Shadow Flicker Impact Analysis for the Hardin

Prepared for Hardin Wind Energy LLC

Prepared by

160 Federal Street Boston, MA 02110

July 2009 Updated December 2009 Updated June 2011 Updated June 2014 Updated March 2016 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

TABLE OF CONTENTS

EXEXCUTIVE SUMMARY ...... 1 1.0 BACKGROUND ...... 2 2.0 WINDPRO SHADOW FLICKER ANALYSIS ...... 3 3.0 WINDPRO SHADOW FLICKER ANALYSIS RESULTS...... 5 4.0 CONCLUSION ...... 7

TABLES

Table 1. Receptors with Over 30 Expected Annual Average Shadow Hours...... 5 Table 2. Statistical Summary of Expected Annual Average Shadow Hours ...... 6

FIGURES

Figure 1 Sensitive Receptors Modeled with WindPro to Predict Expected Shadow Flicker Impacts...... 8 Figure 2 Map of WindPro Estimated Shadow Flicker Impacts for the Hardin Wind Farm (Expected Hours per Year) ...... 9

ATTACHMENT

Attachment A Detailed Summary of WindPro Shadow Flicker Analysis Results

i Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

EXEXCUTIVE SUMMARY

A shadow flicker impact analysis was originally conducted for the Hardin Wind Farm Project (Project) in July 2009. That analysis was based on the original 212 layout project design. The July 2009 analysis was updated in December of 2009 to evaluate the revised Project based on a layout design comprising 203 wind turbines. The analysis was again updated to evaluate the Phase 1a project layout of 132 wind turbines in June of 2011. The analysis was further updated in June 2014 to evaluate the revised project layout of 121 wind turbines and a new wind turbine model (GE 2.5 – 120). The analysis presented here is based on an updated layout of 118 turbine locations and new turbine model (GE 2.3-116) as of March 2016.

The calculated sunshine probability data is presented in Section 2. The WindPro prediction results are presented in Section 3.

1 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

1.0 BACKGROUND

A wind turbine’s moving blades can cast a moving shadow on locations within a certain distance of a turbine. If the shadows pass over a window of a home or public gathering place, they can create alternating periods of low and high light, a temporary phenomena referred to as “shadow flicker”. The maximum length of the shadows depends on the time of year and day (which determines the sun’s azimuth and altitude angles) and the wind turbine’s physical characteristics (height, rotor diameter, blade width, and orientation of the rotor blades). Shadows are longest during low angle sunlight conditions, typical during sunrise and sunset times of the day. However, when the sun angle gets very low (less than 3 degrees), the light has to pass through more atmosphere and becomes too diffuse to form a coherent shadow. Shadow flicker will not occur when the sun is obscured by clouds or fog, at night, or when the source turbine(s) are not operating.

Shadow flicker intensity is defined as the difference in brightness at a given location in the presence and absence of a shadow. Shadow flicker intensity diminishes with greater receptor-to- turbine separation distance. Shadow flicker intensity for receptor-to-turbine distances beyond 1,500 meters is very low and generally considered imperceptible. Shadow flicker intensity for receptor-to-turbine distances between 1,000 and 2,000 meters (between 3,281 and 6,562 feet) is also low and generally considered barely noticeable. At this distance shadow flicker intensity would only tend to be noticed under conditions that would enhance the intensity difference, such as observing from a dark room with a single window directly facing the turbine casting the shadow. At distances less than 1,000 meters (3,281 feet), shadow flicker may be more noticeable. In general, the largest number of potential shadow hours, along with greatest potential shadow flicker intensity, occurs nearest the wind turbines.

Shadow flicker intensity is also affected by the relative percentage of the solar disk which is masked (covered) by the turbine rotor. WindPro calculations also implements German guidance which indicates that when less than 20% of the solar disk is masked, the shadow will be too diffuse to cause a significant impact.

Shadow flicker frequency is related to the wind turbine’s rotor blade speed and the number of blades on the rotor. From a health standpoint, such low frequencies are harmless. For comparison, strobe lights used in discotheques have frequencies which range from about 3 Hertz (Hz) to 10 Hz (1 Hz = 1 flash per second). As a result, public concerns that flickering light from wind turbines can have negative health effects, such as triggering seizures in people with epilepsy are unfounded. The Epilepsy Action (working name for the British Epilepsy Foundation), states that there is no evidence that wind turbines can cause seizures. However, they recommend that wind turbine flicker frequency be limited to 3 Hz (http://www.epilepsy.org.uk/info/photo_other.html). Since the proposed Project’s wind turbine blade pass frequency is approximately 0.79 Hz (less than 1 alternation per second), no negative health effects to individuals with photosensitive epilepsy are anticipated.

2 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

2.0 WINDPRO SHADOW FLICKER ANALYSIS

Tetra Tech estimated potential shadow flicker impacts from the Hardin Wind Farm using the WindPro software package and the following information provided by Hardin Wind Energy LLC (HWE):

• 118 turbines located at the coordinates listed in Attachment B and as shown on Figure 1.

• The wind turbines are assumed to have the dimensions of the GE Wind Energy GE 2.3- 116, a 3-blade 116-meter-diameter rotor wind turbine with a hub height of 80 meters. The GE 2.3-116 has a nominal rotor speed of 15.7 rpm which translates to a blade pass frequency of 0.79 Hz (less than 1 alternation per second).

• 529 receptors (residences) are located at the coordinates listed in Attachment A and as shown on Figure 1.

The analysis makes the following assumptions:

• The elevations of the wind turbines and receptors are determined using USGS digital elevation model (DEM) data.

• The position of the sun and the incident sunlight relative to the wind turbine and receptors on a minute by minute basis over the course of a year.

• Annual average sunshine rates for the area are based on an average of National Climatic Data Center (NCDC) data for stations located in Columbus and Toledo, Ohio and are assumed to be:

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec 38% 45% 46% 51% 56% 58% 60% 58% 57% 53% 34% 29%

Values from Columbus and Toledo were used because NCDC sunshine data is not available for Kenton, Ohio1, but it is available for measurement stations in both Columbus and Toledo, Ohio. The sunshine probability data from these stations were averaged together to calculate sunshine probability data assumed to be representative of the of the project area. Tetra Tech considers this to be a conservative assumption that underestimates cloud cover since it evenly averages data from both sites, even though the project is slightly closer to Columbus and Columbus has a higher cloud cover rate.

• Wind turbine operating hours and orientations are based on approximately 1 year of data measured on-site from 5/21/08 to 6/22/09. Based on this data, wind turbine orientations are assumed to be as follows:

N NNE ENE E ESE SSE S SSW WSW W WNW NNW 4.1% 5.4% 7.7% 6.7% 4.9% 6.3% 8.7% 15.1% 13.1% 13.1% 9.1% 5.8%

1 Alan Black, NOAA Midwestern Regional Climate Center, data request response via email on 11/4/09.

3 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

• Receptor viewpoint (i.e., house windows) is assumed to always be directly facing turbine to sun line of sight (“greenhouse mode”).

• Every receptor is modelled as a 1 m2 area (approximate size of a typical window), 1 meter (3.28 feet) aboveground level. Approximate eye level is set at 1.5 meters (4.9 feet).

• Screening from trees, shrubs, barns, or other obstacles was conservatively not assumed to block shadows. In reality, such factors can block shadows from falling on to windows of receptors.

