That Friday free thing Leeds St I FrkInv. retIrtrary 2. 2007 vat. 7:15SLIE 12 Top lecturer slammed for unfair conduct
By Charlotte Griffiths Speaking to the Leeds Student Dr subject. The student who stayed in his decisive action - as past cases have seriously, and he was right - as a fresher I Hartley said that he had "no comment to class agreed with tins. saying: "I initially shown. We are committed to offering was pretty hungover in some of my make" on the subject and Mai "such thought that Owen Hartley was put off Nutrients and staff equality of opportunity seminars. I think that. if he is being matters were between the university and by the fact that I am well spoken and at the University , and to ensuring our dismissive in another seminar group, it is A senior lecturer in the School of History the departments concerned." But he hum the South. I had heard rumours that values of diversity. inclusiveness, probably a tactic, rather than sexism or has been disciplined by his parent continued, saying: "There's nothing eke he had a chip on his shoulder about the community and mutual respect an: prejudice, or maybe he feels a hit of department regarding his treatment of to be said. Of course some people oiler influx of Southerners to Leeds in recent reflected in all we do." rivalry between the departments". third year dissertation students in the titles that affirm plausible than others. years, but he became better as the weeks Some students taught in Hartley's Beth Forrester, LUU's education Politics department. It happens routinely every year." Went on its I persisted with my title. He parent school seem to have a more ',dicer, commented on the matter:1AM The teaching, style and persouai On request of anonymity, one female became really quite helpful and fairly positive perception of his teaching style is pleased the University has taken swift conduct of Dr Owen l lartley, a principal student described leaving Hartley's enthusiastic towards the end." Katherine Walls, a History student in action over student concerns, in line with teaching fellow in History.. had lad to a group after her Boa class. She had A spokesperson for the University her third year said: "I had a lecture by their continued focus on the student number of complaints from students of initially resigned herself to remaining in said it is policy not to comment on Hartley in the find term of my first year. experience in all aspects of University the School of Politics and International the dissertation group for the whole term, individual complaints MU continued in a he was pretty scary and rude particularly life. The Students' Union will continue to Studies IIPOLISI where Hartley. led a but on hearing that others were also statement: "Any concerns raised by our in the seminars. which I would dread, utunitor the situation and any students dissertation class last semester. The changing and to Politics department student% arc always investigated But it never really hothered me too with concerns about .apects of their written giesances culminated in a fonual were readily transferring students Fran thoroughly. If there is any breach of much. I think it was a method to course are encouraged to seek support complaint submitted to Hanley's parent lanley's class. she made the decision to University policy, we take swift and encourage first years to take Uni front the Student Advice Centre." department by Hugo Radice. the POLIS move. departmental head. "I walked into the seminar a couple nl The complaints concerned both Dr minutes bite and Dr Hanley commented Hartley's academic conduct w its regards on nay clothes in from of everyone in the to dissertation titles and his personal class; they were already sitting down and attitude towards students in his POLIS were mostly boys. I was just standing dissertation class. Some students toured then: and I could feel myself go bright Dr Hanley was dismissive towards red." she said. certain dissertation topics such ar 'The student said Dr Hartley feminism, others complained of his commented on the length of her dress. tovialisation of titles concerning the rule "I thought it was just inc being of the media in politics. Many alarmed sensitive but 1 was so embarrassed, students requested to transfer from When I realised that others had changed from class I did too. but I never lodged a Hartley' h dissertation class. The administration staff in the Politics °Mixt formal complaint." appeared to become accustomed to Another female student staved in reallocating students and squeezing them Hartley's class despite feeling uneasy into other dissertation classes led by that Hartley was vocal about how much alternative professors. he disliked her dissertation title and topic. Members of Dr Hartley's class were She said: "I wanted to do my title concerned that a dismissive attitude about the media and British politics, but towank their choice of dissertation topic Dr Hartley dismissed it, saying that most may adversely affect the mark that would authors who wrote about that kind of be given to their work. However. sonic thing were simply egotistical journalists students were also concerned that who wanted to write about themselves." Hartley's conduct towards the personal Dr Hanky is said to have deknded appearance and social class of his his treatment of dissertation titles in the students was inappropriate. and irrelevant early weeks as a tactical method of to their dissertation. ensuring that students were genuinely dedicated and interested in their chosen and cif Rerilie,'Ile of nfinority (2) • R.A.G. week • Tiger 'tiger (14 41, 2 Leeds Student www.leedsstudent.org.uk Friday, February 2, 2007 News
malty Week started rather unevent- would have worked. Then again, there were added; "Be a hit of payback for that shuck- for a bus before? I mumbled something fully in the Leeds Student office. other factors in play. Firstly, I had come ing initiation article really" We both looked about the sports section. and turned back to HMounds of pizza festered peacefully with the dashing, sporting Sample. whose to the top. Few mtgs. bit of an overhang, my figure of eight knot Later in the final in the corner. and the mould from the coffee shorts-dad legs were already been eyed up the top looked an unreachable distance heat the competition stakes were high. "fin mugs began to form its own democracy„ by the females of the group we joined at the away. going to get to the top" Sample declared
But for one reporter, this was the quiet Sports Centre, not to mention the looks his I started to make up excuses. This com- sportingly. "I'm going up there to place ray before the sporting storm. Bright and early harness recieved. Secondly, there were rep- petition (as this was what had conic about) Exec flag. If you make it, you can put a little rey Thursday morning, all-round sporting giant utations at stake. l had to fly the flag for was not really fair, seeing as I had been pit- Leeds Student one there as well" Enraging. Archie Sample bounded in. "Right, rave to Leeds Snuienr. ted against the Exec's finest athlete. On was never going to make it_ The wall looked Doo me about how good Healthy Week is" I Standing at the foot of the wall, roped hearing this. Archie was defensive of his like the opening scene from cliffhanger, and said. "Better than that. I'll show you" he and harnessed up. Sample gave me a daft' team mates. "Darnola's a natural gymnast, Archie had muscles I'd never even heard of.
