2021 Arab Region
QS Quacquarelli Symonds Developed +100 Academic +10 Branches Programs
Graduate +30 Studies Programs GoGeek
+55K students Platform
Scientific +20 Research +66 Patents Centers
جامعة الملك خالد kkueduksa kkumc www.kku.edu.sa King Khalid University ﺣﺎﺻﻞ ﻋﻠﻰ اﻻﻋﺘﻤﺎد اﻟﻤﺆﺳﺴﻲ ﻣﻦ اﻟﻤﺮﻛﺰ اﻟﻮﻃﻨﻲ ﻟﻠﺘﻘﻮﻳﻢ واﻻﻋﺘﻤﺎد اﻻﻛﺎدﻳﻤﻲ Institutionally Accredited by National Center for Academic Accreditation and Evaluation Quality and Accreditation: Memberships: 40 +
Graduates Employment Rate* 2017 18 Graduates 75 %
UBT_EDU WWW.UBT.EDU.SA 920000490 QS HIGHER EDUCATION REPORT FEATURING THE 2021 ARAB REGION RANKINGS
Contents
Welcome . 5
Arab Leaders’ Thoughts . 7
Rankings Overview. 12
Methedology. 16
Rankings Tables. 17
Innovative Arab Region. 22
Post-lockdown. 36
Contributors. 49
ﺣﺎﺻﻞ ﻋﻠﻰ اﻻﻋﺘﻤﺎد اﻟﻤﺆﺳﺴﻲ ﻣﻦ اﻟﻤﺮﻛﺰ اﻟﻮﻃﻨﻲ ﻟﻠﺘﻘﻮﻳﻢ واﻻﻋﺘﻤﺎد اﻻﻛﺎدﻳﻤﻲ Institutionally Accredited by National Center for Academic Accreditation and Evaluation Quality and Accreditation: Memberships: 40 +
Graduates Employment Rate* 2017 18 Graduates 75 %
3 UBT_EDU WWW.UBT.EDU.SA 920000490
QS HIGHER EDUCATION REPORT FEATURING THE 2021 ARAB REGION RANKINGS
Welcome
Welcome to the October 2020 QS Higher Education Report featuring the 2021 Arab Region Rankings.
The release of this report and its associated rankings are timely, published just over a month after the first virtual QS MAPLE Conference and Exhibition in September 2020. We had originally planned on holding QS MAPLE 2020 in March, but sudden travel restrictions at the time caused a postponement.
While we were disappointed to not meet in person to discuss Building World-Class Universities, the sudden postponement refocused discussions on another area of interest for the region, economic In this Higher Education diversity and globalization. Over the two-day event, experts and higher Report, we bring you education leaders, as well as our first non-human speaker, Sophia some of the highlights of the Robot, discussed Innovative Middle East and Africa, centered on MAPLE 2020. the opportunities and difficulties within the region as many countries continue towards their Vision 2030 strategies.
In this Higher Education Report, we bring you some of the highlights of MAPLE 2020 as well as the QS and Elsevier roundtable, a closed-door event held a day prior to the conference and exhibition. The hour-long discussion covered several areas of interest for university leaders within the region, revealing which concerns overlap and across which countries.
Outside of the Arab region alone, this month’s report unpacks the post-lockdown plans of universities, the thoughts of students, and the possibilities for the future.
I look forward to seeing you in person at MAPLE when circumstances allow and virtually at the next MAPLE in March 2021.
Anton John Crace Editor QS Quacquarelli Symonds
5
QS HIGHER EDUCATION REPORT FEATURING THE 2021 ARAB REGION RANKINGS
Arab Leaders’ Thoughts
By Monica Hornung Cattan, Head of Programs, QS Quacquarelli Symonds
In the lead up to the 2020 MAPLE Virtual Conference and Exhibition in September, QS and Elsevier hosted a roundtable with higher education leaders from the Middle East and Africa, centered on the areas of consideration for university vice chancellors and presidents. Using Elsevier and Ipsos MORI’s 2020 report, Challenges university leaders face in an ever-changing world, to frame discussions, the roundtable uncovered areas in which the strategic planning of institutions in the Middle East and Africa both correspond and differ from others around the world.
