Manhattan Retail Report | Fall 2019 Introduction Executive Summary

Home , 72nd Street (Manhattan), Bleecker Street, Fifth Avenue, Midtown South

THE REAL ESTATE BOARD OF NEW YORK

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT | FALL 2019 INTRODUCTION EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

The Manhattan retail market is evolving with an uptick In fall 2019, average asking rents for available ground in year-over-year leasing activity despite an increase floor retail spaces decreased in 11 of the 17 corridors in retail supply. Outlook remains positive with new analyzed by REBNY in its bi-annual Manhattan retail operators entering the market and heightened interest report, compared to the fall of 2018. in retail spaces. High asking rents have begun to drop, resulting in an uptick in leasing activity and a stabilizing In Lower Fifth Avenue, between 42nd and 49th streets, market. Manhattan retail leases in the second half of average asking rents declined 9% year-over-year to 2019 were driven by e-commerce proof of concept uses $852 psf. This drop is attributed to an increased amount such as food/beverage, service, and medical offices. of available spaces, as high-end apparel is leaving the corridor in favor of emerging downtown shopping strips. Despite traditional storefront retail lessening its footprint, Owners are seeking to fill available spaces at a higher other types of brick-and-mortar uses continue to be in rate by offering short-term lease agreements with the demand as new retailers are becoming more innovative hope of attracting more long-term tenants. Notable new in their uses. Omni-channel retail is effective for digitally leases include Lululemon, Uggs, Club Monaco, and native brands that require showrooms to showcase PUMA. In Upper Fifth Avenue, between 49th and 59th their products/services, which act in conjunction with streets, average asking rents declined 5% year-over- their e-commerce and marketing efforts. An increased year to $2,838 psf. Comparing the two corridors, Upper presence of pop-ups and promotional spaces indicate Fifth Avenue is experiencing slower activity, as no recent that brands are offering unique in-person experiences deals have occurred. Asking rents are expected to to attract both online and in-store shoppers. Other uses decrease. such as bookstore cafes and daytime co-working spaces reflect that consumer demand is shifting in favor of In Times Square on Broadway and Seventh Avenue, modern storefront uses. between 42nd and 47th streets, average asking rents increased 2% year-over-year to $1,889 psf. The retail environment in Times Square is adjusting as new leases primarily consist of food/beverage and experiential retail uses. Owners are willing to cover a greater share of improvements on retail spaces to make it worthwhile for quality tenants. Recent leases consist of Krispy Kreme, JD Sports, and Hard Rock Café.

On West 34th Street, between Fifth and Seventh Avenue, average asking rents declined 8% year-over- year to $528 psf. Compared to Times Square, Herald Square presents a more challenging retail environment with a lower absorption rate and more spaces available on the market. Despite the recent closings of Sephora, GAP and J. Crew, the outlook for Herald Square remains positive with the recent leases by Ulta Beauty, Abercrombie & Fitch, Famous Footwear, and the Century 21 pop-up signing a long-term agreement.

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 2 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY (CONT.)

Average asking rents on Madison Avenue, between 57th In SoHo on Broadway, between Houston and Broome and 72nd streets, declined 22% to $906 psf compared street, average asking rents declined 12% year-over- to the fall 2018. Out of the 17 observed corridors, year to $491 psf. Broadway is composed of loft buildings Madison Avenue experienced the largest year-over- with large retail spaces that are difficult to subdivide due year decline. An increased amount of leases expiring to historic regulations. Further complications stem from has contributed to the high availability rates that has restrictive zoning that places limits on food/beverage led owners to lower asking rents and offer more short- uses in SoHo. The decline in asking rents is attributed term lease agreements. Softening rents has led to to post-recession asking rents nearly doubling to historic increased absorption as recent leases consist of retailers peaks, as flagship brands were considered ideal tenants relocating to smaller-sized storefronts with better co- capable of affording expensive large retail spaces. As tenancy. Notables tenants such as Akris, Mont Blanc, asking rents continue to adjust, Broadway is witnessing and Morgane Le Fay indicate that apparel tenants still increased activity by pop-ups and digitally native brands dominate this corridor. experimenting with retail space.

