<<

15822 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS June 19, 1980 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS

IN MEMORIAM-RUSSELL W. Rowena Jelliffe fought an uphill At this time, Mr. Speaker, I enter JELLIFFE battle to rectify this situation. two articles written about Russell Jel­ As a result, playwright, poet, and liffe in the CONGRESSIONAL RECORD: HON. LOUIS STOKES actor , and television RUSSELL W. JELLIFFE performers Ivan Dixon and Robert Men of foresight and wisdom struggle dili­ OF Guillaume got their starts in Karamu gently to fulfill their dreams, never count­ IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES House. Local talent like Dr. Zelma ing the cost or the sacrifice such devotion George, a superb opera singer, were demands. Such a man was Russell W. Jel­ Thursday, June 19, 1980 liffe. Long before legislation decreed civil also provided a showcase at Karamu rights, he and his wife, Rowena, champi­ e Mr. STOKES. Mr. Speaker, thank House. oned human rights and equal opportunities you for extending me this opportunity With the Jelliffes playing such a at a time <1915> when such liberal views to memorialize a man of great vision vital role in black theater in this coun­ were considered radical. They concentrated and one who had the fortitude to try, I shudder to think what would their efforts on the underprivileged, the de­ make it a reality-Mr. Russell W. Jel­ have happened if it had not been for prived and the displaced regardless of race, liffe. On Saturday, June 7, 1980, Rus­ their unfledging commitment. creed or color. sell W. Jelliffe, founder and director The success of the Jelliffe's Karamu In addition to Karamu House, both House was the fruition of years of constant emeritus of the famous Karamu Russell and Rowena Jelliffe were very struggle, and an unnerving belief in the dig­ House in died. Mr. Speaker, involved in the improvement in the nity of men. Its inter-racial and cultural arts the many Clevelanders and friends quality of life for blacks and the poor program, under their guidance, nurtured around the world who loved and re­ in Cleveland and around the country. painters, dancers, actors, singers and musi­ spected him will participate in a memo­ Mr. Jelliffe was one of the founders of cians who achieved national and interna­ rial service o~ June 25, 1980. tional fame while the founders continued to the Cleveland Metropolitan Housing concentrate on the local black and white Many of my colleagues are familiar Authority and the Cleveland Urban residents of Cleveland. The Jelliffes were an with Karamu House and the exempla­ League. Additionally, he was a unbeatable team. ry dramatic arts, music, dance, and member of the executive committee of Now that partnership has been dissolved theater it has provided to people the NAACP. by his death. Now in the hectic times of the throughout the years regardless of Mr. Speaker, I must reiterate that present day, our city and our nation need race, social status, or economic level. persons of the caliber of Russell Jelliffe, Mr. Russell Jelliffe and his wife men of faith and unselfish dedication who The idea of Karamu House and its Rowena dedicated their lives to the are willing to sacrifice private gain for overriding philosophy of racial har­ less fortunate people in our society­ public good. mony was the dream of Russell Jel­ the ones America had turned its back Unfortunately, the ranks of such individ­ liffe and his lovely wife, Rowena. This on. After his retirement from Karamu uals are slowly dwindling and few, if any, dream has stood the test of time and House in 1963, the Jelliffes traveled are ready to take his place. Does his death has weathered the ups and downs of around the country helping other mark the end of an Era? race relations in this country to groups establish theaters like Karamu become a shining symbol of both the­ House. Because of this compassion and [From the Cleveland Press, June 10, 1980] atrical and social and racial coopera­ achievement, I feel honored to be on JELLIFFE WAS BROTHERHOOD'S CHAMPION tion. the board of Karamu House ~ The world of race relations or of humanity lost a great champion over pleasant one. When Karamu House the weekend with the death of Russell Jel­ was founded, the Jelliffes were consid­ long as Karamu House is open, he will liffe, who with his wife Rowena· founded, in ered to be radicals. At that period in live with us. 1915, what was to become Cleveland's our history, Mr. Speaker, it was not Russell Jelliffe did so much for so famous Karamu House. fashionable for whites to be concerned many. I think that an analogy can be Thus, for 65 years, our town and that in­ about the well-being of blacks. Howev­ drawn between what Russell Jelliffe stitution have been known for their efforts er, the Jelliffes were atypical and did for the performing arts and the at recognizing that all of mankind has stood fast to their dream. following verse written by Mr. Lang­ within it the capacity not only for tolerance but, far more important, for active coopera­ From its inception as a community ston Hughes: tion and good will. settlement house in 1915, the primary I too sing America Karamu's success over the years and the purpose was to apprise blacks from I am the darker brother. Jelliffes' many honors are far too familiar the great migration from the South to They send me to eat in the kitchen when stories to recount here. Each person who company comes, has been touched by them has his own story the North on how to find jobs and to tell. And while the details will differ with housing. Later, Karamu House grew But, I laugh and eat well, and grow strong. the individual, the principle, the thread into a parent organization for adult Tomorrow, I'll be at the table when compa­ that runs so true through the whole fabric, education programs, a children's nurs­ ny comes; is the same: The conviction they held that ery, and dance, quartet, chorus, and Nobody'll dare say to me, "Eat in the kitch- with either individuals or groups, working art groups. Probably most notable was