Leaders also noted they While the historical context of the discussions will remain firmly rooted needed to communicate within a period of uncertainty and lockdowns due to COVID-19, the the quality and benefits roundtable further highlighted that universities’ overall sensitivities in of online degrees. September 2020 were more or less unchanged compared to up to a decade earlier. Rather than completely overhauling higher education, at that point in time at least, the coronavirus pandemic has sped up changes. Leaders at the roundtable also noted this was creating both positive and negative impacts overall.
Elsevier and Ipsos MORI’s report as well as the points raised by university leaders broadly fell into one of eight topics: Developing Strategy, Nurturing Culture, Benchmarking Performance, Building Brand, Driving Research Quality, Establishing Partnerships with Industry, International Collaboration, and Demonstrating Impact. Digital transformation pre-COVID-19
While online education has ramped up significantly during the global pandemic, due in large part to necessity as campuses remain closed, the university leaders were clear to point out much of the digital transformation of university education had already been underway. In some cases, one leader noted, digital and online had been under discussion for over a decade.
Instead, the leaders said COVID-19 had been an accelerant for digital transformation rather than a catalyst.
7 QS HIGHER EDUCATION REPORT FEATURING THE 2021 ARAB REGION RANKINGS
For the region, however, leaders highlighted concerns around the progress of development, particularly for areas underserved by infrastructure. Some gaps in the availability of high- speed internet, for example were putting strains on their ability to continue their efforts towards advancing education access. Additionally, institutions with more advanced experience of digital delivery were in a better position during COVID-19 to continue students’ education. The leaders called for more collaborative support between institutions in the region to push all up to the same level. Collaboration and research
The acceleration of digital transformation across university campuses, however, did present several opportunities to bolster an institution’s impact and level of external collaboration, according to one leader. The technology that has accompanied the online has created new areas of research, particularly around Artificial
8 QS HIGHER EDUCATION REPORT FEATURING THE 2021 ARAB REGION RANKINGS
Intelligence, the Internet of continue to serve the needs working more closely with Things, the Internet of Energy, of the community. One leader the community, industry, and and Digital Twins. said they were particularly society more broadly to convey mindful that research and that message better. In the Just as digital transformation collaboration, which has its same way institutions need has created new areas for own set of benefits in terms to continue to engage with higher education research, the of global reputation, did not the community around their technology has also facilitated supplant local community research, they also must work new ways to undertake engagement. The leaders to change societal perceptions collaborative partnerships. said universities in the of the value of online and According to one leader, this region were balancing local digital education. itself represents a potential and international needs reshaping of university As much as COVID-19 has simultaneously. relationships, and speculated caused significant negative institutions should shift disruption in higher education, their interests from seeing The acceleration of digital the pandemic could potentially themselves as predominantly transformation, however, did push positive changes in competitors to predominantly the way society view virtual present several opportunities. collaborators. education. In the same way opinions on work and working Community and industry from home have changed, Culture As institutions strive to bolster and the way business and the inter-university research Despite the possibilities connecting with peers has collaboration, a significant provided by the rise of digital been altered, this period could opportunity within the education, some leaders be a watershed moment. It region is to similarly bolster also noted they needed to is an opportunity to change industry and private sector communicate the quality and the way the Arab region views partnerships. This, according benefits of online degrees. the value of new education to some leaders, would also One raised concerns that in practices and in turn become a see a significant improvement some areas of the region, an world leader, according to the in research and employability online degree was not viewed roundtable speakers. output. as positively as an in-person This is an abridged version of an degree. While doing so, however, upcoming larger report. other leaders said they were The leaders said as a mindful of ensuring they consequence, they were
9 Organizing Partner
THE FUTURE OF MEDICINE: Challenges and Opportunities in the Disruptive Era
JOIN US ONLINE!
scan me 04 - 06 August 2020 | 14:00 - 17:00 GMT+7
www.qssubjectfocus.com/bangkok-2020 Organizing Partner
THE FUTURE OF MEDICINE: Challenges and Opportunities in the Disruptive Era
JOIN US ONLINE!
