Registered with the Reg. No. TN/CH(C)/374/12-14 Registrar of Newspapers Licenced to post without prepayment for India under R.N.I. 53640/91 Licence No. TN/PMG(CCR)/WPP-506/12-14 Publication: 15th & 28th of every month Rs. 5 per copy (Annual Subscription: Rs. 100/-) WE CARE FOR MADRAS THAT IS CHENNAI INSIDE • Short ‘N’ Snappy • Slow renewal • Madras Week – 8 pages • Letters across the seas • Madras fabric
Vol. XXIV No. 9 MUSINGS August 16-31, 2014 Vanishing water Madras Landmarks (By The Editor) – 50 years ago here can be no denying that the Muttukadu Estuary is one of the most scenic spots near our city. TBut all that may not be for long, given the rampant construction activity going on in its vicinity. But what is worse is the unchecked extraction of groundwater by all the establishments in the area – chiefly IT companies, hotels and housing complexes. This is drying up one of the chief aquifers of the city and it does not bode well for a metro that is perennially water-starved. It is not as though we lack the laws. Since the 1980s, construction had been banned in this area, chiefly to protect the groundwater, which could be drawn by the city in times of need. This ban was, however, lifted in the last decade, mainly to cater to the demand of the IT sector. The considered opinion in the 1990s was that with rainwater harvesting schemes in place within Chennai, it might no longer need the water from Muttukadu. That has, however, proved to be a false assumption, for successively weak monsoons and the lack of proper implementation of rainwater harvesting have ensured that the city is once again searching for fresh sources of the precious liquid. As is usual when such bans are lifted, the stakeholders involved were all consulted. The qualifying remarks of Metrowater were a classic instance of bureaucratese: “Any major developments in the proposed tourism corridor should take into account the unique hydrological ecosystem of the area.” With that mild caution in place, everything was set for rapid ‘development’ of the estuary and its surroundings, with the present result. Groundwater extraction, however, is not the only issue. Dis- posal of sewage is a bigger problem. Many of the establishments here are draining their effluents into G Today it is a nondescript structure that houses the showroom of V.G. the estuary. It may not be long before the water body begins to resemble the Cooum. Experts are of Panneerdas & Co, the company that retails white goods and introduced hire the view that the groundwater in the area has already been irreversibly contaminated. purchase. But in its time, Victory House, Mount Road, was a landmark The Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority and the Corporation of Chennai are being address. Interestingly, the building’s beginnings go back to another merchandiser blamed for the present situa- of consumer products. In the 1890s, Whiteaway, Laidlaw’s, ‘Furnishers and tion. A majority of the struc- General Drapers’, were as much into textile retailing and tailoring as they were tures – be they hotels, offices, into selling a whole range of household requirements. The firm had branches residences or amusement parks throughout British India as well as in the capitals of many of the other British – in the area have been built in colonies in the East. As to who designed the structure is not clear, but it did bear violation of construction codes features of the work of William Pogson who specialised in buildings for retail and CRZ regulations. The two establishments in the city. High Court documents of the 1980s state that the regulatory bodies have chosen building was more than 100 years old at that time, thereby giving an idea about to turn a blind eye, despite be- its date of construction. ing armed with some of the Founded by Thomas Whiteaway and (later Sir) Robert Laidlaw, the firm’s strictest laws in the land. As we best years were till the Great War. It was also known as ‘Right away and paid have said in some of our earlier for’ because of its no credit policy. By the 1940s, with independence in the air, articles connected with building the firm was closing its Indian operations though it continued in the Far East till violations, the lethargy of our the 1960s. The Madras premises were sold to the Swadesamitran – the leading civic body when it comes to en- Tamil daily of the time. The paper was begun in 1882 as a weekly by forcing its rules is amazing. We G. Subramania Iyer, who had six years earlier co-founded The Hindu. After have already seen the kind of leaving The Hindu he was to focus on the Swadesamitran, making it a daily in havoc this has caused within 1899. After him, A. Rangaswami Iyengar of The Hindu was to also serve as the city in places like T’Nagar. editor of the Swadesamitran. It was during his time that Subramania Bharati The same situation appears to joined the paper for a second and short tenure, ending with his death in 1921. In be developing in the outskirts 1928, C.R. Srinivasan took over as editor and proprietor of the paper and it was also. under him that the paper scaled great heights in circulation. With so many buildings Srinivasan purchased the Whiteaway and Laidlaw property after World War coming up, the demand for wa- II and named it Victory House. Some great names in Tamil writing were to ter has skyrocketed in the area. work in the building for the paper. Following Srinivasan’s death in 1962 and the This has resulted in more and change in the tastes of the reading public, the paper declined. In 1977, the paper more borewells being installed, was sold to the Silver Jubilee of Independence Trust controlled by the Congress each with increasing depth to Party. It lingered on till 1985 when it stopped publication. It had since then tap the water that is fast reced- changed hands as a paper and there were sporadic attempts to revive