Binghamton University The Open Repository @ Binghamton (The ORB)
The Society for Ancient Greek Philosophy Newsletter
12-1970
Socrates and Prodicus in the Clouds
Z. Philip Ambrose University of Vermont, [email protected]
Follow this and additional works at: https://orb.binghamton.edu/sagp
Part of the Ancient History, Greek and Roman through Late Antiquity Commons, Ancient Philosophy Commons, and the History of Philosophy Commons
Recommended Citation Ambrose, Z. Philip, "Socrates and Prodicus in the Clouds" (1970). The Society for Ancient Greek Philosophy Newsletter. 74. https://orb.binghamton.edu/sagp/74
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by The Open Repository @ Binghamton (The ORB). It has been accepted for inclusion in The Society for Ancient Greek Philosophy Newsletter by an authorized administrator of The Open Repository @ Binghamton (The ORB). For more information, please contact [email protected]. 0ǔ -?2ś DGA4<0BKś 9>ś Ú /=S3Jś
8 ś ,íś CķàÒúś J*z #Óǔ Ļ^ÔļƤƅǔ
*ś NÀś V[QE J yŬ'ƆƹŜ$Ľ;Ƈgǔ & ( ~8Ú ¹Y<Ú ĕĥƈƥŘŭ8©ǔ OÁś +Yi=TÚ ( qįe ( EĜ ÔzĨś [ôś c0 6Pz ŮÕûįÖ²Ħľǔ
ûś v8! Åś ƁĈA_ǔ f$ Ś´ś )O X Ĵ½ś ĈĚÓ·üś üǔ Ʀ×ǔ ĉ*ǔ µęćêś Łģ¶łáś `ĖFMĊƉkǔ Az >ÅZj,©Ú
+!ś FČĪ ś Æ$ś M¿ś ¹ĐºQ'+ ś Ňś
řýǔ Zóś $!( ª JQ PÃŘś #( ?ǔ `ĢÙǔ ƊÉ(Úŕ³Ûǔ ?ǔ Ƨ ĿċƋǔ \õś ÇY?Ú «+j@+AÚ Q0 NJTÌnǔ Aǔ İƻ ƌǔ az ďb!+ þǔ
SėÜG8oǔ H Od+/ǔ »kjÆÔÚ Vðś 5 Q¹º ÏilºjB¶Ú 1ŀ ǔ [dQd7J@\z ¯Þ´Ĵßǔ #&j@ ]z 8Ú ^&ħŁČƍǔ 6"µĵàǔ °ǐ ]eRf5KA[z ^÷ś ØŋÙĀÚÛ®Ĭ)ś QÄřś
z $huF%i ᶳYƄ·ƵŃǔ Í)¸d /ǔ öś +%. ıăś ǔ Ïîś ¯ś ~ +pǔ $ ^/ ª hǔ Ó½[Ú 2ǔ ( . éaÑùś Zǔ ¹ńÎǔ ś ĵÂś aŰĨFNqǔ Bâǔ !]JC^z + " $ +ǔ .J]z sxbŃĥ ś # '( wQ"z ÿűǔ f' Ǐa Ņtǔ R ś ïś g1#z 7¡ěcy¢Ħś v C;ǔ ºŲơƢU:ǔ D z d2$z 7Ljãäņǔ ƨƩųǔ Mǔ ¬CÚ zUčǃåŇrǔ
+rÌlÚ s ¾×Ú Dz\ØmÙÚ ňǔ *!ĩeǒiǔ ( &(. 6Ez ëĉýŖ%ś ]EÚ
ƼÏƎǔ j ľ ¿Ü>Œś ( ¼YNÚ sJS:z Q2 j &k
:;#"ś À ;Í-ÁjÚ
{GƺŝĘʼnæƏǔ ^®Ú FJhz Ķ çǔ _Ģŕś ¹_NÚ -Įǔ TÚ èDŽƽ Ŋ@ǔ % ǔ Ş J «ǔ *Āǔ Ŵé,ǔ Îìś ÂZSÚ ( ĸiãĤś U3 y:& QOŵƪŶNj¬ǔ ¯FR{Ú mJz qś 7Ǒ Dž(dWıvǔ " ( ġŀw ś Ɛǔ »ŷƫê[jǔ ƶ9ęĭŋĎǔ 3R_ ÕÚ ÝĒäÕ¤ ś ǔ Ō ǔ ĚƑǔ $ vU ¼ōāƂǔ Æ Ú º`GÚ # %( l Ŏǔ d3%z "ǔ S4 0P½Ÿ2c>[Ǔǔ .|n/(Ú şDnj,¾ǔ eĔĖfn{©ś jŅ£ś iJz ǔ z KTz ģǔ ķ ƒ_ǔ X^y Èċō¥Ŋ¦ĝś |VĪƓƬR&ëǔ ¼YĠś Ď J6őś !' ), ºÚ mQ ņ|Êś Ú Ur¸NÚ pez + ;H5^' ¡Ú ÒƔ Źb=Ðǔ ū Êƾźùǔ Ăǔ ¿Ż3Ʒƕsǔ $ Ɩǔ røś ¼aHÚ tJU;z J+z Śĸ>ǔ °0ht¨±Ú Ŀś _4Luz ,KVz ŏkđâś ě ǔ .Ĝìǔ -*" . ăǔ ÉYIÚ ŠL1Ǎǔ Ɨǔ Vjdžz Ú V}Ú ?S6(K'n J-z syj L»ŗś Ąƭǔ TíĹ4 ŏ\mǔ L)*`~ ÛÀdz/üFȧ ^Ö (+?T 2}Ìo3¸p~Gz Ö O5Ŝ -Ŝ ? Ŝ i@ ¡ȧ 4& ÕîŜ Ļ"ȧ 4"¤HÖ Ŝ Ĝ̤ :!ȧ ¬&džDZnÑȧ ¥GI{¶Ö ķŜ o ǻ=ŢuýZȧ üŜ J_ȧ ¹J4npÇKÖ bÖ $) !) / ĚIJÉěŜ Òȧ Ì[ȧ źǼþŻǠvż¢ȧ W¸@¸Ö Ŕ0pèlȧ ŃŜ #ÿǞȧ + ÜļÍţ`ŽĮȧ G)T *" ) / ÍoLÏ¦Ö ǂmE÷wžįȧ 3$Āȧ LJ4Yā0ȧ Ĥȧ Fp5 8p 5C dļß"¥Ŝ ŊĒÿŜ V"eľ 2Ŝ KŜ !'+ àŜ ĺŜ Glİa/ ȧ ǭVȧ ĽĂ"ȧ ǟȧ ſăȧ 1ƪŐFKȧ ȅľ- _ȧ ƀĥ)ĄƁÝąȧ Ǵƫ+Ƃȧ *%/ Þ Ů>\ȑȧ d0ȧ ¡øŜ ,ǽĆ*Şć[ȧ .ȧ ) "$&+ 7',2LZ %ÊŜ ¦ .&ȧ #& & ¨%Ŭȧ !ºŜ H( LT ;-@I48( 1AT pÖ jØï´Ŝ 5DŽïœ9Ljȧ %!)- ĹŜ 9§"Hȧ ¸m(¾Ö |È5fÖ ®Ŝ qbȧ dÒ§u5+Ö 0J 9(SB,T Ó<ȧ =ŏ ß ūȧ ĦŪĈDžȧ _Ö #"ȧ ȆĿC{ĉȧ >2&MZ /.OCT Dzȧ qcȧ ȇşȧ 5&T 6$GT °fp¨¸ Ö ¾%ȧ ŔǡJĊȧ +- ÁǾċȧ ĿŜ ³ĄŜ Dƃȧ .