scan me 04 - 06 August 2020 | 14:00 - 17:00 GMT+7
www.qssubjectfocus.com/bangkok-2020 QS HIGHER EDUCATION REPORT FEATURING THE 2021 ARAB REGION RANKINGS
Arab Region Rankings Overview
By Dr Andrew MacFarlane, Rankings Manager, QS Quacquarelli Symonds
Welcome to the QS World institutions we evaluated this for the Arab Region is almost University Rankings: Arab year worked hard with us to 23 percent more than the Region 2021, our annual verify data and check accuracy. previous year. There is a clear insight into the top performing push in the region to intensify The 2021 edition saw 160 institutions in the Arab region. research, and this is paying off institutions ranked, up from for overall performance. In what has been a 130 last year. This increase challenging year for the is not only a result of more We have maintained a higher education sector sustained efforts around data consistent methodology this across the globe, the level of collection and institutional year. This allows students and engagement from institutions engagement, but a sign that institutions alike to benchmark in the Arab region has been absolute performance, in historical performance more tremendously encouraging. terms of reputation, research, easily. Therefore, we can and teaching is on the rise. begin to look at what the top We aim to provide students performing institutions have with our original data and To add further support to this, in common, and some areas insights to help empower we have seen an increase for growth from emerging them to make the best of 15 percent in papers institutions. decisions for themselves. To and 20 percent in citations, do this, we rely on the support more than double the global In line with any QS ranking, of institutions in the region to growth in the same period. reputation forms a crucial ensure that their data is up- By institution, the average component of the success to-date, accurate and full. The citation increase in the Top 100 of the top institutions.
12 QS HIGHER EDUCATION REPORT FEATURING THE 2021 ARAB REGION RANKINGS
Encouragingly, we have seen Institutions that score well important to employers in the solid year on year increases in in this tend to have well- Middle East region, and the the international nominations rounded faculty offerings, a skills of graduates that they received in our Academic strong culture of research, are least satisfied with. The Reputation surveys. We saw and well-established global most important skills were a 37 percent increase in partnerships. Institutions with flexibility, communication, and academic nominations of our strong scores in reputation problem solving. Professional 2019 and 2020 ranking, and also tend to score well in our experience was the most a further 31 percent between other indicators, bolstering sought after characteristic our 2020 and 2021 rankings. the unsurprising truth that of the global employers we The majority of nominations well-rounded institutions offer surveyed. It is paramount in the region are coming from high quality education to their that institutions