<<

The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Implementation Status & Results State Integrated Project: Rural Poverty (P093787)

Operation Name: Bahia State Integrated Project: Rural Poverty (P093787) Project Stage: Implementation Seq.No: 16 Status: ARCHIVED Archive Date: 31-Jan-2014 Country: Brazil Approval FY: 2006

Public Disclosure Authorized Product Line:IBRD/IDA Region: LATIN AMERICA AND CARIBBEAN Lending Instrument: Specific Investment Loan Implementing Agency(ies): CAR Key Dates Board Approval Date 01-Sep-2005 Original Closing Date 31-Jul-2010 Planned Mid Term Review Date 26-Mar-2012 Last Archived ISR Date 04-Aug-2013 Public Disclosure Copy Effectiveness Date 09-Feb-2006 Revised Closing Date 31-Jan-2014 Actual Mid Term Review Date 19-Jul-2012

Project Development Objectives Project Development Objective (from Project Appraisal Document) The Project would increase social and economic opportunities for the rural poor in Bahia by improving their access to basic socioeconomic infrastructure, thus contributing to the Borrower's objective of increasing the HDI. While building on the CDD approach proven successful under the first phase of Produzir, the second phase would improve on this experience by: (a) integrating with and/or complementing activities of other Bank loans for the State (under the Bahia State Program), particularly the PGRH and Viver Melhor Urbano II; (b) strengthening the cross-sectoral integration and providing significantly more emphasis on education, health, culture, natural resources management and environmental sustainability; and (c) scaling up the impact on poverty by using the skills, social capital and experience of Public Disclosure Authorized the Municipal Councils and community associations to improve the relevance, efficiency, sustainability, targeting and outcomes of non-project State and Federal investments in rural Bahia. Has the Project Development Objective been changed since Board Approval of the Project?

Yes No

Component(s)

Component Name Component Cost 1. Community subprojects 99.37

2. Institutional Development

3. Supervision, Monitoring and Evaluation

Public Disclosure Authorized 2. Institutional Development 7.60 3.Administration, Supervision, Monitoring & Evaluation 4.97

Overall Ratings Previous Rating Current Rating Public Disclosure Copy Progress towards achievement of PDO Satisfactory Satisfactory Overall Implementation Progress (IP) Satisfactory Satisfactory

Page 1 of 22 Public Disclosure Authorized The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Previous Rating Current Rating Overall Risk Rating Low Low

Implementation Status Overview The Bahia State Integrated Project: Rural Poverty completed its first phase on July 31, 2010. At the close of this first phase, the project had benefited some 168,000 families (98% of Project Development Objective Indicator) with 1,835 small-scale community investments totaling US$104 million across 392 targeted municipalities statewide. The Additional Financing (AF) loan of US$30.0 million, which became Effective on January 24, 2011, financed the project's second phase and is totally disbursed prior its closing date on January 31, 2014. The second phase has financed a total of 1,038 community investments that are extending project benefits, principally in water, sanitation and productive inclusion (e.g., agricultural mechanization) directly, to 112,258 rural poor families in the project area. The project has been able to leverage additional project resources from Federal and State programs in an amount equivalent to US$ 220 million.

Public Disclosure Copy Locations Country First Administrative Division Location Planned Actual Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Estado da Bahia Estado da Bahia ✔

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Belmonte

Brazil Not Entered Brejões

Brazil Not Entered Dom Basílio

Brazil Not Entered Iaçu

Brazil Not Entered Ituberá

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Muquém de São Francisco

Brazil Not Entered Nilo Peçanha

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Nova Viçosa

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Poções

Brazil Not Entered Presidente Tancredo Neves Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Santa Maria da Vitória

Page 2 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Country First Administrative Division Location Planned Actual Brazil Not Entered Santana

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Una

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Abaíra

Brazil Not Entered Abaré

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Água Fria

Brazil Not Entered Érico Cardoso

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Alcobaça

Brazil Not Entered Almadina

Brazil Not Entered Amargosa

Brazil Not Entered Amélia Rodrigues

Brazil Not Entered América Dourada

Brazil Not Entered Anagé

Brazil Not Entered Andaraí

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Antas

Brazil Not Entered Antônio Cardoso

Page 3 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered Antônio Gonçalves

Brazil Not Entered Aporá

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Araças

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Aratuípe

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Baianópolis

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Banzaê

Brazil Not Entered Barra

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Barra do Choça

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Barro Alto

Brazil Not Entered Governador Lomanto Júnior

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Page 4 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered Bonito

