Arxiv:2101.00365V3 [Math.AC] 1 Feb 2021
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
GENERALIZED F -DEPTH AND GRADED NILPOTENT SINGULARITIES KYLE MADDOX AND LANCE EDWARD MILLER Abstract. We study generalized F -depth and F -depth, depth-like invariants associated to the canonical Frobenius action on the local cohomology modules of a local ring of prime characteristic. These invariants are naturally associated to the singularity types generalized weakly F -nilpotent and weakly F -nilpotent, which have uniform behavior among the Frobenius closure of all parameter ideals simultaneously. By developing natural lower bounds on these invariants, we are able to provide sufficient conditions which produce broad classes of rings that have these singularity types, including constructions like gluing schemes along a common subscheme, Segre products of graded rings, and Veronese subrings of graded rings. We further analyze upper bounds on Frobenius test exponents of these constructions in terms of the input data. 1. Introduction In this paper we introduce and study generalized F -depth, a depth-like invariant inspired by Lyubeznik’s F -depth. Given a local or graded ring of prime characteristic, these F -depth and generalized F -depth track the degree to which the canonical Frobenius action on the local cohomology modules is nilpotent under composition. Moreover, these invariants are naturally associated to singularity types called weakly F -nilpotent and generalized weakly F -nilpotent singularities as outlined below. The first of these is a weak form of F -nilpotent singularities, which were studied by Blickle in [Bli01] and formally introduced by Srinivas-Takagi in [ST17]. Recently, there has been a significant growing body of literature exploring the properties of these singularity types, see [ST17, PQ19, Quy19, Mad19, KMPS]. Throughout the introduction, we loosely refer to these three classes of singularities as nilpotent singularities. d It is well-known that, for a local ring (R, m) of dimension d, the Frobenius action on Hm(R) is never nilpotent. In d fact, observations in early work of Smith [Smi97] already showed the elements of Hm(R) nilpotent under Frobenius ∗ d must be contained in the proper submodule 0 d , the tight closure of 0 in Hm(R). As the Frobenius action on Hm(R) the lower local cohomology modules is possibly nilpotent, a local ring R is called weakly F -nilpotent if the canonical Frobenius action on each lower local cohomology module is nilpotent. A weakly F -nilpotent ring is F -nilpotent if, ∗ in addition, the Frobenius action restricted to 0 d is nilpotent. It is easy to verify that F -rational singularities Hm(R) are F -nilpotent, the converse holding if the ring in question is also F -injective. There are significant connections between F -nilpotent singularities and vanishing of Hodge-type filtrations outlined in [ST17], which is naturally related to the weak ordinarity conjecture. In [Quy19], Quy shows that weakly F -nilpotent local rings have finite Frobenius test exponents. This is a uniform exponent which checks membership inside the Frobenius closure of each parameter ideal of the ring simultaneously. arXiv:2101.00365v3 [math.AC] 1 Feb 2021 One cannot hope to obtain an exponent that works for all ideals, see [Bre06] and [KS06]. Generalizing [Quy19], the first named author introduced generalized weakly F -nilpotent rings in [Mad19] as those for which the submodule of each lower local cohomology module consisting of elements annihilated by a large iterate of the Frobenius action has finite colength. These singularities are the widest known class to admit a finite Frobenius test exponent. Our approach is based on a natural analogy between Cohen-Macaulay rings and weakly F -nilpotent rings, initiated in work of Lyubeznik [Lyu06] and highlighted by the above listed works on nilpotent singularities. In particular, we study similarities between ordinary depth and Lyubeznik’s F -depth to codify that weakly F -nilpotent singularities are analogous to Cohen-Macaulay singularities. Indeed, weakly F -nilpotent singularities are Cohen- Macaulay after applying the Lyubeznik functor; thus rings enjoying these conditions share many properties in common. Just as a Cohen-Macaulay ring is one of full depth, a weakly F -nilpotent ring is one of full F -depth. To complete the picture, we introduce generalized F -depth, and recognize a generalized weakly F -nilpotent ring as one of full generalized F -depth. Date: February 1, 2021. 