WindPro incorporates terrain elevation contour information and the analysis accounts for terrain elevation differences. WindPro calculates the sun’s path with respect to each turbine location to determine the shadow paths for every minute in a full year. Sun angles less than 3 degrees above the horizon were excluded, for the reasons identified in Section 1. WindPro calculates shadow flicker for conditions when at least 20% of the sun disc is covered by the turbine blades. When less than 20% of the solar disk is masked by the blades, the shadow will be too diffuse to cause a coherent shadow

HWE identified 529 receptors within 1,000 meters of a proposed wind turbine. Only these receptors were analyzed in the WindPro analysis. Figure 1 shows the locations of the modelled receptors and turbines.

4 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

3.0 WINDPRO SHADOW FLICKER ANALYSIS RESULTS

Expected annual average shadows are provided in Attachment A for all modelled receptors. Table 1 presents the expected annual average shadow hours for the receptors expected to receive over 30 hours of shadows per year. Figure 2 illustrates the WindPro predicted shadow flicker impacts for the Project. Table 2 summarizes the expected annual average shadow hours for all receptors modelled. Table 1. Receptors with Over 30 Expected Annual Average Shadow Hours Expected Annual Project Shadow Percent of Receptor ID Average Shadow Hours Participation Available Sunlight [Hours:Minutes/Year] Status Hours H-1179 66:46:00 Participant 1.49% H-2051 61:48:00 Participant 1.38% H-40 49:08:00 Participant 1.10% H-1305 48:19:00 Participant 1.08% H-808 46:58:00 Participant 1.05% H-2569 41:49:00 Non-Participant 0.94% H-738 41:44:00 Non-Participant 0.93% H-1805 41:26:00 Non-Participant 0.93% H-2672 41:12:00 Non-Participant 0.92% H-2106 40:36:00 Non-Participant 0.91% H-2513 40:11:00 Non-Participant 0.90% H-1780 40:09:00 Non-Participant 0.90% H-41 39:39:00 Participant 0.89% H-2102 38:47:00 Participant 0.87% H-733 38:04:00 Non-Participant 0.85% H-2073 37:25:00 Non-Participant 0.84% H-1959 37:08:00 Participant 0.83% H-1675 35:39:00 Non-Participant 0.80% H-2064 35:34:00 Participant 0.80% H-1677 35:25:00 Non-Participant 0.79% H-2553 35:24:00 Non-Participant 0.79% H-2512 34:52:00 Non-Participant 0.78% H-1664 34:37:00 Non-Participant 0.78% H-1185 34:35:00 Non-Participant 0.77% H-1744 34:28:00 Non-Participant 0.77% H-2006 34:11:00 Non-Participant 0.77% H-2571 34:06:00 Non-Participant 0.76% H-1991 33:58:00 Non-Participant 0.76% H-1924 33:01:00 Non-Participant 0.74% H-779 32:56:00 Non-Participant 0.74% H-2496 32:53:00 Non-Participant 0.74% H-2078 32:45:00 Non-Participant 0.73% H-798 32:19:00 Non-Participant 0.72% H-2515 32:02:00 Non-Participant 0.72% H-689 31:44:00 Non-Participant 0.71% H-1187 31:29:00 Non-Participant 0.70% H-2302 31:29:00 Non-Participant 0.70% H-653 31:12:00 Non-Participant 0.70% H-2465 30:03:00 Non-Participant 0.67%

5 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

Table 2. Statistical Summary of Expected Annual Average Shadow Hours Number of Number of Number of Annual Average Non-Participating Participating Total Shadow Hours Receptors Receptors Receptors = 0 Hours 19 1 20 > 0 and < 10 Hours 189 11 200 ≥ 10 and < 20 Hours 186 8 194 ≥ 20 and < 30 Hours 73 3 76 > 30 hours 30 9 39 Total 497 32 529

6 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

4.0 CONCLUSION

This report represents an update to the shadow flicker analysis conducted and submitted in support of the Hardin Wind Energy Amendment 1 application to the Ohio Power Siting Board in June 2011. This analysis was completed utilizing the same modeling assumptions that were utilized in the June 2011 shadow flicker analysis, with the exception of the GE 2.3-116 turbine model characteristics. Shadow flicker impacts within the area of study are expected to be minor. The analysis assumes that the houses all have a direct in line view of the incoming shadow flicker sunlight and does not account for all the trees or other obstructions which may block sunlight. In reality, the windows of many houses will not face the sun directly for the key shadow flicker impact times. For these reasons, shadow flicker impacts are expected to be less than estimated with this conservative analysis, and shadow flicker is not expected to be a significant environmental impact.

7 UV69

H-2109 ") H-2092 ") ") H-2086 HARDIN WIND ENERGY, LLC ") H-30 ") H-45 112 HARDIN WIND FARM !. HARDIN COUNTY UV235 ") H-2102 OHIO ")") 111 H-2604 ")") ")")")")")")")")") H-2639 30 ") H-13 !. ")")") ") 9 H-727 ")")")")") ") 113 ") H-44 ")")")")") ")")") ")")")")")") ")") ") H-6 ") ") ") !. ")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")") ") ")") H-1899 H-16 H-1738 ")") ") ") ") ") ") H-2106 ") H-2117 ") H-1512 H-1511 ") H-1505 ") ") H-1516 H-31 ") ") 1 ") ") ") ") FIGURE 1 H-1736 ") H-1820 !. 5 ") H-1517 H-653 ") !. 12 94 H-2111 ") !. 114 115 2 !. ") ") H-41 SENSITIVE RECEPTORS MODELED !. ") H-345 91 !. 97 H-36 ") H-35 !. !. 6 ") H-2069 116 ") 13 ") H-2230 !. !. !. H-34 ") !. ") WITH WINDPRO TO PREDICT H-1744 ") 3 14 !. 124 ") ") !. 7 ") H-2572 83 H-2091 ") ") H-40 ") H-804 ")")")")") ")") 84 88 92 !. 98 H-2077 H-1677 !. !. ")")")")")")")")")")") ") !. H-12 ") ")")")") ")")") ")") ")")") 85 !. EXPECTED SHADOW ") H-1654 !. 8 H-673 ") ")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")") !. !. 117 ") 4 ")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")") !. H-2728 ") ") ") ") ")")")")")")")")")") !. 123 ") H-2081 H-1676 ") H-1656 9 ") ")")")")")") H-2624 !. !. H-2547 ")")")")")")")")")") !. 118 ") H-1 FLICKER IMPACTS ") ")")")")")")")")") !. 86 !. H-2389 ") ")")")")")")") ") H-2104 ") H-1780 ") 20 15 ") ") H-37 ") H-2083 10 H-2606 ")")")") ") ") ") H-2588 !. !. 101 ") H-2103 ") H-1063 21 !. 78 !. 39 !. ") H-1061 !. 16 11 !. !. 103 UV309 !. H-1305 104 MARCH 2016 !. !. 40 ") 79 121 !. H-1184 ") 76 !. !. 106 ") H-1183 !. 17 131 108 !. !. 127 !. 77 H-1727 !. 132 !. 41 !. !. 80 !. 109 ") 105 ") !. ") ") H-1187 !. !. 18 !. ") ") Turbine Location ") 22 !. !. !. ")")")") ") 42 ")")")")")") H-1203 H-1777 ") H-2985 ")")") ") !. 23 110 !. ") ") ") ") !. 107 19 !. !. 133 ")") ")")") Receptor (Participating) ")")") ") H-1808 ")")")") ") !. 43 ") ")") H-1817 ")") ") ") ") ") !. H-1619 ")")") H-1602 ") 24 H-501 H-2497 ")") ") ") ") H-1664 27 ") H-1909 ") ") ") ")")")") ") ") H-1188 130 ") ") H-329 Receptor (Non-Participating) 33 !. !. ") H-2229 !. 34 35 !. 44 !. 125 ") H-1209 !. !. 25 ") 28 45 H-1977 ") !. 126 ") H-766 H-1638 Interstate Highway ") !. ") H-1882 30 26 !. !. H-682 !. !. !. Major Road ") H-1662 29 46 47 32 !. !. !. 31 48 !. !. ") H-455 UV69 H-1765 ") ") H-1724 H-1192 ") ") 49 H-1792 ") 38 !. ") H-1791 ") 37 !. H-2008 ") !. !. 50 H-1805 ") ") H-1806 ") !. 51 52 59 !. !. 53 !. !. 60 54 195 !. !. 61 UV 55 !. !. 62 56 !. 63 !. H-2064 ") !. 64 H-48 ") 57 ")") H-1069 H-1520 ") !. 58 H-47 ") !. ") H-2051 ") 65 ") H-1988 !. !. 129 73 !. 66 !. ") H-2057 !. 67 ") H-1959 ¯ !. 68 ") H-2050 71 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 MILES !. 69 !. ") H-808 70 H-2672 ") !. 72 !. ") ") H-1533 ") H-1530 ") H-2031 ")")") ") ") H-449 MICHIGARNEFERENCE MAP H-1822 ")