On East 86th Street, between Lexington and 2nd On Bleecker Street, between 7th Avenue South and Avenue, average asking rents declined 11% to $327 Hudson Street, average asking rents declined 5% year- psf. This drop is credited to a lack of available prime over-year to $278 psf. Asking rents on Bleecker Street retail space as current availabilities are located along continue to decline from post-recession all-time highs, 2nd Avenue where asking rents are lower and foot as lesser foot traffic and a more neighborhood centric traffic is more local. More expensive retail spaces along retail landscape has caused flagship brands to look for Lexington Avenue were recently leased by Old Navy and Downtown retail space elsewhere. Bleecker Street has JP Morgan Chase that caused asking rents to artificially gained new traction with Brookfield Properties filling in inflate. its new portfolio of 7 storefronts with a mix of digitally native and e-commerce brands, which has encouraged On Third Avenue, between 60th and 72nd Street, similar retailers to search for space along the corridor. average asking rents remained flat year-over-year at Examples of new digitally native and e-commerce $233 psf. The retail market on Third Avenue remains tenants include LoveShackFancy, Hill House Home, stable with a large stretch of occupied retail space due Slightly Alabama, and Bonberi. to access to public transportation and major retailers keeping and renewing leases nearby. IKEA opening its first Manhattan location on Third Avenue has increased the corridor’s credibility and driven interest from new tenants entering the corridor. In order to fill vacant spaces, owners are becoming more flexible with a steady amount of deal-making occurring with new tenants such as Wells Fargo, TD Bank, and Tudor Salon.

On Columbus Avenue, between 66th and 79th Street, average asking rents remained flat year-over-year at $298 psf. Columbus Avenue is a self-contained and a tight market with low availability. With high residential foot traffic, Columbus Avenue is labeled as a destination location for branded retailers with a diverse mix of tenants composed of smaller-sized storefronts.

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 3 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The REBNY Manhattan Retail Report Advisory Group includes:

Robin Abrams, Compass Karen Bellantoni, RKF Matt Chmielecki, CBRE David A. Green, Colliers International Jordan Kaplan, CBRE Andrew Mandell, Ripco Real Estate Joanne Podell, Cushman & Wakefield Fred Posniak, Empire State Realty Trust Jeffrey Roseman, Newmark Knight Frank Craig Slosberg, Newmark Knight Frank

REBNY would like to thank the following firms for their assistance in preparing the report:

CBRE Compass Colliers International Cushman & Wakefield Empire State Realty Trust Newmark Knight Frank Ripco Real Estate RKF

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 4 HISTORICAL AVERAGE ASKING RENT PSF - GROUND FLOOR RETAIL

125th St | (5th Ave - Morningside Ave)

AN $200 TT

$175

$151 $150 $140 $137

$125 $124 $123 $124 $125

UPPER MANHA $100 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018 F-2018 S-2019 F-2019

Broadway | (72nd St - 86th St) Columbus Ave | (66th St - 79th St)

$450 $400

$403 $400 $350 $341 $325 $315 $306 $344 $350 $338 $300 $291 $273 $263 $304 $298 $298 $300 $250 $279 UPPER WEST SIDE $250 $200 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018 F-2018 S-2019 F-2019 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018 F-2018 S-2019 F-2019

East 86th St | (Lexington Ave - 2nd Ave) Madison Ave | (57th St - 72nd St) $500 $1,600

$1,433 $1,446 $450 $1,390 $450 $1,400 $1,348 $428

$399 $400 $400 $1,200 $1,160

$367 $365 $1,039

$350 $1,000 $327 $906 UPPER EAST SIDE $300 $800 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018 F-2018 S-2019 F-2019 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018 F-2018 S-2019 F-2019

