The Political and Economic Debates of the New York State Canal System 1895 – 1903

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Political and Economic Debates of the New York State Canal System 1895 – 1903 Union College Union | Digital Works Honors Theses Student Work 6-2015 Holding Water: The olitP ical and Economic Debates of the New York State Canal System 1895 – 1903 Erich Grome Union College - Schenectady, NY Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalworks.union.edu/theses Part of the Transportation Commons, and the United States History Commons Recommended Citation Grome, Erich, "Holding Water: The oP litical and Economic Debates of the New York State Canal System 1895 – 1903" (2015). Honors Theses. 318. https://digitalworks.union.edu/theses/318 This Open Access is brought to you for free and open access by the Student Work at Union | Digital Works. It has been accepted for inclusion in Honors Theses by an authorized administrator of Union | Digital Works. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Holding Water The Political and Economic Debates of the New York State Canal System 1895 – 1903 Erich D. Grome Senior Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for Honors in the Department of History Department of Economics Department of History Union College June, 2015 2 Dedication: This work is dedicated to my mother and father. If it were not for your loving and unceasing care, support, and dedication to my upbringing and education, this historical piece would certainly not have been possible. Acknowledgments: There are several people who should rightfully be acknowledged for their time and effort in guiding and assisting me in completing this work. First and foremost, I would like to recognize and thank my thesis advisors, professors Brad Lewis and Andrew Morris. Specifically, I would like to note Professor Lewis’s commitment to a more classical, extensive, and interconnected outlook on the field of Economics, known as Cliometrics, which has certainly shaped my perspective of the major and its application in the world today. Moreover, I would like to cite the immense amount of time spent by and the passion instilled in me by Professor Morris in relation to the pursuance of my Barge Canal study and the vast improvement in my writing ability. Furthermore, I would like to express my appreciation for the several canal historians who have dedicated so much of their time and effort to the preservation of the waterway’s history so that current and future generations will never forget the tremendous exploits of the past. Among these laboring individuals were Craig Williams, Duncan Hayes, and Daniel Ward, as well as the helpful staff of the New York State Library and Archives, all of whom assisted in one manner or another throughout my research and writing process. Finally, I owe a debt of gratitude to all the fine professors, faculty, and staff of Union College for their tireless efforts to make the campus a place of learning and maturation. 3 Table of Contents: Introduction: 6 – 35 Chapter I: Decline of Clinton’s Ditch 36 – 65 Chapter II: From Disastrous Debacle to Decisive Discussion 66 – 89 Chapter III: Casual Insight Turns to Contemplative Investigation 89 – 117 Chapter IV: From Careful Detailing to Contentious Debate 118 – 155 Chapter V: Converting Tumultuous Discord into Legislative Triumph 156 – 188 Chapter VI: Parliamentary Progress Produces Plebiscite Proclamation 189 – 236 Concluding Considerations: 237 – 244 Bibliography: 245 – 252 4 Abstract: With the allure of the famed Erie Canal deteriorating as swiftly as its traffic and physical condition by the latter half of the nineteenth century, New Yorkers gave serious thought to the future of the waterway. As the commerce of the state and its renowned metropolis of New York City declined relative to its rival states and ports during this period, many questioned if enlarging the canal system would lead to its revival and produce similar results for the economy of the state at large. An ever frequent scene of partisan conflict, the proposals to radically enlarge the Erie Canal faced relentless antagonism from competing railroads, distrustful farmers, and wary upstate residents, while receiving the habitually vacillating and oftentimes divided support of canal advocates across New York State. Promoters championed the project as vital to the state and nation to ensure cheaper and adequately regulated transportation rates, resulting in heightened commerce and prosperity, just as it had in the past. Conversely, opponents decried the proposal as antiquated infrastructure and a colossal waste of public funds. Taking its final form as the Barge Canal and approved by referendum in 1903, the significantly enlarged waterway changed course through canalizing lakes and rivers, bypassing numerous cities that its predecessor helped found. In this new canal era, the Barge Canal soon became a stimulus for economic success and expansion throughout the region, just as the Erie Canal had been catalyst for New York State the century before. 