Comparison of Active Renin Concentration and Plasma Renin
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
European Journal of Endocrinology (2004) 150 517–523 ISSN 0804-4643 CLINICAL STUDY Comparison of active renin concentration and plasma renin activity for the diagnosis of primary hyperaldosteronism in patients with an adrenal mass Nicole Unger1, Ingo Lopez Schmidt1, Christian Pitt4, Martin K Walz4, Thomas Philipp2, Klaus Mann1,3 and Stephan Petersenn1 1 Division of Endocrinology, Medical Center, 2 Division of Nephrology and Hypertension, Medical Center, 3 Department of Clinical Chemistry, University of Essen and 4 Department of Surgery and Centre of Minimally Invasive Surgery, Kliniken Essen-Mitte, Essen, Germany (Correspondence should be addressed to S Petersenn, Division of Endocrinology, Medical Center, University of Essen, Hufelandstr. 55, 45122 Essen, Germany; Email: [email protected]) Abstract Objective: Plasma aldosterone concentration (PAC) to plasma renin activity (PRA) ratio is an established screening test for primary hyperaldosteronism. Due to the increased recognition of adrenal incidentalomas, reliable parameters are required. Determination of active renin concentration (ARC) in contrast to PRA offers advantages with regard to processing and standardization. The present study compared PRA and ARC under random conditions to establish thresholds for the diagnosis of primary hyperaldosteronism. Design and methods: Fifty patients with various adrenal tumors, including ten patients with aldo- sterone-secreting adrenal adenomas, as well as ten hypertensive patients and 23 normotensive volunteers were studied. PAC and PRA were measured by radioimmunoassay. ARC was determined by an immunoluminometric assay. Results: Receiver operating curve (ROC) analysis suggested a PAC to ARC ratio threshold of 90 ((ng/l)/(ng/l)) (sensitivity 100%, specificity 98.6%) and a ratio threshold of 62 by additional consider- ation of PAC $200 ng/l (sensitivity 100%, specificity 100%) for the diagnosis of aldosterone-secreting adrenal adenomas. Conclusions: A PAC to ARC ratio of $62 in patients with PAC levels $200 ng/l is a reliable screening method for primary hyperaldosteronism in patients with an aldosterone-producing adenoma under random conditions. Because of its advantages with regard to probe processing and its independence from endogenous angiotensinogen levels, ARC may be preferred to PRA. European Journal of Endocrinology 150 517–523 Introduction either PAC or PRA, the PAC to PRA ratio seems to be independent of diurnal and day-to-day variations, salt Primary hyperaldosteronism is classically characterized intake and diuretics. It was demonstrated as a reliable by a combination of hypertension, hypokalemia, and convenient screening tool for ambulatory con- suppressed renin and an elevated non-suppressible ditions, independent of body posture (6). However, a plasma aldosterone concentration. Measurement of recent study revealed a low reproducibility of the ratio these single parameters does not allow a reliable diag- in patients with an aldosterone-producing adrenal ade- nosis. Normokalemia is noted in patients with primary noma under random conditions (7). PRA is determined hyperaldosteronism (1–3), as well as suppressed renin by radioimmunological measurement of angiotensin-1 in hypertensive patients (4, 5). Due to improved generated from angiotensinogen during in vitro incu- methods in computed tomography (CT) or magnetic bation with plasma renin. However, determination is resonance imaging (MRI), adrenal incidentalomas are limited to physiological angiotensinogen levels. Con- increasingly found. Accurate parameters to distinguish ditions with decreased angiotensinogen levels (e.g. aldosterone-secreting adrenal adenomas from other liver cirrhosis, severe cardiac failure) result in the functioning or non-functioning adrenal masses are underestimation of renin (8, 9). In contrast, estrogen therefore required. treatment increases angiotensinogen levels, resulting The plasma aldosterone concentration (PAC) to in an overestimation of renin (10, 11). The lack of stan- plasma renin activity (PRA) ratio was suggested as a dardization is another methodical disadvantage. screening tool for the diagnosis of primary hyperaldos- Processing of plasma samples, especially in regard to teronism (1). In contrast to single measurement of incubation time, pH and dilution varies among different q 2004 Society of the European Journal of Endocrinology Online version via http://www.eje.org Downloaded from Bioscientifica.com at 09/30/2021 11:59:54PM via free access 518 N Unger and others EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ENDOCRINOLOGY (2004) 150 Table 1 Clinical characterization of the population studied. Values are means^S.D. Diagnosis No. of patients Age (years) Sex (male/female) Tumor size (cm) Aldosterone-secreting adenoma 10 51.4^13.3 3/7 1.8^0.6 Cortisol-secreting adenoma 7 43.7^12.5 0/7 3.3^0.8 Pheochromocytoma 12 49.3^16.5 6/6 3.8^2.5 Non-functioning adrenal mass (NFM) 21 51.9^12.6 10/11 3.9^2.6 Essential hypertension 10 41.6^11.4 6/4 na Healthy volunteers 23 34.2^12.2 10/13 