") H-1322

UV117 ") H-2052 102 !. ")") H-2024 235 UV H-2006 ") ") H-2053 !. 81 ") H-1991 OHIO

")") H-2038 ") ")") H-1993 ") ") ") H-2000 ") ") H-2032 ") H-1835 ")") ") H-1836 99 UV67 !. WEST VIRGINIA UV117 KENTUCKY

Document Path: P:\GIS\Invenergy_HardinWindFarm\GIS\Spatial\MXD\ShadowFlicker\20160329\Fig1_Receptors.mxd UV69

") ") ") HARDIN WIND ENERGY, LLC ") ") 112 HARDIN WIND FARM !. HARDIN COUNTY ") UV235 OHIO ")") 111 ")")")") ") !. ")")")")")")")") ")")")")") ") 113 ") ")")")")") ")")") ")")")")")") ") ") ") !. ")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")") ")")")")") ") ")") ")") ") ") ") ") ") ") ") ") ") ") ") 1 5 ") ") ") ") FIGURE 2 ") !. ") 114 ") !. 12 94 ") !. 115 2 !. 97 ") ") ") MAP OF WINDPRO ESTIMATED !. 6 13 ") 91 !. ") !. !. ") !. 116 ") !. !. ") !. ") SHADOW FLICKER IMPACTS FOR ") 3 14 !. 124 ") ") !. 7 ") ") 83 ") ") ") !. !. ")")")")")") ")") 84 88 92 !. 98 ") ")")")")")")")")")")")") !. 117 ") ")")")")")")")")")")")")")") ")")")") !. 85 !. !. THE HARDIN WIND FARM ") !. 8 ")") ")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")") !. ") 4 ")")")") ")")")")")")")")")")")")")")")") 123 ") ") ")") ")")")")")")")")")") !. ") !. !. 9 ") ")")")")") ")")")")")")")")")") !. 86 !. !. ") (EXPECTED HOURS PER YEAR) ") ")")")")")")")") ") 118 ") ") ")")") 3 ")") 20 15 10 ") ")")") ") ") ") 09 !. !. !. 39 ") 101 ") ") 21 !. 78 !. ") !. 16 11 !. !. 103 UV309 !. ") 79 !. 104 MARCH 2016 ") !. !. 40 121 !. ") 131 76 !. 108 106 !. 17 !. !. 127 !. !. 77 ") !. 132 41 !. !. 80 !. 109 105 ") !. ") ") !. !. 18 !. ") ") Turbine Location ") 22 !. !. !. ")")")") ") 42 110 ")")")")")") 107 ") ")")") ") !. 23 !. ") ") ") ") !. 19 !. 133 ")") ")")") Receptor (Participating) ")")") ") ")")") ") !. !. 43 ") ") ") ")") !. ")")")") ")") 24 ") ")") ") ") ") 27 ") ") 125 ")") ") ")")")") ") ") ") 33 !. !. 130 ")") ") Receptor (Non-Participating) !. 34 35 !. 44 !. ") !. !. 25 ") !. 28 45 ") !. 126 ") Interstate Highway ") 30 26 !. !. ") !. !. !. Major Road ") 29 46 47 32 !. !. Shadow Flicker Iso Line (Expected Hours per Year) 31 !. 48 ") !. !. 15 69 ") ") UV ") ") 49 ") 38 !. 30 ") 37 !. ") ") !. !. 50 50 ") ") 51 52 59 ") !. !. 100 53 !. !. !. 60 200 54 195 !. !. 61 UV 55 !. !. 62 56 !. 63 !. ") !. 64 ")") 57 ") !. 58 ") !. ") ") ") 65 129 !. !. 73 !. 66 !. ") !. 67 ") ¯ !. 68 ") 71 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 MILES !. 69 !. ") 70 ") !. 72 !. ") ") ") ") ") ") ") ") REFERENCE MAP ") MICHIGAN

")

117 ") UV 102 !. ")") 235 UV ") 81 ") !. ") OHIO

")") ") ")") ") ") ") ") ") ") UV67 ")") 99 !. WEST VIRGINIA UV117 KENTUCKY

Document Path: P:\GIS\Invenergy_HardinWindFarm\GIS\Spatial\MXD\ShadowFlicker\20160329\Fig2_Isolines.mxd Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

ATTACHMENT A

Detailed Summary of WindPro Shadow Flicker Analysis Results

A-1 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

Hardin Wind Farm WindPro Predicted Annual Expected Shadow Flicker

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-1 272,136 4,508,078 1:15:00 Non-Participant H-4 268,566 4,509,562 3:06:00 Participant H-6 267,764 4,509,731 0:46:00 Non-Participant H-12 272,588 4,508,485 5:34:00 Non-Participant H-13 268,592 4,509,997 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-15 269,112 4,509,495 6:39:00 Non-Participant H-16 269,319 4,509,660 4:57:00 Participant H-30 271,053 4,510,774 19:03:00 Participant H-31 270,617 4,509,458 12:26:00 Non-Participant H-34 270,530 4,508,792 13:43:00 Participant H-35 270,148 4,509,058 10:39:00 Non-Participant H-36 269,919 4,509,096 11:03:00 Non-Participant H-37 272,461 4,507,933 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-40 272,509 4,508,647 49:08:00 Participant H-41 272,537 4,509,052 39:39:00 Participant H-44 272,567 4,509,787 4:31:00 Non-Participant H-45 272,035 4,510,845 9:35:00 Non-Participant H-47 262,473 4,501,925 24:15:00 Non-Participant H-48 262,589 4,502,300 7:56:00 Non-Participant H-74 262,684 4,502,339 10:05:00 Non-Participant H-247 268,252 4,506,640 22:01:00 Non-Participant H-248 268,330 4,506,532 18:14:00 Non-Participant H-251 268,346 4,506,472 18:01:00 Non-Participant H-252 268,351 4,506,435 18:12:00 Non-Participant H-253 268,360 4,506,266 21:23:00 Non-Participant H-259 268,322 4,506,683 17:35:00 Non-Participant H-260 268,361 4,506,761 15:25:00 Non-Participant H-265 268,407 4,506,723 13:50:00 Non-Participant H-266 268,402 4,506,745 13:49:00 Non-Participant H-273 269,259 4,506,365 24:21:00 Non-Participant H-329 269,409 4,506,166 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-345 264,640 4,509,113 9:18:00 Non-Participant H-346 264,065 4,508,506 6:29:00 Non-Participant H-347 263,912 4,508,579 7:15:00 Non-Participant H-353 269,231 4,506,996 29:30:00 Non-Participant H-354 268,538 4,506,848 9:52:00 Non-Participant H-357 263,948 4,508,535 7:12:00 Non-Participant H-388 264,557 4,496,908 3:48:00 Non-Participant