5 Treading Water and Land: Deliverance; the question that has captivated the minds of mankind since its primordial existence. No, this is not in reference to some divine revelation, but rather to the theme of transportation, one that began with the debate that drove the first primitive human being to climb down from the safety of its tree and cross the open and treacherous grasslands in search of more fruitful prospects. Since this initial decision of exploratory movement to brave the unknown dangers that lay beyond the horizon, humanity has been in a continuous pursuit of improving and easing the means by which they travel from one point to another. Such inquisitive thinking resulted in the inventing of the wheel, unequivocally revolutionizing world history forever, but what about before that? Certainly, early humans encountered large bodies of water and realized their ability to float upon them, along with the similar ability of other materials. Subsequently, makeshift rafts and boats were constructed and thus, aquatic transportation was born, further shaping human civilization and its impact upon the planet. Evolving through time, mankind no longer wished to be bound by the borders and courses of the natural waterways and set out to construct channels that served their travel needs. With the advent of canals, humanity would endeavor to expand their development and tame the wilderness through the further utilization of cheap water travel. Eventually reaching the shores of North America and gazing upon upstate New York’s vast woodlands, flanked on each side by the Great Lakes to the west and the Hudson River to the east, the new holders of this land eyed it with visions of opportunity and enterprise. “The chief element in the prosperity of every State or Nation is the economy of transportation of persons and property. It is the most marked fact in the difference 6 between civilization and barbarism.”1 Though espoused by Horatio Seymour in an 1882 letter, this notion was undoubtedly held by most enlightened people throughout history and certainly inspired DeWitt Clinton to pursue the imaginative undertaking. The fantastical venture alluded to was the construction of the Erie Canal from 1817 to 1825 through the pristine landscape of upstate New York to connect the Midwest to the Atlantic seaboard. The economic gains that would be achieved through the opening and settlement of these regions were enormous, resulting not only from the exploitation of natural resources but from the establishment of agriculture and manufacturing. These developments would undoubtedly occur across New York State, but more important would be its creation of a gateway to the inland western territories. The watery corridor would benefit populaces in the Midwest, New York City, and everywhere in between. Such enthusiastic economic expectations served DeWitt Clinton and other advocates in refuting incessant naysayers, and the near immediate prosperity generated upon the waterway’s completion silenced all critics for nearly a generation. Yet, there was another distinct element employed for the promotion of and perpetuated by the Erie Canal, pride and patriotism. The notion of patriotism that Clinton espoused was more multifaceted and overarching than the simplistic definition of nationalistic pride in use today. The interpretation that he and other statesmen of his generation, as well as the next few generations, held was an idea of enlightened thinking that inspired one to promote the cultivation and progression of knowledge, science, culture, economics, and general wellbeing of the public. Synonymous with civic duty, virtue, and responsibility, such a 1 Henry W. Hill, A Historical Review of Waterways and Canal Construction in New York State, Vol. 12 (Buffalo, New York: Buffalo Historical Society, 1908), p 474. 7 liberal ethos aimed to foster the betterment of society, manifesting in one respect with the construction infrastructural projects under the auspices of a just, benevolent government absent of self-serving motives. For DeWitt Clinton, the Erie Canal exemplified this ideal, espousing in his first address as governor in 1818: When we consider that every portion of the nation will feel the animating spirit and vivifying influences of these great works; that they will receive the benediction of posterity and command the approbation of the civilized world; we are required to persevere by every dictate of interest, by every sentiment of honor, by every injunction of patriotism, and by every consideration which ought to influence the councils and govern the conduct of a free, high-minded, enlightened, and magnanimous people.2 Even when
Recommended publications
  • Low Bridge, Everybody Down' (WITH INDEX)