en,'' with one another is better by far than work­ the fact that the theater became inter­ Then, besides, they'll see how beautiful I ing against one another. nationally known as the first outlet am- My first association with Russell Jelliffe And be ashamed­ came at the time of the opening of the then for black playwrights and actors in the brand new Karamu Theaters at the corner United States. For I too, am America of 89th St. and Quincy Ave. It was Russell Jelliffe's dream that Russell Jelliffe demonstrated that The year 1949 saw Karamu House well the theater could be a place where we are all a part of America. His preoc­ along toward its international fame as an example-more than that, a showcase-for black plays as well as white plays and cupation with this extended from com­ the blending of the artistic talents of blacks actresses could be judged fairly on munity affairs to business to the per­ and whites. tl).eir merits. With the inequitable sit­ forming arts. In this day of increasing But the building of the theaters, small but uation with black plays and actors at racial strife, he leaves us a dream and modern and well equipped, was a milestone that time in this country, Russell and a powerful legacy. that required putting the very best foot for-

e This "bullet" symbol identifies statements or insertions which are not spoken by the Member on the floor. June 19, 1980 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 15823 ward with exciting and dramatic fare that the summer Olympic games in The beginning of the trial immedi­ would make the world sit up and take its Moscow. ately generated public interest which second look at what Cleveland had here. Jay Mogavero and his New England greatly increased when the sentences I personally felt highly honored to be were announced in December. In fact, asked, at the time, to be the musical direc­ Barracuda Amateur Swimming Team tor of the opening presentation, Gian-Carlo were invited last winter by the Soviet the international reaction to the Menotti's gripping opera "The Medium." Union to represent the United States severe sentences was so strong that Russell Jelliffe convinced me, in about four in a special international swimming the Soviet Government had to reduce sentences, of the historic nature of the ven­ meet that was to have taken place this all of them. Of those convicted all ture-just as he was able to do with almost past January. Mogavero's team, con­ have gotten to the West except three everyone he talked to about it. sisting of 10 senior-level girls and an men who still remain in prison camps: Dr. Zelma George, opera singer, sociolo­ equal number of boys, was to have Iosif Mendelevich (32), Yuri Federov gist and a pillar of strength for artistic taken on the Russians in one of a long causes, black and white, had been cast as <37), and Aleksei Murzhenko <37). Madame Flora, the phony spiritualist who series of preparations the Russians Mendelevich, the heart and spirit of gets caught up in her own machinations and were staging in preparation for the the operation, was a student/engineer superstitions. The late Benno Frank, a prod­ summer Olympic games. from Riga who was given a sentence of uct of the Max Reinhardt school of the the­ Mogavero, a former high school and 12 years in strict regime. Despite the ater in Germany and at that time head of college AU-American, stated that this fact that he had a lighter sentence Karamu's lyric-theater endeavors, was the was the first team not from California than some of the others convicted stage director. to ever receive such a distinction. The In all, we gave about 75 performances of along with him, his release has seemed the show, and a truly gala opening produc­ Barracudas were invited by the Soviets incomprehensibly remote. During the tion it turned out to be: Dr. George, in fact, after research found the team to be past 10 years of internment he has made such a spectacular hit in the title role the best in New England and one of courageously persisted in strict adher­ that she was invited by the composer him­ the very top on the entire eastern sea­ ence of his religious beliefs despite the self to go down to and star in a board. resulting harassment and persecution. similar production of "The Medium." After painful preparation and exten­ Mendelevich's health is deteriorating The point is that Jelliffe instinctively sive fundraising efforts were undertak­ rapidly and he is in grave jeopardy. knew just how this and other musical, the­ en, President Carter issued his threat atrical and artistic ventures would help pro­ Federov and Murzhenko were both mote his original thesis, that the races could to boycott the Olympics if Soviet student/workers in major Soviet cities.· successfully intermingle and produce some­ troops were not evacuated from Af­ They had been in prison camps before thing that was exciting and entertaining ghanistan by the end of February. As this occurred for distributing antigov­ and that eventually it would be seen that a good and true American and as a ernment leaflets, had suffered perse­ the differences between the races had noth­ member of an American delegation of ing to do with it. These were people, not young people, Mogavero felt he had a cution after ·their release from prison blacks or whites or Jews or WASPS. They moral responsibility to cancel what and then joined forces with the Soviet were either good, mediocre, or bad, but cer­ was clearly a dream for all of the Bar­ Jews involved in the incident. They tainly not along racial lines. are serving 14 and 15 year terms re­ The show, in other words, would rise to racudas. spectively for varying charges of trea­ great heights or fall on its face not only ac­ For his selfless sacrifice and true son. Both feel strongly that they have cording to what each individual brought to dedication to his country, I would like never pursued criminal aims. In his it but what the melding of talents would to take this opportunity to commend produce. Jay Mogavero and his team of Barra­ statement at the close of the trial Fe­ Russell Jelliffe lived through several vacil­ cudas. They clearly deserve the com­ derov said, "I do not feel guilty • • • as lations of the racial-strife/racial-coopera­ mendation of the entire House of Rep­ a matter of conscience-! have done tion situation. He saw the ups and downs resentatives.