B-2 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-422 259,935 4,510,282 2:00:00 Non-Participant H-448 263,529 4,499,861 18:44:00 Non-Participant H-449 263,732 4,499,778 12:35:00 Non-Participant H-455 265,901 4,505,040 1:25:00 Non-Participant H-467 266,249 4,497,358 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-501 265,734 4,506,288 25:26:00 Non-Participant H-644 259,738 4,509,983 6:54:00 Non-Participant H-653 259,859 4,509,416 31:12:00 Non-Participant H-655 259,886 4,510,088 2:37:00 Non-Participant H-656 259,912 4,509,867 11:31:00 Non-Participant H-662 259,549 4,509,729 6:46:00 Non-Participant H-666 259,801 4,510,028 5:47:00 Non-Participant H-673 263,888 4,508,531 8:18:00 Non-Participant H-674 259,181 4,506,584 8:46:00 Non-Participant H-680 263,957 4,508,470 8:34:00 Non-Participant H-682 258,811 4,505,776 6:55:00 Non-Participant H-689 264,680 4,508,377 31:44:00 Non-Participant H-695 264,270 4,508,627 5:21:00 Non-Participant H-696 264,333 4,508,586 6:45:00 Non-Participant H-697 264,339 4,508,634 6:12:00 Non-Participant H-701 259,519 4,509,772 5:04:00 Non-Participant H-705 259,921 4,509,950 7:44:00 Non-Participant H-706 259,922 4,510,052 2:55:00 Non-Participant H-713 264,285 4,508,716 4:40:00 Non-Participant H-714 264,719 4,508,319 19:36:00 Non-Participant H-715 264,963 4,508,421 17:41:00 Non-Participant H-716 259,922 4,510,153 1:57:00 Non-Participant H-717 259,924 4,510,173 1:32:00 Non-Participant H-718 264,398 4,508,473 9:20:00 Non-Participant H-720 259,935 4,510,231 1:47:00 Non-Participant H-724 264,240 4,508,446 6:31:00 Non-Participant H-725 264,208 4,508,590 5:17:00 Non-Participant H-726 264,274 4,508,516 6:19:00 Non-Participant H-727 259,690 4,510,033 5:54:00 Non-Participant H-731 264,988 4,508,078 15:48:00 Non-Participant H-732 264,988 4,508,102 15:13:00 Non-Participant H-733 264,830 4,508,432 38:04:00 Non-Participant H-734 264,637 4,508,470 21:02:00 Non-Participant H-738 264,802 4,508,446 41:44:00 Non-Participant H-739 264,728 4,508,512 25:46:00 Non-Participant H-740 264,275 4,508,476 6:41:00 Non-Participant

B-3 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-741 264,204 4,508,536 5:40:00 Non-Participant H-742 260,222 4,509,789 14:51:00 Non-Participant H-744 259,633 4,509,773 4:21:00 Non-Participant H-747 264,563 4,508,424 17:15:00 Non-Participant H-748 260,124 4,509,787 17:39:00 Non-Participant H-749 260,107 4,509,803 16:08:00 Non-Participant H-750 264,961 4,508,269 28:31:00 Non-Participant H-752 264,725 4,508,487 29:12:00 Non-Participant H-753 264,209 4,508,561 5:30:00 Non-Participant H-754 264,452 4,508,592 9:07:00 Non-Participant H-755 264,194 4,508,479 6:00:00 Non-Participant H-756 259,665 4,509,778 4:47:00 Non-Participant H-757 259,681 4,509,773 5:00:00 Non-Participant H-758 259,808 4,509,757 7:54:00 Non-Participant H-759 259,837 4,509,765 8:37:00 Non-Participant H-766 267,924 4,505,856 0:31:00 Non-Participant H-767 264,879 4,508,154 18:52:00 Non-Participant H-772 264,891 4,508,328 19:34:00 Non-Participant H-773 264,860 4,508,328 18:20:00 Non-Participant H-776 264,851 4,508,119 16:42:00 Non-Participant H-777 264,847 4,508,085 14:40:00 Non-Participant H-778 264,769 4,508,130 20:01:00 Non-Participant H-779 265,046 4,508,344 32:56:00 Non-Participant H-780 264,359 4,508,462 8:30:00 Non-Participant H-782 259,872 4,509,841 9:47:00 Non-Participant H-783 264,106 4,508,389 6:06:00 Non-Participant H-784 264,246 4,508,402 6:47:00 Non-Participant H-785 264,182 4,508,404 6:19:00 Non-Participant H-786 264,319 4,508,436 7:53:00 Non-Participant H-788 260,002 4,510,103 2:22:00 Non-Participant H-797 264,777 4,508,332 16:21:00 Non-Participant H-798 264,748 4,508,388 32:19:00 Non-Participant H-799 264,745 4,508,360 26:11:00 Non-Participant H-800 264,744 4,508,129 20:02:00 Non-Participant H-801 264,166 4,508,571 5:16:00 Non-Participant H-802 264,166 4,508,590 5:05:00 Non-Participant H-803 264,163 4,508,625 4:52:00 Non-Participant H-804 264,169 4,508,672 4:36:00 Non-Participant H-808 263,497 4,500,338 46:58:00 Participant H-1061 270,899 4,507,616 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-1063 270,837 4,507,754 0:00:00 Non-Participant