    “Low Bridge; Everybody Down!” Notes & Notions on the Construction & Early Operation of the Erie Canal Chuck Friday Editor and Commentator 2005 “Low Bridge; Everybody Down!” 1 Table of Contents TOPIC PAGE Introduction ………………………………………………………………….. 3 The Erie Canal as a Federal Project………………………………………….. 3 New York State Seizes the Initiative………………………………………… 4 Biographical Sketch of Jesse Hawley - Early Erie Canal Advocate…………. 5 Western Terminus for the Erie Canal (Black Rock vs Buffalo)……………… 6 Digging the Ditch……………………………………………………………. 7 Yankee Ingenuity…………………………………………………………….. 10 Eastward to Albany…………………………………………………………… 12 Westward to Lake Erie………………………………………………………… 16 Tying Up Loose Ends………………………………………………………… 20 The Building of a Harbor at Buffalo………………………………………….. 21 Canal Workforce……………………………………………………………… 22 The Irish Worker Story……………………………………………………….. 27 Engineering Characteristics of Canals………………………………………… 29 Early Life on the Canal……………………………………………………….. 33 Winter – The Canal‘sGreatest Impediment……………………………………. 43 Canal Expansion………………………………………………………………. 45 “Low Bridge; Everybody Down!” 2 ―Low Bridge; Everybody Down!‖ Notes & Notions on the Construction & Early Operation of the Erie Canal Initial Resource Book: Dan Murphy, The Erie Canal: The Ditch That Opened A Nation, 2001 Introduction A foolhardy proposal, years of political bickering and partisan infighting, an outrageous $7.5 million price tag (an amount roughly equal to about $4 billion today) – all that for a four foot deep, 40 foot wide ditch connecting Lake Erie in western New York with the Hudson River in Albany. It took 7 years of labor, slowly clawing shovels of earth from the ground in a 363-mile trek across the wilderness of New York State. Through the use of many references, this paper attempts to describe this remarkable construction project. Additionally, it describes the early operation of the canal and its impact on the daily life on or near the canal‘s winding path across the state.
    [Show full text]
  • Table of Contents
    T a b l e C o n T e n T s I s s u e 9 s u mm e r 2 0 1 3 o f pg 4 pg 18 pg 26 pg 43 Featured articles Pg 4 abraham lincoln and Freedom of the Press A Reappraisal by Harold Holzer Pg 18 interbranch tangling Separating Our Constitutional Powers by Judith s. Kaye Pg 26 rutgers v. Waddington Alexander Hamilton and the Birth Pangs of Judicial Review by David a. Weinstein Pg 43 People v. sanger and the Birth of Family Planning clinics in america by Maria T. Vullo dePartments Pg 2 From the executive director Pg 58 the david a. Garfinkel essay contest Pg 59 a look Back...and Forward Pg 66 society Officers and trustees Pg 66 society membership Pg 70 Become a member Back inside cover Hon. theodore t. Jones, Jr. In Memoriam Judicial Notice l 1 From the executive director udicial Notice is moving forward! We have a newly expanded board of editors Dearwho volunteer Members their time to solicit and review submissions, work with authors, and develop topics of legal history to explore. The board of editors is composed J of Henry M. Greenberg, Editor-in-Chief, John D. Gordan, III, albert M. rosenblatt, and David a. Weinstein. We are also fortunate to have David l. Goodwin, Assistant Editor, who edits the articles and footnotes with great care and knowledge. our own Michael W. benowitz, my able assistant, coordinates the layout and, most importantly, searches far and wide to find interesting and often little-known images that greatly compliment and enhance the articles.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 the Story of the Faulkner Murals by Lester S. Gorelic, Ph.D. the Story Of
    The Story of the Faulkner Murals By Lester S. Gorelic, Ph.D. The story of the Faulkner murals in the Rotunda begins on October 23, 1933. On this date, the chief architect of the National Archives, John Russell Pope, recommended the approval of a two- year competing United States Government contract to hire a noted American muralist, Barry Faulkner, to paint a mural for the Exhibit Hall in the planned National Archives Building.1 The recommendation initiated a three-year project that produced two murals, now viewed and admired by more than a million people annually who make the pilgrimage to the National Archives in Washington, DC, to view two of the Charters of Freedom documents they commemorate: the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution of the United States of America. The two-year contract provided $36,000 in costs plus $6,000 for incidental expenses.* The contract ended one year before the projected date for completion of the Archives Building’s construction, providing Faulkner with an additional year to complete the project. The contract’s only guidance of an artistic nature specified that “The work shall be in character with and appropriate to the particular design of this building.” Pope served as the contract supervisor. Louis Simon, the supervising architect for the Treasury Department, was brought in as the government representative. All work on the murals needed approval by both architects. Also, The United States Commission of Fine Arts served in an advisory capacity to the project and provided input critical to the final composition. The contract team had expertise in art, architecture, painting, and sculpture.