• nothing." and faced them with a kind of placid equa­ The time is especially ripe on the nimity, knowing that one would follow the lOth anniversary of the arrests for the other, and that with perseverance and confi­ dence they would level off. FREEDOM NEEDED FOR Members of Congress to continue our The process is by no means complete. LENINGRAD TRIAL PRISONERS protest against the imprisonment of Karamu itself has gone through those ups Mendelevich, Federov, and Murzhenko and downs. It has been run by whites, by HON. S. WILLIAM GREEN and the treatment of all Soviet Jews blacks, and by a mixture of both. It has and other human rights activists. We done many so-called white shows. It has OF NEW YORK must continue the international pres­ done many black shows. It has on occasion IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES sure on the Soviet Government to ful­ been criticized by blacks as being too white, by whites as being too black. Thursday, June 19, 1980 fill the pledges they made under the But it has never really lost sight of the • Mr. GREEN. Mr. Speaker, on June Helsinki accords, the U.N. Human Jelliffes' original idea: The ongoing coopera­ 15, 1980, the Soviet Government Rights Covenants, and other interna­ tion of the races. Which, over the years, is shocked and outraged the free world tional agreements. The release of the what it has always done best. by sentencing 11 persons to death or five Soviet prisoners of conscience last It would be difficult to think of anyone May in exchange for two captured who so confidently persevered in his princi­ lengthy prison terms in what has come to be known as the Leningrad trial. It Soviet spies confirms the belief that ples as Russell Jelliffe, or who made and persistence can get results. I have kept so many friends in so doing.e was the first in a series of such pros­ ecutions for an unsuccessful attempt joined my House colleagues in writing to seize an Aeroflot plane to emigrate to Chairman Leonid Brezhnev to pro­ from the Soviet Union. They were test their imprisonment and urge their JAY MOGAVERO AND THE eventually convicted on a series of release. BARRACUDA SWIM CLUB trumped-up charges of treason and I am dismayed that these three Len­ various crimes against the state. ingrad defendants still languish in HON. NICHOLAS MAVROULES Despite a 99-percent certainty that Soviet prison camps under conditions OF MASSACHUSETTS they would be caught and sentenced that almost defy description. We IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES to labor camps, the Leningrad group cannot sit in silence in the face of such carried out the attempt as one of the suffering, repression, and denial of Thursday, June 19, 1980 only means available to them to cap­ basic human rights, which continues e Mr. MAVROULES. Mr. Speaker, I ture international attention for the unabated for countless thousands. would like to bring to the attention of dissidents' movement. They wanted These courageous men must not be my colleagues the great personal sacri­ their cause, that of all human rights forgotten; the world must continually fice a constituent of mine, Jay Moga­ activists and themselves individually, be made aware of their condition and vero, of West Peabody, Mass., has to get as much attention and support their desire to be free. In the interest made with regard to the boycott of as possible. of humanity we must forcefully voice 15824 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS June 19, 1980 our outrage and express our deepest I insert the text of Secretary "clean" bill for Oahe deauthorization would hopes for their imminent release.e Andrus' response to the delegation's be agreed to be introduced again at the be­ May 12 letter, along with the South ginning of the next Congress. Dakota delegation's response into the During the period between now and mid- THE SPIRIT OF LITHUANIA 1981, when a definitive choice on Oahe RECORD, in addition to a news release I deauthorization will be required, a concert­ STILL LIVES issued describing my thoughts regard­ ed and cooperative effort will be made to ing this agreement. better assess South Dakota water resource HON. LARRY McDONALD U.S. DEPARTMEIIlT OF THE INTERIOR, needs, and to develop agreement on other OF GEORGIA OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY, possibilities for development in addition to Washington, D.C., June 18, 1980. the WEB pipeline. We realize that, within IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Hon. THOMAS DASCHLE, the state and even within the delegation, Thursday, June 19, 1980 House of Representatives, views may differ on various alternatives and Washington, D. C. priorities, and the Administration has e Mr. McDONALD. Mr. Speaker, 40 DEAR MR. DASCHLE: I am writing in re­ strong views as well. We should use the next years ago, the Soviet Union forcibly sponse to your letter of May 12, 1980, and 12 to 14 months as a period of working to­ incorporated Lithuania into the pursuant to the consultations which have gether toward agreement on issues impor­ U.S.S.R. Except for a short period of occurred between us since that time. tant to the water resource needs of South German occupation, Lithuania has I want to begin by thanking you for the Dakota and the appropriate contribution of been a forced member of the U.S.S.R. constructive nature of your letter, and the the Federal Government to those needs. extraordinary effort and care you have We would approach this effort with great ever since. The Soviet Union does not given to resolving the difficult questions re­ but realistic expectations, and expect all like to review that part of her history garding the future water resource needs of others to do the same. A common initial un­ concerning the balmy days of coopera­ South Dakota. In