B-4 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-1069 262,680 4,502,294 11:20:00 Non-Participant H-1104 269,157 4,506,548 12:36:00 Non-Participant H-1105 269,312 4,506,499 28:29:00 Non-Participant H-1107 269,334 4,506,774 25:51:00 Non-Participant H-1108 269,325 4,506,811 29:37:00 Non-Participant H-1112 269,306 4,506,573 20:33:00 Non-Participant H-1133 268,372 4,506,685 15:22:00 Non-Participant H-1134 268,305 4,506,618 18:53:00 Non-Participant H-1135 268,340 4,506,693 16:37:00 Non-Participant H-1137 268,301 4,506,759 18:46:00 Non-Participant H-1138 268,360 4,506,749 15:28:00 Non-Participant H-1145 269,377 4,506,213 0:28:00 Non-Participant H-1147 268,380 4,506,708 14:53:00 Non-Participant H-1160 269,319 4,506,345 12:07:00 Non-Participant H-1179 267,997 4,506,542 66:46:00 Participant H-1181 268,737 4,506,203 11:04:00 Non-Participant H-1183 259,907 4,507,363 11:38:00 Non-Participant H-1184 259,857 4,507,458 14:28:00 Non-Participant H-1185 260,638 4,506,536 34:35:00 Non-Participant H-1186 260,191 4,506,543 15:10:00 Non-Participant H-1187 269,340 4,506,891 31:29:00 Non-Participant H-1188 269,970 4,506,181 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-1192 259,764 4,504,816 20:16:00 Non-Participant H-1195 259,652 4,506,953 5:40:00 Non-Participant H-1201 268,461 4,506,891 13:06:00 Non-Participant H-1202 268,533 4,506,871 10:08:00 Non-Participant H-1203 268,456 4,506,738 12:19:00 Non-Participant H-1208 259,409 4,506,491 15:17:00 Non-Participant H-1209 258,656 4,506,080 6:44:00 Non-Participant H-1291 264,333 4,508,512 7:35:00 Non-Participant H-1303 264,255 4,508,439 6:42:00 Non-Participant H-1304 264,618 4,508,109 18:25:00 Non-Participant H-1305 264,647 4,507,480 48:19:00 Participant H-1307 264,998 4,508,351 27:37:00 Non-Participant H-1314 264,688 4,508,074 19:12:00 Non-Participant H-1318 265,557 4,496,997 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-1320 266,353 4,498,527 27:57:00 Participant H-1322 266,583 4,499,167 0:36:00 Participant H-1324 265,456 4,506,386 14:39:00 Non-Participant H-1504 268,884 4,509,727 0:58:00 Non-Participant H-1505 267,992 4,509,552 1:33:00 Participant

B-5 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-1506 268,657 4,509,701 1:32:00 Non-Participant H-1507 268,990 4,509,542 9:13:00 Non-Participant H-1511 267,636 4,509,515 5:46:00 Participant H-1512 267,111 4,509,496 2:30:00 Non-Participant H-1513 268,838 4,509,449 13:18:00 Non-Participant H-1514 268,977 4,509,442 9:40:00 Non-Participant H-1516 269,638 4,509,481 3:52:00 Non-Participant H-1517 269,481 4,509,314 13:19:00 Participant H-1518 269,483 4,509,425 5:57:00 Non-Participant H-1520 262,530 4,502,115 11:30:00 Non-Participant H-1530 261,273 4,499,918 5:02:00 Non-Participant H-1533 261,289 4,499,980 7:58:00 Non-Participant H-1564 263,482 4,499,828 10:05:00 Non-Participant H-1574 269,280 4,506,491 24:18:00 Non-Participant H-1581 268,329 4,506,563 17:51:00 Non-Participant H-1586 268,353 4,506,495 17:24:00 Non-Participant H-1587 268,358 4,506,290 21:34:00 Non-Participant H-1591 268,290 4,506,711 19:05:00 Non-Participant H-1592 268,268 4,506,768 21:45:00 Non-Participant H-1602 269,381 4,506,328 0:27:00 Non-Participant H-1617 269,367 4,506,357 8:08:00 Non-Participant H-1618 269,294 4,506,381 26:31:00 Non-Participant H-1619 269,263 4,506,329 14:00:00 Non-Participant H-1638 270,134 4,505,832 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-1652 259,868 4,509,625 10:24:00 Non-Participant H-1653 259,811 4,508,489 10:33:00 Non-Participant H-1654 259,812 4,508,543 27:15:00 Non-Participant H-1656 259,828 4,508,334 19:38:00 Participant H-1662 258,786 4,505,589 5:48:00 Non-Participant H-1663 258,639 4,506,484 4:46:00 Non-Participant H-1664 260,633 4,506,403 34:37:00 Non-Participant H-1665 268,550 4,506,216 13:11:00 Non-Participant H-1675 259,770 4,508,215 35:39:00 Non-Participant H-1676 259,821 4,508,368 14:46:00 Non-Participant H-1677 259,838 4,508,757 35:25:00 Non-Participant H-1682 260,136 4,506,546 15:04:00 Non-Participant H-1683 260,223 4,506,538 15:43:00 Non-Participant H-1684 259,917 4,509,887 11:09:00 Non-Participant H-1685 259,908 4,509,796 11:04:00 Non-Participant H-1686 259,928 4,509,796 11:48:00 Non-Participant H-1687 260,082 4,509,892 7:38:00 Non-Participant

B-6 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-1688 260,081 4,509,879 8:52:00 Non-Participant H-1689 260,080 4,509,867 10:02:00 Non-Participant H-1690 260,079 4,509,856 11:13:00 Non-Participant H-1691 260,079 4,509,844 12:27:00 Non-Participant H-1692 260,081 4,509,832 13:32:00 Non-Participant H-1693 260,036 4,509,791 17:13:00 Non-Participant H-1694 260,037 4,509,803 16:36:00 Non-Participant H-1695 260,040 4,509,814 15:50:00 Non-Participant H-1696 260,038 4,509,826 14:59:00 Non-Participant H-1697 260,039 4,509,838 13:56:00 Non-Participant H-1698 260,039 4,509,850 12:49:00 Non-Participant H-1699 260,040 4,509,860 11:52:00 Non-Participant H-1700 260,040 4,509,872 10:48:00 Non-Participant H-1701 260,042 4,509,884 9:36:00 Non-Participant H-1702 260,044 4,509,896 8:28:00 Non-Participant H-1703 259,999 4,509,898 9:36:00 Non-Participant H-1704 260,000 4,509,886 10:37:00 Non-Participant H-1705 259,999 4,509,875 11:29:00 Non-Participant H-1706 259,997 4,509,864 12:26:00 Non-Participant H-1707 259,999 4,509,852 13:16:00 Non-Participant H-1708 259,998 4,509,841 13:59:00 Non-Participant H-1709 259,998 4,509,829 14:36:00 Non-Participant H-1710 259,999 4,509,816 15:07:00 Non-Participant H-1711 259,998 4,509,806 15:25:00 Non-Participant H-1712 259,958 4,509,794 13:19:00 Non-Participant H-1713 259,959 4,509,806 13:37:00 Non-Participant H-1714 259,961 4,509,817 13:49:00 Non-Participant H-1715 259,961 4,509,829 13:39:00 Non-Participant H-1716 259,961 4,509,841 13:21:00 Non-Participant H-1717 259,961 4,509,852 12:59:00 Non-Participant H-1718 259,961 4,509,863 12:31:00 Non-Participant H-1719 259,962 4,509,874 12:01:00 Non-Participant H-1720 259,963 4,509,898 10:29:00 Non-Participant H-1722 259,877 4,510,107 2:30:00 Non-Participant H-1723 260,156 4,506,499 14:21:00 Non-Participant H-1724 261,265 4,504,864 7:21:00 Non-Participant H-1725 268,850 4,506,225 14:01:00 Non-Participant H-1726 269,320 4,506,263 0:33:00 Non-Participant H-1727 268,136 4,507,050 28:59:00 Participant H-1731 259,842 4,510,091 2:17:00 Non-Participant H-1733 259,865 4,509,587 11:39:00 Non-Participant