Third Ave | (60th St - 72nd St)

$400

$356 $350 $340

$300

$261 $264

$250 $233 $233 $226

$200 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018 F-2018 S-2019 F-2019

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 5 HISTORICAL AVERAGE ASKING RENT PSF - GROUND FLOOR RETAIL

Broadway & 7th Ave | (42nd - 47th St) Fifth Ave | (49th St - 59th St)

$2,500 $4,500 OW N

$3,900 $3,900 $2,250 $2,170 $4,000 $2,100

$3,484

MIDT $2,000 $1,930 $1,938 $1,936 $3,500 $1,889 $3,324 $1,860 $3,047 $2,973 $1,750 $3,000 $2,838

$1,500 $2,500 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017S-2018F-2018 S-2019F-2019 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018F-2018S-2019 F-2019

East 57th St | (5th Ave - Park Ave) Fifth Ave | (42nd St - 49th St) *No data avaliable for F-2017

$1,400

$1,500 $1,438 $1,259

$1,250 $1,294 $1,163 $1,158 $1,300

$1,097 $1,100 $1,100 $975 $944 $939 $925 $950 $900 $878 $852 $740

$800 $700 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017S-2018 F-2018 S-2019F-2019 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018 F-2018 S-2019 F-2019

West 34th St | (5th Ave - 7th Ave)

H Broadway | (14th St - 23rd St)

$900 $500

$800 $450 $745 $734

$390 $700 $400 $384 $378 $377 $633 $372 $360 $604 $613

OWN SOUT $348 $600 $573 $350

$528

$500 $300

MIDT F-2016 S-2017 F-2017S-2018F-2018S-2019 F-2019 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018 F-2018 S-2019 F-2019

Fifth Ave | (14th St - 23rd St)

$500

$456 $449 $450 $422

$400 $393 $400 $390

$348 $350

$300 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017S-2018F-2018S-2019 F-2019

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 6 HISTORICAL AVERAGE ASKING RENT PSF - GROUND FLOOR RETAIL

14th St | (9th Ave - 10th Ave) Broadway | (Battery Park - Chambers St) WN $450 $450

$413 $401 $400 $400 $374 $369 $368 $362 $345 $345 $350 $334 $350 $338 $323 DOWN TO $313 $303 $300 $300 $277

$250 $250 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018 F-2018 S-2019 F-2019 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018 F-2018 S-2019 F-2019

Broadway | (Houston St - Broome St) Bleecker St | (7th Ave South - Hudson St)

$900 $550

$812 $471 $755 $775 $475

$644 $650 $400 $595 $373 $558 $351 $544 $332 $525 $491 $325 $293 $294 $278

$400 $250 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018 F-2018 S-2019F-2019 F-2016 S-2017 F-2017 S-2018 F-2018 S-2019 F-2019

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 7 AVERAGE ASKING RENT PSF - GROUND FLOOR RETAIL

125th St | (5th Ave - Morningside Ave) AN Fall18 Spring 19 Fall19 $140 $137 $151 TT LEGEND

%Δ from Spring 19 to Fall 19 10%▲

%Δ from Fall 18 to Fall 19 UPPER MANHA 8%▲

Broadway | (72nd St - 86th St) Columbus Ave | (66th St - 79th St)

$306 $273 $263 $298 $279 $298

4%▼ 7%▲ UPPER WEST SIDE 14%▼ 0%

East 86th St | (Lexington Ave - 2nd Ave) Madison Ave | (57th St - 72nd St)

$367 $365 $327 $1,160 $1,039 $906

10%▼ 13%▼ UPPER EAST SIDE 11%▼ 22%▼

Third Ave | (60th St - 72nd St)

$233 $226 $233

3%▲

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 8 AVERAGE ASKING RENT PSF - GROUND FLOOR RETAIL

Broadway & 7th Ave | (42nd - 47th St) Fifth Ave | (49th St - 59th St)