ČmWø|ıȧ Nq:#Ŝ (&"*- àrŕčiŤȒȧ ¯ĞåŜ ! %& Ƅƨȧ ħƞůȧ ¨ĕ¹ç 3Ŝ *T ) ,. ÔĢŜ lj6*ȓȧ (+ ÐëŜ O )Ŝ Ȉ#)ȧ Ďȧ &*/ &; '2GT ?T & MŀŖáȧ -jȧ > . DT ńãŜ ŖŜ U63FGȧ &ƅȧ ĭÃŜ *BÖ &.;C 5*$ + ŗŜ !NeÖ - Iď}ǢƆIJȧ ǿĐƹXP śȧ ȉ8Jȧ OƟöw:NJȧ ;QȔȧ ȏ3dȧ xƇȧ gp®Ö X ƩŠȧ âSŭ"Zȧ Łȧ PZ µ-Űȧ oAȧ ÝýĊğcĸÞþ1Ŝ Èœō 3C ŒoıÛö¸/Ŝ đĒȧ % ?T @ȧ Bo5Ë©Ö Ä)6f pcÖ =T ðŗNjãhƈ`<ªȧ ;4Ŝ ĪÁŜ "+/ 1ēȧ Ă©Ŝ ȍù2ȧ (ȢȣȡȤȧ Rî ×A 8£ȧ ½ njȧ År8Ö '/ OªF7o%yyÓÖ . */ / 5ť0ȧ .BÖ GŜ :Ŝ mŜ Z Z ÷ij& bäŜ «5sP9QÖ ¬Ŝ ȊłŘ;$ȧ - ƬWȧ Ð#¬Ö - 4 !.'6?C Ȁ?ȋȧ ǣŃTȧ 42ĨǵŦȧ İÍô¶#Ŝ 4-RÖ ǯȧ sŜ ƺaȟ Q![,Ŝ + B+Ŝ C.Ŝ (Ŝ Z ·Bà ȧ lŜ ¿ėƉ ƭńDƊȧ # ,. $-. Ņ Ǐȧ %>ű¤ȧ &6P;T LņŲǐȧ ; ØȖȧ iÔ¯q<,Ö °2oS=TÖ U¼jt>« Ö "5)Z ŀŜ 7ȧ æyŜ w QR6Ŝ 7< K$FT ËƝ\ȧ 5ǁ úìȧ ¶Ƨ Ġ,+ %zǛȧ PŜ x#½µÖ @D0Ŝ ¼íTǬhǜȧ !Źġƚȧ Ʒƛȧ ȧ !# U!ǮȞ }ȧ ăªŜ $(ŸǝĢBjȧ yƜȧ & MũǺõ«ȧ Q!RCGZ RDSZ H>- ( I (9V:AZ 9no!¢¶ß*ē ė=J ŪȈ ĊZ =Ʃ ÀöŒŶ ãȈ ,"#0 [Ʃ ǗȈ ÛƧƩ ,)*0 O1% ËśƩ Ȉ Čÿē S:;\ FȈ ĘĤÓĵŶ ŕÚȈ + ÌÜDƓ ÍÝ8Ʃ 4#$!)56J Q·ıIJȈ ƏȈ ƛƩ ĶÔ GŶ Ŷ .0 ƟŧǠĴȈ ÎƐ$Ʃ Á Ŷ ē jskM #łƩ " ĐÑȈ ëċķęÂÕĸĹŶ ÆƩ ;WF\ )0 ƘyİƩ ǐȈ Q2ùŜ>Ʃ n RYd Ç kǤƣÈȈ ūâȈ àē Ũ'ĺ ìŶ 0 p§ q·^rē 5\ ē ǷǜȈ \ƍŝƩ ƜƂƩ 7=3@J ,A=J (÷Ŷ ÞƩ ŞŹ3 şƩ WņȈ ,Ŷ ƝƃƩ »Ǿ¼Ɲ%Ȉ 6 G=:R\ s ĀÑtē í ŮŶ G#7I ] Ʃ ĖČãŶ ^Ʃ +&0 C >J ŠƄßƩ f3_L =_ƘȈ Jšźıàu¡ŢƩ !8 "HI PĻļÖQœŶ RŃ zƅţƩ wȈ <¿_ÒCuáē ċē ƾùªȈ Ëčâ `D¨ē B#-3>N:C$HO\ vw8ē CƌȈ íȈ ń¢£32 ğÏƩ ŤIJ¤{ _*ćƞƩ #0 ¥ƙĂƆť Ƒ¦ăƟƩ ĠƩ 8á§Ʃ " )ø7ĥĽ8Ŷ 0 K0R Ŷ ŅƩ xē čùŔú9Ŷ áȈ Sņġ!úƇŦHƩ MřȈ Ż ÿƩ ƦȈ ƫȈ Ŷ '89J â¨Ʃ ċ©`ijã sƩ ŧª Ũ«Ʃ ŚÛȈ ľÉǒÊŭƅl/Ȉ KƩ * ( ! * 9I (,D3I Č Ʃ # % ŜÜȈ ĿÍǓÎƆm'Ȉ Oþ®Ȉ :-!;?I .$0 %0 '0 :#ľŶ ƔäƩ ÃSŕŶ ǏĖŨǢéčȈ % X7.Z\ X yã+ē ĥ,À-&Ȉ ǃĀ°Ȉ ÌĎä Wē Ĵö+5ĵå®ňũFƩ NƈƩ ĜłȈ åē Ǖ /Ȉ )!F I 0 ũ×Ŷ ŢTĦůŶ ĬƩ & SP\ ĖģƩ 5-ǰȈ $Ŷ f)ŎȈ æ¯Ʃ # ('* ƕçƩ ļçĊǍȈ - 0 ĉÁnjȈ Ɩ)èƩ Äţ.åŰŶ dØĿŶ :J\ /:J Ģ+µ*Ȉ 8ÅŶ î:D@Ŷ ~ǝǁȈ uƔšȈ ĒÕȈ ŪĤĶé ŷ6AƩ ƹõ£Ȉ XʼnȈ 9ÆŶ ĝƲ ǵTķ|Ȉ D:TQ\ ǫāţȈ e±Ʃ ²"Ʃ {ǴȈ zē IĎŠŀŶ ÖqƬ×Ȉ ĎÆǿȈ ÍEæ{ē ë³ďƩ ĘŁȈ ĽǡƠħ .Ȉ IŽŲȅ çS|èē :2;WH ĚŶ ÇŶ .%&*?I ơƩ ǎtĦŐèȈ Đ´µŊfƩ /(RF 01[\ FG7ē GȈ Ǽ¶ƛ$Ȉ %Ŷ ŶŦºNJƜȈ I\ %DG;J K IG+5 \ Ȉ æŝ Ŷ 4j@ VƢķìĘūƩ U mŶ HÓ0é ©¸,ē I«¹ ē Y£Ô ê2ē RĄadžȈ Tŋ¶ĸ7üg"·ŬƩ ·V*-ŁŶ ƭŖȈ nłW.oŶ Jē Ū&XŶ ĺ`Į³Ȉ ôġĸȈ ŭƩ %+ "&'#+ Ƹó¢Ȉ .& HJ ĚƎȈ òƒȈ ÙûahèűŶ ē ĬȈ U:\ Ş 14ZüŶ Yh ÉÛŃŶ [ń Ŷ íq9Ʃ !" " 5Ŷ ć¹gljȈ 0#åìȈ % Ȉ ,ƉŮƩ Ʃ ć½ëē lv 6Yv<| }ǚƺȈ õ4ĥÓîƩ (¸)ŌƩ vȈ *+ 0 % &0 Kº ē đ¹hĹï.ōůCƩ NjĈ½ģƃȈ >Ņ¡Ŷ lO ) + )$(%* ĺőĦÇƩ lP L4 ŸĻðięºŰ<Ʃ *ý¢þ6)ďÿŶ @\ şņÜ ¸Ŷ Ē»¼rƩ ŀÙrźĔűƊĪsȃȈ Đð£ŇŶ *I Dȇ67Ȉ Ʃ U.}Ŏjż½űƩ ňųőŶ 9ħƩ " $:Ĉē ūʤĀ¥Ť¦Ŷ AȈ ğ'ËŶ ʼn ñ§Ŷ J j騝¶īŶ Ĝđ+āŶ LjȈ ȀũȈ Ăi©ăݹŶ =J ŊŖÌŶ ;Ʃ ųȈ <=0>E I @ǥŸđƉÒȂƩ(Ȉ @4*I Àĉ~ą-ē ňƼȈ ƻö¥Ȉ 7^I: ÉƩ KŮƇnǔÏƧ"Ȉ ,8EV2L\ >9\ ò»$;Ŷ ĆdǦ´Ȉ ÄǯÅǖȈ àƂťĻȈ ëȈ /Ē ŎŶ ǭċČȈ L ē ǘŴȈ ƱśȈ % MƩ 564ē =aM÷íē Nē f¬¼ĆŶ ÎŶ ćšâē Ŷ ßȈ ! % $% ĞŃŻǙğžńæȈ O[Á#!ē îē P\ ¤øďē ŘŶ ơŷÃiį8Ȉ 45?ŬǮ3ƤȈ ǹǞƀȈ °±ÂĐ&ē :ƯȈ ! 12>hSÂȈ ǶŠǛȈ äŔȈ 0 mĄÁƩ &Ʃ ïÏU»'ē ;ưȈ # ¼.ē !ȆƷȈ 0 "đē ĒĂē ! 0 (=-1 J 3" ē >\Nz ]tj5{ n;ŴƩ zdzȈ $ + \ŋȈ 0 Ƴï UƵȈ ŝÝȈ 0 g®řàĊ½Ŷ yDzȈ " % ǂÿ¯Ȉ ( !0 ýĜtąƣƩ ļƏ:ŵƩ 0 /ƊÂŶĝƩ ùē óÃƩ ĽƋľ ,IƩ (>ē pŶ ƤƌƩ Ŷ ÞȈ ("0 ð¥ñē ǻŤǟ#Ȉ $ EşǩȈ ƶĕƑȈ ęƍȈ Ĉ Ŷ 0 />¯ŏ<+Ĕ Ŷ ]Ãăúē ó°± Ŷ\ )I DŽñȈ ;!çŶ JiK J3Ŷ ƓȈ ÓȈ _ Őŭ!