1 2 KYLE MADDOX AND LANCE EDWARD MILLER Important applications come from theorems we prove about F -depth and generalized F -depth. In particular, we are able to provide ample sufficient conditions to ensure standard constructions in the local and graded setting produce rings with nilpotent singularities. Thus far, no systematic framework for such constructions is present in the literature. This makes the study of nilpotent singularities much less developed than other, more well-studied, F -singularity types. As these singularities are inextricably connected to deep conjectures and important concepts in tight closure, it is of critical value to have suitable classes of examples to study in detail. In the body of the paper, stronger forms of the results explained below are provided, in technical terms, as lower bounds on either F -depth or generalized F -depth. These sharper statements establish the importance in recasting questions about nilpotent singularities as statements about controlling these depth parameters; thereby strengthening the valuable analogy between weakly F -nilpotent and Cohen-Macaulay singularities. We present in the introduction however, a summary of only the results pertinent to constructing rings with nilpotent singularities. To avoid technicalities, we retain for the rest of the introduction that k denotes a perfect field of prime characteristic. The first of our results concerns gluing two schemes together along a common subscheme. It is natural to expect that if the schemes involved have nilpotent singularities, there should be simple conditions to ensure the gluing also has nilpotent singularities. In particular, we provide a nilpotent version of a result of Schwede, see [Sch09, Prop. 4.8], which concerns gluing F -injective, Cohen-Macaulay singularities. We obtain gluing results for weakly F -nilpotent and generalized weakly F -nilpotent singularities, as well as the following result for F -nilpotent singularities. Theorem 1. (Theorem 3.4) If (R, m, k) is a local ring with ideals a and a so that dim R/(a a ) = dim(R/a )= 1 2 1 ∩ 2 1 dim(R/a2) = dim R/(a1 + a2)+1, and R/a1 and R/a2 are F -nilpotent and R/(a1 + a2) is weakly F -nilpotent, then R/a a is F -nilpotent. 1 ∩ 2 We then turn our attention to graded Frobenius actions and graded nilpotent singularities. In particular, we analyze how F -depth and generalized F -depth behave under taking Segre products and Veronese subrings of graded rings. Graded modules with Frobenius actions are well studied from the point of view of Lyubeznik’s -modules, see [Bli01, LSW16] and references therein. The full framework of -modules is not needed for our considerations,F which simplifies the statements and applications in our approach.F Furthermore, careful study of the Hartshorne- Speiser-Lyubeznik numbers are needed to obtain effective bounds on Frobenius test exponents, and this information is lost in the context of -modules. The novelty of working with graded rings and graded Frobenius actions is that one obtains a natural FrobeniusF action on the degree 0 part of a graded module with Frobenius action. This degree 0 part controls much of the story for graded nilpotence and is important for studying graded nilpotent singularities. We call a module nilpotent in degree 0 provided this natural action on the degree 0 part is nilpotent. Theorem 2. (Corollary 4.11 and Theorem 4.14) Suppose R and S are graded rings of depth at least two and dimensions dR and dS respectively, both with degree 0 part k. Set T = R#S the Segre product. If R and S are dR generalized weakly F -nilpotent, so is T . If we further assume R and S are weakly F -nilpotent and HmR (R) and dS HmS (S) are nilpotent in degree 0, then T is weakly F -nilpotent. To further demonstrate these applications, we establish that an interesting class of well-known Segre products are weakly F -nilpotent. The singularities of Segre products of elliptic curves and the projective line are essentially the simplest normal non-Cohen-Macaulay domains of dimension 3, c.f., the example at the end of Section 5 [Lyu06]. Replacing the elliptic curve by a general Fermat hypersurface of degree d, we find that a certain class are not that far off from being Cohen-Macaulay under the analogy described above. Theorem 3. (Theorem 4.18) Let d 1 and p the characteristic of k. Set S = k[u, v] and consider the Fermat d ≥ d d hypersurface R = k[x0,...,xn]/(x0 + + xn−1 xn) with p > d and n 2. If p 1 mod d, then the Segre product R#S is weakly F -nilpotent. ··· − ≥ ≡ − Concerning Veronese subrings, we show that the nilpotence of the local cohomology modules descends from a graded ring to all of its Veronese subrings, and in particular if R is (generalized) weakly F -nilpotent, so is S. We utilize this to provide a nilpotent version of a theorem of Singh, [Sin00, Prop. 3.1], concerning how F -rational singularities behave under taking Veronese subrings. Theorem 4. (Theorem 4.20) Suppose R is a graded ring of dimension d and degree 0 part k. If R is F -nilpotent on the punctured spectrum, then for all n 0, the Veronese R(n) is weakly F -nilpotent. Furthermore, Hd (R) is ≫ mR nilpotent in degree 0 if and only if for all n 0, the Veronese R(n) is F -nilpotent. ≫ GENERALIZED F -DEPTHANDGRADEDNILPOTENTSINGULARITIES 3 To provide a wide class of generic examples, we apply the techniques developed to provide a nilpotent version of the F -rational characterization from [KSSW09, Thm.