CG21 bis:CG21 bis 18/06/08 12:02 Page 25 O.H. CREIGHTON ‘THE RICH MAN IN HIS CASTLE, THE POOR MAN AT HIS GATE’ 1 : CASTLE BAILEYS AND SETTLEMENT PATTERNS IN NORMAN ENGLAND F RECENT DEVELOPMENTS within British castellology, one of the most important factor of all in the nucleation of rural the more significant has been an upsurge in interest in communities in medieval Europe 3. In parts of continental O the wider settings of castles and their place within the Europe, especially the Mediterranean zone, medieval castles medieval landscape. Particularly striking has been an increas - have long been viewed as catalytic features in rural landscapes. ing realisation that the immediate environs of many later The incastellamento phenomenon – the nestling of enclosed medieval castles were composed to produce ornamental rural communities around seigneurial sites on prominent topo - settings, while through survey and fieldwork, archaeological graphical positions, so characteristic of parts of Italy in the research projects have progressively broadened their horizons ninth and tenth centuries – is only part of a wider phenomenon to examine interrelationships between fortifications and their whereby castles acted as nuclei for rural settlement growth 4. But hinterlands 2. This paper focuses on an important yet often in England, the place of castles within the medieval settlement neglected aspect of the castle’s interrelationship with its pattern has frequently been overlooked, and their contribution surroundings – its impact on patterns of human settlement, in to its evolution somewhat under-estimated. the context of eleventh- and twelfth-century England. Using a In the English countryside most private castles were simul - combination of archaeological, documentary and landscape taneously manorial centres, with appurtenances of lordship evidence, particular attention will be given to the significance such as fishponds or watermills not unusually linked to the of castle baileys and outer baileys as topographical factors in the defences of baileys and outworks, or else found in immediate growth, reorganisation and planning of settlements. Such association. A further indication of the close connection evidence has, in turn, great significance for our understanding between castles and the rural economy is their context within of far wider issues of interest, including social and economic the rural settlement pattern, and in particular, their importance relationships between lords and communities, and definitions as elements of village topography. Sites of lordship frequently of communal and private defence in town and country. structured the topographical characteristics of rural settlements, In their seminal work The Village and House in the Middle with baileys or precincts often providing a ‘morphological Ages (first published 1980), Jean Chapelot and Robert Fossier frame’ for the settlement and the high-status core constituting viewed the castle as a ‘mother economic cell’ – ‘indubitably’ a ‘plan dominant’ and frequently a focal point for growth 5. The planning or re-casting of villages by castle lords is but 1. C. F. Alexander, from the third verse of the popular hymn ‘All Things one manifestation of a wider phenomenon of seigneurial inter - Bright and Beautiful’ (1848). The verse (usually omitted in modern versions) vention in medieval settlement change. A particularly clear ends ‘God made them, high or lowly, and ordered their estate’. 2. For examples of recent studies of the landscape settings of individual castles see EVERSON et al. , 2000; HIGHAM & BARKER , 2000; DARLINGTON , 3. CHAPELOT & FOSSIER , 1985, 129-33. 2001. For synthesis see CREIGHTON , 2002; JOHNSON , 2002, ch. 2; 4. W ICKHAM , 1981, 162-3, 173-4; CHRISTIE , 1999, 45. CREIGHTON & HIGHAM , 2003, ch. 6. 5. R OBERTS , 1987, 73-5. Château Gaillard 21 , p. 25-36, Publications du C RAHM , 2004 CG21 bis:CG21 bis 18/06/08 12:02 Page 26 26 O.H. C REIGHTON example of a settlement bearing the hallmarks of lordly plan - LAXTON, NOTTS. ning in association with a castle focus is the Nottinghamshire village of Laxton, one of the most celebrated of all English Fishponds Castle medieval villages on account of its substantially surviving open field system 6. Far from being the ‘typical’ Midland village sometimes assumed, detailed scrutiny of Laxton’s morphology as reflected in a remarkable estate map of 1635 indicates that the settlement was planned or re-planned with a large Norman motte and bailey castle as its focus (Fig. 1), most likely when the castle emerged as an important estate centre of the de Caux family in the twelfth century 7. Particu - larly striking is the formalised relationship between the castle site and principal east-west street, with a series of regular plots bounded by a former back lane. Reinforced by a substan - tial linear bank, this feature formed a ‘seam’ in the settlement plan, demarcating the boundary between the lord’s demesne (containing a seigneurial park, fishponds, rabbit warren, stable one facilities and possible jousting paddock) and the village. hectare 0 250m Notably, the outer bailey also extended up to this boundary, which clearly exerted a profound topographical influence on settlement form and development. Fig. 1 : Plan of Laxton (Nottinghamshire), based on Ordnance A number of archaeological excavations and related surveys Survey First Edition (1887), showing the relationship between the have also provided compelling evidence for the planning of motte and bailey castle a village plan with clear planned elements. rural settlements relative to castle foci in the eleventh and twelfth centuries. In the Oxfordshire parish of Middleton uncertain, however, as do the seigneurial motives, although Stoney, a long-term programme of excavation and fieldwork tightening social control and economic rationalisation would established that a small castle of the de Camville family was a seem to be important factors. To these three examples can be relatively impermanent feature of village topography, being added many others, including several in Yorkshire, where estate built in the mid twelfth century but dismantled on the orders of -reorganisation and planning of castles and associated villages King John in 1216 8. Yet during this brief period of high-status by Norman landlords in the wake of economic dislocation in the occupancy, the local settlement pattern was radically re-oriented eleventh and early twelfth centuries seems to have been partic - following the grant of a market, a deer park created, the road ularly commonplace. Likely candidates include Bowes and system re-planned, and a new parish church built in close asso - Bishopton (County Durham), Cropton, Kirkby Malzeard and ciation with the seat of lordship. Clearly there is no simple Sheriff Hutton (North Yorkshire), and Barwick-in-Elmet (West correspondence between the longevity or status of a castle site Yorkshire) 11 . We must not overlook, however, that beyond the and the level of the seigneurial impact on landscape reorgani - central belt of village England, in areas where the medieval sation. countryside contained fewer nucleations and a more kaleido - In the Lincolnshire claylands, the ‘classic’ deserted village scopic blend of smaller hamlets and farmsteads (as in the south- of ‘Goltho’ partially excavated, along with an associated mano - west peninsula) that most Norman castles still functioned as rial site and castle, in the late 1960s and early 1970s appears to manorial centres within a settlement pattern where lordship have been another settlement whose plan bears the hallmarks was not expressed in the planning of villages 12 . of seigneurial intervention 9. Here, a large and regular row- While disruption of property due to the construction of based unit of plots appears to have been grafted onto an earlier castles appears to have been a characteristic feature of Norman village core containing the castle and adjacent church, proba - urban castle-building (see below), rather less frequently does bly early in the twelfth century when the manor was consoli - evidence emerge for the imposition of Norman castles and their dated by the de Kyme family, whose presence within the parish baileys over villages. The limited evidence available suggests was also signified by the upgrading of the castle and establish - that where Norman castle-builders superimposed on extant ment of a deer park and new Gilbertine priory 10 . The precise rural communities this was generally in the face of extreme chronologies for such policies of settlement re-planning remain military necessity. The unusual unfinished castle of Burwell (Cambridgeshire), was one of a chain of fen-edge sites rapidly erected in a brief royal campaign of the 1140s. These circum - 6. ORWIN & ORWIN , 1967. stances, of pragmatic response to short-term military circum - 7. C AMERON , 1980, 220-4. 8. R AHTZ & ROWLEY , 1984. 9. B ERESFORD , 1975; 1987. 11. CREIGHTON , 1999; 2002, 202-6. 10. E VERSON , 1988; CREIGHTON , 2002, 21-7. 12. H IGHAM , 1982, 106. Château Gaillard 21 , p. 25-36, Publications du CRAHM , 2004 CG21 bis:CG21 bis 18/06/08 12:02 Page 27 ‘The Rich Man in his Castle, The Poor Man at His Gate’ 27 stances, seem to explain why a site was chosen that entailed the many other of the numerous eleventh- and twelfth-century clearance of part of a village, as with the nearby and contem - mottes and ringworks located within iron-age hillforts, includ - porary site of Rampton 13 . The clearest archaeological evidence ing sites such as Hembury and Loddiswell (Devon), Mount of village disruption is at Eaton Socon (Cambridgeshire). Here, Caburn, Glynde (East Sussex) and Barwick-in-Elmet (West construction or expansion of the site’s bailey defences buried Yorkshire), were associated with enclosed settlements that have a church, cemetery and part of an extensive settlement subse - left no tangible traces. quently transplanted to a fresh site; again a military Anarchy- While it is customary to describe sites such as these as period context seems likely, with the site occupying a ‘deserted’ settlements, this terminology obscures the fact that strategically important crossing of the Ouse 14 .