Ecological Studies of Cancer Incidence in an Area Interested by Dumping Waste
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
ANN IST SUPER SANITÀ 2011 | VOL. 47, NO. 2: 181-191 181 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_11_02_10 ES Ecological studies of cancer incidence I in an area interested by dumping waste sites in Campania (Italy) ETHODOLOG M Lucia Fazzo(a), Marco De Santis(a), Francesco Mitis(b), Marta Benedetti(a), (b) (a) (c) ND A Marco Martuzzi , Pietro Comba and Mario Fusco (a)Dipartimento di Ambiente e Connessa Prevenzione Primaria, Istituto Superiore di Sanità, Rome, Italy (b) RCH World Health Organization, Centro Europeo Ambiente e Salute, Rome, Italy A (c)Registro Tumori della Regione Campania c/o ASL Napoli 4, Brusciano, Italy ESE R Summary. Cancer incidence was investigated in an area which has been affected by the illegal prac- tices of dumping hazardous waste and setting fire to mismanaged waste. For the 35 municipalities of this area that are served by a Cancer Registry, municipal standardized incidence ratios (SIR) and hierarchical Bayesian estimators (BIR) were computed. Moreover, municipal spatial clustering and a Poisson regression by municipality index of waste-related exposure were performed for 10 cancer types. Increased municipality SIRs were found for some cancer types. The BIRs confirmed the in- creases for liver cancer in two municipalities. Statistically significant clusters were detected for liver, lung, leukaemia and soft tissue sarcomas. In the regression analysis, testis cancer showed significant trend with the index of waste-related exposure (RR = 1.18). Key words: cancer incidence, waste dumping sites, testicular neoplasms, liver neoplasms. Riassunto (Studi ecologici dell’incidenza tumorale in un’area interessata da siti di smaltimento di rifiuti in Campania, Italia). È stata investigata l’incidenza oncologica in un’area interessata da pratiche illegali di smaltimento e di combustione incontrollata di rifiuti. Per i 35 comuni di quest’area serviti da un Registro Tumori sono stati calcolati i rapporti standardizzati di incidenza (standardized inci- dence ratios, SIR) e gli stimatori bayesiani (BIR). Per 10 sedi tumorali sono state eseguite, inoltre, analisi di cluster spaziali e di regressione con un indice municipale di esposizione a rifiuti. SIR in eccesso sono stati osservati per diverse sedi tumorali; i BIR hanno confermato gli eccessi di tumore epatico in due comuni. I tumori epatici e polmonari, le leucemie e i sarcomi dei tessuti molli hanno mostrato cluster significativi. Nell’analisi di regressione il tumore del testicolo ha mostrato un trend in eccesso significativo (RR = 1,18). Parole chiave: incidenza tumorale, rifiuti, neoplasie del testicolo, neoplasie del fegato. INTRODUCTION health effects, even though the evidence (stronger The territory of Naples and Caserta Provinces in for reproductive outcomes than for cancer) is not Campania Region (Southern Italy), consisting of conclusive. Similar conclusions were reached for in- 196 municipalities, has been extensively affected, cinerators, with specific reference to a possible role since the eighties, by the illegal practices of dumping of dioxins in the increased risk in soft tissue sarco- hazardous waste and setting fire to both hazardous mas (STS) and non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma (NHL) and solid urban mismanaged waste. A part of this [1]. A more recent review of epidemiological stud- area (77 municipalities) has been declared “site of ies published between 1983 and 2008 about health national interest for remediation” by the Ministry of effects of solid urban waste management reached Environment, because of the presence of dumping comparable conclusions [2]. waste sites, together with other sources of environ- For some cancer types a priori hypotheses of an mental pollution. association with residence near waste management In the last decades, several studies on the possible sites appear to be more consistent, even if with health impact of waste management and disposal the limitations indicated by the above-mentioned were published. A WHO Report on these issues was reviews. Associations with residence in the neigh- published in 2007; it concluded that the scientific lit- bourhood of landfill sites have been suggested for erature provides some indication of the association following cancer types: liver, lung, stomach, kidney, between residence near a landfill site and adverse bladder and leukaemia [3-9]. Address for correspondence: Lucia Fazzo, Dipartimento di Ambiente e Connessa Prevenzione Primaria, Istituto Superiore di Sanità, Viale Regina Elena 299, 00161 Rome, Italy. E-mail: [email protected]. ANNALI_2_2011.indb 181 9-06-2011 14:30:43 182 Lucia Fazzo, Marco De Santis, Francesco Mitis, et al. In light of the widespread practice of setting fire risks in high exposure compared to low exposure in- ES I to waste deposits in parts of the study area and the dex municipalities for all causes, all cancer and liver subsequent detection of high levels of dioxins in ani- cancer mortality in both genders, stomach cancer mal milk [10], even if no waste incinerator was oper- and lung cancer in men, and for the occurrence