~A Eth 30p a ni RoaidJs Au thority
RP1 36 Public Disclosure Authorized Volume 4 FINAL REPORT
RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN PACKAGE 'A" ROAD PROJECTS
Public Disclosure Authorized DERA - MECHARA Public Disclosure Authorized
MARCH 2003
Public Disclosure Authorized Pan African Consultants Plc.
In association with
AFRO-CONSULT EthiopianRoads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dern -Mechara Road upgradingproyect
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...... , 6
1.1. INTRODUCTION...... 6 1.2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION ...... 6 1.3. D..SCR.PTION OF THFTHE PROJECT AP-DESCRIPTIONAREA ...... 6 1.4. LEGALFRAMEWORK...... 7 1.5. POTENTI IAL SOCIAL IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURES ...... 7 t.6. IMPLEMENTATION OF RAP AND MONITORING PLAN ...... 9 2 INTRODUCTION .10 2.1 BACKGROUND ...... 10 2.2 OBJECTIVES OF THE RAP .10 2.3 MTHODOLOGY...... 10 2.4 REPORT STRUCTURE ...... 11 2.5 THE TEAM COMPOSITION FOR THE PREPARATION OF RAP.12 3. DESCRIPTIONS OF THE PROJECT ROAD .14
3.1 BACKGROUND .14 3.2 DERA- CFIOLE ...... 15 3.3 CHOLE - GOLOLCHA ...... 15.15 3.4 GOLOLCHA - MECHARA ...... 15 4 POLICY AND LEGAL FRAME WORK ...... 16 4.1 POLICY FRAMEWORK ...... 16 4 1.1 The Constitution of FDRE ...... 16 4 1.2 The Environmental Policy of Ethiopia...... 181..8-.. 4 2 REVIEW OF LAWS AND REGULATIONS AT THE FEDERAL AND REGIONAL LEVELS ...... 20 4 2 1 The Rural Lands Administration and Utilization Proclamation ...... 20 4 2.2 Oromiya Rural Land Use and Admniestration Proclamation (Draft) .. 20 4.3 LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR THE EXPROPRIATION AND COMPENSATION OF PROPERTY ... 22 4.3.1 Expropriation. 22 4 3 2 Right of Way ...... 24 4 3 3 Property to be compensated ...... 24 4 3 4 Comnpensation and Valuation Procedures and Methods .. 25 4 3.5 Dispute Settlement Procedures and Remedies ...... 27 4.4 INSTITUTIONAL AND ADM INISTRATIVE FRAMEWORK ...... 28 4.4.1 Federal Democratic Repuiblic of Ethiopia and Administration Regions ... 28 4 4.2 The Environmental ProtectionAuthority ... 28 4.4.3 EthiopianRoads Authority .. 29 4 4.4 Regional Governments ..... 3...... 0.30 5 POTENTIAL SOCIO ECONOMIC IMPACTS OF THE PROJECT...... 32
51 DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT SoCIo ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT ...... 32 5.1.1 Total Number Persons Affected by the Project ...... 32 5.1.2 Family Size of the PAPS . . . . 34 5 1 3 Gender and Age Structure of the PAPS.. 34 5 1 4 Livelihood of the PAPS ...... 34 5 1 6 Ethnicity, Religion and Language of the PAPS 37 5.1.7 Educational level of the PAPS ...... 37 5 1.8 Historical, Cultural, and Religious Resources 38 5 1.9 Social Organizationsto be Affected . 38 5 2 SoCIo ECONOMIC IMPACT OF THE PROJECT . . . . . 38 5.2.1 Social Acceptability of the ProjectRoad ...... 38
Resettlement Action Plan 1 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
5 2.2 Impact of the Project in Urban Areas ...... 39 5.3 IMPACT CATEGORY OF PAPS ...... 4...... 40 5 3 1 PartiallyAffected Households ...... 41 5.3 2 Fully Affected Households ...... 42 5.4 IMPACT OF THE PROJECT ON RURAL AREAS ...... 42 5.4.1 Impact of the Project on Perennialcrops . 44 5 4.2 Impact due to Establishment of Construction Camps and Borrow/QuarrySites 45
6 ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR DEFINING AFFECTED PERSONS . . 46
7 METHODS OF VALUING AFFECTED ASSETS ...... 48
7.1 METHODS OF VALUING REPLACEMENT OF THE HOUSES ...... 48 COMPENSATION STRATEGY ...... 51 7 2 COMPENSATION RATES FOR LOSS OF CROPS ...... 53 7.3. COMPENSATION FOR PERENNIAL CROPS ...... 56 7 3 1 Present Value of Delayed Annuity from Eucalyptus Tree 57 7 3 2 Present Value of Delayed Annuity from Banana Tree 58 7 3 3 Present Value of Delayed Annuity from an Orange Tree 58 7 3 4 Present Value of Delayed Annuity from Mango Tree 59 7 3 5 Present Value of Delayed Annuity from Coffee. 59 7 3 6 Present Value of Delayed Annutty from Chat Tree . 60 7 3 7 Present Value ofDelayed Annuttyfrom Papaya Tree.. 61 7 3.8 Present Value ofDelayedAnnuityfrom Sugar Cane. 61 7.4 COMPENSATION FOR ELECTRIC AND TELEPHONE POLES ...... 62 7.5 COMPENSATION FOR WATER PIPES IN MICHETA AND MECHARA TOWNS ...... 63 7.6 RELOCATION/RE HOUSING OPTIONS . . . 64
8. ORGANIZATIONAL PROCEDURES FOR DELIVERY OF ENTITLEMENTS .. 65
9. IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS FOR THE RAP ...... 65
9.1 BUDGET REQUIREMENT FOR THE IMPLEMENTING COMMITTEE...... 70
10. GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISMS ...... 73 11. RAP IMPLMENTATION COST ...... 75
12. CONSULTATION WITH PAPS ...... 76
13. MONITORING PLAN ...... 77
ANNEX I LIST OF REFERENCES ...... 78 ANNEX 2 PERSONS CONTACED AND INSTITUTIONS VISITED ... 80
Resettlement Action Plan 2 February. 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
LIST OF ABBREVIATION
CSA Central Statistics Authority CSE Conservation Strategy of Ethiopia EC Ethiopian Calendar EIA Environmental Impact Assessment EPA Environmental Protection Authority EPC Environmental Protection Council EEPCO Ethiopian Electric and Power Corporation EPE Environmental Policy of Ethiopia ERA Ethiopian Roads Authority FDRE Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia FHH Female Headed Households FV Future Value GCRC Gross Current Replacement Cost GPS Geographic Positioning System HH Household Head MoA Ministry of Agriculture NA Not Available NGO Non-Governmental Organizations NPV Net Present Value OGA Other Governmental Agencies PAA Project Affected Area PAPS Project Affected Persons PV Present Value PVF Present Value Factor RAP Resettlement Action Plan RRA Rural Road Authority ROW Right-of-Way TOR Terms of Reference WB World Bank WSS Water Supply Service
Resettlement Action Plan 3 February, 2003 and AFRO Consult Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF Dera -Mechara Road upgrading project
Figure 1 Locations Map of the Project Area
S A H E,L fjlScala I 'A I San'a Y E E N ~~tSi 0 ~ d-y?h~ ~ ~ ~ 4ammarn lbb_, MukallM Ad Duwayd M & 49edari4 d Jzz El ObeidKuJst / ' N i
t- 4 onderO ' ;,r'-QAden G u If o f A d e n
NUTB, JIAhi AaN DEPRESSI¶Ahir S U - 0 7 <>ee \;5>aq
N .s_A h Debr'e Marko6 Mal6l t EHifOPIAN PMATEAU Harbeise Surso Qardho \, DOOXO 4) . y Addis Abab -Harer Denmbi DabHloo ' NUGAALEED0 G;aroowe Gore LCam Mechara A D E-3r
04, I
_croject Roads Mehaf ,alcamo AIJIDO '.I elaf RANCE NHobyo 0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~wy
\ X-obyo =>s~ ' Krnyeb, . ) reriga Garbahaqfey'OM A L IA OCE t 6 AAByNhbo MoJaA ds ' ' G Ah N 0 A %IMarsabm- . 0 .arderi
February, 2003 Resettlement Action Plan 4 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAFandAFROConsult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
Figure 2 Layout of the Project Area
TIM
DERA DENETINOEL
NEBRESELAM (CHANCHO)
GOLOLCHA UVER
MAGNA_
Resettlement Action Plan 5Fbur.20 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1.1. Introduction
The project is intended to upgrade the road along the Dera - Mechara line, and it is sub divided into three different road sections, namely;
Section 1: Dera- Chole (length 100 km) Section 2: Chole - Gololcha (approximate length 60 km, under construction at time of preparation of this report) Section 3: Gololcha - Mechara (length 80 km)
Each section of the above roads will be implemented by a separate contractor, and the contractor award will be made by ERA.
1.2. Project Description and Justification
The road network, which is crucial to the connection between rural communities and urban centers has deteriorated markedly as a result of lack of investment, and is constraining development of the economy. The project road traverses entirely within the Oromiya National Regional State. The population and economy of the region traversed by the project road is almost totally dependent upon agriculture and livestock. The sector employs more than 90% of the economically active population in the project area.
The construction of the road is expected to make a significant contribution to improving some of the constraints on agricultural and livestock resources development in the project area.
The project comprises upgrading and new construction works to approximately 240km of existing road between Dera - Mechara.
1.3. Description of the Project Area
The Dera - Mechara Road is located in the Eastern Oromiya Region of The Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia and crosses two zones (Arsi and West Hararghe) and six woredas. The Project Road starts at the township of Dera which is situated astride the Nazreth-Asela highway, route 8, approximately 124km south-southeast of Addis Ababa. From Dera, the Road generally follows north easterly direction towards the town of Mechara where it links up with the towns of Asbe Teferi, Dire Dawa and Harar. The project road is partly an existing one and partly new that links about sixteen of the predominantly agricultural trade centers, woreda towns and villages along the route and has been chosen, by ERA, partly for upgrading and partly new construction under this project. When completed, the road will constitute and integral link of the 360 km long Dera - Mechara - Asbe Teferi road. The
Resettlenment Action Plan 6 February,2003 EthiopianRoads Authority PAN4AF and AFRO Consiult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
upgraded road will therefore provide long needed access from this vast agricultural area to the national network. In the western area, a link will be provided with Nazareth and Addis Ababa and, in the easterly area, with Awash, Dire Dawa and the port of Djibouti.
Apart from agriculture and livestock and general commerce in the major towns along the route, there appear to be few other economic activities in the project area at the present time. Industrial development in the project area is embryonic. The contribution of manufacturing industries to the generation of income and employment in the project area is non existent when compared to agriculture.
Any detail data and information of the specific place of the project areas could be referred in the different pages of the attached Annex. The Annex is believed to provide vital and basic information of the Project Affected People (PAPS).
1.4. Legal Framework
The Constitution of Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia (Art. 44.2) provides that state programs that result in the displacement of people or adversely affect the livelihood of the local population shall give the right to commensurate monetary or other means of compensation including relocation (resettlement) with adequate State assistance.
The World Bank OP 4.12 under the title of "Involuntary Resettlement Policy" has addressed the need for the treatment of the project impacts, which cannot be avoided. Many other manuals, policies, laws & regulations of the country also addressed the involuntary resettlement issue. The Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) proclamation states that no proponent shall comrnmence implementation of a project without conducting proper environmental and social impact assessment and authorization from the Authority or from the Relevant Regional Agency, as appropriate.
The Terms of Reference (TOR) for this project requires preparing Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) for Dera- Mechara road upgrading project. Therefore, as per the requirements of the TOR and the EPA and World Bank guidelines, the consultant has carried out this RAP for the proposed road upgrading project.
1.5. Potential Social Impacts and Mitigation Measures
The total number of Project Affected People (PAPS) both in urban and rural areas will be 3644 people found in 389 households; from Dera - Chole section 120 households and one institution that has 1335 people, from Chole - Golocha section 105 households with 989 people, and from Gololcha -
Reseltletenet Action Plan 7 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Constult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
Mechara section 164 households and one institution with 1320 people. Out of the above indicated of 389 households, 285 households and three public and government institutions will be partially affected, and the remaining lOlhouseholds will be fully affected.
The negative impacts of the project on rural settings (on settlement areas, farm land, and perennial crops) will occur is observed through the taking and occupation of farm and forest land for the use of campsites, detour, quarry site, and spoil dumping areas, and access road construction for quarry transportation. The above negative impacts will also be observed on the environment and also in disrupting the livelihood of the population. In such type of situation, some households will lose small part of their farm land, permanent crops and housing areas.
The loss on farn land and permanent crops and other assets will contribute to reduced income level of the households. In order to minimize the negative impacts of the project and also to restitute those households to be resettled a well designed valuation compensation approach is developed for households that would be affected by the project both in rural and urban centers. The methods adopted for valuing the affected assets and resources is based on a replacement cost and also by considering the compensation value estimate.
In addition to farm lands, grazing area, and houses (used either for residential or business purposes) the project will also have impact on telephone and electric lines as well as on pipes lines for the distribution of water services in the town section of the road.
Main Findings - Basic Data 1. Location 1 a. Region Oromnya b. Zone Arsi and West Hararghe 2. Road Length (km) 240 3. Status Existing Road upgrading project and construction of new road section 4. Road Functional Classification Trunk road 5. Proposed Surfacing type Gravel 6. Households and Public Institutions to be 389 Affected 7. Number of Project Affected Persons 3644 (PAPS) 8. 8. Households that will be Partially 285 Affected 9 Households that will be Fully Affected 101 10. Public & Government Buildings to be 3 (a primary school, Police station and a Affected ware house) 11 Total Number of Houses or Buildings to be 407 Affected 12. Number of perennial crops and Enset to be 25,057 affected
Resettlenient Action Plan 8 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - MecharaRoad upgradingproject
The total cost of the Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) including compensation for crop and permanent trees; houses used for residential and business purposes; compensation for inconveniences; for monitoring of the RAP and contingency estimated amounts to Birr 20,280,000.
The following table shows the amount of compensation required for the resettlement program in Dera-Mechara road project.
Item Description Compensation Estimate (in million Birr) Compensation for strip of farm lands in rural areas* 1.30 Compensation for loss of trees (Eucalyptus trees, fruits, coffee, 2 80 chat, sugarcane) Compensation for water pipes 0.12 Compensation for loss of houses 10.02 Disturbance allowance 1.56 Compensation for crops and land loss* * 0 73 Compensation for loss of electric and telephone poles 1.00 Monitormg 0 11 Sub Total 17.27 Contingency (15%) 3.52 Grand Total 20.79
Note *Individual farmers will be identified dunng implementation of this RAP ** Land loss for contractors' camp, matenals site, detour and spoil dumping sites
1.6. Implementation of RAP and Monitoring Plan
Integration of monitoring plan will be established within the overall RAP implementation levels to oversee re-establishing process of the Project Affected Persons (PAPS). It will be a compliance monitoring and this will assist to control the form of measures incorporated in RAP documents, and the extent to which recommendations on these matters, as set out in the RAP, are complied with. The monitoring will play a major part in determining the overall RAP of this project and in the future preparation of RAP.
ERA's Environmental Monitoring and Safety Branch is responsible for the monitoring and ERA's ROW branch is responsible for the implementation of RAP and to effect payment for the PAPS.
Resettlement Action Plan 9 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - MecharaRoad upgradingproject
2 INTRODUCTION
2.1 Background
The Ethiopian Roads Authority (ERA) has assigned Pan African Consultants Plc. in association with Afro Consult and Trading Plc. of Ethiopia, to prepare a Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) for the proposed Nazereth-Assela-Dodola and Shashemene - Goba road; Dera - Mechara road; and Nekmte - Mekanejo road upgrading project.
This report presents the RAP for Dera -Mechara road upgrading project.
2.2 Objectives of the RAP
The central objective of the consulting services is to prepare Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) for Dera - Mechara road. The RAP assesses the adverse social impacts of the project roads construction and operations and suggest mitigation measures including budget, to adress the issues at stake.
2.3 Methodology
Road projects will create a range of direct and indirect impacts on the human environment. Understanding the socio-economic settings and issues and constraints along the project road is essential for the design of road projects. The TOR requires undertaking RAP. The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) guideline prepared by Environmental Protection Authority (EPA, 1999) and the World Bank require development projects to reduce adverse effects on the physical, biological, and socio-economic environments. The consultant has therefore (in response to both the requirements of the TOR and the EIA guideline), carried out this RAP for the projects under consideration in accordance with the Country and World Bank guidelines.
The methodology adopted for the preparation of this RAP is summarized below.
Collection of Available Data: The consultant collected and reviewed project specific background documents and published regulations, guidelines, national policy, CSA's census reports and documents (see References). The national legislative and institutional framework, policies, procedures, guidelines etc. has also been reviewed.
Field Visits: Detailed field visits were carried out in all the project areas in order to gain first-hand information and knowledge of existing environmental conditions and also to put the proposed designs and construction works into context. The project team has carried out the visit in order to facilitate joint
Resettlement Actton Plati 1 0 February, 2003 Ethuoptan Roads Autlhority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgrading project
review of potential problems and possible solutions. During the trip, information on, socio-economic aspects, cultural and other values in the project area had been collected through designed questionnaire survey, consultation with PAPS, meetings and discussions with Zonal, Woreda, Municipal and Kebele (rural and urban) administrations and data collected also through Geographic Positioning System (GPS), etc.
Public Consultation: The field visits also included interviews and discussion with local authorities and ERA and consultation with Project Affected Persons (PAPS) along all sections of the roads, in order to obtain supplementary information on socio-economic and socio-cultural conditions, and views on various aspects of the project. The consultation was also to obtain background informnation relevant to socio-economic impact assessment and in particular, to identify any areas of specific concern which needed to be addressed. Organizations and individuals consulted are listed in Annex Two. In the consultation process, individual affected households were interviewed and consulted to fill detail and specific information using structured questionnaire formats.
Characteristics of the project: A review of the project designs has been carried out, with particular reference to establishing the form and scope of the works and construction materials in order to identify potential sources of impact of the project on the socio-economic environment.
Description of the Project Area: A baseline data on the socio-economic environment of the project area has been collected and evaluated. Direct information was obtained by visiting the project area. The project area comprises the area which will be under direct influence (i.e., where the impacts of the land-take requirement and construction activity can be felt) of the project and includes the road section and its influence area, quarry and borrow areas, etc. The project road passes through five woredas in Arsi zone, and one woreda in West Hararghe zone; in Oromiya region.
Identification of socio-economic Impacts: Key potentially adverse impacts on the socio-economic environment associated with implementation of the proposed project have been identified.
Monitoring Plan: A monitoring plan has been developed and will be fully integrated with implementation process as part of this RAP.
2.4 Report Structure
This report provides an assessment of the social impacts of the proposed road upgrading project and follows the following flows:
Resettlement Action Plan 1I1 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
* Following the List of abbreviations, Executive Summary and the Introduction, Chapter 2 provides a brief description of the project and components for which land acquisition and resettlement is required. * Chapter 3 presents the existing and evolving policy, legal and institutional framework. The chapter also presents the assessment results of the legal framework reviewing the fit between the borrower laws and regulations and Bank policy requirements and measures proposed to bridge any gaps between them; * In Chapter 4 existing socio-economic conditions of the Project Affected People (PAPS) and Project Affected Area (PAA) is discussed in brief. In this chapter, affected population is estimated and to the extent possible, the likely categories of affected households and institutions are presented. * Socio Economic impacts of the PAPS on Chapter 5 * The methods of valuing affected assets is discussed in Chapter 6 * Organizational procedures for delivery of entitlement is discussed in Chapters 7 * Eligibility criteria in chapter 8 * Description of the implementation process, linking resettlement implementation to civil works is presented in chapter 9. * Chapter 10 describes the grievance redress mechanism and Chapter 11 presents the arrangements of funding resettlement, including the preparation and review of cost estimates, the flow of funds and contingency arrangements; * The mechanism for consultation with, and participation of affected and displaced persons in planning, implementation and monitoring is presented in Chapter 12 and * Chapter 13 presents the arrangement for monitoring by the implementing agency.
2.5 The Team Composition for the Preparation of RAP
Sociologist/Team Leader: ASSEFA ADDISU, Bachelor Degree in Sociology and Anthropology in 1980 attended several updating courses in rural development, management, and organisation strengthening, rural reconstruction. He has 20 years of experience working for government organisations, NGO's and private firms. He has extensive experience on social projects monitoring and evaluation, the development of policy and strategy for rural development schemes.
Economist: YUSUF AHMED, B.A. in Economics with minor in management, MSc. Transportation Science and a wide range of training in planning, statistics, finance, projects, and information. He has over 25 years of extensive work
Resetilenient Action Plan 12 Februnay, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
experience and services at various responsible positions. He has also extensive experience in conducting feasibility studies, regional analysis, land use and traffic studies, etc.
Civil Engineer: TESFAYE ASFAW, A civil Engineer and long years of experience in the planning, design, construction and maintenance of all types of transport infrastructures while working for ERA, TCDE and PANAF Consult. He has also been involved in the management of planning, study and implementation of a highly integrated development programmes during his service to the Ministry of Coffee and Tea Development holding Chief Engineer and General Manager.
Environmentalist: DEJENE WOLDEMARLAM, Master of Technology in Civil Engineering in addition to several short term workshops on EIA. He has 14 years experience as environmentalist and conducted a number of EIA for Road projects in Ethiopia.
Legal Expert: INMIRU TAMIRAT, has more than 15 years experience providing advice and expertise on policy, legal and institutional matters with respect to both national and international resources development and management issues. He has been providing advice and expertise on policy, legal and institutional matters with respect to national and international natural resources and environmental management issues, international trade law matters linked with agriculture and intellectual property rights.
Resettlement Action Plan 13 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Autihority PANAF and AFRO Consuilt Dera - Mechara Road uipgradling p-oject
3. DESCRIPTIONS OF THE PROJECT ROAD
3.1 Background
Recognizing the relative importance of the transport in supporting social and economic growth and meeting the poverty alleviation objectives, The Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia (FDRE) has placed increased emphasis on improving the quality and quantity of the road infrastructure as part of its economic development program and poverty alleviation strategy. To address the constraints in the road sector related to restricted road network coverage and low standards, federal Government of Ethiopia formulated a 10-year Road Sector development Program, was officially launched in September 1997, and since then, both Government and donor-funded projects have been under implementation.
The proposed road more or less traverses initially across an existing track over certain sections whilst the central section contains a portion of totally new alignment. It runs through the villages and towns of Dera, Sire, Koshim, Bolo, Denbe Tino, Negele, Moye, Chole, Lega Buna, Wendo Gasha, Deraratu, Magana Hadere, Debre Selam (or Chancho), Timuga, Micheta, Kortu, and finally ends at Mechara with total length of about 240km. Due to the rugged condition and its inaccessibility in wet seasons most Section of the existing tracks are only passable by 4x4 vehicles during the dry season only. The route traverses one of the fertile areas of the country. The central and eastern sections of the road are located in important coffee growing areas whilst the western end is located on the eastern Ethiopian highlands. The highlands are important agricultural production area.
The eastern terminus point, Mechara, is situated about 240km from Dera measured along the shortest existing motor able route, which consists of a combination of sections of feeder road, animal tracks, and over a substantial length, no defined route whatsoever.
The Project Road is divided into the following three Sections:
Section 1: Dera- Chole (length 100 km) Section 2: Chole - Gololcha (approximate length 60 km, under construction at time of preparation of this report) Section 3: Gololcha - Mechara (length 80 km)
Each section of the above roads will be implemented by a separate contractor, and the contractor award will be made by ERA.
Resettlement Action Plan 14 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consuilt Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
3.2 Dera- Chole
Dera - Chole section with the exception of minor realignment section near the approach to Sire town, the alignment in the first 28 km from Dera town, capital of Dodota sire woreda, and the last 25km to Chole, generally follows existing roads recently built to RR 50 standard. The land use in the areas surrounding the proposed road is predominantly agricultural, amounting to some 77% of the length of this section. The remaining adjacent land consists of built-up localities (12%) and unused land (11%). The 11 % unused land is mainly grazing and bushy forest area. Grazing land is a rather fluid concept, is not limited space and varies with agriculture seasons.
In this section of the road there are 119 households affected from Dera, Sire, Koshim, Chole, Moye and Negele, and the majority or 92% come from rural villages and 8% are live in urban centers. The road will follow an existing alignment of a gravel road passing through the woredas of Chole, Jeju, Merti and Dera. Impacts on bushy area, communal grazing land and agricultural land will therefore be limited to small strips of land along the road. There will not be shortage of grazing land or agricultural land in the Dera - Chole area or on any other section of the Dera - Mechara road.
Since bushy areas and grazing land is owned "collectively "by the kebele inhabitants, and apart from this, loss of strips of grazing land will not have significant impact on the local community.
3.3 Chole - Gololcha
Chole - Gololcha section is almost entirely located on a new alignment. It starts at the end of Section 1, some 5km east - south - east of Chole town, in Chole woreda, and continues to follow the existing RR 50 feeder road for some 2.2 km before leaving it just after passing over the existing single lane bridge over the Legebuna River. After leaving the existing road the project road plunges down a 1,200m escarpment to the village of Magna. Thereafter, it traverses extensive agricultural lands, passing through the village of Haro, and then to Gololcha where it rejoins the existing road near the existing Gololcha Kela River bridge.
In this section of the road there are 106 households affected from Derartu, Magana Hadere, Haro, Lega Buna, Wendo Gasha rural villages, and hence, all PAPS in this section of the road come from the rural villages.
3.4 Gololcha - Mechara
Gololcha - Mechara section starts at a point close to the town of Debre Selam (or Chancho) in Gololcha woreda, and 10 km west of Debre Selam (or
Resettlement Action Plan 15 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
Chancho) town, and basically follows the general route of the existing track eastwards to Mechara town, in Daro Lebu woreda. However, there are several minor realignments in this section, in order to effect geometnc improvement. The route in this Section traverses largely mountainous terrain and numerous steep-sided river and stream gorges. The majority of this Section has no existing drainage structures of any kind.
Gololcha - Mechara, only 26% of the adjacent land is under cultivation, with 69% unused, and 5% consisting of built-up areas. The 69% unused and open land consists of small parts of seasonal grazing land owned communally and also bush area that is not suitable for farming. The unused area is actually not suitable for settlements because of its poor land and very hot climate.
In this section of the road 164 households are affected from Debre selam, Kortu, Mechara, Micheta, and Timuga. 40% of the PAPS are from urban areas and 60% are from rural areas.
4 POLICY AND LEGAL FRAME WORK
4.1 Policy Framework
4.1.1 The Constitution of FDRE
As the supreme law of Ethiopia, all national policies, laws and regulations as well as the institutional frameworks of the country must comply with the Constitutional provisions. The Constitution of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia, Proclamation 1/1995, has several provisions which have direct policy, legal and institutional relevance for the appropriate implementation of the resettlement action plans which are being prepared by the Ethiopian Roads Authority in order to mitigate the impact on people who might be affected by the Road Sector Development Program under way.
The current land tenure system is, in essence, not different from that adopted by the previous regime although there are certain elements that may be considered to give the user of the land more security than in the past. The Constitution itself addresses this issue to some extent when it guarantees Ethiopian peasants and pastoralists the right to have access to land as well as the protection against eviction from their possession (Art. 40.4 and 40.5). The detailed implementation of this provision is to be specified by subsequent laws.
Art. 40.3 of the Constitution provides for the public ownership of both rural and urban land as well as all natural resources. It further states that land is the common property of the Ethiopian people and cannot be subject to sale or to other means of exchange. In other words, private ownership of land and other natural resources is excluded in that one very essential element of private
Resettlement Action Plan 16 Febnrary, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF andAFRO Consult Dera - Mecliara Road upgradingproject
ownership- that of alienating land by sale, mortgage or any form of transfer with respect to land- is expressly prohibited by the Constitution.
Moreover, ownership of land is vested in the State (and the people of Ethiopia) while rural and urban dwellers have only usufruct rights over land. A usufruct right gives the user of the land, the right to use the land and the right to benefit from the fruits of her/his labor which may be crops, trees etc found on the land or any permanent works such as buildings etc. The rights regarding the latter may be considered private property and any interference on the usufructuary right such as expropriation shall entail compensation. This is clearly provided in Art. 40.7 of the Constitution which says that ' Every Ethiopian shall have the full right to the immovable property he builds and to the permanent improvements he brings about on the land by his labour or capital'. It further states, among other things, that the owner of such rights is entitled to compensation and that the particulars shall be determined by law. Art. 40.8 in turn strengthen this by providing for expropriation of private property by the government for public purposes subject to the payment in advance of compensation commensurate to the value of the [expropriated] property. The detailed implementation of this provision is also left to be determined by subsequent law.
More importantly, and specifically, Art. 44.2 of the Constitution provides that state programs that result in the displacement of people or adversely affect the livelihood of the local population shall give the right to commensurate monetary or other means of compensation including relocation (resettlement) with adequate State assistance.
This is an important provision to the resettlement action plan that ERA undertakes with respect to the road projects in the sense that the Government has obliged itself not only to compensate for the works on land created by the labour and capital of any Ethiopian citizen but also to compensate for the lost land through resettling those affected by State programs with adequate assistance. Although in strict legal terms, an individual landholder does not have full ownership rights over the land he/she uses because of the fact that the landholder cannot alienate the land through sale, mortgage or any other form of transfer of ownership, the Constitution endows the land holder rights akin to ownership in the sense that it gives the landholder the right to continued access to the land and the right to be compensated for lost land. The State has also obliged itself to relocate/resettle the landholder. In this sense, the landholder has the right to be relocated to land similar to that lost through expropriation or involuntary resettlement. One issue that may arise is what if the landholder is not willing to resettle in another area and claims monetary compensation or if land is not readily available? As we shall see later in some detail, it is submitted that the landholder will be compensated for the lost land in an alternative form which may include the cost of alternative means of livelihood, relocation cost etc. The land itself has no market value for the land
Resettlenient Action Plan 17 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO ConsIIlt Deir - Mechara Road upgrading project
user because he/she cannot alienate the land in the form of sale or mortgage. This is why it may be difficult to adequately assess the amount of compensation.
The right of the public and the community to full consultations and participation as well as to the expression of their views in the planning and implementation of environmental policies and development projects that affect them is enshrined in the Constitution (Arts. 92.3 and 43.2). The rights of women to full consultations in the formulation of national development policies and in designing and execution of projects especially when such projects are likely to affect their interests is also stipulated in the Constitution (Art. 35.6). Thus, in the course of the preparation of resettlement action plans, all affected stakeholders need to be appropriately consulted in order to identify their needs and interests including determination of the amount of compensation required.
In relation to the environment, the Constitution also stipulates that the Government will endeavor to ensure a clean and healthy environment as a basic right of the Ethiopian people (Arts. 44.1 and 92.1). It also provides that the design and implementation of development programs and projects will not damage or destroy the environment (Art. 92.2). This indicates a recognition that development programs and projects would pass through an Environmental Impact Assessment process.
In sum, as discussed in this section, the Constitution has laid down the policy and legal basis regarding land tenure policy, the need for appropriate compensation and consultations regarding those affected by development projects and State programs as well as the recognition of the need to conduct an environmental impact assessment of development projects. Subsequent policies, legislations and institutions are designed to meet these Constitutional provisions.
4.1.2 The Environmental Policy of Ethiopia
The Environmental Policy of Ethiopia which includes social assessment was approved by the Council of Ministers in 1997. The policy contains ten sectoral and ten cross-sectoral policies including provisions required for the appropriate implementation of the policy.
Although there are some relevant elements in the sectoral policies incorporated in the document, the cross-sectoral policies are of much more relevance to the resettlement action plans that ERA is undertaking particularly regarding community participation and environmental impact assessment.
Resettlement Action Plan 18 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
The policy elements on community participation are progressive and relevant in the context of preparing the resettlement action plans. The relevant ones are:
* To ensure that all phases of environmental and resource development and management, from project conception to planning and implementation to monitoring and evaluation are undertaken based on the decisions of resource users and managers; * To develop effective methods of popular participation in the planning and implementation of environmental and resource use and management projects and programmes;
Of more important in the context of the resettlement action plan are the policy provisions on Environmental Impact Assessment which provide the basic policy framework in the area and form the basis for subsequent issuance of laws, regulations and guidelines in the area. The policy elements are as follows:
* To ensure that environmental impact assessments consider not only physical and biological impacts but also address social, socio- economic, political and cultural conditions; * To ensure that public and private sector development programmes and projects recognize any environmental impacts early and incorporate their containment into the development design process; * To recognize that public consultation is an integral part of EIA and ensure that EIA procedures make provision for both an independent review and public comment before consideration of decision makers; * To ensure that and environmental impact statement always includes mitigation plans for environmental management problems and contingency plans in case of accidents; * To ensure that, at specified intervals during the project implementation, environmental audits regarding monitoring, inspection and record keeping take place for activities where these have been required by the Environmental Impact Statement; * To ensure that preliminary and full EIAs are undertaken by the relevant sectoral ministries or departments, if in the public sector, and by the developer, if in the private sector. * To create by law an EIA process which require appropriate environmental impact statements and environmental audits for private and state development projects; * To establish the necessary institutional framework and determine the linkages of its parts for undertaking, coordinating and approving EIAs and the subsequent system of environmental audits required to ensure compliance with conditionalities; * To develop detailed sectoral technical guidelines in EJAs and environmental audits;
Resettlenment Action Plan 19 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consiult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
* To ensure that social, socio-economic, political and cultural conditions are considered in environmental impact assessment procedures and included in sectoral guidelines; and * To develop EIA and environmental audit capacity and capability in the Environmental Protection Authority, sectoral ministries and agencies as well as in regions.
The above environmental policy provisions reveal that much has been covered, at least at the policy level, regarding the measures that need to be taken and procedures to be followed when conducting an environmental impact assessment of development projects from the planning level up to the implementation and post-implementation level. As the resettlement action plan that is prepared by ERA is part of the Environmental Impact Assessment process, particularly taken to mitigate the socio-economic and cultural impacts of the road projects, the policy provisions will be considered to serve as guidelines for more specific sectoral policies, laws and institutional set ups that are required to translate such policy provisions. The following sections will attempt to address such issues.
4.2 Review of Laws and Regulations at the Federal and Regional Levels
4.2.1 The Rural Lands Administration and Utilization Proclamation
The Constitution leaves the detailed implementation of the provisions concerning tenure rights over rural land to be determined by subsequent specific laws to be issued at both the federal and regional levels. Accordingly, at the federal level, the Rural Lands Administration and Utilisation Proclamation was enacted in 1997 to further determine the land use system and use rights in the country.
The Proclamation provides that land administration laws to be enacted by Regions would be based on the provisions provided therein and specifies the basic principles of rural land distribution and utilization including the scope of land use right which Regional laws will grant. Similar to the Constitution, the Proclamation provides that peasants and nomads (pastoralists) shall have the right to get rural land holding the size of which shall be determined based upon the particular conditions of the locality and free of charge.
4.2.2 Oromiya Rural Land Use and Administration Proclamation (Draft)
Based on the Federal Land Administration and Utilization Proclamation No.89/1997, regions have commenced enacting their own land administration and utilization laws. For our purposes, since all the three roads subject to the resettlement action plans are within the Oromiya Region, a brief examination of the relevant provisions of the Draft Oromiya Land Use and Administration Proclamation will be made here.
Resettlement Action Plan 20 February, 2003 Elhiopian Roads Authiority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
The Proclamation provides for the right of access to rural land free of charge for those whose lives depend on agriculture and who are aged 18 years or above (Art.5.1). The holder of the land is guaranteed a life long right of use of the land for agricultural purposes or lease the land to a third party or bequeath it to his/her heirs. Full property rights is also given to the right holder over any property produced or built on the land including the right to alienate it in any manner (Art. 6.1). However, the latter right of alienation does not extend to the land itself (Art. 6.2) which is consistent with the federal Constitution discussed before (Art. 6.2). However, the use right of the individual land user is subject to termination when the land is required for public uses and when this is decided with the participation of the community [affected] (Art. 6.4). When the right of the landholder is terminated for reasons of public use, the right of the landholder to get compensation for the assets on the land or tree crops cultivated on the land is provided in Art. 6.5 of the draft Proclamation including the right to be compensated for similar land. The responsible organ which is designated in the Proclamation itself, as " the Land Administration and Natural Resources Authority" (Art.24) will also issue a life long certificate of holding right to the land user (Art. 15).
In case conflict arises regarding the rights of the landholder, the draft Proclamation provides for an initial appeal to the local social court (Gaanda). A party aggrieved by the decision of the social court has the right to appeal to the first instance ordinary court (Aanaa court). Where the Aanaa court confirms the decision of the social court the decision of the first instance court will be final. However, if the decision of the first instance court rescinds the decision of the social court, then a final appeal may be made to the higher court. However, it also provides for the resolution of disputes by other means upon agreement by the parties concerned.
Although the Oromiya Rural Land Use and Administration Proclamation is still in a draft form, it contains very relevant provisions regarding the right of a rural landholder where his rights of use is affected through eviction or expropriation of land for public use as for instance for the purpose of road construction, rehabilitation or upgrading. It clearly provides for relocation of the landholder to a similar land and for compensation of lost assets and tree crops on the land and the manner for dispute resolution. It also requires that the communities affected by such development projects need to be consulted. One important provision is the issuance of certificate of use right to the landholder which makes it easier to identify the right holder of a given land where resettlement action plan is prepared by ERA in the future.
The above two sections have shown the general policy and legal framework at the macro-level regarding the land tenure and environmental policies and general provisions pertaining to resettlement/relocation of land users (usufructuaries) as well as the principles and general requirements for the
Resettlement Action Plan 21 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
right to be compensated for property lost on work made on land and the need for public consultations in case of eviction or expropriation of property. The next section will be a discussion of legal and administrative requirements more specifically dealing with the requirements of the resettlement action plans that ERA is undertaking.
4.3 Legal Framework for the Expropriation and Compensation of Property
The expansion of road construction has got a paramount importance for the efforts of the development activities of the country. Any development activity is directly linked to the presence of road infrastructure and recognizing this, the Government of Ethiopia is currently undertaking the upgrading of the existing roads as well as the construction of new roads. Like many other projects, the construction of roads could result in major negative ill effects upon the environment in general and the people in particular unless an appropriate measure to encounter the negative impacts is taken. People whose subsistence is dependent on the same occupy almost all of the urban and the rural areas through which the road passes. It is a fact that the people are expecting the commencement of the road construction to begin soon. They are also expecting to become compensated for any losses that may arise as a result of the construction of the project. The identification and the implementation of compensation are required to be effected prior to the construction of the road. The need for the preparation of the mitigation measure is presented in operational manual of the World Bank.
The World Bank OP 4.12 under the title of "Involuntary Resettlement policy" has addressed the need for the treatment of the project impacts, which cannot be avoided. Many other manuals, policies, laws & regulations of the country also addressed the involuntary resettlement issue. The main objective of this study is to identify the socio economic impacts of the project to the extent feasible and propose mitigation measures, which need to be implemented prior to the construction of the road.
4.3.1 Expropriation
The 1960 Civil Code of Ethiopia contains relevant provisions regarding expropriation of property for public purposes considered to be in the public domain (Arts.1444-1488). Art. 1445 provides that any property belonging to the State or other administrative bodies shall be deemed to form part of the public domain. It also stipulates that properties which form part of the public domain are those placed at the disposal of the public or destined to a public service.
More relevant for our purpose, Art. 1446 provides that roads, streets.. .etc. if * owned by the State or other administrative bodies form part of the public domain. It further stipulates that the competent authorities may, by way of
Resettlement Action Plan 22 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
expropriation proceedings, obtain the land necessary for the creation of roads and streets and may, by alignment proceedings widen or straighten existing roads or streets (Art. 1450). In case the alignment land shows un built land within public ways such land shall be incorporated to such public ways and where the alignment plan shows built land such land shall be charged with a servitude to draw back (Arts. 1451 and 1452). Servitude is a form of property right provided in the Civil Code (Arts. 1359-1385) which gives the right of way to someone over the property of another. In other words, in case of road construction (rehabilitation/upgrading etc), the government body which does the work is given the right of way over another's property or holder of the land. In this sense, it creates a restriction on the right of the holder of the land. In both instances, the expropriation for building roads gives the person the right to claim compensation in accordance with Arts 1470-1477 of the Civil Code (Art. 1453). The compensation provisions of the Civil Code will be discussed in a later part of this section.