ĨHŶ BȈ 0 5?2 "*J Nû¬Ȉ ÐāòÄē ü[ƗȈ Ś%²ĩŶ Ʃ ŘȈ YS'\ ҤȈ ĿŐo~: pĆƩ " ? \ ŏƋ¸ijǽȈ ñŞǨȈ žƩ ƁeǬȈ 0 -ēÄĞGƩ ,TD QóĊÕ/ē /Q0Yg (! *+ øZƖȈ īƩ ėŶ ǧĠƴ Ȉ ēØȈ (""³´ĉµŶ >F+J " RbĆē ]ŌȈ LM )ŝ $'(3 6 FW ± @M «ċŝ C$%2M Àŝ Ĺ8Ř ő Ř %$ )6 G5Y H$Y ēĞć ðğ0Ř ÝFŘ % &"(t #B/7/+G #>5, G &9Ĕ1Ř *6 óį¤¸ßŝ ŐñÈŘ sA 16 HTIY .Mr ~j Ġgt ªH%Ç ¸&ªXtÇ )= '0= åÕ Ċŝ &5+6 ġ>ò TŘ +< g ÁÂŘ tB[~>Cu t'Ç âiŝ æŒŘ ĈŘ ĵŝ Ì%œÞĢŘ H5Y 6 sD* S+{ ĉÛ ,kCŘ %ģŘ Ć7Ř ë2Ŀ '`Ř %&D 1Ălj kŝ KBM ļùŝ "6 |B, >°Ąŝ <=± / ± &ÍĕŘ WÇ kÇ -? + = vB- bßŘ A# t I 6 B%6QCY 1 = = Å vX1M éŝ őòćeŝ L5Y 2H6= Y O.@± d1Qt Nf:_ O[)t J± C120$3%G s4WUV5t ,` U+P*t ÎIŘ XÇ (½)ÃÇ C = ĖlĤóŘ "ÏFŘ #Ř ĥ3Ř üŘ MŘ ì2 āėmŘ ÃŘ %t 6 #:¡Ř E¢MÀ ĂĦĊÐ?ħĨŘ íŝ &, ± M*H M u±Ç B71pr ĸŝ «tmYfÇ %= ŔJ (Ř b+u,Ç ¹«Ç WCr BôŊD3 É1Ř +|PŘ ŏ ĩŘ xŘ 0 ÷s> 4Øŝ = ey ¨ŝ *! "eÇ #M &-#'0OJ.XY t'¬©5/ c-vÇ ¿ŝ Ñ@ĪŘ ŋ)ŕ]S£N¤ GÒ@# UŘ zB\?E *Ř ŗuŘ -íċŀõŘ ÄŘ n. ÄÇ å¥īŘ 8=!J0UY ŌçŘ SJ(Y Ŕ?Ģŝ àJŘ ^\ '<= ( 6w ?D :@5 D ]%ft !8 ,< C& B.CÇ g2wµÇ OÓ®Eı¯DŇ°Ř êŝ o3«JZhÇ ¼=Ç Řŝ Ď ±IJVŘ M ! hr Ķŝ := 2(#- +< gi¹!4Ç Ŗĩ¢ŀĪŝ X'2ilw (@s '(*± ŝ 'r *}ň²WŘ úŝ _T3g ď³tijŘ C"r Ľ;´Ř sbc ± 94.G 2oŝ UR4m 2 += ē¾µÊKŝ NŘ ł/ĸŘ >t ± G_ŝ ĺŝ )~(Ř ± #ŝ '+3 ± fĐÔĄ éµ Ř M M ê Ř (M 6 p5´L Ç #CNr ęÒá$Ěŝ C 3!,D Ys )01± M6Ç ï¶pđÕ âvŘ ¹ 7Ç [Ç !'7= 63 @Wx8"Ç ijŝ 9´¡Ç .:;7@ LEY Ĵ4at ķŝ N¾>Ç :1 < :,60ŝDM !G ŝ Ç ęA÷+ĝ_Ř '- {¬B ,M &)D kjt BPn ¬ \®]vlÇ q)´O^ Ç lXr r$:Ç xC5 ' \¯#}¨q± nt IRFb !6t D &:G Z[± ¤± Dh$ G]t ± Q?/2c3S@K7t K± E9¡M9¬fj± pq=Ht "8A);G V± JL;ZeMBt @E ¯Ç ®Q ºER´Ç ¶ĨĔ{Ëŝ ¬Čŝ ]¿`}FÇ =#,D Ri ńŘ 46 2- 6 06 =ņËÖLŘ ŝ M JAM ŐïąÃÁŝ E:r ġìŝ OFă Lx~± `a_"r± ¡ĿÉcŝ nŝ "%' < À`®MÇ ī|ŝ ěŅĜIJhŝ Lm c0C;r I#r - - V V - ! # ºæBDŽ # V V V V V V - 3/:9E SP,Ž QV PV 'SV »ŹŗũŽ ĤZēijŭĊCŘNŽ &1 Yƀ -.Ž H?f*FV 26=Zv v Fħƀ L'w &ArBKCnDqt DE L%t Ţŕƀ $YG?v fV)R]A$*^t âmċ ÃĨ Şƀ f/w \óďţ/İƀ Ĩ ïdŽ GqXw 8 ; Ŷƀ ĖĠ¡ĺÝ ¢Ž KÌĵŽ ?-V ŖÚĵƀ #9+).0A ű46.ãƀ pºġĨ TĨ ŒÆŽ ø» `Ĩ G)w qĨ N+4:G[KO,Q\v őÄ Ž Ą´Ž ϦŽ EGS=DiC - >+t ,1UùSĐħKČØÄĨ G'w ]hS i3GE^v ; şÛ Ķƀ Ğ ŷƀ ÿƀ LXĨ M347NV ŗƀ %4!,6A Ž rƀ ) ůŽ ā Ž F Gw # ƀ Ťwõķĸƀ @Ì÷ 'Ĺƀ ezA-¡ĺžƀ ŵƀ År+súĨ 7ƀ đÆ ĘtñûM¸Ĩ u%Ç ď¦ÙÈü;Ĩ >3A t @G+(Sw °Ĩ kƀ Ļù¢ƀ Ñƀ £ƀ &%IĨ 94; sGT_v ëƀ vĨ Ĕ[ŴŽ Tr?Zw ÔĨ c ÔB ŮŽ '>ƀ ĞĨ `T,#jat G*w ¤ƀ 4 Y&Ĩ )Ĩ EBH q +ƀ Ü ļƀ HSg1GNtw ixŽ %ýĨ f 'ĥŽ ć·Ž ŐÃŽ )Ó¼ "ƀ àĨ "wĨ aþ4Ĩ øhųŽ f?ft ťĽ¥1)ƀ 5æĀÓľƀ { ú¦ƀ Ō㎠n}Ž §ŭ¨ġ© ƀ IV ę§É xÿ<Ĩ DébZĒĀ2Ĩ êNÊO´- Ĩ Ý? 2Ÿƀ ,I /;]w K&=% B3A äŽ Ų% Ŀƀ ?Ĩ ªûāŀlż čyĨ Źƀ S5`oGP-C gv vuw 2:^w AhGRI?H.6?w Í.«ƀ c¨,ãµP[z.Ĩ UŢıŽ qs\ťĹ Ž 7A ÖħŽ C$ ďG9 Z#V ëĨ 1 ; ŦőÎöƀ ųðEƀ Ňh< "Ĩ Ĩ TšİŽ műŽ ¼Ģ#¶Úģ=Ĩ bƀ m4Ģ ĖċüCė |ƀ ÔŁƀ VēĨ >,V a.Gtv :*A {Ĩ ¬łĘ=&8 ƀ %GUv 8A Ġ0#|ìĨ JÅŽ , A 1!V .I j/bv ĐÀóîôWŽ q ®ƀ Ïƀ ¯Ů°s±ƀ 'Ĩ ¡} +Ĩ ;5OV F ĔāĨ iX-UbA%.ct K12LV (5²ƀ ęĂŘƀ G&v f%n³ŃJƀ \½äQí©ĂËĨ $ %E Ā³Ž m0rDSv Čƀ ' clS8v 7djqV ;<ev 'A ōÁŽ ŨĦŽ ŧ$´ģWƀ " '- =I &=ńƀ .ÛĨ 9ñµƀ ŎĬŽ 0*ĕ~Ĩ ŃŧrńŞaüv0Ž #! - +!Ž Iãà`ëŶ Ž i/ w &])ÌĨ þ±Ž Ĩ ÙīŽ fĮĈŽ Y/s0 G1&t ÖĨ !Ĩ B v @D5I Ò®Ž !(H åÜîÍĨ 1Wv 1ƀ œÉŽ 5õŻŽ ą(Ž _ Õ¶ă·ņ+ƀ U7_jGO3C `w $2?" 'A ; =A 5; # ; ">I #80' 9 E Ě)Ąƀ 'Ĩ m/v ğïdĨ 7MXt ; ±ªÎĨ Gw OHnv g¸0ƀ Dƀ aGw V æ¹ĤĨ Ĩ ŏÂŽ Ŧ]éŽ ¿©ûÞŝßŪªľŽ N6t HĄ6Ĩ h¹ąESƀ kzŽ 6YIJ%Ž A Ě Ï ĥĨ ĭŽ HV 7mv U/@0V «¾ç· Ĩ 8ƀ ¢Ĩ :.V L%v Š~Ž F<.)I 1.=I ?=Ž Ðą :Ĩ `äƀ Bð1ĆÑĨ ÇXįŽ ĎG 8 wŽ ÝĖĨ »ƀ S!P"i8k9GDw ÿ²Ž (¼ƀ $+#,; <ö"Ž cÂŊŜ<Ãƀ VGV E^ÞÒĈ/ò_®ÓĨ M(w dĥčè~ŋLƀ GX#v jyŽ ZBîŌšĜuÄōKƀ [ ũŎ9$ƀ ƀ :ŝƀ (A ;A 4á{ŁŽ !0; ŊĂŽ âÅƀ ŏŪÉŒƀ ¶Ž QÜçÎíŽ @ĶřŽ NI^ ƀ GR%Fw Êœƀ YI=Gdw C×-7Ĩ #E đĒ#Ž t Eft ØĪŽ ĝŔŐ ;Æƀ iKw |Ž v )IJv $5 t ýĨÇƀ "Ð: È!