Migrant Domestic Workers

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Migrant Domestic Workers fact sheet Migrant Domestic Workers What is Domestic Work? I did not even get enough food. Domestic work includes a range of tasks Sometimes I only had bread and tea. carried out in private homes including cooking, cleaning, laundry, taking care of I worked all day, with only bread and children and the elderly, and running tea. One day, I asked for my full errands. Many domestic workers live in salary and I told madam not to send their employer’s homes and women and me to work at the houses of her girls make up the overwhelming majority friends and relatives, and I said that, of domestic workers worldwide. Domestic “If you don’t give me my salary I will work represents up to 10 per cent of total not work at all”. After saying this, I employment in some countries. Despite was beaten right away. She even this, domestic work is looked upon by used shoes to beat me. My right hand many as unskilled and remains Photo: Pernin Lucas was broken and there were bruises undervalued and under regulated. 2 of violence to control and force them to work, all over my body.” Amrita 2Female Nepali domestic worker (name changed) often without pay. Others fall into bonded interviewed as part of KAFA newsletter, Stop the A survey with Lebanese employers of labour as a result of the transportation and Exploitation of Migrant Domestic Workers, ,issue Migrant Domestic Workers showed: recruitment costs, as well as the commission #2, Beirut: 2010, (p.7) - 88% believed the employer has fees charged by the agent and/or broker the right to confiscate their incurred in taking up a job abroad. Anti – Slavery International’s employee’s passport Their vulnerability is compounded on arrival Research and Findings - 31% lock their domestic worker in the destination country as migrant In 2012 Anti-Slavery International conducted in the house when they go out domestic workers rarely speak the language research in Nepal, Lebanon and India - 80% do not allow their employee of their employers, have little or no examining the legislation, policy and practice 1 to leave the house on her day off knowledge of their rights and are often of the migration cycle in origin and 1 Data collected by KAFA from interviews with 102 mistreated and forced to work long hours destination countries with particular male and female Lebanese employees, Abdulrahim, with very little pay or food. Many migrant reference to its impact on female migrant Beirut: 2010 (p 37-40) domestic workers have reported domestic workers. It concluded that a experiencing physical, mental and sexual combination of gender discrimination in Key Issues and Concerns Related abuse, having their salary withheld and policies, lack of pre-departure preparedness, to Migrant Domestic Work being confined in their employer’s house, lack of legal protection and little or no Economic and social pressures and a lack of consequently they feel isolated and regulation of recruitment agencies has education compel women to migrate in desperate with little hope of paying the debts resulted in a failure to protect female migrant search of lucrative employment abroad. With incurred by agency imposed migration fees. domestic workers at every level. Whilst some little knowledge of the migration process or positive policies have been introduced, what their work will involve, their overall the research showed that many vulnerability is exploited by agencies, Every domestic worker has the right to a policies and practices expose women to brokers and employers. Migrant domestic safe and healthy working environment. greater risks and vulnerabilities. workers are particularly vulnerable to abuse Each Member shall take, in accordance and exploitation, including forced labour, with national laws, regulations and Our research also showed that there is a due to the unique and specific practice, effective measures, with due disproportionately high rate of reported circumstances of the work inside a private regard for the specific characteristics of suicide amongst Nepali migrant household, combined with a lack of legal domestic work, to ensure the domestic workers in Lebanon. In 2010 protection and regulation, and their occupational safety and health of alone a Nepali Times article reported vulnerability as migrants living in a foreign domestic workers. that 15 Nepali domestic workers country. Many are trafficked for forced committed suicide, but it is believed that Article 13, International Labour labour, with some employers forbidding many more cases go undocumented.3 Organization Convention 189 concerning them from leaving the house, confiscating 3 Hom Karki, Suicide in Lebanon, Nepali Times: issue decent work for domestic workers their passports, and using violence or threats #517, 27 August 2010 Nepali Times Anti-Slavery International, Thomas Clarkson House, The Stableyard, Broomgrove Road, London SW9 9TL Tel: +44 (0)20 7501 8920 Fax: + (0)20 7738 4110 email: [email protected] www.antislavery.org She [the domestic worker] is under my name. I am responsible for her in everything. So, I would feel worried if she goes out or if she sleeps outside my house. I would be scared that she might do something wrong…I would be responsible for that.4 4 Abdulrahim, Beirut: 2010 (p 17) Legislation, policy and leave a slavery-like situation since they important method for educating migrant practice which create a could be deported and lose their domestic workers to make them less livelihood if they leave that employer. vulnerable to exploitation from recruiters vulnerability to slavery: Since employers are legally responsible and employers. An investigation of the Travel Bans: Abuse and exploitation for the