Janet Sobel: Primitivist, Surrealist, and Abstract Expressionist Author(S): Gail Levin Source: Woman's Art Journal, Vol
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Woman's Art Inc. Janet Sobel: Primitivist, Surrealist, and Abstract Expressionist Author(s): Gail Levin Source: Woman's Art Journal, Vol. 26, No. 1 (Spring - Summer, 2005), pp. 8-14 Published by: Woman's Art Inc. Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/3566528 Accessed: 07-12-2019 17:46 UTC REFERENCES Linked references are available on JSTOR for this article: https://www.jstor.org/stable/3566528?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contents You may need to log in to JSTOR to access the linked references. JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at https://about.jstor.org/terms Woman's Art Inc. is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Woman's Art Journal This content downloaded from 150.108.161.119 on Sat, 07 Dec 2019 17:46:46 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms A iR_ _r q?- *-- rL .-* .. 1.. IkA ItON .^ - .iw.~ .. PI. 5. Janet Sobel, Music (1944), oil on canvas, PI. 6. Janet Sobel, Disappointment (c. 1943), oil and sand on canvas, 24" x 17/2". Location unknown. Photo: Sidney Janis, 26" x 43". Courtesy Gary Snyder Gallery, New York. Abstract & Surrealist Art in America (1944). PI. 7. Janet Sobel, Pro & Contre (1941), oil on board, PI. 8. Janet Sobel, Untitled (c. 1943), mixed media on paper, 19" x 27". 30" x 20". Courtesy Gary Snyder Gallery, New York. Courtesy Gary Snyder Gallery, New This content downloaded from 150.108.161.119 on Sat, 07 Dec 2019 17:46:46 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms * 0 '~ I ~ JANET SOBEL Primitivist, Surrealist, and Abstract Expressionist By Gail Levin T he feminist movement was of "her already latest painting," underway, Music, which did not makewhen, the checklist. in 1968, William Rubin, a curator Some figurative at the works Museum were also on the of list.6 Modern Emily Genauer, re- Art (MoMA), traveled to Plainfield, viewing the show, singledNew out Jersey, "compositions liketo Retreating meet Horses Janet Sobel (1894-1968). By then and Heavenly bedridden Quarrel, in which and the artistnear has painteddeath, her subjects she felt honored when he acquired on herglass, modeling nonobjective her figures in calligraphic painting, whorls, giving Milky them a Way (1945), for the museum's great permanent feeling of movement."7 collection Pollock may also(as have well seen Sobel's as a second, smaller work for himself, work in Septemberwhich 1944, he inwould a group show later at the donate).' Norlyst Art Rubin was interested in Sobel Gallery because curated by her Eleanor "all-overLust and Jimmy Ernst.drip" paint- ings, including Milky Way, had influencedWe can be sure, too, the that Pollock abstract knew Sobel's expression- Music, for it ap- ist Jackson Pollock, a fact first peared remarked as a full-page color in reproduction the late that year 1950s in Sidney by Janis's no less an authority than the critic Abstract Clement & Surrealist Greenberg. Art in America. Janis also reproduced a color When in 1958 Greenberg revised plate of Pollock'sa 1955 She- essay,Wolf, as well "American-Type as a black-and-white reproduc- Painting," he added Sobel, discounting tion of Composition the (1943) influence by Lee Krasner.8 Whileon PollockJanis classified of Mark Tobey and asserting: "Leonore Krassner" as one of the "American Abstract Painters," along with Stuart Davis, Willem de Kooning, and her teacher Hans Back in 1944, however, he [Pollock] Hofmann, had he placed noticed both Sobel andone Pollock or withtwo the "Americancurious paintings shown at Peggy Guggenheim's Surrealist Painters," by along a with'primitive' Mark Tobey, William painter, Baziotes, Jim- Janet Sobel (who was, and still is,my Ernst,a housewife Dorothea Tanning, living Adolph Gottlieb, in Brooklyn). and Mark Rothko, Pollock (and I myself) admired theseamong others. pictures It is very likely, ratherfurtively: too, that Pollock saw the travelingthey showed schematic little drawings group offaces show organized almost to celebrate lost the publication in a dense of Janis's book, tracery of thin black lines lying culminating over andin New underYork at Mortimer a mottled Brandt Gallery, field from of No- predominantly warm and translucent vember 29 throughcolor." December 30, 1944. This exhibition included Pollock's Mad Moon Woman (1941), Sobel's Music (1944), Tobey's Greenberg, who surely understood Threading that Light (1942), Sobel and Krasner'spainted Composition with (1943), a naif'sas well approach to the night sky or to as worksthe byrhythms 46 other artists. of music, categorized her technique as "the first really Sobel 'all-over' told Janis that one Music that was inspired I had