ƀ ( Ãwɖ 'åɖ F?]@^m cɖ ǔȸ ǣȡŇɖ R#z AFT$GW /Ä æɖ DŽŞĜǏ $PF=m TQ" ɖ 0uQvÄ çɎÇè Ǖ ×ɖ (Aɖ hÀ§:Ɨéɖ 0Ŏɖ E4 Ɲêȣɖ ɖ ƀɖ #ǤdzǴ2f¨ǵɖ CǏ v9ƔëǶɖ pŦìɖ Ɓíɖ ®Ä !1Ä Śō^8Uƥ&ɖ ¼ɖ D0Q îŏï ɖ ƪǏ h)z ¤ð _Ƿɖ Ä śã=ňȢǸñǹɖ 1#Q ŗB\ɐɖ DǏ Vc&'!X`Wm òɖ 6 %ɖ +ȤƘóɖ >n\z ƫǏ ;ȴȥɖ 0$Q ŧôɖ QVz eɖ NF>"'Fz $ 2Ä ɅN)ɖ ©Øɖ Ȱ1ɖ /G ¼a¨RÄ Ũõɖ Evg*z Jɖ 3#8=69 ¶SÄ !3$ 4Ä _/Fd(*m ].#mAgdQm Őɖ @Ǐ ½ɖ 'ÒǏ BFA0W Ä =-8ä/ɖ ń×Ǐ ÈƂȺƒV|$qTƽ_ɖ %m "+ 3G ]FG 3 &4 Jő"ɖ "'! RúÊ!ËxNJǏ g+z AA.W %ƞǺöƙȻ÷ǻɖ %2W ƩǏ Cɖ 5L6Q H_ UXMGBY0 8m ǥɖ )øɖ Ǽǖjù >ɖ IÄ ȼƃ|ª ƄƦɖ Fm Ŵ AėǏ ƓðǏ ł Ƥ"ÔǏ :&_ ƣÓǏ Ƨúƨrɖ "\^9m $O??Sr]z Hɖ T-Z_ 0%Q '$(&3G ?¢ġŷǏ O7ɖ ¥*ûƟǽW!ɖ YZ)Ǐ [I_ ȵǗ`ɖ W mǘʼnŊÉ*ɖ 1&Q 50) J=Q 3Hz 07 9G ÞǏ ßcűĘè0Ǐ ɖ i)4^z >(25EQ ;5Ƒ-aɖ Sý įēƏ'ĔŚƐǏ ?@_z ȶǙƾ`ɖ QDɖ )KXm j+Fm 3M5?Q ~DZ-/Mɖ lEüƅȽýɖ ÿıǏ gnWIz jǏ ȦũþXǭɖ Ce 9m $]H^%ÂÃÄ ǁ ƙǏ i,z J;4K_ !$ i ?x<ÿɖ JpÄ ŪĀɖ ā93sū"ɖ EǏ æʼn¤ŸǏ wÄ ƢřǏ ůÎ{mĦǏ Ŭ«ȧɖ Yɖ ƿ#Ǐ PĂɖ seOFz ŗâǏ M M$ F1Q ăƆȾĄɖ rĠǏ ǦąƚXŜƿaɖ ÝŠŇīǏ QĆɖ w56,Ä ɖ ¬ǰ /ŝ"ɖ 82-Q j-5`z akAz eŤƯ¶ƀǏ ŭɖ LYmrvasn CZR ƾǏ 8 7W ,_&²Ä ·Q7xÄ ïǏ $ © ]m oÄ &'ƩZɖ A.U_ 'A?2_ cOUzbgw{ ć;ĈǾǿɕ sƇDȀɖ ǀKɖ LÁƪŞɖ .6bz $ -6,W KÄ ½` '[³Ä ɆRċFɖ qɖ YȂɖ ã-N ^ɖ "W ĺŌōǏ|@G AH *49 >Ǐ sǏ ?*+ #ɖ ɖ 7\z ČƬɖ VA]_ jae8k¾Ä tS$ȱɖ ¡ǧǁÚÊxoɖ ÏƺÐŘ ÑǏ ƈɖ ¨TÄ 1: Q W %²Į³Ǐ ǨčKĎ<ȨďÛɖ āijǏ yjǚƉÜĐnɖ Q Q ȩůđ2ɖ %8#i/JlnVwz ´ªUÄ «S®Ä ?Dz h1R_fm @47 'Q ÜşņĪǏ ( F-5*_ GĴǏ 1bLCm ŰĒɖ ǛoŋzÝǂ ¢¯ 1bɖ $ "¿Ä £ǩǃ+ȷȃɖ Ĭ`ĝªžǏ ŵ Ǐ ɖ ɇ1lɖ ǜ°ɑɖ I1Q Ȅēɖ Œ4űɖ %÷´Ǐ $y(9¨Ä œɖ >!G ËO3ĔnƓDŽƭɖ ɈŲ,Ì*ɖ ȅĕɖ ŘĖėȆɖ ÍDžy]?ɖ òƳ£Ǐ yĶǏ ¸f:-Ä *.G0Q ųĘɖ ©Ž$ LJǏ fƮɖ ádŲęé1Ǐ $ LW GȇȲęɖ $ 6ŴBɖ ;Ä ɉdžɖ ÎŵĚLɖ ƯȪHěȈpȉɖ HÄ SH4eZm $Ǐ ưuCǮĜmȫɖ ĂĵǏ \Ä ƠƲğ@ɖ ti0z ŶĠɖ qÄ ¥Źź^džǏ <9W ŌǪ$ÏġȊɖ ɋŷ Pɖ c¯¡?lHÄ OK,Q S±ȿĢɖ ǝǫLJɀƊģɖ z PGTBC7K'z Ĥɏ»Ǟĥɖ ĀIJǏ W P/Q G; H+AQ <:W uRĦɖ OY7(8Lz àǏ 8q9A=yg:OMz ħȋĨɖ 5&Ð ƳȌDzÑȬȍɖ g1z Lj4ĩɖ Ȏ0ơĪ'.cŠɖ ;05m ®Va¢Ä ɖ &;Zfmz .pNz řīɖ UJW 960^_ ƴǓ²ßƋɖ UċƛǏ ai:FN>B^m ŅØǏ 3%B>@4 G ȏljÒƌĬƍĭȐɖ ,Ä ƚõ¯ĊŢǏ ĭĖ°ţǏ r}@£Ä i+0ś*W ÄĮš³/ɖ NJɖ ɍkȑƎhɖ HW M àȒɖ [ĩǏ N[dŢȓɖ ǀþzôǏ 3 _ ¨WA]Ä ie\X ƢgIɖ 'sL«!mB Ä EDW ȔwƵɖ pzÄ S )9 ŦƸ»ŨƂ+Ǐ ȕǟ3ƶţȖɖ kĞÃƉ,Ǐ 7_ ƕǏ !į´ ,İdɖ n¤Ä ŸǒƷ kı@ɖ Ź.bŤȗɖ 15.AG "ÀÄ ¬QC¥DÄ äZɁIJɖ MIkT[m Ļİ®ĢLjǏ O~Ä "E.Ä tǏ D"-G QøľǏ i2xz /M:WA_ ȭź Ȯɖ Ƙ¨Ǐ vƟƃǏ oî"ĕ|ƱħƦŰpÕǏ V3>4W čƹÇŀ&ÈǏ ɒɖ :ijƸťȘɖ ɖ RB 4N)G _ ûÌđŮǏ 3C6,G ɖ Ɲ¸Ɓº2Ǐ 3):G *EG +X _ ¾¿ŪÀǏ ąķƗňǏ ^,m v%Ə!Ĵɖ G,7Żĵ5ɖ ƊǏ W Ěƶ·ĽƬťǏ Nj ɖ ƣnj5Ķɖ 816 JƒǏ FDžǏ áǎșɖ KƄƠĥ¼Ǐ ɄI ɓɖ ļµbƜĤljǏ A Ǐ ŒìÁơÂūǏ ƻɖ Ƽĺɖ " gÄ Aɖ )YdFHÄ ;2 ? DĘǐ Y 4w [YAI8w y` LC# '0 !" I!w )5 #. ( #5 6 )*5 .8[ R&/F[ BJf"IgCQKw v6§ ¹ƾbīĬǐ R'[ ĕƔ®ń ]ǐ . R([ !j-ÐIw . Ɗâǐ !&5 + 25 $0S u¡~Ia<§ zJ§ yk -/ K!`{K0' U =Ɔǐ 859ǐ 76§ ) 35 ņǐ ǐ '. ǐ .#6 38 %U U -& 0U #U U $U0 U U ' 0 &'U %0 YǍǐ ġljĐưǐ 0 R?US !S WSB*e .!G 0 + >&0 IM:QU `UJ6X.e CY0J7?e abP: @_e ( '0 h:#w -Wfǐ \bLxk§ n8§ )/8 D@PAU '+/ rǂǐ ƸUDŽǐ w6§ V#öĝÓǐ (. wK§ l|ǐ #6 HIFS09#[ z4>o ō >BM,ǁǐ iRw Ɛí¡Ē'ǐ ƈàǐ * +9 Ñķǐ $ 6 6 38 Ć÷Ũǐ ăƽĞÔǐ ƛ ǐ "(&03- 48 fÝ.?F[ Ƥž¾Îƥ¿ſƀǐ !6 jkǐ {5 þœŃ ƒqƓǐ '$ +(5 #6 ßƫpǐ " šĹƼÒ&ǐ YX.:$[ Ŵî¯^ Ā°)ǐ [Nc=§ AG=B)JZ;%[ FGāǐ "êǐ N¬\űħŲǐ 0 5 ?