Alex said. gerous locale "Leeds Student and the Exec Sarah's down the gym every day now, and Lucky for him, I was interviewing the Jess Linacre would definitely win a bleep instructors during his attempt. The flag By Part-time journalism aside. most of my working together eh? That'll he a first" he hobbies are typical of your average student, said. I gulped. Thirty leer up a wall on a test against us all" he said. By Goti,the Exec must have been lose, but the teamwork was quite easily performed in the seated posi- rope, I was going to be protected by one of were the Spaiizm army! "Who's the paper's fun. Alt, this 'fun' word I have adopted. The tion. ril just watch then, keep the bench the Exec. a group regularly harassed by us fittest athlete?" He had stumped me there. union has done its job:Healthy Week must warm. If it hadn't been tor the extraordinar- journos, harvested for quotes on every pos- The sword had cut the pert in half. I thought have affected me.FinaI score: Executive ily over-zeulous climbing instructor, this sible occasion. As if I needed reminding, he back to the office. Had any of us even run one. IS nil. Ethnic minorities 'least likely to get firsts' GLOBAL By Charlotte Griffiths
By Jessica Geen Collector said. "Having spoken to deliberately blocking students with Bill Rantmell, higher education many black students. it seems that the potential to get firsts The lack of minister, said: "The government is Students m an Aberdeen university people do feel that there arc forms of firsts among students from ethnic committed to ensuring that people were left bewildered when they institutional racism that are part of minorities is the tip of the iceberg of from all backgrounds and all sections were given an exam with the Black and Asian students arc less educational structures. Where there a much wider crisis. There is a higher of society have the opportunity to answers attached during their Janu- likely than their white peers to is anonymous marking. degree levels percentage of black students in non- benefit from and thrive in higher ary examination period. achieve a first ctuss degree, between black and white students are Russell Group universities. they're education. That is why we undertook The dozens of final year students according to a study published last not different, not really applying to the top ten this research and why we have of Robert Gordon University week. "that was the reason 1 first institutions. already asked the Higher Education arrived to their exam in Business The study. carried out by the instituted the campaign. also I found "My other concern is who we arc Academy and Equality Challenge Studies to find the marker's copy of Department for Education and Skills out that there are so many factors talking about when we say 'ethnic Unit to start immediate follow-up the exam paper placed on their desk (DIES), found that those least likely that affect other students. and that's minority students' - British students work with higher education by mistake. The students chose hon- to attain firsts were black Caribbean, why anonymous markets is or foreign students. If we take out institutions. to investiaate these esty over the easier option and alert- black African and Chinese students. necessary_ foreign students, many of our results further, ed invigilators to the mistake, The report said: "Although the "It's not just a race or gender campuses would he mainly white." "This work is supported by The exam has been rescheduled participation of students from issue. it's about students- feeling On the issue of employment Dr. Universities UK and GuildelE and and will take place later in the minority ethnic communities in confident enough to complain about Sewell said: "I do think this can have will build upon existing good month. A spokesperson of Robert higher education is higher than for a lecture_ Universities have to listen an impact on employment prospects. practice. We have to ensure that Gordon University said: "the stu- students from white communities, the to constructive criticism that students but the issue of where you got to every student regardless of race or dents were sitting the exam on Sat- attainment of those who complete a may have in order to improve the university is just as important - this sex is given equal opportunity to urday when the mistake happened. first degree programme his measured quality of teaching." is reflective of a much wider issue." succeed within higher education. The marker's version of the exam by class of deereel is markedly lower Doctor Tony Sewell, a former Dr. Sewell outlines three main This is both a social and economic paper, which included the answers. than that of their white peers." lecturer at Leeds University who now aspects of this "wider crisis" as the necessity." was distributed to the students in The study took into account runs the 'Generating Genius' project low percentage of black and Asian The study also found that while error and the exam was prcenptly factors such as gender, subject, prior said: "My view is that I wouldn't say students going to the top ten women outperformed men in other stopped by the invigilators. attainment and deprivation, hut said that universities per se were universities, the lack of support areas, they were less likely to "The university has procedures there remained an "unexplained available for students from ethnic achieve a first, and students at in place for the preparation and