it. During ing. Many of the housing com- the 1980s, a fire broke out in the building, destroying much of the newspaper plexes have more than one archive and nearly all the photo negatives – a 100-year history was lost in one borewell and some of these are evening. drying up within one or two years of drilling – an indication Victory House was rented out to various commercial establishments from of how fast we are using up the the 1970s. The ground floor, all 7000 sq ft of it, was occupied by VGP who water. These complexes have in moved in in 1971. In the early 1980s, the then owners decided that the building turn begun depending on water needed to be demolished and rebuilt, the existing structure showing signs of tankers, which in turn are weakness. All tenants barring VGP vacated and litigation followed which ended in 1987 with the High Court of Madras ordering the tenant to vacate. What th bringing in water from wells dug Celebrate the 375 birthday of MADras! followed next was VGP purchasing the entire property and constructing a (Continued on page 12) modern showroom-cum-office space in place of old Victory House. CMYK 2 MADRAS MUSINGS August 16-31, 2014 Slim-don’t-fits here comes a day in the been a second home to Julius went ahead with other work. Tlife of The Man from Ma- Ceasar, for he, as you remem- A good two hours later, he had dras Musings when he realises ber, wanted to have men a call. The TV anchor was on that he has nothing to wear. around him that were fat. The the phone apologising pro- This, by the way, is every other same applies to the women of fusely. Her cameraman had day, for MMM has just one Chennai as well, but of that gone out for lunch and just re- weakness – he likes his MMM will not speak, for he, turned and so could they come Pelicans nesting at Nelpattu. clothes, in which aspect he does not bandy about with then? They were, she also markedly differs from the women unnecessarily. added, just around the corner Chief, who chugs along main- And, so, given this tendency from MMM’s office. MMM taining that it is comfort that to put on weight, no doubt due secretly wondered as to why counts and not style. Not that to widespread availability of this call could not have been Revitalising the Chief does not turn out in junk food and increasingly sed- made when the cameraman the best of Savile Row when he entary lifestyles, how are fellow did not return at the appointed wants to. It was only the other Chennaiites coping with these hour but he held his counsel day that MMM saw the Chief drain pipe trousers and slim fit and agreed that they could conservation at a Consulate reception all shirts? Very well, apparently, come immediately. suited and booted and being for even as MMM stood and The corner that they had to the life and soul of the party. watched, several outsized men negotiate to reach MMM’s But to get back to the sad grabbed several of the trousers office was evidently one of traditions tale of MMM’s apparel – and and shirts and wheezed their those long ones, for, after half how sad it is. Knowing MMM’s way to the payment counter. an hour or so, there was no elivering the Pupul Jayakar Lecture hosted by INTACH in propensity to lament about the MMM wonders as to how they sign of anyone even remotely DDelhi, Prof. Madhav Gadgil said, “A community involves not lack of suitable wear, his good can fit in. He assumes that they resembling a cameraman who only human population but other beneficient elements such as hills lady periodically hauls him buy two of each and then gets had fed well or a TV anchor and rivers, woods and trees, birds and monkeys, and according such upto the various malls that dot them stitched into one. who was eager to get MMM’s the city. views on heritage. beings respect, even veneration.” There, under her eagle eye, Indian Stretchable It was late in the evening, “India’s rich heritage of conservation traditions evolved in a MMM tries out various shirts long after the Ra in the heav- society that instinctively respected nature in India. Let us not for- and trousers, only to have her Time ens has set, that the trio – in- get that,” he said. reject most of them. After ome Madras Week and terviewer, cameraman and Prof. Gadgil pointed out that “scientific practices of nature con- having worn everyone down CThe Man from Madras general helper – trooped in. servation in no way represent a real advance over the traditional during the course of a longish Musings suddenly begins get- They were ushered in to a con- folk-knowledge- based systems. All that has happened is that the afternoon, MMM and good ting phone calls from newspa- ference area where they were spatial scale of efforts to conserve biodiversity has changed along lady depart, having made some per correspondents, radio jock- asked to set up their equip- with enlargement of resource catchments or footprints of modern purchases. eys and TV anchors. MMM is ment and then call MMM But nothing in Chennai can generally quite happy to talk to when ready. A good 45 min- societies.” He felt our scientific understanding of complex ecologi- proceed smoothly and one of them but there is one variety utes later, the all-clear was cal systems is in fact still very limited. At present there are no uni- these is the size of these that gets his goat – the one that blown and the cry went versal laws to guide ecological management comparable to the laws clothes. They are no longer does not do its homework be- around for MMM to duly of physics and chemistry, for example, that enabled Man to land what they used to be. Those fore calling. He is therefore, appear. on the moon. The professor spoke at length about the destruction to nature and people’s livelihood so widely prevalent in our times. The most glaring example he cited was the Vedanta site in Odisha where SHORT ’N’ SNAPPY forested slopes and flowing streams of