LISTING OF CITATIONS - VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE

Hearing on 8th October 2014 at 10.00 am in Registrar's Office, 240 High Street, Elgin

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

1 23231/49954 STORE ETC YESS ELECTRICAL T 22,250 22,250 22 PINEFIELD PARADE REGIONAL OFFICE MANAGER ELGIN MATHESON A

2 25350/49969 DISTILLERY DIAGEO PLC P 119,000 119,000 LINKWOOD DISTILLERY (PART) PER KENNETH MCCORMACK LINKWOOD GVA JAMES BARR ELGIN GVA JAMES BARR A

3 85214/49930 SITE HUTS DIAGEO PLC P 2,150 2,150 LINKWOOD DISTILLERY (PART) PER KENNETH MCCORMACK LINKWOOD GVA JAMES BARR ELGIN GVA JAMES BARR A

4 85547/50222 CAFE COSTA LTD T 40,500 40,500 UNIT 4A SPRINGFIELD RETAIL PARK EDGAR ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A ELGIN

5 30659/50053 RETAIL WAREHOUSE BRANTANO UK LTD T 99,000 99,000 UNIT 4 SPRINGFIELD RETAIL PARK EDGAR ROAD G L HEARN A ELGIN

6 85181/49929 RETAIL WAREHOUSE STEINHOFF UK GROUP T 64,000 64,000 UNIT 6 PROPERTIES ELGIN RETAIL PARK EDGAR ROAD RAPLEYS A ELGIN

7 85308/49933 RETAIL WAREHOUSE MULTI TILE LTD T 60,500 60,500 UNIT 7 ELGIN RETAIL PARK EDGAR ROAD RAPLEYS A ELGIN

8 23537/49938 SHOP STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD T 43,250 43,250 143 HIGH STREET C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP ELGIN MONTAGU EVANS A

9 23817/49970 OFFICES JOHNSTON CARMICHAEL T 146,000 146,000 COMMERCE HOUSE SOUTH STREET ELGIN WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED A

10 25176/50210 QUARRY TARMAC CALEDONIAN LTD P 22,500 22,500 CLODDACH ESTATES DEPARTMENT 97,500 M 48,750 BIRNIE ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

11 34034/50215 QUARRY TARMAC CALEDONIAN LTD T 50,000 M 25,000 LOCHINVER ESTATES DEPARTMENT ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

12 25462/49916 AIRFIELD DE OPERATIONS NORTH P 30,000 30,000 MILLTOWN ELGIN GVA JAMES BARR A

13 85560/50197 SEPTIC TANK SCOTTISH WATER P 100 100 BLEACHFIELD TERRACE HEAD OFFICE PROPERTY SERVICES GERALD EVE LLP A

01/10/2015 Page 1 of 2 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

14 85452/50047 RIVER GAUGING STATION SCOTTISH ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION P 525 525 CLAYPOTS BRIDGE AGENCY CULLEN BUCKIE

15 26728/50102 TA CENTRE THE RESERVE FORCES & P 18,500 18,500 9 UNION STREET CADETS ASSOCIATION KEITH GVA JAMES BARR A

16 53555/50032 SEPTIC TANK SCOTTISH WATER P 850 850 CRAIGHEAD COTTAGES HEAD OFFICE PROPERTY SERVICES KEITH GERALD EVE LLP A

17 85559/50033 SEPTIC TANK SCOTTISH WATER P 750 750 LONACH CRESCENT HEAD OFFICE ROTHIEMAY PROPERTY SERVICES GERALD EVE LLP A

18 27082/50051 FACTORY WALKERS SHORTBREAD LIMITED P 440,000 440,000 FISHERTON WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED A

19 27271/50198 DISTILLERY THE EDRINGTON GROUP P 1,150,000 1,150,000 MACALLAN CRAIGELLACHIE ABERLOUR GVA JAMES BARR A

20 27320/50067 QUARRY BREEDON AGGREGATES LTD P 5,500 5,500 GLEN 27,500 M 13,750 ROTHES ABERLOUR GERALD EVE LLP A

21 84608/49917 WAREHOUSES GLEN GRANT DISTILLERY COMPANY LTD T 23,000 23,000 STATION STREET PER BRIAN TILLEY CONTROLLER ROTHES GVA JAMES BARR A

22 27578/50106 FIRE STATION SCOTTISH AMBULANCE SERVICE O 16,000 16,000 MAIN STREET GERALD EVE LLP A

23 27639/50094 DISTILLERY WILLIAM GRANT & SONS LTD P 2,150,000 2,150,000 BALVENIE/GLENFIDDICH KEITH GVA JAMES BARR A

24 83448/50103 TELECOMMUNICATIONS NETWORK EVERYTHING EVERYWHERE LIMITED P 466,000 466,000 (PART) (EVERYTHING EVERYWHERE) THE MORAY COUNCIL AREA GVA A

01/10/2015 Page 2 of 2