spite of differences which derstanding of the conditions which will de­ tion between two of history's bloodiest may exist regarding some specific issues, I termine ultimate agreement will vastly im­ dictators-Hitler and Stalin. The facts am convinced we share a commitment to prove our capability to work together. Obvi­ remain, however, and in the cause of meeting South Dakota's needs through ously, there must be a mutual understand­ human freedom, we should not permit sound water management and development, ing that the package put together in the the Central Committee of the Commu­ and seeing that the Federal role is a major coming months will require Administration and cooperative one. agreement. From the Administration's view­ nist Party of the Soviet Union to The Administration has made clear its point, you should understand that support forget these facts. Since becoming part view that it cannot support the permanent for any additional future projects or pro­ of the Soviet Union, hundreds of thou­ authorization of the WEB project in the ab­ grams will be based on established planning sands of Lithuanians have been de­ sence of a deauthorization of the Oahe and evaluation procedures, consistency with ported to Siberia, thousands have died Unit, and I believe the reasons for this are existing Federal programs, standards set in Soviet forced labor camps, others well understood. You have made clear, in forth in the President's water policy mes­ have suffered untold miseries and per­ return, two central points. First, that if sage of June 6, 1978, and consistency with secutions, particularly those strongly Oahe is to be deauthorized, you must con­ existing budgetary constraints. Such stand­ adhering to the Catholic faith. Infor­ sider and address other water development ards are indeed more demanding, in some needs in the state in addition to the WEB cases, than those being applied to the WEB mation reaching the United States in­ project. Second, that additional time is proposal itself. dicates that the struggle for human needed to identify and analyze other pro­ It should also be understood that, the freedom and dignity goes on in Lithua­ posals and to permit adequate public consid­ prior decision to authorize and fund the nia in spite of the Communist Party eration of them. Oahe unit, or any speculative evaluation of and the KGB. And the Lithuanians Our reaction to these points is favorable, that authorization, cannot serve as a meas­ now have some support for their cause and with some variation, we are able to ure of what might be agreed upon in coming from such Soviet dissidents as Malva accept the basic premise of your May 12 months. While no reasonable alternative Land, Viktor Nekipelov, Tatiana Veli­ letter. What we propose is a process which can be ruled out at the beginning of this would create the time and opportunity for process, it is equally important to under­ kanova, Andrei Sakharov, and Arina development of other responses to state stand that agreement is unlikely if it is Ginzburg, who all signed a letter of needs, yet leave you in a position in mid- predicated on unresolvable budgetary, legal support of the rights of the Baltic na­ 1981 similar to that which exists today-a or political basis. We have previously indi­ tions to be free last year. May the fires choice between the continued authorization cated our feeling that the formulation ad­ of freedom burn more strongly in the of Oahe indicate that, under condi­ Study Commission projects in its "medium Latin porta, or gate, and a port is, in truth, tions of only moderate economic growth, growth" scenario that investment in U.S. the gateway to a state, region, or country. U.S. waterborne foreign trade will increase port and harbor facilities dedicated to inter­ The word "airport" has, of course, the same from the 622.2 million long tons reported in national commerce will total some $13 bil­ derivation and meaning.) 1975 from 1975 The nation's early settlements clustered bulk tonnage previously mentioned) to 970.0 through the year 2000, with $9.4 billion of near the sea for a variety of sensible rea­ million tons by 1985, 1.1 billion tons by 1990, the total coming from local and state gov­ sons. Fishing on the rivers and in the and 1.4 billion tons by the year 2000. exclusively-public operation. It should dem­ decisions. decade in the defense against the American onstrate that the purpose of collecting edu­ A second objection is that the parental state of the personal education rights of cation taxes from the public is to assist par­ grant would lead to widespread discrimina­ parents and students to religious liberty and ents to educate their children and not to tion against such groups as minorities and academic freedom, the National Association give government officials control over the poor. Here no one can deny the lamen­ for Personal Rights in Education schooling, as, for instance, through impos­ table failures of some private schools any­ respectfully urges the Republican Party to adopt the following three planks in its 1980 ing secular humanism or academic imperial­ more than those who so self-righteously ism on the children of this nation. It must criticize such schools can deny that in im­ national platform: conclude that if parents become burdened portant areas public schools have been the The Republican Party affirms that the with government education officials deter­ prime architects of racial segregation. But, primary right of education belongs, not to mined to control schooling, they must con­ whatever the past, inner-city private the state and federal governments, but to sider the curtailment of taxation. parents; schools, hanging on desperately in these in­ The examination must highlight that the flationary times, are providing a rich source The Republican Party endorses tax-sup­ personal constitutional rights of parents of quality education for many minority and ported parental grants or vouchers through and students under the establishment and poor children. which parents could be assisted in enrolling their