ùśůǐ túģÕǐ ËŞûĤÖǐ oǐ .j`P /s>U1 o]4§ ,%. 8 TĜǐ UM>Ond§ NPJOEB *0 ƻǐ ep§ Ř£ē ÿǐ ;KJCU ĭǐ Ƌãǐ 4>W K[ 0 R¢ƢŬ(ǐ $T[ 46 sćŪūǐ đ ǐ >|7 8>Nr!^!U & /6 "UB9- ǐ E [ £qD§ dƦÛñƘÀ!-ǐ ! "/ '.0 f§ 'E7;8S ~ǐ & "^#§ ój H ďýĂ1ǐ )*0#'" +6 L§ DLw ^?Q\kw WtljAM9w $2(9 -2 "0.*2 Êǐ / 0 " q`@ t ? g§ 0`k ) 5 %_SI`w +2 .2 %/(! ,2 " ABJ? y?`V 4w ïƺ²ƴ³ +ǐ Ly{D$§S >øŗũǐ #/S 5 hk`=U WŌ. /* 618 `l" ðŻǐ " & &2S ƭǐ :AD4S ų2ǐ OìDžǐ k# Įǐ 38 `G,ǀǐ %V5§ 1#6 R[ w 9 WPT&§ E'§ Cpu %1S $'#! )0 :r§ * -. '8 ĉ`ĨØ$_Ù±*ǐ ŭǐ P3S ëXƮǐ J56=S Eęǐ `6 ,5 6Q§ W ۦvŁĢ ǐ XZaDbw , !. R*[ # & 3%&6 »ƿ¼ıŽüƶ½ČLjǐ ƇÞǐ B(h§ ". m:&C]w ƁÂÏƨčIJÃƂƃ.ǐ |L_ LX¤§ 9j`2: r;'EYw ŝºÚƪcƗʼnİǐ #2 ! & f;$VaQ%X m}ǐ ' .9 <Ƅǐ +5 #%/ Ìǐ +5 9R§ C1F+5[ U 4 8 Yw§ 9 ƞǐ uǐ . nj67ǐ -5 # ,6 ,0 6?LR[ $ / )"5 n<(w .45 S S S S U Ǐ3ƙI/ŋǐ ǃSŏǐ ÁĖƷǐ %>&M3Ne )0 " &0 C)*}ni§ i=)uw " " ĶÇǐ U)3[ Rbk % 7& 9 +. s;*w Covw +¦ KLDY3 ƍåǐ @ ,j§ s6§ 8-U È0ǐ @ @1w HFdow Ľǐ " " Əèǐ . #2&-6 i>2w )3ò (S 1 w y Ċ&ˁʼnŊȉ˕ ÊŋŌ# éě˕ [Ŏ$Ɩ¼Ǧ WE@s 0U˕ ăPWzō8˕ ɫƱȊ˕ '9 [;msQX5 bw ' xĨ)Ɔ.-K ƿǦ U0F ĉ¡7A A q5 ² ;Ǧ 6!]w >2A Gk_7XYs ıǚǦ Ŏɬêˌɭ˕ 8˕ ňßǦ ǀǞɮ˕ ǤÒǦ 0ȋ˕ ʚǁɯ˕ ë,ŏ˕ 5ƣ˕ ? K Í ʖʗȡǟ˕ ãǂHǸŐ˕ ǃő˕ >ɰ˕ Ǧ ªSub6² ɱ˕ ƜNjÇĬǠǦ ^Ǧ 5Ĉ Ǧ ÉQɲ Ȣȵf Č˕ ċĶǦ ɳǠ8&˕ ǡ ˕ &9K Ǎ¹ųǝǦ ("0 ˕ Ʈõ·Ǧ E&s SL.iZs |Ǧ ? :A DŽƳ{˕ [Es "=#-A $.K Ąʛ1ɁʫǢˍ®˕ @w RO/En$dw |Œ˕ ˂ȣ˕ ǘ#ġƔǦ ĝǦ IU˕ @A ,+ #! 0 dij:ʜ˕ qD² Á˕ óēƎǦ kǗ6/œ˕ u˕ ʸ5ì Ȍ¯À Yø¿ŵÀǦ 8² hĩƑŌǦ &R*6A Ȯƫ˕ ɴȶŔčǣƤ˕ ^Va[¯² bmAs o3%w fnEs ǔŒ%ĢƚǦ «T]!U² M¢9² t %˕ 1 ʬŕȍls˕ ǙǦ {Ŗ˕ ÙSB1@ ʘ˕ ȷíɋîą2ŗ˕ HQs ]ħDŽƄńĴǦ ǀǦ J9<˕ 9 Ř˕ CǤɌ˕ ȸ3?mř˕ ÏŚl2śɵ˕ }Ǧ T ¥śX 5 A 1A e&sw hŜPSŝ˕ A DžOǥĕŞ˕ ǑĆöǦ %0 Ǧ˕ ȯş˕ 7Šɶȿ˕ úǭš<˕ ZþÉĘźƝǦ &0 Ȏ ˕ ʝ ˕ Ďdž"ɷŢ˕ !z0Ǧ DžƫǦ ŸmƴýŹǦ Ǻţ zĜ<˕ E 8Ĥ¦ 4A A uÿ:ɸ˕ ìV"A .'0 0 $9 (M 9s ɹ- !n˕ ×Ǧ üŖŕ&ÈǦ ƴ3ˎ˕ "˕ ǻŤq~OkSˏ^˕ `LJť˕ ǼŦ o˕ *ŧȹŨȏq˕ ȺȐ˕ ,e˕ YªY ɺ ˕ cĽ Ǧ *CƥJĖ˕ ǰũ£˕ $Ǧ 0 bļǦ Ū(ɻː=˕ '^ F(aw IBs ÓǦ őƲùÁŶǦ ú¡Ǧ ǽɼ˕ Ġ*Ǧ ¼½Üwï3˕ NǦ (ʞȑ˕ ƵDZȤ$ˑ˕ °² C6DzOˇȒƶ˕ Ljū˕ ǕǣǦ ŅÜǦ à ďŬ˕ (*9 ŇÝǦ â 89ʭŭ^¾¿˕ Ì=˕ Ýû ʮɽ¤˕ _ðZ˕ 8AǦ R{Ǧ Ʒ4ȥĀX˕ qMN r& ĜŦÊŻNJǦ gȓɾ˕ >K WNn©² Űű2Ǧ VV² M!) *0 ɿŮ ˕ 9 §:² -0 ) 02 lj Ǫ˕ ɂǧñ˕ NC s ƹƐǦ ¤Ìƞ)ł'/Ǧ I:1\s EGK + eòʀ˕ ĐȦȔʨ &° ßNJsɍů˕ ČƈǦ ĿÄǎÅ%Ǧ b˕ 7G:@(2/K Ʀ˕ I AK R;² ,ü˕ ʼnàǦ Ví¨şŠ©ƅǦA !ÚǦ ĔƏ5Ǧ Ó˕ ĐƌǦ ʁȻŰű˕ ȧʟ˕ /ȕ˕ 9FŲ˕ ĪiƒưǦ |² ˕ !+;K ,!A >fw ÈEų$;˕ q² ăƢǦ 54˒˕ .+ A ,ódz˕ ˕ ;5?s ǁǦ )gZ*w '/ D0CK KºǦ ǒƱƕǦ Njʂ˕ M˕ ƪņǦ ǴŴa7Ȗ˕ S,R² O¤˕ <; A ƵIJǦ ˕ njʄ˕ řǗǦ Ůljſ"ŚƦƩ:Ǧ 7;hw =cH>¨VpO² )0ʯŶ˕ 0² ȗ ˕ ɎŷʅʆŸǿĉf@Ź˕ aFs LŽrÔƣ1Ǧ LjƶǦ Fź˕ ÐijŪĂqƠĚơǦ ("9 G+p8Vw ¢œÆƛBǦ JŋǏǦ < K MǦ ?² ÿnŧŨǡDǦ OĵǦ ǍŻ˕ 0289 6gs ʡ}Ǝ˕ Iv ² ÒƝʏB˕ ŭtƤƥuǦ #9 òĒƍǦ ½ƗƘkǞǦ ĸǦ H*cģV @"bA²A ēǓǨƏ˕ /3A ĎƉǦ ˄ǔƐ Ƒɒ˕ ƾǦ c?ș˕ ǕIʐ˕ vů"ğÙƧƨǦ -/H0äëǦ ŲǦ p0_+Kjds ƒƬ+ ɓW˕ )˕ dĮ6Ǧ á/ĔƓ˕ ɀEȽV˕ yLJ£ęŁêǦ sTw Ɣ˕ ƻǶ ʢ" ʑ§˕ gĈ3:˕ Ñƕ#@Ɩʒ˕ ˕ s9.w q$.A aĻǦ k rv\?w ɔøB06Ț y ȭƩƗ7˕ 1Aw þ2˕ 'ĀÍǦ ȾKƘùʓ ƙʔ˕ VNy ƚ˕ $0 ˈDʳW˕ 5'R A ō#Ǧ ǩƪjǷ ˓ 9²˕ Ǧ <4Ǧ Âé]Å Ç˕ $ ? ? > .? !.y T T *T * `[ƫ" Ƭ T p " * T pT # %* T T T *1 %1 %1 !1 Ƭ j,kDp * $( &)1 R T[p 1>WgO1nbd +p (]p ."%- 1 %1 őĽåƬ ! * * Ƭ ,1 æƬ 12çƬ T T T / 1 #KT K Ĕd; Ƭ *1 MT ~ƆƏƩƬ +1 01 1 '#)* hƊ ÞŔƬ ãĒä¢ēqģ Ƭ FÛÂp^4å6ģ £ ³Ċr¹hģ đÔ*&ģ )AĺƊ ŧƊ ºģ Tc zÆ 0/Ü'ÅƬ ě½Ƭ oûĭĻ Ɗ kļüFRĽƊ '|ŰyƊ e'.