54 and 5 × 52 , respectively, both images shows the brightest structures seen in the three- centered on FUSE Pos4. color optical image3, displayed in Figure 1 for comparison 2.2. FUSE with the IRAC data. The “shell” structure seen to the East/Northeast of HD 34078 with a radius of ∼ 400′′ ob- IC 405 was observed by FUSE on 2003 March 11 – 13 served in DSS images and in Plate IV of Herbig (1958) as part of the D127 guest observer program (France et al. is observed at 8.0 µm. 2004). Spectroscopy was obtained in the FUSE far- Two bright nebular regions were chosen for analysis in UV bandpass (905 – 1187 A)˚ through the low-resolution this work, based on previous ultraviolet studies. Fila- (30′′ × 30′′; ∆λ ≈ 0.33A)˚ aperture (Moos et al. ments A and B were part of the France et al. (2004) far- 2000). The data acquired at positions Pos3 and Pos4 UV study of IC 405. Data acquired at these positions show H2 emission lines and were used to guide the showed a combination of fluorescent H2 emission and Spitzer observations presented in this work. We use the dust-scattered starlight. These observations provided de- LiF2a (1087 – 1179A)˚ channel to measure the strength tection of continuum pumped H2 emission where the ro- of the strongest far-UV band of continuum pumped H2 tational substructure was spectroscopically resolved at fluorescence, λ ∼ 1100A,˚ for comparison with the pure wavelengths shortward of Lyα. Filament A is broken rotational emission lines in the IRS bandpass (§4.2). The up into three subregions: the main A knot with exist- FUSE data were obtained in time-tagged mode and re- ing UV spectroscopy; ∼175′′ to the west, Filament A∗ duced with the CalFUSE pipeline, version 2.2.3, with is a clumpy feature located at the end of the Filament errors determined from the associated count rate plots. A structure; and Filament A∗∗ to the southwest was the Both positions were observed for roughly 12.5 ksec. brightest feature in the 70 µm data (these nebular fea- tures are labeled in Figure 1). The brightest features in 3. ANALYSIS AND RESULTS: IMAGING AND SPECTROSCOPY the optical image are related to the regions containing Filaments A and B at infrared wavelengths. Filaments The 8.0 µm IRAC images showed the best combination A and B are also the dominant features in the 6300 – of S/N (∼6 – 38 for the faintest to the brightest nebular ′′ features), spatial resolution (.2 ; Fazio et al. 2004), and 3 T.A. Rector, http://antwrp.gsfc.nasa.gov/apod/ap011204.html; nebular structure with a field-of-view that covered all of also presented in Figure 1 of France et al. (2004). A Spitzer Study of IC 405 5
MIPS − 24 µm MIPS − 70 µm B
1000 B OFF ON IRS−SL 1000 Mapping
* A A * 500 A** A A ON OFF Arcseconds Arcseconds 500 A**
0
0
−300−200−100 0 100 200 −100 0 100 200 300 Arcseconds Arcseconds
Fig. 2.— Post-BCD 24 µm map of IC 405. The region near Fig. 3.— Post-BCD 70 µm scan of IC 405. The position of HD HD 34078 (0,0) shows the wake-like morphology, suggesting the 34078 is at the origin. The Filament A∗∗ region is the strongest presence of a bow shock as the star traverses the ambient nebu- feature in the 70 µm data. lar material. The bow shock region at 8 and 24 µm can be seen enlarged in Figures 4 and 5. The overlays on Filament A and B represent the IRS-SL scan regions, with the ON/OFF convention used in Figures 10 and 12 indicated. (The IRS-SL scans are shown in more detail in Figures 8 and 9.) 6750 A˚ photographic images presented in Herbig (1958; Plate III), where line emission from Hα, [N II], and [S II] is the primary source of the nebular brightness. The following subsections are divided into imaging and spectroscopic results. The imaging is presented first, starting near HD 34078 and moving out into the north- ern filaments. An analysis of the IRS spectroscopy fol- 6 France et al.
Fig. 6.— IRAC 4.5 µm image of the HD 34078 region with a logarithmic intensity scale to enhance the nebular emission. The Fig. 4.— IRAC 8.0 µm blow up of the bow shock region, scaled “cirrus” features described in §3.1 are identified. The 4.5 µm band to illustrate the shock structure. The shock subregions are labeled shows these structures at a higher contrast than the shell structure Shock-East (SE ), Shock-Center (SC ), and Shock-West (SW ). Pho- seen in Figure 1. tometry of the subregions is given in Table 1.
lows, we determine the relative contribution of the neb- ular species to the IRAC images and observe position- dependent line strengths. We note that the IRAC band overlap regions and spectroscopic programs were cen- tered on Filaments A and B, thus six-band imaging and spectroscopy do not exist for all IC 405 subregions. A brief comparison between the imaging and spectroscopy of the different regions is given in §3.3.