The provisions on expropriation proceedings and procedures on compensation are provided under Arts. 1460-1488 of the Civil Code. Some of the relevant provisions regarding expropriation proceedings stipulate:
* That the competent authority has the right to compel the owner to surrender the ownership (in our case the use right of the landholder) of an immovable property for public purposes (Art. 1460); * The project which makes expropriation necessary shall be declared by notice to be in the public interest (Art. 1463). * Where public inquiry is necessary, the declaration of public utility will not be made until the public interest has been consulted (Art. 1465). * Once the project is declared to be in the public interest, determination of which immovables need to be expropriated for carrying out the project will be made and the persons having property rights over the immovables will be notified to this effect. The persons to be affected by the expropriation shall express their views on the necessity of the expropriation within a reasonable time (Art. 1466).
In a similar vein, the Ethiopian Roads Authority Re-establishment Proclamation No 80/1997 gives era the power to " use, free of charge, land and such other resources and quarry substances required for the purpose of construction and maintenance of highways,...and other required services; provided, however, that it shall pay compensation in accordance with the law of properties on the land it uses" (Art. 6.18). The right of expropriation given to ERA under its reestablishment Proclamation and in previous proclamations is in essence similar with the provisions of the Civil Code because the road works conducted by ERA is in the public domain.
Resettlenient Action Plan 23 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authlority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgrading project
4.3.2 Right of Way
ERA has been exercising what it calls a right of way of adjacent land to roads it constructs which is 30 mts in extent. This right of way that ERA exercises seems to have been established in practice through specifications and not by any form of legislation which gave ERA, by law, to exercise such right. In practice the ROW of concept in ERA is flexible. In this sense, therefore, it might be difficult to assert that it would not give compensation to persons who have encroached on land deemed to be a right of way unless this is enforceable by law. It seems that it is in recognition of this that Art. 6.17 of Proclamation No. 80/1997 re-establishing ERA gives the power to ERA to "determine the extent of land required for its activities, in the adjacency as well as surrounding of highways, and the conditions of use of such land by others". From the discussions we have had with ERA, it is now conducting a study as to how to determine the right of way and the conditions of its use by third parties. The practice to date is that ERA pays compensation to affected persons regarding land deemed to be a right of way. This is a correct position in light of the fact that the right of way ERA is de facto and not de jure (emanating from law) and therefore cannot be legally enforceable. However, it is proposed that in the future ERA's right of way will be determined by law which can then be enforceable on persons encroaching in such right of way. If the right of way forms part of the public domain, it may not be occupied by a private person except with the authorization of the competent authority as provided in Art. 1457 of the Civil Code. In such cases, the Civil Code empowers the competent authorities (in this case ERA) to order at any time the destruction of any work or the cessation of any activity which impairs the existence or purpose of the property forming part of the public domain (Art. 1459(1) ). In other words, once ERA establishes by law a right of way, this may be considered a public domain and it can enforce its rights by means of ordering a cessation of any activity that violates such rights or even order the destruction of any works done in such right of way. Moreover, if any administration grants a concession or authorization on such public domain this may be revoked (Art. 1459 (2) and in such cases the person affected by such revocation can claim compensation from the administrative authority which gave the concession or authorization (Art. 1459) (3).
4.3.3 Propertyto be compensated
As discussed in the section 4.3.1 that deals with expropriation, the Constitution lays down the basis for the property to be compensated in case of expropriation as a result of State programs or projects in both rural and urban areas. Art. 44.2 clearly states that " All persons who have been displaced or whose livelihoods have been adversely affected as a result of state programs have the right to a commensurate monetary or alternative means of compensation, including relocation with adequate state assistance." Thus, persons who have lost their land as a result of acquisition of such land for the
Resettlenient Action Plan 24 February, 2003 Etlhiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
purpose of road works are entitled to be compensated to a similar land plus the related costs arising from relocation; assets such as buildings, crops or fruit trees that are part of the land etc. The Resettlement/Rehabilitation Policy Framework prepared by ERA also expressly and appropriately recognizes that Art. 44.2 of the Constitution of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia provides the basis for the compensation procedures and the legal framework for its resettlement and rehabilitation policy (ERA, 2002, p. 13)
4.3.4 Compensation and Valuation Proceduresand Methods
The 1960 Civil Code of Ethiopia contains some provisions pertaining to compensation procedures. Art. 1470 provides that an owner, bare owner or usufructary of an expropriated immovable and any person who benefits by servitude (e.g. customary rights of way to a religious site or national parks etc) shall inform the competent authorities of the amount of compensation they claim within one month after notification that their rights would be affected by the expropriation. Where there is disagreement on the amount of compensation claimed by the affected persons and the competent authority, Art. 1471 provides for the establishment of an arbitration appraisal committee to decide on the amount of compensation. However, there is no provision regarding who should be members of such arbitral committees.
It is provided that the principle in determining the amount of compensation is " the amount of compensation or the value of the land that may be given to replace the expropriated land shall be equal to the amount of actual damage caused by expropriation" (Art. 1474 (1)). As regards elements to be taken into account when determining the amount compensation, the statement made by the contending parties (the persons to be affected by the expropriation and the administrative authorities e.g. ERA) regarding the value of the property or the rights expropriated is to be taken into account as well as the increase in value arising from the construction of the public works (Art. 1475). However, any building or improvement made after the service (notification) of the expropriation order for the purpose of obtaining a greater amount of compensation shall not be taken into account in determining the amount of compensation (Art.1476). Although the principle is set out with respect to valuation of land and other assets expropriated as discussed above, the details to be followed regarding valuation methods are not provided for in the Civil Code. This is left to the bodies established to determine the details of the valuation procedure presumably because it is a technical matter.
The Resettlement/Rehabilitation Policy Framework prepared by ERA (ERA, February 2002) contains various elements that ERA will follow regarding compensation procedures; Methods of valuation; consultation and participation process, grievance procedures as well as the institutional framework in the preparation of the resettlement action plans.
Resettlement Action Plan 25 Febnrary, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - MecharaRoad upgradingproject
Regarding compensation procedures, ERA has provided for a three-step approach to be followed. First, the establishment of compensation committees in each local government (Woreda) affected by the expropriation comprising of representatives from local governments, representatives from project affect persons (PAPS) and the ERA right of way agent. Second, is the assessment of replacement values of identified assets and the third step is to establish compensation rates for all assets to be expropriated. The compensation committees have the function of conducting the registration of affected properties and the number of PAPS per households and determining the compensation rates taking into account the World Bank requirements. It is also provided in the policy framework that all compensation will be effected ahead of the civil works (p27). This is in line with Art. 1478 of the Civil Code which provides that the competent authorities may not take possession of an expropriated immovable until they have paid the amount of compensation fixed.
Although the criteria of eligibility is not expressly articulated in the resettlement/rehabilitation framework prepared by ERA, the identification of the eligible persons for compensation is presumably done during the course of registration of affected properties and the census made of project affected persons. Moreover, ERA has committed itself to take into account World Bank requirements for determining compensation. Thus, the eligibility criteria contained in OP 4.12 of the World Bank's operational manual on involuntary resettlement will be the one that ERA follows when determining eligible persons for compensation. The criteria for eligibility for displaced persons contained in OP 4.12 are: a) those who have formal legal rights to land (including customary and traditional rights recognized by law of the country); b) those who do not have formal legal rights to land at the time the census begins but have a claim to such lands or assets- provided that such claims are recognized under the laws of the country or become recognized through a process identified in the resettlement plan and c) those who have no recognizable legal right or claim to the land they are occupying (see p. 6 of OP 4.12). These are important factors because they also determine the compensation rates to be provided to PAPS.
Aggrieved PAPS will also have a chance to make their complaints to ROW agent, the consultant and finally to the compensation committee.
The eligibility criteria set by the World Bank is basically in line with the national legal requirements. In regard to legal rights over land, the eligibility with respect to land rights can be easily determined in most cases because land is owned by the Government in both rural and urban areas and there are authorities such as peasant associations in rural areas and municipalities, Woredas and Kebeles in urban areas who allocate the land or give legal recognition to such land to the person using such land affected by expropriation. Legal documents such as certificates of registration may be
Resettlement Action Plan 26 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - MecharaRoad upgradingproject
difficult to obtain in rural areas but in cases of urban areas where municipalities exist there affected persons may have such legal documents. In practice, however, such legal documents may be difficult to find even in urban areas and most residents may claim such rights due to many years of possession or occupation of the land which in most cases is recognized by the urban authorities. Moreover, the Civil Code also recognizes that a possessor of an immovable shall become an owner of such an immovable if he/she has paid taxes for fifteen consecutive years (Art. 1168). With the exception of the land which is owned by the Government, this would apply to buildings, residential houses etc .
One other important factor contained in the World Bank's OP 4.12 is the non- entitlement of persons who encroach on the area subject to expropriation after a 'cut-off date'. The cut-off date is presumably after the period a census is made to determine eligible persons at the initial stage the compensation committee undertakes this activity. For Dera - Mechara Road the cut off date is the 24 of January 2003. Such persons will not be eligible to compensation or any other form of resettlement assistance.
The procedures followed for identifying PAPS; the Consultations and Participation process of various stakeholders and the determination of compensation rates and valuation procedures are discussed at length in ERA's Resettlement/Rehabilitation framework. It is not the purpose of this section to discuss these further. What can be said generally is that they provide adequate procedures and methods of valuation and are in line with World Bank's requirements and the national policies, laws and regulations. What needs to be seen is how in practice these requirements are adhered to. ERA's policy framework provides sufficient guidelines for monitoring and evaluation and it is believed that this would really be a learning process for improvement of future resettlement action plans.
4.3.5 Dispute Settlement Procedures and Remedies
In the resettlement/rehabilitation framework prepared by ERA, it is provided that if a dispute arises regarding the amount of compensation to be paid to the project affected persons, then recourse is available to the courts of the local government. It provides, however, that the most preferred option is to take time to settle the dispute amicably by involving the local administration and influential persons as well as elders within the community. The Civil Code also provides that appeal shall lie to the court from the decisions of the committee and that such appeal shall be made within three months from the decision of the committee having been served on the interested party (Art 1477). The draft Oromiya proclamation on Rural Land Use and Administration also provides an appeal to the local social court in the first instance and any party aggrieved with the decision of the social court has the right to appeal to the ordinary court. In case the decision of the first instance
Resettlement Action Plan 27 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
ordinary court is different from that of the social courts, then a final appeal can be made to the next higher court. It also provides that the resolution of the dispute can be made by other means upon the agreement of the parties concerned (Art. 25). It can be said, therefore, that the approach taken by ERA regarding dispute resolution is generally consistent with both the federal and regional laws. What may be underlined here is that the preferred option of dispute settlement ought to be the option of settling the dispute amicably because recourse to courts may take a very long time even years before a final decision is made and therefore, will not be the preferred option for both parties concerned.
4.4 Institutional and Administrative Framework
4.4.1 FederalDemocratic Republic of Ethiopia and Administration Regions
The Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia (FDRE) was formally established on August 21, 1995. The FDRE comprises of the Federal states with nine Regional State members. The new government structure takes power from the center to regions and localities. The relative roles of government at the different levels (Federal, Regional and Local) in terms of power and duties, including on fiscal matters, have been defined by the Constitution, Proclamations Nos. 33 of 1992, 41 of 1993, and 4 of 1995. Under these proclamations, duties and responsibilities of Regional States include planning, directing and developing social and economic programs, as well as the administration, development and protection of resources of their respective regions.
4.4.2 The Environmental Protection Authority
The Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) was established in August 1995, under Proclamation 9/1995, and is an autonomous government body reporting directly to the Council of Ministers. It has a broad mandate covering environmental matters at federal level. The Proclamation sets out the main responsibilities and broad organizational structure of the EPA and these include: to establish a system for EIA of projects, policies, strategies, laws and programs and to enforce implementation of this EIA process (i.e. review EIA reports) and the recommendations which result from it for projects that are subject to Federal licensing, execution or supervision. EPA is also responsible to provide advice and technical support to the regions on environmental matters
In view of the multi-sectoral nature of the EPE and the number of government agencies involved in various aspects of environmental management, overall co-ordination and policy review and direction is the responsibility of an Environmental Protection Council (EPC) within EPA, whose members represent the key agencies concerned with policy implementation. With these
Resettlenient Action Plan 28 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
powers, EPA has the mandate to involve itself with all environmental issues and projects that have a federal, inter-regional (involving more than one Region) and international scope.
4.4.3 Ethiopian Roads Authority
The Ethiopian Roads Authority (ERA) is the Government body responsible for the administration of the RSDP. ERA is a legally autonomous agency in charge of the development and management of the country's road network: planning, construction and maintenance of trunk and major link roads, while responsibility of rural roads has been decentralized to regional Rural Road Authorities (RRAs).
ERA's Legal Division and Right of Way (ROW) Branch: ERA's legal division, and in particular its right of way protection branch is responsible for negotiations, condemnations and revival work of for right ways with property owners, Regional government bodies, rural and urban kebele administrations to secure right of way for highway maintenance and construction purpose as well as for the establishment of quarry and camp sites.
The ROW branch negotiates with property owners, rural and urban dwellers associations (or kebele administration) in fixing compensation for any building, crop, vegetation and other property through judicial methods.
It also investigates claims and disputes arising from land acquisition; recommends acceptance or rejection of compensatory claims and ensures that payments are effected as agreed with claimants or as decided by the competent authority; secures receipts and land transfers for road construction.
Organizes property valuation committee from appropriate Regional officials, community elders and introduce the committee with the authority's standard methodology and procedures of valuation of properties on the land.
The ROW branch in consultation and based on expert opinions or such organizations for the valuation of property or, where appropriate establishes arbitration appraisal committee for conducting negotiations with property owners or their representatives, ensures that accepted appraisal methods and techniques are followed in the valuation of property.
ERA's Environmental Monitoring and Safety Branch
The Environmental Monitoring and Safety Branch (EMSB) was established in January 1998 as Environmental Management Branch (EMB). It is established within the Planning and Programming Division of the Engineering and Regulatory Department to address environmental matters arising from the road development programme.
Resettlenient Action Plan 29 February, 2003 EthiopianRoads Authiority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechlara Road upgradingproject
The main responsibilities of the unit will include:
* Advising senior management and assisting in the decision-making process on all road sector environmental issues; * Advising senior management and assisting in the decision-making process on all road sector environmental issues; * Ensuring that environmental issues are adequately addressed in connection with the activities of all ERA departments and divisions; * Carrying out or supervising EIAs for road sector projects.
4.4.4 Regional Governments
The project road falls within Oromiya Regional National State, in Arsi, West Hararghe and Bale zones. The Regional Governments have zonal administrations under them and sub divided again into Weredas. The basic administration unit is the Wereda and each Wereda is sub-divided into Kebele in urban areas and Peasant Associations (PA) in rural areas. Each administrative unit has its own local government elected by the people.
Based on the powers and responsibilities of the Regional Governments, the Regional Governments have established Sectoral Bureaus, Commissions and Authorities.
In accordance with the principles of government decentralization set out in the Ethiopian constitution, Regional states shall establish their own independent Regional environmental agencies or designate existing agencies that shall be responsible for environmental monitoring, Rural Road Authorities (RRA) protection and regulation within their respective jurisdictions. These are expected to reflect the environmental management requirements at local level.
The Regional Government Environmental Agencies shall:
* based on the CSE, coordinate the formulation, implementation, review or revision of regional conservation strategies. * facilitate the establishment of lower level environmental coordinating bodies at the zonal, wereda and community levels * ensure the implementation of Federal environmental standards or, as appropriate, issue and implement their own no less stringent standards. * prepare reports on the state of the environment and sustainable development of their respective states and submit them to the Authority.
Resettlement Action Plan 30 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
Oromiya Office of Environmental Protection: In accordance with the principles of government decentralization set out in the Ethiopian constitution, Regional states shall establish their own independent Regional environmental agencies or designate existing agencies that shall be responsible for environmental monitoring, protection and regulation within their respective jurisdictions. These are expected to reflect the environmental management requirements at local level.
Many of the responsibilities related to environment within the Oromiya Regional Government Bureaus are only now being formulated and additionally the original bureau structure is being reorganized whereby the environmental activities which used to be part of the bureau of agriculture, is now included in the newly established Office of Environmental Protection.
The Regional Government's Office of Environmental Protection shall:
* based on the CSE, coordinate the formulation, implementation, review or revision of regional conservation strategies. * facilitate the establishment of lower level environmental coordinating bodies at the zonal, wereda and community levels * ensure the implementation of federal environmental standards or, as appropriate, issue and implement their own no less stringent standards. * prepare reports on the state of the environment and sustainable development of their respective states and submit them to the Authority.
Resettlentent Action Plan 31 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradimgproject
5 POTENTIAL SOCIO ECONOMIC IMPACTS OF THE PROJECT
5.1 Description of the Project Socio Economic Environment
The socio-economic impacts of the project that can be created as a result of the construction of the Dera- Mechara Roads upgrading project, in urban areas, it will affect houses used for residential and business purposes, and lead to displacement, it will also disrupt the supply of services such as power, telephone and water; and in rural areas it will also affect farm lands, permanent trees and income of households. The impact that will occur both in urban and rural areas due to the expropriation of houses and farm lands contributes to displacement of the population and relocation or resettlement to a new location, interruption in their business and job and decrease in income and means of living; and also social inconveniences as a result of displacement.
5.1.1 Total Number Persons Affected by the Project
The total numbers of persons that will be affected by the project are 3,664 found in 389 households. The main cause for this effect is that the road construction work will affect their houses; which is either residential, or used for business for service delivery. The figures, which are summarized in table 6.1. 1, provide information on the number of persons and institutions that will be affected in each section of the road. The data on household size (or family size) is obtained from each affected household head. In some cases where the household head was not available during the survey, the data was made available either by one of the family members or else obtained from neighbors and verification is made by cross checking it from local authorities.
In some rare cases where the information regarding the household is not available from the above indicated sources, some reasonable estimation has been made on the basis of the specific area under consideration.
Out of the total length of the Dera - Mechara road, a significant proportion the road passes through a number urban areas, and rural trade and market centers, rural villages and farm lands. As can be seen from the table, along the first section of the road, Dera - Chole, the towns to be affected include, Dera, Sire and Chole. The rural kebeles; market and trade centers that the road passes include, Koshim, Moye and Negele. In this section a total of 1335 people that come from 120 households are identified to be affected by the project.
In the second section of the road from Chole to Gololcha, a number of urban and rural trade centers will be affected. In this section a total of 989 people found in 105 households will be affected. In the third and the last section of the road, which is from Gololcha to Mechara, a total 1,320 people within 164
Resettlement Action Plan 32 Febrary, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - MecharaRoad upgradingproject
households will be affected. The areas that will be affected along this section of the road include the towns of Debre Selam, Micheta and Mechara; and also rural kebeles or villages that the road passes through are Timuga, and Kortu kebeles.
Table 5.1.1 Number of household that will be affected both in urban and rural settlements
Road Section Name of the No. of Total no. of Public and community town/village Household PAPS organizations to be Heads affected 1. Dera -Chole Dera town 2 7 Police station Sire town 7 44 Koshim PA 50 563 Primary School Moye PA 1 5 140 Negele PA 45 575 Sub Total 119 1329 2. Chole - Chole Town 1 6 Gololcha Derartu PA 19 199 Magna Hadere PA 10 70 Haro PA 46 433 Legebuna PA 11 72 Wendo Gasha PA 19 215 Sub Total 106 995 3. Gololcha - Debre Selam 11 51 Mechara (Chancho) Town Timuga PA 57 534 Kortu PA 36 237 I Coffee marketing store/ware house/ 2. Muslim community Micheta Town 29 251 cemetery Mechara Town 31 248 Sub Total 164 1320 Grand Total 389 3644
Resettlement Action Plan 33 February.2003 Ethiopian Roads Autilority PANAFand AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
5.1.2 Family Size of the PAPS
During the field survey detail information about the project affected population including the household size and gender for each household has been collected and compiled. The total number of household that will be displaced due to the project are 389 households, which have 3,644 members. The average family size of the population to be displaced is 9.4 people. The family size of PAPS is higher than the regions' and the country average family size. This is because the population in area is predominantly inhabited by Muslims and has better resource some of the men have more than one wife, and because of cultural reasons also the wives live in the same compound but each having independent house of their own. Hence, the increase in the average family size is related because some men have more than one wife.
The list of names for each household that will be affected by the construction of the road and other detail information about PAPS is presented in Annex 3 of this report.
5.1.3 Gender and Age Structure of the PAPS
Out of the 389 household heads that would be affected by the project, 40 are Female Headed Households. The number of female headed households is high in the urban centers compared to rural settlements.
Among the vulnerable households, 40 are also Female headed households and 45 are elderly men who will be assisted and supported by the community and local administration at the time of implementing RAP.
Regarding the age structure of the people, there are children, young and elderly people that will be affected by the project.
The gender and age structure of the people for each of the places, which are going to be affected by the project, is also shown in the socio economic data under annex three in this report.
5.1.4 Livelihood of the PAPS
The people in the project road area are engaged in different economic activities and the major ones being farming and trade. Farmers comprise 57%, and business men or traders comprise 32% and 3% pensioned and elderly people and the remaining population being civil servants, unemployed and daily laborers. In Gololcha- Mechara road section, the majority of the trade activity is associated with the sale of coffee. The coffee grown in this area is known for its high quality production and fetches good market price in the national coffee market. Hence, the construction of the road will have a
Resettlement Action Plan 34 Febnrary, 2003 EthiopianRoads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consull Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
positive impact on the producers and business community and will provide market outlet to them.
In addition to coffee plantation there are also other types of perennial crops that grow in the area, which are a source of wealth for the people. To list only some of them, fruit trees like orange& banana, chat, coffee, sugar cane and also many other types of fruit trees are available there in addition to the availability of farming activities. But on the contrary, people do not get markets for much of their produces due to the in availability of the road.
Due to the fact that the road condition of the road including that of the urban areas are so poor, the people are mostly disconnected from the rest of country and therefore the people depend much for their livelihood on agricultural productions. Whenever there is an opportunity of access road to the project area, the people can be motivated to produce more and benefit from its sale. The availability of access road is also a major means of reflecting the attitudes of the people towards the construction ideas of the road. In one part of the road, newly poorly access road that link the Debre selam town to its neighboring place called Haro village has been constructed very recently by an intensive human labor. Following this access road, heavy vehicles has started to enter and made bulk purchase of the coffee of the farmers and deliver it to the major markets of the surrounding areas. The farmers have started earning increased income from their coffee farms, which was not possible in the past.
The people residing along the proposed project road have raised their worry on the delay of the project, and are eager to know when the construction activity is going to commence. Some even have proposed to the extent of sacrificing their land and property without being compensated for the sake of the construction of the road.
Resettlement Action Plan 35 February,2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
Table 5.1.4 Occupation of household heads to be affected in each section of the road
Dera - Chole - Gololcha - No Type of Occupation Chole Gololcha Mechara Total 1. Carpenter 1 1 2. Farmer 73 85 63 221 3. Pensioned 1 1 9 11 4. Tailor 2 3 5 5. Trader 35 15 73 123 6. Butcher 2 3 5 7. Guard 1 1 8. Health worker 1 1 9 House Wife 3 3 10. Daily Labourer 3 3 11 Teacher 1 1 12. Cashier 1 1 13. Civil Servant 1 1 14 student 1 1 15 Teacher 1 3 4 16 Weaver 1 1 17NA 5 1 6 Total 120 105 164 389
Note The occupation of trader includes those persons working as shop keeper, local drink brewers, petty traders, crop (cereal) traders, tea shop owners, restaurant owners and other similar business activities.
5.1.5 Vulnerable Groups
The vulnerable groups were identified during field data collection and through interviews that were carried out with the affected population. Female headed households, elderly and the disabled are among the vulnerable groups that require special provision and care. The vulnerability increases if the household head is an elderly or if she is a single mother. Out of the total number of 389 households affected by the project there are 85 vulnerable persons. These persons are constituted mainly of heads of female households (40) and of elderly (45). Among the elderly, 45 are men and 15 are female. The 40 heads of female households are engaged in shop and in small business, such as petty trade, selling local brews and the like. The list of the vulnerable household heads in particular of the elderly and FHH is found in Annex 7.
At the time of implementing the compensation and the resettlement action plan of the project special attention, support and care will be given to female headed households and to the elderly. The support will be made in rebuilding their houses, transferring and transporting their household items and materials to the newly constructed residential houses or houses used for business
Resettlement Action Plan 36 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - MecharaRoad upgradingproject
purpose. Even though it may be difficult to quantify the support provided in monetary terms, these supports are to be considered as one form of "social compensation" for both female headed households and the elderly.
For vulnerable groups that rent and live in kebele houses, the kebele is responsible to construct the houses for them in the relocated site, and also provide all services the vulnerable groups will require when they move to the relocated sites. Vulnerable groups that live in their own houses and who will be affected by the project and need assistance and support are expected to get it either from the extended family network, close friends or from kebele administrations and ERA.
The process through which the vulnerable persons will be assisted by the kebele and ERA is described under relocation options.
In some extreme cases were the vulnerable group do not have extended family network and close friends the kebele administration will facilitate the administrative issues and will give priority in every matter to the group.
In terms of the compensation estimate for houses, farmlands and permanent crops there is no provision allowance made to discriminate between female headed and male headed households. However, special assistance and support will be provided by local authorities to vulnerable groups at the time of relocation.
5.1.6 Ethnicity, Religion and Language of the PAPS
The populations in the area belong to two main ethnic groups, namely; Oromo and Amhara; and the majority of PAPS belong to Oromo ethnic group followed by the Amnhara.
Regarding language, Oromiffa is widely spoken language in the area followed by Amharic.
In terms of religion the majority of the PAPS are Muslims followed by small number of Christians.
5.1.7 Educationallevel of the PAPS
The majority of the PAPS and also the other remaining population in the area illiterate and do not have access to educational services. The literate households found in the project area also have not gone above or beyond primary school level, except some individuals who have completed high school and diploma level education.
Resettlement Action Plan 37 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
5.1.8 Historical, Cultural, and Religious Resources
The Ethiopian Tourism Commission has published a Tourism Master Plan (Tourconsult, 1995) which identified a number of sites of historical, cultural, religious and archaeological importance in the country and none of these are located along the Project Area. Enquiries to residents along the project road have indicated that there are no known sites of historical or archaeological significance in the vicinity of the road, except a cemetery that belongs to the Muslim community in Micheta town where a portion of it will be affected.
5.1.9 Social Organizationsto be Affected
In the entire project area, people have got formal and informal social organizations, and among the social organizations Edir and Baltina are the the two commonly known associations mostly neighborhood associations formed on voluntary basis. Edir and Baltina are mainly established to console and comfort its members when someone among the family member or when a close relative passes away. It is a form of association that provides support and assistance to its members and also the community at times major difficulties or problems. Households that will be displaced from their current area and who will be moving to new places their membership could be interrupted only if where they move is a distant or far away place. However, the new location where the PAPS will be relocated is not very far away from their current location, there would not be major disruption of the above associations or other type of social disruption.
5.2 Socio Economic Impact of the Project
5.2.1 Social Acceptability of the Project Road
The project road has immense value and importance to the livelihood of the population in Arsi and West Hararghe administrative zones of Oromiya Regional state. The influence zone of project road extends from Addis Ababa to the port of Djibouti and Somalia Regional State and to other neighboring zones.
The road is highly critical in providing access to market facilities and outlets, to health and educational services, in linking and creating improved and better relationship of the population of the area with other parts of the country. It is believed that with the construction of the mentioned road there will be better improved public services, growth and development of market centers, improvement in public transport services and increased movement of the population and also increased income due to opening and linking up of market services and facilities.
Resettlement Action Plan 38 February, 2003 EthiopianRoads Authority PANAF andAFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
All the interviewed people in the major towns and rural areas located along the road, including elders, women and elected members of the community, have given a clear indication of acceptance of road improvements and construction.
5.2.2 Impact of the Project in Urban Areas
The project impact in the urban areas as is mainly due to houses found in the right of way, water supply lines or pipes, electric power lines and also telephone lines.
With regard to the urban areas of the project, two types of effects are expected to take place, namely; full (or total) and partial effect. Households, whose entire compound area or its large proportion to be taken by the project are termned as fully affected and on the other hand those households who may only lose part of their compound and house area are categorized as households who will be partially affected. Partially affected households will be allowed to construct new residential or business houses in their previous location (or plot of land) as far as they have sufficient land that would pernit them to construct new houses.
The purpose or use of the houses of the PAPS is mainly for residence, trade and business, or both as a residence and business and for other purposes. Due to the location advantage of the houses, some of the owners and residents use the houses for different business activities that could generate regular income. The common type business activities for which the owners use the houses include, hotel, restaurant, Kiosk (shop), sale of local drinks (Tella, Tej, Areke), for grain and coffee store, barber shop, etc. having business license or without any license. There are also a significant number of households that use their houses (rented or privately owned) for both businesses as well as for residential purposes.
Those households who may lose all their land area or its large proportion and will be allocated another land from the municipality of the town or the kebele for re housing within the vicinity of the town. The authorities found in all levels zonal, woreda, municipality and kebele have confirmed and agreed that those affected households and institutions will be provided with land in suitable locations in the vicinity.
Resettlement Action Plan 39 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consiult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
Impact on public services and utilities (Water supply, Electricity and Telephone Lines) in urban areas
On the basis of information obtained from the Mechara and Micheta towns water supply offices there will be pipe lines found in the ROW to be affected. The following table shows pipes affected by the road project.
Table 5.2.2 Pipelines for water supply to be affected by the Project
Pipe Size in inches Towns Micheta Mechara 4 250m 500m 3 250 m 500 m Source Micheta and Mechara WSS office
Detail information about the existing electric power lines and telecommunications lines found along the Dera - Chole section of the road could not be obtained from the Regional offices of the Ethiopian Electric and Power Corporation and the Ethiopian Telecommunication Corporation located in the town of Nazareth. Both organizations reported tat they require ample time to make cost estimate for the compensation and could not do it with such short period. Hence, it was not possible to make exact cost estimate to obtain the required information from the above offices.
Nevertheless, for the sake of budget preparation, some estimates were made on the basis of previous experiences.
5.3 Impact Category of PAPS
In terms of housing, there are 407 houses (386 residential and one police station, one primary school and on coffee ware house) will be affected by the project. Out of the 389 households, 101 will be fully affected and the remaining 288 PAPS will be partially affected. The average floor area of houses to be affected is 44.31 M2 . This is by far under the minimum area size that municipalities give for the construction of residential houses currently. Among the 389 household heads 17 household heads have more than one family and more than one residential house due to polygamous marriage. Some of these household heads that have polygamous marriage have all their wives in the same compound, however, each wife and her children live in their own house independent of each other.
Regarding the compound area of the total land area found with in the project, it is highly difficult to put a given figure. However, the minimum suggested land area allocation for construction of residential houses as per the local officials is 200m2 per person for the urban areas in the region.
Resettlement Action Plan 40 February.2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
The summary of the compound areas, the floor areas of the houses, the land to be taken by the project and also the left over land area is presented in the annex 5.
The type and purpose of houses that will be affected by the project are not of similar in all the project areas. The houses identified in the project area are those houses constructed from wood and plastered with mud and have corrugated iron sheet roofs; houses made from hollow concrete block; thatched roof houses and houses built with stone masonry works. The highest proportions of the houses that are common in the project area are houses made from wood and mud and that have corrugated iron roofing.
Out of the total houses to be affected 231 (or 82%) are privately owned, 55 (or 14%) are owned by kebeles and the remaining 3 (or 4%) houses are owned by Government institutions.
Similarly, most of the houses that will be fully affected due to the road construction are residential houses except some of the houses that are used for business purpose. Moreover, due to the location advantage created as a result of the presence of the road, almost all households who reside along the road use their houses for commercial activities.
The types of the houses built with and the purpose and use of the houses are the basis for determining the compensation estimates.
5.3.1 PartiallyAffected Households
Out of the total number 389 household heads to be affected, 285 (or 74%) household heads and three institutions will be partially displaced. These 285 households and the three institutions will have sufficient land area to rebuild their houses without moving out of their present location. Since most of the PAPS reside in rural villages and around their farm lands they have sufficient land to move back and construct new houses. In the towns sections and in rural trade and market centers most of the PAPS also have sufficient land area to rebuild similar size of house to their present house without leaving or going out of their area and affecting their business and residence.
Resettlement Action Plan 41 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road uipgrading project
5. 3. 2 Fully Affected Households
Out of the total 389 households to be affected in the project area, 101 households will be fully affected and need to be relocated. These households have got initially small plots of land from which the project will take a portion or the total of it. Therefore, since they can not manage to rebuild on the remaining plot, a similar size of house they are treated as fully affected households, and hence, they will be provided with new housing plots and receive cash compensation at a replacement cost for building new houses, including relocation allowances. The relocation allowances will be made for vulnerable persons, for people renting kebele house, and also for businesses.
The local authorities in all the project road have agreed and confirmed in writing that they will provide land for the relocation of fully displaced houses in the same vicinity of each town or village. As per the local authorities land for land compensation will not be a problem either in the towns or rural sections.
Table 5.3.2 Number of households to be fully affected
Road Section Location Number of Type of Remark Household settlement Heads
Dera -Chole Koshim Rural The local authorities village 21 have agreed to provide Moye village I Rural land for relocation of Negele village 40 Rural these PAPS in each Sire town 1 Urban area. Sub Total 63 Goloicha- Mechara Debre Selam Rural town 1 Timuga village 22 Urban Micheta town 8 Urban Mechara town 7 Urban Sub Total 38 Grand Total 101
5.4 Impact of the Project on Rural Areas
The negative impacts of the project on rural areas are mainly observed on crop production and perennial crops and trees that grow in the area. The perennial or permanent trees that are found in the project area are Coffee, Chat, Mango trees, Sugar cane, Eucalyptus and other types of trees. On the other hand the major crops grown in the project area that will be affected by the project are wheat, maize, and teff.
Resettlement Action Plan 42 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
In rural areas there would not be full displacement of the people from their current holdings due to the project. However, there will be a number of farmers who will lose strips of their farm land and houses to the project. These households will be relocated in their own plots by moving to the back side of their compound area or farm land without being fully displaced from their current holdings or village.
Hence, the above type of households, could easily rebuild their houses on what ever site they prefer during the relocation of their houses. Thus, these people are going to stay with in their surroundings without much disruption of their social relationships and extended family network.
Therefore, the type of impact that would be expected in rural areas of the road is mainly of a partial character, which only leads to the partial displacement (except in those rural villages of koshim, Timuga, and Negele).
The main reason for this is that farm lands of the rural areas are also considered as their compounds as far as the right to construct their houses within their area they prefer. In such rural areas, there is no limitation as to where to construct the residential houses and therefore the compound area of the project is not something to be determined easily.
Table 5.4 Summary table of total house area and farm land and to be affected in each section of the road
Road section Compound Area House Area Compound Left Over Land in m2 in m2 Area to be in m2 Taken in m2 Dera- Chole Dera 2,400.00 59.20 9.84 2,390.16 Koshim 248.08 248.08 54.38 193.70 Moye 1,461.43 660 17 781 65 679.78 Negele 1,905.85 695.71 502.45 1,403.40 Sire Town 814.42 585.33 56.69 757.73 Sub Total 2,767.12 2,383.54 Chole-Gololcha Derartu PA Strip of farm land 479.35 479.35 Strip of farm land Hadera Magna PA Strip of farm land 317.65 313.35 Strip of farm land Haro PA Strip of farm land 1,073.11 1,071 91 Strip of farm land Legebuna PA Strip of farm land 368.75 368.75 Strip of farm land Wendo Gasha Strip of farm land 528.25 150.18 Stnp of farm land Chole Town 500.00 39.00 1.50 498.50 Sub Total 8,736.32 2,545.79 1,440.26 7,296.06 Gololcha- Mechara Debreselam 1,406 54 258.30 33.75 1,372.79 Kortu Strip of farm land 766.40 1154.33 Strip of farm land Mechara 10,078.24 3,094 94 341 81 9,736.43 Micheta 10,433.00 1,929.35 648.16 9,784.84 Timuga 12,747.76 2,719.49 818.88 11,928 88
Resettlement Action Plan 43 February,2003 Ethiopian Roods Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - MecharaRoad upgradingproject
Sub Total 33,259.00 | 8,910.17 | 2,963.18 | 30,295.82 l Grand Total 41,995.32 14,223.07 | 6,786.98 | 35,208.33 l The detailsfor each individual HHarepresented in the attachedAnnex 5.
5.4.1 Impact of the Project on Perennialcrops
25,057 perennial crops of different types, namely; Coffee, Chat, Banana, Mango, Papaya, Orange and Eucalyptus trees that serve as good source of income for farming households will be affected by the project.
The total number of trees that will be affected by the project and that will be compensated by the project are summarized in the table below.
Table 5.4.1 Perennial crops to be affected in the Project Area
Road Section Type of perennial Number of perennial crops crops affected Dera -Chole Eucalyptus 2,466 Chole -Gololcha Banana 220 Mango 3 Orange 18 Papaya 10 Sugar Cane 406 Eucalyptus 3,112 Chat 3,492 Coffee 7,950 Goloecha -Mechara Banana 10 Eucalyptus 6,245 Orange 3 Papaya 3 Chat 130 Coffee 879
Table 5.4.1 Size of Land Area of Crops and Enset to be affected
Road section Type Crops No. of Enset * to Total area in and Enset be affected hectare Chole -Gololcha Enset 110 Maize 10.02 Teff 0.3 Wheat 37.4 Bean 0.9 Zengada 3.03 Goloicha -Mechara Wheat 0.5 * Enset = False Banana
Resettlement Action Plan 44 February. 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
5.4.2 Impact due to Establishment of Construction Camps and Borrow/QuarrySites
The different campsites as well as the access routes may require significant area of land both at temporal and permanent basis. Together with this, land for detour and for dumping soil might also be required during the construction of phase of the project. The identification of the above sites will be carried out by the woreda compensation committee and ERA and the contractor. However, estimate could be done on the basis of some assumptions.
The average area of land required for the site office and residence campsite is taken from the current practice of the Mieso site of the Awash - Hima Road upgrading project. This camp site has occupied 20,000m2 of land. On the basis of reality the contractors need much more land than the supervision site and therefore 40,000 m2 is estimated for the contractors' campsite. In addition to the above sites there might also be a number of other sites that would be used both for supervision as well as the contractor purposes.
In those places that would be occupied and used by the project for the construction of camp sites, soil dumping area, for access road construction it will displace the users from their farm land permanently. In such cases, the compensation estimate deserves to be considered for a longer period and properly. However, it should be noticed that land for ancillary works is most often requisitioned from non-farmland. Farmers who may lose land permanently due to ancillary works will be compensated with new land. This compensation arrangement includes any farmer who may lose land permanently. This arrangement has been confirmed by the Woreda Councils (See Annex 8). However, due to non-availability of farmland in the Arsi Zone, cash compensation will be paid to affected HH.
The following table depicts the area of land that may be required by each of the campsites.
Table 5.4.2 Area Estimations and Camp site (000m2 )
No Road Name Section Supervision Contractor Detour and Total Camp(m2) Camp (m2) Soil Dump 1 Dera-Mechara Dera -Chole 20 40 40 100 Chole -Gololcha 20 40 40 100 Gololcha -Mechara 20 40 40 100
Total _ 60 120 120 300 Source T7he estimateforboth types of camps is based oni the Mieso camp & residence camp
Resettlenient Action Plan 45 February.2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
6 ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR DEFINING AFFECTED PERSONS
ERA has committed itself to take into account World Bank requirements for determining compensation. Thus, the eligibility criteria contained in OP 4.12 of the World Bank's operational manual on involuntary resettlement is the one that ERA follows when determining eligible persons for compensation. The eligibility criteria set by the World Bank is basically in line with the national legal requirements.
Therefore, the following criteria for eligibility for displaced persons contained in OP 4.12 are adopted as part of this RAP.
* Those who have formal legal right to land (including customary and traditional rights recognized by law of the country); * Those who do not have formal legal rights to land at the time the census begins but have a claim to such lands or assets- provided that such claims are recognized under the laws of the country or become recognized through a process identified in the resettlement plan and * Those who have no recognizable legal right or claim to the land they are occupying (see p. 6 of OP 4.12).
Persons who encroach on the area subject to expropriation after a 'cut-off date' are not entitled. The cut-off date is after the period a census is made to determine eligible persons at the initial stage the compensation committee undertakes this activity. Such persons will not be eligible to compensation or any other form of resettlement assistance.
Accordingly, the consultant has identified eligible persons for compensation and assessed the number of PAPS per households and the affected properties (including properties and farm lands found within the right-of-way) and determined the compensation rates taking into account the ERA's Resettlement Policy and World Bank requirements.
However, during implementation of this RAP each affected household head or individual person or party that claim entitlement have to prove their legal rights over the immovable to be expropriated in order to qualify as a legitimate stakeholder and receive compensation.