OW N $1,860 $1,936 $1,889 $2,973 $3,047 $2,838 MIDT

2%▼ 7%▼

2%▲ 5%▼

East 57th St | (5th Ave - Park Ave) Fifth Ave | (42nd St - 49th St)

$939 $878 $852 $925 $944 $740

3%▼ 22%▼

9%▼ 20%▼

West 34th St | (5th Ave - 7th Ave) Broadway | (14th St - 23rd St) H

$573 $613 $528 $378 $372 $377 OWN SOUT 14%▼ 1%▲

8%▼ 0% MIDT

Fifth Ave | (14th St - 23rd St)

$393 $400 $348

13%▼

12%▼

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 9 AVERAGE ASKING RENT PSF - GROUND FLOOR RETAIL

14th St | (9th Ave - 10th Ave) Broadway | (Battery Park - Chambers St) WN

$303 $277 $345 $338 $401 $413 DOWN TO

25%▲ 3%▲

14%▲ 22%▲

Broadway | (Houston St - Broome St) Bleecker St | (7th Ave South - Hudson St)

$558 $544 $491 $293 $294 $278

10%▼ 5%▼

12%▼ 5%▼

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 10 APPENDIX

AVERAGE ASKING RENT PSF – GROUND FLOOR RETAIL

Fall 19 Spring 19 Fall 18 % Spring 19 % Fall 18 UPPER WEST SIDE Broadway (72nd St - 86th St) $263 $273 $306 -4% -14% Columbus Ave (66th St - 79th St) $298 $279 $298 7% 0%

UPPER EAST SIDE East 86th St (Lexington Ave - 2nd Ave) $327 $365 $367 -10% -11% Madison Ave (57th St - 72nd St) $906 $1,039 $1,160 -13% -22% Third Ave (60th St - 72nd St) $233 $226 $233 3% 0%

MIDTOWN East 57th St (5th Ave - Park Ave) $740 $944 $925 -22% -20% 5th Ave (49th St - 59th St) $2,838 $3,047 $2,973 -7% -5% 5th Ave (42th St - 49th St) $852 $878 $939 -3% -9% Broadway & 7th Ave (42nd St - 47th St) $1,889 $1,936 $1,860 -2% 2%

MIDTOWN SOUTH Herald Square West 34th St (5th Ave - 7th Ave) $528 $613 $573 -14% -8% Flatiron 5th Ave (14th St - 23rd St) $348 $400 $393 -13% -12% Broadway (14th St - 23rd St) $377 $372 $378 1% 0%

DOWNTOWN Meatpacking 14th St (9th Ave - 10th Ave) $345 $277 $303 25% 14% West Village Bleecker St (7th Ave South - Hudson St) $278 $294 $293 -5% -5% SoHo Broadway (Houston St - Broome St) $491 $544 $558 -10% -12% Lower Manhattan Broadway (Battery Park - Chambers St) $413 $401 $338 3% 22%

UPPER MANHATTAN Harlem 125th St. (5th Ave - Morningside Ave) $151 $137 $140 10% 8%

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 11 APPENDIX

MEDIAN ASKING RENT PSF – GROUND FLOOR RETAIL

Fall 19 Spring 19 Fall 18 % Spring 19 % Fall 18 UPPER WEST SIDE Broadway (72nd St - 86th St) $260 $250 $325 4% -20% Columbus Ave (66th St - 79th St) $287 $248 $280 16% 2%

UPPER EAST SIDE East 86th St (Lexington Ave - 2nd Ave) $330 $365 $375 -10% -12% Madison Ave (57th St - 72nd St) $900 $1,000 $1,160 -10% -22% Third Ave (60th St - 72nd St) $225 $225 $225 0% 0%