prepare their Engineering and Technology, students. students for the realities of which when taken together the global workplace. By Equipping students for with the increase in citations ensuring that work experience life after graduation is an in this field (23 precent), is woven into the fabric of especially important role for indicates a strong focus on their education, as well as institutions, particularly as sciences from the region. integrating these soft skills many students face uncertain into the learning experience, Reputation is a hard-earned futures. In our annual QS institutions will be supporting metric that takes time to Global Employer Survey, their students’ futures in the build and effort to nurture. we looked at the skills most region and beyond.
13 REINTRODUCING QS IN CONVERSATION An online series bringing together higher education’s thought leaders
FIND OUT MORE at qsinconversation.com
#QSinconversation
QS HIGHER EDUCATION REPORT FEATURING THE 2021 ARAB REGION RANKINGS
16 61-70 81-90 25 25 28 31 37 30 32 33 28 12 45 27 10 46 42 11 13 38 15 49 14 41 17 40 22 34 16 18 20 43 35 21 47 19 39 48 24 23 36 1 2 4 3 5 6 7 8 9 2020 Institution Name KING ABDULAZIZUNIVERSITY(KAU) NOTRE DAME UNIVERSITY-LOUAIZE (NDU) AMERICAN UNIVERSITYOFBEIRUT(AUB) MANSOURA UNIVERSITY QATAR UNIVERSITY APPLIED SCIENCEUNIVERSITYOFBAHRAIN (KFUPM) KING FAHD UNIVERSITYOFPETROLEUM&MINERALS HOLY SPIRITUNIVERSITYOFKASLIK UNITED ARABEMIRATES UNIVERSITY KING KHALIDUNIVERSITY KING SAUDUNIVERSITY(KSU) ASSIUT UNIVERSITY AMERICAN UNIVERSITYOFSHARJAH KING FAISAL UNIVERSITY SULTAN QABOOS UNIVERSITY YARMOUK UNIVERSITY KHALIFA UNIVERSITY AJMAN UNIVERSITY AJMAN ABU DHABIUNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY OFJORDAN AN-NAJAH NATIONALAN-NAJAH UNIVERSITY THE AMERICANUNIVERSITYINCAIRO PRINCESS SUMAYA UNIVERSITYFORTECHNOLOGY CAIRO UNIVERSITY PRINCESS NOURAHBINTABDULRAHMANUNIVERSITY JORDAN UNIVERSITYOFSCIENCEANDTECHNOLOGY ALFAISAL UNIVERSITY LEBANESE AMERICANUNIVERSITY HELWAN UNIVERSITY AIN SHAMSUNIVERSITY CANADIAN UNIVERSITYOFDUBAI UNIVERSITY OFSHARJAH (FORMERLY UNIVERSITYOFDAMMAM) IMAM ABDULRAHMANBINFAISAL UNIVERSITY(IAU) UMM AL-QURAUNIVERSITY(UQU) ARABIAN GULFUNIVERSITY ALEXANDRIA UNIVERSITY PRINCE MOHAMMADBINFAHD UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITÉ SAINT-JOSEPH DEBEYROUTH ZAYED UNIVERSITY AHLIA UNIVERSITY LEBANESE UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY OFKUFA KUWAIT UNIVERSITY GERMAN JORDANIAN UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY OFBAGHDAD THE HASHEMITEUNIVERSITY BEIRUT ARABUNIVERSITY AMERICAN UNIVERSITYINDUBAI UNIVERSITY OFBAHRAIN UNIVERSITY OFBALAMAND QS HIGHEREDUCATION REPORTFEATURING THE2021ARABREGIONRANKINGS SA LB LB EG QA BH SA LB AE SA SA EG AE SA OM JO AE AE AE JO PS EG JO EG SA JO SA LB EG EG AE AE SA SA BH EG SA LB AE BH LB IQ KW JO IQ JO LB AE BH LB location 100 0 99 9 38 8 99 3 65 3 93 2 43 5 99 7 26 5 97 7 58 4 99 8 61 3 96 2 79 0 82 3 66 3 70 3 43 4 49 7 98 7 36 8 99 1 33 5 45 9 91 4 13 7 65 7 34 0 93 0 36 5 80 6 33 8 74 2 20 6 92 7 30 7 60 0 64 9 37 5 71 7 37 7 76 5 37 6 74 7 37 