Persons renting kebele houses if displaced (either fully or partially) the kebele will be responsible to build a house either in their present location or in new locations through compensation they received, and finally rent these houses with the same rental cost like their current location. The local authorities in all woredas, municipalities and town councils have agreed to rent the kebele houses as proposed above.
Resettlement Action Plan 46 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
The following table shows the number of PAPS living in their own and kebele house in each section of the road.
Table 6. PAPS having their own house and those renting kebele houses
Road Section Name of the Type of house ownership town/village No. of No. of kebele No . of privately houses Public/ owned which are government houses rented owned houses 1. Dera -Chole Dera town I I Sire town 1 6 Koshim PA 49 1 Moye PA 15 Negele PA 52 Sub Total 118 6 2 2. Chole - Chole Town 1 Gololcha Derartu PA 19 Magna Hadere PA 10 Haro PA 47 Legebuna PA 12 Wendo Gasha PA 19 Sub Total 108 3. Gololcha - Debre Selam 11 Mechara (Chancho) Town Timuga PA 58 Kortu PA 37 3 Micheta Town 22 9 1 Mechara Town 9 23 Sub Total 137 35 1 Grand Total 363 41 3
Resettlenient Action Plan 47 February,2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgrading project
7 METHODS OF VALUING AFFECTED ASSETS
The major impact of the road on the areas extends to both the urban dwellers as well as the rural parts of the road. The rural areas will be affected by through the houses, farmlands as well as the permanent trees. On the other hand impact of the project upon the urban areas will be limited the house effect only through which the people will be affected.
Zonal, woreda and kebele administrations have confirmed that there is no shortage of land to relocate the affected population within the vicinity of each town. Land will not be a problem in the project area as far as the zonal, woreda and kebele authorities are concerned. (refer to Annex 9 for the confirmation)
However, in rural areas compensation for loss of land will be made in cash for the foregone income or benefit and in addition to the cash compensation also land to land compensation will also be made. The issue of land to land compensation has been discussed and confirmed by Zonal, woreda and kebele officials since there is not shortage of land in the area. (refer to Annex 9 for the confirmation)
Compensation for communal grazing areas or communal properties is not envisaged because land is public property and also as such there is not shortage of grazing area in the area.
7.1 Methods of Valuing Replacement of the Houses
The replacement cost is being taken as a basis for estimating the value of the houses. In accordance with the Resettlement /Rehabilitation Policy Framework of the Ethiopian Roads Authority, the basis for valuation of houses is Gross Current Replacement Cost (GCRC). This is defined as the estimated cost of erecting new building having the same gross external area as that of the existing with the site works and services on a similar piece of land. The valuation process will also consider the use of compensation value for other affected properties and assets.
In estimating the replacement cost allowance for deprecation is not considered. It is the current construction cost, which is being considered. Secondly, those houses that some portion of it will be affected are assumed as if the entire gross house size will be affected. Therefore, the entire house area of the current house is considered to be replaced. The estimate of the houses is done on the basis of the type of the houses. For houses built with wood and mud the replacement cost is calculated on the basis of the unit rate of the wood and mud houses in the locality and similar procedure is applied to the other types of houses. The unit cost of construction is taken from the
Resettlement Action Plan 48 February, 2003 EthiopianRoads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
municipalities of each zone in the project area. On the basis of the specific towns with in which the houses will be relocated, the specification for replacement of the houses was collected. However, the unit rates are calculated to be similar for the towns under consideration.
Irrespective of the location of the area, the unit costs are taken to be similar for the same type houses and used from the same purpose. This conclusion was reached at by analyzing the construction cost of the different areas. The following table represents the unit costs of the houses that are in use for the estimation of the reconstruction of the houses. In calculating the replacement cost of the house, 25% over and above the replacement cost estimate will be added in order to account for the inconveniences.
The valuation of compensation estimates for the urban areas is worked out based on the following major procedures.
i. The houses could be affected partially or completely, but what has been assumed is that the original gross floor area of the houses will be reconstructed or replaced. ii. The replacement of the houses is made using similar type of construction material per the original house. iii. The residuals (materials from the demolished house) of the original assets are to be given to the affected people. iv. No allowance will be made to deduct the deprecation cost. v. The current market price of constructing the houses is taken which includes all of the expenses associated with the construction activities. vi. The quality of the replaced houses will be much better than old houses. vii. Compensation value is estimated to account for the psychological inconveniences, assets damages during transfer, lose of social interactions and social services, and to be in a better position after the displacement.
Regarding to the rural area, the following are the major procedures, which are followed in order to arrive at the valuation for compensation estimate.
i. The compensation estimate for farm lands, crops as well as for the permanent trees are worked out based on the highest market prices. ii. The present value of the stream of the incomes that could be eamed over the entire life of the asset in consideration is taken. iii. The land area which may be taken for campsites, detour, and soil dump land is treated to be compensated at a permanent level. The top soils could be disturbed and the land might not be returned to its original users of the land and therefore full compensation is to be made for its owners. iv. Trees, farm lands and any other property found within the right -of -way will be eligible for compensation.
Resettlemient Action Plan 49 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Autihority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
It is assumed that all of the compensation will be effected prior to the starting of the civil works. The valuing of compensation for the public sectors of telecommunication, electricity, and water is directly taken from the concerned bodies.
Table 7.1 Unit cost for the replacement of houses
No. Type of the House (materials Purpose of the Birr/mt of Birr/Thatche constructed with) House floor area d House 1 Front side with stone masonry Residence 600 and other parts with wood and mud 2 Hollow Concrete Block Residence 1000 3 Stone Masonry Residence 1200 4 Thatched Roof Houses Residence 600 5 Wood and mud houses Residence 464.8 6 Wood and mud houses Store 300 7 Stone Masonry Store 600
For wood and mud type of the houses, the unit cost estimated to be Birr 464.8/M2 floor area. For the Stone masonry type of the house, Birr 1200/M2 floor area, Birr 1000/M2 for hollow block concrete is assumed for all of the affected houses. This estimate can enable he people built by better quality of houses as compared with the existing ones.
On the basis of the discussion with all the concerned authorities and government offices understanding has been reached that the PAPS and especially those who will be relocated entirely from their current places need to get the equivalency of the location advantage they lose.
In compensating households who will lose their current location which has several benefits and advantages 25% of the house estimated cost will be provided to the project affected persons for losing their current places and for all inconveniences and social disruption created due to the project. Therefore, it is considered that 25% will be provided as a compensation value to the above types of households. With this 25% compensation value, the affected person can cover any expenses associated with any relocation activities including access to social and public services.
During the meeting held with local government authorities concerning the replacement of a new location for the PAPS, have agreed and confirmed to provide a new site which will have similar location advantage compared with their present location. Land will not be a problem in the area.
The local authorities have also agreed to provide what ever land left over for the affected business, which is in most cases is less than 200m2 in addition to their new location. The affected households could only use their present land if the location is under the town master plan. The idea is more to support the affected households whose business is also affected.
Resettlement Action Plan 50 February, 2003 Etliopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consuilt Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
The replacement cost of the houses will be Birr 8,013,927 without the compensation estimate, and with the compensation estimate included it will be Birr 10.029,956. The following table shows the replacement cost and compensation for thatched and non thatched houses.
Table 7.1.2 Total replacement and compensation estimate for houses
No Type of the Houses Replacement Compensation Total in Birr Cost(Birr) Estimate(Birr) l I Thatched Houses 29,251 19,500 48,751 2 All types of non 7,984,676 1,996,169 9,980,845 Thatched Houses Total 8,013,927 2,015,669 10,029,596
Compensation Principles for Various Affected Population Groups
Affected Population Categories Compensation Entitlements Compensation Strategy
- Full compensation to rebuild new - Relocate/rebuild house within the house remaining plot
- Compensation value Residence inconvcnience cost, to enable PAP to build better house and the cost of during transfer to the new place.
- Full compensation to rebuild new Relocate/rebuild house within the O X house remaining plot
- Compensation value inconvenience cost, to enable the PAP to build better house and the X X Business cost of transport during transfer Z to the new place.
- Compensation for income restoration during construction t: and transfer.
- Full compensation to rebuild new - Relocate/rebuild house within the house remaining plot - Disturbance allowance to cover loss of income and relocation cost -Residence and Business (multi-purpose)
Resettlement Action Plan 51 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
-Residences - Land replacement for housing Provide new land for rebuilding house - Full compensation for housing in the same town - Disturbance allowance to cover cost of relocation and transport -Business - Land replacement to re-establish New plot with locational advantage to similar business reestablish business (income restoration) o
- Residence and Business - Full compensation to rebuild new Provide new land for rebuilding house house and restablish business - Disturbance allowance to cover 4.- cost of relocation and transport - Adequate compensation to replace lost income
- Compensation Value - The local administration will be (Disturbance allowance) to the paid the appropnate compensation tenants and rebuild new houses within the - Full compensation to rebuild new remaining land Partially Affected house - Retain the right on the new house to be rebuild'within the existing compound - Compensation Value - The local administration will be (Disturbance allowance) paid the appropriate compensation - Full compensation to rebuild new and rebuild houses within the house remaining land and alot to the same Fully Affected - Retain the right on the new house renter with the same rate to be rebuild within the existing compound - The housing right at the same rate on new site. - Full compensation for rebuilding - New land for rebuilding the Government Buildings new offices facilities
- Land on abondoned route after - Relocate on/provide new farmland Due to realignment reinstating on abondoned route - Forgone benefits for the duration - Minimize impacts where possible of impact - Forgone benefits for the duration - The temporary access road will be Due to Temporary access or of impact restored and retumed back to the detour - Restored farm land after the same owner after the construction impact is over - Forgone bcnefits for the duration - The temporary access road will be Borrow and Quarry Sites: of impact restored and returned back to the temporary - Restored farm land after three same owner after the construction years is over Borrow and Quarry Sites - Forgone benefits for ten years Permanent
Note: * The permanent loss due to borrow and quarry areas is a partial loss to the PAP and It is only when ERA decides to retain the sitesfor routine maintenance
Resettlement Action Plan 52 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
7.2 Compensation rates for loss of crops
Monetary compensation will be provided for households whose land will be taken by the project. It is known that the construction of camp sites, access roads, detour and soil dump areas require significant area of land at temporal level. But due to the fact that the topsoil could be affected by the project activities mentioned above, the land may remain un-productive for unspecified period of time. In addition to this, the campsites might remain under the ownership of the client for sake of road maintenance works. Therefore, regarding the agricultural lands that will be taken by the project, it is advisable to consider that people found on those areas would be displaced permanently.
The valuation of compensation is based on the different types of crops grown in the area and on its market value.
The following table shows major crops and the highest possible market pnce of the products.
Table 7.2.1 Gross Annual income of farmers per hectare of land
Type of Land crop Yield Yield Market Gross Gross crop proportion Area (Qt/ha) Qt/Crop Price income/ income in percent (Ha) area Birr/100 ha (Birr) kg (Birr) Teff 2 0.02 15 0.3 210 3,150 63 Wheat 45 0.45 30 13.5 150 4,500 2025 Maize 20 0.2 20 4 150 3,000 600 Bean 15 0 15 15 2.25 140 2,100 315 Soya Bean 10 0.1 12 1.2 180 2,160 216 Pea 8 0.08 15 1.2 140 2,100 168 Total 100 1 - 22.45 162 2,835 3,387
The above table represents the level of gross income for crops grown in the project area and its produce from a given hectare of land. On the average crops grown in the project area are in the order indicated in the table. Thus, teff occupies 2% of land out of the whole farmland of the areas and wheat 45% and the same procedure applies for the rest of the crops shown in the table. The gross income that can be obtained from one hectare of land is therefore calculated to be Birr 3,387 as it is shown in the above table. The possible highest market price of the crops is taken in order to base the compensation estimate at a fair level.
The production of crops is possible only through the application of different types of inputs ranging from human labor up to the application of modem inputs. The identified major inputs and expenses of the farmers required from
Resettlement Action Plan 53 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roa(ds Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
one hectare of land is also can be calculated using area specific figures. The following table presents the input requirements for one hectare of land.
Table 7.2.2 Cost of production per 1 hectare of land
Input type Unit of Input Required Average Unit Total Price Measurement Per Ha of Land Price (Birr) (Birr) Fertilizer 50 Kg 2 200 400 Pesticide Unit 4 0.75 3 Land Tractor cost 1 70 70 Preparation Weeding Man days 20 5 100 Harvesting Quintal 22.45 12 269.40 Land Tax Birr - 90 Total 932.40
The total input requirement for one hectare of land is Birr 932.40. The production of the gross income of farm products is therefore possible through the application of the above level of expenses.
By deducting the input estimate from a gross income of the farm land the result is the net income that can be obtained from one hectare of land. The following tables show the level of the net income that can be obtained from one hectare of land.
Table 7.2.3 Average annual net income from 1 hectare of farm land Crop types Average Annual Average Cost of Average Annual Net Gross Income Production Income(Birr) (Birr) (Birr) Teff 63 18.648 44.40 Wheat 2025 419.58 1605.40 Maize 600 186 48 413.50 Bean 315 139.86 175.10 Soya Bean 216 93.24 122.80 Pea 168 74.592 93 40 Total 3387 932.40 2454.60
As per the calculation made in the above table, from a given one hectare of land the net annual benefit that can be earned through the application of modern farm inputs will be Birr 2,454.60. The application of modern inputs has become a commonly practice in all the project areas.
The valuation of compensation estimate is worked out on the basis of the current market price of the crops, which are grown in the project areas. The major crops grown in the area are the ones indicated in the table above. Other types of crops also could possibly grow in the area but at a very limited scale. Therefore, for the sake of considering the compensation issue, the above crops are selected because they are grown by the majority farmners in the area.
Resettlement Action Plan 54 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Autlhority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradlngproject
According to the common practice, when one is to be displaced from his/her farmland, the ten-year gross income from the specified land will be calculated and is given as a compensation for the affected people.
There might be cases where monetary compensation may be the only means of compensation where land for land compensation might not be applicable. It is also possible that only some portion of the land will be affected by the project, which will not lead to resettlement. Commonly, the construction of road doesn't lead to full displacement of the rural people due to the fact that only a small proportion of the holdings will be taken up.
The area required for the campsites as well as soil dumping and other requirements can be compensated by land in Bale administrative zone of the project side. However, officials of other zones, have proposed monetary compensation for the loss of farm land. But in order to avoid the financial constraints of the compensation the budget estimate is worked out in this report.
The farmers are going to lose their land at permanent level so that they are also going to lose the benefits that could be derived from it at a permanent level. It is true that the user of the land will transfer his holdings to his off springs implying that the benefit that can be derived from the land continues indefinitely. Therefore the unit rate of compensating one hectare of farmland for the indefinite period of time is established.
For a stream of net income (xi) accruing in each year (t), the present value (X) is given by applying the planning discount rate (i) over infinity:
X = Y_ xt /Q +r)t x=X= I This is a finite sum because the net income will not have a growth rate as high as the discount rate over any longer period. The present value of above formula can be reduced to the following formula.
X=xo/r
where X=net present value r= the discount rate.
The current discount rate of the country is 10% and therefore by applying. The above formula, the net present value of the Birr 2,454.60 is calculated to as follows.
Net Present Value = Birr 2,454.6/0.1=24,454
Resettlement Action Plan 55 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Autihority PANAF andAFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
The above method of calculation of the present value of the farrn products over infinity is directly adopted from the work of E.V.K.FitzGerald entitled "Public sector investment planning for developing countries". Therefore, the farm lands that are found along this road are recommended to be paid at the rate of Birr 24,454 for one hectare of farm land. This payment will be applied for those farmlands that have got a nature of permanent take over of the lands from the users. The above rate actually is found out to be in conformity with the current practice in the area. The 10-year income from the products also equals to Birr 24,454 (which is Birr 2,454.6* 10).
The total area of land required for campsites, detour, and soil dumping is estimated to be 50 hectare of land. The following table depicts the total amount of compensation which is required for the farmlands found along the road.
Table 7.2.4 Compensation estimate for loss of strips of farm lands No. Road Section Supervi Contra Detour Total Unit Rate Total (Birr) 2 sion ctors and Spoil (m ) in Birr Camps Camps Dumping (m2) (Lm2) Site 1 Dera 1 2 4 4 10 24,454 244,540 Mechara 2 2 4 4 10 244,540 3 2 4 4 10 244,540 Total 6 12 12 30 733,620
7.3. Compensation for Perennial Crops
Regarding the computation of the stream of future incomes that can be obtained from the sell of the products of fruit bearing trees, the present value of delayed annuity method of calculation is applied. The present value of a delayed annuity is calculated in two methods. The first method is to compute the present value of the annuity at the date that annuity started, while the second method is to discount that value to some other date. The discount rate of the country, which is 10%, is applied for the computation. On the basis of this method of calculation, the present value of the income streams from banana, orange, mango, coffee, chat, papaya, and sugar cane will be presented below. Three major assumptions were used for establishing the unit rates of the trees.
All trees were assumed to be at their seedling stage in year 1995 E.C (or this year). The first date of production will be at different time periods in the future. The major input applied for the production of the fruits is family labor and usually the cost of labor provided for the trees are valued at zero by farmers.
Resettlement Action Plan 56 February, 2003 EthiopianRoads Authority PANAF and AFRO Cons/lt Deta -Mechara Road upgradingproject
The above assumption leads us to establish a uniform unit rate for similar type of trees without considering the benefits, which are already received by the owners. These past benefits are considered to be zero and therefore, the owners will get the whole benefits that could be derived from the tree over its entire life. During the survey, it was observed that there are trees that are fully matured and have started to bear fruits. On the other hand, there are also trees that are found at seedling stage. If different unit rate is established for a single type of tree on the basis of the age for each same type of the tree, the application of the compensation payment will be difficult for the affected to accept it. Therefore, in order to bring all of the trees in a similar unit rate, the seedling stage is being considered.
7.3.1 Present Value of Delayed Annuity from Eucalyptus Tree
Eucalyptus tree can exist for up to 30 years time by actively giving production. It can give production every five-year time interval. For the first cut period, which is after 5 years from its plantation date, only one stem could be harvested. Then during its consecutive cut periods, the tree duplicates itself with a number of copies. Therefore in its second round i.e. at its loth year, a number of 3 copies can be harvested from the same original root. In the same token, at the third rotation period 4 copies and at the fourth rotation period 5 copies will be harvested. Then after this rotation time the yield starts declining and therefore at the fifth and six rotation periods 2 and 1 copies respectively will be harvested. Accordingly, the total active life span of one tree is therefore 30 years time. The unit market price of one eucalyptus tree is 4 Birr.
The present value of the stream of income that can be derived from one root of tree is therefore calculated by applying the following formula.
PV=FVXPVF
PVF=1/(l+t)
PV=FVX1/(1 +t)n
Where PV =Present Value FV =Future Value PVF=Present Value Factor and t=discount rate which is 10%.
By applying the above formula, the present value is calculated and presented in the following table.
Resettlement Action Plan 57 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechlara Road upgradingproject
Table 7.3.1 Present value of Eucalyptus trees
Year No. of Copies Market Price PVF PV (FV) 5 3 6 0.6209 11.1762 10 4 6 0.3855 9.252 15 5 6 0.2394 7.182 20 3 6 0.1486 2.229 25 2 6 0.0923 1.1076 30 1 6 0.0573 0.3438 Total 31.3
7.3.2 Present Value ofDelayed Annuityfrom Banana Tree
Banana tree starts giving yield after 1 year of its seedling time. One tree of banana duplicates itself and can survive up to the maximum time period of 10 years time. From a given parent tree and its copies, a total of 200 banana fruits could be collected per year. On the basis of the current market price, one piece of banana could be sold at a rate of Birr 0.10 and on the basis of this, the present value of the streams of future incomes from one parent tree can be calculated using the present value of delayed annuity method. The applied discount rate used is the standard 10% discount rate of the country. This income deals with the present value at the end of 1995 E.C of annuity of Birr 20(200 * Birr 0.10) per year extending from the end of 1998 E.C until the year 2007, with 10% discount rate. Income occurs at the end of each year, including 2007. This would be a 10 year annuity, with a present value at the start of 1998 of
P1998 =AXPVA(lOYr, 10%) =Birr 20 X 0.909091 =Birr 111.72
The discounted value at the start of 1995 can be computed now by discounting
P 19 9 5 = P1998 X PVF (3yr, 10%) = Birr 122.89 X 0.7513 =Birr 92.2
7.3.3 Present Value ofDelayed Annuityfrom an Orange Tree
Orange tree starts giving yield after 6 years of its seedling time. One tree can survive up to the maximum time period of 50 years time. From a given parent tree a total of 300 orange fruits could be collected per year. On the basis of the current market price, one fruit tree can be sold at a rate of Birr 0.05.on the basis of this, the present value of the streams of future incomes from one parent orange tree can be calculated using the present value of delayed annuity
Resettlement Action Plan 58 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgrading project
method of calculation. A 10% discount rate of the country is applied. This income deals with the present value at the end of 1995 E.C of annuity of Birr 15(300 * Birr 0.05) per year extending from the end of 2000 E.C until the year 2050, with 10% discount rate. Income occurs at the end of each year, including 2050. This would be a 50 year annuity, with a present value at the start of 2000 of
P2000 =A X PVA (5OYr, 10%) =Birr 15 X 9.915 =Birr 148.722
The discounted value at the start of 1995 can be computed now by discounting
P199 5 = P2000 X PVF (6yr, 10%) = Birr 148.722 X 0.5644 = Birr 83.95
7.3.4 Present Value of Delayed Annuity from Mango Tree
Mango tree starts bear fruit after 8 years of its seedling time. One mango tree can survive up to the maximum time period of 40 years time. From a given parent tree a total of 737 mango fruits could be collected per year. On the basis of the current market price, one fruit tree can be sold at a rate of Birr 0.20 cents, and on the basis of this, the present value of the streams of future incomes from one parent tree of mango it can be calculated using the present value of delayed annuity method of calculation. A 10% discount rate of the country is applied. This income deals with the present value at the end of 1995 E.C of annuity of Birr 47.40(737 *Birr 0.20) per year extending from the end of 2003E.C until the year 2043, with 10% discount rate. Income occurs at the end of each year, including 2043. This would be a 40 year annuity, with a present value at the start of 2003
P2003 =A X PVA (4OYr, 10%) =Birr 47.40 X 9.779 =Birr 1441.43
The discounted value at the start of 1995 can be computed now by discounting
P199 5 = P2003 X PVF (8yr, 10%) -Birr 1441.43 X 0.466 = Birr 672.44
7.3.5 Present Value of Delayed Annuity from Coffee
Coffee tree starts giving yield after 4 years of its seedling time. One coffee tree can survive up to the maximum time period of 26 years. From a given parent tree a total of 4 kilograms of coffee could be collected per year. On the
Resettlement Action Plan 59 Febnrary, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF andAFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
basis of the current market price, one kilogram of coffee can be sold at a rate of Birr 7, and on the basis of this, the present value of the streams of future incomes from one parent coffee tree can be calculated using the present value of delayed annuity method of calculation. A 10% discount rate of the country is applied. This income deals with the present value at the end of 1995 Ethiopian Colander of annuity of Birr 28(4*7) per year extending from the end of 1999 E.C until the year 2025, with 10% discount rate. Income occurs at the end of each year, including year 2025. This would be a 26 year annuity, with a present value at the start of 1999 of
P1999 =A X PVA (26Yr, 10%) =Birr 28 X 9.161 -Birr 356.51
The discounted value at the start of 1995 can be computed now by discounting
P19 9 5 = PI999 X PVF (4yr, 10%) = Birr 356.51 X 0.683 = Birr 175.2
7.3.6 Present Value of Delayed Annuity from Chat Tree
Chat tree starts giving yield after 5 years of its seedling time. One tree of Chat can survive up to the maximum time period of 30years time. From a given parent tree a total of 19 Akaras of chat could be collected per year. On the basis of the current market price, one Akara of chat can be sold at an average rate of Birr 2.13, and on the basis of this, the present value of the streams of future incomes from one parent tree of the chat tree can be calculated using the present value of delayed annuity method of calculation. A 10% discount rate of the country is applied. This income deals with the present value at the end of 1995 E.C of annuity of Birr 40.47(19*Birr 2.13) per year extending from the end of 2000E.C until the year 2030, with 10% discount rate. Income occurs at the end of each year, including 2030. This would be a 30 year annuity, with a present value at the start of 2000 of
P2000 =A X PVA (3OYr, 10%) =Birr 40.47 X 9.423 =Birr 381.51
The discounted value at the start of 1995 can be computed now by discounting
PI 995 = P2000 X PVF (5yr, 10%) =Birr 381.51 X0.621 =Birr236.4
Resettlement Action Plan 60 February, 2003 EthiopianRoads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
7.3.7 Present Value of Delayed Annuity from Papaya Tree
Papaya tree starts giving yield after 2 years of its seedling time. One tree of papaya can survive up to the maximum time period of 2 years time. From a given parent tree a total of 50.5 kilograms of Papaya could be collected per year. On the basis of the current market price, one kilogram of Papaya can be sold at an average rate of Birr 0.50, and on the basis of this, the present value of the streams of future incomes from one parent papaya tree can be calculated using the present value of delayed annuity method of calculation. A 10% discount rate of the country is applied. This income deals with the present value at the end of 1995 E.C of annuity of Birr 25.25(50.5* Birr 0.50) per year extending from the end of 2000E.C until the year 2005, with 10% discount rate. Income occurs at the end of each year, including 2005. This would be a 5 year annuity, with a present value at the start of 2005 of
P2000 =A X PVA (5Yr, 10%) =Birr 25.25X 3.791 =Birr 95.72
The discounted value at the start of 1995 can be computed now by discounting
P199 5 = P2000 X PVF (5yr, 10%) = Birr 95.72 X 0.826446 = Birr 79.10
7.3.8 Present Value of Delayed Annuity from Sugar Cane
Sugar Cane tree starts giving yield after 2 years of its seedling time. One tree of Sugar Cane can survive up to the maximum time period of 5 years time. From a given parent tree a total of 30 sticks of Sugar Cane could be collected per year. On the basis of the current market price, one stick of sugar cane is sold at an average rate of Birr 0.50, and on the basis of this, the present value of the streams of future incomes from one parent Papaya tree can be calculated using the present value of delayed annuity method of calculation. A 10% discount rate of the country is applied. This income deals with the present value at the end of 1995 E.C of annuity of Birr 15(30*Birr 0.50) per year extending from the end of 1997E.C until the year 2001, with 10% discount rate. Income occurs at the end of each year, including 2001. This would be a 5 year annuity, with a present value at the start of 2001 of
P2001 =A X PVA (SYr, 10%) =Birr 15X 3.791 =Birr 56.86
The discounted value at the start of 1995 can be computed now by discounting
Resettlenient Action Plan 61 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF andAFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
P199 5 = P2 00 1 X PVF (5yr, 10%) = Birr 56.86 X 0.621 = Birr 35.6
The total sum of compensation estimate for each type of permanent tree is given per road section in the following table.
Table 7.3.1 Summary table for compensation estimate for perennial crops
Road Section Name of tree No. of trees Unit rate Total cost in (Birr/tree) Birr Chole -Gololcha Banana 220 92.20 20,284.00 Mango 3 672.44 2017.32 Orange 18 83.95 1,511.10 Papaya 10 79.10 791.00 Sugar Cane 406 35 65 14,473.90 Chat 3,492 236.40 825,508 80 Coffee 7,950 175.20 1,392,840 Eucalyptus 3,112 31.30 97,405.60 Dera -chole Eucalyptus 2,466 31.30 77,185.80 Gololcha - Mechara Banana 10 111.72 1117.20 Orange 3 83.95 251.85 Papaya 3 79.10 237.30 Eucalyptus 6,245 31 30 195,468.50 Chat 130 236.40 30732 Coffee 879 175.20 154,000.80 Total 2,813,825.17
Table 7.3.2 Summary table for compensation estimate for crops per road section
Road Section Crop type Hectare Unit rate Total cost in Birr (Birr/ha) Chole -Gololcha Maize 10.02 24,454 245,029.08 Teff 0.3 24,454 7336 20 Wheat 37.4 24,454 914,579.60 Bean 0.9 24,454 22,008.60 Zengada 3.03 24,454 74,095.62 Gololcha - Mechara Wheat 0.5 24,454 12,227.00
Total _ 1,275,276.10
7.4 Compensation for Electric and Telephone poles
ERA has a long tradition of compensating for the loss of public infrastructure and properties that are affected due to road construction. Water pipes, telephone poles, power poles will be compensated at replacement cost to the relevant office. However, telephone lines are not common along the road
Resettlement Action Plan 62 February, 2003 Ethiopian RoadIs Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
corridor. Even though the concerned office has failed to estimate the compensation amount that may be required for the preparation of budget, it is however found necessary to show a certain estimate of these infrastructures or services in order to avoid budget constraint that will happen if not shown in this RAP.
The only two towns that benefit electricity and telephone services are Dera and Sire towns. The utility line for each service follows the general routing of the existing road between the two towns, although diverging for some considerable distances in many locations.
7.5 Compensation for water pipes in Micheta and Mechara towns
The following table presents the total budget requirement of the water pipes, which needs to be relocated during construction of the road.
Table 7.5.1 Compensation estimate for pipes in Micheta town
Diameter of Total length Unit cost Total cost in Birr pipe in inch of pipes in (Birr/m) meter
4 250 83.3 20,825
3 250 83.3 20,825 41,650
Table 7.5.2 Compensation for water pipes in Mechara town
Diameter of Total length Unit cost Total cost in Birr pipe in inch of pipes in (Birr/m) meter
4 500 83.3 41,650
3 500 83.3 41,650 83,300
Conflict between these utility lines and the proposed road works occurs in only in three locations;
i) at a location some 3km from Dera (approximately km 3.0), where both the electricity and telephone lines cross the roadway, ii) between km 11.7 and km 11.85, where the telephone line crosses the road, and iii) between km 19.8 and km 21.0, where both electricity and telephone lines cross the road and where it has been necessary to realign the road to move it away from the danger zone imposed by an adjacent major erosion gully.
Resettlement Action Plan 63 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Autthority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - MecharaRoad upgradingproject
Base on experiences a total sum of Birr one million is estimated for the relocation of an insignificant line of the two governmental corporations.
7.6 Relocation/Re Housing Options
Cash compensation to all PAPS including vulnerable households will be paid by ERA. To ensure that compensation will be used for building new houses, ERA and the kebele will establish a compensation committee that will monitor the rebuilding of houses by the PAPS.
There are five type houses that exist and will be affected by the project. The type of houses include those made from wood and mud, thatched roofs, hollow concrete block, stone masonry, front stone masonry and its other sides are built with wood and mud.
Table 7.6. Type and number of houses to be affected in each town or village
Type of Houses Front side Hallow masonry & Wood & Thatched Concrete Stone other side Town/PA Mud Roof Block masonry wood & mud Total Dera- Chole Dera Town 2 2 Sire Town 6 1 7 Chole Town I 1 Koshim PA 50 50 Sub Total 59 1 60 Chole- Gololcha Negele Town 52 52 Moye Town 15 15 Legebuna PA 2 10 12 Debre Selam 7 4 11 Derartu PA 15 4 19 Wendo Gasha PA I 18 19 Haro PA 35 12 47 Sub Total 127 48 175 Gololcha - Mechara Kortu PA 28 11 1 40 Magna Hadere 10 10 Mechara Town 22 9 1 32 Micheta Town 28 4 32 Timuga Town 58 58 Sub Total 146 15 10 1 172 Grand Total 332 63 10 1 1 407
Resettlenient Action Plan 64 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - MecharaRoad upgradingproject
8. ORGANIZATIONAL PROCEDURES FOR DELIVERY OF ENTITLEMENTS
The organizational procedures for delivery of entitlements show the procedures to be adopted in the delivery of entitlements for PAPS. Zonal, Woreda and Kebele administrations; and in those areas where there are municipalities will provide all administrative procedures and entitlements for PAPS. The procedures to be followed or adopted include:
* To register the PAPS and to make clear their current entitlement rights * To verify the entitlement rights of PAPS with concerned authorities; woreda administration, municipalities and kebele administrations on the legal and administrative rights of the PAPS. * Evaluation and assessment of the legal and administrative issues PAPS * Consultation of PAPS and reach to common understanding and consensus concerning their entitlement * To effect the entitlement certificate for each PAPS
9. IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS FOR THE RAP
Zonal and woreda authorities, Municipalities and town councils, rural and urban kebele administration officials that are found in each of the affected areas of the project were consulted as how to implement the compensation process either in rural or urban areas. The institutions that were consulted are the ones that have got direct responsibility on the issue.
Organizations that would be responsible to implement the project include government institutions and kebele associations/administration, and representatives of PAPS and renowned persons and elders.
During the field assessment organisations and institutions that were consulted include:
1. Zonal Administration Offices 2. Zonal Industry and Urban Development Departments 3. Municipalities of the towns affected 4. Woreda Administration Offices 5. Zonal Water Resources Offices 6. Woreda Water Resources Desks 7. Urban Water Supply and Sewerage Services 8. Zonal Agricultural Desks 9. Woreda Agricultural Offices 10. Rural and urban kebele administrations 11. Influential persons in the area
Resettlement Action Plan 65 February, 2003 Figure 3 Resettiment Action Plan -Composition of the Implementing Committee in Urban and Rural Areas
F~~~~~~~~7~~~~~~~1ERA 1 ~~~~~~Oroevya2...... 60 Regional |t >
RAP-ImplemnloCmite.-...... RPIpceatomto URE4LAREAS ...... RURAL AREAS
_ _ Rcp~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Gvrnmentatvs AI -[ - Chakmanl l RcpesentaUvetwm ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~thcAff--WceWcreda 0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
f ROWApcnttndmERAl l -~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~SECRETARY
R.-W-atn Pt
0 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAFPandAFRO Consult Dera - MecharaRoad upgradingproject
In the entire project areas the above mentioned institutions were consulted about the whole mechanisms of the implementation processes. The local populations have been waiting so eagerly the construction of the road from the time they have heard some years back about its possible construction. The populations, in particular Gololcha - Mechara section have requested the government through their representatives.
The responsibilities assigned for each organization or body is mainly on the basis of their legal mandates responsibilities given to each office. The organizations as well as their assumed responsibilities are presented in summarized form in the table below. These proposed participants are to form an ad hoc committee, which assumes a form of organizational structure.
'(The Implementation schedule is attached separately as Table 9. 1)
Resettlement Action Plan 67 February.2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
Table 9.2 Consultation procedures for Institutions and Individuals responsible for the Implementation of compensation and their Assumed Responsibilities
A) For Urban Areas
No Organizations, Responsibility committees and individuals involved Ethiopian Roads Budget Allocation, (disperse )Coordination and implementation 1 Authonty of the compensation and resettlement action plan and Momtormg & evaluation Oromiya Regional Coordination, awareness creation and support 2 Council 3 Zonal Administration Coordinate the whole resettlement issue, facilitate compensation Offices for PAPS, and facilitate land for land compensation, facilitate the relocation sites and the restoration of services. 4 Zonal Industry and Urban Compensation of estimate for houses, prepare site plan for the Development Department relocation of PAPS 5 Zonal Water Resources Coordinates and prepares compensation estimates for water Offices supply systems to be affected 6 Municipalities Identify land for the relocation of PAPS and provide support in restoration, and provide special attention and support for the disabled, sick, elderly and female headed households 7 Zonal Agricultural Desks Coordination and support of PAPS and preparation of cost estimates for land, crops and permanent Trees 8 Urban Water Supply and Restore water supply system and construct new water supply Sewerage Services line in areas where PAPS are relocated 9 Elders and renown Provide advice on the fairness in relocation process and individuals valuation of compensation and coordinate on the support to be made for elders, FHH and disabled 10 Legal Department Monitor the legal framework and ensure that compensation and relocation of PAPS is made as per the rule 1 Representatives of PAPS Represents PAPS in all meetings and discussions held with ROW branch of ERA and with other offices 12 Telecommunication Restoration of telephone lines and provide to PAPS 13 EEPCO Restoration of Electric Lines and provide power lines to the relocated PAPS 14 Kebele admunistrations Register PAPS, and construct kebele houses with the compensation received in the new locations and rent out to PAPS, Provide support for vulnerable groups among PAPS
B) For Rural Areas
No Organizations, Responsibility committees and individuals involved Ethiopian Roads Budget Allocation, Coordination and implementation of the 1 Authonty compensation and resettlement action plan and Monitoring & evaluation Oromiya Regional Coordination & Awareness Creation 2 Council 3 Zonal Administration Coordinate the whole resettlement issue, facilitate compensation Offices for PAPS, and facilitate land for land compensation, facilitate the relocation sites and the restoration of services
Resettlement Action Plan 68 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - MecharaRoad iupgradingproject
No Organizations, Responsibility committees and individuals involved 4 Zonal Industry and Urban Compensation of estimate for houses, prepare site plan for the Development Department relocation of PAPS 5 Legal Departments Monitor the legal framework and ensure that compensation and relocation of PAPS is made as per the rule 6 Woreda Administration Identify land for the relocation of PAPS and provide support in Offices restoration; provided land for land compensation in places where land is available, and provide special attention and support for the disabled, sick, elderly and female headed households 7 Woreda Agricultural Preparation of cost for the valuation of compensation of crops Offices and permanent Trees 8 Affected persons Represents PAPS In all meetings and discussions held with Representatives ROW branch of ERA and with other offices 9 Renown elders from the Provide advice on the fairness in relocation process and locality valuation of compensation and coordinate on the support to be made for elders, FHH and disabled 10 Zonal Agncultural Desks Coordination of compensation for land, crops and pennanent Trees I I Kebele (PA) Register PAPS and provide admimustrative support for the Admunistrations implementation team and ERA's ROW branch while making cash compensation, provide land for land compensation where land is available
On the basis of the meetings and discussions held with the officials, the implementation of the compensation presses should pass through the following five different phases and these phases are briefly described below:
Committee Formation Phase The Ethiopian Roads Authority in consultation with Oromiya Regional State will form a committee in different zones traversed by the project road. The notification will contain list of institutions that will be involved in the committee. It will also clearly put the time frame given to under take the task. The Oromiya Regional State in return will establish implementing Committee at zonal, woreda and in the towns to coordinate and implement the resettlement action plan in consultation with ERA's ROW branch.
Awareness Creation At this phase, the committee members will make themselves clear about the duties expected from them. Any clarification about the scope of the project will be given by the client. The committee members in return will elaborate to the Project Affected People so that the compensation program can proceed with the full participation of the people.
Compensation phase This phase is a stage where by the compensation program will be executed. All form of compensations will be accomplished on the basis of the exact
Resettlement Action Plan 69 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgrading project
project area Based on this notification; the proper owners of the assets will be checked against the study document for compensation.
Reporting ROW branch, zonal and woreda administration offices will produce a report regarding their accomplishments and submit to the ERA and Oromiya Regional State. The Regional state in return will communicate to the client (ERA) about the accomplished compensation process and the site is ready for the construction of the road.
Time Required for Compensation There are a number of crucial activities that will be performed to make the physical relocation of the people under this project possible. There will be many different activities which will be undertaken either by the direct involvement of the committee or the people themselves which may require longer period of time. Among the different activities, which needs longer time period, the constructions of the houses are identified to be one of the major ones. Houses made up of wood and mud, hollow concrete block and stone masonry are the three types of houses to be constructed as a replacement and out of these, the wood and mud house types require longer time to dry and become habitable especially in highland areas where there is not sufficient sunshine that will allow it to dry easily. Assuming that every process including compensation payment is carried out in the planned time, the construction of this type of houses might take a minimum of three months. The time that will be used for the construction of the houses is the only assumed constraint which might delay the resettlement program to be completed within a possible short period. From the point of view of giving high priority to the project, the officials have confirmed that the implementation of compensation will be effectively and efficiently under taken within reasonable time specified by the client. The officials therefore take this period as the reference time required for the implementation of compensation process.
The tentative time within which the compensation program will take place is proposed to be 16 weeks. All of the compensation aspects of the program could be completed ahead of the civil works if it is planned properly. The proposed time schedule is presented in the table below.
9.1 Budget Requirement for the Implementing Committee
To plan, administer and oversee resettlement and compensation, it is recommended to establish an Implementing Committee (IC) composed of four members as shown in Figure 3.
The Committee will have the mandate, authority and funds to ensure proper assessment and timely compensation to the PAPs. The committee would
Resettlement Action Plan 70 February, 2003 EthiopianRoads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
report directly to the the responsible Regional Government Office, Woreda Administrator in rural areas and Head of the Municipality in urban areas, and ERA.
The task and responsibility of the committee is challenging and tiresome and demands extra effort. Hence, it is recommended to pay an allowance at the rate of 70 Birr per day.
A number of professionals such as surveyors to measure the size of land and property will assist in day-to-day tasks.
Table 9.1 Fund Required for the Implementing Committee
No. Cost item Amount (birr) 1 Per diem for 4 members 120 days 70 Birr/day 33,600 2 Per diem for 2 surveyors 120 days 50 Birr/day 12,000 3 Per diem for 1 driver 120 days 50 Birr/day 6,000 4 Per diem for 1 Prof. From EMSB 45 days 70 Birr/day 3,150 5 Fuel and lubricants 12,000 TOTAL 66,750
Financial resources to carryout the compensation and re-housing plans will be made available by ERA when and where required and construction plan will be prepared in concert with relocation plans. The total amount will be Birr 66,750. This budget requirement includes for the implementation as well as monitoring and evaluation of the implementation of the compensation program.
Resettlement Action Plan 71 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Conszilt Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
Table 9.2 Synchronized Implementation Schedule for Road Project and Resettlement Action Plan
No AcUon ~~~~~Year2003 I Year 2004 Year 2003 Year 2003 Ya2O No~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~NcotJ!FI|M|DI A|M|JI*1*A SI s N O) J F . A M J J A _ O NIDJ_FIMAM J J_ II N_]JFJ AIO NID I PRECONSTRUCTION PHASE__
1 1 ERA Submits the RAP'sbudget to FDRE i I|[||| |||Fi 12 ERA Reviews and submitstheR~AP to WBfor review i ______1 3 Approval of RAP by the W3B ll L 1 4 Estabishment of RAP-implementing Committee (IC) Tr W|j m 1 5 Tendennq and Award of Design and Supervsion Contracts ll _ 1 6 Conduct a nclht-of-way survey ROW Report and detaileddrawngs showng projeGdband acquisition 1 61 requirements subminted to ERA ______Detailed drawngs shomng mains servces relocation requirements i i 16 2 submitted to servce providers i ______
17 Conduct a one day workshop for the IC members and local authontbes e F r"|L______1 71 concemmngthe prDcess and responsibility Confmmcompensabon and rates and relocation options through i i 1 72 a onsultabon mth RAP-IC and the Woreda Councils H I I L L=______17 3 Payment of CompensationII IIIIII II_ *** ___
1754 Construction of new houses t r.______176 Installabon of Utilities for PAPs (water supply, eledncity, and telephone) II IIIIII II- T Reoaofuic Utiltes (water suppfy, eiecdncaty,and telephone) by f fw L
2 1 Procurement Process (render and awardfor construction) = ___ra * ** 3P3*w PO 2 2 Mobilezabonof theacontractorsII IIIIII IIIILil _ __ I I
2 3 conbxtor hasunimpeded access to the site ll I1 2 4 Site clearance inspection and certification on complebon of the works ll llllll ||SrT I I I I I I I I
Resettlement Action Plan 72 February,2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
Implementation Time Frame by Week
The following table shows the implementation schedule for each type of activity to be carried out.
I _ Weeks No. Activity |I 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 1 Formation of the Committees _ - 2 Awareness Creation _ __
3 Site Preparations for Resettlers _ _ __ 4 Engineering & Architectural designs - 5 Construction of Houses 6 Water Supply, electricity, Telephone Compensation for the People E U ... U 7 Water Supply, electricity, Telephone Compensation for the Organizations 8 Crop & Permanent Tree Compensation __ U E. 9 Transferring of People to new sites __l______11 Completion Report Writing l_l_l_l 12 Civil Work _ _ __l_ _ _l
Resettlement Action Plan 73 Febnuary, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechiara Road upgradingproject
10. GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISMS
Where dispute arises between the principal parties- in this case mainly between ERA and subsidiary other local government authorities in the project affected area and the project affected persons- the initially preferred means of settling disputes is by arbitration. This is permissible under Ethiopian law (see Arts. 3325-3336 of the Civil Code), and also according to Art. 25 of the draft Oromia Rural Land Use and Administration Proclamation. The number and composition of the arbitral tribunal may be determined by the concerned parties. In the case of a dispute arising regarding compensation amounts both in kind and monetary terms, it is suggested that the maximum number of the members of the arbitral tribunal should not exceed five. This would allow meaningful representation from local government authorities and project-affected people but exceeding this amount might create unnecessary delay in decision making. The composition of the arbitral tribunal could be decided from the outset instead of leaving it to the disputants to appoint the arbitrators. This would be the preferred option since it might take a lot of time to appoint arbitrators if left to the disputing parties. It would also allow the appointment of relevant persons from both the local authorities and project- affected people and as far as possible 'independent' persons to make the decisions. Individual members of the compensation committee who initially decided the compensation rates should by no means be members of the arbitral tribunal since they have already taken a position.
Accordingly, it is suggested that the following be members of the arbitral tribunal:
A. In Urban Areas (towns) 1. Woreda Administrator - Chairperson 2. The Mayor of a town or Chairperson of the town council 3. Head of Woreda Urban Development Department 4. Chairman of Kebele Administration 5. Two members elected by the project-affected persons where the RAP is to be implemented.
B. In Rural Areas 1. Woreda Council- Chairperson 2. Woreda Agricultural Office 3. Kebele (or Peasant Association) chairman 4. Two members elected by the project affected persons where the RAP is to take place.
In case the dispute is not resolved by the arbitral tribunal, the aggrieved party has the right to appeal to the ordinary courts of law in the region.
What should be underlined here is that the preferred option of dispute settlement ought to be the option of settling the dispute amicably because recourse to courts may take a very long time even years before a final decision is made and therefore, should not be the preferred option for both parties concerned.
Resettlenient Action Plan 74 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road uipgrading project
Figure 4 ProJect Affected persons Grievance Resolution Channels
RAP-IC presentsthe ompensatronpackage to PAP
The PAP evaluatesthe compemsatkmpackage
The PAP refusesto accept the cempensoton package and expresses hs reserraton to tre RAP-IC
The agreved PAP Is give. a chanceby the RAP-IC to expbari why the packages net acceptabletD hoe D
jThe PAP an th A-IC fai to agntee andenher partynepon the snuatzon to
The bcal aothorty bnegs the PAP and the RAP-IC fo, tsrtherdisctssno |
The PAP and the RAP-IC f to agree ard the local authoty appoets abrtral ribtsal PAP Project Afftoted Person RAP Re.e.tt..*e.t A.Utn Pi.. IC Impt-emtine Commcttee ERA Ethiopia. Roeds Authority The ar,btraltnbunal hearsfrom the PAPatd the ROW-A Rlgtf-WtlWey Agent RAP-IC The tobanagrerestRsrecornmner,daeon
RAtheRAP-IC tew The PAP refusesto accept the thom pensates Decstn,Jsttct otthe bathralhibural packageas agreed byhthe PAP
PAP acceptstire package The RAP-IC retusesto teyew the compe.sahfonpackage asprte edC of the arbgraltnbunal
The PAP goes ho wnten cotnseetto the ROW-ARAP-IC
The PAP recees the T PAP takes s case compensatbito ERA Rmstagse co ot-waayAgest
Resettlement Action Plan 75 February. 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
The PAPS also could make their complaint to ERA's Right of Way branch, to the contractor, resident engineer before taking the case to administrative bodies or court.
11. RAP IMPLMENTATION COST
The total budget for the implementation of RAP including 20% contingency will be Birr 20.79 million. The budget includes all compensation costs for the relocation of the affected households, for the restoration of their assets and properties, and for the replacement of houses and for the restoration of social services (power lines, electricity and water pipes). The highest amount of budget is allocated for the replacement of houses followed by compensation made for perennial crops and trees.
Table 11 Resettlement / Rehabilitation Budget
Item Description Compensation Estimate (in million Birr) Compensation for strip of farm lands in rural areas* 1.30 Compensation for loss of trees (Eucalyptus trees, fruits, 2.80 coffee, chat, sugarcane) Compensation for water pipes 0.12 Compensation for loss of houses 10.02 Disturbance allowance 1.56 Compensation for crops and land loss* * 0.73 Compensation for loss of electric and telephone poles 1.00 Monitoring 0.11 Sub Total 17.27 Contingency (20%) 3.52 Grand Total 20.79
Note *Individual farmers will be identified dunng implementation of this RAP **Land loss for contractors' camp, materials site, detour and spoil dumping sites
Resettlement Action Plan 76 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Autlority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
12. CONSULTATION WITH PAPS
The local people specifically PAPS were consulted at the maximum level. The views and the aspiration of each PAP were gathered. As far as possible the compensation is worked out on the basis of the demand of the PAPS.
Consultation with PAPS has been made on several issues that include detail information through interview process based on a structured questionnaire to lean and understand more about their livelihood, income, and on other social issues, on cost estimates for compensation and etc. The detail information collected include name of household head, family size, occupation, income, ownership of property, age, educational level, ethnicity, language, and religion.
Consultation is also made with all responsible government authorities and community institutions found in the project areas including local and international NGOs involved in relief and rural development activities.
With woreda and kebele administration, and with the PAPS consultation was made on the location, availability of land for re housing, compensation to be made, support to be made for the vulnerable, cut off date, and on the implementation procedures. Zonal and woreda administration, and municipalities and town councils, urban and rural kebele administrations have fully agreed and confirmed (minutes are attached in annex nine) to provide land for the PAPS to be able to construct houses within the vicinity of the town. Zonal administration offices play the coordinating and facilitating role in the implementation of RAP, and woreda administration in association with municipalities and town councils in the recognized urban centers, and in rural areas PA's will be directly responsible for the implementation of RAP jointly with ERA's ROW branch.
The committees, which will be responsible for implementation of the compensation program, will be formed and the compensation program will be implemented by ERA's ROW branch in the project areas prior to the commencement of the civil works of the project.
Resettlement Action Plan 77 Febnrary.2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgrading project
13. MONITORING PLAN
It is recommended to fully integrate a monitoring plan within the overall RAP implementation levels to oversee re-establishing process of the Project Affected People (PAPS). It will be a compliance monitoring and this will assist to follow the type of measures incorporated in RAP documents, and the extent to which recommendations on these matters, as set out in the RAP, are complied with. The monitoring will play a major part in determining the overall RAP of this project and in the future preparation of RAP.
For the monitoring and evaluation activities, the committee to be established will take a prime responsibility at the project area level. The committees through their coordinator which are the administration offices at zonal and the woreda levels will follow and clarify the implementation processes, and whenever found to be necessary arrange the ground for consultation with Project Affected People (PAPS), and work closely with ERA's ROW branch.
The monitoring and evaluation process if possible will be Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation including all the stakeholders (PAPS, Zonal, Woreda and Kebele administrations, NGOs, other Government organizations, and host communities)
ERA's Environmental Management Branch with the support of independent monitors (consultants) will be responsible to monitor and evaluate the compensation to be made to PAPS. The following indicators will be used in the process of the monitoring;
* Amount of compensation to be made * Mechanisms for the restoration and restitution of PAPS * Appropriateness of relocation sites * Appropriateness of the time schedule for RAP * Public infrastructures and social services re established * Support and assistance made to vulnerable groups and women * Appropriateness of grievance redress mechanisms * Problems and difficulties encountered
Finally, the project monitoring report will be written by ERA's Environmental Management team, including data for each PAPS will be prepared and submitted to all concerned stakeholders and partners.
Resettlement Action Plan 78 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF and AFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgrading project
ANNEX 1 LIST OF REFERENCES
Environmental Policy of Ethiopia: Environmental Protection Authority, Addis Ababa, April 1997
Draft Proclamation on the Establishment of Environmental Protection Organs: Environmental Protection Authority, Addis Ababa, 2000
Environmental Impact Assessment Guideline: Environmental Protection Authority, Addis Ababa, 2000
The Conservation Strategy of Ethiopia; Vol I-V: Secretariat for the Conservation Strategy of Ethiopia, Environmental Protection Authority in collaboration with Ministry of Economic Development and Cooperation, Addis Ababa, April 1996
Road Sector Development Programme 1997-2007. Second Draft Final Report. Ethiopian Roads Authority, Addis Ababa, January 1996
Ethiopian Roads Authority, Resettlement/Rehabilitation Policy Framework, February 2002, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Ethiopian Roads Authority, Environmental Procedures Manuals, 2001, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Constitution of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia Proclamation No.1/1995
The 1994 Population and Housing Census of Ethiopia; Results for Oromiya Region. Volume 1: Part I and VI. FDRE Office of Population and Housing Commission, Central Statistical Authority, Addis Ababa, April 1996
Environmental Impact Assessment Source Book, (Volume I, II & III). World Bank Documents Number 139, 140 & 141, World Bank, Washington, DC: World Bank, Environment Department 1991
Roads and the Environment: A Handbook, World Bank Technical PAPser No. 376, Washington, DC: World Bank, Environment Department, 1997.
Environmental Assessment. Operational 4.01, Annex A. World Bank, Washington, D.C, 1989.
Road Sector Development Programme Sipport Projects - Phase II, Environmental Impact Assessment Final Report, Aficon International, 2001, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Resettlement Action Plan 79 February, 2003 Ethiopian Roads Authority PANAF andAFRO Consult Dera -Mechara Road upgradingproject
Feasibility Study of RSDP II: Seven Roads Projects: Final Study Report, Volume 1, 1999, Kocks Consult GMBH Consulting Engineers in assosciation with Metaferia Consulting Engineers, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Detailed Engineering Design and tender document preparation for DERA - MECHARA road upgrading project. Environmental Impact Assessment, Wilbur Smith Associates in Association with Pan African Consultants, July 1998, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Design review, pre qualification of contractors and evaluation of bids for Dera - Mechara road upgrading project (Section 1: Dera - Chole; Section 2A: Chole - Magna (Km o+000 to 22+400); Section 2B: Magna - Gololcha (Km 22+ 400 to 60 + 920) and Section 3: Gololcha - Mechara
Land acquisition review report for Dera - Mechara road upgrading project Wilbur Smith Associates in Association with Pan African Consultants, July 1999, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Resettlement Action Plan 80 February, 2003 EthiopianRoads Authority PANAF andAFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
ANNEX 2 PERSONS CONTACED AND INSTITUTIONS VISITED
No. Woreda Location/ Name of person Organization Responsibility Town contacted 1 Daro Lebu Mechara Ato Getaneh Hailu Mechara town Finance and Budget special Head administration of fice 2 Daro Lebu Mechara W/o Emebet Teka Mechara town Administration and special Finance Head administration office 3 Daro Lebu Mechara Ato Wegayhu Wereda Wereda Belayneh administration Administrator 4 Daro Lebu Micheta Ato Menkir Yosuf Special kebele Vice Administrator administration 5 Daro Lebu Micheta Ato Fekadu Amensisa 6 Daro Lebu Mechara W/o Bedade Werku Water supply and Department Head sewerage 7 Gololcha Chancho Ato Mehamed Kasa Woreda Vice Administrator Administration office 8 Gololcha Chancho Ato Birhanu Erco Woreda Agriculture Expert office 9 Gololcha Chancho Ato Niguse Asefa Woreda Woreda Administration Administrator 10 Gololcha Chancho Ato Endeshaw Tesfaye Rural development Acting Head office 11 Gololcha Chancho Ato Girma Tebeje Rural development Department Head office 12 Chole Chole Ato Teshome Demissie Wereda Vice Administrator Administration office 13 Chole Chole Ato Solomon Gashaw Water development Department Head 14 Chole Chole Genet Tesfaye Municipality Department Head 15 Chole Chole Ato Tesfaye Gudesa Agriculture Department Head
Resettlement Action Plan 81 February, 2003 EthiopianRoads Authority PANAF andAFRO Consult Dera - Mechara Road upgradingproject
No. Woreda Name Responsibility 1 Jeju Worda W/o Almaz Shumi Community Development officer 2 Jeju Worda Ato Mohamed Husen Public relation desk officer 3 Jeju Worda Ato Mohamed Usman Woreda Council deputy speaker 4 Chole Woreda Ato Mamo Kasso Woreda Administrator 5 Chole Woreda Ato Teshome Demisse Woreda D/Administrator 6 Chole Woreda Ato Tesfaye Gudisa Woreda Agriculture Office 7 Dodota Sire Ato Weyuma Leliso Woreda D/Administrator 8 Dodota Sire Ato Mekuria Dinku Aboye Woreda Justice head 9 Dodota Sire W/o Ashu Gudeta Womens's affair head Dodota Sire E l Al Woreda community Development 10 Ato Emanuel Alemu Representative 11 Dodota Sire Ato Mengistu Jara Dera Town Municipality Secretary 12 GoolhAoegituNgaWoreda Culture & Information 12 Gololcha Ato Mengistu Negash Head 13 Gololcha Ato Solomon Geta Woreda Rural Development co- ordinator 14 Gololcha Ato Niguse Assefa Woreda Community Development Officer Gololcha . . Woreda Public matter and Kebele 15 Ato Kasim Tibeso administration officer 16 Gololcha Ato Hailu Debele Woreda Justice department 17 Gololcha Ato Mesfin Ashebir ChairMan of Chancho Kebele 18 Daro Lebu Ato Amin Yoseph Woreda Security officer Daro Lebu Woreda Militia Training and 19 Ato Jemal Mohamed selectingslcigoferc officer 20 Daro Lebu Ato Hasredin Suleman Woreda Council Speaker 21 Merti Ato Kedir Hamde Woreda D/Administrator 22 Merti Ato Adefris Mekonen Woreda Justice department 23Merti Ato Abdela Aman Woreda Culture & Information 23 Merti Ato Abdela Aman head
Resettlement Action Plan 82 February, 2003 Annex 3: Socio Economic Profile of PAPS
~~~~~~~~~~~~~House Family No. Town/PA Name of1 Household Head Kebele No. Age Gender size
Section 1 -Dera - Chole
1 Chole Town Ato Gashaw Alemu 01 None 60 Male 5 2 Dera Town Ato Nuru Mohamed 02 394 78 Male 5 3 Dera Town Police Station 4 Koshim PA Ato Kemal haji Husmu Koshim None NA Male 15 5 Koshim PA Ato Mama Haji Husmo Koshim None NA Male 10 6 Koshim PA Haji Jundi Tufa Koshim None NA Male 8 7 Koshim PA Ato jeldl Alyou Koshim None NA Male 7 8 Koshim PA Ato Aman Kedir Koshim None NA Male 10 9 Koshim PA Ato Jemal Sufi Koshim None NA Male 9 10 Koshim PA Ato Temam Nuri Koshim None NA Male 11 11 Koshim PA Ato Demsew Denb Koshim None 50 Male 11 12 Koshim PA Ato Derib G/Yes Koshim None 80 Male 11 13 Koshim PA Ato Kemal Kedir Koshim None 50 Male 15 14 Koshim PA Ato Gebe Taha Koshim None 25 Male 17 15 Koshim PA Ato Abubeker Sheh Mehamed Koshim None 55 Male 16 16 Koshim PA Ato Hadi Shuba Koshim None 60 Male 20 17 Koshim PA Ato Ousla Amamo Alyu Koshim None 58 Male 23 18 Koshim PA Ato Telil Terko Koshim None 65 Male 20 19 Koshim PA Ato Damtew Asbo Koshim None 30 Male 8 20 Koshim PA Haji Tirtil, Koshim None 60 Male 10 21 Koshim PA Ato Abdi Telbo Koshim None 42 Male 12 22 Koshim PA Ato Abdrehman Hapi Haji Koshim None 32 Male 10 23 Koshim PA Ato Shikule Addem Koshim None NA Male 5 24 Koshim PA Shek Hasen Shek Adem Koshim None 40 Male 14 25 Koshim PA Shek Hasen Shek Adem Koshim None 40 Male 7 26 Koshim PA Ato Husen Edns Koshim None 55 Male 16 27 Koshim PA Ato Junedi Kebir Tahir Koshim None 45 Male 11 28 Koshim PA Ato Mehamed Haji Kasimk Koshim None 50 Male 10 29 Koshim PA Ato Abulkenm Hamdi Koshim None 35 Male 1 30 Koshim PA Ato Kemal Teleio Koshim None 27 Male 13 31 Koshim PA Ato Arba Kedir Koshim None 38 Male 6 32 Koshim PA Ato Arba Kedir Koshim None 38 Male 6 33 Koshim PA Ato Arba Kedir Koshim None 38 Male 6 34 Koshim PA Ato Seid Eko Koshim None 35 Male 5 35 Koshim PA Shek Kedir Shek Hasen Koshim None 35 Male 6 36 Koshim PA Ato Abre Aman Koshim None 20 Male 4 37 Koshim PA Ato Abdurhaman Haji Adem Koshim None 40 Male 10 38 Koshim PA Ato Mama Haji Husen Koshim None 40 Male 15 39 Koshim PA Ato Abdela Hasen Koshim None 50 Male 10 40 Koshim PA Ato Musa Haji Husen Koshim None 50 Male 9 41 Koshim PA Ato Beyn Shek Amdeha Koshim None 37 Male 6 42 Koshim PA Ato Haji Sal, Gobena Say Koshim None NA Male 15 43 Koshim PA Ato Redewan Seid Abyu Koshim None NA Male 9 44 Koshim PA Ato Sali Hajpkem Denbeba Koshim None NA Male 18 45 Koshim PA Ato Lema Deiene Koshim None NA Male 8 46 Koshim PA Ato Daimu Haji Haj] Koshim None NA Male 9 47 Koshim PA Ato Yemen Abdul Semed Koshim None NA Male 8 48 Koshim PA Ato Teshome Dendene Koshim None NA Male 10 49 Koshim PA Ato Ismael Mehamed Koshim None NA Male 8 50 Koshim PA Ato Haji Feko Chef Koshim None NA Male 9 51 Koshim PA Denebe Guye School Koshim 52 Koshim PA Ato Saliya Kedir Weko Koshim None NA Male 6 53 Koshim PA Ato Seifu Jima Hail Husen Koshim None NA Male 9 54 Moye PA W/o Ehite Birr 01 NA 60 Female 10 55 Moye PA Ato Tadese Beleke 01 NA 50 Male 8 56 Moye PA Ato Desalegne Shiferaw 01 NA 45 Male 5 57 Moye PA Ato Birhane Banty,walu 01 NA 61 Male 5 58 Moye PA Ato Niguse Eshete 01 NA 48 Male 8 59 Moye PA W/o Birke Teshome 01 NA 27 Female 2 60 Moye PA Ato Asefa Kebede 01 NA 52 Male 15 61 Moye PA Ato Takele Haile Motl 01 NA 45 Male 10 62 Moye PA Ato Abera Kidane 01 NA 50 Male 12 63 Moye PA Wlo Nigstl Eshete 01 NA 50 Female 8 64 Moye PA Ato Haji Abdo Amda Bekule 01 NA 90 Male 7 65 Moye PA Ato Eshete Girma Zewde 01 NA 32 Male 6 66 Moye PA Ato Kagnew Amare Miltke 01 NA NA Male 10 67 Moye PA wlo Feleku Birhane Zergaw 01 NA NA Female 7 68 Moye PA Alo Birkneh Tegegne 02 NA NA Male 12 69 Negele PA Ato Shikuri Adem 01 None 62 Male 17 70 Negele PA Ato Hajl Jemal Hail Husen 01 None 70 Male 10 71 Negele PA Haji Mehamed Abir Ahmed 01 None 80 Male 5 72 Negele PA Ato GenaHaji 01 None 35 Male 12 73 Negele PA Ato Ahmed Alyu 01 None 32 Male 7 74 Negele PA Ato Tura Haji Mehamed 01 None 36 Male 7 75 Negele PA Ato Muzein Habir Husen 01 None 45 Male 7 76 Negele PA wlo Kasech Adere 01 None 35 Male 6 77 Negele PA Same Same Same Same Male Same 78 Negele PA Ato Nuru Shek Ahmed 01 None 35 Male 4 79 Negele PA Same Same Same Same Male Same 80 Negele PA Ato mehamed Hasen 01 None 35 Male 6 81 Negele PA Ato Hasen Gobena 01 None 50 Male 20 82 Negele PA Same Same Same Same Male Same 83 Negele PA Ato Kemal Amda golo 01 None 50 Male 15 84 Negele PA Ato Haji Ture 01 None 36 Male 6 85 Negele PA Ato Fekru Haj] Kul, Adem 01 None 32 Male 5 86 Negele PA Ato Jeyligne Adem Kebu 01 None 50 Male 20 87 Negele PA Ato Junedin Say Sheku 01 None 56 Male 20 88 Negele PA Ato Husen Roba 01 None 45 Male 35 89 Negele PA Ato Abdul Kadir Tekako 01 None 55 Male 40 90 Negele PA Ato AlIye Haji Husen 01 None 35 Male 10 91 Negele PA Ato AbdurAman Hail Mehamed 01 None 50 Male 30 92 Negele PA Ato Kasim Tesema Hute 01 None 55 Male 25 93 Negele PA Ato Hsji Hamda Tekeko 01 None 28 Male 20 94 Negele PA Ato Husen Haji Amano 01 None NA Male 6 95 Negele PA Ato Ahmed Haji Isman Kobelo 01 None 35 Male 10 96 Negele PA Ato Mehamed Haji Gena Tufa 01 None 50 Male 20 97 Negele PA Ato Husen Shekena Wako 01 None 35 Male 12 98 Negele PA Ato Mehamed Ahmed Elo 01 None 55 Male 35 99 Negele PA Ato Hajl Aman Wako 01 None 33 Male 6 100 Nege/e PA Ato Temam Mehamed Jara 01 None 33 Male 12 101 Negele PA Same Same Same Same Same Same 102 Negele PA Shekuli Adem 01 None NA Male 5 103 Negele PA Shek Asen Shek Adem 01 None 40 Male 4 104 Negele PA Same Same None Same Same Same 105 Negele PA Ato Husen Endns 01 None 55 Male 4 106 Negele PA Ato Jundi Kebir Tahir 01 None 45 Male 6 107 Negele PA Ato Mehamed Hapi Kasim 01 None 50 Male 10 108 Negele PA Ato Abdul kenm Hamda 01 None 35 Male 1 109 Negele PA Ato Kemal Telilo 01 None 27 Male 13 110 NegelePA AtoArebaKedir 01 None 38 Male 6 111 Negele PA Same Same None Same Same Same 112 Negele PA Same Same None Same Same Same 113 NegelePA Ato SeidEko 01 None 35 Male 5 114 Negele PA Shek Kedir Shek Asen 01 None 35 Male 6 115 Negele PA Ato Abre Aman 01 None 20 Male 4 116 Negele PA Ato Abdurahman Haji adem 01 None 40 Male 10 117 Negele PA Ato Mama Haji Husen 01 None 40 Male 15 118 Negele PA Ato Abdela Hasen 01 None 50 Male 10 119 Negele PA Ato Musa Haji Husen 01 None 50 Male 9 120 Negele PA Ato Beyan Shek Abdurahman 01 None 37 Male 6 121 Sire Town Ato Ousman Amino 01 288 70 Male 13 122 Sire Town W/o Birtukan Mekonen Desta 01 703 70 Female 2 123 Sire Town Ato Belhu Abebe 01 262 30 Male 8 124 Sire Town W/o Bekelech Zerfu 01 263 NA Female 4 125 Sire Town Ato Akllu Dejene 01 NA 25 Male 3 126 Sire Town Ato Zenebe Ayele 01 265 25 Male 3 127 Sire Town Wlo Menma Gendo 01 NA 43 Female 4 Section 2- Chole - Golokcha
128 Derartu PA Ato Mehamed Husen Derartu None. 35 Male 5 129 Derartu PA Ato Ked, Jima Derartu None 60 Male 15 130 Derartu PA Ato Niguse Mulugeta Derartu None 30 Male 10 131 Derartu PA Ato Jemal Mehamed Derartu None 42 Male 13 132 Derartu PA Ato Knmal Mehamed Derartu None. 40 Male 8 133 Derartu PA Ato Julo Iroba Derartu None. 64 Male 12 134 Derartu PA Ato Abdulkedir Kene Derartu None. 54 Male 8 135 Derartu PA AtoAbrahamBedaso Derartu None 52 Male 16 136 Derartu PA Ato Aman Ambo Derartu None 43 Male 8 137 Derartu PA Ato Ture Guder Derartu None 42 Male 5 138 Derartu PA W/o Genu Abdi Derartu None 40 Female 5 139 Derartu PA Ato Kedero Mehamed Derartu None 25 Male 12 140 Derartu PA Haji Kemal Mehamed Derartu None. 59 Male 32 141 Derartu PA Ato Mukenm abdo Derartu None. 30 Male 6 142 Derartu PA Ato Aman Ahmed Derartu None 45 Male 7 143 Derartu PA Ato Kasim GobeNA Derartu None. 50 Male 7 144 Derartu PA Wlo Alima Mehamed Derartu None. 53 Female 4 145 Derartu PA W/o Zemzem Horo Derartu None 60 Female 6 146 Derartu PA Wlo Widnesh Derartu None. 65 Female 1 147 Magna Hadere Ato Adamu Belete Hadere None 28 Male 7 148 Magna Hadere Kes Gulma w/Yohannis Hadere None NA Male 5 149 Magna Hadere Shek Jemal Abdi Hadere None 30 Male 6 150 Magna Hadere Ato OumerAman Hadere None 25 Male 8 151 Magna Hadere Ato Jemal Mume Hadere None 25 Male 3 152 Magna Hadere Ato Ebu Geda Hadere None 70 Male 5 153 Magna Hadere Ato Sultli Alh Hadere None 60 Male 5 154 Magna Hadere Ato Mehamed Adem Hadere None 40 Male 11 155 Magna Hadere Ato Ahmed Tufa Hadere None NA Male 4 156 Magna Hadere Ato Dino Mehamed Hadere None NA Male 6 157 Haro PA Ato Adem J,bnl Haro None 45 Male 9 158 Haro PA Ato Abdul Kenm Muktar Haro None 20 Male 3 159 Haro PA Ato Hasen Aliye Haro None 25 Male 9 160 Haro PA Ato Abdulahi Mehamed Haro None 50 Male 13 161 Haro PA Ato Kedir Haji Haro None 35 Male 7 162 Haro PA Ato Dinku Legese Haro None 40 Male 6 163 Haro PA Shek Jemal Ahmed Haro None 45 Male 11 164 Haro PA Ato Nibras Abdella Haro None 19 Male 7 165 Haro PA Ato Husen Kedir Haro None 30 Male 7 166 Har PA Ato Abera Gulilat Haro None 25 Male 7 167 Haro PA Ato l7lahun Wakene Haro None 30 Male 9 168 Haro PA Ato Juhar Ahmed Harm None 32 Male 7 169 Haro PA Ato Yusuf Adem Haro None 35 Male 13 170 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Husen Haro None 25 Male 4 171 Haro PA Ato Husen amaro Haro None 25 Male 4 172 Haro PA Ato NAsirKasim Haro None 30 Male 5 173 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Amin Haro None 20 Male 9 174 Haro PA Ato Lema Worku Haro None NA Male 9 175 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Kemal Haro None NA Male 3 176 Haro PA Ato Abdul feta Haji Haro None 30 Male 7 177 Haro PA Ato Zubeda Haji Haro None 40 Male 10 178 Haro PA Ato Mehamed AlIyu Haro None 44 Male 9 179 Haro PA Ato Shimelsh Ketema Haro None NA Male 12 180 Haro PA Ato Kediro Mehamed Haro None 45 Male 13 181 Haro PA Ato KemerKemal Haro None 35 Male 5 182 Haro PA Ato Adem Yesuf Haro None 40 Male 7 183 Haro PA Ato AbdurAman Haro None 42 Male 4 184 Haro PA Ato Ibrahim Aman Haro None 36 Male 6 185 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Hasn Haro None 38 Male 9 186 Haro PA Ato Ismael Oumer Haro None 45 Male 10 187 Haro PA Ato AlIyu Mehamed Jinga D,bu None 40 Male 7 188 Haro PA Ato Taha Abi Basha Jinga Dlbu None 45 Male 8 189 Haro PA Ato Kebeti Gulilat Haro None 25 Male 7 190 Haro PA Ato Amanu Bambo Haro None 40 Male 19 191 Haro PA Ato Nltsu Melese Mamo Haro None 25 Male 6 192 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Kebede Haro None 28 Male 7 193 Haro PA Ato Abdi Mehamed Haro None 50 Male 12 194 Haro PA Ato Temem Oumer Haro None 50 Male 17 195 Haro PA Ato Regasa Leta Haro None 30 Male 8 196 Haro PA At oShimelis Asemu Haro None 40 Male 11 197 Haro PA AtoMehamed Allyu Haro None 29 Male 15 198 Haro PA W/o Dasash Admas Haro None 28 Female 9 199 Haro PA Ato Ahmed Mume Aby Haro None 40 Male 9 200 Haro PA Same Same Same Same Same Same 201 Haro PA Ato Girsha Kasim Haro None 50 Male 9 202 Haro PA Ato Kebede Haile Haro None 80 Male 4 203 Haro PA Wo Rase Abebe Haro None 36 Female 5 204 Legebuna PA Ato Legese Debele Legebuna None 58 Male 6 205 Legebuna PA Ato Jemal Mehamed Alhye Legebuna None 30 Male 6 206 Legebuna PA Ato Jemal Adem Kuri Legebuna None 20 Male 3 207 Legebuna PA Ato Melese Beyene Welde Legebuna None 53 Male 3 208 Legebuna PA Ato Mehamed Kemal Amedo Legebuna None 27 Male 6 209 Legebuna PA Same Same Same Same Same Same 210 Legebuna PA Ato Mehamed NurAhmed Legebuna None NA Male 6 211 Legebuna PA Ato Siraj Husen bedaso Legebuna None 40 Male 15 212 Legebuna PA Ato Suran Hasinboru Legebuna None 45 Male 4 213 Legebuna PA Ato Jibril Kelil Adem Legebuna None 60 Male 6 214 Legebuna PA Ato Abdella Ousman Abdi Legebuna None 23 Male 4 215 Legebuna PA Ato Mehamed Husen Shek Adem Legebuna None 19 Male 2 216 Wendo Gasha PA Ato KedirAhmed Yae Gugu None 25 Male 3 217 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Abdul Kadir Ousman Yae Gugu None 55 Male 16 218 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Husen Amdajilo Yae Gugu None 26 Male 5 219 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Mehamed Amda Yae Gugu None 28 Male 6 220 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Tilma Bedaso Yae Gugu None 29 Male 7 221 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kadi Bedao Chaco Yae Gugu None 30 Male 222 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Bulo Kebir Sheka Yae Gugu None 57 Male 8 223 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Ahmed Bedaso Chaco Yae Gugu None 32 Male 14 224 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Dbele Shegu Jima Yae Gugu None 65 Male 8 225 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Abiti Debele Yae Gugu None 35 Male 5 226 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kasim Gobe Yae Gugu None 65 Male 15 227 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Mussa Bornu Tune Yae Gugu None 35 Male 13 228 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Aliye Amda Jillo Yae Gugu None 33 Male 14 229 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Mustofa Kebir Yae Gugu None 30 Male 11 230 Wendo Gasha PA Shek Esmael Chole Yae Gugu None 70 Male 36 231 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kedir Batt Roba Yae Gugu None 60 Male 6 232 Wendo Gasha PA Ato GeNA Tolosa Yae Gugu None 30 Male 7 233 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kedir Ahmed Yae Gugu None 40 Male 8 234 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Msbaou Shek Esmael Yae Gugu None 20 Male 5