B-7 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-1734 259,866 4,509,672 9:59:00 Non-Participant H-1735 259,871 4,509,717 9:53:00 Non-Participant H-1736 259,380 4,509,500 6:18:00 Participant H-1738 259,469 4,509,716 7:24:00 Non-Participant H-1744 259,841 4,508,905 34:28:00 Non-Participant H-1751 259,320 4,506,583 11:09:00 Participant H-1752 259,841 4,510,108 2:19:00 Non-Participant H-1758 259,790 4,510,109 1:52:00 Non-Participant H-1759 258,834 4,506,519 9:05:00 Participant H-1765 260,687 4,504,842 20:55:00 Non-Participant H-1771 268,641 4,506,141 13:44:00 Non-Participant H-1774 260,441 4,509,815 8:44:00 Non-Participant H-1775 260,574 4,509,788 13:38:00 Non-Participant H-1777 259,771 4,506,800 10:19:00 Non-Participant H-1780 259,740 4,508,112 40:09:00 Non-Participant H-1784 264,062 4,508,407 5:56:00 Non-Participant H-1785 263,995 4,508,523 6:48:00 Non-Participant H-1786 263,991 4,508,441 8:18:00 Non-Participant H-1790 259,080 4,504,340 27:39:00 Non-Participant H-1791 258,957 4,504,457 13:01:00 Non-Participant H-1792 259,017 4,504,627 14:15:00 Non-Participant H-1797 258,861 4,504,032 12:11:00 Non-Participant H-1801 268,801 4,506,208 12:17:00 Non-Participant H-1802 268,661 4,506,218 10:47:00 Non-Participant H-1805 259,111 4,504,205 41:26:00 Non-Participant H-1806 259,135 4,504,116 6:08:00 Non-Participant H-1808 259,565 4,506,564 9:11:00 Non-Participant H-1809 259,268 4,506,589 8:44:00 Participant H-1817 258,575 4,506,501 3:55:00 Non-Participant H-1820 259,862 4,509,558 15:07:00 Non-Participant H-1821 263,419 4,499,861 11:18:00 Non-Participant H-1822 263,542 4,499,707 2:13:00 Non-Participant H-1835 264,527 4,496,886 3:37:00 Non-Participant H-1836 264,562 4,496,870 4:00:00 Non-Participant H-1847 259,735 4,509,853 5:26:00 Non-Participant H-1848 259,734 4,509,871 5:26:00 Non-Participant H-1849 259,640 4,509,816 4:19:00 Non-Participant H-1850 259,545 4,509,815 3:23:00 Non-Participant H-1852 264,152 4,508,493 5:46:00 Non-Participant H-1855 259,528 4,509,783 4:19:00 Non-Participant H-1856 259,925 4,510,091 2:46:00 Non-Participant

B-8 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-1857 259,919 4,510,108 2:39:00 Non-Participant H-1865 259,949 4,510,150 1:45:00 Non-Participant H-1866 259,922 4,510,191 1:27:00 Non-Participant H-1867 264,446 4,508,506 10:13:00 Non-Participant H-1868 264,411 4,508,430 10:06:00 Non-Participant H-1872 259,923 4,510,254 1:52:00 Non-Participant H-1881 264,255 4,508,478 6:26:00 Non-Participant H-1882 260,593 4,505,816 17:17:00 Non-Participant H-1891 259,626 4,509,853 4:00:00 Non-Participant H-1896 264,474 4,508,462 11:44:00 Non-Participant H-1897 264,441 4,508,467 10:32:00 Non-Participant H-1898 264,634 4,508,424 27:45:00 Non-Participant H-1899 260,603 4,509,787 15:19:00 Non-Participant H-1900 260,287 4,509,785 12:09:00 Non-Participant H-1902 259,867 4,509,748 9:37:00 Non-Participant H-1904 264,562 4,508,471 15:16:00 Non-Participant H-1905 264,227 4,508,513 6:02:00 Non-Participant H-1906 259,673 4,509,888 4:26:00 Non-Participant H-1907 259,576 4,509,771 3:56:00 Non-Participant H-1909 264,614 4,506,311 19:31:00 Participant H-1917 264,528 4,508,424 14:48:00 Non-Participant H-1918 264,501 4,508,425 13:45:00 Non-Participant H-1919 260,169 4,509,789 16:31:00 Non-Participant H-1920 260,501 4,509,813 9:19:00 Non-Participant H-1921 260,402 4,509,793 10:13:00 Non-Participant H-1922 259,890 4,510,251 1:29:00 Non-Participant H-1924 264,673 4,508,418 33:01:00 Non-Participant H-1925 264,680 4,508,455 29:15:00 Non-Participant H-1926 264,673 4,508,478 23:47:00 Non-Participant H-1927 264,678 4,508,499 22:00:00 Non-Participant H-1928 264,681 4,508,535 19:13:00 Non-Participant H-1929 264,501 4,508,438 13:19:00 Non-Participant H-1930 264,527 4,508,440 14:11:00 Non-Participant H-1931 264,498 4,508,470 12:34:00 Non-Participant H-1932 264,527 4,508,472 13:25:00 Non-Participant H-1933 264,530 4,508,503 12:56:00 Non-Participant H-1934 264,454 4,508,536 10:12:00 Non-Participant H-1939 259,698 4,509,775 5:15:00 Non-Participant H-1940 259,745 4,509,768 6:30:00 Non-Participant H-1941 259,764 4,509,769 6:52:00 Non-Participant H-1942 259,875 4,509,771 9:53:00 Non-Participant

B-9 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-1955 264,474 4,508,506 11:14:00 Non-Participant H-1956 264,477 4,508,428 12:29:00 Non-Participant H-1957 264,440 4,508,428 11:05:00 Non-Participant H-1958 264,367 4,508,430 8:58:00 Non-Participant H-1959 263,421 4,500,995 37:08:00 Participant H-1960 263,500 4,500,258 29:31:00 Non-Participant H-1961 263,511 4,500,084 13:45:00 Non-Participant H-1970 259,875 4,509,817 9:52:00 Non-Participant H-1971 259,873 4,509,801 9:51:00 Non-Participant H-1972 259,817 4,509,803 8:00:00 Non-Participant H-1973 264,188 4,508,438 6:11:00 Non-Participant H-1974 264,227 4,508,480 6:13:00 Non-Participant H-1975 264,334 4,508,474 7:51:00 Non-Participant H-1977 265,824 4,505,862 22:14:00 Non-Participant H-1978 259,733 4,509,811 5:33:00 Non-Participant H-1979 259,973 4,510,102 2:37:00 Non-Participant H-1984 264,147 4,508,440 6:00:00 Non-Participant H-1988 265,222 4,501,829 5:41:00 Non-Participant H-1991 266,508 4,497,962 33:58:00 Non-Participant H-1993 266,057 4,497,360 0:00:00 Participant H-1999 265,770 4,497,284 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-2000 265,145 4,497,128 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-2006 266,386 4,498,290 34:11:00 Non-Participant H-2008 264,636 4,504,407 11:51:00 Non-Participant H-2024 266,456 4,498,573 14:51:00 Participant H-2031 263,258 4,499,914 6:35:00 Participant H-2032 265,339 4,497,177 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-2033 266,383 4,497,439 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-2034 266,574 4,497,478 1:34:00 Non-Participant H-2035 266,575 4,497,489 1:19:00 Non-Participant H-2036 266,571 4,497,500 0:56:00 Non-Participant H-2037 266,572 4,497,512 0:33:00 Non-Participant H-2038 266,572 4,497,524 0:09:00 Non-Participant H-2039 266,539 4,497,520 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-2040 266,540 4,497,506 0:08:00 Non-Participant H-2041 266,540 4,497,495 0:32:00 Non-Participant H-2042 266,540 4,497,484 0:54:00 Non-Participant H-2043 266,543 4,497,470 1:27:00 Non-Participant H-2050 264,032 4,500,846 12:29:00 Non-Participant H-2051 264,288 4,501,901 61:48:00 Participant H-2052 266,580 4,498,843 8:21:00 Participant