4 40 3 52 2 66 2 29 5 Academic Reputation 100 100 91 34 91 79 88 76 98 14 67 27 97 28 71 58 61 82 54 98 64 93 55 96 63 90 10 98 61 86 47 72 21 48 15 71 37 99 66 39 96 64 58 51 60 49 67 83 66 80 Employer Reputation 96 4 92 3 96 6 62 8 83 6 93 3 88 1 92 1 26 7 68 1 23 6 97 6 99 6 15 7 17 7 32 4 18 6 79 4 32 3 21 9 50 5 54 7 75 6 61 2 23 8 50 6 12 9 96 3 93 7 98 8 14 4 26 6 80 1 60 9 64 9 11 6 71 4 10 8 51 3 69 3 23 5 41 6 14 8 99 9 9 2 3 7 6 2 8 54 99 Faculty Student 99 4 28 6 93 7 19 1 98 1 89 5 11 8 96 8 19 8 95 6 14 6 92 5 34 4 12 2 67 3 48 6 17 4 67 5 72 2 32 8 35 7 73 3 32 5 11 1 14 9 20 3 72 8 14 6 32 9 13 8 36 2 48 7 23 4 16 8 42 4 39 1 49 8 23 5 35 6 22 6 12 5 100 100 3 8 8 6 5 1 7 4 14 50 11 Papers per Faculty 48 3 65 9 83 7 49 8 96 7 99 2 50 6 69 6 24 4 90 9 53 7 67 5 47 7 57 9 93 2 33 8 35 3 30 1 23 9 77 3 38 2 43 2 97 5 88 7 52 5 31 2 38 2 26 9 38 7 49 2 42 5 98 2 42 3 41 4 29 7 65 4 20 7 18 9 51 7 100 8 9 1 9 3 7 6 8 8 48 7 7 - - Citations per Paper 10 5 72 1 49 9 48 5 98 3 96 7 70 7 99 2 95 8 56 4 17 6 74 8 82 3 14 4 19 5 58 2 39 6 43 8 10 4 98 4 64 4 12 1 68 3 78 2 71 8 52 1 77 3 25 7 31 5 38 7 71 1 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 2 2 5 2 3 1 3 2 3 4 7 1 2 7 9 99 21 International Faculty 95 4 96 4 16 3 98 7 70 4 88 7 94 4 21 8 65 6 10 5 48 7 57 2 72 5 46 5 18 8 11 9 67 4 89 7 49 8 67 7 93 8 62 2 23 9 85 9 50 1 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 1 2 6 4 1 2 90 48 97 2 Staff with PhD 39 4 46 2 79 3 97 3 58 2 36 4 55 8 61 1 30 8 10 1 29 9 67 3 52 8 36 3 50 3 15 2 53 3 56 8 97 5 65 2 39 7 40 4 76 5 55 7 49 7 46 5 22 6 60 1 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 8 5 3 4 5 9 8 3 3 7 8 1 9 6 9 6 6 1 4 1 2 74 36 51 International Students 15 9 94 3 97 3 98 8 95 9 55 7 82 7 56 8 42 6 98 2 26 3 98 6 25 2 57 6 40 1 99 5 22 1 57 3 42 9 29 2 77 7 11 7 64 2 16 9 28 7 10 6 58 9 20 6 89 5 20 1 66 7 56 8 24 2 47 4 100 100 9 8 5 3 7 8 9 7 8 9 5 2 93 98 98 72 63 91 43 5 International Research Network 27 6 98 2 28 3 78 3 92 3 96 1 21 2 91 9 50 3 54 8 81 8 54 5 83 5 51 5 66 7 32 6 28 9 98 5 97 1 32 5 99 7 28 5 84 7 26 2 73 4 39 5 54 2 15 9 60 3 30 9 86 3 19 7 90 3 20 5 73 1 60 7 84 8 24 5 13 8 24 6 43 4 43 3 31 8 44 3 100 100 100 9 1 8 2 35 Web Impact Overall 17 18 QS HIGHEREDUCATION REPORTFEATURING THE2021ARABREGIONRANKINGS - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 101-110 111-120 111-120 101-110 111-120 101-110 101-110 101-110 111-120 101-110 91-100 91-100 91-100 91-100 91-100 71-80 61-70 71-80 51-60 51-60 81-90 61-70 71-80 81-90 51-60 71-80 51-60 81-90 61-70 71-80 51-60 61-70 61-70 71-80 51-60 51-60 61-70 61-70 71-80 61-70 71-80 81-90 81-90 51-60 81-90 61-70 71-80 71-80 50 50 44 2020 Institution Name AL AZHARUNIVERSITY TANTA UNIVERSITY MARITIME TRANSPORT ARAB ACADEMY FORSCIENCE,TECHNOLOGY AND SALEM AL QUDSUNIVERSITYTHEARABINJERU- UNIVERSITÉ DEMONASTIR FAYOUM UNIVERSITY AMERICAN UNIVERSITYOFRASALKHAIMAH(AURAK) UNIVERSITY OFBABYLON TAIF UNIVERSITY BIRZEIT UNIVERSITY ZAGAZIG UNIVERSITY (GUST) GULF UNIVERSITYFORSCIENCEANDTECHNOLOGY BRITISH UNIVERSITYINEGYPT ISLAMIC UNIVERSITYOFLEBANON