    [Show full text]
  • The Concordiensis, Volume 25, Number 11
    Union College Union | Digital Works The oncC ordiensis 1902 The oncC ordiensis 1900-1909 1-16-1902 The oncorC diensis, Volume 25, Number 11 John D. Guthrie Union College - Schenectady, NY Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalworks.union.edu/concordiensis_1902 Recommended Citation Guthrie, John D., "The oncC ordiensis, Volume 25, Number 11" (1902). The Concordiensis 1902. 2. https://digitalworks.union.edu/concordiensis_1902/2 This Book is brought to you for free and open access by the The oncC ordiensis 1900-1909 at Union | Digital Works. It has been accepted for inclusion in The oncC ordiensis 1902 by an authorized administrator of Union | Digital Works. For more information, please contact [email protected]. -. • ~f' -·,-~-~~·· ' .. :I:' i ; 't oncordien is. ,, -....... PUBLISHED WEEKLY BY THE STUDENTS OF UNION COLLECE, {. SCHENECTADY, N. Y. )i VoL. XXV. JANUARY 16, 1902. No. 11. ' ' ~ ' . ,'·; '. •, ·.. ·; ,:· ._ ...1':·.:. .• .,l .. · ..: . '. ~ ' ·~ ' '. .... '' . ,\ .,; . \ . I. • ~ • ' <' I ~ • 1 '. -· .......' . K··.· ·GI Union University. ·,.. ·c··. · .• .•... ·.· .. R···u'···E··: : .. , . i •.• 1: B',DR'·· .&··' ,.. ',·c·.,o: .. ;·.' ·. I F . I' ' ~ AIDREW Y. Y. RAYMOND, D. D., LL. D.,. President. 'THE UP-TO-DATE UNION COLLEGE, G:ROCERY HOUS.E· SCHENECTADY, N. Y. •• 1. Course Leading ta the Degree af A. B.___:The usual Classical Course, including li'rench a:n:d G-erman. ..After Sopho­ more year the work is largely elective. FU:LL AND COMPLETE LI:NE OF' 2. Course Leading to the Degree of B. S.-The modern i' languages .are substituted £or the ancient, and the amount of GRO:CEBIE~S AN·:O PRO'VlSlONS., Mathematics and :English studies is increased. After the f Sophomore year a large list of electiTes is offered, f .