children in public or private elemen­ freedom clauses cannot be denied by reason Actually, while government denial of tax of any church-state controversy. It should equity for alternative schooling falls on tary and secondary schools of their choice; demonstrate that the U.S. Supreme Court, families from all classes, it weighs particu­ The Republican Party calls for an exami­ while ignoring the establishment involved in larly heavily on families which are economi­ nation of the relations of American govern­ assigning the tax monopoly to preferred cally incapable of making a choice and thus ments to parents and students in the field schools and values, has incredibly concluded remain in a state of dependency on govern­ of schooling, with particular emphasis on that the Establishment Clause would be vio­ ment teachers. Further this condition is the distribution of education taxation. lated by giving dissenters an equitable being politically reinforced by the National One basic principle for such an examina­ share. In his dissent in Meek v. Pittenger Education Association, the American Feder­ tion should be that for many families reli­ <1975) Chief Justice Burger referred to such ation of Teachers, and other enemies of pa­ gion is essential to schooling and that, if court action as not simply tilting the Consti­ rental choice. From our inner-city experi­ governments tax the public for schooling, tution against religion but literally turning ence we assert that minority and poor fami­ they should so distribute the taxes as to the Religion Clause on its head. lies are generally capable of making the protect religious rights. Unfortunately The examination would reveal the wide­ right choices with parental grants. In any American governments have generally allo­ spread dissatisfaction of parents with the case we contend that the parental grant cated a monopoly of the tax to support pre­ academic and moral tone in many public would prove to be the most effective weapon ferred schools without regard for religious schools, with a striking example being the against discrimination and injustice. dissenters. large-scale ongoing abandonment by many_ There are other matters to be discussed, A first example is seen in the colonial New Protestants of their once-cherished public even if only briefly. One is that quality edu­ England congregational schools, which were schools in favor of private Christian schools. cation cannot be mass-produced or conduct­ based on a preferential tax arrangement be­ ed by armies of educational bureaucrats far tween the political community and one In conclusion, with the hope that the Re­ removed from the scene, but must rather be church. A second example is the state public publican Party will wholeheartedly join the carried on by parents and teachers cooper­ school system, which was, as the research of struggle to make certain that every Ameri­ ating as teams under conditions of smallness Professor Jorgenson of Missouri and other can family that wishes so, whether in public and freedom and individual attention in a scholars have demonstrated, founded in the or private schools, can at long last have family atmosphere of love and work person­ mid-19th century in great part on a prefer­ equitable access to the education tax dollar, al dignity. Such closeness was the secret of ential tax collusion between the American we again respectfully request the Republi­ many of the original public schools. It is the state and the dominant Protestant churches can Party to take a strong stand in its 1980 secret of many hardy inner-city private of the day, with dissenters being denied tax national platform for parental rights in edu­ schools. It can be the secret of attaining equity. A third example is that, with the cation, for tax-supported parental grants, quality education for American children if private Protestant values on the decline in and for the long-overdue examination of the parental power is restored through parental the public schools, the tax monopoly today relationships between the American state grants. preferentially supports the private values of and its citizens in the matter of schooling.e On a second point the role of schools in secular humanism-a life orientation that teaching, character formation, and prepara­ looks only to man without reference to tion of students for economic life should be God-as the new educational establishment, studied. As to the unemployment of so with the National Education Association CONGRESSMAN GREEN NOTES many young minority and poor and as well being a new national priesthood. PASSING OF RABBI BERNARD J. to the nonproductivity of so many young The U.S. Supreme Court, proceeding BAMBERGER people from all backgrounds, we ask this under the illusion that the public school is committee to examine to what extent this or can be genuinely neutral, has played a unemployment and nonproductivity may disastrous role in this matter. Thus by oust­ HON. S. WILLIAM GREEN be-in part-attributed to their schooling or ing residual elements of Protestantism from OF NEW YORK lack thereof. the public schools, the Court has given pow­ We also plead with this committee to con­ erful impetus to the takeover by secular hu­ IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES sider that more serious threats to American manism. The Court has also struck down­ Thursday, June 19, 1980 freedoms are arising from the expanding of with decisions vitiated by historical igno­ the state and federal controls over school­ rance and documentary distortion-all but a • Mr. GREEN. Mr. Speaker, it is with ing. Many good-willed legislators support few of the many state laws enacted to recti­ a profound sense of grief that I rise to practically any proposal to fund govern- fy deep-rooted tax inequities to dissenters. note the passing last Saturday of 15832 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS June 19, 1980 Rabbi Bernard J. Bamberger, rabbi orthopedic consultant. At the time of my BRIBERY BEGINS EARLY emeritus of Temple Shaaray Tefila. emigration to the United States, I