na Total 83 44.6^14.6 35/48 na na, not available. laboratories. In patients with suppressed renin, the removed. The diagnosis was postoperatively confirmed ratio is clearly dependent on the lower detection limit. by histological and immunohistochemical examin- An assay sensitivity of 0.5 ng/ml per hour for a PRA ations as well as clinical follow-up. assay compared with 0.1 ng/ml per hour for another Controls included ten patients with essential hyper- assay results in an unequivocal lower PAC to PRA ratio. tension and 23 healthy normotensive volunteers To avoid these disadvantages, generation of mono- taking an ad libitum sodium diet. In patients with essen- clonal antibodies against active renin allowed direct tial hypertension, endocrine disorders were excluded by measurement of active renin concentration (ARC) inde- the following tests: primary hyperaldosteronism was pendent from angiotensinogen levels. Standardization excluded by a normal PAC and PAC to PRA ratio; Cush- of ARC measurement by calibration against a WHO ing’s syndrome was investigated by midnight plasma standard enables improved comparability among differ- cortisol levels and a dexamethasone suppression test; ent laboratories. The present study compared PRA and pheochromocytoma was excluded by normal meta- ARC under random conditions to investigate the use of nephrines and urinary catecholamines. Furthermore, ARC for the diagnosis of primary hyperaldosteronism in renal artery stenosis was excluded by MRI and/or patients with aldosterone-producing adenomas. duplex ultrasound in nine of ten patients. In total, 83 subjects were included in this prospective study (perti- nent data are given in Table 1). Materials and methods At the time of investigation, patients with an aldos- Subjects terone-secreting adrenal adenoma, patients with pheo- chromocytoma, and patients with hypertension were Fifty patients with a current adrenal mass were on various antihypertensive medications, as well as grouped into four categories: ten aldosterone-secreting nine hypertensive patients with non-functioning adre- adrenal adenomas; seven cortisol-secreting adrenal nal adenomas. Three of ten patients with an aldoster- adenomas (one subclinical and six overt Cushing’s syn- one-producing adenoma received spironolactone dromes), 12 pheochromocytomas; and 21 non-func- preoperatively (Table 2). tioning adrenal masses (17 non-functioning Blood samples were drawn from patients in an adenomas, two cysts, one metastasis of bronchial carci- upright body position from a forearm vein between noma, one myeololypoma). The diagnoses were made 0800 h and 0900 h. The study protocol was approved preoperatively by appropriate biochemical parameters by the local ethical committee and informed consent in combination with evidence of an adrenal mass on was given by all patients. CT or MRI. Primary hyperaldosteronism due to an adre- nal adenoma was diagnosed by a plasma aldosterone to Assays renin activity ratio $300 (ng/l to ng/ml per h) and PA C $200 ng/l (12) and in part confirmed by increased PAC was measured by RIA (Byk & DiaSorin, Dietzen- urinary aldosterone-18-glucuronide excretion, saline bach, Germany). The normal range in an upright pos- infusion test, adrenal vein sampling and/or postural ition was 100–350 ng/l. Assay sensitivity was 50 ng/l stimulation test. Four patients showed a normokaliemic and assay variability was determined by within-assay hyperaldosteronism. In these ten patients, CT or MRI coefficients of variation (CV) of 11.2% for 73 ng/l and revealed a unilateral adrenal mass. Clinical follow-up 8.2% for 308 ng/l and between-assay CV values of was carried out in five patients demonstrating a nor- 17.7% for 73 ng/l, 10.4% for 208 ng/l and 6.6% for malized PAC to PRA ratio postoperatively. Because of 454 ng/l. the limitations of the screening parameters, patients PRA was also determined by RIA (Byk & DiaSorin). with mild hyperaldosteronism might have been The normal range in an upright position was 1.8– undiagnosed. 6.3 ng/ml per hour. Assay sensitivity was 0.1 ng/ml Except for five non-functioning adenomas with a size per hour. Within-assay CV values were 7.5% for less than 3 cm, all adrenal masses were subsequently 0.17 ng/ml per hour, 5.4% for 8.8 ng/ml per hour www.eje.org Downloaded from Bioscientifica.com at 09/30/2021 11:59:54PM via free access EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ENDOCRINOLOGY (2004) 150 Diagnosis of primary hyperaldosteronism 519 Table 2 Medication in patients with hypertension. Aldosterone-secreting Cortisol-secreting Essential Medication adenoma adenoma Pheochromocytoma NFM hypertension a blockers 2 — 6 1 1 b blocker 6 4 1 3 7 Ca-channel blocker 4 2 2 5 7 ACE inhibitors 4 1 2 4 3 AT1-receptor antagonists — 2 1 2 1 Diuretics 2 1 1 2 1 Clonidin 1 — — 1 1 Spironolactone 3 — — — — ACE, angiotensin converting enzyme; AT1, angiotensin-A. and 9.9% for 13.5 ng/ml per hour. Between-assay CV analysis suggested a ratio threshold value of 680 (sen- values were 7.7% for 2.6 ng/ml per hour, 8.1% for sitivity 100%, specificity 91.8%, area under the curve 8.6 ng/ml per hour and 11.5% for 13.0 ng/ml per hour.