MIDTOWN East 57th St (5th Ave - Park Ave) $750 $900 $800 -17% -6% 5th Ave (49th St - 59th St) $2,500 $3,050 $2,600 -18% -4% 5th Ave (42th St - 49th St) $888 $800 $909 11% -2% Broadway & 7th Ave (42nd St - 47th St) $1,800 $1,800 $2,000 0% -10%

MIDTOWN SOUTH Herald Square West 34th St (5th Ave - 7th Ave) $507 $600 $650 -16% -22% Flatiron 5th Ave (14th St - 23rd St) $325 $400 $418 -19% -22% Broadway (14th St - 23rd St) $388 $375 $350 3% 11%

DOWNTOWN Meatpacking 14th St (9th Ave - 10th Ave) $375 $262 $300 43% 25% West Village Bleecker St (7th Ave South - Hudson St) $300 $270 $268 11% 12% SoHo Broadway (Houston St - Broome St) $475 $544 $547 -13% -13% Lower Manhattan Broadway (Battery Park - Chambers St) $411 $413 $325 0% 26%

UPPER MANHATTAN Harlem 125th St. (5th Ave - Morningside Ave) $125 $125 $130 12% 8%

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 12 APPENDIX

RANGE OF ASKING RENTS PSF – GROUND FLOOR RETAIL

Fall 19 Spring 19 Fall 18 UPPER WEST SIDE Broadway (72nd St - 86th St) $166 _ $409 $166 _ $410 $200 _ $450 Columbus Ave (66th St - 79th St) $150 _ $458 $125 _ $458 $178 _ $458

UPPER EAST SIDE East 86th St (Lexington Ave - 2nd Ave) $200 _ $475 $225 _ $475 $250 _ $475 Madison Ave (57th St - 72nd St) $350 _ $1,502 $800 _ $1,600 $720 _ $1,700 Third Ave (60th St - 72nd St) $185 _ $300 $160 _ $300 $165 _ $300

MIDTOWN East 57th St (5th Ave - Park Ave) $650 _ $800 $800 _ $1,175 $800 _ $1,175 5th Ave (49th St - 59th St) $1,750 _ $3,750 $2,000 _ $4,000 $2,000 _ $4,000 5th Ave (42th St - 49th St) $600 _ $1,176 $500 _ $1,500 $590 _ $1,744 Broadway & 7th Ave (42nd St - 47th St) $1,425 _ $2,350 $1,500 _ $2,350 $1,000 _ $2,350

MIDTOWN SOUTH Herald Square West 34th St (5th Ave - 7th Ave) $400 _ $800 $447 _ $850 $314 _ $750 Flatiron 5th Ave (14th St - 23rd St) $300 _ $415 $295 _ $550 $285 _ $511 Broadway (14th St - 23rd St) $325 _ $425 $325 _ $410 $311 _ $500

DOWNTOWN Meatpacking 14th St (9th Ave - 10th Ave) $150 _ $700 $195 _ $375 $195 _ $450 West Village Bleecker St (7th Ave South - Hudson St) $142 _ $379 $150 _ $584 $182 _ $465 SoHo Broadway (Houston St - Broome St) $250 _ $733 $300 _ $978 $300 _ $900 Lower Manhattan Broadway (Battery Park - Chambers St) $150 _ $785 $150 _ $625 $125 _ $500

UPPER MANHATTAN Harlem 125th St. (5th Ave - Morningside Ave) $100 _ $250 $90 _ $250 $76 _ $230

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 13 CORRIDOR MAPS

UPPER WEST SIDE Broadway

UPPER MANHATTAN Columbus Avenue 125th Street

MIDTOWN

E 57th Street UPPER EAST SIDE

E 86th Street 5th Street Broadway 7th Avenue 7th

DOWNTOWN

14th Street

Bleecker Street Third Avenue Madison Avenue

MIDTOWN SOUTH Broadway

W 34th Street Broadway 5th Avenue Broadway

MANHATTAN RETAIL REPORT FALL 2019 | 14