Conciliating Between Polities: a Pragmatic Study on Contemporary Visual Artists in the Netherlands
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
Conciliating Between Polities: A Pragmatic Study on Contemporary Visual Artists in the Netherlands Milica Jovićević 447848 Prof. Stocco Ferreira Erasmus School of History, Culture and Communication Erasmus University Rotterdam Department of Art, Culture and Society Master Thesis May 15, 2018 Word Count: 25,129 Cover Image: Jonas Raps installing his artwork. Retrieved from https://www.heden.nl/tentoonstellingen/jonas-raps-winnaar-heden-start-prijs ABSTRACT Literature suggests that there is a presiding romanticized notion of what it is to be an artist, where they encompass the charismatic myth and thus use an aesthetic logic as the guide to make artwork. With today’s evolving post-industrial society, the traditional art career is of question, and for it to sustain itself in a modern-day context, literature indicates artists must conciliate between two forms of (non) mutually exclusive logics – the “aesthetic” and “market” logic. There are numerous factors that to extent provoke a conciliation process between these two polities, such as the role of the art academy, artistic labor markets, private versus public funding, and the relationships between artists and selling. Thus, via qualitative semi-structured interviews, a thematic analytical tool and a pragmatic sociological perspective, this study sets foot into understanding, how do contemporary visual artists in the Netherlands conciliate between the market and aesthetic logic, since graduating from a fine arts academy. KEYWORDS: charismatic myth, art academies, artistic careers, aesthetic logic, market logic, pragmatic sociology 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction ............................................................................................................................................. 3 Literature Review ..................................................................................................................................... 4 The Sacred and Romanticized Art ....................................................................................................... 4 Two Spheres In One Visual Artists World ............................................................................................ 6 Art Academies as The Culprit? ............................................................................................................ 7 The Sweat of an Artist’s Brow - Artistic Labour Market .................................................................... 11 The Artist Who Wins and Takes It All - Private versus Public Funding .............................................. 13 Commodifying the Creative Integrity - Pricing and Selling ................................................................ 15 Artist-Dealer (or Gallerist) Relationship, or Marriage? ...................................................................... 17 The Notion of Success ....................................................................................................................... 19 Research Question and Valorization ...................................................................................................... 20 Theoretical Framework - Pragmatic Sociology ........................................................................................ 22 Methodology ......................................................................................................................................... 27 Units of Analysis and Sampling ......................................................................................................... 27 Data Gathering Methodology - Semi-Structured Interviews ............................................................. 29 Data Analysis Methodology .............................................................................................................. 30 Analysis .................................................................................................................................................. 36 THE ACADEMY ................................................................................................................................... 36 The Romantic Mythical Artist ....................................................................................................... 36 The Bubble That Eventually Pops .................................................................................................. 37 THE ARTISTIC PRACTICE ..................................................................................................................... 39 A Social Responsibility…. ............................................................................................................... 39 … Without Much Consideration For The Audience ....................................................................... 41 THE LABOUR MARKET ........................................................................................................................ 43 The Unpredictable Nature Of An Artistic Career… ........................................................................ 43 … That Requires A Job On The Side … ........................................................................................... 45 … Or Preferably Funding ............................................................................................................... 47 THE ART MARKET ............................................................................................................................... 50 Selling; To the demand ................................................................................................................. 50 Selling; A shift of worth ................................................................................................................. 52 Pricing the priceless ...................................................................................................................... 54 Selling; an identity mold maker .................................................................................................... 55 Showing; To the Artistic Vision ..................................................................................................... 57 The Art Market and Artistic Careers ................................................................................................... 58 Managing Authenticity ................................................................................................................. 58 Conclusion and Reflection ...................................................................................................................... 60 Conclusive Findings ........................................................................................................................... 60 Biting Off More Than The Paper Can Chew ....................................................................................... 63 References ............................................................................................................................................. 64 Appendices ............................................................................................................................................ 72 Appendix A: Overview of Respondents ............................................................................................ 72 Appendix B: Interview Guide ............................................................................................................. 88 Appendix C: Relevance ...................................................................................................................... 90 Appendix D: Consent Form ............................................................................................................... 91 Appendix E: The “Framework” .......................................................................................................... 93 2 INTRODUCTION “Being an artist I must relate to art, not to the market. I want to keep money out of my relationship with art. But at the same time, it confuses and annoys me that I have to deal with money to keep my little enterprise in business. I understand that to serve a higher purpose I need money to survive, but it doesn’t feel right. I want art to belong to a sacred world and not to the world of Mammon” (Abbing, 2002, p. 37) Abbing (2002), illustrates the conflicting relationships between the “aesthetic” and “market” logic that artists must face in their career. The first embodying the “sacred” construct of the art world, in which the artist is romanticized and mystified, the latter embodying a for-profit and commercial logic. One opposes the other, yet at the same time influences one another. There are many factors that encompass the dichotic and challenging relations between the aesthetic and market logic in an artistic career and the following literature review will describe them by addressing the topic of the romanticization of the artist, the aesthetic and market logic, the role of the art academy, artistic labor markets, private versus public funding, and the relationships between artist and dealer/gallerists. These topics cover different “situations” that artists must face in one or another, situations which play with differing values pertaining to the market versus aesthetic logic/world. They all bring about a potential situation of “conflict” of values and reality checks between the world of the “market’ and the world of the “aesthetic,” influencing how they conciliate between the two and make decision on behalf of their desired occupational 3 identity.