worker during her stay, Nepali government’s training course of migrant domestic workers is so sponsorship also encourages restrictions aimed at migrant domestic workers widespread that origin countries, on freedom of movement and highlighted a number of issues including amongst them Nepal, Ethiopia, the communication, thus leaving them lack of awareness of the availability of the Philippines and Madagascar, have vulnerable to abuse. The right to change training, high costs, inaccessibility of banned their nationals from employer is a fundamental safeguard training centres in rural areas, lack of travelling to certain countries and the practice of tying migrant workers monitoring of training centres and the including Lebanon and the Gulf to to a particular employer has been wide availability and use of fake proof of find domestic work. identified by anti-trafficking experts as attendance certificates. one of the key factors contributing to Rather than halting the flow of migrant trafficking and can lead to victims Absence of legal protections: Domestic domestic workers to destination becoming ‘illegal’ and the perpetrators workers are frequently excluded from countries, labour bans: Labour Laws, which denies them all rights going unpunished. • Hamper the ability of service given to workers in other sectors such as providers and duty bearers to Lack of regulation of recruitment agencies minimum wage, annual and sick leave, monitor, support and protect and employers: High fees imposed by the maximum hours of work, the right to form migrant workers. agencies, both in the origin and destination associations and organize, and the right • Prevent monitoring of countries, leave the domestic workers with to resign with proper notification. recruitment agencies, brokers debts and make them more vulnerable to Lack of embassy representation: Our and employers. exploitation. Due to the nature of domestic research has highlighted that migrant • Encourage women to seek work, employers have increased control over domestic workers in countries where there employment through informal their employees and a lack of monitoring is little or no diplomatic representation routes thus exposing themselves bodies and regulation means abuses often from their own countries are particularly to further risks and vulnerabilities. go undetected and unpunished. vulnerable to exploitation. Equally, where there is embassy representation, there is Sponsorship Systems: In many Lack of pre-departure preparedness of frequently a lack of cooperation between countries a domestic workers right to female migrant domestic workers the foreign missions and the destination work is tied to a specific employer, travelling to destination countries: countries to ensure better protections and meaning that they are less likely to Preparation before departure is an conditions of work. Recommendations: It is of the utmost importance that both origin and destination countries work to establish effective prevention, protection and rehabilitation mechanisms through which migrant domestic workers can be supported. Anti-Slavery International also urges all Governments to: Lift all Labour Permit Bans: All restrictions on migration must be lifted. Governments should encourage potential migrant domestic workers to obtain work permits legally, thereby limiting the number of women using informal routes and enabling authorities and other concerned stakeholders to better identify, track and support those domestic workers going to destination countries. Create an alternative to existing sponsorship systems: A government sponsored visa system must be created that allows domestic workers employment mobility and does not tie their visa to a specific employer. Improve recruitment processes by better regulating and monitoring private recruitment agencies. Abusive recruitment practices must stop. There is a need for
Recommended publications
  • Gender Pay Gap Reporting During the Covid-19 Pandemic
    GENDER PAY GAP REPORTING DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC Guide March 2021 The CIPD is the professional body for HR and people development. The registered charity champions better work and working lives and has been setting the benchmark for excellence in people and organisation development for more than 100 years. It has more than 150,000 members across the world, provides thought leadership through independent research on the world of work, and offers professional training and accreditation for those working in HR and learning and development. Reporting during the COVID-19 pandemic Guide Gender pay gap reporting during the COVID-19 pandemic Contents Executive summary 2 Introduction: why reporting is essential 4 COVID-19: how the pandemic is affecting gender pay gaps 8 Reporting guidance for 2020/21: what and how to report 12 Notes 18 Acknowledgements This guidance was prepared by Duncan Brown, principal associate at the Institute for Employment Studies. 1 Reporting during the COVID-19 pandemic 1 Executive summary Introduction On 24 March 2020, the Government Equalities Office (GEO) and the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) suspended enforcement of the compulsory gender pay gap reporting requirements for the 2019/20 year, shortly before the annual deadlines. The Government confirmed in December 2020 that compulsory reporting would resume in the current reporting year. New information and guidelines on the treatment of furloughed employees were included in the Government’s release, which we cover and expand on in this supplementary guidance. On 23 February 2021, the EHRC announced that it would postpone any enforcement action against employers until 5 October 2021, in response to the continued effects of the pandemic.