was head The problems of Soviet medicine begin in Rabbi Bamberger had been the of traumatology, orthopedic surgery, and the medical schools. There the practice of leader of Temple Shaaray Tefila from military surgery at a major 250-bed Moscow paying bribes for admission is so well estab­ clinic. lished and widespread that its study be­ 1944 until his retirement in 1971. The Soviet medicine is not what it seems to comes a special discipline of the science of temple, located in the 18th Congres­ visitors. For security reasons, they geography. sional District at 250 East 79th Street, are never admitted to our finest medical In Soviet Georgia, bribery is a way of life. is this year observing its 135th anni­ facilities. These are the "palace hospitals" So Dr. Otary Gelbakhiani, dean of the versary. It is one of New York's oldest created by the Communist Party to serve its Tbilisi medical school, routinely demanded and most prominent reform Jewish own elite-perhaps 2,000 top Party officials a bribe of 40,000 rubles from every enrollee. synagogues. and their families-and administered by Dr. would INSIDE: BRIBERY AS A DOC­ way approaching the level of care at a U.S. bave to work 90 years to attain the wage of TOR'S WAY OF LIFE-PART I counterpart. a beginning bus driver. My own years of ex­ Most foreigners assume that in this social­ perience and level of specialization were HON. LARRY McDONALD ized state treatment is free and readily such that, at the end, I earned the maxi­ available. It is neither. The hospitalized mum possible doctor's salary-500 rubles a OF GEORGIA Soviet citizen pays for everything out of his month. However, stipends from my consul­ IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES own pocket. He buys his own meals (since tancies at the "special" hospitals and occa­ sional royalty checks from my books almost Thursday, June 19, 1980 the hospital usually embezzles the miserly 82 kopecks the government allots for food doubled my income in some years. • Mr. McDONALD. Mr. Speaker, one each day). He hires someone to spoon-feed How then is it possible to pay a 40,000- of the things that apologists for Com­ him if necessary; he rents his sheets and ruble bribe to enter medical school, when munist regimes always tell us is that hospital clothing; his family buys much of during his first five years of practice, the or­ medical care is free and it is good in his medicine elsewhere, since the hospital dinary doctor earns a grand total of only doesn't stock it; and he hands out money to 6,600 rubles, progressing in his fifth five­ socialist countries. This is not true and year period to 9,000 rubles? After 25 years, informed people know this. The free his nurses and doctor in the hope that they will give him special care and attention. such a doctor has officially earned a grand world countries deliver the best medi­ Often, especially if he suffers from a seri­ total of only 39,000 rubles-still not enough cal care and discover most of the new ous condition, he must pay for the privilege to cover the bribe he paid to get into medi­ medicines. However, the myth contin­ of being hospitalized. Mothers of asthmatic cal school. ues to outlive the facts. Dr. Vladimir children not only must pay-unofficially- To explain this paradox, I give you the Golyakhovsky, a former Soviet doctor, 1,000 rubles to have their children admitted case of a graduate of the very same Tbilisi wrote several articles that appeared in to the bronchial asthma ward of Moscow's medical school. A specialist in venereal dis­ Medical Economics on February 18, Hospital No. 52, but then must come to the eases in the beautiful little Black Sea resort 1980, and March 3, 1980, graphically hospital after work and clean floors. town of Gagra, he was able to pay for his Why is health care in the wealthiest and "free" medical education in two months describing how Soviet medicine really most powerful nation in the Communist with his earnings from our "free" medical operates. No American would wish to world in so sick and sorry a state? There are care. Every morning, his senior nurse ex­ go near a Soviet hospital after reading three principal reasons: plains to the queue of unfortunate tourists these articles. Part I describes his ex­ The Soviet government allots too little lined up from office door to the shore that perience with the medical education money for medicine because it receives no the doctor treats patients at his house-a system in the U.S.S.R. Part II will de­ cash return from this investment. Medicine charming cottage next door, set among scribe Soviet medicine in actual oper­ gets only what budgetary crumbs remain grape arbors. Sometimes a disgruntled pa­ ation. I commend these articles to the after the government has paid for propa­ tient complains, "I've already paid for sex in ganda, the military, and the inefficient this town, and I don't intend to pay for my attention of my colleagues: economy. Thus, Soviet doctors lack equip­ venereal disease, too." The nurse gives him SOVIET MEDICINE FROM THE INSIDE: BRIBERY ment adequate to diagnose, to treat, or to an appointment for two weeks hence and AS A DOCTOR'S WAY OF LIFE-PART I operate. calls the police to report him as a VD carri­ In 1953, the Soviet Union's secret police, The morale of doctors and nurses is very er. The disgruntled patient now has to bribe the KGB, herded nine of the country's most low. They feel they are ruining their own the nurse and the policeman, too. brilliant physicians into a dungeon and tor­ health in exhausting, round-the-clock labor In season, this doctor treats 40 to 50 pa­ tured them until they "confessed" to poi­ for a miserly monthly stipend. They contin­ tients a day, charging about 25 rubles each. soning several top Communist officials, in ue to practice medicine out of compassion His fees are flexible, though-from 10 what the press dutifully recorded as the for the suffering, but many have fallen into rubles for students to 50 rubles for fat offi­ Doctors' Plot. That same year, I began my corruption and apathy. cials or their wives. At