Section 3 - Goloicha - Mechara 235 Debre Selam Wlo Zehara Nura 01 None 32 Female 3 236 Debre Selam W/o Yesunesh HiManam 01 None 48 Female 4 237 Debre Selam W/o Sofia Abdi 01 None 16 Female 1 238 Debre Selam W/o Abiba Dasa 01 None 80 Female 1 239 Debre Selam W/o Zemnu Dade 01 None 60 Female 5 240 Debre Selam Ato Hal/ye Feysa 01 None 60 Male 4 241 Debre Selam Ato Kebede Abera 01 None 40 Male 6 242 Debre Selam Ato Oumer Hamda 01 None 45 Male 6 243 Debre Selam Ato Husen Tulu 01 None 50 Male 3 244 Debre Selam Ato Mama Abdela 01 None 35 Male 1 245 Debre Selam Ato Abdo Bedaso 01 None 60 Male 6 246 Kortu PA W/o TeNAgne G/Michael Workye Kortu None 60 Female 4 247 Kortu PA Ato Eshetu Getahun Abebe Kortu None 40 Male 2 248 Kortu PA Ato Husen Ouso Beker Kortu None 35 Male 5 249 Kortu PA Ato Musa Ouso Oda Kortu None 60 Male 11 250 Kortu PA Same Same Same Same Same Same 251 Kortu PA Ato Desaalegne Berhanu Haile Kortu None 34 Male 7 252 Kortu PA Same Same Same Same Same Same 253 Kortu PA Ato Juhar Beker Ahmed Kortu None 50 Male 12 254 Kortu PA Same Same Same Same Same Same 255 Kortu PA Ato Kelil Kortu None 30 Male 1 256 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed Haji Ibrahim Kortu None 70 Male 15 257 Kortu PA W/o SeadaAli Kortu None 40 Female 3 258 Kortu PA Ato Tefera Worku Kortu None 55 Male 10 259 Kortu PA W/o Debre G/Maariam Kortu None 50 Female 6 260 Kortu PA W/o Zemzem Haji Kortu None 50 Female 5 261 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed Zeynu Kortu None 20 Male 2 262 Kortu PA Wlo Tininesh Dubale Kortu None 25 Female 3 263 Kortu PA Wlo Yesunesh G/HaNA Kortu None 30 Female 5 264 Kortu PA Ato Slraj Aliye Abdi Kortu None 40 Male 6 265 Kortu PA Ato K,flu WiMariam Kortu None 35 Male 6 266 Kortu PA Ato Kamil Sedik Weda, Kortu None 65 Male 3 267 Kortu PA Ato Harun Husen Oumer Mohamede None 25 Male 8 268 Kortu PA Ato Mohamed Haron Haji Mohamede None 40 Male 5 269 Kortu PA Ato Yas, Yusuf Mehamed Tlmuga Wac None 32 Male 5 270 Kortu PA Ato Kedir Irere Beyotl Timuga Wac None 30 Male 8 271 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed Ibrahim Abdela Timuga Wac None 35 Male 7 272 Kortu PA Ato Sude Dad, Timuga Wac None 25 Male 2 273 Kortu PA Ato Taha Kasim Omer Timuga Wac None 30 Male 6 274 Kortu PA Ato Muktar Jima Daro Lebo None 32 Male 4 275 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Amere Mechara None 40 Male 9 276 Kortu PA Same Same Same Same Same Same 277 Kortu PA Shek OumerAmye Mechara None 75 Male 8 278 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed Bedaso Mechara None 20 Male 3 279 Kortu PA Ato Ousman Hasen Mechara None 27 Male 5 280 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Yesuf Mechara None 30 Male 3 281 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Ahmedd Kemen None 32 Male 3 282 Kortu PA Ato Abdul ManOusman Kemen None 32 Male 3 283 Kortu PA Ato Adem Musa Kemen None 25 Male 2 284 Kortu PA Ato Isa Adem Kemen None 28 Male 6 285 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Mume Kortu None 40 Male 8 286 Mechara Town Atoahmed Omda Ako 01 None 40 Male 10 287 Mechara Town Ato MejiNA Abdulahi 01 None 30 Male 5 288 Mechara Town Shek Taha 01 None 45 Male 5 289 Mechara Town Ato Getachew Manekul 01 None 50 Male 4 290 Mechara Town Ato Aby Ahmed 01 None 46 Male 9 291 Mechara Town Ato Mohammed Abdulah Oxede 01 None 60 Male 5 292 Mechara Town Same Same Same Same Same Same 293 Mechara Town Ato Abdulkadie Yuye 01 None 40 Male 7 294 Mechara Town Ato San, Abrha 01 None 50 Male 4 295 Mechara Town Ato Husen AbiJelal 01 None 40 Male 7 296 Mechara Town Ato Hamid Hasen 01 None 35 Male 3 297 Mechara Town Ato Hamed siraj 01 None 45 Male 8 298 Mechara Town Ato Yusuf Shek Bereka 01 None 35 Male 5 299 Mechara Town Ato Hamed Hasen 01 None 35 Male 7 300 Mechara Town Ato Lule Behabtu 01 None 45 Male 3 301 Mechara Town Ato Sani Haji 01 None 45 Male 5 302 Mechara Town Ato Mehamed Abdulahi 01 None 50 Male 5 303 Mechara Town Ato Mehamed Sheka Adem 01 None 60 Male 10 304 Mechara Town Wlo Sofia Hasen 01 None 50 Female 7 305 Mechara Town Wlo AmiNA Hasen 01 None 40 Female 9 306 Mechara Town Ato abrham Sheka 01 None 55 Male 9 307 Mechara Town Wlo Alima Issa 01 None 60 Female 4 308 Mechara Town Ato Mehamed All 01 None 50 Male 8 309 Mechara Town Ato Sani Hajl Mehamed 01 None 60 Male 13 310 Mechara Town Ato Ahmed Mehamed 01 None 33 Male 9 311 Mechara Town Ato Muluka Kasim 01 None 40 Male 5 312 Mechara Town Sek Faris Buser 01 None 70 Male 15 313 Mechara Town Ato Tofik Husen 01 None 45 Male 4 314 Mechara Town Ato nuru Ahmed 01 None 55 Male 15 315 Mechara Town W/o YewdarBegashaw 01 None 80 Female 9 316 Mechara Town Ato Jemal Mehamed 01 None 32 Male 4 317 Mechara Town Ato Abdurehman Ousamn 01 None 35 Male 4 318 Micheta Town Haji Ahmed Husen 01 None 80 Male 35 319 Micheta Town Wlo Kedire Shek Ahmed 01 None 40 Female 6 320 Micheta Town Same 01 None Same Same Same 321 Micheta Town Ato Mehamed Abdulahi Oxede 01 None 60 Male 14 322 Micheta Town Coffee Marketing (Store) 01 323 Micheta Town Wio Almaz Desta 01 None 70 Female 15 324 Micheta Town Ato Mehamed Shek Abdurehim 01 None 35 Male 7 325 Micheta Town W/o Shitu Abebe 01 None 50 Female 8 326 Micheta Town Ato Jemal Ahmed 01 None 29 Male 4 327 Micheta Town Ato AlIu Abdo 01 None 50 Male 9 328 Micheta Town Ato Negede Mekonen 01 None 35 Male 5 329 Micheta Town wlo Zehara Kasim 01 None 55 Female 6 330 Micheta Town Ato T,nrneh Neway 01 None 67 Male 10 331 Micheta Town Shek Abdelaadem 01 None 40 Male 6 332 Micheta Town ato Husen Mume 01 None 35 Male 4 333 Micheta Town W/o Aster H/WeId 01 None 27 Female 4 334 Micheta Town Ato Kebede Demise 01 None 73 Male 4 335 Micheta Town wlo Zewde Demise 01 None 55 Female 5 336 Micheta Town Ato Feleke Kasa 01 None 52 Male 2 337 Micheta Town W/o Worke Bellachew 01 None 36 Female 8 338 Micheta Town Ato Mume Iso 01 None 50 Male 5 339 Micheta Town Ato H/Weld Reta 01 None 50 Male 12 340 Micheta Town Ato Zenebe Lema 01 None 40 Male 13 341 Micheta Town Same Same None Same Female Same 342 Micheta Town Ato Tesfa Terefe 01 None 25 Male 3 343 Micheta Town Ato Demirew Haile 01 None 50 Male 6 344 Micheta Town Same 01 None Same Same Same 345 Micheta Town Ato Shenf Hasen 01 None 25 Male 10 346 Micheta Town W/o Getu zewde 01 None 38 Female 5 347 Micheta Town Same Same None Same Same Same 348 Micheta Town Ato Mebrate Tadese 01 None 75 Male 12 349 Micheta Town Ato Husen Mehamed 01 None 25 Male 2 350 Timuga Ato Ahmed Hametoye Haye Ameto 01 None 40 Male 4 351 Timuga Ato MohamedAliye 01 None 40 Male 7 352 Timuga Ato Mehamed Ahmed Adem 01 None 45 Male 9 353 Timuga Ato Oumer Mehamed Oumer 01 None 35 Male 13 354 Timuga Ato Ibrahim Mehamed Abdro 01 None 30 Male 5 355 Timuga Ato MehamedAwel Yesuf 01 None 25 Male 10 356 Timuga Ato Yesuf Beker 01 None 50 Male 12 357 Timuga Ato Ahmed Haji Adem 01 None 40 Male 20 358 Tlmuga Ato Wube Rima 01 None 70 Male 2 359 Tlmuga Ato adem Gula 01 None 50 Male 20 360 Timuga Ato Ahmed Abdulahi 01 None 60 Male 20 361 Timuga Ato Ahmedin Haji Ibrahim 01 None 35 Male 9 362 Timuga Ato Abdela Isa Musa 01 None 35 Male 6 363 Timuga Shek Kedir Ahmed 01 None 60 Male 11 364 Timuga Ato nlgusellma 01 None 40 Male 5 365 Timuga Ato Zeyad lryu Haji 01 None 30 Male 3 366 Timuga Ati mehamed Seid Ali 01 None 67 Male 18 367 Timuga Ato Abdurehman Ayele 01 None 40 Male 11 368 Timuga Ato Aliyu Tehib 01 None 40 Male 10 369 Timuga Ato MehamedAhmed 01 None 35 Male 8 370 Timuga Ato Adem Elias 01 None 40 Male 9 371 77muga Ato Hasen Ahmed 01 None 27 Male 3 372 Timuga Ato Aliu Mehamed 01 None 30 Male 7 373 Timuga Ato Sadik Bulto 01 None 28 Male 3 374 Timuga Ato Esmael Gir 01 None 40 Male 5 375 Timuga Ato Tajidan Adem 01 None 40 Male 7 376 Timuga Ato MehamedAbro 01 None 50 Male 4 377 Timuga Ato Ahmed Hamed 01 None 50 Male 6 378 Timuga Ato Abdela lbro 01 None 30 Male 2 379 Timuga Ato Derreje Mekonen 01 None 30 Male 3 380 Timuga Ato Zenhun Mamo 01 None 25 Male 5 381 Timuga Shek Hasen Abdela 01 None 40 Male 6 382 Timuga Ato Hasen Oumer 01 None 25 Male 3 383 Timuga Ato Mehamed Tado 01 None 45 Male 10 384 Timuga Ato Tejedi Hajl Ahmed 01 None 35 Male 6 385 Timuga Ato Abrham Jara 01 None 45 Male 12 386 Timuga Aato Jemal Ahmed 01 None 55 Male 15 387 Timuga Ato Kedir Ware 01 None 73 Male 5 388 Timuga Ato Mehamed Abdule 01 None 45 Male 6 389 Timuga Ato Ibrahim Abdurehman 01 None 38 Male 8 390 Timuga Ato Musa Mumed, 01 None 60 Male 26 391 Timuga Ato Abdurehman Hasen 01 None 70 Male 8 392 Timuga W/o Kenya Golu 01 None 25 Female 393 Timuga Ato Mehaed Oumer 01 None 35 Male 394 T7muga Ato Ase Gole 01 None 40 Male 15 395 Timuga Ato Ahmed Bedbo 01 None 60 Male 20 396 Trmuga Ato Sileshi Meketa 01 None 65 Male 6 397 T7muga Ato checheha Silesh, 01 None 23 Male 3 398 7rmuga Ato Hasen Husen 01 None 45 Male 5 399 Timuga Ato Mehamed Kelifa 01 None 33 Male 10 400 rimuga Ato Ahmed Mume Ibro 01 None 45 Male 6 401 Timuga Ato Jafar Haji 01 None 30 Male 11 402 Timuga Wlo Wagaye Tesfaye 01 None 40 Female 5 403 7imuga Same Same Same Same Same Same 404 Timuga Ato AlIye Amed, 01 None 27 Male 3 405 Timuga Ato Golo Fato 01 None 51 Male 12 406 Timuga Ato Ziad Ali 01 None 35 Male 3 407 Timuga Wlo Wesen Slleshi 01 None 26 Female 4 Monthly Ethnic Occupation Education Income gru Language Religion
______(B~irr) gru
NA None NA Oromo Oromiffa Chnstian Pensioned NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim
Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Musilm Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Fanmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Musilm Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Fanmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Fanmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Shop Keeper NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Fanmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Orthodox Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trade NA NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trade NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trade NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trade NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Fanmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Orthodox Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Orthodox Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Musilm Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromlffa Chnstian Tailor NA NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Butcher NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstan Farmer NA NA Amhara Amharic Chnstan Tella Retailer NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Farmer NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnsban NA NA NA Amhara Amharic Chnsban Farmer NA NA Amhara Amharic Chnsban Tella Retailor NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Musilm Farmer NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader NA NA Amhara Amharic Chnstlan Trade NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Trade NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Trade NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Trade NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Trade NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Trade NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Trade NA NA Oromo Oromifa Mushm Trade NA NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Same Same Same Same Same Same Trade NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Same Same Same Same Same Same Trade NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Trade NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Same Same Same Same Same Same Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Health worker NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Musi/m Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Musilm Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Musi m Fanmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Musihm Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Teacher NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Musihm Trader NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Ornomifa Mushm NA NA NA Oromo Oromifa Mushm Tailor NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Same Same Same Same Same Same Trader NA NA Oromo Oromlfa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromifa Mushm Same Same Same Same Same Same Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Mushm Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Mushm Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Musihm Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Mushm Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Same Same Same Same Same Same Same Same Same Same Same Same Trader NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Faamer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromifa Muslim Hotel Business NA 2,000 Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Tella Retailer Illiterate NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Butcher 7 300 Amhara Amharic Chnstian Tella Retailer NA 200 Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader 12 200 Oromo Oromiffa Chnstian Trader 10 200 Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim
Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Traderr NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Christian Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Tailor Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer llhIterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Chnstian Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Chnstian Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Tailor Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Christian Tallor Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Carpentor Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Amhara Amharic Christian Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Trader NA NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Amhara Amharic Chnstian Trader NA NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Same Same Same Same Same Same Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Pensioned NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Christian Farmer Illiterate NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Farmer lliterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Same Same Same Same Same Same Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Fanmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Musilm Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Iiiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Fanmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim
Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Labourer 10 200 Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Pensioned Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Chnstian Pensioned Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Guard Illiterate 300 Oromo Oromiffa Chnstian Labourer Illiterate NA Amhara Amharic Christian Farmer Illiterate 20 Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Cashier NA 1,400 Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Christian Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Christian Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Mushm Same Same Same Same Same Same Farmer NA NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Same Same Same Same Same Same Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Same Same Same Same Same Same Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Chnstian Pensioned NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Trader NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Civil Servant NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Pensioned NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Iliterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Same Same Same Same Same Same Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Musim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Itliterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Same Same Same Same Same Same coffe Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Pensioned NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Coffe Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Teacher NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Pensioned NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Somalia SomaligNA Muslim
Trader NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian House Wife NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim pensioned NA NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Teacher 7 NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim House Wife 8 NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Weaver Illiterate NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Tella Retaller Illiterate NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Trader Illiterate NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Tella Retailer 9 NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Farmer NA NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader NA NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian teacher Certificate NA Oromo Oromiffa Chnstian Same Same Same Same Same Same teacher Certificate NA Amhara Amharic Chnstian Farmer 5 NA Amhara Amharic Chnstian Farmer Illiterate NA Amhara Amharic Chnstian Trader 5 NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim House Wife 6 NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian same same same same same same pensioned Illiterate NA Amhara Amhanc Christian student 8 NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Ililterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer liliterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Chnstian Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Pensioned Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader 4 NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Labourer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Fanner Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader 7 NA Amhara Amhanc Christian Trader Illiterate NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Butcher Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Butcher Illiterate NA Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Butcher Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer llilterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Ormmlffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Fanmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer 4 100 Oromo Oromlffa Muslim Trader 9 250 Oromo Oromlffa Musilm tea room 7 150 Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Same Same Same Same Same Same Trader 2 NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Farmer Illiterate NA Oromo Oromiffa Muslim Trader Illiterate NA Amhara Amhanc Chnstian Annex Four Resettlement Option for PAPS Type of Resettlement No Town/PA Name of the Household Head Ownership Self Settlement Assisted Resettlement Section 1 - Dera Chole 1 Chole Town Ato GashawAlemu Pnvate Self Settlement 2 Dera Town Ato Nuru Mohamed Pnvate Self Settlement 3 Dera Town Polhce Station Woreda Self Settlement 4 Koshim PA Ato Kemal haji Husmu Pnvate Self Settlement 5 Koshim PA Ato Mama Haji Husmo Private Self Settlement 6 Koshim PA Haji Jund, Tufa Private Self Settlement 7 Koshim PA Atojeld, Alyou Pnvate Self Settlement 8 Koshim PA Ato Aman Kedir Pnvate Self Settlement 9 Koshim PA Ato Jemal Sufi Pnvate Self Settlement 10 Koshim PA Ato Temam Nuri Pnvate Self Settlement 11 Koshim PA Ato Demsew Denb Pnvate Self Settlement 12 Koshim PA Ato Denb G/Yes Pnvate Assisted Resettlement 13 Koshim PA Ato Kemal Kedir Pnvate Self Settlement 14 Koshim PA Ato Gebe Taha Pnvate Self Settlement 15 Koshim PA Ato Abubeker Sheh Mehamed Pnvate Self Settlement 16 Koshim PA Ato Hadi Shuba Pnvate Self Settlement 17 Koshim PA Ato Ousla Amamo Alyu Pnvate Self Settlement 18 Koshim PA Ato Telil Terko Pnvate Self Settlement 19 Koshim PA Ato Damtew Asbo Pnvate Self Settlement 20 Koshim PA Haji Tirtili Pnvate Self Settlement 21 Koshim PA Ato Abdi Telbo Pnvate Self Settlement 22 Koshim PA Ato Abdrehman Hajl Haji Pnvate Self Settlement 23 Koshim PA Ato Shikule Addem Private Self Settlement 24 Koshim PA Shek Hasen Shek Adem Private Self Settlement 25 Koshim PA Shek Hasen Shek Adem Private Self Settlement 26 Koshim PA Ato Husen Edns Private Self Settlement 27 Koshim PA Ato Junedl Kebir Tahir Pnvate Self Settlement 28 Koshim PA Ato Mehamed Haji Kasimk Pnvate Self Settlement 29 Koshim PA Ato Abulkenm Hamdi Private Self Settlement 30 Koshim PA Ato Kemal Telelo Private Self Settlement 31 Koshim PA Ato Arba Kedir Pnvate Self Settlement 32 Koshim PA Ato Arba Kedir Pnvate Self Settlement 33 Koshim PA Ato Arba Kedir Pnvate Self Settlement 34 Koshim PA Ato Seid Eko Pnvate Self Settlement 35 Koshim PA Shek Kedir Shek Hasen Pnvate Self Settlement 36 Koshim PA Ato Abre Aman Pnvate Self Settlement 37 Koshim PA Ato Abdurhaman Haji Adem Pnvate Self Settlement 38 Koshim PA Ato Mama Haji Husen Pnvate Self Settlement 39 Koshim PA Ato Abdela Hasen Private Self Settlement 40 Koshim PA Ato Musa Haji Husen Pnvate Self Settlement 41 Koshim PA Ato Beyn Shek Amdeha Private Self Settlement 42 Koshim PA Ato Haji Sal, Gobena Say Private Self Settlement 43 Koshim PA Ato Redewan Seid Abyu Pnvate Self Settlement 44 Koshim PA Ato Safi Hajilkem Denbeba Pnvate Self Settlement 45 Koshim PA Ato Lema Dejene Pnvate Self Settlement 46 Koshim PA Ato Daimu Haji Haji Pnvate Self Settlement 47 Koshim PA Ato Yemen Abdul Semed Pnvate Self Settlement 48 Koshim PA Ato Teshome Dendene Pnvate Self Settlement 49 Koshim PA Ato Ismael Mehamed Pnvate Self Settlement 50 Koshim PA Ato Haji Feko Chef Private Self Settlement
51 Koshim PA Denebe Guye School Private _Assisted Resettlement 52 Koshim PA Ato Saliya Kedir Weko Private Self Settlement I 53 Koshim PA Ato Se,fu Jima Hajl Husen Pnvate Self Settlement 54 Moye Wlo Ehite Blff Pnvate Self Settlement 55 Moye Ato Tadese Beleke Private Self Settlement 56 Moye Ato Desalegne Shiferaw Pnvate Self Settlement 57 Moye Ato Blrhane Bantyiwalu Private Self Settlement 58 Moye Ato Niguse Eshete Private Self Settlement 59 Moye W/o Birke Teshome Pnvate Self Settlement 60 Moye Ato Asefa Kebede Pnvate Self Settlement 61 Moye Ato Takele Haile Mot, Pnvate Self Settlement 62 Moye Ato Abera Kidane Pnvate Self Settlement 63 Moye W/o Nigst, Eshete Pnvate Self Settlement 64 Moye Ato Hajl Abdo Amda Bekule Pnvate Self Settlement 65 Moye Ato Eshete Girma Zewde Pnvate Self Settlement 66 Moye Ato Kagnew Amare M,tke Pnvate Self Settlement 67 Moye w/o Feleku Birhane Zergaw Pnvate Self Settlement 68 Moye Ato B,rkneh Tegegne Private Self Settlement 69 Negele Ato Shikuri Adem Private Self Settlement 70 Negele Ato Haji Jemal Haji Husen Private Self Settlement 71 Negele Haji Mehamed Abir Ahmed Pnvate Self Settlement 72 Negele Ato GenaHaj] Pnvate Self Settlement 73 Negele Ato Ahmed Alyu Pnvate Self Settlement 74 Negele Ato Tura Haji Mehamed Pnvate Self Settlement 75 Negele Ato Muzein Habir Husen Pnvate Self Settlement 76 Negete wlo Kasech Adere Pnvate Self Settlement 77 Nege/e Same Pnvate Same 78 Negele Ato Nuru Shek Ahmed Pnvate Self Settlement 79 Negete Same Pnvate Same 80 Negele Ato mehamed Hasen Pnvate Same 81 Negele Ato Hasen Gobena Pnvate Self Settlement 82 Negele Same Pnvate Same 83 Negele Ato Kemal Amda golo Pnvate Self Settlement 84 Negele Ato Haji Ture Pnvate Self Settlement 85 Negele Ato Fekru Haji Kul, Adem Pnvate Self Settlement 86 Negele Ato Jeyligne Adem Kebu Pnvate Self Settlement 87 Negele Ato Junedin Say Sheku Pnvate Self Settlement 88 Negele Ato Husen Roba Pnvate Self Settlement 89 Negele Ato Abdul Kadir Tekako Pnvate Self Settlement 90 Negele Ato Allye Haji Husen Pnvate Self Settlement 91 Negele Ato AbdurAman Haji Mehamed Pnvate Self Settlement 92 Negele Ato Kasim Tesema Hute Pnvate Self Settlement 93 Negele Ato Hsji Hamda Tekeko Pnvate Self Settlement 94 Negele Ato Husen Haji Amano Pnvate Self Settlement 95 Negele Ato Ahmed Hail Isman Kobelo Pnvate Self Settlement 96 Negele Ato Mehamed Haji Gena Tufa Pnvate Self Settlement 97 Negele Ato Husen Shekena Wako Pnvate Self Settlement 98 Negele Ato Mehamed Ahmed Elo Pnvate Self Settlement 99 Negele Ato Haji Aman Wako Pnvate Self Settlement 100 Negele Ato Temam Mehamed Jara Pnvate Self Settlement 101 Negele Same Private Same 102 Negele Sheku/i Adem Pnvate Self Settlement 103 Negele Shek Asen Shek Adem Private Self Settlement 104 Negele Same Pnvate Same 105 Negele Ato Husen Endris Pnvate Self Settlement 106 Negele Ato Jundi Kebir Tahir Pnvate Self Settlement 107 Negele Ato Mehamed Haji Kasim Private Self Settlement 108 Negele Ato Abdul kenm Hamda Private Self Settlement 109 Negele Ato Kemal Telila Pnvate Self Settlement 110 Negele Ato Areba Kedir Private Self Settlement 111 Negele Same Pnvate Same 112 Negele Same Private Same 113 Negele Ato Seid Eko Pnvate Self Settlement 114 Negele Shek Kedir Shek Asen Pnvate Self Settlement 115 Negele Ato Abre Aman Pnvate Self Settlement 116 Negele Ato Abdurahman Haji adem Pnvate Self Settlement 117 Negele Ato Mama Haji Husen Pnvate Self Settlement 118 Negele Ato Abdela Hasen Private Self Settlement 119 Negele Ato Musa Haji Husen Private Self Settlement 120 Negele Ato Beyan Shek Abdurahman Pnvate Self Settlement 121 Sire Town Ato Ousman Amino Kebele Assisted Resettlement 122 Sire Town W/o Birtukan Mekonen Desta Pnvate Self Settlement 123 Sire Town Ato Belhu Abebe Kebele Assisted Resettlement 124 Sire Town W/o Bekelech Zerfu Kebele Assisted Resettlement 125 Sire Town Ato Akl,lu Dejene Kebele Assisted Resettlement 126 Sire Town Ato Zenebe Ayele Kebele Assisted Resettlement 127 Sire Town W/o Menma Gendo Tona & her Bro Kebele Assisted Resettlement Section 2- Chole Gofokcha 128 Derartu PA Ato Mehamed Husen Pnvate Self Sefflement 129 Derartu PA Ato Kedi Jima Private Self Settlement 130 Derartu PA Ato Nlguse Mulugeta Private Self Settlement 131 Derartu PA Ato Jemal Mehamed Private Self Settlement 132 Derartu PA Ato Krmal Mehamed Pnvate Self Settlement 133 Derartu PA Ato Julo Iroba Private Self Settlement 134 Derartu PA Ato Abdulkedir Kene Private Self Settlement 135 Derartu PA Ato Abraham Bedaso Pnvate Self Settlement 136 Derartu PA Ato Aman Ambo Pnvate Self Settlement 137 Derartu PA Ato Ture Guder Pnvate Self Settlement 138 Derartu PA W/o Genu Abdi Pnvate Self Settlement 139 Derartu PA Ato Kedero Mehamed Private Self Settlement 140 Derartu PA Hapi Kemal Mehamed Private Self Settlement 141 Derartu PA Ato Mukenm abdo Private Self Settlement 142 Derartu PA Ato Aman Ahmed Private Self Settlement 143 Derartu PA Ato Kasim Gobena Pnvate Self Settlement 144 Derartu PA W/o Alima Mehamed Pnvate Self Settlement 145 Derartu PA Wlo Zemzem Horo Pnvate Self Settlement 146 Derartu PA W/o Widnesh Private Self Settlement 147 Magna Hadere Ato Adamu Belete Private Self Settlement 148 Magna Hadere Kes Gulma w/Yohannis Pnvate Self Settlement 149 Magna Hadere Shek Jemal Abdi Pnvate Self Settlement 150 Magna Hadere Ato OumerAman Pnvate Self Settlement 151 Magna Hadere Ato Jemal Mume Pnvate Self Settlement 152 Magna Hadere Ato Ebu Geda Pnvate Self Settlement 153 Magna Hadere Ato Sulti Al Pnvate Self Settlement 154 Magna Hadere Ato Mehamed Adem Pnvate Self Settlement 155 Magna Hadere - Ato Ahmed Tufa Pnvate Self Settlement 156 Magna Hadere Ato Dino Mehamed Private Self Settlement 157 Haro PA Ato Adem Jibnl Pnvate Self Settlement 158 Haro PA Ato Abdul Kerim Muktar Pnvate Self Settlement 159 Haro PA Ato Hasen Aliye Pnvate Self Settlement 160 Haro PA Ato Abdulahi Mehamed Private Self Settlement 161 Hare PA Ato Kedir Haji Private Self Settlement 162 Haro PA Ato Dinku Legese Pnvate Self Settlement 163 Haro PA Shek Jemal Ahmed Private Self Settlement 164 Haro PA Ato Nibras Abdella Private Self Settlement 165 Haro PA Ato Husen Kedir Private Self Settlement 166 Hare PA Ato Abera Guhilat Pnvate Self Settlement 167 Haro PA Ato Tilahun Wakene Pnvate Self Settlement 168 Haro PA Ato JuharAhmed Pnvate Self Settlement 169 Haro PA Ato Yusuf Adem Pnvate Self Settlement 170 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Husen Pnvate Self Settlement 171 Haro PA Ato Husen amaro Pnvate Self Settlement 172 Harm PA Ato Nasir Kasim Pnvate Self Settlement 173 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Amin Private Self Settlement 174 Harm PA Ato Lema Worku Private Self Settlement 175 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Kemal Pnvate Self Settlement 176 Haro PA Ato Abdul feta Haji Private Self Settlement 177 Haro PA Ato Zubeda Haji Pnvate Self Settlement 178 Haro PA Ato Mehamed AlIyu Pnvate Self Settlement 179 Haro PA Ato Shimelsh Ketema Pnvate Self Settlement 180 Haro PA Ato Kediro Mehamed Pnvate Self Settlement 181 Haro PA Ato Kemer Kemal Pnvate Self Settlement 182 Haro PA Ato Adem Yesuf Pnvate Self Settlement 183 Haro PA Ato Abdur Aman Private Self Settlement 184 Haro PA Ato Ibrahim Aman Pnvate Self Settlement 185 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Hasn Pnvate Self Settlement 186 Harm PA Ato Ismael Oumer Pnvate Self Settlement 187 Haro PA Ato Aliyu Mehamed Private Self Settlement 188 Haro PA Ato Taha Ab, Basha Private Self Settlement 189 Haro PA Ato Kebet, Gulilat Private Self Settlement 190 Haro PA Ato Amanu Bambo Private Self Settlement 191 Hamo PA Ato Nftsu Melese Mamo Private Self Settlement 192 Hamo PA Ato Mehamed Kebede Pnvate Self Settlement 193 Haro PA Ato Abdi Mehamed Pnvate Self Settlement 194 Haro PA Ato Temem Oumer Pnvate Self Settlement 195 Haro PA Ato Regasa Leta Private Self Settlement 196 Haro PA At oShimelis Asemu Pnvate Self Settlement 197 Haro PA AtoMehamed AlIyu Private Self Settlement 198 Haro PA W/o Dasash Admas Pnvate Self Settlement 199 Haro PA Ato Ahmed Mume Aby Pnvate Self Settlement 200 Haro PA Same Pnvate Self Settlement 201 Haro PA Ato Girsha Kasim Pnvate Self Settlement 202 Haro PA Ato Kebede HALILE Pnvate Self Settlement 203 Haro PA Wo Rase Abebe Pnvate Seff Settlement 204 Legebuna PA Ato Legese Debele Pnvate Self Settlement 205 Legebuna PA Ato Jemal Mehamed Allye Private Self Settlement 206 Legebuna PA Ato Jemal Adem Kun Private Self Settlement 207 Legebuna PA Ato Melese Beyene Welde Pnvate Self Settlement 208 Legebuna PA Ato Mehamed Kemal Amedo Pnvate Self Sefflement 209 Legebuna PA Same Pnvate Self Settlement 210 Legebuna PA Ato Mehamed NurAhmed Pnvate Self Settlement 211 Legebuna PA Ato S,raj Husen bedaso Private Self Settlement 212 Legebuna PA Ato Suran Hasinboru Private Self Settlement 213 Legebuna PA Ato J,bnl Kelil Adem Pnvate Self Settlement 214 Legebuna PA Ato Abdella Ousman Abdi Pnvate Self Settlement 215 Legebuna PA Ato Mehamed Husen Shek Adem Pnvate Self Settlement 216 Wendo Gasha PA Ato KedIrAhmed Private Self Settlement 217 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Abdul Kadir Ousman Pnvate Self Settlement 218 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Husen Amdajilo Pnvate Self Settlement 219 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Mehamed Amda Pnvate Self Settlement 220 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Tilma Bedaso Pnvate Self Settlement 221 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kad0 Bedao Chaco Pnvate Self Settlement 222 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Bulo Kebir Sheka Pnvate Self Settlement 223 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Ahmed Bedaso Chaco Pnvate Self Settlement 224 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Dbele Shegu Jima Private Self Settlement 225 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Abit, Debele Private Self Settlement 226 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kasim Gobe Private Self Settlement 227 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Mussa Bornu Tune Private Self Settlement 228 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Aliye Amda Jillo Pnvate Self Settlement 229 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Mustofa Kebir Pnvate Self Settlement 230 Wendo Gasha PA Shek Esmael Chole Pnvate Self Settlement 231 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kedir Bati Roba Private Self Settlement 232 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Gena Tolosa Private Self Settlement 233 Wendo Gasha PA Ato KedirAhmed Private Self Settlement 234 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Msbaou Shek Esmael Pnvate Self Settlement