EFFAT UNIVERSITY PRINCE SULTAN UNIVERSITY ISLAMIC UNIVERSITYOFGAZA SUEZ CANALUNIVERSITY SOUTH VALLEY UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY OFDUBAI TAIBAH UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY OFKHARTOUM UNIVERSITÉ DECARTHAGE AL NAHRAINUNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY OFBASRAH AL-IMAM MOHAMEDIBNSAUDISLAMICUNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY OFMOSUL AMERICAN UNIVERSITYOFTHEMIDDLEEAST(AUM) UNIVERSITY OFNIZWA BRITISH UNIVERSITYINDUBAI UNIVERSITY OFSADAT CITY GERMAN UNIVERSITYINCAIRO AL-AHLIYYA AMMANUNIVERSITY ISLAMIC UNIVERSITYINMADINAH AMERICAN UNIVERSITYINTHEEMIRATES JEDDAH UNIVERSITY BENHA UNIVERSITY MUSTANSIRIYAH UNIVERSITY CADI AYYAD UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITÉ DETUNISELMANAR MAJMAAH UNIVERSITY MAJMAAH UNIVERSITY OFTECHNOLOGY -IRAQ MUTAH UNIVERSITY AL AINUNIVERSITY PHILADELPHIA UNIVERSITYAT JORDAN AL BALQA APPLIEDUNIVERSITY PRINCE SATTAM BINABDULAZIZ UNIVERSITY DAMASCUS UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITÉ DESOUSSE FUTURE UNIVERSITYINEGYPT UNIVERSITY OFTABUK NAJRAN UNIVERSITY NAJRAN AL AKHAWAYN UNIVERSITYIFRANE QASSIM UNIVERSITY AL ZAYTOONAH UNIVERSITY APPLIED SCIENCEPRIVATE UNIVERSITY-JORDAN EG EG EG PS TN EG AE IQ SA PS EG KW EG LB SA SA PS EG EG AE SA SD TN IQ IQ SA IQ KW OM AE EG EG JO SA AE SA EG IQ MA TN SA IQ JO AE JO JO SA SY TN EG SA SA MA SA JO JO location 55 5 37 7 34 8 34 7 41 6 34 4 41 4 37 3 ------Academic Reputation 47 44 41 51 39 58 ------Employer Reputation 33 2 88 9 29 8 90 8 35 6 46 8 71 3 57 1 19 2 80 9 30 1 22 1 36 1 99 9 20 3 24 2 37 7 82 4 50 6 34 4 67 1 99 6 58 8 92 2 43 7 68 1 32 3 100 100 37 27 64 20 36 ------Faculty Student 26 7 38 9 86 3 17 9 26 5 14 9 16 4 16 5 39 7 16 3 17 9 41 9 77 6 18 3 38 7 20 2 27 7 36 2 18 7 23 1 35 2 32 4 26 2 17 9 33 9 18 1 16 2 16 4 16 7 39 1 24 9 100 58 44 ------Papers per Faculty 28 1 75 6 72 5 71 2 30 9 63 7 44 3 37 6 24 2 87 8 23 5 47 6 58 5 68 2 53 2 44 8 29 8 57 9 31 6 78 6 99 5 82 4 41 8 60 6 29 1 41 7 51 2 73 9 26 1 30 2 100 61 ------Citations per Paper 17 4 26 8 11 2 97 2 99 7 97 4 66 7 25 9 99 4 11 2 36 1 65 5 88 8 78 5 21 9 66 9 81 9 53 4 69 4 10 4 100 100 100 100 100 100 6 2 7 2 87 15 60 ------International Faculty 83 9 29 8 66 4 21 8 49 3 18 8 64 6 71 1 99 1 81 5 44 8 58 2 90 8 84 1 31 9 69 6 96 7 91 5 95 4 64 4 96 5 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 39 ------Staff with PhD 16 4 96 7 21 1 36 9 12 9 36 2 42 4 59 7 99 4 11 6 20 1 34 9 16 9 93 6 37 3 16 8 47 5 99 5 15 1 90 4 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 8 3 14 31 ------International Students 43 2 66 5 79 5 44 5 37 6 24 3 25 5 44 1 37 7 83 6 19 4 27 7 74 8 67 1 69 4 52 2 62 9 33 6 55 7 30 6 40 1 33 2 33 2 70 8 27 2 50 8 74 6 22 2 43 3 30 1 65 4 20 9 79 6 44 25 ------International Research Network 46 4 34 2 41 1 48 3 52 8 53 6 32 4 98 7 41 9 25 9 23 3 77 6 33 9 25 7 37 5 74 8 52 1 34 2 23 6 36 2 32 7 56 5 22 7 80 4 42 6 27 3 26 9 91 2 55 9 27 1 30 2 23 6 48 9 41 ------Web Impact ------Overall - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -