K a R N a T a K U N I V E R S I T Y, DHARWAD DEPARTMENT of LEGAL CELL STATEMENT SHOWING the DETAILS of the COURT CASES DISPOSED of TILL November 2018 1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 K A R N A T A K U N I V E R S I T Y, DHARWAD DEPARTMENT OF LEGAL CELL STATEMENT SHOWING THE DETAILS OF THE COURT CASES DISPOSED OF TILL November 2018 1. MATTER RELATING TO SERVICE PARTICULARS S.No WP/WA/OS/etc Petitioner Name Against Matter relating to Details of Order passed Univ Advocate Quashing the order Dt: 04.01.2002 by W.P. rejected on 28.01.2008 as there is Dr. R.M. W.P. NO. Smt. S.R. Mane & which Smt. S.R. Mane was appointed as no illegality or impropriety on the part of 1. Sonakamble, V.B. Ganachari 9274/02 KUD Lecturer & to appoint Petitioner as BOA in selecting Smt. S.R. Mane for the Gulbarga Lecturer in Social Work etc post of Lecturer in Social Work. Quashing the order dt: 26.02.2005 by W.P. allowed on 28.01.2008 setting State Govt. & which the appointment of the Petitioner aside the order Dt: 26.02.2005 by which 2. W.P. NO. 10529/05 Smt. S.R. Mane N.B. Bhat K.U.D. was nullified by the State Govt. the appointment of Smt. S.R. Mane was nullified Quashing of Seniority list Dt: 01.07.2002 Dismissed on 22.09.2008 as having M.M. Gaikwad & & to finalize list considering objections & become infructous as 1st Petitioner N.B. Bhat/ 3. W.P. NO. 34664-68/02 K.U.D Others also calling fresh objections. retired, 2 to 5 Respondent promoted as M.S. Hiremath Dy. Registrar / O.S. Quashing the order Dt: 11.09.01, 28.12.01 and W.P. dismissed on 23.07.2008 as his 24.04.03 issued by the Registrar by Which his contention that decision of the Syn. W.P. NO. 32310/03 4. S.N. Huddar K.U.D annual increments of 99 & 2000 were withheld rejecting his appeal is not speaking order R.U. Gouley & treating suspension period form 18-8-94 to is not correct 21-11-99 as L.W.P. & rejecting his appeal by the syndicate. Challenging the order of the single Judge W.A. dismissed on 18.02.2009 as devoid in W.P. No. 32310/2003 of merits reserving liberty to the 5. W.A. 5081/08 S.N. Huddar K.U.D appellant for redress his grievances C.R. Gouley before the authorities if so advised or need arises. Smt. Sushila G. For declaration of her name in pensionery Dismissed on 29.10.2009 by the 1st Addl 6. O.S. 524/02 KUD K.L. Patil Sadhani benefits like GPF, DCRG, Pension etc., C.J. (Jr.Dn) Smt. Sushila G. Regular appeal against order in O.S. No. Dismissed on 26.09.2008 by the IInd 7. R.A. No. 219/03 KUD .. Sadhani 524/02 Addl. Civil Judge (Sr. Dn) Quashing select list prepared by the W.P. allowed on 18.06.07 directing the University appointing respondent 2 to 11 University to consider the application of as per annexure – D (govt. employees) the Petitioner to the post of 8. W.P. NO. 8736/03 S.F. Mushannavar K.U.D. proceed making appointment on basis of peon/Watchman on basis of marks N.B. Bhat age –cum-merit scored qualifying Exam (He was informed on 29.10.08 as not eligible as per merit) 2 S.No WP/WA/OS/etc Petitioner Name Against Matter relating to Details of Order passed Univ Advocate Quashing the Order dt: 29-10-07 Disposed of on 4-3-2009 directing the respondents to consider the Application to the post of Peon/Watchman on the N.B.Bhat 9. W.P.No.20202/07 S.F. Mushannavar KUD basis of marks obtained in 4th Std & MSHiremath without reference to the Marks obtained in the Interview. Quashing the order dt: 19.07.2003 by which he was assigned minimum of the Disposed of on 08.09.2008 as abated in N.B. Bhat 10. W.P. NO. 31723/03 M.Y. Dasanakoppa K.U.D. scale of Rs. 3300-6300 in view of lapses view of death of the Petitioner. M.S. Hiremath of duties at the revaluation of Engineering examination. To consider the service rendred in the LIC Disposed of on 07.11.2008 to count the Dr. S.S. for the purpose of counting as qualifying entire service rendered LIC for the said 11. W.P. No. 31448/03 K.U.D. V.B. Ganachari Vishwashwaraih service for pension & for payment of benefits as preyed by the Petitioner consequential retiral benefits Dr.S.S. Challenging the Order dt:7-11-08 Appeal is dismissed on 18-11-09 as 12. W.A. No. 1302/ 09 KUD N.B.Bhat Vishweshwaraih Passed in W.P.No.31448/03 withdrawn To regularize the services of the Petitioner Allowed