    [Show full text]
  • The Signers of the U.S. Constitution
    CONSTITUTIONFACTS.COM The U.S Constitution & Amendments: About the Signers (Continued) The Signers of the U.S. Constitution On September 17, 1787, the Constitutional Convention came to a close in the Assembly Room of Independence Hall in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. There were seventy individuals chosen to attend the meetings with the initial purpose of amending the Articles of Confederation. Rhode Island opted to not send any delegates. Fifty-five men attended most of the meetings, there were never more than forty-six present at any one time, and ultimately only thirty-nine delegates actually signed the Constitution. (William Jackson, who was the secretary of the convention, but not a delegate, also signed the Constitution. John Delaware was absent but had another delegate sign for him.) While offering incredible contributions, George Mason of Virginia, Edmund Randolph of Virginia, and Elbridge Gerry of Massachusetts refused to sign the final document because of basic philosophical differences. Mainly, they were fearful of an all-powerful government and wanted a bill of rights added to protect the rights of the people. The following is a list of those individuals who signed the Constitution along with a brief bit of information concerning what happened to each person after 1787. Many of those who signed the Constitution went on to serve more years in public service under the new form of government. The states are listed in alphabetical order followed by each state’s signers. Connecticut William S. Johnson (1727-1819)—He became the president of Columbia College (formerly known as King’s College), and was then appointed as a United States Senator in 1789.
    [Show full text]
  • Public School Teachers' Department Improving The
    PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHERS' DEPARTMENT Edited by LEROY J. KOEHLER State Teachers College, East Stroudsburg, Pa. IMPROVING THE TEACHING OF PENNSYLVANIA HISTORY BY NATHAN G. MEYER Assistant County Superintendent, Monroe County, Pa. ACCORDING to Professor J. E. Woodbridge of Teachers College, Columbia University, the purpose of history is "to give one perspective so that he may formulate a philosophy of life." If this is true, then every teacher, and especially every teacher of history, should have had as a prerequisite to teaching a dynamic course in the whole field of world history, including local history. If there are, as some historians agree, really many histories, one for each important person or thing of the past which cannot be absolutely terminated, then it follows that most of the note- worthy persons and things of the remote past can be related to the corresponding persons or things in the local present. Let me illustrate this statement as it applies to a thing. A history teacher in Philadelphia might arouse the interest of her pupils in the Circus Maximus by this question: "Which is larger, the Circus Maximus or the stadium of the University of Pennsylvania?" The answer and discussion of the size of an amphitheater of the past with a local stadium of the present would give a new mean- ing to the Circus Maximus. Recently I visited a school in Monroe county in which I found a good example of the fact that the history of an important person, Abraham Lincoln, has not been absolutely terminated. The teacher I refer to had enriched his history teaching of Abraham Lincoln by using the picture of a girl, now attending a public school, who is a descendant of the family of Abraham Lincoln's sweetheart, Anne Rutledge.
    [Show full text]
  • Dewitt Clinton High School As Scholastic Model of Postwar Racial Progression and African American Leadership
    Journal of Higher Education Athletics & Innovation Volume 1, Issue 7 Basketball, Books, And Brotherhood: Dewitt Clinton High School as Scholastic Model of Postwar Racial Progression and African American Leadership Arthur Banton Department of History Tennessee Technological University Abstract: In 1950, the City College of New York (CCNY) became the first racially integrated team to win the national championship of college basketball. Three of the players on that team, Arthur Glass, Mike Wittlin, and Ed Warner, attended DeWitt Clinton High School in the Bronx, New York. At the time Clinton High School was one of the most academically rigorous public schools in the city and the United States. During this postwar period, nearly one third of Clinton graduates attended college at a time when the national high school graduation rate stood at 20%. Unlike most high schools in the United States, Clinton was racially integrated with more than 20% of the student body identifying as African American. Like their contemporaries, Black students were encouraged to pursue opportunities that seemed unthinkable in an era of racial stratification. As a result, Clinton produced several Black students armed with the skills to navigate the terrain of prejudice and other social barriers. DeWitt Clinton High School was a model for interracial brotherhood while also fostering Black leadership. The Black athletes who attended CCNY were better prepared for the transition of competing on a racially integrated college team, can be partially attributed to their secondary schooling at DeWitt Clinton. This article examines the racial climate of DeWitt Clinton during the postwar years when the three young men were in attendance and how it fostered a culture of Basketball, Books, and Brotherhood.