3.1. Imaging: IRAC and MIPS Bow Shock - The wake feature seen clearly in the 8.0 µm IRAC (Figure 4) and 24 µm MIPS (Figure 5) im- ages is thought to be enhanced dust emission produced by the interaction of HD 34078 with the ambient nebular medium (van Buren & McCray 1988). The bullet-tip in- teraction region is seen most clearly in the 24 µm images (despite the saturation of the brightest ridge), and three positions were chosen for analysis. Moving from left to right on the image blow-ups, they are labeled Shock-East (SE), Shock-Center (SC ), and Shock-West (SW ). The 8.0 µm data show an emission arc of diameter ∼ 75′′ with an enhancement of factors of > 5 (in units of MJy sr−1) relative to the interfilament medium. The emission arc has a brightness peak 10 – 20′′ to the northeast of the stellar coordinates. The 24 µm image shows a similar ′′ Fig. 5.— MIPS 24 µm blow up of the shock region, scaled 75 arc, with higher contrast emission in the outer edges to illustrate the shock structure. The stellar position is at the of the arc. The 24 µm data also suggest a connection origin. The inner 10 – 25′′ near HD 34078 in the direction of stellar motion (North, +y) is saturated at 24 µm, indicative of the high between the shocked material and the cirrus features dis- temperature of the grains in the shock region. The dashed lines cussed below. The 24 µm flux density transitions from indicate the location and direction of the spatial profiles presented the cometary arc into the cirrus features to the east of in Figure 7. 24 µm photometry of the shock region is given in the star more smoothly than at 8 µm. Both the 8 and 24 Table 1 µm images show a clear spatial offset between the posi- tion of HD 34078 and the peak of the infrared emission. A Spitzer Study of IC 405 7
350 ble 1. SE, SC , and SW are labeled in Figures 4 and 5, South North South North South North 300 with dashed lines representing the cuts in Figure 5. The −1 VTAN ~ 100 km s 24 µm profiles show the dominance of the bow shock, 250 ′′
) again noting that the peak brightness regions (10 – 25
−1 S 200 E from HD 34078) are likely saturated. The position of HD 150 (MJy sr SC SW 34078 is indicated with the dotted line at 0 and the direc- 100 m Surface Brightness tion of stellar motion through the nebula is labeled in the µ 50 24 center panel. The SE profile shows the largest breadth 0 due to its association with the cirrus-like structures. The 70 µm profiles show an enhancement at the shocked re- 150 gion, but rise to a maximum at the intersection of the ) ∗∗ ′′ −1 nebular arm containing Filament A (y ≈ 400 , marked 100
SE ** SC ** SW ** with the dashed line in Figure 7). The second peak in (MJy sr ′′ 50 the 70 µm SE and SC profiles near 520 are associated m Surface Brightness ∗ µ with the intersection of Filament A . We also observe Filament A Filament A Filament A 70 0 an additional peak at the intersection of the Filament 0 200 400 0 200 400 0 200 400 Position (Arcsec) B arm, but we do not show a comparison as the image registration was of poorer quality. Fig. 7.— Spatial profiles of the 24 and 70 µm MIPS scans of the southern region of IC 405. The 24 µm data have been convolved Flux ratio (F24/F70) profiles were made using these ex- to a resolution of ≈ 18′′ for comparison with the 70 µm map. The tractions. These profiles were interpolated onto a com- direction and magnitude of the stellar motion through IC 405 is mon spatial grid (≈ 4.7′′/pixel) before comparison. The indicated. The 24 µm profiles outline the shock region while the registration in y was the primary source of uncertainty 70 µm cuts show a weaker peak near the stellar position and a maximum near the Filament A∗∗ region. for these comparisons. These ratios were used to derive the dust temperature profile in the shocked region, dis- cussed in §4.1.1. Photometry of the SE, SC , and SW regions was performed on the 8, 24, and 70 µm images TABLE 3 following the procedure described below. The photomet- 24 µm MIPS photometry of nebular filaments. ric values for the shock regions are listed in Table 1. The