the end of a long day, own medical career in Petrozavodsk, a prin­ Soviet medical administrators are corrupt, the doctor cheerfully empties his pockets of cipal city near the Finnish border. incompetent, arrogant, and wasteful. There envelopes. This is his moment of triumph, Since that time, I have observed the are too many of them, and they are too because he makes about 1,000 rubles a day. I whole range of Soviet health delivery, from powerful. They manage to impose Marxist saw it with my own eyes. He would laugh at a small wooden district hospital with five ideology even on the physical sciences. They me and say, "Well, Mr. Moscow Professor, cots serving lumbermen in the frozen north seriously hamper the work of doctors who can you make as much as an ordinary to the offices of the Ministry of Health. I treat the sick. They have put Soviet physi­ doctor like me?" have treated patients, performed research, cians 25 to 50 years behind their American The answer, which I did not feel comfort­ taught medical students, and served as an colleagues. able discussing with him is that, of course, I June 19, 1980 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 15833 could if I so chose. In Russia, vzyatka-brib­ In 1948, for example, medical officials ment has spent about 18,000 rubles on each ery-in the medical system is all-pervasive. began a campaign to canonize Ivan Pavlov's student, and the Ministry of Health has al­ But I found it distasteful to demand bribes physiology teachings as the foundation of ready decided on all the new doctors' assign­ for operating, and neither was I happy to all medical disciplines. Millions of empty ments, so the school fails nobody. The stu­ accept envelopes afterward, although sever­ words were spoken at hundreds of confer­ dents understand this and consider the al times they were forced on me by grateful ences and published in thousands of disser­ tests a formality. patients who wouldn't take Nyet for an tations and articles. Any scientific work that The first exam-which all must pass answer. There were occasions, however, didn't quote Pavlov was unacceptable, and before they can take the medical science ex­ when regular patients offered tokens of ap­ any scientist who neglected to join the choir aminations-is on Marxist philosophy. Pro­ preciation-like the expensive foreign of praise found himself jobless. Pavlov, rec­ fessors struggle to stifle their yawns as stu­ record player I received from Bolshoi prima ognizing many mistakes in his theories, had dents babble incoherent answers to three or ballerina Maya Plysetskaya-and occasional intended to rewrite them before he died, but four randomly · chosen questions. Then the special privileges. this did not stop Soviet medical teachers professors give totally arbitrary grades that The most memorable came when the from mindlessly parroting his physiological depend more on what they had for break­ father of an important military engineer I teachings. fast than on what the students said. If ev­ had operated on told me to be sure to con­ Until the early 1960s, Soviet professors eryone is feeling especially jolly, the stu­ tact him when I had time for a holiday in taught that Mendelian genetic theory was a dents get good grades without even answer­ an official resort rest home in the Caucusus. bourgeois fraud and that Lysenko's stupid ing any questions. I saw one student get two Three years later, I remembered his offer, magic tricks were true because they were 2's

Vote Vote Vote Bill No. and description Date Bill No. and description Date Bill No. and description Date Yea Nay Yea Nay Yea Nay

H.R. 8773. Interior ...... July 23 ...... 417 Vote by party: H.R. 7555. labor/ HEW (Hyde amend- June 17 ...... *201 *155 ---- Democrat...... 200 51 ment) . Vote by party: Republican ...... 131 2 Democrat...... 281 Vote by party: Democrat...... 103 134 Republican 136 H.R. 14239, State/Justice ...... June 18 ...... 208 ---- Republican ...... 98 21 H.R. 9861. Defense ...... Oct. 2...... 353 61 Vote by party: Democrat...... 146 H.R. 7558, Agriculture ...... June 21 ...... _ 3_80__ 28 Vote by party: Republican ...... ==62== Democrat...... 211 59 Vote by party: Republican...... 142 2 Democrat...... 264 4 H.R. 14233, HUD ...... June 22 ...... 369 18 Republican ...... = 1=16==24 H.R. 10029. military construction ...... Oct. 8...... 353 51 Vote by party: Democrat...... 246 3 H.R. 7589, military construction ...... June 21 ...... _ 3_91__ Vote by party: Republican ...... 123 15 Democrat...... 231 46 Vote by party: Republican ...... 122 5 Democrat...... 255 14 H.R. 15194, Public Works/Employment... .. Aug. 25 ...... 311 72 Republican ...... = 1=36==2 H.R. 10647, supplementary ...... Nov. 13 ...... 334 47 Vote by party: Democrat...... 243 13 H.R. 7797 , foreign assistance ...... June 23 ...... _ 2_08__ 1_74 Vote by party: Democrat...... 236 19 Republican ...... 68 59 Vote by party: Republican ...... 98 28 Democrat...... 157 95 H.J . Res. 1096. supplementary Guam ...... Sept. 21...... 372 ---- Republican ...... ==51==79 Average of 19 rollcall votes...... 357 48 Vote by party: H.R. 7932, legislative branch ...... June 29 ...... _ 2_50__ 1_56 Vote by party: Democrat...... 248 Democrat...... 246 24 Republican ...... =1=24== Vote by party: Republican ...... II 0 25 Democrat...... 202 63 Average of 16 rollcall votes ...... 324 47 Republican ...... ==48==93 VOTE BREAKDOWN ON HOUSE APPROPRIATIONS BILLS- Vote by party: Democrat...... 225 22 H.R. 7933 , Defense ...... June 30 ...... _3_33__ 54 1976 Republican ...... 99 25 Vote by party: Democrat...... 208 51 Vote Republican ...... = 1=25==3 Bill No. and description Date VOTE BREAKDOWN ON HOUSE APPROPRIATIONS BILLS- Yea Nay H.R. 9005, District of Columbia ...... Sept. 16 298 64 1977 ---- H.J. Res. 801. supplementary railroad ...... Feb. 18 ...... _ 2_98__ 9_5 Vote by party: Democrat...... 219 20 Vote by party: Vote Republican ...... 79 44 i>emocrat...... 215 47 Bill No. and description Date === Yea Nay Republican ...... ==83==48 H.R. 9375, supplementary ...... Oct. 25 313 98