by Shostakovich's ever seen, Sev- since Tobey's show came months enth Symphony. later." Janis Greenberg quoted Sobel about this further work: "Music isal- my lowed as how he found it "strangely impression of thepleasing," music of Shostakovich adding: created in "Later a world torn on,by Pollock admitted that these pictures war and bloodshed. had Shostakovich made hasan captured impression the power of the on him."2 Russian people and by his music has given them strength. His mu- Following in the wake of Greenberg, Rubin wrote in 1967: sic has so stimulated me and I have tried to present these feelings "Pollock arrived at his all-over style without having seen the To- in my picture."9 In the Seventh Symphony, first played in 1942, the beys," adding that "he had seen, however, in 1944 and again in composer reacted to the horrors of the siege of Leningrad and the 1946, a few paintings by Janet Sobel, which prophesied his own deaths caused by the Nazis and by Stalin's orders, themes that style even more closely than did the Tobeys."3 Rubin's position lat- clearly resonated with Sobel. er was refuted by Judith S. Kays, who, in 1997, reasserted Tobey's Given the prominent exhibition history documented for Sobel's influence on Pollock, taking Rubin to task for errors and unsub- Music, with its dripped enamel paint in an all-over pattern, it is stantiated argument.4 Kays objected to Rubin's placement of So- not surprising that Milky Way, which quite closely resembles Mu- bel's all-over canvas Music (1944; P1. 5) "in a group show at Peggy sic, recommended itself to Rubin for acquisition. Both Music and Guggenheim Art of This Century early in 1944," when Sobel did Milky Way appeared in Sobel's 1946 solo show at Peggy Guggen- not show there until 1945. Kays also pointed out that Greenberg's heim's gallery, Art of This Century.l1 Pollock, too, employed astro- claim in 1958 that Tobey's show came months later" is inaccurate, al- nomical themes in titles of the immediately succeeding years, al- though accepted by Rubin, since Tobey showed his all-over paintings though he was still working with traditional oil paints. However, in at the Willard Gallery during April 4-29, 1944, actually preceding 1947 he added aluminum paint and gravel to the oil in Galaxy, slightly Sobel's first solo show at the Puma Gallery, which opened on and used enamel paint, together with oil and aluminum paint, in April 24, 1944, and remained on view through May 14. the large dripped canvas Lucifer. The enamel paint that Sobel Pollock did, however, see Sobel's Puma Gallery show. Pollock's used in Milky Way came from her husband's costume jewelry friend, the painter Peter Busa, told an interviewer: "When Jackson business. first saw her show at the Puma Gallery, he was very enthralled Greenberg wrote to Sobel's son Sol in 1971, confirming and re- with it."5 Although a checklist of the 26 works shown at the Puma iterating his opinion: "Thank you for your note about your mother Gallery exists, not all of the titles can be identified. At the same & her art. Yes, I did give Bill Rubin his lead. (I was impressed by time, a 1944 review in the Brooklyn Eagle discussed the exhibition the same painting, independently, that Pollock was impressed by; This content downloaded from 150.108.161.119 on Sat, 07 Dec 2019 17:46:46 UTC WOMAN'S ART JOURNAL 0 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms Fig. 1. Janet Sobel, Through the Glass (c. 1944), enamel on glass, oil and sand .r'8-" > ' . 1j ,f.' . 1$ on canvas, 261/" x 293/8". Courtesy Gary Snyder Gallery, New York. Fig. 2. Janet Sobel, The Advisor (1943), oil on masonite, 24" x 24". isn't it in Peggy Guggenheim's collection now? Pollock told me, in Courtesy Gary Snyder Gallery, New York. 1948 when he saw-in reproduction-his first Tobey, that he thought your mother was better.) I, too, would like to see you."' show. Indeed, at the time more than one critic remarked that So- By 1945, Sobel was attracting attention that was remarkable, bel used "her own version of white writing," clearly linking her especially considering that critics had identified her a year earlier work with Tobey's. as "a housewife from Brooklyn who really does have a delightful Until Milky Way was acquired by Rubin in 1968 and shown decorative flair for pattern and color," and as a "primitive," and "an among the recent acquisitions at the Museum of Modern Art in unschooled artist."'2 She was juried into "The Women" at Peggy 1970, two decades had elapsed since Sobel's work had been ex- Guggenheim's gallery, where her abstractions appeared alongside hibited in New York City.7 After the burst of activity during and works by such important women artists as Leonora Carrington, just after World War II, neither galleries nor museums paid her Kay Sage, and Hedda Sterne.