~ÜľƊ - JC Ƭ Lc éƊ ğMµÕ¬ģ +ģ ,ėģ Ɗ ĶĠq8Ɗ vŀƊ ýƊ LÛ(U+% p <, \Ɗ \Q7Ƭ BơƬ NÌ")- Næ+ 'ģ GƊ ƠĠƃƬ I.A60^p )Ƭ ƓbŐƬ UÍŜ;Ƭ AP6Ƭ ¤= _O5çsģ " ā ñŘƬ Ƭ ĆjčƬ kŠ¥Ƭ - þŹĮÝƀVƊ ]R8Ƭ CÃģ - .3 3Vc ƢƄƬ 3 7S 6FNc >/(S ¾ńƊ !", - ÄĶ Ƭ ſÕ¶Ƭ )9(:(" źmŻƬ Ð Ƭ 2'¶űãêƊ ĂëIìŅƊ íăƊ Ɗ ÇwƬ ġƬ 5P"ĄîSƊ }ƅƬ ũƊ · -;ģ =Ƭ H/6ŪÍąù0ÞƊ ŵ#İŴTƊ GZH_c äŢƬ ţĩƗƬ |ƟƬ #- žƉġƊ " Ƭ ),y&c " ģ 2%PT ŻƊ éú!®ŧƬ võƬ Ą!ģ 1ņƁƊ ´ĕ»ģ 2ŇňĆ#L7Ɗ Q%*Ɗ ģ 1$OT ·ƈF/ʼn@s,Ɗ @B:p Ja ģ DƊ ąģ `¿ćÙ Ɗ Ĉ Ɗ DtPb¯ é7ģ KÄêuģ l°ŊĉïƊ Ċ´= ŋƊ ¡Ƭ £işƤƬ łhƬ Ƭ )À¡Ɗ Ŷ;(ƂƊ Åģ 4; ? S RS ÙœƬ % 3 &- - ) - NŋĴìƌŬƬ ľrŊs ü(Ƭ ¢Ɗ " ŕƬ ßĊƬ ëģ 5 HZ+Ƭ aċðßŌÎČDƊ n! Ɗ RÜċ¸)1ģ ĄfƣƬ Ƭ ÝSÖ#4°2vģ !GT 7&'8[Oc #*c (T9Pc HÆd wíģ ęÇČkģ .`c ^;7p xîe.¥×¦,)ģ č=Ɗ % ōƊ ģ -VI:J;L YƬ EÁ#Ƭ ƂƬ ªƒ«Ď¬Ƭ ŝ èŞƊ ŴėƬ CPDKS ŵƜƬ ƑŌƦ şĩ " $4Ɗ A'"H>6IT ÂģŁƬ ¿ZÀģ jKZÖ4ųŠƊ *3 3 Ž$Ɗ 1*S %!+29S 6OEN 3, $S 1 $*! Ɗ 23 C2%bc šĝĪ×ŢƊ özƊ ]Ā©āģ Xįņož¯ŨƬ ÷Ɗ >%ţƊ ( %3 cĵ®īĞøYƊ Bª Ă3:ģ Ë Ɗ -K:FKGS İÃƬ MŇıêƋũƬ eċƬ 3ģ îŮƀķ ïuþƬ mğķ *³ŤƊ Ĝ 0ģ ĬO%¯Ɗ ťÛØ&xJUƊ 10 � especially in regard to the intermediate position they seemed to have occupied between the physical philosophers and the rhetoricians, their interest in language, and their emphasis on ethics. This intermediate position is perhaps reflected in Prodicus1 definition of sophists as µ.Eeopia cpi.Aocrocpou -rE &veipoc; xai rro.Ai-rixou (Diels6 B6).24 The second reason is that the nmne of Prodicus quickens the attention to the role of Prodicus in the whole play. It is consistent with Aristophanic style to draw attention to allusions of this type by na.'ll ing n.Qlrles. Frogs 75 ff. offers an interesting parallel. There Heracles asks why Dionysus doesn't wish to bring Sophocles back to life. Dionysus gives two reasons: He wants to see what Iophon can do without Sophecles and besides Sophocles is too mild mannered. He needs a rascal like Euripides in c ase he has to make a run for it from Hades. What Aristophanes probably intends to imply in this passage is that Euripides is a figure more suited to comedy than Sophocles, an implication which is a slap at his rival comedian of 405, Phr;rnichus, who made Sophocles play a role in his Muses similar to that of Euripides in the Frogs.25 Just as the re ference to Sophocles seems to have had more than mere general significance, so also the reference to Prodicus directed the audience's attention to the Clouds' rival meteora, the �' not to reject them, but to acknowledge them as having inspired the ir own existence in this play. B1 this explanation it becomes quite clear why the Clouds bow to the sophia. and gnome of Prodicus: He had in effect invented them. And why then does he not become an actual character of the play? Because Socrates is funnier, because he struts in the streets and rolls his eyes and makes priestly faces as he endures his shoeless existence. These conclusions are totally at variance with the discussion of this passage by Dover in the introduction to his new edition: "�· 358 ff. are intelligible as comedy only if we believe that Aristophanes