pro- difference" between ethnic minority minorities and the high drop-out rate Russell Group universities usually duction of exam papers. which students and white students. for black students, particularly from performed better. Mature students regrettably failed on this occasion. It also warned: " These results non-Russell Group universities. and those living at home were more A replacement exam, with a new potentially have quite serious He said: "There are a number of also likely to get a good degree. exam paper. has been scheduled implications, A number of studies things you can do to change this. The LUU Education Officer Beth which should minimise the impact have found that attaining a 'good' kind of things they've done in the US Forrester said: "Leeds has a very to our students. We have apologised degree carries a premium in the is to have free college programmes strong widening participation to all students concerned." labour market, and that this premium for students. The other thing is for programme, which targets all student The mistake of the Scottish Busi- has been increasing over time, as the the Russell Group universities to groups that may not automatically ness school coincidentally comes at higher education system has - think about how they entice ethnic consider applying to Leeds. It's not the same time that the Leeds Uni- expanded. As a result, there is a minority students onto their just for students from ethnic versity Business school is also suf- considerable cost attached to this campuses there may he issues of minorities, but also those from lower fering from the embarrassing conse- attainment gap identified in relation support and funding there. We need socin-economic groups and those quences of a mistake made on Janu- to minority ethnic students." to perhaps have a greater culture, who are first generation applicants, ary 16, when an exam paper was A campaign was launched in now that we're paying higher fees, of "The students' union is also handed out to students that was January 2006 by last year's LUU having scholarships for poorer cot-limited to this cause - it's a big identical to a past paper from 2004. Education Officer Ruqayyah students. The private sector should issue which we have raised with the The Leeds students have also Collector to introduce anonymous get involved offering scholarships vice-chancellor, trying to ensure that had to re-sit their exam recently. or marking at Leeds University. alongside the government." He the image of Leeds University is been subjected to a wait until sum- Research has shown that black added: "Qualitative research needs to truly representative and appealing to mer to sit the paper along with their students perform better when be done to find the reasons behind all our target groups. spring modules. assessed under anonymous CAMPAIGNER: Ruqayyah Collector these figures." conditions. PHOTO: LUU
Leeds Student newspaper - LS11 Editor - Ben Schofield / Associate Editor • Ky Capel / News . Alex Doorey, Charlotte Griffiths, Rachel Hunter & Paul Tait / Under the Radar Michael Wooldridge, Sam Ward & Stephan Page 1 Extra - James Gardiner & Phil Spooner 1 Comment Hind Hassan I Sport - Michael Niles, Adam Lord & Ahran Symonds-Baigl Photos • Patrick Nixon & Emma Daizell / Online - Barry Carlyon / Advertising assistant - Hannah Swales / Advert design • Rebecca Edlin Copy editors - Vicky Sharkey, Marya Yasin, Sarah Chadwell, Louisa May Cooper, Hayley Foy, Hollie Schofield, Kyle Green, Poppy Roberts, Graeme Nye, Lucy Killoch, Nicky Drummond, Rose Hampton, Maddy McGarrie, Luke Rushworth, Zahra Bakir, Ramey Alwakeel, Sophie Foster & Daniel Smith Leeds Student newspaper, Leeds University Union, PO Box 157, Leeds, LS1 1UH; (0113) 3801 450; editolsweb.org.uk To advertise email [email protected] Leeds Student www.leedsstudent.org.uk Friday, February 2, 2007 3 News Geography to launch new masters course in political activism By Charlotte Grifftths WaIcy, believes that the course will idea. He said: "I think it will be a valuable Guy Searle is often active in student degree in revolution. However, although reinvigorate staff at the department who addition, it is quite similar to a course that politics around campus and thinks that the the course will never ask you to put your find themselves occupied with more I did last tern called international personal drive behind activism cannot be life on the line, it will teach people how to The Geography department will launch mundane tasks in the department: "the development and rebellion. It was really taught in a lecture theatre, he said: "1 think get their paint across in the modem, Britain's first masters course in Activism department and faculty are extremely interesting and taught an alternative that the course can never teach the kind of bureaucracy entrenched climate, if that and Social Change in September next supportive and excited about the course" perspective to capitalism which I drink heroism and bravery that is required of can be taught effectively it is a good year. he said. His colleague. Stewart people need to know about." true activism, after all, Che didn't rued a thing." Elements of the course will include Hodkinson. is a research fellow and tutor 'action planning sessions' and modules in the course, he said: "We think there is a o' or. ago. - covering campaigning skills, using the big demand from students for such media and direct action. The course is the courses." first of its kind in Europe