Section 3 - Gololcha Mechara 235 Debre Selam W/o Zehara Nura Pnvate Self Settlement 236 Debre Selam Wlo Yesunesh H/Manam Pnvate Self Settlement 237 Debre Selam Wlo Sofia Abdi Pnvate Self Settlement 238 Debre Selam WI o Abiba Dasa Pnvate Self Settlement 239 Debre Selam Wlo Zeinu Dade Pnvate Self Settlement 240 Debre Se/am Ato Ha,lye Feysa Pnvate Self Settlement 241 Debre Se/am Ato Kebede Abera Pnvate Self Settlement 242 Debre Selam Ato Oumer Hamda Pnvate Self Settlement 243 Debre Selam Ato Husen Tulu Pnvate Self Settlement 244 Debre Selam Ato Mama Abdela Pnvate Self Settlement 245 Debre Selam Ato Abdo Bedaso Pnvate Self Settlement 246 Kortu PA W/o Tenagne G/M,chael Workye Pnvate Self Settlement 247 Kortu PA Ato Eshetu Getahun Abebe Private Self Settlement 248 Kortu PA Ato Husen Ouso Beker Pnvate Self Settlement 249 Kortu PA Ato Musa Ouso Oda Pnvate Self Settlement 250 Kortu PA Same Private Self Settlement 251 Kortu PA Ato Desaalegne Berhanu Haile Private Self Settlement 252 Kortu PA Same Private Self Settlement 253 Kortu PA Ato Juhar Beker Ahmed Pnvate Self Settlement 254 Kortu PA Same Private Self Settlement 255 Kottu PA Ato Kelil Pnvate Self Settlement 256 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed Haji Ibrahim Pnvate Self Settlement 257 Kortu PA Wlo SeadaAli Pnvate Self Settlement 258 Kortu PA Ato Tefera Worku Pnvate Self Settlement 259 Kortu PA W/o Debre G/Maanam Private Self Settlement 260 Kortu PA Wlo Zemzem Haji Pnvate Self Settlement 261 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed Zeynu Kebele Assisted Resettlement 262 Kortu PA Wlo Tirunesh Dubale Kebele Assisted Resettlement 263 Kortu PA Wlo Yesunesh G/Hana Kebele Assisted Resettlement 264 Kortu PA Ato Siraj Aliye Abdi Private Self Settlement 265 Kortu PA Ato Kiflu WiManam Pnvate Self Settlement 266 Kortu PA Ato Kamil Sedik Wedai Pnvate Self Settlement 267 Kortu PA Ato Harun Husen Oumer Pnvate Self Settlement 268 Kortu PA Ato Mohamed Haron Haji Private Self Settlement 269 Kortu PA Ato Yasi Yusuf Mehamed Pnvate Self Settlement 270 Kortu PA Ato Kedir Irere Beyoti Private Self Settlement 271 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed Ibrahim Abdela Private Self Settlement 272 Kortu PA Ato Sude Dadi Pnvate Self Settlement 273 Kortu PA Ato Taha Kasim Omer Pnvate Self Settlement 274 Kortu PA Ato Muktar Jima Pnvate Self Settlement 275 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Amere Pnvate Self Settlement 276 Kortu PA Same Private Self Settlement 277 Kortu PA Shek Oumer Amye Pnvate Self Settlement 278 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed Bedaso Private Self Settlement 279 Kortu PA Ato Ousman Hasen Pnvate Self Settlement 280 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Yesuf Private Self Settlement 281 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Ahmedd Private Self Settlement 282 Kortu PA Ato Abdul ManOusman Pnvate Self Settlement 283 Kortu PA Ato Adem Musa Pnvate Self Settlement 284 Kortu PA Ato Isa Adem Private Self Settlement 285 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Mume Private Self Settlement 286 Mechara Atoahmed Omda Ako Kebele Assisted Resettlement 287 Mechara Ato Mejina Abdulahl Kebele Assisted Resettlement 288 Mechara Shek Taha Kebele Assisted Resettlement 289 Mechara Ato Getachew Manekul Kebele Assisted Resettlement 290 Mechara Ato Aby Ahmed Private Self Settlement 291 Mechara Ato oxede Pnvate Self Settlement 292 Mechara Same Pnvate Self Settlement 293 Mechara Ato Abdulkadie Yuye Kebele Assisted Resettlement 294 Mechara Ato Sanm Abrha Private Self Settlement 295 Mechara Ato Husen AbiJelal Kebele Assisted Resettlement 296 Mechara Ato Hamid Hasen Kebele Assisted Resettlement 297 Mechara Ato Hamed siraj Kebele Assisted Resettlement 298 Mechara Ato Yusuf Shek Bereka Kebele Assisted Resettlement 299 Mechara Ato Hamed Hasen Kebele Assisted Resettlement 300 Mechara Ato Lule Behabtu Kebele Assisted Resettlement 301 Mechara Ato Sanm Haji Pnvate Self Settlement 302 Mechara Ato Mehamed Abdulahi Pnvate Self Settlement 303 Mechara Ato Mehamed Sheka Adem Pnvate Self Settlement 304 Mechara WIo Sofia Hasen Pnvate Self Settlement 305 Mechara W/o Amina Hasen Kebele Assisted Resettlement 306 Mechara Ato abrham Sheka Kebele Assisted Resettlement 307 Mechara Wlo Alima Issa Kebele Assisted Resettlement 308 Mechara Ato Mehamed Alh Pnvate Self Settlement 309 Mechara Ato Sani Haji Mehamed Kebele Assisted Resettlement 310 Mechara Ato Ahmed Mehamed Kebele Assisted Resettlement 311 Mechara Ato Muluka Kasim Kebele Assisted Resettlement 312 Mechara Sek Fans Buser Kebele Assisted Resettlement 313 Mechara Ato Tofik Husen Kebele Assisted Resettlement 314 Mechara Ato nunu Ahmed Kebele Assisted Resettlement 315 Mechara Wlo Yewdar Begashaw Kebele Assisted Resettlement 316 Mechara Ato Jemal Mehamed Kebele Assisted Resettlement 317 Mechara Ato Abdurehman Ousamn Kebele Assisted Resettlement 318 Micheta Haji Ahmed Husen Private Assisted Resettlement 319 Micheta W/o Kedire Shek Ahmed kebele Assisted Resettlement 320 Micheta Same kebele Assisted Resettlement 321 Micheta Ato Mehamed Abdulahl Oxede Pnvate Self Settlement 322 Micheta Coffee Bord(Store) Govemment Self Settlement 323 Micheta W/o Almaz Desta Pnvate Self Settlement 324 Micheta Ato Mehamed Shek Abdurehim kebele Assisted Resettlement 325 Micheta W/o Shitu Abebe Private Self Settlement 326 Micheta Ato Jemal Ahmed Private Self Settlement 327 Mlicheta Ato Aliu Abdo Private Self Settlement 328 Micheta Ato Negede Mekonen Pnvate Self Settlement 329 Micheta wlo Zehara Kasim Private Self Settlement 330 Micheta Ato Tirnuneh Neway Pnvate Self Settlement 331 Micheta Shek Abdelaadem Private Self Settlement 332 Micheta ato Husen Mume Private Self Settlement 333 Micheta Wlo Aster H/Weld Private Self Settlement 334 Micheta Ato Kebede Demise Private Self Settlement 335 Micheta w/o Zewde Demise Pnvate Self Settlement 336 Micheta Ato Feleke Kasa kebele Assisted Resettlement 337 Micheta Wlo Worke Bellachew kebele Assisted Resettlement 338 Micheta Ato Mume Iso Pnvate Self Settlement 339 Micheta Ato H/Weld Reta Private Self Settlement 340 Micheta Ato Zenebe Lema kebele Self Settlement 341 Micheta Same Private Self Settlement 342 Micheta Ato Tesfa Terefe kebele Assisted Resettlement 343 Micheta Ato Demirew Haile kebele Assisted Resettlement 344 Micheta Same kebele Assisted Resettlement 345 Mlcheta Ato Shenf Hasen kebele Assisted Resettlement 346 Micheta W/o Getu zewde Pnvate Self Settlement 347 Micheta Same Pnvate Self Settlement 348 Micheta Ato Mebrate Tadese Pnvate Self Settlement 349 Micheta Ato Husen Mehamed Pnvate Self Settlement 350 Timuga Ato Ahmed Hametoye Haye Ameto Pnvate Self Settlement 351 Timuga Ato Mohamed Aliye Pnvate Self Settlement 352 Timuga Ato Mehamed Ahmed Adem Pnvate Self Settlement 353 Timuga Ato Oumer Mehamed Oumer Pnvate Self Settlement 354 Timuga Ato Ibrahim Mehamed Abdro Pnvate Self Settlement 355 Timuga Ato Mehamed Awel Yesuf Pnvate Self Settlement 356 Timuga Ato Yesuf Beker Pnvate Self Settlement 357 Timuga Ato Ahmed Hajp Adem Pnvate Self Settlement 358 Timuga Ato Wube Rima Pnvate Self Settlement 359 Timuga Ato adem Gula Private Self Settlement 360 Timuga Ato Ahmed Abdulahi Private Self Settlement 361 Timuga Ato Ahmedmn Haji Ibrahim Private Self Settlement 362 Timuga Ato Abdela Isa Musa Pnvate Self Settlement 363 Timuga Shek Kedir Ahmed Pnvate Self Settlement 364 Timuga Ato nlgusellma Pnvate Self Settlement 365 Timuga Ato Zeyad Iryu Hajl Pnvate Self Settlement 366 Timuga AtU mehamed Seid Ali Pnvate Self Settlement 367 Timuga Ato Abdurehman Ayele Pnvate Self Settlement 368 Timuga Ato Alhyu Tehib Pnvate Self Settlement 369 Timuga Ato Mehamed Ahmed Pnvate Self Settlement 370 Timuga Ato Adem Elias Pnvate Self Settlement 371 Timuga Ato Hasen Ahmed Pnvate Self Settlement 372 Timuga Ato AlIu Mehamed Pnvate Self Settlement 373 Timuga Ato Sadik Bulto Pnvate Self Settlement 374 Timuga Ato Esmael Gir Pnvate Self Settlement 375 Timuga Ato Tajidan Adem Pnvate Self Settlement 376 Timuga Ato Mehamed Abro Pnvate Self Settlement 377 Timuga Ato Ahmed Hamed Pnvate Self Settlement 378 Timuga Ato Abdela Ibro Pnvate Self Settlement 379 Timuga Ato Derreje Mekonen Pnvate Self Settlement 380 Timuga Ato Zenhun Mamo Pnvate Self Settlement 381 Timuga Shek Hasen Abdela Pnvate Self Settlement 382 Timuga Ato Hasen Oumer Private Self Settlement 383 Timuga Ato Mehamed Tado Pnvate Self Settlement 384 Timuga Ato Tejed, Haji Ahmed Private Self Settlement 385 Timuga Ato Abrham Jara Private Self Settlement 386 Timuga Aato Jemal Ahmed Private Self Settlement 387 Timuga Ato Kedir Ware Private Self Settlement 388 Timuga Ato Mehamed Abdule Private Self Settlement 389 Timuga Ato Ibrahim Abdurehman Private Self Settlement 390 Tlmuga Ato Musa Mumedi Private Self Settlement 391 Timuga Ato Abdurehman Hasen Private Self Settlement 392 Timuga Wlo Kenya Golu Pnvate Self Settlement 393 Timuga Ato Mehaed Oumer Pnvate Self Settlement 394 Timuga Ato Ase Gole Private Self Settlement 395 Timuga Ato Ahmed Bedbo Pnvate Self Settlement 396 Timuga Ato Silesh, Meketa Private Self Settlement 397 Timuga Ato checheha Silesh, Private Self Settlement 398 Timuga Ato Hasen Husen Pnvate Self Settlement 399 Timuga Ato Mehamed Kelifa Pnvate Self Settlement 400 Timuga Ato Ahmed Mume Ibro Pnvate Self Settlement 401 Timuga Ato Jafar Haji Pnvate Self Settlement 402 Timuga Wlo Wagaye Tesfaye Pnvate Self Settlement 403 Tlmuga Same Pnvate Self Settlement 404 Timuga Ato Aliye Amedi Pnvate Self Settlement 405 Timuga Ato Golo Fato Pnvate Self Settlement 406 Timuga Ato Zlad Alh Pnvate Self Settlement 407 Timuga Wlo Wesen Sileshi Private Self Settlement Annex Five - Impact Category
No Town/PA Household Head Kebele Purpose of the House Total Compound Area (m2)
Chole Gololcha Section
_ Derartu PA Ato Mehamed Husen Derartu shop 250 2 Derartu PA Ato Kedi Jima Derartu shop 250 3 Derartu PA Ato Niguse Mulugeta Derartu Residence 250 4 Derartu PA Ato Jemal Mehamed Derartu Residence 250 5 Derartu PA Ato Krmal Mehamed Derartu Residence 250 6 Derartu PA Ato Julo Iroba Derartu Residence 250 7 Derartu PA Ato Abdulkedir Kene Derartu Residence 250 8 Derartu PA Ato Abraham Bedaso Derartu Residence 250 9 Derartu PA Ato Aman Ambo Derartu Residence 250 10 Derartu PA Ato Ture Guder Derartu Mill 250 11 Derartu PA Wlo Genu Abdi Derartu Residence 250 12 Derartu PA Ato Kedero Mehamed Derartu Residence 250 13 Derartu PA Haji Kemal Mehamed Derartu Residence 750 14 Derartu PA Ato Mukenm abdo Derartu Residence 250 15 Derartu PA Ato Aman Ahmed Derartu Residence 250 16 Derartu PA Ato Kasim Gobena Derartu Residence 250 17 Derartu PA W/o Alima Mehamed Derartu Residence 250 18 Derartu PA W/o Zemzem Horo Derartu Residence 250 19 Derartu PA W/o Widnesh Derartu Residence 250 20 Magna Hadere Ato Adamu Belete Hadere Residence 1000 21 Magna Hadere Kes Gulma w/Yohannis Hadere Mi// 1000 22 Magna Hadere Shek Jemal Abdi Hadere Residence 1000 23 Magna Hadere Ato OumerAman Hadere Residence 1000 24 Magna Hadere Ato Jemal Mume Hadere Residence 1000 25 Magna Hadere Ato Ebu Geda Hadere Residence 1000 26 Magna Hadere Ato Sultl A/i Hadere Residence 1000 27 Magna Hadere Ato Mehamed Adem Hadere Residence 1000 28 Magna Hadere Ato Ahmed Tufa Hadere Residence 1000 29 Magna Hadere Ato Dmo Mehamed Hadere Residence 1000 30 Haro PA Ato Adem Jibnl Haro Residence 1000 31 Haro PA Ato Abdul Kenm Muktar Haro Residence 1000 32 Haro PA Ato Hasen Aliye Haro Residence 1000 33 Haro PA Ato Abdulahi Mehamed Haro Residence 1000 34 Haro PA Ato Kedir Haji Haro Residence 1000 35 Haro PA Ato Dinku Legese Haro Residence 1000 36 Haro PA Shek Jemal Ahmed Haro Residence 1000 37 Haro PA Ato Nibras Abdella Haro Residence 1000 38 Haro PA Ato Husen Kedir Haro Residence 1000 39 Haro PA Ato Abera Gulilat Haro Residence 1000 40 Haro PA Ato Tilahun Wakene Haro Residence 1000 41 Haro PA Ato Juhar Ahmed Haro Residence 1000 42 Haro PA Aao YusufAdem Haro Residence 1000 43 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Husen Haro Residence 1000 44 Haro PA Ato Husen amaro Haro Residence 1000 45 Haro PA Ato Nasir Kasim Haro Residence 1000 46 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Amin Haro Residence 1000 47 Haro PA Ato Lema Worku Haro Residence 1000 48 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Kemal Haro Residence 1000 49 Haro PA Ato Abdul feta Haji Haro Residence 1000 50 Haro PA Ato Zubeda Haji Haro Residence 1000 51 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Aliyu Haro Residence 1000 52 Haro PA Ato Shimelsh Ketema Haro Residence 1000 53 Haro PA Ato Kediro Mehamed Haro Residence 1000 54 Haro PA Ato Kemer Kemal Haro Residence 1000 55 Haro PA Ato Adem Yesuf Haro Residence 1000 56 Haro PA Ato Abdur Aman Haro Residence 1000 57 Haro PA Ato Ibrahim Aman Haro Residence 1000 58 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Hasn Haro Residence 1000 59 Haro PA Ato Ismael Oumer Haro Residence 1000 60 Haro PA Ato Aliyu Mehamed Jinga Dibu Residence 1000 61 Haro PA Ato Taha Abi Basha Jinga Dibu Residence 1000 62 Haro PA Ato Kebeth Gulilat Haro Shop 1000 63 Haro PA Ato Amanu Bambo Haro Shop 1000 64 Haro PA Ato Nitsu Melese Mamo Haro Shop 1000 65 Haro PA Ato Mehamed Kebede Haro Restaurant 1000 66 Haro PA Ato Abdi Mehamed Haro Restaurant 1000 67 Haro PA Ato Temem Oumer Haro Shop 1000 68 Haro PA Ato Regasa Leta Haro Restaurant 1000 69 Haro PA At oShimehs Asemu Haro Residence 1000 70 Haro PA AtoMehamed Aliyu Haro Clinic 1000 71 Haro PA W/o Dasash Admas Haro Restaurant 1000 72 Haro PA Ato Ahmed Mume Aby Haro Residence 1000 73 Same Same Same Tea Room 1000 74 Haro PA Ato Glrsha Kasim Haro Tea Room 1000 75 Haro PA Ato Kebede HALILE Haro Residence 1000 76 Haro PA Wo Rase Abebe Haro Residence 1000 77 Legebuna PA Ato Legese Debele Legebuna Residence 1000 78 Legebuna PA Ato Jemal Mehamed Aliye Legebuna Residence 1000 79 Legebuna PA Ato Jemal Adem Kun Legebuna Residence 1000 80 Legebuna PA Ato Melese Beyene Welde Legebuna Residence 1000 81 Legebuna PA Ato Mehamed Kemal Amedo Legebuna Residence 1000 82 Same Same Same Residence 1000 83 Legebuna PA Ato Mehamed NurAhmed Legebuna Residence 1000 84 Legebuna PA Ato Siraj Husen bedaso Legebuna Residence 1000 85 Legebuna PA Ato Suran Hasinbowu Legebuna Residence 1000 86 Legebuna PA Ato Jibnl Kelil Adem Legebuna Residence 1000 87 Legebuna PA Ato Abdella Ousman Abdi Legebuna Residence 1000 88 Legebuna PA Ato Mehamed Husen Shek Adem Legebuna Residence 1000 89 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kedir Ahmed Yae Gugu Residence 1000 90 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Abdul Kadir Ousman Yae Gugu Residence 1000 91 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Husen Amda]ilo Yae Gugu Residence 1000 92 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Mehamed Amda Yae Gugu Residence 1000 93 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Tilma Bedaso Yae Gugu Residence 1000 94 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kadi Bedao Chaco Yae Gugu Residence 1000 95 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Bulo Kebir Sheka Yae Gugu Residence 1000 96 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Ahmed Bedaso Chaco Yae Gugu Residence 1000 97 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Dbele Shegu Jima Yae Gugu Residence 1000 98 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Abiti Debele Yae Gugu Residence 1000 99 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kasim Gobe Yae Gugu Residence 1000 100 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Mussa Boru Tune Yae Gugu Residence 1000 101 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Aliye Amda Jillo Yae Gugu Residence 1000 102 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Mustofa Kebir Yae Gugu Residence 1000 103 Wendo Gasha PA Shek Esmael Chole Yae Gugu Residence 1000 104 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kedir Bati Roba Yae Gugu Residence 1000 105 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Gena Tolosa Yae Gugu Residence 1000 106 Wendo Gasha PA Ato KedirAhmed Yae Gugu Residence 1000 107 Wendo Gasha PA Ato Msbaou Shek Esmael Yae Gugu Residence 1000
Dera Chole Section 108 Chole Town Ato Gashaw Alemu 01 Residence 500 109 Dera Town Ato Nuru Mohamed 02 Residence 1600 110 Dera Town Police Station 02 Office 800 111 Koshim PA Ato Kemal haji Husmu Koshim Trade 144 112 Koshim PA Ato Mama Haji Husmo Koshim Trade 142 113 Koshim PA Haji Jundi Tufa Koshim Trade 194 114 Koshim PA Atol jeldi Alyou Koshim Trade 450 115 Koshim PA Ato Aman Kedir Koshim Trade 96 116 Koshim PA Ato Jemal Sufi Koshim Trade 194 117 Koshim PA Ato Temam Nun Koshim Trade 104 118 Koshim PA Ato Demsew Denb Koshim Trade 98 119 Koshim PA Ato Denb G/Yes Koshim Residence 300 120 Koshim PA Ato Kemal Kedir Koshim Residence 39 121 Koshim PA Ato Gebe Taha Koshim Residence 35 122 Koshim PA Ato Abubeker Sheh Mehamed Koshim Residence 450 123 Koshim PA Ato Hadi Shuba Koshim Residence 200 124 Koshim PA Ato Ousla Amamo AIyu Koshim Residence 540 125 Koshim PA Ato Telil Terko Koshim Residence 450 126 Koshim PA Ato Damtew Asbo Koshim Residence 300 127 Koshlm PA Haji Tirtili Koshim Residence 300 128 Koshim PA Ato Abdi Telbo Koshim Residence 300 129 Koshim PA Ato Abdrehman Haji Haji Koshim Residence 300 130 Koshim PA Ato Shikule Addem Koshim Mill 61 131 Koshim PA Shek Hasen Shek Adem Koshim Shop 6 132 Koshim PA Shek Hasen Shek Adem Koshim Residence 27 133 Koshim PA Ato Husen Edns Koshim Residence 100 134 Koshim PA Ato Junedi Kebir Tahir Koshim Residence 30 135 Koshim PA Ato Mehamed HajIKasimk Koshim Residence 26 136 Koshim PA Ato Abulkerim Hamdi Koshim Residence 26 137 Koshim PA Ato Kemal Telelo Koshim Residence 89 138 Koshim PA Ato Arba Kedir Koshim Kichen 16 139 Koshim PA Ato Arba Kedir Koshim Residence 35 140 Koshim PA Ato Arba Kedir Koshim Residence 58 141 Koshim PA Ato Seid Eko Koshim Bucher 30 142 Koshim PA Shek Kedir Shek Hasen Koshim Casette Shop 23 143 Koshim PA Ato Abre Aman Koshim Bucher 27 144 Koshim PA Ato Abdurhaman Hapi Adem Koshim Residence 27 145 Koshim PA Ato Mama Ha], Husen Koshim Residence 36 146 Koshim PA Ato Abdela Hasen Koshim Shop 40 147 Koshim PA Ato Musa Haji Husen Koshim Shop 31 148 Koshim PA Ato Beyn Shek Amdeha Koshim Residence 33 149 Koshim PA Ato Haji Sali Gobena Say Koshim Residence 300 150 Koshim PA Ato Redewan Seid Abyu Koshim Residence 300 151 Koshim PA Ato Sali Hajikem Denbeba Koshim Residence 300 152 Koshim PA Ato Lema Dejene Koshim Residence 300 153 Koshim PA Ato Daimu Haji Haji Koshim Residence 300 154 Koshim PA Ato Yemen Abdul Semed Koshim Residence 300 155 Koshim PA Ato Teshome Dendene Koshim Residence 300 156 Koshim PA Ato Ismael Mehamed Koshim Residence 300 157 Koshim PA Ato Haji Feko Chef Koshim Shop 300 158 Koshim PA Denebe Guye School Koshim School 300 159 Koshim PA Ato Saliya Kedir Weko Koshim Residence 300 160 Koshim PA Ato Seifu Jima Haji Husen Koshim Residence 300 161 Moye Town W/o Ehite Birr 01 Store & Shop 500 162 Moye Town Ato Tadese Beleke 01 Trade 96 163 Moye Town Ato Desalegne Shiferaw 01 Trade & Residence 96 164 Moye Town Ato Birhane Bantyiwalu 01 Residence 200 165 Moye Town Ato Niguse Eshete 01 Trade 27 166 Moye Town W/o Birke Teshome 01 Trade 1000 167 Moye Town Ato Asefa Kebede 01 Trade & Residence 1000 168 Moye Town Ato Takele Haile Moti 01 Residence 1000 169 Moye Town Ato Abera Kidane 01 Residence 1000 170 Moye Town W/o Nigsti Eshete 01 Trade & Residence 1000 171 Moye Town Ato Haji Abdo Amda Bekule 01 Pharmacy 1000 172 Moye Town Ato Eshete Girma Zewde 01 Store 1000 173 Moye Town Ato Kagnew Amare Mitke 01 Tailor 1000 174 Moye Town w/o Feleku Birhane Zergaw 01 Residence 1000 175 Moye Town Ato Birkneh Tegegne 02 Shop 1000 176 Negele Town Ato ShikuriAdem 01 Tea Room & Store 388 177 Negele Town Ato Haji Jemal Haji Husen 01 Store 110 178 Negele Town Haji MehamedAbirAhmed 01 Residence &Tea Room 104 179 Negele Town Ato GenaHail 01 Bucher 130 180 Negele Town Ato Ahmed Alyu 01 Hotel & Residence 184 181 Negele Town Ato Tura Haji Mehamed 01 Tea Room 27 182 Negele Town Ato Muzein Habir Husen 01 Tea Room 27 183 Negele Town w/o Kasech Adere 01 Hotel 125 184 Negele Town Same Same Residence 0 185 Negele Town Ato Nuru Shek Ahmed 01 Residence 128 186 Negele Town Same Same Residence 0 187 Negele Town Ato mehamed Hasen 01 Tea Room 133 188 Negele Town Ato Hasen Gobena 01 Tea Room 250 189 Negele Town Same 01 Residence #REFi 190 Negele Town Ato Kemal Amda golo 01 Residence 53 191 Negele Town Ato Haji Ture 01 Residence 21 192 Negele Town Ato Fekru Haji Kuli Adem 01 Residence 18 193 Negele Town Ato Jeyligne Adem Kebu 01 Residence 38 194 Negele Town Ato Junedin Say Sheku 01 Tea Room 24 195 Negele Town Ato Husen Roba 01 Trade & Store 30 196 Negele Town Ato Abdul Kadir Tekako 01 Residence & Store 58 197 Negele Town Ato Aliye Haji Husen 01 Residence &Shop 71 198 Negele Town Ato AbdurAman Hajl Mehamed 01 Trade & Store 29 199 Negele Town Ato Kasim Tesema Hute 01 Store 30 200 Negele Town Ato Hsji Hamda Tekeko 01 Bucher 44 201 Negele Town Ato Husen Haji Amano 01 Shop 41 202 Negele Town Ato Ahmed Haji Isman Kobelo 01 Shop 36 203 Negele Town Ato Mehamed Hajl Gena Tufa 01 Restaurant & shop 50 204 Negele Town Ato Husen Shekena Wako 01 Restaurant & Store 54 205 Negele Town Ato Mehamed Ahmed Elo 01 Tea Room 38 206 Negele Town Ato Haji Aman Wako 01 Store 29 207 Negele Town Ato Temam Mehamed Jara 01 Residence & Tailor 35 208 Negele Town Same Same Residence & Tailor 35 209 Negele Town Shekuli Adem 01 Mill 61 210 Negele Town Shek Asen Shek Adem 01 Shop 6 211 Negele Town Same 01 Residence 27 212 Negele Town Ato Husen Endns 01 Residence 100 213 Negele Town Ato Jundi Kebir Tahir 01 Residence 30 214 Negele Town Ato Mehamed Haji Kasim 01 Residence 26 215 Negele Town Ato Abdul kenm Hamda 01 Residence 26 216 Negele Town Ato Kemal Telilo 01 Residence 89 217 Negele Town Ato Areba Kedir 01 Kichen 16 218 Negele Town Same 01 Residence 35 219 Negele Town Same 01 Residence 58 220 Negele Town Ato Seid Eko 01 Bucher 30 221 Negele Town Shek Kedir Shek Asen 01 Shop 23 222 Negele Town Ato Abre Aman 01 Bucher 27 223 Negele Town Ato Abdurahman Haji adem 01 Residence 27 224 Negele Town Ato Mama Haji Husen 01 Residence 36 225 Negele Town Ato Abdela Hasen 01 Shop 40 226 Negele Town Ato Musa Haji Husen 01 Shop 31 227 Negele Town Ato Beyan Shek Abdurahman 01 Residence 33 228 Sire Town Ato Ousman Amino 01 Hotel 71 229 Sire Town W/o Birtukan Mekonen Desta 01 Tella House 300 230 Sire Town Ato Belhu Abebe 01 Residence & Trade 1000 231 Sire Town W/o Bekelech Zerfu 01 Residence & Trade 1000 232 Sire Town Ato Ak/ilu Dejene 01 Residence & Trade 49 233 Sire Town Ato Zenebe Ayele 01 Residence 1000 234 Sire Town W/o Menma Gendo Tona & her Brotherss 01 Residence 1000
Golokcha Mechara Section 235 Debre Selam W/o Zehara Nura 01 Residence 160 236 Debre Selam W/o Yesunesh HiManam 01 Residence 75 237 Debre Selam W/o Sofia Abdi 01 Residence 300 238 Debre Selam W/o Abiba Dasa 01 Residence 28 239 Debre Selam W/o Zeinu Dade 01 Residence 500 240 Debre Selam Ato Hal/ye Feysa 01 Residence 96 241 Debre Selam Ato Kebede Abera 01 Residence 96 242 Debre Selam Ato Oumer Hamda 01 Residence 200 243 Debre Selam Ato Husen Tulu 01 Residence 27 244 Debre Selam Ato Mama Abdela 01 Residence 158 245 Debre Selam Ato Abdo Bedaso 01 Residence 400 246 Kortu PA W/o Tenagne G/Michael Workye Kurtu Residence 1000 247 Kortu PA Ato Eshetu Getahun Abebe Kurtu Residence 1000 248 Kortu PA Ato Husen Ouso Beker Kurtu Residence 1000 249 Kortu PA Ato Musa Ouso Oda Kurtu Residence 1000 250 Same Same Same Residence 1000 251 Kortu PA Ato Desaalegne Berhanu Halle Kurtu Residence 1000 252 Same Same Same Store 1000 253 Kortu PA Ato Juhar Beker Ahmed Kurtu Residence 1000 254 Same Same Same Residence 1000 255 Kortu PA Ato Kelil Kurtu Residence 1000 256 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed Haji Ibrahim Kurtu Residence 1000 257 Kortu PA W/o SeadaAhi Kurtu Residence 1000 258 Kortu PA Ato Tefera Worku Kurtu Residence 1000 259 Kortu PA WIo Debre G/Maanam Kurtu Residence 1000 260 Kortu PA Wlo Zemzem Haji Kurtu Residence 1000 261 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed Zeynu Kurtu Residence 1000 262 Kortu PA WIo Tirunesh Dubale Kurtu Residence 1000 263 Kortu PA W/o Yesunesh G/Hana Kurtu Residence 1000 264 Kortu PA Ato S,raj Aliye Abdi Kurtu Residence 75 265 Kortu PA Ato Kiflu WiManam Kurtu Residence 750 266 Kortu PA Ato Kamil Sedik Wedai Kurtu Residence 300 267 Mechara Town Atoahmed Omda Ako 01 Store 38 268 Mechara Town Ato Mejina Abdulahi 01 Store 50 269 Mechara Town Shek Taha 01 trade 72 270 Mechara Town Ato Getachew Manekul 01 Pharmacy 64 271 Mechara Town Ato Aby Ahmed 01 Shop 37 272 Mechara Town Ato oxede 01 Shop 400 273 Same Same Same Shop 98 274 Mechara Town Ato Abdulkadie Yuye 01 Shop 44 275 Mechara Town Ato San, Abrha 01 Shop 37 276 Mechara Town Ato Husen AbiJelal 01 Residence 25 277 Mechara Town Ato Hamid Hasen 01 Residence 330 278 Mechara Town Ato Hamed siraj 01 Residence 101 279 Mechara Town Ato Yusuf Shek Bereka 01 Store Coffee 320 280 Mechara Town Ato Hamed Hasen 01 Residence 450 281 Mechara Town Ato Lule Behabtu 01 Residence 30 282 Mechara Town Ato Sani Haji 01 Residence 46 283 Mechara Town Ato MehamedAbdulahi 01 Residence 172 284 Mechara Town Ato Mehamed Sheka Adem 01 Residence 78 285 Mechara Town W/o Sofra Hasen 01 trade 83 286 Mechara Town W/o Amina Hasen 01 Tea Roam 158 287 Mechara Town Ato abrham Sheka 01 Tea Roam 400 288 Mechara Town W/o Alima Issa 01 Tea Roam 400 289 Mechara Town Ato Mehamed Ali 01 Tea Roam 400 290 Mechara Town Ato Sani Haji Mehamed 01 Shop 66 291 Mechara Town Ato Ahmed Mehamed 01 trade 60 292 Mechara Town Ato Muluka Kasim 01 trade 26 293 Mechara Town Sek Fans Buser 01 trade 31 294 Mechara Town Ato Torik Husen 01 Residence & store 33 295 Mechara Town Ato nur Ahmed 01 For Trade 33 296 Mechara Town Wlo Yewdar Begashaw 01 For Trade 33 297 Mechara Town Ato Jemal Mehamed 01 For Trade 120 298 Mechara Town Ato Abdurehman Ousamn 01 For Trade 140 299 Mlcheta Town HajiAhmedHusen 01 Store 108 300 Micheta Town W/o Kedire ShekAhmed 01 Store 600 301 Same Same 01 residence 600 302 Micheta Town Ato Mehamed Abdulahi Oxede 01 residence 400 303 Mlcheta Town Coffee Bord(Store) 01 residence 336 304 Mlcheta Town W/o Almaz Desta 01 residence 246 305 Micheta Town Ato Mehamed Shek Abdurehim 01 Residence 53 306 Micheta Town W/o Shitu Abebe 01 Residence 450 307 Micheta Town Ato Jemal Ahmed 01 residence 308 308 Micheta Town Ato Aliu Abdo 01 Residence 71 309 Micheta Town Ato Negede Mekonen 01 Residence 200 310 Micheta Town w/o Zehara Kasim 01 Residence 300 311 Micheta Town Ato Tiruneh Neway 01 Store 400 312 Micheta Town Shek Abdelaadem 01 Store 1000 313 Micheta Town ato Husen Mume 01 Residence 1000 314 Micheta Town W/o Aster H/Weld 01 Residence 49 315 Micheta Town Ato Kebede Demise 01 Residence 1000 316 Micheta Town w/o Zewde Demise 01 Residence 1000 317 Mlcheta Town Ato Feleke Kasa 01 Residence 1000 318 Micheta Town W/o Worke Bellachew 01 Residence 100 319 Micheta Town Ato Mume Iso 01 Residence 1000 320 Micheta Town Ato H/Weld Reta 01 Residence 88 321 Micheta Town Ato Zenebe Lema 01 Residence 56 322 Micheta Town Same 01 Residence 264 323 Mlcheta Town Ato Tesfa Terefe 01 Residence 49 324 Mlcheta Town Ato Demirew Haile 01 Residence 100 325 Same Same 01 Residence 0 326 Micheta Town Ato Shenf Hasen 01 Residence 130 327 Micheta Town W/o Getu zewde 01 Residence 151 328 Micheta Town W/o Getu zewde 01 Residence 0 329 Micheta Town Ato Mebrate Tadese 01 Residence 84 330 Mlcheta Town Ato Husen Mehamed 01 Residence 75 331 Kortu PA Ato Harun Husen Oumer Mohamede Residence 1000 332 Kortu PA Ato Mohamed Haron Haji Mohamede Residence 1000 333 Kortu PA Ato Yasi Yusuf Mehamed Timuga Wacheka Residence 1000 334 Kortu PA Ato Kedir Irere Beyot Timuga Wacheka Residence 1000 335 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed Ibrahim Abdela Timuga Wacheka Residence 1000 336 Kortu PA Ato Sude Dad, Timuga Wacheka Residence 1000 337 Kortu PA Ato Taha Kasim Omer Timuga Wacheka Residence 1000 338 Kortu PA Ato Muktar Jima Darn Lebo Residence 1000 339 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Amere Mechara Residence 1000 340 Kortu PA Same Same Residence same 341 Kortu PA Shek Oumer Amye Mechara Residence 1000 342 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed Bedaso Mechara Residence 1000 343 Kortu PA Ato Ousman Hasen Mechara Residence 1000 344 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Yesuf Mechara Residence 1000 345 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Ahmedd Kemen Residence 1000 346 Kortu PA Ato Abdul ManOusman Kemeri Residence 1000 347 Kortu PA Ato Adem Musa Kemen Residence 1000 348 Kortu PA Ato /sa Adem Kemen Residence 1000 349 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Mume Kurtu Residence 1000 350 Timuga Town Ato Ahmed Hametoye Haye Ameto 01 Store 75 351 Timuga Town Ato Mohamed Aliye 01 Store 750 352 Timuga Town Ato Mehamed Ahmed Adem 01 Residence 300 353 T7muga Town Ato Oumer Mehamed Oumer 01 Residence 38 354 Timuga Town Ato Ibrahim Mehamed Abdro 01 Store 50 355 Timuga Town Ato Mehamed Awel Yesuf 01 Mill 72 356 Timuga Town Ato Yesuf Beker 01 Residence 64 357 Timuga Town Ato Ahmed Hajl Adem 01 Mil 37 358 Timuga Town Ato Wube Rima 01 Residence 400 359 Timuga Town Ato adem Gula 01 Residence 98 360 Timuga Town Ato Ahmed Abdulahi 01 Residence 44 361 T7muga Town Ato Ahmedin Haji Ibrahim 01 Residence 37 362 Timuga Town Ato Abdela Isa Musa 01 Residence 25 363 Timuga Town Shek KedirAhmed 01 Residence 330 364 Timuga Town Ato nigusellma 01 Store 101 365 Tlmuga Town Ato Zeyad Iyu Hai 01 Mill 320 366 Timuga Town Ati mehamed Seid Ah 01 Residence 450 367 Timuga Town Ato Abdurehman Ayeie 01 Trade 30 368 Timuga Town Ato Aliyu Tehib 01 Trade 46 369 Timuga Town Ato Mehamed Ahmed 01 Residence 172 370 Timuga Town Ato Adem Elias 01 Store 78 371 Timuga Town Ato Hasen Ahmed 01 Store 83 372 Timuga Town Ato Aliu Mehamed 01 Residence 158 373 Timuga Town Ato Sadik Bulto 01 Residence 400 374 Timuga Town Ato Esmael Gir 01 Residence 400 375 Timuga Town Ato Tajidan Adem 01 Residence 400 376 Timuga Town Ato Mehamed Abro 01 Tea Room 66 377 Timuga Town Ato Ahmed Hamed 01 Tea Room 60 378 Timuga Town Ato Abdela Ibro 01 Trade 26 379 Timuga Town Ato Derreje Mekonen 01 Shop 31 380 Timuga Town Ato Zenhun Mamo 01 Shop 33 381 Tlmuga Town Shek Hasen Abdela 01 Shop 33 382 Timuga Town Ato Hasen Oumer 01 Shop 33 383 Timuga Town Ato Mehamed Tado 01 Residence 120 384 Timuga Town Ato Tejedi Haji Ahmed 01 Trade 140 385 Timuga Town Ato Abrham Jara 01 Trade 96 386 Timuga Town Aato Jemal Ahmed 01 Trade 45 387 Timuga Town Ato Kedir Ware 01 bucher 161 388 Timuga Town Ato Mehamed Abdule 01 Shop 22 389 Timuga Town Ato Ibrahim Abdurehman 01 Residence 78 390 Timuga Town Ato Musa Mumedi 01 Residence 364 391 Timuga Town Ato Abdurehman Hasen 01 Residence 35 392 Timuga Town W/o Kenya Golu 01 Residence 92 393 Timuga Town Ato Mehaed Oumer 01 Residence 300 394 Timuga Town Ato Ase Gole 01 Store 300 395 Timuga Town Ato Ahmed Bedbo 01 Residence 300 396 Timuga Town Ato Slieshi Meketa 01 Trade 300 397 Timuga Town Ato checheha Sileshi 01 Shop 20 398 Timuga Town Ato Hasen Husen 01 Residence 300 399 Timuga Town Ato Mehamed Kehifa 01 Residence 100 400 Tlmuga Town Ato Ahmed Mume Ibro 01 Residence 1200 401 Timuga Town Ato Jafar Haji 01 Residence 536 402 Timuga Town W/o Wagaye Tesfaye 01 Store 58 403 Same Same Same Residence 600 404 Timuga Town Ato Aliye Amedi 01 Trade 42 405 Timuga Town Ato Go/o Fato 01 Shop 800 406 Timuga Town Ato Ziad All 01 Residence 1000 407 T7muga Town Wlo Wesen Sileshi 01 Residence 500 Compound Area House Area Type of Impact