partly on 08.01.07. Quashed & to pay all consequential benefits. Interim order Dt: 08.06.05 by which petitioner prayer not to terminate the Petitioner from was informed that he is not eligible for the services appointment to the post of driver as per 13. W.P. NO. 22641/05 Syed Mohammed K.U.D. C&R rules, directed the University to N.B. Bhat reconsider afresh the request of Petitioner for regularization & pass order in accordance with law (Informed by order dt:23.07.07 rejecting the request) Quashing University letter Dt: 20.11.2004 Disposed of on 10.12.2007 with informing that she is not entitled for direction to the Petitioner to submit 14. W.P. NO. 19336/05 Smt. S.V. Chavadi K.U.D. pensionery benefits as not completed representation along with GO & other N.B. Bhat/ minimum required 15 years of Service. documents (Pension sanctioned as per P.O. Dt: 17.04.2008) Quashing Res. No. 5, Dt: 06.08.03 of Disposed of on 05.06.2007.Set aside University Advisory Committee and order NSS Advisory Committee proceedings Dt: 21.01.04 of University by which relating to petitioner. Remitted back to 15. W.P. NO. 23205/05 K.K. Kurbet K.U.D. revised pay scales assigned to petitioner the Registrar, K.U.D for fresh N.B. Bhat were cancelled & to pay as per NSS consideration & to take decision in prevailing rules. accordance with law after considering representations from the petitioner. SLP (Civil) No. 1740/05 To quash the disciplinary proceedings SLP dismissed on 15.02.2007 16. Before supreme Court S.B. Kanavi KUD initiated against him S.N. Bhat Delhi 17. W.P. No. 774/05 C.G. Hiremath KUD To Fix pay scale as per Imrapur The W.P. disposed of on 25-1-2005 with N.B.Bhat 3 S.No WP/WA/OS/etc Petitioner Name Against Matter relating to Details of Order passed Univ Advocate Committee Report & to grant directions to the Respondents to consider consequencial benefits & to consider the the representation & to pass appropriate representations in accordance with law. orders. To quash the order dt: 04.04.2005 & to fix Dismissed on 23.09.2008 as the pay scale as per Imrapur Committee report petitioner having joined after N.B.Bhat 18. W.P. No. 24563/05 C.G. Hiremath KUD Commencement of KSU Act not entitled M.S.Hiremath for Imrapur committee report. Declaring the University’s action of W.P. allowed on 20.07.2005 holding that conducting interview for the post of Peon petitioners are held entitled for being /Watchman and selection made therein and considered for the post of Peon/Watchman by Smt. Jayashree R. 19. W.P. No. 8148-49/03 K.U.D appointing respondent R-3 to R-21 as taking into account their merit as per the N.B.Bhat Terdal & Another illegal, arbitrary & controversial to Special qualifying examination only without referring to the marks assigned to them at the Requirement Rules 2001- under backlog interview. Further directed University to redo vacancies. the select list Challenging the order passed in W.P. No. W.A. Dismissed on 26.02.2009 as Smt. Jayashree R. N.B. Bhat 20. W.A. No. 3743/05 KUD 8148-49/2003 filed by Smt. J.R. Terdal & devoid of merits Terdal & Another M.S. Hiremath another. SLP © cc 19279/09 Smt. Jayashree R. Challenging the Order dt: 26-2-09 in W.A S.L.P dismissed as condonation of delay 21. KUD S.K.Kulkarni (Before Supreme Court) Terdal No.3743/05 not granted. Quashing the order Dt: 03.09.04 by which Disposed of on 24.06.2005 with a the promotion of the petitioner as Reader direction to the petitioner to submit withdrawn & re-designated as Lecturer objection to order dt: 03.09.2004 & the 22. W.P. No. 13036/05 Dr. D.R. Albal K.U.D (Sr. Scale) in view of audit objections & to University to consider the same as no N.B.Bhat permit the petitioner to continue in the opportunity given before passing said merit promotion Scheme order. To consider the representation on dt; Disposed of on 01.03.2007 to consider 13.04.2004 fixing the pension at Rs. 8262/- per the representation of the petitioner Prof. G. 23. W.P. 44719/2004 KUD month & to pay difference of commutation dt: 13.04.2004 & pass order in N.B. Bhat Gourishankar amount of Rs. 15,186/- difference amount accordance with law in the light of pension of Rs. 387/- per month from date of notification issued from time to time. retirement along with 12% interest. Prof.