    [Show full text]
  • (PCB) Pollution of the Hudson River: Social Policy and Health Considerations Laura Schad Union College - Schenectady, NY
    Union College Union | Digital Works Honors Theses Student Work 6-2016 Polychlorinated Biphenyl (PCB) Pollution of the Hudson River: Social Policy and Health Considerations Laura Schad Union College - Schenectady, NY Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalworks.union.edu/theses Part of the Environmental Health and Protection Commons, Environmental Monitoring Commons, and the Toxicology Commons Recommended Citation Schad, Laura, "Polychlorinated Biphenyl (PCB) Pollution of the Hudson River: Social Policy and Health Considerations" (2016). Honors Theses. 208. https://digitalworks.union.edu/theses/208 This Open Access is brought to you for free and open access by the Student Work at Union | Digital Works. It has been accepted for inclusion in Honors Theses by an authorized administrator of Union | Digital Works. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Polychlorinated Biphenyl (PCB) Pollution of the Hudson River: Social Policy and Health Considerations By Laura Schad ********** Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for Honors in the Department of Sociology UNION COLLEGE June 2016 i Abstract SCHAD, LAURA. Polychlorinated Biphenyl (PCB) Pollution of the Hudson River: Social Policy and Health Considerations. Department of Sociology, June 2016. ADVISOR: Ilene Kaplan The purpose of this paper is to examine pollution in the Hudson River and the role General Electric has had in creating this problem. The focus will be on social issues and problems that have emerged as a result of the environmental damage from pollution. Until recently, there was little research done on the health and environmental justice issues that impact the New York communities where GE’s factories were located. This paper examines the material collected and studies that were done which document Hudson River pollution and the contributions as well as clean up efforts of General Electric.
    [Show full text]
  • Fascinating Facts About the U.S. Constitution
    The U.S. Constitution & Amendments: Fascinating Facts (Continued) Fascinating Facts About The U.S. Constitution The U.S. Constitution has 4,400 words. It is the The Constitution does not set forth requirements oldest and shortest written Constitution of any major for the right to vote. As a result, at the outset of government in the world. the Union, only male property-owners could vote. ___________________ African Americans were not considered citizens, and women were excluded from the electoral process. Of the spelling errors in the Constitution, Native Americans were not given the right to vote “Pensylvania” above the signers’ names is probably until 1924. the most glaring. ___________________ ___________________ James Madison, “the father of the Constitution,” Thomas Jefferson did not sign the Constitution. was the first to arrive in Philadelphia for the He was in France during the Convention, where Constitutional Convention. He arrived in February, he served as the U.S. minister. John Adams was three months before the convention began, bearing serving as the U.S. minister to Great Britain during the blueprint for the new Constitution. the Constitutional Convention and did not attend ___________________ either. ___________________ Of the forty-two delegates who attended most of the meetings, thirty-nine actually signed the Constitution. The Constitution was “penned” by Jacob Shallus, Edmund Randolph and George Mason of Virginia A Pennsylvania General Assembly clerk, for $30 and Elbridge Gerry of Massachusetts refused to ($726 today). sign in part due to the lack of a bill of rights. ___________________ ___________________ Since 1952, the Constitution has been on display When it came time for the states to ratify the in the National Archives Building in Washington, Constitution, the lack of any bill of rights was the DC.