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Botuporã

Brazil Not Entered Brejolândia

Brazil Not Entered Brotas de Macaúbas

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Cabaceiras do Paraguaçu

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Caculé

Brazil Not Entered Caém

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Caetité

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Caldeirão Grande

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Canápolis

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Page 5 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Cândido Sales

Brazil Not Entered Cansanção

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Caraíbas

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Castro Alves

Brazil Not Entered Catolândia

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Central

Brazil Not Entered Cícero Dantas

Brazil Not Entered Cipó

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Cocos

Brazil Not Entered Conceição da Feira

Brazil Not Entered Conceição do Almeida

Brazil Not Entered Conceição do Coité Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Conceição do Jacuípe

Page 6 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered Conde

Brazil Not Entered Condeúba

Brazil Not Entered Contendas do Sincorá

Brazil Not Entered Coração de Maria

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Coronel João Sá Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Cravolândia

Brazil Not Entered Crisópolis

Brazil Not Entered Cristópolis

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Curaçá

Brazil Not Entered Dário Meira

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Elísio Medrado

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Entre Rios

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Euclides da Cunha

Brazil Not Entered Eunápolis

Brazil Not Entered Fátima

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Page 7 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered Filadélfia

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Gavião

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Heliópolis

Brazil Not Entered Ibiassucê

Brazil Not Entered Ibicaraí

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Ibicuí

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Ibirapuã

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Ibititá

Page 8 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Igaporã

Brazil Not Entered Igrapiúna

Brazil Not Entered Iguaí

Brazil Not Entered Ilhéus

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Ipecaetá

Brazil Not Entered Ipiaú

Brazil Not Entered Ipirá

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Irará

Brazil Not Entered Irecê

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Itacaré

Brazil Not Entered Itaeté

Brazil Not Entered Itagi

Brazil Not Entered Itagibá

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Itaguaçu da Bahia

Page 9 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered Itaju do Colônia

Brazil Not Entered Itajuípe

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Itambé

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Itanhém Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Itapé

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Itiruçu

Brazil Not Entered Itiúba

Brazil Not Entered Itororó

Brazil Not Entered Ituaçu

Brazil Not Entered Iuiú

Brazil Not Entered Jaborandi

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Page 10 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered Jandaíra

Brazil Not Entered Jequié

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Jiquiriçá

Brazil Not Entered Jitaúna

Brazil Not Entered João Dourado

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Jucuruçu

Brazil Not Entered Jussara

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Lajedão

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Lamarão

Brazil Not Entered Lapão

Brazil Not Entered Lençóis

Brazil Not Entered Licínio de Almeida

Brazil Not Entered Livramento de Nossa Senhora

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Macaúbas Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Page 11 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Mairi

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Mansidão

Brazil Not Entered Maracás Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Maraú

Brazil Not Entered Marcionílio Souza

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Mata de São João

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Monte Santo

Brazil Not Entered Morpará

Brazil Not Entered Morro do Chapéu

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Mucugê

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Mundo Novo

Page 12 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Mutuípe

Brazil Not Entered Nazaré

Brazil Not Entered Nova Canaã

Brazil Not Entered Nova Fátima

Brazil Not Entered Nova Ibiá Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Nova Redenção

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Novo Horizonte

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Ouriçangas

Brazil Not Entered Ourolândia

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Palmeiras

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Pé de Serra

Brazil Not Entered Pedrão

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Piatã

Page 13 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered Pilão Arcado

Brazil Not Entered Pindaí

Brazil Not Entered Pindobaçu

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Piraí do Norte

Brazil Not Entered Piripá

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Planalto

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Potiraguá

Brazil Not Entered Presidente Dutra

Brazil Not Entered Presidente Jânio Quadros

Brazil Not Entered Queimadas

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Retirolândia

Brazil Not Entered Riachão das Neves

Brazil Not Entered Riachão do Jacuípe

Brazil Not Entered Riacho de Santana Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Page 14 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Ribeirão do Largo