the Niyamgiri hills provide a living to the Kondh tribes. The rich biodiversity of the Niyamgiri massif critically links a series of forests and wildlife sanctuaires. who know MMM personally usually very short (and MMM went across to be Today it is threatened by mining operations. The Vedanta site is will agree that he is built on snappy) with the kind that met by a beaming anchor, a one of the main sources of Vamsadhdhara River, and mining op- what are known as generous calls and asks him to tell “all cameraman who was all burps, erations would result in a hydrological disaster, destroying the very proportions (known in Delhi that he knows about Bucking- and a surly helper who no integrity of its ecosystem. It also severely disturbs 7 sq. km of wild- as healdhee type). He is broad ham Canal” or, for that mat- doubt had not had his lunch. life habitat wrecking its ecology. The Kondhs are agitated because where he ought not to be, and ter, “the Beach”. To these he MMM extended a wintry smile they believe their survival is at stake. that means clothes that allow responds by tersely informing and asked them as to what did The Government of India Forest Rights Act (FRA) vests for certain roominess, espe- them that Google would be the owe the pleasure of the visit. cially in leg wear. That is, how- best source for what they re- “We came to discuss clock recognisable community and habitat rights, with its preamble ever, sadly no longer the case, quire. Several of this kind towers with you, Sir”, gushed clearly stating that forest dwellers are “integral to the very survival for some madness has gripped never call back after that, but the anchor. “We want to know and sustainability of the forest ecosystem.” The FRA further authorises all the designer labels in the some of the more persistent why most of them don’t work the Gram Sabhas to ensure that their habitat is preserved from any city which are now churning ones do and these need to be and why those that do are not destructive practices affecting their cultural and natural heritage. out only slim fits. These begin humoured. keeping the correct time. And The Forest Rights Act, however, has not been formalised to with a waist size approaching One of the last named kind also are they relevant today date, with the result, the District Administrations have often failed zero and then go on to narrow was recently in touch with when everyone has watches to to act either fairly or firmly to protect the rights of the Kondhs. In legs. Imagine MMM’s plight MMM. She, it transpired, was remind them of the time and fact, the State Government has already taken a decision to trans- when he has to try and strug- from a TV channel that takes the necessity for punctuality?” fer tribal land to the mining group. Dr. Gadgil pointed out: “Not gle into them. He made bold its name from Soleil who lights So much for heritage! to ask as to what had hap- only is the transfer of community resources for mining without seeking up our day. In terms of chan- pened to the older and broader nels, this would qualify as Tailpiece their informed consent unfair, it is also illegal after the enactment of the fits and was given a contemp- THE channel of channels and FRA.” tuous glance by the sales help as The Man from Madras MMM was loath to give her Musings heard of Prof. Gadgil spoke about many other instances of rights being at one of the outfitters. The short shrift. She said she was H blatantly violated in other States as well. He cited Karwar which good lady shushed MMM Kisholam, asked a junior keen to get my views on some reporter from a famed national was incorporaed into Karnataka in 1960 under the Linguistic firmly by asking him to change aspect of heritage and so could with the times. MMM would newspaper. MMM had not. Reorganisation of States. Some villagers learned that their land she call on me at the earliest? The caller was astounded. would be taken over and so quickly razed it to the ground in just 2 love to, but his figure no MMM agreed and we fixed a longer can change. How could MMM, who had weeks. The case dragged on for many long years, till eventually the time. MMM also warned the worked so closely with the High Court ordered that the land be given back to the villagers. What surprises MMM is correspondent that he had a Chief who literally drips his- Concluding his talk by describing many other such instances of that the slim fit has hit the fetish for punctuality and that tory, not know of Kisholam his time was not his own. So FRA violations, Prof. Gadgil posed a devastating question: Should racks just when Chennai is go- the architect whose death cen- ing through one of the most could she please make it on our biodiversity wealth be surrendered to moneyed mining inter- tenary falls this year and about obese phases in its existence. time? The woman agreed and whom one of the Chief’s side- ests, just to serve a capital-intensive economy that is so wasteful of All around him MMM sees said that she and her team natural resources? The Western world could afford to do it once kicks was giving a talk? It was men with paunches hanging would be at MMM’s office by quite a while after he had hung upon a time as they had successfully accumulated large capital out, waists ballooning from 3.00 pm sharp. up that MMM realised that the stocks through colonisation. India cannot afford this extravagance. trousers, and necks disappear- The time came and went reporter was talking about This question needs to be posed in all Indian States. And also needs ing behind bulging jowls. Just and not a sign of the team from Chisholm (‘Chishum’ for the to be responded by the new Government. (Courtesy: Virasat – the by looking at them you can the sun god’s own channel. uninitiated). journal of INTACH) guess that our city would have MMM did not bother and – MMM August 16-31, 2014 MADRAS MUSINGS 3