shared the popular esteem of Prodikos as an artist, and regarded Socrates, by contrast, as a pretentious parasite who inexplicably fascinated some wealthy young men but had nothing coherent to say and produced nothing of any artistic 11 merit . (This last smacks of the publish-or-perish principle. ) "Socrates lacked charis; and he was indifferent to what Ar., in common with most of his audience, regarded as the good things of life. That is why he was chosen as the victim of a comedy whic.h set out to exploit the humorous potentialities of intellectual activity. 1126 In this judgment Dover ignores the real similarity between the interest of Prodicus and Socrates . While he may be right that Plato's references to Prodicus are not unfriendly , he ignores also the repeated emphasis, especially in the Platonic testimony, upon Prodicus ' concern for money. 27 Even if we assume that the charge was true and that Socrates himself stolidly refused to accept money for teaching and in fact disclaimed the ability to teach, it seems very plausible tha t Plato whould have pre ferred to emphasize these differences than to attempt to disassociate Socratic thought from that of Prodicus. To make money the distinction between the two men would have been clear e nough even to Strepsiades. But to have sought before the Athenian discasts of ·399 to undo the conflation of the thought of Socrates and Prodicus, which had its basis in fact and was capitalized upon by Aristophanes, would have required a subtlety of argument too fine for court-room oratory . Ċˎ ı ˎ dċƏ !8Ə¢ pƏ OOrƏ ʻʧxXˎ Ǖˎ 3("0Ïˎ ˎ GU¶ŰƏ ©eŶƏ ʽ¤ˎ ĺ/4ˎ Îˎ ij Ə kr ʯ$ ôƏ JƗy^ʁǽsˎ dˎ @"y)ˎ g± 29/ɐYˎ ĝ ȖƘBˎ ʏș´,ˎ ÕĨ8>ˎ "r "@N ńʕ=KGˎ ƁĴƏ Ť bťűƏ Dǖ ʍˎ $Ò -Ə C AƏ ɣʖPˎ kr "¿µȚˎ ćLĪ ĘƏ %ŚƏ ɶCǾȰDžˎ ˎ ˀ 5 Ǘˎ F cś3ƌ ,ī ÂěoƏ gˎ ˎ R&Ə Ī5zǿɑ`UÙˎ ]¥4ˁ'"Xˎ ĵ1Ə Ŏ zũ0 ˎ ƻ÷ˎ ª0Tō EƏ KƏ ķŴˎ Ə ʨRˎ ¯bˎ jtN%ˎ %ˎ ˎ :*ɷƅE©ʩ Lˎ ȱˎ /Ȳˎ Ǻö ʀȀˎ /1JkƏ 4 »ɦˎ hr D ˎ Íj80żˎ ǘDˎ Ņ7& .ˎ IAˎ Ƈȁ6ˎ C4Ə $ŝKˎ *ƈˎ »{Ǚ^ɒˎ )ƼÌc-ˎ tˎ Ųõ5Əěøɓ5ŵ±'ˎ r#sˎ ŇƏ ųö=ŜƏ ƈƏ -,Yˎ ŏǚkˎ (("Ə Ə _ʂ²vˎ lr *;nƏ 9ˎ Ğx;! w ūƙˎ Ć HƏ ˎ J9?r ;(ˎ ¥Ȃˎ v2 Hˎ IJ ˎ ¦ˎ ŔåƂŹƏ ĶźYķ+Ə ŝÓÃBsƏ ȃˎ VƏ C Ŷqˎ Ə _²ęƏ \Ə ˎ 'PƏ Ǹˎ \p ʗ"ˎ Ə 'ȥɇȳ˂ˎ ëfƏ $ŎÐW0ŻƏ ǛŬˎ ǜIˎ ǝȄ ǞMÊɈˎ ½ÔĸƏ Õ`Ə *aˎ ir ɵ ;|ȯˎ ĸƚ ¯ˎ ʪkʰˎ (ŽƛÀB'*ˎ ǟˎ džƜ¶Šˎ )Ë·ʃˎ 8Ə Mˎ " Ə -/4%1r r 2_$r & r őǹʔ¸Úˎ gČ#Ə ºHƏ 9Ɲˎ ģȦˎ ĮƞɧÛˎ FĤŪŷÀȅˎ [ďGÜˎ ¼Hˎ #2$N EFr r \Hˎ ! ɨțÝˎ ',=N =íĹƏ ɉeõˎ 1r· Eˎ D Ȇˎ ɔ?Ïùˎ Ðˎ \ƽYˎ ĜƏ Ñĩȴ ÒÞˎ ½8ɪˎ ½ƟƠ(Èˎ gr EAC GN OXr Č[ĒĖˎ ;or ĴǼˎ īLJʘSZˎ ,N ¬Ĭ4Ə /ƃ Ə ç ) 2Ə Ə ˎ ơ¹Ƣxšˎ ʱWˎ jr ÁM¡Q.!/ ˎ [Ir Ļ&+ȇˎ #*ˎ QƏ > ˃úˎ #Hr ®ø&Bĭ ŌtƏ ûˎ 1'>N iƏ ʲœˎ )ˎ P ÄɕȈyˎ ɖƣžƤˎ \Br ɗ+ƥʄ#ˎ XňƄĺ#ZĻƏ fr LjÉh¾ˎ !1Ʀɧ&ˎ hˎ ¯·ÖŞƏ Ħ4|ˎ ƾˎ ļ& ljÃ_ßˎ j]×Ə 9Ə Oˎ ÁǠ 2<Ţˎ [ėAƏ ƿˎ ĭ àˎ RƏ PÂˎ ɘǡ,ˎ fˎ YîLæuƏ Ê .ˎ ?ȉȵNJ6$ªˎ Ū ,ÑkƏ %Ə Łº=6Åáˎ Ɇ`ˎ Ǣˎ ǻˎ !:Ə ğuʅ=ə ȶâˎ gƏ ȧƧˎ ^Dr KRdr ɚɫƨƩſL+{ãˎ n¹ +ˎ ŏŊƏ ǣ| üˎ 'r ţ?ˎ ɬNjʙˎ 9ˎ Diƪˎ Ȋˎ r6ƀ ˎ ȭ &ƫˎ ¢ˎ ¾ Ɖȋʚˎ EǤ ȷˎ Qk(njʛjlˎ V4ƕ;Ƭˎ #Rˎ ùƏ v°^˄ýˎ 6r ņǷȬäˎ & ĉĖjÄú3Ə ,r L/N abr '5 +N Öˎ ŤɊˎ N ¾n .Ə ˎ ˎ ǀɭˎ ŔÆˎ (˅ɋ)ƭˎ (r Ĉ ƅØƏ şÉƏ MVr +7Iʆ ˎ ªƊˎ DŽˎ !hˎ ɛ> ,ˎ ʾʇ§ˎ Ǧˎ $`ˎ ˎ Ľ2ȌʝÇþˎ įˎ ťɸˎ @NÙ^+Ə Eˎ čļŨ/ ƏĮ?)