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Rio do Antônio

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Ruy Barbosa

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Santa Bárbara

Brazil Not Entered Santa Brígida

Brazil Not Entered Santa Cruz Cabrália

Brazil Not Entered Santa Cruz da Vitória

Brazil Not Entered Santa Inês

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Santa Luzia

Brazil Not Entered Santanópolis

Brazil Not Entered Santa Rita de Cássia

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Santo Amaro

Brazil Not Entered Santo Antônio de Jesus

Brazil Not Entered Santo Estêvão

Brazil Not Entered São Desidério

Brazil Not Entered São Domingos

Brazil Not Entered São Félix

Brazil Not Entered São Félix do Coribe Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered São Felipe

Page 15 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered São Gabriel

Brazil Not Entered São Gonçalo dos Campos

Brazil Not Entered São José da Vitória

Brazil Not Entered São José do Jacuípe

Brazil Not Entered São Miguel das Matas

Brazil Not Entered São Sebastião do Passé

Brazil Not Entered Sapeaçu Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Sátiro Dias

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Saúde

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Sebastião Laranjeiras

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Serra do Ramalho

Brazil Not Entered Sento Sé

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Serrolândia

Brazil Not Entered Sítio do Mato

Brazil Not Entered Sítio do Quinto

Brazil Not Entered Sobradinho

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Tanhaçu

Brazil Not Entered Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered

Page 16 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered Taperoá

Brazil Not Entered Tapiramutá

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Teodoro Sampaio

Brazil Not Entered Teofilândia

Brazil Not Entered Teolândia

Brazil Not Entered Terra Nova Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Tucano

Brazil Not Entered Uauá

Brazil Not Entered Ubaíra

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Ubatã

Brazil Not Entered Uibaí

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Uruçuca

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Valença

Brazil Not Entered Valente

Brazil Not Entered Várzea da Roça

Brazil Not Entered Várzea do Poço

Brazil Not Entered Várzea Nova

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Vereda

Brazil Not Entered Vitória da Conquista Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Wagner

Page 17 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Brazil Not Entered Wanderley

Brazil Not Entered Wenceslau Guimarães

Brazil Not Entered Xique-Xique

Brazil Not Entered Luís Eduardo Magalhães

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Glória Public Disclosure Copy Brazil Not Entered Prado

Brazil Not Entered Milagres

Brazil Not Entered Aramari

Brazil Not Entered Chorrochó

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered Macururé

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Brazil Not Entered

Results

Project Development Objective Indicators Indicator Name Core Unit of Measure Baseline Current End Target % of rural poor self-selecting into the Project, Text Value 0% 10.5% of total rural poor identifying and implementing subprojects. Date 09-Feb-2006 31-Jan-2014 31-Jan-2014 Comments Under Phase 1, 168,000 At end of Phase 1, PDO families participated in the indicator was 98% of target project and gained benefits value of 25%. Target value from subprojects they have has been revised to reflect implemented. Under Phase2 Phase 2. An I&E study was 112,258 families have completed and results will be Public Disclosure Copy benefited reflected in the BCR and ICR

Page 18 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Productive investments generating full-time Percentage Value 0.00 40.00 40.00 employment for beneficiary families Date 24-Jan-2011 31-Jan-2014 31-Jan-2014 Comments Productive subprojects are This is a Phase 2 indicator min. 35% of total sub-projects and was fully achieved. I&E completed, and generate results will be reflected in the incremental employment and BCR and ICR income Women participation in productive investments Percentage Value 0.00 40.00 40.00 Sub Type Date 24-Jan-2011 31-Jan-2014 31-Jan-2014 Breakdown Comments Women receive minimum This is a Phase 2 indicator 30% of all productive and was fully achieved Public Disclosure Copy subprojects 70% in Manioc Mill 30% in Mechanization 30%-40% other productive investments

Intermediate Results Indicators Indicator Name Core Unit of Measure Baseline Current End Target 2,500 subproject investments implemented and Text Value 0% (Project taken as free- 2,873 subprojects were maintained by community associations standing for data purposes) financed, comprised of 1,835 (cumulative). subprojects in Phase 1 and 1,038 in Phase 2 (AF) Date 09-Feb-2006 31-Jan-2014 31-Jan-2014 Comments Improved health and At end of original project, sanitation subprojects actual results were 97% of dominate (60% of total), with target. Target now includes another 40% representing Phase 2 and has surpassed subprojects in support of the total target . productive inclusion (e.g., agricultural mechanization). Community benefited in project Area 1 and Text Value 0 Area 1 = 259 Area 1 = 259 Area 2 Sub Type Area 2 = 767 Area 2 = 767 Breakdown Date 24-Jan-2011 31-Jan-2014 31-Jan-2014 Comments Min. 320 communities Phase 1 - Area 1 = 491 and Phase 1 - Area 1 = 491 and benefited in Area A1 and 480 Area 2 = 1,401 Area 2 = 1,401 in area A2 Phase 2 - Area 1 = 259 and Phase 2 - Area 1 = 259 and Area 2 = 767 Area 2 = 767 Total Area 1 = 750 and Area Total Area 1 = 750 and Area 2 = 2,168 2 = 2,168 Public Disclosure Copy I&E Studyresults will be reflected in the BCR and ICR.