    [Show full text]
  • Filling Vacancies in the Office of Lieutenant Governor
    MAY 2009 CITIZENS UNION | ISSUE BRIEF AND POSITION STATEMENT Filling Vacancies in the Office of Lieutenant Governor INTRODUCTION Citizens Union of the City of Shortly after Citizens Union’s last report on the subject of filling vacancies in February 2008, New York is an independent, former Governor Eliot Spitzer resigned from the office of governor and former Lieutenant non-partisan civic organization of Governor David A. Paterson assumed the role of New York’s fifty-fifth governor. Although the members dedicated to promoting good government and political reform in the voters elected Paterson as lieutenant governor in 2006, purposefully to fill such a vacancy in the city and state of New York. For more office of governor should it occur, his succession created a vacancy in the office of lieutenant than a century, Citizens Union has governor, and, more importantly, created confusion among citizens and elected officials in served as a watchdog for the public Albany about whether the current Temporary President of the Senate who serves as acting interest and an advocate for the Lieutenant Governor can serve in both positions simultaneously. This unexpected vacancy common good. Founded in 1897 to fight the corruption of Tammany Hall, exposed a deficiency in the law because no process exists to fill permanently a vacancy in the Citizens Union currently works to position of lieutenant governor until the next statewide election in 2010. ensure fair elections, clean campaigns, and open, effective government that is Though the processes for filling vacancies ordinarily receive little attention, the recent number accountable to the citizens of New of vacancies in various offices at the state and local level has increased the public’s interest in York.
    [Show full text]
  • The Other Madison Problem
    THE OTHER MADISON PROBLEM David S. Schwartz* & John Mikhail** The conventional view of legal scholars and historians is that James Madison was the “father” or “major architect” of the Constitution, whose unrivaled authority entitles his interpretations of the Constitution to special weight and consideration. This view greatly exaggerates Madison’s contribution to the framing of the Constitution and the quality of his insight into the main problem of federalism that the Framers tried to solve. Perhaps most significantly, it obstructs our view of alternative interpretations of the original Constitution with which Madison disagreed. Examining Madison’s writings and speeches between the spring and fall of 1787, we argue, first, that Madison’s reputation as the father of the Constitution is unwarranted. Madison’s supposedly unparalleled preparation for the Constitutional Convention and his purported authorship of the Virginia plan are unsupported by the historical record. The ideas Madison expressed in his surprisingly limited pre-Convention writings were either widely shared or, where more peculiar to him, rejected by the Convention. Moreover, virtually all of the actual drafting of the Constitution was done by other delegates, principally James Wilson and Gouverneur Morris. Second, we argue that Madison’s recorded thought in this critical 1787 period fails to establish him as a particularly keen or authoritative interpreter of the Constitution. Focused myopically on the supposed imperative of blocking bad state laws, Madison failed to diagnose the central problem of federalism that was clear to many of his peers: the need to empower the national government to regulate the people directly. Whereas Madison clung to the idea of a national government controlling the states through a national legislative veto, the Convention settled on a decidedly non-Madisonian approach of bypassing the states by directly regulating the people and controlling bad state laws indirectly through the combination of federal supremacy and preemption.
    [Show full text]
  • Fall 2001 Serious Times
    CEO Forum EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR What we must become David L. Winton Phone: (909) 659-0789 • Fax: (949) 240-4844 his will be my last message as CEO of APMP. For the past E-mail: [email protected] four years, I have been either CEO or COO, which affords Web site: http://www.apmp.org Tme a rather unique view of what we need to do to continue our evolution as a professional association. So bear with me while BOARD OF DIRECTORS I once again express some hard opinions based on experience, analysis, and stubbornness. CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER If I leave the membership of APMP with anything of value, it is Eric Gregory, CACI, Inc. • [email protected] this: We must become the professional association of choice for new business acquisition experts. Why do I say this? CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER One of the key things we need at APMP as a part of our long- Karen Shaw, BAE Systems term strategic plan is growth. Although a nonprofit organization, we are not much different from [email protected] a business. Growth is good; stagnation and contraction are bad. There is not much to argue about there. Growth in membership provides additional revenue through dues and conference atten- SECRETARY dance and becomes a constant source of new ideas and leadership necessary to propel the organ- Nancy L. Cottle ization to a solid place among professional associations. But our source of members among those [email protected] who consider themselves exclusively proposal management professionals is a much smaller domain than that which touches the full cycle of new business acquisition activities.
    [Show full text]