    [Show full text]
  • ISHA NEWSLETTER International Social History Association
    Vol. 7 | No. 1 | December 2018 ISHA NEWSLETTER International Social History Association CONTENTS 1. Labor and historical periodization of capitalism by Alessandro Stanziani >>> 2. Labor Feminists and Domestic Workers by Eileen Boris >>> 3. The Latin American Problem in the Liberal Mind: Adolph Berle and the Limits of Anti-Communism as Social Policy by Leon Fink >>> 4. Cooperation across disciplines: The Bonn Center for Dependency and Slavery Studies (BCDSS) by Jeannine Bischoff >>> 5. Co-existence and interaction between free and unfree labour: The workers’ perspective, Turin, 21–22 September 2018 by Giulia Bonazza >>> Labor and historical periodization of capitalism by Alessandro Stanziani* Unlike Polanyi, I will not speak of a “great transformation” to show a break in the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries that swept away the old pre-capitalist world through enclo- sures and the poor law and replaced it with a self-regulating economy which, in turn, is said to have been replaced by a new form of interventionism in the twentieth century. This chro- nology is false not only because the privatization of lands,1 the proletarization of the peasant- ry (see here after) and the mechanization fully developed only after the mid-nineteenth cen- tury, but also because the nineteenth-century market was anything but self-regulated.2 On the contrary, there is no reason to oppose the liberal nineteenth century to the eighteenth and twentieth centuries described as interventionist, each in its own way. What differentiated these periods was not liberalism versus regulation, but different forms of regulation, with different aims, goals, and tools. Eighteenth and nineteenth century liberal interventions sup- ported increasing social and economic inequalities, while since the late nineteenth century state intervention sought to reduce inequalities, although only between labor and capital in- side each country and increased inequalities between the main land and its colonies.
    [Show full text]
  • Anti-Slavery International Submission to the UN Special Rapporteur on Contemporary Forms of Slavery, Including Its Causes and Consequences
    May 2018 Anti-Slavery International submission to the UN Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of slavery, including its causes and consequences Questionnaire for NGOs and other stakeholders on domestic servitude Question 1 Please provide information on your organisation and its work with migrant domestic workers who became victims of contemporary forms of slavery, including the countries in which you work on this issue. Anti-Slavery International, founded in 1839, is committed to eradicating all forms of slavery throughout the world including forced labour, bonded labour, trafficking of human beings, descent-based slavery, forced marriage and the worst forms of child labour. Anti-Slavery International works at the local, national and international levels to eradicate slavery. We work closely with local partner organisations, directly supporting people affected by slavery to claim their rights and take control of their lives. Our current approaches include enabling people to leave slavery, through exemplar frontline projects with partner agencies; helping people to recover from slavery, with frontline work ensuring people make lasting successful lives now free from slavery; supporting the empowerment of people to be better protected from slavery; and using this knowledge base to inform, influence and inspire change through advocacy and lobbying within countries for legislation, policy and practice that prevent and eradicates slavery; international policy work and campaigning; and raising the profile and understanding of slavery through media work and supporter campaigns. We have projects across four continents. While the number of projects and the individual countries covered by projects varies at any one time, our current and/or recent work includes the United Kingdom, Peru, Mali, Mauritania, Niger, Senegal, Tanzania, Bangladesh, India, Nepal, Lebanon, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan and Vietnam.