Page 19 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Reduction in incidence of water-borne disease Text Value 0 in communities with water supply subprojects Sub Type Date 24-Jan-2011 31-Jan-2014 31-Jan-2014 Breakdown Comments Min. 50% reduction in About 40,000 families were This is a Phase 2 indicator. incidence of water-borne benefited with water and I&E Study results will be disease in communities with sanitation subprojects. reflected in the BCR and ICR. water supply subprojects Results in water-borne About 40,000 families were disease reduction were benefited with water and measured in the I&E Study, sanitation subprojects. but not yet available. Results in water-borne disease reduction were measured in the I&E Study, but not yet available. Public Disclosure Copy % Community associations receiving training in Text Value 0% 100% subproject management & operation Date 09-Feb-2006 31-Jan-2014 31-Jan-2014 Comments As prerequisite for funds Target fully achieved under transfer, all community Phase 1 and Phase 2. associations take part in training for subproject management, operation and maintenance. % Municipal Councils receiving training in HDI- Text Value 0% (Project taken as free- 100% M and Priority-setting standing) Date 09-Feb-2006 31-Jan-2014 31-Jan-2014 Comments The State Secretariat of Target fully achieved under Agriculture (SEAGRI) is Phase 1. Activities completed worked to consolidate for Phase 2. municipal councils into a new model - Sustainable Development Municipal Councils, by an established deadline of June 30, 2013. % CAR staff receiving TA and training for Text Value 100% community associations and Municipal Date 09-Feb-2006 31-Jan-2014 31-Jan-2014 Councils Comments 178 events under Phase I Target substantially achieved with the participation of staff under Phase 1. CAR from CAR HQ in Salvador and conducted a series of regional all eight CAR regional offices training events for staff, which statewide. Under Phase II, are duly reflected in the 383 CAR technical staff have indicator achievement. taken part in training events. Public Disclosure Copy

Data on Financial Performance (as of 15-Jan-2014)

Page 20 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

Financial Agreement(s) Key Dates Project Ln/Cr/Tf Status Approval Date Signing Date Effectiveness Date Original Closing Date Revised Closing Date P093787 IBRD-73270 Closed 01-Sep-2005 14-Dec-2005 09-Feb-2006 31-Jul-2010 31-Jul-2010 P093787 IBRD-77320 Closed 28-Jul-2009 09-Dec-2010 24-Jan-2011 31-Jul-2011 31-Jan-2014 P093787 TF-10751 Closed 08-Dec-2011 08-Dec-2011 18-Jan-2012 15-Apr-2012 15-Apr-2012 P093787 TF-58071 Closed 29-Nov-2007 29-Nov-2007 29-Nov-2007 29-Nov-2010 27-Nov-2011

Disbursements (in Millions) Project Ln/Cr/Tf Status Currency Original Revised Cancelled Disbursed Undisbursed % Disbursed P093787 IBRD-73270 Closed USD 54.35 54.35 0.00 54.35 0.00 100.00

Public Disclosure Copy P093787 IBRD-77320 Closed USD 30.00 30.00 0.00 30.00 0.00 100.00 P093787 TF-10751 Closed USD 0.10 0.09 0.01 0.09 0.00 100.00 P093787 TF-58071 Closed USD 1.66 1.56 0.10 1.56 0.00 100.00

Disbursement Graph

Key Decisions Regarding Implementation None. Public Disclosure Copy Restructuring History

Page 21 of 22 The World Bank Report No: ISR13631

There has been no restructuring to date., CD Decision on 05-Feb-2010, Level two Approved on 11-Mar-2010, Level two Approved on 24-Jul-2012, Level 2 RVP Decision on 31- Jul-2013 Related Projects P110617-Bahia State Integrated Rural Poverty Additional Financing Public Disclosure Copy Public Disclosure Copy

Page 22 of 22