HD 34078 Region – The largest difference be- Position Program RA (2000) δ (2000) Fluxa tween the 8.0 µm and optical images of IC 405 are the ( h m s) (◦ ′ ′′) (Jy) cirrus-like sheets of emission that are seen to the north- east of HD 34078 (∆ x = -250 – 0′′, ∆ y = 0 – 300′′ A r16032768 05 16 30.99 +34 25 03 1.045 ± 0.126 in Figures 1, 4, 5, and 6). This cirrus structure extends A∗ r16032768 05 16 19.70 +34 25 18 0.984 ± 0.123 ∗∗ along filaments roughly from HD 34078 into the region A r16032768 05 16 15.52 +34 23 58 1.175 ± 0.134 containing Filament A∗∗. It may be possible to observe B r16032768 05 16 18.17 +34 32 27 0.892 ± 0.117 this substructure in the optical with high spatial reso- lution and a narrow field of view, imaging the nebula aIRS Long-Low spectra were analyzed to assess the emission without strong contamination from the central star (i.e. line contribution to the 24 µm band flux. Discrete lines were - HST -ACS). found to contribute less than 8% of emission in the 21.5 – 26.2 These cirrus sheets are the strongest features in the µm bandpass. 4.5 µm IRAC images of this region (Figure 6). The re- gion of patchy emission (-330′′,-75′′) seen at 8.0 µm is observed with a lower relative strength at 4.5 µm. MIPS 24 µm imaging of this region finds similar relative inten- The 4.5 µm IRAC image is dominated by the saturated sities as those seen at 4.5 µm, strong cirrus sheets to the core of HD 34078 (Figure 6), but asymmetries in the northeast of the star, with much lower relative intensity PSF suggest that an enhancement exists in the direction features coincident with the patchy 8.0 µm and “shell” of stellar motion. An arc is detected in the 70 µm MIPS structure. This suggests that there is a common dust observations, which can be seen faintly in Figure 3. component responsible for the cirrus emission seen at We measured the variation in dust profile across the 4.5, 8.0, and 24 µm, while there is an additional compo- interaction region by taking spatial cuts through the 24 nent contributing to the 8.0 µm flux in the “shell” region. and 70 µm MIPS data, intersecting the SE, SC , and SW This additional 8.0 µm component is most likely a com- positions. In order to make a fair comparison, the 24 µm bination of an increased contribution from the 7.7 and data were convolved to a resolution of 18′′ and rebinned 8.6 µm AEFs. One of the results of the IRS scans of the to the dimensions of the 70 µm scan. The images were bright filaments, discussed below, is that the percentage then aligned with a ∼ 3◦ rotation to account for space- contribution of AEFs to the total flux in a given imaging craft roll orientation and registered with their WCS data band increases in the brightest knots. We propose that using a combination of image analysis tools (custom IDL the regions showing an enhanced brightness in the 8.0 codes as well as ds9 from the Chandra X-Ray Center and µm IRAC band relative to the dust emission at 4.5 and the SSC data retrieval program Leopard). We found that 24 µm are favorable for survival of the AEF carriers. the registration was accurate to roughly 2′′ in x (∼ RA) Filament A - Filaments A∗ and A∗∗ were covered by and 10′′ in y (∼ Dec). These profiles are shown in Figure all four IRAC imaging fields and the MIPS scans at both 7 running from south to north (left to right on the figure), 24 and 70 µm. A portion of Filament A was lost at the intersecting the SE, SC , and SW coordinates listed in Ta- edge of the 70 µm map, but covered in all other bands 8 France et al.
Fig. 8.— Six-color imaging of the Filament A, A∗, and A∗∗ regions. Data from the four IRAC bands and two MIPS bands are shown at their original resolution, with intensity scales intended to display the nebular structure. The black regions on the 3.6 and 70 µm images were not observed. The overlays shown on the 8.0 µm image represent the IRS-SL aperture scan direction and the ON/OFF convention used in this work. This spectroscopy indicates that the AEFs make an important contribution to the nebular emission at positions of peak filament brightness.