Cam pound Total Gross Remain in % ofthe House Area % ofthe Area to be Coatn House Affeato bed Rempounid Compound Arein to be Taken House Area Full Partial Affected(M2) CompoundArea (m2) Taken Aream2 in m2 to be Taken
48.6 2014 19.4 48.6 486 100 486 2014 19 4 486 486 100 X 24 0 226.0 96 24 0 24.0 100 v 42.0 208.0 16.8 42 0 42.0 100 V 348 2152 139 348 348 100 168 233.2 67 16 8 16.8 100 v 42 0 208 0 16 8 42.0 42 0 100 312 218 8 12.5 312 31.2 100 V 15 1 235 0 60 15 1 15 1 100 $
56 0 194 0 22 4 56 0 56 0 100 _ 71 242.9 28 71 71 100 / 24 0 226 0 96 24 0 24.0 100 v 62 1 687.9 83 62 1 62 1 100 / 24 8 225 3 9.9 24.8 24 8 100 v 95 2406 38 95 9.5 100 7.1 2429 28 71 7.1 100 7.1 2429 28 71 7.1 100 12.6 2374 50 12.6 126 100 / 12.6 237.4 50 12 6 12 6 100 28.3 971 7 28 28.3 283 100 / 32 8 967 2 33 32.8 32.8 100 310 969 0 31 310 31.0 100 30.5 9695 31 305 305 100 v 50.6 949 4 5.1 50.6 50 6 100 34.2 9658 34 34.2 34 2 100 V 34 2 965 8 34 34 2 34.2 100 34.2 9658 34 34 2 34 2 100 v 34 2 965 8 3.4 34 2 34.2 100 V 34 2 965.8 3.4 34 2 34 2 100 43 3 956 7 43 43 3 43 3 100 V 428 9572 43 428 428 100 V 42 5 957.5 42 42 5 42 5 100 V 29 1 9709 29 29 1 291 100 / 32 0 968 0 32 32 0 32.0 100 V 16 8 983.2 1 7 16.8 16.8 100 158 984.2 16 15.8 158 100 173 982 7 1.7 173 173 100 V 20 0 980.0 2.0 20.0 20.0 100 21.7 978.3 2.2 21.7 21 7 100 V 23.8 976 2 2.4 23 8 23 8 100 V 16.0 984 0 16 160 16.0 100 = 16 0 984.0 1.6 16.0 160 100 I 22 8 977.2 2.3 22 8 22 8 100 I 18.0 982 0 1 8 18.0 18.0 100 31 7 968.3 3 2 31 7 31 7 100 400 960 0 4.0 40 0 40 0 100 80 0 920.0 8 0 80 0 80 0 100 369 963 1 3.7 369 36 9 100_ 39 1 960 9 3.9 39.1 39 1 100o 48 1 951.9 4.8 48.1 48.1 100 18.0 982 0 1 8 18.0 18 0 100 19.2 980.8 1 9 192 19.2 100 31 7 968.3 3.2 31 7 31 7 100 _ 71 992 9 0.7 7.1 71 100 _ 8 5 991 5 0 9 8 5 8 5 100 _
71 992 9 0.7 7.1 71 100 _ 71 992 9 0 7 7.1 7.1 100 _ 8 5 991.5 0 9 8 5 8 5 100 7.1 992 9 0 7 71 7.1 100 = 71 992.9 0.7 7.1 7.1 100 4 9 995.1 0.5 4 9 4 9 100 _ 7.7 992.3 0 8 7 7 7 7 100 _ 7 3 992 7 0 7 7.3 73 100 7.3 992.7 0.7 73 7.3 100 168 9832 1 7 16.8 16.8 100 34 0 9660 3 4 35.2 34 0 9666 50 0 950.0 5 0 50 0 50 0 100 _ 32.2 967.8 3 2 32 2 32.2 100 7.1 992 9 0.7 71 7.1 100 _ 50 8 949 2 5 1 50.8 50.8 100 8.4 991.6 0.8 8 4 84 100 7.1 992 9 0 7 71 71 100 _ 24.6 9754 2 5 24 6 24 6 100 = 24 6 9754 2 5 24 6 24.6 100 71 992 9 0 7 7.1 71 100 = 7.1 992 9 0.7 71 7.1 100 71 9929 0 7 28.3 71 25 71 9929 0 7 28 3 71 25 = 71 992 9 0.7 28.3 71 25 12 6 9874 1.3 50 2 12.6 25 = 7.1 992.9 0 7 28 0 0.0 0 4 2 995.8 0.4 34 2 4 2 12.1 7.1 9929 07 28.3 7.1 25 V 7.1 992 9 0 7 28.3 7.1 25 7.1 992.9 07 283 7.1 25V 71 9929 0.7 28 3 71 25 71 992 9 0.7 28 3 71 25V 7 1 992 9 0 7 28 3 7 1 25, 30.2 9698 3.0 302 302 100 7.1 992.9 0.7 28 3 7.1 25 4.2 9958 04 34 2 4 2 121 = 42 9958 04 34 2 4 2 12.1 4 2 9958 04 34.2 4 2 121 = 7.1 9929 0 7 283 7.1 25. 4 2, 995.8 04 34 2 4 2 121 = 12 61 987.4 13 50.2 12 6 25V 7.1 9929 0.7 283 71 25 12 6 987.4 1.3 50 2 12.6 25 4.2 995 8 0 4 34.2 4.2 12 1 126 987.4 13 502 126 25 VI 4 2 995 8 0.4 34.2 4.2 12 1 7.1 992.9 0 7 28 3 7 1 25 00 1000 0 0.0 24.0 24.0 100 71 992.9 0.7 71 71 100 _ 71 9929 07 71 7.1 100 _ 71 9929 07 71 7.1 100 _ 7.1 9929 07 71 71 100 / 7.1 992.9 07 71 71 100 / / = ______#REF_ 1.5 498 5 0 3 39.0 1 5 3 8 66 7968 04 364 6.6 18.1 3 2 122.4 0.4 22.8 3 2 142 / 21.6 122 4 15 0 31 0 21 6 69 8 22 3 119.7 15.7 305 223 73 1 28.5 165 3 14 7 40 9 28.5 69 8/ 158 4343 35 226 15.8 698 / 144 81 6 150 206 144 698 29 1 164 9 15 0 41 7 29 1 69.8 94 94.6 9.0 339 9.4 2766 11 7 858 12.0 273 11.7 4299 18.0 282 0 6.0 38 9 18.0 46.3 23 4 15 6 60 0 23.4 23 4 100 22.5 12 5 64 3 22 5 22 5 100 / 365 4135 8.1 460 365 794 22 8 1773 11.4 41 6 22 8 54.7 _ 56 4 483.6 10 4 68 3 56 4 82.7 / 25.2 424 8 5 6 27.1 25 2 93 0 408 2592 136 418 408 97.6 26 0 274 0 8 7 27.3 26 0 952 / 18.2 281 8 6 1 18 2 18.2 100 a 18.6 281 5 6 2 29.2 18.6 63 6 61.4 0 0 100 0 61.4 614 100 5 5 0.0 100.0 5 5 5 5 100 / 27 0 0.0 100.0 27 0 27 0 100 58 0 42.0 58.0 58.0 58 0 100 30 0 0 0 100.0 30.0 30 0 100 25 5 0 0 100.0 25.5 25 5 100 26 0 0.0 100 0 26 0 26.0 100 a 889 0 0 1000 889 889 100 _ 15.5 0 0 100.0 15.5 15 5 100 34 8 0.0 100 0 34.8 34 8 100 30.6 27 5 52 6 58.1 30 6 526 / 30 0 0 0 100 0 30 0 30.0 100 1 226 0.0 1000 226 22.6 100 / 27-3 0.0 100.0 27.3 27 3 100 267 0 0 100.0 26.7 26 7 100 357 00 1000 357 357 100 39.5 0 0 100 0 39 5 39.5 100 _ 310 0 0 100 0 31 0 31.0 100_ 32.9 0.0 100 0 32.9 32 9 100 14 0 2860 4 7 28 0 14.0 50 33 5 266.5 11 2 40 3 33.5 83 1 279 2721 9 3 33.5 279 83 3 25 2 274 8 84 32.0 25 2 78 7 24.5 275.5 8 2 42 0 245 58 3 6.2 2938 2 1 260 62 23.8 179 2821 6 0 179 17.9 100 24 8 2753 8.3 24 8 24 8 100 48.7 251.3 16 2 48.7 48 7 100 78.0 222 0 26 0 78.0 78 0 100 17.9 282 1 6.0 179 179 100 179 282 1 60 179 179 100 42 0 458 0 8 4 68.6 4.9 71 0 8 94 7 0.9 19 2 24 12 5 0 8 94.7 0 9 22 8 2 9 12.5 1 7 198 7 0.9 20 8 52 25 0 8 264 2.9 376 9.4 25 71 992.9 0.7 42 0 3 0 7t1 4 2 995.8 0.4 39 7 13 6 34.4 7,1 9929 0 7 279 12.4 44.4 7.1 992.9 0 7 31 2 7.8 25 _ 20 0 980.0 2 0 35 6 54 1522 160 984.0 1 6 1103 15 8 14 3 71 992 9 0 7 35 3 4.7 133 _ 20 0 980 0 2.0 353 4 7 1333 4 2 9958 0.4 64.4 4 6 71 _ 30.0 970.0 3 0 69 6 70 10 = 80 0 308.0 20 6 80 0 80.0 100 34 1 75 9 31 0 34.1 34.1 100 _ 20 8 83.2 200 20 8 20.8 100 _ 31 2 98 8 24 0 31.2 31 2 100 61 6 1224 33 5 61 6 61 6 100 _ 27.1 0.0 100 0 271 271 100 V 271 0 0 100.0 271 271 100 _ 29 0 81 2 23 2 33.6 29.0 86.2 14 9 14.9 14.9 100 = 29 0 98 5 22 7 29 0 29 0 100 _ 00 0.0 14 9 00 0 254 1071 19.2 254 25.4 100V 125.0 94 8 50 0 125 0 125 0 100 _ 30 2 30.2 30.2 100 V 52.5 0 0 100 0 52.5 52 5 100 _ 21 2 0 0 100.0 21 2 21.2 100 V 180 00 100 0 18 0 18 0 100 V 38,4 0 0 100.0 38.4 38.4 100 V 237 0.0 100 0 23 7 23 7 100 V 30 1 0.0 100 0 301 30 1 100 V 584 0.0 100 0 584 58.4 100 V 71 31 00O 100.0 71 3 71 3 100 V 285 0o0 100 0 28.5 28 5 100| 30 0 0 0 100 0 30 0 300 100 / 44.0 0 0 100.0 440 440 100 V 41.3 0.0 100.0 41 3 41.3 100| 35 9 0.0 100 0 359 35.9 100 | 50 3 0 0 100 0 50.3 503 100 _ 53 9 0 0 100 0 53 9 53 9 100 37 7 0 0 100 0 37.7 377 100 29.0 0.0 100 0 29.0 29.0 100 34 7 0 0 100 0 34 7 34.7 100 34 8 0 0 100.0 34 8 34.8 100 61 4 0.0 100 0 61.4 61.4 100 5 5 0 0 100.0 5.5 5 5 100 27.0 0 0 100 0 27.0 270 100 / 33 6 664 33.6 58 0 33 6 58 30 0 0 0 100.0 30 0 30 0 100 5 1 20.4 20 0 255 5 1 20 5.1 20.9 19.6 26.0 5.1 19 6 88 9 0 0 1000 88 9 88 9 100 15 5 0.0 100 0 15 5 15 5 100 34 8 0 0 100.0 34 8 34 8 100 30 6 275 52 6 58.1 30 6 52 6 5 0 25 0 16 7 30 0 50 16.7 73 153 32 3 22.6 73 32 3, 58 21.5 21.3 273 5 8 21 3 5 8 20 9 21 7 26.7 5 8 21 7 8 7 270 24 4 35 7 8.7 24 4 79 31 6 20 0 39 5 7.9 20 62 24 8 20.0 31 0 6 2 20 6.2 26 7 18 9 32 9 62 18.9 V 22.1 48.4 31 3 25 0 20.0 80 60 0 240 0 20 0 38 3 2.5 6.4 62 5 9375 6.3 50.4 2 8 5 6 30 0 970 0 3.0 40 3 0 8 2 1 19.2 30.0 39 0 366 3 0 8 1 25 0 975 0 2.5 99.2 171 172 25 0 9750 25 66.5 10.5 15.8 =~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
6 0 154 0 3 8 26.7 6 0 22 5 0 0 75 0 0 0 575 0 0 0 1.8 2982 0 6 25.4 1.8 71 8.1 198 28 9 25 4 8 1 31 7 149 485.1 3 0 28 5 14 9 52.3 0.8 94.7 0 9 13 0 0.8 63 08 94 7 0 9 7.1 0.8 11.6V 0.9 199.5 0 5 4 2 0.9 22.2 0 4 268 1.5 71 0 4 5 9 0 0 158 1 0 0 71 0 0 0 0.0 400 0 0.0 20.0 0 0 0 43.8, 956.2 44 160 7.1 44.2 7 11 992.9 0.7 71 42 588 0o0 1000.0 0 0 20.0 7 1 353/ 60.0 940 0 6 0 71 71 100 _ 4 9 995 1 0 5 30 0 20.0 667 _7 36 6 9634 3 7 80 0 16.0 20 _ 4 9 995 1 0 5 172 2 7.1 41 _ 71 992 9 0 7 85 0 20 0 23 5 48 0 952 0 4.8 36 6 4 2 11 4 32.8 9672 3 3 40.8 30.0 735 7.1 992.9 0 7 86.7 75 0 86.5 384 961.6 3 8 172 2 172 2 100 = 12 6 9874 1.3 850 850 100 30 0 970 0 3 0 44 6 36.6 81 9 71 992 9 0.7 48 0 408 85 71 992.9 0.7 86.7 86 7 100 4.9 9951 0.5 924 0 0 0 5 0 995.0 0 5 136.7 0 0 0 63 68 8 8.3 148 5 44 6 30.1 / 375 , 712.5 5 0 105 0 48 0 45.7 10 5 289 5 3 5 100.0 39 5 39 5 12 5 25 0 333 90.0 8.4 9 3 25 0 25 0 50 0 420 0 19.1 4.55 27.0 45 0 37.5 763 165 21.6 32 0 32 0 50 0 54 1 250 462 7.7 29 5 20.6 360 13.9 38 7, 46.0 354 0 11 5 36.0 162 45 370 61 0 378 360 30 0 83 3 16 7 275 378 360 1.9 5.2 16.0 21 0 43.2 360 4.8 13 3 2 8 22.0 11 3 36.0 3 2 9 11 0 319.0 33 51.8 3 2 6.25 378 63 0 37 5 45 6 3 2 71 36 8 283 2 11 5 46 8 3.2 6 9 15 0 435 0 3.3 40 9 3.2 79 10 0 20 0 33 3 191 1 3.2 1 7 14 5 31 5 31.5 191 1 8 6 4 5 6 9 165 1 4.0 191 1 72 3 8 4 7 73 3 6.0 74 5 5.2 70 176 64 9 21 3 102 1 5 7 5 6 45.2 1124 28.7 102 1 18 2 17.8 52 0 348.0 13 0 102.1 18 2 17.8 4 0 356.0 11 0 102.1 18 2 17.8 260 374 0 6.5 141 1 9.7 6 9 5 7 60 3 8 7 141.1 173 12 3 52 54 8 8 7 44 2 173 39.1 4 0 22.4 152 44.2 173 39.1 13 0 18 5 41 2 44 2 173 391 14.4 19 0 43 2 108 0 78 72 14.4 19 0 43.2 86 5 7.8 9 0 17 4 15 5 52.8 61 5 1.0 1.7 10 0 110 0 8 3 150 0 1.0 0.7 2.8 137.2 2 0i 336.2 1.0 0 3 48.0 60 0 44 4 108.0 48 0 44 4 41.0 559 1 68 865 410 474/ 20 5 579.5 3.4 61.5 20.5 3333 100 0 300 0 25 0 150 0 100 0 66 7 102 5 233 7 30 5 3362 102 5 305 v 12 3 233 7 5 0 136.5 12.3 9 0 88 43 8 16 7 31.5 8.8 278 13 5 436.5 3 0 48.6 13.5 27.8 = 28 2 279.8 9.2 75 2 28 2 37.5 22.1 484 31.3 45 6 221 485 / 46 0 154.0 23.0 662 46 0 69.4 18 8 281.2 6 3 42 3 18.8 44 4 35.5 364 5 8.9 42.6 35.5 8333 15.5 984.5 1.6 61.4 15.5 25.3 9 8 990 2 1 0 508 9 8 194 =V 19 2 300 39 0 492 19 2 3900 30 0 970 0 3.0 30 0 30 0 100 _
6 5 993 5 0 7 50 1 65 130 _ 6 5 993 5 0 7 50 1 65 13 0 4 3 995 7 04 271 4 3 1599 18 3 981 7 1 8 62 2 18 3 2944 264 61.6 300 704 264 375 V 24 8 31 0 44 4 55 8 24 8 444 V 10 6 253 4 4 0 763 10 6 13.9 _ 21 6 270 44 4 48 6 21 6 444 V 2 9 79 0 2 9 17.4 2 9 16 7 18 1 42 6 18 1 425 _ 18.5 111 5 14 2 43.5 18.5 42.5 _ 3.0 144 2 2.0 18.0 3.0 1677 4.0 24.0 4.0 16.7 _ 40 0 44.0 476 49 6 40 0 806 V 22.5 52.5 30.0 60.0 22 5 375 V 462 953.8 4 6 462 462 100 43 8 956.2 4 4 43.8 43 8 100 V 71 992.9 0.7 7.1 7.1 100 _ 7.1 992 9 0 7 71 0 0 0 _ 60 0 940 0 60 60 0 60 0 100 _ 4.9 9951 0.5 4 9 4 9 100 36.6 963.4 36.6 36.6 36 6 100 _ 4.9 995.1 0 5 4 9 4 9 100 V 71 944 9 0 7 7.1 71 100 48.0 48.0 48 0 100 _ 32.8 9672 3 3 32.8 32 8 100 V
7.1 992.9 0 7 7.1 7.1 100 _ 38 4 961 6 3 8 384 38 4 100 12 6 9874 1.3 12 6 12.6 100 _ 300 970 0 3 0 30 0 30 0 100 _ 71 992 9 0.7 7.1 71 100 _ 71 992 9 0 7 7.1 71 100V 49 995.1 0.5 4 9 4.9 100 50 995.0 0.5 5.0 5.0 100 V 6 3. 68 8 83 75 0 6 3 833 37 51 712.5 5.0 68.9 15 9 23.1 _ 10.5 289.5 3 5 31 9 3 9 12 3 12 5 25 0 33.3 375 12.5 33.3 25 0 250 50.0 50.0 25.0 50 270 45 0 375 72.0 270 375 32 0 32.0 500 64 0 32 0 50 7 7 29 5 20 6 372 7 7 20.6 46 0 354 0 11.5 460 14.5 31 5 370 610 378 98.0 370 378 16 7 275 37.8 44 1 16 7 378 160 21 0 43 2 370 16 0 43 2 2 8 22.0 11.3 24 8 2 8 11 3 11 0 319.0 3 3 49.2 8 2 16.7 378 63 0 375 79.8 378 47.4 36 8 283 2 11 5 89 1 28 1 31 5 15 0 4350 3 3 558 90 16.1 10 0 20 0 33 3 30 0 10.0 33 3 14 5 31 5 31 5 43 8 13 8 31 5 6 9 165.1 4.0 53 3 69 12 9 4.7 73 3 60 29.5 4 5 15.3 V 17 6 649 21 3 451 176 39 0V 45 2 112.4 28 7 97 7 452 462 V 52.0 348 0 13 0 39.5 13 5 34.2 44 0 356.0 110 31 0 9 5 30.6 V 26.0 374 0 6.5 27 7 5.7 20 6 5 7 60.3 8 7 27.7 5 7 206 V 5.2 54 8 87 252 5.2 206 V 40 224 152 240 40 167 V 13 0 18 5 41.2 31 5 13 0 41.2 V 14 4 19.0 43 2 334 144 432 V 14 4 19 0 43 2 334 144 432 V 174 15 5 52.8 32 9 17.4 52 8 10 0 110.0 83 32.4 54 16.7 V 2.8 1372 20 378 2.8 74 V 208 752 21 7 26.6 91 34.2 16 43 7 34 276 16 5.7 V 26 8 133 8 16 7 80 3 26.8 33.3 V 81 13 5 37.5 29 6 11.1 375 78 70 2 10.0 33 8 0.0 0 172 346.8 47 43 2 17.2 39.8 V 13 9 21 0 39.8 42 3 16 8 398 V 15 2 76.8 16 5 382 15 2 39 8 24 0 2760 80 403 9.8 242 V 54 0 2460 18.0 860 36 0 419 V 585 241.5 19 5 91.7 402 43.8 75 2925 2.5 45 9 3.7 81 _ 33 165 16 7 19 8 33 167 V 15 0 285.0 5.0 36 6 6.1 167 V 40 96.0 40 31.0 40 12.9 V 111.0 10890 93 52 2 22 2 42.5 V 8.0 528 0 1.5 77 7 8.0 103 13.4 445 231 579 13 4 231 V 45.0 5550 75 39 0 90 231 V 4.2 37.8 10.0 342j 42j 1233 I/ 100 7900 13 528 40 76 / 125 0 875 0 12.5 9.2I 0.0 0 V 134.0 366.0 26 8 878 48.2 550 _ Annex Six - Co Densation Cost for PAP______Cost estImate for wood .6 Mud House CoSt for tached House
Roar UMITotal Cost Conipensallon ~~~~~UnitCost for CompensalIon Purp.ose of the Type of the House Area (lm) ReleetRoorTotal Unit Cost CompensationVau25of TalCts(n Tatched ~~~~~ValueTahefor TotalhosCst Tatched Cost estImateChH for No TowniPA Name of Houisehold head House (m2) CosB(lr/m2)Replccret Vlemen%cost Toa ot Br houseTacd hosCssechH CostRePicemen (Birrlm2) cost) ~houses(25%of (Blrr) (BIrrIHouse) Replcemnen cost)
Section I -Dera Chole ______2 ______36____37__ 1 Derortu PA Ato I(edi Jima shop Wood &Mud 4866 464 80 22,589 10 5,647 27 28,236 37 ______002,33 2 Derarlu PA Ato Niguse Mlugmeta Residence Wood &Mud 24 464 80 11,155 11 2,788 78 13,943 89 _____ 0 _____ 0 13,943 89 3 DerauiluPA Ato Jemal Mehomed Residence Wood &Mud 42 464 80 19,521 44 4,880 36 24,401 80 0 0 24,401 80 4 Deraflu PA Ato Kimaal Mehamled Residence Wood ,&Mud 34 8 464 80 16,174 91 4,043 73 20,218 64 0 0 20,218 64 5 Derartu PA Ato Julo iroba Residence Wooid Mud 16 8 464 80 7,808 58 1,952-14 8,760 72 0 ______0 9,760 72 6 Derarlu PA Ato Abdulkedir Kenlo Residence Wood .6Mud 42 464 80 19,521 44 4,680036 24.401 80 0 0 24,401680 7 1Deraulu PA Ato Abraham Bedaso Residence WDod& Muid 312 464860 14,501 64 3,625 41 18,127 05 10 0 18,127 05 8 Derartu PA Alo ~Aman Amb~o Residence Wood &Muid 1505 464 80 6,99518S 1,748 80 8,743 98 0 0 8,743 98 9 Dera,lu PA Ato Ture Guider MS Wood &Mud 561 300 00 16,800 00 4,200 00 21,000 00 _ ___ 0 0 21,000 00 10 Derartu PA Wlo Genu Abcid Residence Titched Roof 7 0651 - -- - 600 150 750 750 00 II Derartu PA Ato pedemMeWhamed Resitlence Wood &Mud 24 464 80 11,1551if 2,788 78 13,943 89 0 ______0 13.943869 12 Derartu PA HaJiKenmal Adehared Residence Wood S Mud 62 1 464 80 28,863 84 7,215 96 36,0 79 81 0 0 36,079 81 13 Derartu PA Ato Mukenm obdo Residence Wood &Mud 24 75 464 80 11,503 71 2,875 83 14,379 63 0 0 14,379 63 14 DerOrtUPA Ala Aman Ahtnedf Residence Wood 8 Mud 8 45 464 80 4,392 32 1,09808 5,490 41 0 0, 5,49041 15 Derartu PA Alo Kaseil Gobena Residence Tatched Roof 7065 -- 600 150 7501 750 00 16 Derartu PA Wlo AlemaMehamed Residence Tatched Roof 7 065-- 600 150 750 750 00 17 Derarlu PA Wlo ZemzemiHorn Residence Tatclied Roof 12 56 - - 600 150 750 750 00 18 Derortu PA Wlo Kidnesh Residence Wood &Muid 12956 464 80 5,837 84 1,459 46 7.297 30 0 0 7,297 30 19 Magna Hadere Alo Adamu Beelet Residence Wood .6Mud 28 26 464 80 13,135 14 3.283 79 16,418 93 0 0 16,418 83 20 Magna Hadere Kes Gulma wjYohannes MS/ Wood S Mud 32 8 300 00 9,840 00 2.460 00 12,300 00 0 0 12,300 00 21 Magna Hadere Shek Jemal Abd: Residence WoodS&Mud 30 96 464 80 14,390 09 3,597 52 17,887 610 0 17,987 61 22 Magna Hadere Ato OumerAman Residence I Wood &Mudt 30 531 464 80 14,190 23 3,547 56 17.737 79 _____ 0 0 17.737 79 23 Magna Hadete AIo Jemal Muwne Residence Wood &Mudf 50 631 464 80 23,532 63 5,683 16 29,415 79 0 0f 29,415 78 24 Magna Hadere Ato Ebu Gods Residence Wood &Mud 34 228 464 80 15,90811f 3,977 03 19.885 14 0 0 19,885 14 25 Magna Hademe Ato SultbAli Residence WoodS&Mud 34 226 464 80 15,908 11 3.977 03 19,085 14 0 0 19,885 14 26 Magna Hadere Alo Mehamed Adem Residence Wood &Mud 34 226 464 80 15,908 11 3,971 03 19,685 14 0 0 19.885 14 27 Magna Hadere Ala Ahmied Tufo Residence wood 8 Mud 34 226 464 80 15,908911 3,977 03 19.885 14 0 0 19,885 14 28 Magna Hadere Ato 0ino Mehamed Residence Wood &lAud 34 226 464 80 15,908 11 3,977 03 19,885 14 0 0 19,885 14 29 Haro PA AtaAdorn J,bnl Residence Wood &Mud 43 31 464 80 20,130 32 5,032 58 25,162 90 0 0 25,16290o 30 HarO PA Ato Abdul Kenm Muktar Resldence Wood S Mud 42864 46480 19,911 87 4,977197 24,889 840 0 24.889 84 31 HaonPA Ala Hasen Abye Residence Wood S Mud 42481 464 80 19,744954 4,936 14 24,680 68 0 0 24.680 68 32 Haor PA Ato AbdfulaheMnhamed Residence Wood &Mud 29 11 464 80 131,53022 3,382 55 16.912 770 0 16,912 77 33 HarO PA Ala Kedir Haji Residence WoodS& Mud 32 464 80 14,873 48 3,718 37 18,591 850 0 16,591 85 34 Haor PA Ala Dinku Legese Residence Wood & Mud 16 83 464 80 7,822 52 1,955 63 9,778 150 0 9,778 15 35 Haro PA Shek Jemsl Ahmod Residence WoodS& Mud 1581 464 80 7,348 43 1,837 11 9,185540 0 9,185594 36 Haor PA Ato Ribras Abdeffa Residence Wood & Mud 17 34 464 80 8,059 57 2,014 89 10,074 460 0 10,074 46 37 Horn PA Ato Husen Kedir Residence Wood 6 Mud 20 4648 8 ,295 92 2,323 98 11,619910 0 11,619 91 38 Harn PA Ala Abers Gulilat Residence Wood S Mud 21 7 464 80 10,086608 2,521 52 12.607 60 0 0 12.607 60 39 Haor PA Ato Tilohun Wokene Residence Wood & Mud 23 76 464680 11,04356 2,76.089 13,804 45 0 0 13.804 45 40 Horn PA Alo Juhiar Ahmed Residence WoodS& Mud 15899 464 80 7,43209 1,85802 9,290 11 0 0 9,2901II 41 Horn PA Ato Yusuf Adorn Residence Wood & Mud 15 99 464 80 7,43209 1,85802 9,290 11 0 0 9.290 1I 42 Horn PA Ala Mehamedf Husen Residence WoodS& Mud 22 8 464860 10,597 35 2,649 34 13,246 69 0 0 13,246 69 43 Haor PA Ala Husen amarn Residence Wood & Mud 18 464 80 8,366 33 2,091 58 10,45791 0 0 10.457 91 44 Horn PA Ala RashrKasim Residence wowdS Mud 31 72 464 80 14,743 34 3,885 83 18,429 17 0 0 18.429 17 45 Horn PA Ato MehamnedAnmin Residence Wood & Mud 40 464 80 18,591 85 4,647 96 23,239 81 0 0 23.239 81 46 Haor PA Ala Lema Worliu Residence Wood & Mud 80 46480o 37,183 70 9,29502 46,479 62 0 0 46.479162 47 Harn PA Ato MehanmedKemaol Residence Wood& Mud 36 464680 17,150 98 4,287 75 21.438 73 0i 01 21.438 73 48 Horn PA Ato Abdul feta Haji Residence Wood&SMud I3908L 464 80 18,15494 4,538 73 22.693 67 0l 0 22,993 67 49 HamoPA Alo Zubeda Halt Residence Wood &Mud 48 06 464 80 22,338 11 5,564 53 27,922 63 ______0 0 27,92263 50 HaroPA Ata Meharned Ahiyu Residence Wdood&Mud 18 464 80 8,366 33 2,091 58 10.457 91 _ ___ 0 0 10,457 91 51 HamoPA Ato Shffnelsh Ketema Residence Wood &Mud 19 2 464 80 6,924 09 2.231 02 11,155 11 0 0 11,155 11 52 HarmPA Ata Kediro Mhamed Residence Wood &Mud 31 72 464 80 14,743 34 3,685 83 18,429 17 0 ' 0 18.429 17 53 HamoPA Ato Kemer Kemal Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 - - 600 150 750 750 00 54 HamoPA Ato Adem Yesuf Residenre Tatched Roof 8 5487 --- 600 15O 750 750 00 55 HamoPA Ato Abdur Aman Residence Tatchied Roof 7 065 - 600 150 750 750 00 56 HamDPA Ala Ibrahim Aman Residence Tatched Roof 7065 -- 600 150 7501 750 00 57 HamoPA Ata Mehamed Hasn Residence Tatched Roof 85487 --- 600 150 7501 750 00 58 HamoPA Ato Ismael Oumer Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 --- 600 150 750 750 00 59 HamtPA AdoAkiyu Mehamed Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 --- 600 150 750 750 00 60 HamtPA Ato Taha Ab, Basha Residence Tatched Roof 4 9063 - -600 150 750 750 00 61 HamoPA Ala Kebeb Gulita Shop Wood &Muid 768 464 80 3,569 63 892 41 4,46204 0 0 4,462 04 62 HamxPA Ala Amanu Bambo shop Wood &Muid 7 26 464 80 3,374 42 843 61 4,218 03 0 0 4,218 03 63 HamoPA Ala N4su Melese Mama Shop WoodS& Mud 7 26 464 80 3,374 42 643 61 4,218 03 0 0 4,218 03 64 HamoPA Ala Mehamed Kebede Restaurant Wood & Mud 16 8 464860 7,80858 1,952 14 9,780 72 0 0 9,780 72 65 HamoPA Alo Abdi Mehamed Restaurant Wood &Mud 35 2 464 80 16,360 83 4,090 21 20,451 03 0 0 20,451 03 66 HamoPA Ala Temem Oumer Shop Wood &Mud 50 02 464690 23,249 11 5,812 28 29.061 38 0 0 29,061 38 67 HamoPA AdaRegasa Leta Restaurant WoodS&Mud 32 24 464 60 14,985 03 3,746 26 18,731 29 0 0 18,731 29 68 HamoPA Al oShffnelis Asemu Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 - - - 600 150 750 750 00 69 HamoPA Atoelehamed Akyu Crinic WoodS Mud 50 84 464 80 23,630 24 5,907 56 29,537680 0 0 29,537680 70 HamoPA Wlo Dasash Admas Restaurant Wood &Mud 84 464 80 3,904 29 976 07 4,880 36 0 0 4,880 36 71 HamOPA Alo Ahmed Mume Aby Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 - - - 800 150 750 750 00 72 Same Same Tea Room Wood&.Mud 24 6 464 80 11,433 99 2.858 50 14,292 48 0 0 14,292 48 73 HamoPA Alo Girsha Kasimn Tea Room Wood& Mud 2461 464680 11,433 99 2.858050 14,292 48 0 0 14,292 48 74 HamoPA Ala Kebede HALULE Residence TalChed Roof 7 065 - - 600 150 750 750 00 75 HamoPA Wo Rase Ababe Residence Tatchad Roof 7065 -- 600 150 750 750 00 76 Legebuna PA Ala Legese Debele Residence Tached Roof 28 26 - 600 150 750 750 00 77 Legebuna PA Ala Jemal Mehamed Ahye Residece Tached Roof 28 26 -- 600, 150 750 750 00 78 Legebuna PA Ala Jemal Adem Kun Residence? Tached Roof 28 26 - -- 600 150 750 750 00 79 Legebuna PA Ala Meiese Beyene Wekie Residence wood &Mud 50 24 464 80 23.351 36 5,837684 29,189 20 029190 80 Legebuna PA Ala Mehamied Kemal Amedo Residence Tached Roof 28 --- 60io70700 81 Same Same Residence Tached Roof 34 195 601070700 82 Legebuna PA Ala Mehamed Nur Ahmedf Residence Tached Roof 28 26 601070700 83 Legebuna PA Ala SarajHusen bodaso Residence Tarhed Root 28 26 601070700 84 Legebuna PA Alo Suran Hasmnboru Residence Tached Roof 28 26 601070700 85 Legebuna PA AlaoJibnlKell Adem Residence Tached Roof 28 26 60 5 5 5 O 86 Legebuna PA Ala Abdeila Ousman Abdfi Residence Tarhed Roof 28 26 60IO70700 87 Legebuna PA Ala Wehamed Husen Shek Adaem Residence wo)od& Mud 30 24 464 80 14,055 44 3,513 86 17,569 30 ______0______17,569 30____ 88 PA Ata Kedir Ahlmed Residence Tatched Roof 28 261 ______600____750750_ 89 PA Ala Abdul Kadir Ousman Rmsidence Tatched Roof 34 195 600 10 750750 W 00 PA Ala Husen Amdfajlo Residence Tatchud Roof 34 195 _00____750750__ 91 PA Ala Mehamed Amda Residence Tatched Roof 34 195 6______750__50__ 92 PA Ala ThinsmBadasa Residence Tatched Roof 28 26 -75 60- 500 93 PA Ala Kadi Bedao Chaca Residence Tatched Roof 34 195 - -507017500 94 PA Ala BuaDKebir Sheka Residence Tatched Roof 50 24 - 60 707-00 95 PA Ala Ahmed Bedaso Chaco Residence Tatched Roof 28 26 -70 60- 500 96 PA Ala Dbele Shegu Jima Residence Tatchud Roof 50 24 - 0-1075 500 97 PA Ala Abio Debele Residence Tatched Roof 34 195 - 60 75-500 98 IPA Ala KasemGobe Residence Tatched Roof 50 24 _00____750750__ 99 PA Ala Mussa Bonm Tune Residence Tatched Roof 34 195 __00______0_750______750_____ 100 PA Ala AhryeAmda J#1b Residence Tatched Roof 28 26 60015 750 7000 101 PA Ato Mustofa Kebir Residence Wood and Mud _ 24 464 80 11,155 II 2,788 78 13,943 89 601 150 251 751 25 14,695 14 102 PA Shek EsmaselChole Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 ______00____ 750 7000 103 PA Ala KedarBatt Roba Residence Tatched Roof 706560 075 750 00 10I4 PA Ala Gena Talosa Residence Tatched Roof 70651 600 15 75 750 00 105 PA Ala KedwrAhmed Residence Tatched Roof 7065 600 150_ 750 7000 106 1PA lAlaosbaou Shek EsmaeI Residence Tatched Roof 705600______750_____ 750 00 GoloIcha 2 -Section -Chole ______107 Chole Town Ato GashawAlemu Residence Wood & Mud 391 464 80 18.12705 4,537 76 22,658862 0 0 22,658 82 108 Dera Town Alo Nuru MAohamed Residence Wood &Mud 3641 464 80 16.918658 4,229 65 21,148 23 0 0 21,148 23 T 109 Dera own Police Station Office Wood & Mud 2286 464 80 10,597 35 2,649 34 13,246 69 _ ___ 0 0 13.246 69 fo10-KshimPA Ato Kemal haji Husmu Trade Wood 8 Mud 30 96 464860 14,390 09 ,572179610 0 17,987 61 ill Koshim PA Ato Mama Haji Husmo Trade Wood &Mud 30 53 464 80 14,190 23 3,547 56 17,737 790017377 112 Koshim PA HajiJundi Tufa Trade Wood &Mud 40 85 464 80 18,986 93 4,746 73 23,733 66 0 0 23,733 66 113 KoshimnPA Ato ietdi Atyou Trade Wood &Mud 22 575 464 80 10,492 77 2,623 19 13,11597 0 0 13,115 97 114 Koshim PA Ato AmanaKedir Trade Wood &Mud 20 64 464 80 9,593 39 2,398 35 11,991 74 0 0 11,991 74 115 Koshim PA Ata Jemial Sufi Trade Wood &Mud 41 71 464860 19,386 65 4,646 66 24,233 31 ______0 0 24.233 31 118 Koshan PA Alo Temam Nun Tradte Wood &Muid 33 92. -46480o 15,765 89 3,941 47 19,707 36 0 0 19,70736 117 Koshim PA Ato DJemsew Denb Trade Wood &Mud 2731 464860 12,688 94 3,172 23 15,861 17 0 0 15.861 17 118 Koshim PA Ato Denb GtYes Residence Wood &Mud 38 88 464 80 18,071 28 4,517 82 22,589 10 0 0 22,589 10 119 KoshamnPA Ato Kemal Kedir Residence Wood &Muid 2.34 464 80 10,876 23 2,719 06 13,595 29 0 0 13.595 29 120 Koshim PA Ala Gebe Taha Residence Wood .6Mad 225 464 80 10,45791 2,614 48 13,072 39 0 13,072 39 121 KaShffnPA Ato Abubeker ShehMeharned Residence Wood &Mud 45 99 464 80 21,375 98 5,343 99 26,719 97 0 26,719 97 122 1Kashefn PA Ata Hadil Shuba Residence Wood .8Mud 41 6 464.8 19,335 52 4,833 88 24,169 40 10 24,169 40 123 Kashan PA Ala Ousta AmaMnoAtyu Residence Wood&6Mud 68 25 46480 31,722 34 7,930 59 39,652 93 0 39,652 93 124 Koshin PA Ata TeldTerko Residence Woo.d &Mud 27 09 464860 12,591 33 3,147 83 15,739 16 0 15.739 16 125 KashamnPA Ata Damtew AsbO Residence Wood .6Mud 47 82 464 80 19,437 78 4,859 44 24,297 22 _____ 0 24,297 22 126 KoshimnPA Haji Tirtdi Residence Wood &Muid 273 464 80 12Z68894 3,172 23 15,861 17 0 75,861 17 127 KoshamPA Ala Abdi Telbo Residence Wood &Mud 1821 464 80 8,459 29 Z 114 82 10,574 11 0 70,574 11 728 Kashan PA Ala Abidrahmian HapoHaji Residence Wood &Mud 2915 464 80 13,548 87 ,821.30 0 23______1,930100 729 Koshim PA Ata Shikule Addem mg Woo.6&Mud 61 36 30000 78,408 00 4,602.00 23.010 00 02,lo 130 KashimPA Shek Hasen Shek Adem shop Wood & Mud 5 5125 464 80 2.562 19 640 53 3,202 74 0 3.202 74 731 Kashen PA ShekiHasen Shek Adem Residence wood Muid 27 464860 12Z54950 3,137 37 15.686 87 0 15.686 87 732 Koshim PA Ala Husen Edns Residence Wood &Mutd 58 464 80 26.958 78 6,739 53 33,697 73 0 33.697 73 133 KashffnPA Ato Junedi KebsirTahef Residence Wood &Mud 30 464 80 13,94389 3,485 97 17,429 86 0 17,429 86 134 KashinlPA Ala MehamredHall Kasefnk Residence WDod& Muid 25 5 464 80 11.852 30 2,963 08 14.815 38 0 14,815 38 135 KoshinIPA Ala AbulkennmHamidi Residence Wood &Mud 26 01. 464 80 12.089 35 3,022 34 15,71169 0 75.177 69 736 Kashim PA Ala Kemal Telela Residence Wood &Mud 88 92 464 80 47,329 68 10,33242 51,662 10 51620 137 Koshim PA Ala Arba Kedaf Kichen Wood &Mud 75 54 46480O 7.222 93 1,805 73 9.028 67 09086 738 Kashim PA Ala Arba Kedir Residence Wood .6 Mud 34 87 464860 16.179 56 4,044.89 20,224 44 20244 139 Koshini PA Ala Aiba Kednr Residence Wood &Muid 5874 464 80 27.023 25 6,755 81 33,779 06 33790 140 Kashim PA Ala Seid Eko Bucher wood &Mud 30 464 80 13,943 89 3.485 9717496 17,429 86 147 KoshafnPA Shek Kedir Shek Hasen Casette Shop Wood &Mud 22 63 464 80 10,518 34 2,629 58 13,147 92 13479 142 Koshim PA AlaAbre Aman Bucher WoodS&Mud 27 26 464 80 12,670 34 3,167 5915379 15.837 93 143 Koshim PA Ato Abdurhamanl-Haji Adem Residence WoodS Mud 26 68 464 80 12,400 76 3,700 19 7 5,500 95 150 9 144 Kiosham PA Ala Mama Haji'Husen Residence Wood &Mud 35 67 464 80 16,579 28 4,144862 20,724 10 20741 145 Kashim PA Ata Abdela Hasen Shop Wood &Mud 39 5 464 80 18,359 45 4.589 86 22,949 31 22993 16Koshim PA Ata Musa HapiHuLsen Shop Wood &Mud 31 464 80 14,408 68 3.602,17 18,070 85 180 5 147 Koshfn PA Ato Beyn Shek Amadeha Residence wood& Mudf 32 86 464 80 15,273 20 3,878 30 79,091 50 148 KoshiimPA Ala HapiSali GObenaSaY Residence Wood &Mud 28 464 80 13,014 29 3.253 57 16.267 87 0 16.267 87 149 Koshim PA Ala Rode wan SeidAbsyu Residence Wood &Mud 40 28 464 80 18.72199 4,680 50 23.402 49 0 23.402 49 750 KoshimnPA Ala Sali Hajikem Denbeba Residence Wood &Mud 33 48, 464 80 15.56138 3.890 34 19,45772 0 19.451 72 157 KoshbimPA Ala Lema Dejene Residence Wood .6Mud 32 04 464 80 14,892 07 3.723 02 18.61509 0 18.615 09 752 Koshan PA Ala Dalmu HajpHaft Residence Wood &Mud 42 464 80 19.521 44 4,880 36 24.401 80 0 24.401 80 153 Koslffn PA Ala Yemen Abdul Senined Residence Wood& Mud 26 04 464 80 12,106329 3,025 82 15,129 720 15,129 72 754 KoshamPA Ala Teshome Dendene Residence Wood &Mud 17898 464 80 8.378 92 2,079 73 10,398 65 0 10,39865 755 Koshim PA Ala IsamelMehamed Residence Wood &Mudt 24 75 464 80 11,503 71 2,875 93 74.379 63 0 14,379 63 156 KoshafnPA Ala Haji Feko Chef Shop wood &Mudf 48 72 464 80 22Z64487 5,661 22 28,306 09 0 28,306 09 157 Kashlfn PA Denebe Guiye School School Wood &Mud 78 045 464 80 36,275 02 9,068 76 45,343 78 0 45,343 78 158 Koshen PA Ala Satla Kedir Weko Residence Wood .6Mud 17 898 464 80 8.318 92 2,079 73 10,39865 0 10,398 65 159 KoshafnPA Ala Seifu Jima Haji Husen Residence Wood &Mud 77898 464 80 8.318 92 2,079 73 70,39865 0 10,39865 180 Moye Town W/ Ehite Bxr store 6 Shop Wood &Mud 68 6 300 00 20.580 00 5,145 00 25,725 00 0 0 25,725 00 767 Moye TOwn Ala Tadese Beleke Trade Wood &Mudf 19 2 464 80 8,924 09 2,231 02 17,155 11 0 0 11.1551if 162 W4ye Town Ala Desalegne Sheferaw Trade &Residence Wood &Mud 22 8 464 80 10.597 35 2,649 34 13,246 69 0 0 13.246 69 763 Maye Town Ala BefhaneBantyiwalu Residence Wood &Mud 20 8 464 80 9.667 76 2,476 94 12.064 70 0 0 12.084 70 764 MaoTown Al iueseeTrade Wod6Md36 464 80 77,476 34 4,369 08 21,645 42 ______00 21.845 42 165 Mayoeaw Wia BarkeTeshome T rade Wad. Mu, 42 46.480 19.521 44 4,880 36 24,401 80 0 4478 166 MoYe Town Ato Asefa Kebede Trade &Residence Wood &Mud 39 68 464 80 18,443 II4607 2,5 90 3038 167 MOYeTown Ato Takele Har7eMdOl Residence Wood &Mud 27 9 464 80 12,967 81 3,241 95 16,209 77 0 0- 16,209877 168 Woye Town Ato Abera Kidane Residence Wood &Mud 31 2 464 80 14.501864 3,625 41 18,127 05 0 0 18,127 05 169 MoYeTown Wlo Ngsb Eshete Trade S Residence Wood &Mud 35 64 464 80 16,565 34 4,141 33 20,706 67 0 _ ____ 0 - 20,706 67 170 Moye Town Ato Haji Abdo Amda Bekule Pharmacy Wood &Mudl 110 25 464 80 51,243 78 12,810 95 64,054 73 ______0 ______0 64,054 73 171 Moye Town Ato Eshete GermaZewde Store Wood &Mud 35 25 300 00 10,575 00 2,643 75 13,218 75 _____ 0 0 13,218 75 172 Wdye Town Ato K.agnew Amare Mitke Tailor Wood &Mud 35 25 464 80 16,384 07 4,096802 20,460 08 0 0 20.480 08 173 Moye Town wlo Feleku Birhane Zergaw Residence Wood &Mud 64 4 464 80 29,932 88 7,483 22 37,416 09 0 ______0 37,416 09 174 Moye Town Ato &akneh Tegegne Shop Wood &Mud 69 6 464 80 32.349 82 8,087 45 40,437 27 0 0 40,437 27 175 Negele Town Ato Shikun Adem TeaRoom &Store Wood &Mud 80 04 464 80 37,202 29 9,300 57 46,502 86 0 ______0 46,502 86 176 Negele Town Ato Haji Jemal HapiHuSen Store WoodS&Mud 34 1 300 00 10,230 00 2,55750 12,787 50 0 ______0 12,787 50 177 Negele Town HapMeWhamedAbtrAhmed Residence 67TeaRoom Wood &Mud 20 8 464 80 9,667 76 2,416 94 12,064 70 0 _ ____ 0 12Z06470 178 Negele Town Ato GenaHaji Sucher WoodS&Mud 31 2 464 80 14,501 64 3,625 41 18,127 05 0 ______0 18,127 05 179 Negele Town Ato Ahmed Alyu Hotel &Residence WoodS&Mud 61 64 464 80 28,650 04 7,162 51 35,812 55 0 0 35,812 55 180 Negele Town Ato Tura Haji Wdhamed Tea Room WDOdS&Muid 27 14 464 80 12,614 57 3,153 64 15,768 21 0 0 15,768 21 181 Negele Town Ato Muzein Habir Husen Tea Room WoodS&Mud 27 14, 464 80 12Z61457 3,153 64 15,768 21 0 0 15,768 21 182 Negele Town wlo Kasech Adere Hotel WoodS&Muid 33 64 464890 15,635 74 3,008 94 19,544 68 _ ___ 0 0 19,544 68 183 Negele Town Same Residence Wood &Mud 14 85 464680 6,902 22 1,725 56 8,627 78 _____ 0 0 8,627 78 184 Negele Town Ato NunuShek Ahmed Residence Wood &Muid 29 464680 13,479 09 3,369 77 16,848 86 _____ 0 0 16,848 86 165 Hegele Town Same Residence WoodS&Mud 14 88 464 80 6,916 17 1,729 04 6,645 21 0 0 8,645 21 186 Negele Town Ato mehaamedHasen Tea Room Wood &Mud 25 44 464 80 11,824 42 2,956 10 14,780 52 0 0 14,780 52 187 Negele Town Ate Hasen Gobena Tea Room Wood &Muid 125 464 80 58,099 53 14,524868 72.624 41 ______0 0 72,624 41 188 Negele Town Same Residence Wood &Mud 30 24 464 80 14,055 44 3.513 86 17.569230 _____ 0 0 17,569230 189 Hegele Town Ato Kemal Amfda golD Residence woodS&Mud 52 5 464680 24.401 80 6,100 45 30.502 25 _ ___ 0 0 30,502 25 180 Negele Town Ato HapiTure Residence Wood &Mud 2115 464680 9.830 44 2,457 61 12.288 05 _ ___ 0 0 12,26805 191 Negele Town Ato Fekru Hail Kul, Adem Residence Wood &Mud 16 464680 8,366 33 2,09158 10,457 91 _____ 0 _ ____ 0 10,457 91 192 Negele Town Ato Jeyligce Adem Kebu Residence Wood &Mud 38 35 464 80 17,824 93 4,456 23 22,261 17 0 ______22,281 177 193 Negele Town Ato Juned:n Say Sheku Tea Room Wood &Mud 23 7 464860 11,015 67 2,753 92 13,769 59 0 _ ____ 13,769 59 194 Negele Town Ate Husen Roba Trade &Store Wood &Mud 20 09 464860 13,985 72 3,496 43 17,482 15 _____ 0 ______17,482 15 195 Negele Town Ato Abldul Kadir Tekako Residence &Store Wood S Mud 58 41 464 60 27,148675 6.787 19 33,935 93 0 0 33.935 93 196 Negele Town Ato AllyeHailHusen Residence &Shop WoodS&Mud 7134 464 80 33.158 56 8.289 64 41,446 20 0 0 41.448 20. 