    [Show full text]
  • A Qualitative Study of Female Migrant Domestic Workers' Experiences Of
    Article A Qualitative Study of Female Migrant Domestic Workers’ Experiences of and Responses to Work-Based Sexual Violence in Cyprus Christiana Kouta 1,* , Christalla Pithara 2,3 , Zoe Apostolidou 1, Anna Zobnina 4, Josie Christodoulou 4, Maria Papadakaki 5 and Joannes Chliaoutakis 5 1 Department of Nursing, School of Health Sciences, Cyprus University of Technology, Limassol 3036, Cyprus; [email protected] 2 Population Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, Bristol BS8 2PS, UK; [email protected] 3 National Institute for Health Research Applied Research Collaboration West, University Hospitals Bristol and Weston Foundation Trust, Bristol BS1 2NT, UK 4 Meditteranean Institute of Gender Studies, 46 Makedonitissas Avenue, Box 24005, Nicosia 1703, Cyprus; [email protected] (A.Z.); [email protected] (J.C.) 5 Department of Social Work, School of Health Sciences, Hellenic Mediterranean University, 71004 Heraklion, Greece; [email protected] (M.P.); [email protected] (J.C.) * Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract: Domestic workers face increased risk for sexual harassment and assault in the workplace but are often reluctant to disclose abuse or seek retribution. We report on a study looking at mi- Citation: Kouta, C.; Pithara, C.; grant domestic workers’ responses to sexual violence, reasons behind their responses, and factors Apostolidou, Z.; Zobnina, A.; enhancing or diminishing vulnerability to abuse. We carried out qualitative, in-depth, individual Christodoulou, J.; Papadakaki, M.; and group interviews with 15 female domestic workers from the Philippines and Sri Lanka working Chliaoutakis, J. A Qualitative Study in the Republic of Cyprus. Descriptive thematic analysis was used to analyse data using QSR NVivo of Female Migrant Domestic Workers’ 10.0.
    [Show full text]
  • COVID-19: Significant Payroll and Self-Employment Tax Relief
    April 2020 COVID-19: Significant Payroll and Self-Employment Tax Relief If you are in business for yourself—say, as a corporation or self-employed—payroll taxes and self-employment taxes are likely two of your biggest tax burdens. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, individuals and business are suffering. Congress wants to help you individually and also keep small businesses afloat. To do this, Congress decided that in addition to other measures, it should give you payroll tax and selfemployment tax relief, as we describe in this article. We’ll tell you how the Families First Coronavirus Response Act (FFCRA) and the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act will give you payroll and self-employment tax relief. Payroll Tax Deferral If you have employees (including yourself), then you can postpone payment of the employer share of payroll taxes incurred from the date of enactment of the CARES Act (March 27, 2020) through December 31, 2020.1 You’ll need to pay 50 percent of your 2020 postponed employer taxes no later than December 31, 2021, and the remaining 50 percent no later than December 31, 2022. Note. This provision doesn’t apply if you use the small business loan forgiveness provision under the CARES Act. For this alternative, see COVID-19: New SBA Loans for Small Businesses—Maybe a Great Deal. Self-Employment Tax Deferral If you owe self-employment tax in tax year 2020, you’ll pay it as follows:2 • 50 percent on your 2020 Form 1040 return (which you file in 2021), • 25 percent no later than December 31, 2021, and • 25 percent no later than December 31, 2022.
    [Show full text]
  • Unfree Labor, Capitalism and Contemporary Forms of Slavery
    Unfree Labor, Capitalism and Contemporary Forms of Slavery Siobhán McGrath Graduate Faculty of Political and Social Science, New School University Economic Development & Global Governance and Independent Study: William Milberg Spring 2005 1. Introduction It is widely accepted that capitalism is characterized by “free” wage labor. But what is “free wage labor”? According to Marx a “free” laborer is “free in the double sense, that as a free man he can dispose of his labour power as his own commodity, and that on the other hand he has no other commodity for sale” – thus obliging the laborer to sell this labor power to an employer, who possesses the means of production. Yet, instances of “unfree labor” – where the worker cannot even “dispose of his labor power as his own commodity1” – abound under capitalism. The question posed by this paper is why. What factors can account for the existence of unfree labor? What role does it play in an economy? Why does it exist in certain forms? In terms of the broadest answers to the question of why unfree labor exists under capitalism, there appear to be various potential hypotheses. ¾ Unfree labor may be theorized as a “pre-capitalist” form of labor that has lingered on, a “vestige” of a formerly dominant mode of production. Similarly, it may be viewed as a “non-capitalist” form of labor that can come into existence under capitalism, but can never become the central form of labor. ¾ An alternate explanation of the relationship between unfree labor and capitalism is that it is part of a process of primary accumulation.