(Figure 8). The 3.6 µm images of this region display a 8 and 24 µm images with an effective resolution of about peak along the star-facing edge of the clouds containing 18′′, comparable to that of the 70 µm map (Rieke et al. the filaments. The filaments are seen at 4.5 µm, though 2004). The convolved images were integrated over a dis- faint compared to the cirrus features seen near the star at crete number of pixels and multiplied by the solid angle this wavelength. The 4.5 µm images were the weakest (in subtended by each pixel, 3.4 × 10−11 sr pixel−1 at 8 µm, units of MJy sr−1) in our filamentary imaging. We found 1.5 × 10−10 sr pixel−1 at 24 µm, and 5.8 × 10−10 sr the 4.5, 5.8, and 8.0 µm bands to be tracing the same pixel−1 at 70 µm. spatial regions, with the 5.8 and 8.0 bands enhanced rela- We chose the photometric extraction regions based on tive to the 4.5 µm. Again, this is attributed to additional the sizes of the filaments in the 8.0 µm data. We found flux from AEFs in the 5.8 and 8.0 µm bands. that the central cores of all four filament positions could The 24 and 70 µm MIPS images of Filament A show be contained in a box of roughly 20′′ × 20′′. A 20 pixel consistency with the 8.0 µm reference image. The 24 µm square used at 8 µm, a 10 pixel square was used in the map shows an additional flare structure pointing from 24 µm band, and a 5 pixel square extraction was used Filament A∗∗ to the northwest (RA = 05h16m14.49s, for the 70 µm MIPS data. These extraction regions are δ = +34◦24′47.0′′, J2000). This feature is also seen of the same order as the projected size of the FUSE weakly at 4.5 µm. LWRS aperture (30′′ × 30′′) used at Filaments A and Nebular photometry (at 8, 24, and 70 µm) of Filaments B (Figure 1). The photometric measurements were used A and B was performed and the flux densities are pre- to constrain the nebular dust temperature in IC 405, as sented in Tables 2, 3, and 4. To ensure a fair comparison, discussed in §4.1 and §4.2. the spatial resolution of the 8.0 µm IRAC image and the Filament B - The Filament B region is located 24 µm MIPS scan were degraded. A two-dimensional ≈ 1000′′ north of HD 34078, a part of what Herbig Gaussian kernel was convolved with the data to produce (1958) labels the “E nebulosity”. This is a position A Spitzer Study of IC 405 9
Fig. 9.— Six-color imaging of the Filament B region. Data from the four IRAC bands and two MIPS bands are shown at their original resolution. The images are qualitatively similar, but quantitative analysis shows that the South (HD 34078-facing) edge of filament is more extended at 24 µm, suggesting that the carriers of the AEFs are being destroyed in the tenuous interfilament medium. The 24 µm map also shows a “Plume” to the north and a “Binary” feature to the northeast of the main Filament B emission, not seen as distinctly in other bands. Again, the overlays shown on the 8.0 µm image represent the IRS-SL aperture scan direction and the ON/OFF convention.
TABLE 4 70 µm MIPS photometry of nebular filaments.
Position Program RA (2000) δ (2000) Flux ( h m s) (◦ ′ ′′) (Jy)
A partially off scan map – – – A∗ r16032768 05 16 19.66 +34 25 20 2.562 ± 0.193 A∗∗ r16032768 05 16 15.64 +34 23 50 3.141 ± 0.214 B r16032768 05 16 17.74 +34 32 32 2.356 ± 0.186
where FUSE detected fluorescent emission from H2 The MIPS scans at 24 and 70 µm follow the structure as the most prominent spectral feature from Lyβ to seen in the IRAC bands, with a few noteworthy excep- 1190 A˚ (France et al. 2004). Filament B was covered tions. The MIPS data show that the southern edge of in all six imaging bands used in this work as well as with the region occurs closer to the star at 24 µm than at spectroscopic scans. Unlike the southern filaments de- the IRAC wavelengths. The 24 µm brightness increases −1 ′′ scribed above, all four IRAC bands appear to be tracing gradually (B24 47 – 61 MJy sr ) over a ∼ 30 transition the same material in the Filament B region. They show region onto Filament B, while the 8.0 µm brightness rises the same northeast-to-southwest elongated filamentary more abruptly at the edge of the filament, increasing in structure with a peanut-shaped central concentration. brightness by more than a factor of two (B8 18 – 40 MJy This peanut-shaped central structure, shown in all six sr−1) over a 15′′ interface region. Destruction of small IR imaging bands in Figure 9, is the center of Filament grains and the carrier of the 7.7 µm AEF in the more B (RA = 05h16m16.88s, δ = +34◦32′21.0′′, J2000). tenuous environment south of Filament B could produce 10 France et al.
12 3 10 ON OFF 0.14 2 S(2) 12.7 µm AEF + [NeII] 8 ON OFF 2 m AEF H