197 Negele TOwn Ato AbdurAmnan HapiMehamed TradeS&Store Wood &Mud 28 5 464680 13,246 69 3,311 67 16.558 38 0 16.55636 198 Negele Town Ato Kas,m Tesema Hule Store WoodS&Muid 30 300 00 9,000 00 2.250 00 11.250 00 0 11.250 00 199 NegeAeTown Ato HsjpHamda Tekeko Bucher Wood 6 Mud 43 99 464 60 20,446 39 5.111 60 25.557 968_____ 0 25.557 96 200 Negele Town Ate Husen Haji Amano Shop Wood &Mud 41 26 464680 19,186679 4.796 70 23.983 468 ______0 0 23.963 46 201 Negele Town Ato Ahmed Hajilsman Kobelo Shoe Woodf6 Mud 35668 46480o 16,676 69 4.169 22 20.646 11 ______0 0 20.646 11 202 Negele Town Ato Mehamed Hap Gena Tufa RestaurantS& shop WoodS&Mud 50 25 464 80 23,356 01 5,639 00 29,195 01 _____0 0 29,195 01 203 Negele Town Alo Husen Shekena Wako Restaurant &Store WoodS9Mud 53 94 464 80 25,071 11 6,267 76 31.338 6688____ 0 0 31,336 66 204 Negele Town AtoMehamed AhmnedElo Tea Room woodS&Mud 37 74 464680 17.541 41 4.385 35 21,926 76 ______0 21,926 76 205 Negete Town Ato HajiAmnan Wake Store Wood &Mud 29 300 00 8.700 00 2,175 00 10,875 00 ______0 _ ____ 10,675 00 206 Negete Town Ato Temam Mehamed Jara Residence &Tailor Wood &Mud 34 68 464680 16.119 13 4,029 76 20.146 92 ______0 ______20.14692 207 Negele Town Same Residence S Tailor Wood &Mud 34 83 464680 16.188 85 4.047 21 20,236 06 0 ______20,236 06 206 NegeAeTown ShekuhtAdem Mill Wood &Mud 6136 200 00 18.408 00 4,602 00 23,010 00 0 23.010 00 209 Negele Town Shek Asen Shek Adem Shop Wood & Mud 5 5125 464 80 2.562 19 640 55 3,202 74 0 0 3,202 74 210 Negele Town Same Residence WoodS&Mud 27 464680 12,54950 3,137 37 15.686 67 0 15,666 67 211 Negete Town Ate Husen Endos Residence Wood S Mud 56 464 80 26.956 18 6.739 55 33,697 73 0 33,697 73 212 Negele Town Ate Jund, Keb,r Tahir Residence Wood &Mud 30, 464680 13.643689 3.485_97_ 17,429686 0 17.429866 213 Negele Town Ato Mehamed HapiKasffn Residence WoodS&Mud 25 5 464 80 11.852 30 2.963 06 14,815 36 0 14,81538 214 Negele Town Ato Abdul kenm Hamda Residence WoodS& Mud 26 01 464 80 12.089 35 3.022 34 15,111 69 0 ______15,111 69 215 Negele Town Ate Kemal Telilo Residence Wood 6 Mud 6892 464680 41,329 68 10,332 42 51,662 10 0 ______51,662 10 216 Negele Town Ate Areha Kedir Kichen Wood &Mud 15 54 464680 7.222 93 1.805 73 9,026 67 ______0 ______9,026 67 217 Negele Town Same Residence Wood &Mud 34681 464680 16.179 56 4.044689 20,224 44 0 20,224 44 216 Negele Town Same Residence Wood &Mud 5814 464680 27,023 25 6,755681 33,779 06 0 33,779 06 219 Negate Town Ate Seid Eke Bucher WoodS&Mud 30 464 80 13,94369 3,465 97 17,429 86 0 17.429866 220 Negele Town Shek Ked,rShek Asen Shop WoodS& Mud 22 63 -464680 -10.51634 2.629 56 13,147 92 0 0 13,147 92 221 Negele Town Ate AbireAman Bucher WoodS&Mud 27261 464680 12,670 34 3,167 59 15,837 93 0 15.637 93 222 Negele Town AteAA urahman=Hpademn Resdence Wod Mud 26 66 464 80 12.40076 3,100 19 15,500 95 0 15,50095 223 NegeAeTow IAteMm a ue Residne Wood 6 Mud 35 67 464680 16.5'79 2 4,_144_82_ 20,724 10 020,724 10 224 Negt Town I Ate AbdfelaHasen iShop Wood 6 Mud 39 5 464 8 18,359 45 4.569686 22,949 31 0 0 22.949 31 225I Negate Town I Ate Musa HapiHusen iShop Wood 6 Mud 31 4646 14,408666 3,602 17 16,0106 0 0 16,010685 226 Negele Town Ato Beyan Shek Abdurahman Residence Wood &Mud 32 86 464 80 15,273 20 3,818 30 19,09150 0 19,091 50 227 Sife Town Ato Ousman Amino Hotel i'.V00&iimud 25 500 00 12,500 00 3,125 00 15,625 00 _ ___ 0 0 15.625 00 228 Sire Town WloBertukan Mekonen Desta Te8laHouse Wood &Mud 38 335 464 80 17,81796 4,454 49 22,272 45 _ ___ 0 0 22.272 45 229 Sire Town Ato Bethu Abebje Residence &Trade Wood &Mud 50 41 464 80 23,430 38 5,857 59 29,287 97 0 0 29.287 97 230 Sire Town Wlo Bekelech zerfu Residence &Trade Wood &Mud 40 32 46480 18,740 58 4,685 15 23,425 73 0 0 23.425 73 231 SiweTown Ato AkIItuDejene Residence &Trade Wood &Mud 36 58 464 80 17,002 25 4,250 56 21,252 81 0 0 21.252 81 232 Sire Town Ato Zenebe Ayele Residence Wood &Mud 99 1a 464 80 46.098 49 11,524 62 57.623 11 0 0 57.623 11 233 1Sire Town lBroftherss Residence WoodS&Mud 66 5 464 80 30,908 95 7,727 24 38,636 18 0 0 38,636 18 Section 3 -Golotcha Mechara 234 Debre Selam Wlo Zehara Nura Residence Wood &Mud 26 66 464 80 12,39147 3,097 87 15,48933 0 0 15.48933 235 Debre Selam Wlo Yesunesh H/Macam Residence wood &Mud 57 51 464 80 26,730 43 6,682 61 33,413 04 0 0 33.413 04 236 Debre Setam Wlo Sofia Abdi Residence WoodS&Mud 25 42 49480O 11,815 12 2,953 78 14,768890 0 0 14,768900 237 DebreSetani Wlo Abiba0Dasa Residence WoodS&Mud 25 42 464 80 11,815 12 2,953 78 14,768 90 0 0 14.76890 238 Debre Setam Wlo Zeinu Dade Residence WoodS&Mud 2-~852 4T6480O 13,255399 3,314 00 16,569 98 0 0 16,569 98 239 Debre Selam Ato Haitye Feysa Residence Wood &Mud 13 02. 464 80 6,051 65 1,512 91 7,56456 0 0, 7,564 56 240 Debre Setam Ato Kebede Abera Residence TatchLd Roof 7 065 - - - eoo 150 750 750 00 241 Debre Setam Ato Oumer Hanida Residence Tatched Roof 4 1527 - 00 150 750 750 00 242 Debre Setam Ato Husen Tutu Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 --- 600 150 750 750 00 243 Debre Selam Ato Mama Abdela Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 - - - 800 1,50 750 750 00 244 Debre Setam Ato Abdo Bedaso Residence WoodS&Mud 20 464 80 9,295 92 2,323 98 11,619 91 011691 245 Kortu PA Wlo Tenagne G/Michaet Woikye Residence Wood SMud 16 464 80 7,436 74 1,859 18 9,295 92 ______9,295 92 246 Kortu PA Ate Eshetu Getahun Abebe Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 ______600____ ISO ___ 750 750 00 247 Kortu PA Ato Husen Ouso Beker Residence WoodS&Mud 20, 464 80 9,295 92 2,323 98 11.619 91 0 0 11,619 9 248 Koitu PA Ate Muse Ouso Oda Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 ______750600 750 00 249 Same Same Residence WoodS&Mud 30 464 80 13.943 89 3.485 97 17,42986 ______0 _ ____ 0 17,429 86 250 Kortu PA Ato Desaategce Berhanut-Haile Residence WoodS&Mud 80 464 80 37,183 70 9.295 92 46.479 92 _____0 0 46.479 62 251 Same Same Store WoodS&Mud 1722 30000 51.660 00 12,915 00 64,575 00 0 0 6__575__ 252 Kortu PA Ato Juhar Beke rAh-med Residence Wood &Muid __85 464 80 39,507 68 9,876 92 49.364 60 ______49__3__4__60 233 Same Same Residence WoodS&Mud 3653 464 80 16.988 30 4,247 08 21.235 38 0 0 21,235 38____ 254 Kortu PA Ato KetY Residence WoodS&Mud 4086 464 80 18,963 69 4,740 92 23,704 61 0 0 23.704 61 255 Kortu PA Ato Mehamed HajitIbrahim Residence Wood &Mud 86 7 464 80 40,297 83 10,074 46 50.372 29 0 0 50,372 2 256 KoiIu PA Wlo SeadaAti Residence WoodS&Mud 172 2 464 80 80,037 91 20,009 48 100.047 38 0 0 100.047 38 257 Kortu PA Ato Tefera Worku Residence Wood &Mud 85 464 80 39,507968 9,876 92 49,364 60 0 0 49.384860 258 Kortu PA Wio Debra G./Maanam Residence Wood &Mud 44 64 464 80 3,4505.187 13 25,935 63 ____ _ 0 25,935 63 259 Koitu PA Wie Zemzem Haft Residence Wood &Mud 48 464 80 22,310 22 5.577 55 27,887 77 0_____ 0 27,687 77 280 Kortu PA Ato Wehamedt Zeynu Residence Wood &Mud 86 7 464 80 40,297 83 10,074 46 50.372 29 0______50_372_29 261 Kortu PA WiOTirunesh, Dubale Residence Wood &Mud 92 4 46480 42,947 17 10.736 79 53,683 96 _____ 0 0 53.683 96 262 Kortu PA W/o Yesunesh 0./Hana Residence Wood &Mud 136711 464 80 63,542 29 15.885 57 79.427 86 ______0 0 79.427866 263 Kortu PA Ato Siraj Atiye Ahdi Residence WoodS&Mud 148 5 464 80 69,022 24 17.255 56 86.277860 ______0 0 86.277860 264 Kortu PA Ato Ka'luWiManam Residence Wood SMud 105 464 80 48,903 60 12.200 90 61,004,50 0_____ 0 61,004 50 265 Kortu PA Ato K am# Sed&kWedai Residence HCB 100 04 1.000 00 100,040 00 25.010 00 125.050 00 0_____ 0_____ 125___050_____ 266 Mechara Town Atcehmed Omda Ako Store WoodS&Mud 92 4 300 00 27,720 00 6,930 00 34.950 00 0 0 34.650 00 267 Mediate Town Ato Mejina Abdulahi Store Wood SMud 136 71 300 00 41,013 00 10,253 25 51,266 25 0______51,266 25____ 268 Meciate Town Shek Taha tradeb Wood &Mud 148 5 464 80 69,022 24 1 17.255 56 86.277 80 _6_277_60 0 0 269 Mechara Town Ato Getarchew Manekul Pharmnacy HCB lOS 1.000 00 105,000 00 26,250 00 131.250 00 ______131___250____ 270 Mechara Town Ato Aby Ahmed shop HCB _____ 100 04 1 1,000 00 100,040 00 25,010 00 125,050 00 0 0 12,050 0 271 Mediate Town Ato oexde Shop HCB 90 1,000 00 90.000 00 22.500 00 I12.500 00 _____0__ 0 0 1Same 272 Same Shop HCB 420 1,00000 420,000 00 105.000 00 525.000 00 ______525__000___ 273 MeChara Town Ate Abdulkadie Yuye Shop HCB ______76 26 1,000 00 76.260 00 19.065 00 95.325 00 0______95,325 00____ 274 Mediate Town Ate Sani Abrha Shop HCB 5_____4 06 1,000 00 54,060 00 13,515 00 97,575 00 ______0_____ 67,575 00___ 275 Mechara Town Ale Husen Abijetal Resndence HCB 36 1,000 00 36.000 00 9,000 00 45.000 00 _____ 0 ______0 45.000 00 276 Mediate Town Ato Hamid Hasen Residence HCB 36 1.000 00 36.000 00 9.000 00 45.000 00 _____ 0 ______0 45.000 00 277 Mechara Town Ale Hamed siraj Residence Wood SMud 36 46480u 16.732 66 4,183 17 20.915983 0_____ 0______320,915 278 Mediara Town Ato Yusuf Shek- Bereka Store Coffee HCB 1 361 600 00 21,600 00 5.400 00 27,000 00 0 _ ____ 0 22,000 00 279 Mediara Town Ato Hamed Hasen Residence Wood SMud 36 464 80 16.732 66 4.18317 20.915 83 0_____ 20,915 83______280 AecharaM Town Ato Lute Behabtu Residence WoodS&Mud 361 46480 16.732 66 4.183 17 20.915 83 0_____ 20,915 83______281 MedharaTown Ato Sani Haji IResidence Wood SMud 51 841 464 80 1 24.095 04 6.023 76 30.118 79 ______282 MaChareTown Ata Mehamed Abdulahi Residence Wood &Mudf 456 464 80 21,194 71 5,298 68 26.493 38 0 0 26,493 38 283 Machara Town Ata Mahamed Sheka Adem Residence Wood &Mud 46 8 464 80 21.752 46 5,438 12 27,190-58 0 0 27,190 58 284 MachamaTown Wio Sofia Hlasen trade Wood &Mud 40 92 464 80 19,019 46 4,754 87 23,774 33 _ ____ 0 0 23,774 33 285 Mechara Town Wlo Amina/-Hasen Tea Roam Wood &Mud 191 09 464 80 88,817 91 22.204 48 111,022 368_____ 0 0 111,022 38 286 Mechara Town Alo abrham Sheka Tea Roam Woodf&Mud 191 09 464 80 88,817 91 22.204 48 111,022 38 ______0 0 111,022 36 287 MeCharaTown Wlo AlIma lssa Tea Roam Wood &Mud 191 09 464 60 68,817 91 22.204 46 111,022 38 0 0 111,022 38 288 Mechara Town Ata Mehamed Ah Tea Roam Wood &Mud 74 52 464 80 34,638 61 8,659 15 43,295 77 0 0 43. 295 77 289 Mechara Town Ato San HaltMehamed Shop Wood & Mud 102 08 464 80 47,446 40 11,861960 59,308 00 0 0 59,308 00 290 MfecharaTown Ato Ahimed Mehamed trade Wood & Mud 102 08 464860 47,448 40 11.861 60 59,308 00 0 0 59,308 00 291 Mechara Town Ata Muluka Kasefn trade Wood &Mud 10208 464 80 47,446 40 11,861 60 59,308 00______0 0 59,308 00 292 Mechara Town Sek Fans Buser trade Wood &Mud 102 08 464 80 47.446 40 11,861 60 59.308900______0 0 59,308 00 293 Machare Town Ato Tofik Husen Res,dence&store Wood &Mud 141 05 464680 65,559 51 16,369 88 81,949 38 0 0 81,949 38 294 M4echara Town Ato nuru Ahmed For Trade Wood &Mud 141 05 464 80 65,559 5I 16,389868 81,949 38 _ ____ 0 _ ____ 0 81,949 38 295 Mechara Town Wlo YewdarBegashaw For Trade Wood &Mud 44 2 464680 20,543 99 5.136 00 25.679 99 _ ____ 0 _ ____ 0 25,679 99 298 Mechara Town Alo Jemal Meharned For Trade Wood &Mud 4421 464 80 20,543 99 5.136 00 25,679 99 ______0 0 25,679 99 297 Mechara Town Ato AbdurehmnanOusamn For Trade Massonary &CIS 44 2 1,20000 53,040 90 13,260900 66,300 00 ______0 0 66,3900 0 298 Micheta Town HajiAhimedHusen Store Wood &Mud 108 300900 32,400 00 8.100 00 40,500o ______0 ______0 40,500 00 299 Micheta Town Wlo Ked,reShek Ahmed store Wood &Muid 86 45 300 00 25,935 00 6,483 75 32,418 75 _____0 0 32,418 75 300 Same Same residence Wood &Muid 615 464 80 28,584.97 7,146824 35,73121 ______0 0 35,731 21 201 Micheta Town AtoMeh-amed Abdutahi Oxede residence Wood &Mud ISO 464680 69,719 43 17,429 86 87.149 29 _ ___ 0 ______0 87,149 29 302 MIrheta Town Coffee Bord(Store) residence Wood &Muid 336 2 464 80 156,264 48 39,088 12 195,320 61 0 ______0 195,320 61 303 Micheta Town WlcOAlmaz Desta residence Wood &Mud 13653 464 80 63,458 63 15.864 66 79,323 28 0 ______0 79,323 28. 304 Micheta Town Ato Wehamed Shek Abdurehim Residence Wood &Mud 3151 464 80 14,641 08 3.660 27 18,301 35 ______0 0 18,201 35 205 MAichetaTown WioShtu Abebe Residence Wood & Mud 486 464 80 22,589 10 5.647 27 28,236 37 0 0 28,236 37 306 Micheta Town Ato Jamal Ahmed residence Wood &Mud 752 464 80 34,952 67 8,738 17 43,690684 0 0 43.690 64 207 Micheta Town Ato Aliu Abdo Residence Wood &Mud 45 59 464 80 21,190 08 5,29751 26,487 57 0 0 26.487 57 308 Micheta Town Ato Negete Mekonen Residence Wood &Mud 66 24 464860 20,768810 7,697 03 38.485 13 ______0 0 38,485 13 309 Micheta Town wlo Zehara Kasffm Residence Wood &Mud 423 464 80 19,660 88 4,915 22 24,576 10 0 0 24,576 10 310 Micheta Town Ato Tiruneh Neway Store Wood &Mud 426 300900 12Z78000 3,195 00 15,975 00 ______0 0 15.975 00 311 Micheta Town Shek Abdelaadem store Wood &Mud 6138 300 00 18,414 00 4,603 50 23,017 50 _ ___ 0 0 23,017 50 312 Micheta Town ato Husen Mume Residence Wood &Mud 50 64 464 80 23,630 24 5,907 56 29,537680 ______0 0 29,537 80 313 MfichetaTown W/o Aster ItWeld Residence Wood &MLud 492 464 80 22,867 97 5.716 99 28.584 97 ______0 0 28.584 97 314 Micheta Town Ala Kebede Demise Residence Wood &Mud 30 464 80 13,943 89 3.485 97 17.429 86 ______0 _ ____ 0 17,429.866 315 Micheta Town wlo Zed~e- Demise Residence Wood &Mud 50 05 464 80 23.263 05 5.815 76 29.078 81 ______0 _ ____ 0 29,078 81 316 Micheta Town Ato Feteke Kasa Residence Wood &Mud 50 05 464 80 23.263 05 5,815 76 29,078 81 _ ___ 0 ______0 29,078 81 317 Micheta Town Wlo Worke Bettachew Residence Wood &Mud 2709 464 80 12,591 33 3.147 83 15,739 16 ____ 0 ______0 15,739 16 318 Micheta Town Ato Mume Iso Residence Wood 8 Mud 62 22 464680 28,919 82 7.229 91 36,149.53 ______0 0 36,149 53 319 Micheta Town Ato HlWeld Reta Residence Wood &Muid 70 4 464680 32.721 65 8,180 41 40,902 07 0 0 40,902 07 320 Micheta Town Ato Zenebe Lemna Residence Wood &Mud 55 8 464 80 25.935 63 8,483 91 32,419 54 0 0 32Z41954 321 Micheta Town Same Residence Wood &Mud 76 32 464 80 35,473 25 8,868 31 44,341 56 0 0 44,341 58- 322 Mlcheta Town Ato Tesfa Terefe Residence Wood &Mud 486 464 80 22.589 10 5,647 27 28,236 37 ______0 0 28,236 37 323 Micheta Town Ato Demirew Haile Residence Tatched Roof 174 - 8 00 150 750 750 00 324 Same Same Residence Wood &Mud 42 63 464680 19.814 26 4,953 57 24,767 83 0 0 24,767 83 325 Micheta Town Ato ShernfHasen Residence Wood &Mud 435 464 60 20,218 64 5,054 66 25.273 29 0 0 25.273 29 326 Micheta Town Wlo Getu zewde Residence Tatched Roof 18 - - . 600 150 750 750 00 327 Mtcheta Town WlboGetu zewde Residence Wood &Mud 241 464 80 11,155 II 2,788 78 13,943 89 0 0 13,943 89 328 Micheta Town Ato Mebrate Tadese Residence Tatched Roof 49 6 - . - 600 150 750 750 00 329 M,rchetaTown Ato Husen Mehamed Residence Tatchud Roof 60 . - . 600 150 750 750 00 330 Kortu PA Ato Harun Husen Oumer Residence Wood &Mud 46 2 464 80 21,473 58 5,368 40 26,841 98 0 0 26,841 98 331 Kortu PA Ato M#ohamedHamon Hapo Residence Wood &Mud 43 8 464 80 20,358 07 5,089 52 25,44759 _____ 01 0 25,447 59 332 Kortu PA Ato Yas, Yusuf Mahamed Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 . - - 600 ISO 750 750 00 333 Kortu PA Ato Kedir Irere Beayo Residence Tatched Roof 7065 - - - 600 1SO 7.50 750 00 334 Ko,tu PA Ato Mahamed Ibrahim Abdeta Residence Wood &Mud 6_0 464 60 27,887 77 6,971 94 34,859 72 0 0 34.859 72 335 Kortu PA Ato Sude Dad, Residence Tatched Roof 4 9063 - - .600 150 750 750 00 336 Kortu PA Ato Taha Kasim Oiner Residence Wood &Mud 38 6 -.- 600 150 750 750 00 337 Ko,l PA Ato Muktar Jimae Residence Tatched Roof 4 9063 - 600 150 750 750 00 38otuPA lAto AbdeataAmere iResidence Tatched Roof 7 065 --- 690 150 7501 750 00 339 Karlu PA Same Residence Wood &Mud 46 464980 22,310 22 5,577 55 27,887 77 0 27877 340 Kortu PA Shek OumerAmye Residence Wood &Mud 32 76 300 00 9,828 00 2,45700 12,285 00 0 _____Z__ 2285 00 341 Kortu PA Alo kiehamed Bedaso Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 - - - 600 150 750 750 00 342 Kortu PA Ato Ousman Hasen Residence Wood &Mud 38 43 300 00 11,529 00 2,682 25 14,411 25 0 0 14,411 25 343 Kortu PA Ato Abdela Yesuf Residence Wood &Mud 12 56 464860 5,837 84 1.459 46 7,297 30 0 0 7,297 30 344 KorIu PA Ato Abdela Ahmedd Residence Woodl&Mud 30 464960 13,943689 3.465 97 17,429686 0 _ ____ 0 17,429 86 345 KoMuPA Ato Abdul ManOusman Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 - - 600 150 750 750 00 346 K,ortuPA Ato Adem Musa Residence Tatched Roof 7 065 - 6001 150 750 750 00 347 Koilu PA Ato isa Adem Residence Tatched Roof 4 9063 _____--600 150 750 750 00 348 Kortu PA Ato AbdeataMume Residence Wood &Mud 5 300 00 1,500 00 375 00 1,875 00 0 0 1,875 00 349 Trenuga Town Alo Ahmed Hametoye Haye Amtaw Store Wood &Mud 75 300 00 22,500 00 5,625 00 28,1 25 00 0 0 28,125 00 350 TrmugaTown Ato Mohamed Al,y Stoem Wood &Mud 6859 300 00 20,870 00 5,167 50 25,837 50 _ ___ 0 0 25,837 50 351 Timuga Town Ato Mehamed Ahmed Adem Residence Wood &Mud 31 92 464 80 14,836 29 3.709 07 18,545 37 0 0 18,545 37 352 Timuga Town Ato OumerMeahamed Oumfer Residence Wood &Mud 37 5 484 80 17,429 88 4.357 46 21.787 32 0 0 21,787 32 353 Timuga Town Ato lbrah,mnMehamed AbdmD store Wood &Mud 501 300 00 15,000 00 3.750 00 1 18,750 00 0 0 18,750 00 354 TimuigaTown Alo Mehamied Awel Yesuf MN Wood &Mud 72 300 00 21,600 00 5,400 00 27,000 00 0 0 27.000 00 355 Tintuga Town Ato Yesuf Baker Residence Wood &Mud 64 464 80 29,746 96 7,436 74 37,183 70 _____ 0 0 37,183 70 356renga Town Ato Ahmed HajiAdem M1ll Wood &Mud 37 17 300 00 11.151 00 2777 3987 3987 357 TffmugaTown Ato Wube Rimsa Residence Wood &Mud 45 99 464 80 21,375 98 5,343 99 26,719 97 0 0 26.719 97 358 refnuga Town Ato adam Gula Residence Wood &Mud 98 464 80 45,550 03 11,387 51 56,937 54 _____ 0 0 56.937 54 359 Timuga Town Ato Ahmed Abdulahi Residence Wood &Mud 44 1 464 80 20,497 51 5,124 38 25,621 89 0 0 25,621 89 380 TimnugaTown Ato Ahmedin Halitbrahim Residence Wood &Mud 36 96 464 80 17,178 87 4,294 72 21,473 58 ______0 0 21.473 58 361 Tffnuga Town Alo Abdela Isa Musa Residence wood &Mud 24 8 464890 11,526 95 2,881 74 14,40868 0 0 14.408 68 362 ThmugaTown Shek Kedir Ahmled Residence Wood &Mud 49 2 464 80 22,86797 5,716 99 28,584 97 _____ 0 0 28.584 97 363 Timuga Town Ala nlgusellma Store Wood &Mud 79 8 300 00 23~,940 00 5,985 00 29,925 00 _____ 0 0 29,925 00 364 Timuga Town Ato Zeyad tryu Haji Mill Wood &Mud 89 06 30000 267,7800 6,679 50 33,397 50 0 0 33,397 50 365 Ti-mugaTown At, mehamed Said Ak Residence Wood &Mud 558 464 80 25,935 63 6,483 91 32,419 54 0 0 32,419 54 366 Timuga Town Alo Abdurehman Ayele Trade Wood &Mud 30 464 80 1.4893,485 97 17,429 86 0 0 7428 367 Timuga Town Ala AhiyuTehil, Trade Wood &Mud 43 8 454 80 20,358 07 5,089 52 25,447 59 ______0 0 25,447 59 368 Tffnuga Town Ala Mehamed Ahtmed Residence Wood &Mud 53 32 46480o 24,782 93 6,195 73 30,978 67 0 0 30,978 67 369 rffnuga Town Ala Adem Elias store Wood &Mud 29 5 300 00 8,850 00 2,212 50 11,062 50 0 0 11.062 50' 370 rffnuga Town Ala Hasen Ahmed Store Woodf& Mud 4511 300 00 13,53000 3,382 50 16.912 50 0 0 16.912 50 371 Trtnuga Town Ato AkuMWhamfed Residence Wood &Mud 97651 464 80 45,387 35 11.346 84 56.734 19 0 0 56.734 19 372 Temuga Town Ato Sadik Bulbo Residence Wood &Mud 39 52 464 8-0 18.368 75 4.592 19 22.960 93 0 ______0 22,960 93 373 renuga Town Ala Esmael Gir R'sidence Wood &Mud 30 96 464 80 14.390,09 3,597 52 17,987 61 ______0 _____ 0 17.987 61 374 Timuga Town Ala Tajidan Adam Residence Woodf& Muid 27 72 464 80 12,864.15 3,221 04 16,105 19 _____ 0 0 16,105 19 375 TimnugaTown Ala Mehamed Abro Tea Room Wood &Mud 27 72 464 80 12,884 15 3,221 04 16,105 19 0 0 16,105 19 376 TefnugaTown Ato Ahmedl-Hamed Tea Room Wood &Mud 25 2 464 80 11,712 86 2,928 22 14,641 08 ______0 _____ 0 14.64108 377 iTimuga Town Ala Abdeta Ibmo Trade Wood &Mud 24 464 80 11.155 11 2.788 78 13,943 89 _ ___ 0 0 13.943 89 378 Timuga Town Ala Derrae Mekonen shop Wood &Mud 31 45 484 80 14,617 84 3.654 46 18.272 30 0 0 18.272 30 379 1rimuga Town Ala ZernhunMamao Shop Wood &Mud 334 48480 15,542 79 3.885 70 19.428 48 ______0 0 19,428 48 380 T-imugaTown Shek Hasen Abdela Shop Wood &Mud 33 44 464 80 15,542 79 3.885 70 19,428 48 ______0 0 19,42848 381 Timuga Town Ala Hasen oumer Shop Wood &Mud 3286 464 80 15.273 20 3.818 30 19,091 50 ______0 0 19,091 50 382 TffmugaTown Ala Wahamed Tado Residence Wood &Mud 324 464 80 15.059 40 3,764 85 18,824 25 ______0 0 18,824 25 383 Timuga Town Ala Tejed Haji Abmed Trade Wood &Mud 378 484860 17.569 30 4,392 32 21,961 62 ______0 0 21,961 62 384 TimuigaTown Ala Abrham Jara Trade Wood &Mud 26 6 464860 12,363 58 3,090 89 15,454 47 ______0 0 15,45447 385 Ti'muga Town Aato Jemal Ahmed Trade Wood &Mud 2756 464 80 12,809 78 3,202 45 16,012 23 ______0 0 18,012 23 386 TimnugaTown Ala Kedir Ware bucher Wood &Mud 80 25 464 80 37,299 90 9,324 97 46,624 87 0 0 46,624 87 387 Tffnuga Town Ala Mehamed Abdule shop Wood &Mud 29 6 464 80 13,757 97 3.439 49 17,197 46 0 0 17,19746 388 ThuLgs Town Ala Ibrahim Abdurehman Residence Wood &Mud 3386 464 80 15,710 11 3,927 53 19,837 84 0 0 19.637 64 389 Tffnuga Town Alo Musa Mumedi Re,sidence Wood &Muid 43 16 464 80 20,060 60 5,015 15 25,075 76 0 0 25.0 75 76 390 refnuga Town Ala AbdurLhman Hasen Residence Wood &Mud 42 33 464 80 19.674 82 4,918 71 24,593 53 ______0 0 24.593 53 391 Timuga Town Wlo Kenya Golu Residence Wood &Mud 38181 464 80 17,745 92 4,438 48 22,182 40 0 0 22,182 40 392 T-imugaTown Ala Mehaed Oufner Residence Wood &Mud 40 261 300 00 12,078 00 3.019 50 15.097 50 ______0 0 15,097 50 393 Trenuga Town Ala Ase Gale Store Wood &Mud 86 300 00 25, 800 00 6,450 00 32,250 00 ______0 0 32,250 00 394 rimnugaTown Ala AhrmedBedbo Residence Wood &Mud 91 671 484 80 42,60787 10,651 97 53,259684 ______0 0 53,259684 395 Timugs Town IAlo Slash, Meketa Trade Wood &Mud 45 881 464 80 21,324 85 5,331 21 26,656 06 ______0 0l 26.656 06 396 Timuga Town AtoochechchaSloehS Shop Wood SMud 198 46480 9,20296 2,30074 11,50371 0 0 11.50371 397 Timuga Town Ato Hasen Husen Residence Wood &Mud 366 46480 17,011 S4 4,25289 21,26443 _ _ _ _ 0 0 21,28443 398 TimnugaTown Ato ehameijKefifa Residence Wood &MuLd 31 464 80 14,408 68 3,602.17 18,01085 _0 0 18,01085 399 Timuga Town Ato Ahmed Mume Ibno Residence Wood &Mud 522 464 80 24.262 36 6,065 59 30.327 95 0 0 30,327 95 400 Timuga Town Ato Jafat Hajl Mill Wood &Mud 77 72 300 00 23,318 00 5,829 00 29,145 00 0 0 29.145 00 401 Timuga Town Wlo Wagaye Tesfaye Residence Wood &Mud 5785 464 80 26,88846 6,722 12 33,610 58 0 0 33,610 58 402 Sarne Same Tea Room Wood &Mud 39 464 80 18,127 05 4,531 76 22,658 82 0 0 22,65B 82 403 Trmuga Town Ato Altye Amedi Residence Wood &Mud 34 2 464 80 15,896 03 3,974 01 19,870 04 O 0 19,87004 404 Timoga Town Ala Gaa Fato Residence Wood &Mud 52 8 46480 24,541 24 6,135 31 30,676 55 0 30,676 55 405 Timuga Town Ato ZiadA8 Residence Wood &Mud 92 464 80 4,276 13 1,.06903 5,345 16 _0_ _ 0 0 5,345 16 406 Tlmuga Town Wlo Wesen Si7eshi Residence Wood &iMud 8775 46480 40,785 87 io 196 47 50.982 33 0 0° 50,982 33 Totat ______I 7,984,676 73 1 ,996,_169.18 9_980 845_92 48, 751.25 10,029,597.17 Annex Seven
List of Vulnerable PAPs
Dera - Chole Section
No. Town / PA Name of the Household Kebele House Age Gender Reason for Vulnerability ______Head No. Ag Gedr RaofrVunablt 1. Dera Town Ato Nuru Mohamed 02 394 78 Male Old Age 2. Sire Town Ato Ousman Amino 01 288 70 Male Old Age Female Household Head 3. Sire Town W/o Birtukan Mekonen Desta 01 703 70 Female and Old Age 4. Sire Town W/o Bekelech Zerfu 01 263 None Female Female Household Head 5. Sire Town W/o Merima Gendo Tona 01 None 43 Female Female Household Head 6. Koshim PA Ato Derib GNYes Koshim None 80 Male Old Age 7. Koshim PA Ato Telil Terko Koshim None 65 Male Old Age
Chole - Gololecha Section
No. Town / PA Name of the Household Kebele House No. Age Gender Reason for Vulnerability Head 1. Chole Town Ato Gashaw Alemu 01 None 60 Male Old Age 2. Derartu PA Ato Kedi Jima Derartu None 60 Male Old Age 3. Derartu PA Ato Julo Iroba Derartu None 64 Male Old Age 4. Derartu PA W/o Genu Abdi Derartu None 40 Female Female Household Head 5. Derartu PA W/o Alima Mohamed Derartu None 53 Female Female Household Head Female Household Head 6. Derartu PA W/o Zemzem Horo Derartu None 60 Female and Old Age None Female Household Head 7. Derartu PA W/o Widnesh Derartu 65 Female and Old Age 8. Magna Hadere PA Ato Ebu Geda Hadere None 70 Male Old Age
RAP, Dera- Mechara, Vulnerable Groups No. Town / PA Name of the Household Kebele House No. Age Gender Reason for Vulnerability Head
9. Magna Hadere PA Ato Sulti Ali Hadere None 60 Male Old Age 10. Haro PA W/o Dasash Admas Haro None 28 Female Female Household Head 11. Haro PA Ato Kebede Haile Haro None 80 Male Old Age 12. Haro PA W/o Rase Abebe Haro None 36 Female Female Household Head 13. Legebuna PA Ato Legese Debele Legebuna None 58 Male 14. Legebuna PA Ato Jibril Kelil Adem Legebuna None 60 Male Old Age 15. Wendo Gasha PA Ato Dbele Shegu Jima Yae Gugu None 65 Male Old Age 16. Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kasim Gobe Yae Gugu None 65 Male Old Age 17. Wendo Gasha PA Shek Esmael Chole Yae Gugu None 70 Male Old Age 18. Wendo Gasha PA Ato Kedir Bati Roba Yae Gugu None 60 Male Old Age 19. Moye PA W/o Ehite Birr 01 None 60 Female Female and Old Age 20. Moye PA Ato Birhane Bantyiwalu 01 None 61 Male Old Age 21. Moye PA W/o Birke Teshome 01 None 27 Female Female Household Head 22. Moye PA W/o Nigsti Eshete 01 None 50 Female Female Household Head Ato Haji Abdo Amda 23. Moye PA Bekule 01 None 90 Male Old Age w/o Feleku Birhane 24. Moye PA Zergaw 01 None NA Female Female Household Head 25. Negele PA W/o Kasech Adere 01 None 35 Female Female 26. Negele PA Ato Shikuri Adem 01 None 62 Male Old Age Ato Haji Jemal Haji 27. Negele PA Husen 01 None 70 Male Old Age Haji Mehamed Abir 28. Negele PA Ahmed 01 None 80 Male Old Age
RAP, Dera- Mechara, Vulnerable Groups Goloicha - Mechara Section
No. Town / PA Name of the Household Kebele House No. Age Gender Reason for Vulnerability Head Debre Selam 1. (Chnacho town) W/o Zehara Nura 01 None 32 Female Female Household Head Debre Selam 2. (Chnacho town) W/o Yesunesh H/Mariam 01 None 48 Female Female Household Head Debre Selam Female Household Head 3. (Chnacho town) W/o Sofia Abdi 01 None 16 Female and Old Age Debre Selam Female Household Head 4. (Chnacho town) W/ o Abiba Dasa 01 None 80 Female and Old Age Debre Selam Female Household Head 5. (Chnacho town) W/o Zeinu Dade 01 None 60 Female and Old Age 6. Timuga PA Ato Wube Rima 01 None 70 Male Old Age 7. Timuga PA Ato Ahmed Abdulahi 01 None 60 Male Old Age 8. Timuga PA Ati mehamed Seid Ali 01 None 67 Male Old Age 9. Timuga PA Ato Kedir Ware 01 None 73 Male Old Age 10. Timuga PA Ato Musa Mumedi 01 None 60 Male Old Age 11. Timuga PA Ato Abdurehman Hasen 01 None 70 Male Old Age 12. Timuga PA W/o Kenya Golu 01 None 25 Female Female Household Head 13 Timuga PA Ato Ahmed Bedbo 01 None 60 Male Old Age 14. Timuga PA Ato Sileshi Meketa 01 None 65 Male Old Age 15. Timuga PA W/o Wagaye Tesfaye 01 None 40 Female Female Household Head 16 Timuga PA W/o Wesen Sileshi 01 None 26 Female Female Household Head 17. Micheta Town W/o Kedire Shek Ahmed 01 None 40 Female Old Age 18. Micheta Town W/o Almaz Desta 01 None 70 Female Female Household Head 19. Micheta Town W/o Shitu Abebe 01 None 50 Female Old Age Female Household Head 20. Micheta Town W/o Zehara Kasim 01 None 55 Female and Old Age Female Household 21. Micheta Town W/o Aster H/Wold 01 None 27 Female Heads
RAP, Dera- Mechara, Vulnerable Groups No. Town i PA Name of the Household Head Kebele House No. Age Gender Reason for Vulnerability Female Household Head 22. Micheta Town W/o Zewde Demise 01 None 55 Female and Old Age Female Household 23. Micheta Town W/o Worke Bellachew 01 None 36 Female Heads Female Household Head 24. Micheta Town W/o Aysha Ibrahim 01 None 62 Female and Old Age Female Household 25. Micheta Town W/o Getu zewde 01 None 38 Female Heads Female Household Head 26. Micheta Town Haji Ahmed Husen 01 None 80 Male and Old Age Female Household Head 27. Micheta Town W/o Almaz Desta 01 None 70 Female and Old Age 28. Micheta Town Ato Tiruneh Neway 01 None 67 Male Old Age 29. Micheta Town Ato Kebede Demise 01 None 73 Male Old Age 30. Micheta Town W/o Aysha Ibrahim 01 None 62 Female Old Age 31. Micheta Town Ato Mebrate Tadese 01 None 75 Male Old Age W/o Tenagne G/Michael Female Household Head 32. Kortu PA Workye Kortu None 60 Female and Old Age 33. Kortu PA Ato Musa Ouso Oda Kortu None 60 Male Old Age Ato Mehamed Haji 34. Kortu PA Ibrahim Kortu None 70 Male Old Age 35. Kortu PA W/o Seada Ali Kortu None 40 Female Female Household Head 36. Kortu PA Ato Tefera Worku Kortu None 55 Male Old Age 37. Kortu PA W/o Debre G/Maariam Kortu None 50 Female Female Household Head 38. Kortu PA W/o Zemzem Haji Kortu None 50 Female Female Household Head 39. Kortu PA W/o Tirunesh Dubale Kortu None 25 Female Female Household Head 40. Kortu PA W/o Yesunesh G/Hana Kortu None 30 Female Female Household Head 41. Kortu PA Ato Kamil Sedik Wedai Kortu None 65 Male Old Aqe 42. Kortu PA Shek Oumer Amye Kortu None 75 Male Old Age
RAP, Dera- Mechara, Vulnerable Groups No. Town / PA Name of theHead Household Kebele House No. Age Gender Reason for Vulnerability Ato Mehamed Sheka 43. Mechara Town Adem 01 None 60 Male Old Age
44. Mechara Town W/o Sofia Hasen 01 None 50 Female Female Household Head 45. Mechara Town W/o Amina Hasen 01 None 40 Female Female Household Head Female Household Head 46. Mechara Town W/o Alima Issa 01 None 60 Female and Old Age
47. Mechara Town Ato Sani Haji Mohamed 01 None 60 Male Old Age 48. Mechara Town Shek Faris Buser 01 None 70 Male Old Age Female Household Head 49. Mechara Town W/o Yewbdar Begashaw 01 None 80 Female and Old Age
RAP, Dera- Mechara, Vulnerable Groups Annex Eight: Minutes of meeting with local authorities
Summarv notes of the meeting held with woreda administration; town and municipal council members conceming rural and urban kebeles where the Dera - Mechara road passes through.
The meetings were held between March 9 -11/03 in the woredas of: 1. Dodota Sire 2. Jeju 3. Merti 4. Chole 5. Gololecha and 6. Daro Lebu
The meetings with the local authorities were held and minutes taken in Amharic. The minutes of the meetings with each woreda are attached with this Annex and are summarized below.
The main discussion points of the meeting were: 1. To provide the list of PAPs found in each section of the road (town or kebele) to woreda administration, kebele authorities and town councils. 2. To inform local authorities that the cut off date for compensation starts from the date that the consultant carried out the field survey and recorded list of PAPs 3. To ensure the availability of land in the area for replacement for households or PAPs who will be fully affected 4. To ensure that kebele administrations will construct similar houses using the compensation payment made to it as replacement cost for affected kebele houses, and shall provide the houses it constructed for fully affected households and who reside in the affected kebele houses with the same amount of rent 5. The local authorities (woreda and kebele) shall monitor to ensure that PAPs who own private houses and received compensation from ERA will rebuild similar type of their previous house 6. Local authorities will provide special support and assistance to identified vulnerable households (elderly and female headed households) to rebuild their house and restore their income
In all woredas where the consultant had meeting with woreda administrations, town councils, rural and urban kebeles have confirmed to:
* Provide land for relocated houses * Provide assistance to vulnerable groups * Monitor that PAPs will rebuild their houses with the compensation they receive To monitor that no new construction is carried out in the ROW after the cut off date * To ensure that kebele administrations will provide similar houses to those PAPs who already rent kebele houses and affected by the project.