H.J. Res. 811 , supplementary legislative .... Feb. 24 ...... _3_36__ 52 H.J. Res. 227 , supplementary power...... Feb. 7...... _3_41__ Vote by party: Democrat...... 223 48 Vote by party: Republican ...... 90 50 Democrat...... 240 21 Vote by party: Democrat...... 229 === Republican ...... ==96==31 Republican ...... 112 Average of 18 rollcall votes...... 328 68 H.R. 12203, foreign assistance ...... Mar. 4...... _2_14__ 1_52 === H.J. Res. 269, supplementary disaster ...... Mar. 3...... 411 Vote by party: ---- Democrat...... 232 30 Vote by party: Republican ...... 95 38 Democrat ...... 161 89 Vote by party: Republican...... ==53==63 Democrat...... 278 Republican ...... =1=33== *Hyde amendment. yea / nay votes are counted in reverse. H.J. Res. 857 , further continuing ...... Mar. 16 ...... _3_09__ 75 H.R. 4876, economic stimulus ...... Mar. 15 ...... 281 126 ---- VOTE BREAKDOWN ON HOUSE APPROPRIATIONS BILLS- Vote by party: Democrat...... 227 30 Vote by party: 1978 Republican ...... __82__ 45 Democrat...... 237 31 Republican ...... 44 95 H.J. Res. 890, supplementary health ...... Apr. 5...... _3_54__ 12 === Vote H.R. 4877 . supplementary ...... Mar. 16 ...... 306 98 Bill No. and description Date Vote by party: ---- Yea Nay Democrat...... 234 Vote by party: Democrat...... 246 20 Republican ...... =1=20== H.J. Res. 746 , supplementary power...... Mar. 7...... 353 50 Republican ...... ==60==78 H.R. 13172. second supplementary ...... Apr. 13...... _3_52_ _ 35 Vote by party: H.R. 7552, Treasury, Postal ...... June 8...... 359 45 ---- Democrat...... 257 8 Vote by party: Republican...... 96 42 Democrat...... 248 9 Vote by party: Republican ...... =1=04==26 Democrat...... 244 24 Republican ...... 115 21 H.J. Res. 796. supplementary disaster Mar. 23 393 relief. H.R. 13965, District of Columbia ...... May 26 ...... _3_50__ 13 === H.R. 7557 , Transportation ...... June 8...... 391 11 Vote by party: Vote by party: ---- Democrat...... 260 Democrat...... 239 Vote by party: Republican ...... =1=33== Republican ...... =1=11== Democrat...... 263 Republican ...... =1=28== H.J. Res. 859, supplementary USRA ...... Apr. 27...... 202 196 H.R. 14261. Treasury/ PostaL ...... June 14 ...... _2_58__ 99 H.R. 7636. Interior...... June 9...... 395 Vote by party: Vote by party: ---- Democrat ...... 158 98 Democrat...... 203 34 Vote by party: Republican ...... 44 98 Republican ...... ==55==65 Democrat...... 266 Republican ...... 129 346 23 H.R, 14236, Public Works ...... June 15 ...... _3_78__ 20 === H.J. Res. 873. supplementary SBA ...... May 8.. H.R. 7556, State/ Justice ...... June 13 ...... 353 42 Vote by party: Vote by party: ---- 229 15 Democrat...... 257 8 Democrat...... Vote by party: Republican ...... 117 8 Republican ...... =1=21==12 Democrat...... 253 8 Republican ...... 100 34 297 H.R. 14235, military construction ...... June 16 ...... _ 3_61__ 22 H.R. 12930, Treasury, Postal ... June 7 98 H.R. 7553, Public works ...... June 14 ...... 356 54 Vote by party: Vote by party: ---- 54 Democrat...... 227 21 Democrat ...... 202 Vote by party: Republican 95 44 Republican ...... =1=34==1 Democrat...... 239 32 Republican ...... =1=17==22 H.J. Res. 945, black lung program ...... June 9 ...... 237 72 H.R. 14237. Agriculture ...... June 16 ...... _3_77__ 26 ----· H.R. 7554, HUD ...... June 15. 374 32 Vote by party: Vote by party: ---- Democrat ...... 260 Democrat ...... 185 13 Republican ...... 117 Vote by party: Republican .. 52 59 Democrat ...... 260 8 114 24 .. ... June 17 ...... 331 Republican ...... H.R. 12933. Transportation...... June 12 ...... 347 25 H.R. 14262. Defense ...... ---- === 15836 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS June 19, 1980 VOTE BREAKDOWN ON HOUSE APPROPRIATIONS BILLS- VOTE BREAKDOWN ON HOUSE APPROPRIATIONS BILLS- VOTE BREAKDOWN ON HOUSE APPROPRIATIONS BILLS- 1978-Continued 1979 1979-Continued

Vote Vote Vote Bill No. and description Date Bill No. and description Date Bill No. and description Date Yea Nay Yea Nay Yea Nay

Vote by party: H.R. 4289, supplemental 1-979 ...... June 6...... 127 270 H.J. Res. 430, supplementary ...... Oct. 25 ...... 290 105 Democrat...... 225 16 ---- Vote by party: Republican ...... =1=22==9 Vote by party: Democrat ...... 103 148 Democrat ...... 200 46 Republican ...... 24 122 H.R. 12929, labor/ HEW ...... June 13 ...... _3_38__ 61 Republican ...... 90 59 Vote by party: H.R. 4390, legislative branch 1980 ...... June 13 ...... 186 232 H.J. Res. 440, continuing 1980...... Nov. 13 ...... _ 3_79__ Democrat...... 231 28 Vote by party: Vote party: Republican ...... ==1=07==33 Democrat...... 159 108 by Republican ...... 27 124 Democrat ...... 246 H.R. 12934, State. Justice ...... June 14. _3_59__ 34 Republican...... = 1=33== H.R. 4388, Energy/Water resources June 18 ...... 359 29 Vote by party: 1980. Average of 19 rollcall votes ...... 288 111 Democrat...... 242 15 Republican ...... 117 19 Vote by party: Vote by party: Democrat...... 225 22 Democrat...... 20 I 52 Republican ...... 134 7 H.R. 12935, legislative branch ...... June 14 ...... 279 90 Republican ...... 87 59 H.R. 4391 , military construction ...... June 18 ...... 366 21 Vote by party: *Final of 5 votes.e Democrat ...... 207 36 Vote by party: Republican ...... 72 54 Democrat...... 227 18 Republican ...... 139 3 H.R. 12927. military construction ...... June 16 ...... 278 13 RESETTLING CUBAN REFUGEES H.R. 4387, agriculture ...... June 19 ...... 391 30 Vote by party: Democrat ...... 183 10 Vote by party: Republican ...... 95 3 Democrat ...... 258 9 HON. ED BETHUNE Republican ...... 133 21 H.R. 12928. Public Works...... June 16 ...... 263 59 OF ARKANSAS H.R. 4394 , HUD ...... June 27 ...... 359 53 IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Vote by party: Vote by party: Democrat ...... 173 37 Democrat ...... 250 13 Thursday, June 19, 1980 Republican ...... 90 22 Republican ...... 109 40

H.R. 12936, HUD ...... June 19 ...... 332 47 H.R. 4389, labor/HEW ...... June 28 ...... 327 84 e Mr. BETHUNE. Mr. Speaker, yes­ terday our distinguished colleague Vote by party: Vote by party: Democrat ...... 231 13 Democrat...... 239 18 from Florida