B-10 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-2053 266,559 4,498,205 16:50:00 Non-Participant H-2056 264,964 4,501,872 14:49:00 Non-Participant H-2057 264,141 4,501,201 18:58:00 Non-Participant H-2064 264,571 4,502,499 35:34:00 Participant H-2067 272,023 4,508,265 1:40:00 Non-Participant H-2069 270,971 4,508,960 15:14:00 Non-Participant H-2070 272,494 4,508,253 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-2073 272,603 4,508,748 37:25:00 Non-Participant H-2077 271,035 4,508,609 28:55:00 Non-Participant H-2078 272,577 4,508,873 32:45:00 Non-Participant H-2080 270,986 4,508,693 25:07:00 Non-Participant H-2081 272,549 4,508,246 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-2083 272,536 4,507,882 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-2086 271,813 4,510,998 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-2091 270,822 4,508,648 26:11:00 Non-Participant H-2092 271,487 4,511,014 0:00:00 Non-Participant H-2102 270,963 4,510,327 38:47:00 Participant H-2103 270,222 4,507,803 0:37:00 Participant H-2104 269,249 4,508,025 9:31:00 Non-Participant H-2106 270,936 4,509,539 40:36:00 Non-Participant H-2109 270,663 4,511,005 4:05:00 Non-Participant H-2111 270,970 4,509,188 24:12:00 Non-Participant H-2117 272,538 4,509,507 9:39:00 Non-Participant H-2147 269,232 4,506,511 17:25:00 Non-Participant H-2154 268,400 4,506,222 19:40:00 Non-Participant H-2155 268,352 4,506,721 15:50:00 Non-Participant H-2229 268,723 4,506,122 14:53:00 Participant H-2230 264,749 4,508,979 14:04:00 Non-Participant H-2286 260,264 4,506,567 16:07:00 Non-Participant H-2295 259,887 4,510,189 1:32:00 Non-Participant H-2296 259,887 4,510,170 1:57:00 Non-Participant H-2298 259,883 4,510,059 2:36:00 Non-Participant H-2299 259,887 4,510,024 3:49:00 Non-Participant H-2300 259,879 4,509,994 5:58:00 Non-Participant H-2302 260,959 4,504,874 31:29:00 Non-Participant H-2310 259,882 4,509,973 7:06:00 Non-Participant H-2389 263,939 4,508,069 7:17:00 Non-Participant H-2465 264,674 4,508,363 30:03:00 Non-Participant H-2466 264,723 4,507,958 15:04:00 Non-Participant H-2467 264,707 4,507,962 15:17:00 Non-Participant H-2468 264,671 4,507,974 16:11:00 Non-Participant

B-11 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-2469 264,294 4,508,622 5:34:00 Non-Participant H-2471 264,310 4,508,633 5:34:00 Non-Participant H-2472 264,207 4,508,648 4:50:00 Non-Participant H-2484 259,922 4,509,987 5:10:00 Non-Participant H-2485 259,919 4,510,029 2:53:00 Non-Participant H-2496 264,720 4,508,385 32:53:00 Non-Participant H-2497 267,052 4,506,298 22:50:00 Non-Participant H-2498 264,666 4,508,201 15:59:00 Non-Participant H-2499 264,574 4,508,590 11:11:00 Non-Participant H-2500 264,563 4,508,594 10:43:00 Non-Participant H-2501 264,525 4,508,613 9:42:00 Non-Participant H-2502 264,358 4,508,690 5:43:00 Non-Participant H-2503 264,613 4,508,568 13:49:00 Non-Participant H-2511 264,910 4,508,431 27:47:00 Non-Participant H-2512 264,908 4,508,444 34:52:00 Non-Participant H-2513 264,880 4,508,449 40:11:00 Non-Participant H-2514 264,862 4,508,410 26:36:00 Non-Participant H-2515 264,827 4,508,412 32:02:00 Non-Participant H-2518 264,205 4,508,616 5:05:00 Non-Participant H-2519 264,697 4,508,672 12:58:00 Non-Participant H-2520 264,204 4,508,668 4:41:00 Non-Participant H-2521 264,612 4,508,135 17:49:00 Non-Participant H-2522 264,288 4,508,512 6:32:00 Non-Participant H-2547 264,667 4,508,285 18:06:00 Non-Participant H-2548 264,665 4,508,261 15:59:00 Non-Participant H-2549 264,777 4,508,268 17:38:00 Non-Participant H-2550 264,779 4,508,247 19:09:00 Non-Participant H-2551 267,133 4,506,298 27:02:00 Participant H-2552 264,991 4,508,124 14:44:00 Non-Participant H-2553 264,829 4,508,423 35:24:00 Non-Participant H-2556 264,635 4,508,501 18:47:00 Non-Participant H-2566 264,852 4,508,251 24:36:00 Non-Participant H-2567 264,855 4,508,278 22:25:00 Non-Participant H-2569 264,828 4,508,446 41:49:00 Non-Participant H-2571 264,754 4,508,495 34:06:00 Non-Participant H-2572 264,714 4,508,713 11:57:00 Non-Participant H-2582 264,645 4,508,646 11:57:00 Non-Participant H-2588 265,437 4,507,940 24:15:00 Non-Participant H-2590 264,886 4,508,278 26:00:00 Non-Participant H-2591 264,885 4,508,252 26:10:00 Non-Participant H-2593 264,993 4,508,150 14:20:00 Non-Participant