    [Show full text]
  • IN EUROPE MIGRANT Domestic Workers
    PROMOTING THE INTEGRATION OF Migrant DOMESTIC WORKERS IN EUROPE MODULE IV Effective Protection of Migrant Domestic Workers Labour Rights ©ILO/Jacek Cislo TABLE OF CONTENTS Module IV – Effective Protection of Migrant Domestic Workers Labour Rights OBJECTIVES .............................................................................................................................................. 3 Module IV – Effective Protection of Migrant Domestic Workers Labour Rights KEY MESSAGES .......................................................................................................................................... 5 Module IV – Effective Protection of Migrant Domestic Workers Labour Rights OVERVIEW OF THE ISSUE ......................................................................................................................... 7 Module IV – Effective Protection of Migrant Domestic Workers Labour Rights LEARNING BY DOING ................................................................................................................................ 15 Module IV – Effective Protection of Migrant Domestic Workers Labour Rights FACT SHEET ............................................................................................................................................... 19 Module IV – Effective Protection of Migrant Domestic Workers Labour Rights GOOD PRACTICES ...................................................................................................................................... 23 Module IV – Effective
    [Show full text]
  • Modern Slavery and Migrant Domestic Workers
    FLJ+Fudge rev 1.qxp_Layout 1 19/10/2016 15:08 Page 3 View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Kent Academic Repository Regulation, Regulators, and the Crisis of Law and Government Modern Slavery and Migrant Domestic Brief Policy Workers The Politics of Legal Characterization Judy Fudge The Foundation for Law, Justice and Society in association with the Centre for Socio-Legal Studies and Wolfson College, University of Oxford www.fljs.org FLJ+Fudge rev 1.qxp_Layout 1 19/10/2016 15:08 Page 4 The Foundation for Law, Justice and Society Regulation, Regulators, and the Crisis of Law and Government This programme examines the regulatory system in the wake of the global financial crisis, assessing its current weaknesses, the role of legislative and judicial bodies, and identifying measures for future reform of both markets and regulatory regimes. It aims to shed light on the recent failures of regulators, often captive of the very industries they are meant to regulate, and examine ways to improve the accountability and effectiveness of the regulatory system. © The Foundation for Law, Justice and Society 2016 FLJ+Fudge rev 1.qxp_Layout 1 19/10/2016 15:08 Page 1 Executive Summary ■ This policy brief outlines the problem of addressing the long-standing exploitation of migrant domestic workers by using a modern slavery and trafficking approach which is embedded in the criminal law. It explains why migrant domestic workers who enter the UK on temporary visas are vulnerable to exploitation by their employers. ■ A variety of different legal jurisdictions — criminal law, immigration law, human rights and equality law, and labour law — can be used to tackle the problem of migrant domestic workers’ exploitation.