and aims to help A spokesperson for Friends of the students to develop skills to become Earth, Hannah Griffiths, thinks that the competent in active campaigning and course will create good candidates for social change. A spokesperson said: "the their organisation: "Friends of the Earth school is delighted to offer this ground. would be interested in working with breaking new Masters Programme in people who have been through this Activism and Social Change (ASC). It course." she said. "We look for people offers students an opportunity to be fully with a wide range of qualities. This course engaged in an innovative and original could help us to find people who have a interdisciplinary programme of research- real understanding of creating social led teaching and participatory study change and of activism in the UK" which brings together the worlds of Marlene Barrett of the World academia and progressive social Development Movement agrees, she said: campaigning. "I think this course is a good thing "Only here will you develop rigorous becau.se it will provide the opportunity to conceptual and theoretical understandings stimulate academic thinking on of resistance movements for change. alternatives to the neoliberal approach to engage with campaigners and development. strengthen links between practitioners struggling for a better world, the academic and development experienoe innovative assessment communities, and provide an opportunity methods such as action research projects, for campaigners to acquire particular and develop campaigning and research skills in campaign organising." skills to equip you for future work or James Wainwright is a Geography ACTIVE STUDENT: This may count as homework from next year study," Senior lecturer of the school, Pain finalist and thinks the course is a good PHOTO EMMA DALLELL `RentMe' goes by a new name
By Virginia Newman Park corner looks very professional Andrea Kerslake, the Housing and welcoming with glass sliding Specialist from the LUU Student doors and white modern furnishings" Advice Centre said that she has 'RentMe' tenants have been advised said one student searching for a place received no written confirmation that by the Student Advice Centre to to live next year. "When I asked deposits have been transferred over withhold rent payments until they whether the letting agency used to he from RentMe to PADS, although confirm a new company takeover. RentMe, the PADS assistant was Danielle Cooper said that Rent Me RentMe, the student housing very defensive but admitted that it were "in the process of transferring company which has provoked many was." them." complaints from its tenants has been When asked whether prospective Currently no conclusion has been bought out and renamed as 'PADS'. tenants should he worried about the added to this and the future for As Leeds Student understands, the bad press that RentMe has had in the Rent Me tenants and future PADS company Rent Me no longer exists past, a PADS representative claimed tenants is unknown. Kerslake said: but it is not known whether they that: "PADS is nothing to do with "1 have had a meeting with Danielle have gone bankrupt or simply RentMe as they have a new Cooper and despite many promises stopped trading. director." of action there has been little The new company PADS on He continued: "PADS has bought progress to date which is very Hyde Park Corner is located on the out RentMe and a couple of other disappointing." same premises which Rent Mc were companies. The reason that RentMe There are other issues of concern reported to be refurbishing, at a cost had so many problems was because that need to be resolved for students of 200K, by Leeds Student on they didn't keep up with property who are tenants with RentMe. October 27 2006. maintenance, but PADS has a Any Leeds student who has a The director of PADS Danielle maintenance section downstairs in contract with RentMe should e-mail Cooper has spoken to the LUU the office. Tenants of PADS should their contact details to Student Advice Centre. She said that be reassured that if they have any adviceMuu.leeds.ac.uk (with the she has taken over the management problems they can go into the office subject 'RentMe database') so that of the properties but is a managing and their concerns will be dealt the Advice Centre can contact agent rather than the owner of the with." students when they have further properties. Tenants currently with RentMe information such as what is Despite maintaining that her are still protected by law and their happening to deposits, and possible business is not the same as RentMe, contracts cannot he terminated or students entitled to compensation. she has taken on all the existing changed without their consent. Kerslake has advised tenants who RentMe staff and kept the new Problems relating to disrepair will rented from RentMe to stop all rent refurbished shop floor design in the now be taken up with PADS. payments until they have been same style, except for the name. University of Leeds students have informed in writing by RentMe that Danielle is also managing property not, to date. received any letters their contract and deposits have been PADS HQ: 'RentMe' gets taken over on behalf of Hedley Manton, the informing them to change rent transferred to PADS and that that is previous owner of RentMe. payments to PADS instead of who rent payments should now be PHOTO: Michael Liparoto "The new PADS office on Hyde RentMe, made to. ...41111