B-12 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-2594 264,987 4,508,195 17:22:00 Non-Participant H-2595 265,024 4,508,193 14:12:00 Non-Participant H-2596 264,955 4,508,197 19:41:00 Non-Participant H-2597 264,960 4,508,152 14:31:00 Non-Participant H-2598 264,953 4,508,119 14:50:00 Non-Participant H-2599 264,946 4,508,086 15:07:00 Non-Participant H-2601 264,995 4,508,244 24:09:00 Non-Participant H-2602 264,995 4,508,291 29:16:00 Non-Participant H-2603 264,998 4,508,320 29:20:00 Non-Participant H-2604 259,889 4,510,203 1:18:00 Non-Participant H-2605 264,879 4,508,105 14:52:00 Non-Participant H-2606 264,503 4,507,987 18:34:00 Non-Participant H-2607 264,587 4,508,586 11:40:00 Non-Participant H-2608 264,511 4,508,620 9:12:00 Non-Participant H-2609 264,552 4,508,600 10:13:00 Non-Participant H-2622 264,607 4,508,065 18:32:00 Non-Participant H-2623 264,701 4,508,634 15:03:00 Non-Participant H-2624 265,069 4,508,290 26:00:00 Non-Participant H-2625 264,668 4,508,041 18:19:00 Non-Participant H-2626 264,663 4,508,024 17:36:00 Non-Participant H-2634 265,262 4,507,948 20:51:00 Non-Participant H-2637 260,044 4,509,975 4:12:00 Non-Participant H-2638 260,035 4,510,142 2:10:00 Non-Participant H-2639 260,061 4,510,110 2:14:00 Non-Participant H-2640 260,044 4,510,082 2:28:00 Non-Participant H-2641 260,044 4,510,059 3:05:00 Non-Participant H-2642 260,042 4,510,030 3:34:00 Non-Participant H-2643 264,887 4,508,181 21:16:00 Non-Participant H-2644 264,889 4,508,198 22:59:00 Non-Participant H-2645 264,913 4,508,205 22:47:00 Non-Participant H-2646 264,852 4,508,201 24:05:00 Non-Participant H-2647 264,817 4,508,195 23:46:00 Non-Participant H-2648 264,846 4,508,185 23:00:00 Non-Participant H-2652 264,953 4,508,357 19:56:00 Non-Participant H-2653 264,967 4,508,299 28:50:00 Non-Participant H-2654 264,966 4,508,322 27:34:00 Non-Participant H-2655 264,936 4,508,323 23:57:00 Non-Participant H-2656 264,887 4,508,295 23:35:00 Non-Participant H-2657 264,890 4,508,353 17:40:00 Non-Participant H-2658 264,893 4,508,371 16:42:00 Non-Participant H-2659 264,889 4,508,385 15:58:00 Non-Participant

B-13 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

WindPro Predicted Expected Shadow Project Hardin Flicker Receptor UTM-E UTM-N (Hours per Participation ID (m) (m) Year) Status H-2660 264,916 4,508,385 16:31:00 Non-Participant H-2661 264,860 4,508,384 17:41:00 Non-Participant H-2662 264,858 4,508,371 16:22:00 Non-Participant H-2663 264,821 4,508,164 21:46:00 Non-Participant H-2664 264,837 4,508,160 21:07:00 Non-Participant H-2665 264,850 4,508,159 20:40:00 Non-Participant H-2666 264,760 4,508,097 17:57:00 Non-Participant H-2667 264,559 4,507,917 17:57:00 Non-Participant H-2668 264,413 4,508,506 9:20:00 Non-Participant H-2669 264,411 4,508,522 9:08:00 Non-Participant H-2670 264,413 4,508,538 8:57:00 Non-Participant H-2671 265,021 4,507,956 24:20:00 Non-Participant H-2672 263,502 4,500,303 41:12:00 Non-Participant H-2677 264,652 4,507,971 16:26:00 Non-Participant H-2678 264,307 4,508,512 7:11:00 Non-Participant H-2685 264,770 4,508,162 21:58:00 Non-Participant H-2689 264,783 4,508,359 22:27:00 Non-Participant H-2690 264,780 4,508,386 29:44:00 Non-Participant H-2691 264,723 4,508,335 22:16:00 Non-Participant H-2692 264,671 4,508,307 21:16:00 Non-Participant H-2693 264,768 4,508,203 22:22:00 Non-Participant H-2694 264,731 4,508,203 20:20:00 Non-Participant H-2695 264,665 4,508,114 19:26:00 Non-Participant H-2696 264,667 4,508,133 19:17:00 Non-Participant H-2697 264,665 4,508,163 18:39:00 Non-Participant H-2698 264,661 4,508,181 16:37:00 Non-Participant H-2700 264,279 4,508,655 5:07:00 Non-Participant H-2701 264,373 4,508,589 7:35:00 Non-Participant H-2702 264,413 4,508,554 8:50:00 Non-Participant H-2703 264,395 4,508,572 8:13:00 Non-Participant H-2704 264,365 4,508,626 6:09:00 Non-Participant H-2705 264,413 4,508,681 5:53:00 Non-Participant H-2706 264,163 4,508,557 5:20:00 Non-Participant H-2707 264,164 4,508,638 4:47:00 Non-Participant H-2708 264,165 4,508,654 4:42:00 Non-Participant H-2728 271,597 4,508,268 5:53:00 Non-Participant H-2899 263,542 4,499,759 4:08:00 Non-Participant H-2910 264,995 4,508,272 27:51:00 Non-Participant H-2911 264,773 4,508,231 20:49:00 Non-Participant H-2985 268,207 4,506,645 25:20:00 Non-Participant

B-14 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

ATTACHMENT B

Turbine Locations for the Hardin Wind Farm

B-1 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

Turbine UTM-E UTM-N ID (m) (m) 1 260483 4509447 2 260245 4509129 3 260245 4508748 4 260562 4508352 5 261039 4509479 6 261126 4509185 7 261190 4508860 8 261348 4508566 9 261586 4508328 10 261690 4507883 11 261769 4507526 12 262515 4509248 13 262674 4508979 14 262817 4508709 15 260856 4507955 16 260856 4507597 17 260872 4507296 18 260943 4507010 19 261031 4506716 20 260130 4507951 21 260265 4507691 22 261914 4506970 23 262059 4506676 24 262122 4506279 25 262136 4505892 26 262358 4505647 27 262913 4506190 28 262936 4505790 29 263085 4505380 30 261604 4505674 31 261524 4505062 32 260656 4505232 33 259485 4506158 34 259836 4506105 35 260233 4506085 37 259489 4504339 38 260117 4504478 39 263832 4507752 40 263829 4507458 41 263822 4507167 42 263806 4506869

B-2 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

Turbine UTM-E UTM-N ID (m) (m) 43 263799 4506549 44 263832 4506208 45 263789 4505751 46 264083 4505586 47 264335 4505328 48 264358 4504964 49 263647 4504591 50 263584 4504316 51 263472 4503989 52 264001 4503876 53 263333 4503615 54 263366 4503258 55 263521 4502950 56 263591 4502606 57 263710 4502176 58 263938 4501955 59 264477 4503843 60 264517 4503546 61 264543 4503271 62 264579 4502920 63 264828 4502676 64 264940 4502401 65 262691 4501653 66 262754 4501382 67 262830 4501094 68 262979 4500830 69 263055 4500502 70 262955 4500135 71 262258 4500476 72 262198 4500158 73 263557 4501303 76 265018 4507197 77 265216 4506987 78 265782 4507601 79 265928 4507339 80 266039 4507059 81 266069 4498106 83 265269 4508621 84 265613 4508536 85 266015 4508380 86 266272 4508187

B-3 Hardin Wind Farm – Shadow Flicker Analysis

Turbine UTM-E UTM-N ID (m) (m) 88 266785 4508512 91 267543 4508924 92 267691 4508520 94 268330 4509086 97 269063 4508952 98 269055 4508642 99 265417 4496676 101 267307 4507677 102 265941 4498603 103 267880 4507465 104 268161 4507349 105 268435 4507234 106 268720 4507118 107 269765 4506575 108 266943 4507104 109 267255 4506866 110 267509 4506615 111 270596 4509993 112 271437 4510527 113 271469 4509681 114 271432 4509199 115 271998 4509030 116 272136 4508765 117 270570 4508379 118 270660 4508104 121 267602 4507587 123 267868 4508198 124 268287 4508814 125 266185 4506127 126 266267 4505846 127 261760 4507229 129 264304 4501576 130 267670 4506408 131 264416 4507151 132 262960 4506939 133 263023 4506606

B-4