    [Show full text]
  • Rights of Domestic Migrant Workers in Europe
    RIGHTS OF MIGRANT DOMESTIC WORKERS IN EUROPE Credits: Design: Stefan Einarsson Photographer: ®Torfi Agnarsson RIGHTS OF MIGRANT DOMESTIC WORKERS IN EUROPE Contents I Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................................. 3 II Executive Summary ........................................................................................................................... 4 III Foreword ........................................................................................................................................... 5 IV Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 6 V Domestic work: women, migration and human rights ........................................................................ 7 1. Definition of domestic work ........................................................................................................... 7 2. Continued gender dimension of domestic work ............................................................................ 7 3. The growing migration dimension of domestic work ..................................................................... 7 4. The magnitude of the phenomenon .............................................................................................. 8 5. Relationship between domestic work, informal/undeclared employment and irregular migration . 9 6. Relationship between migration, labour market
    [Show full text]
  • Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law: Frequently Asked Questions
    Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law: Frequently Asked Questions COVID-19 Alert Update about Workplace Laws During COVID-19, available at nyc.gov/workers, includes a summary of City labor laws for employers and employees as you deal with the impact of COVID-19 on your workplace. The Department of Consumer and Worker To contact OLPS: Protection (DCWP) Office of Labor Policy & Standards (OLPS) enforces NYC’s Earned • Email [email protected] Safe and Sick Time Act (Paid Safe and Sick • Call 311 (212-NEW-YORK outside NYC) Leave Law) referred to in FAQs as the Law. and say “Paid Safe and Sick Leave” • Use Live Chat, available at These FAQs provide general information and nyc.gov/BusinessToolbox guidance for employees and employers. They (employer inquiries only) are not intended to serve as individualized • Visit nyc.gov/workers2 legal advice.1 For specific questions, you should contact your legal advisor. Sections I. GENERAL QUESTIONS II. EMPLOYEES COVERED BY THE LAW III. RIGHT TO AND NOTICE OF SAFE AND SICK LEAVE IV. USE OF SAFE AND SICK LEAVE V. HOW SAFE AND SICK LEAVE IS PAID VI. RETALIATION VII. EMPLOYER RECORDS VIII. COMPLAINTS AND ENFORCEMENT IX. OTHER FEDERAL AND STATE LAWS RELATED TO LEAVE 1 OLPS will update FAQs as appropriate. Please note the date at the bottom of FAQs and check nyc.gov/workers to make sure you have the most current FAQs. 2 Visit nyc.gov/workers for the law and rules, helpful sample documents, and information about other labor laws enforced by DCWP. Updated November 2, 2020 Page 1 of 41 I.
    [Show full text]
  • NDWA Domestic Worker Sample Contract
    Domestic Worker Employment Agreement The Employer and Domestic Worker should negotiate the terms of the agreement to best suit both parties. This agreement is entered into between ___________________ (“Employer”) and __________________(“Domestic Worker”) on ________________(date). 1. Beginning date of employment: 2. Employment length:! □ Until either party terminates the agreement. □ For a fixed term: ______________# of □ Month(s) □ Year(s) □ Other:____________ 3. Position Title: 4. Supervisor Name: Contact Information: 5. Location of Employment (address): 6. Employer’s Address: 7. Work Responsibilities (check all that apply and, if applicable, describe nature): □ Housekeeping □ House cleaning! □ Home management! □ Childcare and nanny services Description of child(ren) (number of children, name, age, gender, etc.): ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ Description of duties related to care of child(ren): ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ □ Adult care, including sick, convalescing, and elderly individuals Description of adult(s) (number of adult(s), name, age, gender, etc.): ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ Description of duties related to care of adult(s):
    [Show full text]
  • Taking Action Against Violence and Discrimination Affecting Migrant Women and Girls1
    Women taking part in a communication campaign encouraging Vietnamese migrant women affected Peer facilitators during a self-help group session for by violence to speak out © IOM women victims of violence in Viet Nam © IOM Taking Action against Violence and Discrimination Affecting Migrant Women and Girls1 IOM is committed Violence against women is one of the most to the principle pervasive global and systemic forms of human Prevalence of violence against migrant that humane and rights violations that exist today. Even though women – a few examples: orderly migration many migrant women do not encounter • In Spain, in 2006, 12.1 per cent of women migrants (compared to 6% of Spanish women) indicated that benefits migrants violence and benefit from migration, for they had been victims of violence at the hands of and society. As an some of the 105 million international migrant their former or current spouse (PACE, 2009). intergovernmental women worldwide (UN DESA, 2009), violence • Of 145 domestic workers from Sri Lanka working in body, IOM acts and discrimination2 can appear at the very the Arab states and sampled in a study, 17 per cent with its partners had been sexually harassed and 5 per cent had been start of the migration process. In fact, in raped (UNDP/IOM et al., 2008). in the international some cases, discrimination and violence in • According to the European Parliament, some community to: the private or public sphere can even act 500,000 women and girls living in Europe have been assist in meeting as women’s main motivation to migrate, subjected to female genital mutilation (FGM), with the operational although in many instances they may not be another 180,000 at risk every year of undergoing the procedure (European Parliament, 2009).
    [Show full text]