Ə ŭˎ »ƉƏ ūÚƏ Åfŵ ĕĽĝoƏ Ůˎ ħȍȠòĵ& )ˋGˎ Ŵû3Ə ƁSȡm(Äˎ Nˎ ĹMɹʈȢˎ Ê>iżÛËƏ J? ʳˎ Ƃ1*Ʈȸ<µǎˎ ¨ˎ 0ʑTˎ 1fˎ ľ ƖȘʞċˎ İ ɮŕ.Hˎ Ňcˎ 5ŕƏ *HN VEvƏ D N `r 0/N +r ł-Ư@ǧ8}æˎ JN ;1 N ęçˎ ɜCZˎ ėēó[Đ ƆȎ ÌQˆˎ ʟǏˌ ǐư3ɺˎ Ŗˎ Ž)=ŖWÌƏ >Ə ³ Ƌˎ ˎ h9 Ə ǨƱˎ u ʉ 0ɻˎ ]Cr ÓǩȏÅˎ #6ühDƏ Ŀ& "#ʠèˎ NWr ýƏ ʊ Ȝˎ ɝ Aˎ ĠǪW>5Ôˎ ž+Ə Nˎ Îˎ )ˎ 78N dǃˎ 3LAr Qȝȣ=ǫ+Kˎ ǁˎ nˎ ʡǑUEn Aˎ ˎ %Ǭ_TKˎ ˇˎ 7 4qŬƏ ƌ³ ȹÆʋɯ # Sˎ eˎ ǭˎ ſ@'ľƏ 3ˎ £)IĎƀlƏ PYr Ə Ģ«ɰ-ˎ ×ˎ ¿ĞC }Ə 2Ə e=1w\hG# n ʋˈ ¶ ɅɆº ˈ GP >B U äRA9ˈ 9ˈ ˈ ľjfǔˈ Ō:Ǖˈ %j 4ª ()@ )9 , 9 &P1P _ -5&P +P ,LP ; j ŬCƆ NɰƇ ȓpLˈɱ ˈ ŗ$ bɴˈ n;.ˈ ő*¯ˈ Inw HS '#ˈ Q ) ˈ 8J +?:@P 0 ˈ i,OB8B k-T 26 fN¼P½ˈ Ǝfɯ ġˈ ŭ %ˈ ɜ GȐˈ O^=!ˈ j O?D6P Î k+ zk>#ˈ =ǀ ˄Ȕɝˈ `j Ô(j F%ȕƩǸˈ ı¾:ˈ ʒO!ˈ ŋȟbĢˈ sˈ 63Ƞˈ :DE j ®sƙˈ ;$@ ǹˈ Ū²°ˈ ^Z_Jj Ą0Ȗqˈ Ǻ ˈ µˈ ˈ C>6ˈ "?6ˈ S© ,; j J!(N F&j &+P ĸ,ˈ [) j * &FA&P "ˈ ŘBŮ cU/ˈ E9Ćˈ ʼnʨƫ/ˈ éȩ.ćˈ NU ª ĹÅˈ gˈ _+×'Ʉ1 ßˈ "ˈ ɾǖˈ ʓƚìˈ ¢5ˈ +iª ,P ;@ª ŒǻqHĈˈ ª '"NP )0P ĪKWˈ >&?P eĉˈ eˈ Jʶʊ8Ȫ`!ˈ 3ɫƗƼˈ ȡ.RǗ ˈ e*;(j ÙƬʹˈ { aˈ n|! :?/B"HP Yɿʔƭˈ I%j ʯƛ5ˈ + j Éɞ { (ˈ ˈ ʕíˈ &ˈ rʀˈ Iɟ*ʩƜˈ ƽ·ˈ ģɠ+ RǘůOˈ Ȟ¿ˈ ˈ Í<ˈ Ǚˈ È Ċˈ ŁɎn xæɵˈ TU Űˈ £ɭ}ȗǼEˈ RJ ˈ `J iàˈ P F*{mG`?ª I¤ja:n"#|Oª r9, IKMGLJU V9ª Úɇˈ űˈ 4ǚ*ǂċˈ ˈ 1ºˈ ĥŇXˈ *4P Bˈ P$Lƃˈ ]qª ĤSlɶ v%ˈ ˈ Ȣßˈ ɂ &G:@P AG P ab 1&.27U *8 P &Nª ĘĴȫęĚîˈ wēˈ ª &: P ţǛˈ ĵP ˈ ȣáˈ ǜ ʪˈ Ə#ˈ Ê-¼ʌIˈ DK,ˈ @P +>7 ,P 4P 4¥ˈ 64+@!;E9#4-P 2ns}o P +Ɵˈ 80ˈ xKª X- j lyª ENª XsRª ŎJ|Ș(ˈ ª &6<P ŅƖ1Gôˈ ª &:&-P ʙ27ˈ ˈ ʍ©PLjˈ ª ¯S ȦBˈ Ŵ^Ô ˈ Ħ ɓ¦ŵ½ƴˈ ʴˈ ĿɌŶˈ śǴ¨õˈ @ 2 @ (G:P P $Sj \pª e 5:HP &6 ˈ nLCP ʂˈ ǟ@ˈ "ˈ Ŕ-!Ȁ}ėˈ SU Ƶ Âɲ ʃ7ˈ >¨ª -:g ,)P 0 Jb ª $ HwB£ª P B?IJ2C P ǠŷUˈ YșZʺˈ ɏÊƠˈ ɥ mʚçˈ ŀ$Ț ˈ wƒ( j ª ǡ'ˈ ĝĞŤǢˈ ɔS@?ɛË ˈ o:P ª .b j ] ˈ ɷʛljNJ Hˈ =¦ª ɦuȋ }/ˈ j#ˈ ʰˈ ž2M,àˈ Ũ- ʜˈ 3P ũi ˈ "KAˈ ǣ <Ù/ˈ Zoª \/ j NjVǾ)ˈ 4P ¹ƀI¿öˈ 4 ˈ % ˈ Ǥª bˈ ?Kˈ Y5 j áÕdzʝˈ 3, 4 @ )Cª fˈ tˈ ª b6 j ʄ%ˈ ǥ ˈ ƓÚ rˈ zˈ @NP ±+Ãˈ 9ˈ A6% j Ì k _ˈ =§ª ķʞ;Ì;ƶˈ kˈ ( ˈ /?%45P ? P 69 59 Ÿ#ơˈ tg j 49 [ Öčˈ ňˇ2ˈ Ǧ ˈ YTǑ6ˈ 0Z.ˈ ħ, É Ɗ ˈ K =P 7Źʮ*Nnjˈ ʟɖˈ ˈ 2 ˈ ˈ Ĩ>%5ˈ ,,P ĭ¢Ďˈ +0@ ŜÆȧQďˈ ȳˈ I P ɍȴƘTȵȁÄLˈ A$? ˈ 'ª țȂȶÁ÷ˈ )@ ŝ¡) ʎ!ˈ ū'ÃL3øˈ LP 6zcª 'K#5 P c` U LM!ª ,-.9\0 j ' !0 C!IP ]ʻ(ˈ ɸÆƔDȃǍˈ 1āƊ èģ 7Q8S L'S c
%j ª ɹ´ɘùˈ W^tb_uSª ƂÛ[ʼˈ I%j [.#j ɪÇȜµˈ ȷˈ ǰˈ Ó x1ƕˈ G1)P k<ª )d j ƢBƄˈ ǧmˈ ?ʵˈ c JT8IGj H%j u:x e¥ª ɺ ɮ#Ȅã1ÄMˈ ʽúˈ Į¥'EJˈ ƿˈ (d5 1UDª ȅ+ ƣˈ ÝʏAˈ ņ Ƌˈ %\ MfRj oźȒ¡ɻˈ l ˈ ȸŻˈ ƷʠMǩˈ ʉ)·ˈ ƪˈ «ˈ Cv/ˈ »ˈ >ʬÐyȹˈ À Üˈ ʲ'¦ˈ ÐɼÓË ƌdûˈ )*n o©Q'Ñ 8t ˈ I%j j Ⱥʐ|ˈ "2w43V §aˈ |nt j ʈ§Ƹˈ ŧȻȏ~zˈ ĩ,¤ʤ)ȼˈ ȆPˈ ,OP Ŧˈ 1ˈ 2 ˈ X Y] C j ŞȌNˈ ˈ ,4# U (P ˈ gj %=ZN 3ª ÞDZ&E ˈ Ŗ.ɨˈ <Ƚ!ɽˈ ª -2P Ļ ˈ ȍ;\ʆl yˈ H%j ]%js.n ª ]2 j wh&üˈ 238)<,3->@ ÜǪˈ )vƹ ˈ ˈ ƤȇFʡˆˈ nv|' @"ˈ ˁ>ˀýˈ cˈ ¡ª şǵ(ˈ (PU $ 9 #-U }ª .7,P .9P Š)ˈ .ª * 2P 3 j ŃƥȾ ® âˈ Ç9ˈ ǫˈ S ǎ(ˈ 9 $;9U 7U _a DNE= P ʱǬˈ ZM~ˈ ǭ 4ˈ EfFps[_<U,n ~Wn53S \Oˈ W&^nyR2( hɳˈ @£ˈ JJSˈ n żGȈ i ȿˈ ȉrNƦƧˈ ª gJ+K$|Q2 XǷʾ#Vÿˈ e4IU j ƅˈ R/n %JH'hB9= j ğˈ -;P Ŋ×,þˈ ńɀ|Wˈ h ª -=P 5 ª š Dz<¬7Āˈ 'QU 8'(9 *U ~ ª 2/ P H@ U IʢD4ˈ ÞǮÒ ɩˈ XSu_&ʣˈ =6@ 3*"&9.?@ Fg$B:`ˈ M@P ¤ˈ ˈ ȨuQʿĔˈ Ēˈ -FP İ"Wˈ ļÏ+ʇãˈ [`ˈ Ľƺd<ŽɁāˈ /9 0 9 Ţ Ƕ'ƨĂˈ +9 ! U ? U ª 0+ U %«¾±3ˈ ǯˈ ´ǏƻOˈ Ûˈ əʥˈ %KHCj eBq{_@ 0m6 , ª