of ating in the area, literature about the health impact congenital anomalies of the internal urogenital tract ETHODOLOG of incinerators was considered. Increased risks for and of the central nervous system. liver and lung cancer, NHL and STS were reported The aim of the present study is to describe the spa- M in the neighbourhood of incinerators [2]. tial distribution of neoplastic disease incidence in ND A Even if there is not direct epidemiological evi- this area and to generate hypotheses of etiological dence of an increase risk of testis cancer in areas interest with respect to the aforementioned waste- RCH A with waste dumping sites, testis cancer was included related exposures, that might subsequently be tested in the study. The a priori etiological hypotheses were by ad hoc analytical studies. Cancer incidence is in ESE R derived by awareness of the possible etiological role fact a more valid outcome than mortality, because it of exposure to endocrine disruptors [11]. The en- is based on pathology data and it is not affected by docrine disruptors are also taken into account in differential survival patterns reflecting differences the etiology of congenital malformations [12] and in access to appropriate diagnostic and therapeutic in the assessment of congenital malformations risk procedures. Furthermore, the use of incidence data around landfills [1]. Similarly, biliary tract cancer enables the study of neoplastic diseases character- was included for its suspected association with ex- ized by low mortality rates. The present study was posure to endocrine disruptors [13]. prompted by the availability of cancer incidence With regard to the territory of Naples and Caserta data in a subarea of the Province of Naples, com- provinces, since 2006 several studies have been car- prising 35 municipalities, that is served by a cancer ried out on cause-specific mortality and prevalence registry (Figure 1). of congenital malformations in this area, in order to investigate the health status of the population and its potential relationship with the presence of dump- MATERIALS AND METHODS ing waste sites. The first study showed increased risks The study area is constituted by the municipalities in cancer mortality in the southern part of Caserta of Naples Province, served by a Cancer Registry; the province and in the northern part of Naples prov- time-window of analysis is from 1997 to 2005, cor- ince [14]. Subsequently, municipal cluster analysis responding to that of the Registry’s time coverage. of cancer mortality and congenital malformations The Cancer Registry of Local Health Authority occurrence showed significant clusters of munici- “Naples 4”, the only cancer registry operating in palities located in the same areas evidenced in the Caserta and Naples Provinces, constituted the source previous study [15]. More recently, a study has been of the study subjects. The Registry is part of the published on the correlation between cancer mor- Italian Network of Cancer Registries (AIRTUM) tality, prevalence of congenital anomalies at birth and is certified by International Agency for Research and a municipal waste-related exposure index [16]. on Cancer (IARC) at the international level [17]. The findings, adjusted for socioeconomic depriva- The Cancer Registry database includes 17 300 cas- tion, show statistically significant increased relative es of cancer diagnosed in the period 1997-2005 and Fig. 1 | The map of study area of Naples Province in Campania Region (Italy). ANNALI_2_2011.indb 182 9-06-2011 14:30:43 CANCER INCIDENCE IN AN AREA OF CAMPANIA 183 resident at the time of diagnosis in the 35 municipal- software package. BIRs, bayesian smoothed relative ES ities of area of the Local Health Authority “Naples risks, with their 95% credibility intervals were com- I 4”. According to the coding rules adopted in cancer puted with the Rapid Inquiry Facility (RIF), using registration, International Classification Diseases WinBugs [21, 22] based on the procedures by Besag for Oncology 3rd edition (ICD-O-3) codes based on et al, [23]. For STS morphologic classification only, topographic criteria were used. The SIR and BIR 90% confidence intervals were used, in order to bal- ETHODOLOG analyses included 14 892 cases diagnosed in the pe- ance the fairly low statistical power due to small M riod 1997-2005 with the following 25 cancer types: sample, also in view of the relatively stronger avail- ND A head and neck, esophagus, stomach, colon-rectum, able a priori hypotheses. liver, biliary ducts, pancreas, larynx, lung, skin Clustering and regression analyses were performed RCH (melanoma), mesothelioma, breast, uterine cervix, only for 10 of all the 25 selected cancer types, for A uterus, prostate, testis, kidney, bladder, brain, thy- which a priori hypotheses of an association with ESE roid, Hodgkin’s lymphoma, non Hodgkin’s lympho- residence near waste dumping sites were available R ma, myeloma, leukaemia and malignant tumours of (stomach, liver, biliary ducts, lung, soft-tissue sar- the connective and soft tissue (the category of the comas, kidney, bladder, non Hodgkin’s lymphoma, topographical classification in which most of the leukaemia, testis) and for all cancers.