Excavations at the Long Cist Cemetery on the Hallow Hill, St Andrews, Fife
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Proc Soc Antiq Scot, (1996)6 12 , 387-454 Excavations at the long cist cemetery on the Hallow Hill, St Andrews, Fife, 1975-7 Edwina Proudfoot* with contributions by Christopher Aliaga-Kelly, Dorothy Lunt, the late Archibald Young, Gordon Cook, June Cundill, Peter Cundill, Michael Catherin& y Ro eD Smith ABSTRACT Excavations west of St Andrews were undertaken from 1975 to 1977, following the discovery of long gardenciststhe Hallowhousein the new ofon a Hill. Long cistsbeenhad discovered there 1861,in when 20 were opened. The recent excavations revealed a complex of long cists and other graves of an unenclosed burial ground of Early Christian date. Part of the cemetery was loosely organized, while elsewhere the cists were arranged in well-ordered rows. An unusual two-tier boulder-edged grave was found; no burial survived in the upper level; in the lower level an incomplete burial of a child accompaniedwas Romanby otherand objects, combinationa similar well-recordedthata to in cist uncovered in the 19th-century explorations. Other features included a cobbled road through the site, post-holes and possible structural remains, all affected by centuries of cultivation. The site has been equated on topographic and toponymic evidence with the lost Early Christian site, Eglesnamin. Radiocarbon dates for a number of cists calibrate generally to between the sixth and the ninth centuries report completedThe was AD. ofgranta aid with the from Historic Scotland. INTRODUCTION INVESTIGATIONS AT THE HALLOW HILL IN THE 19TH CENTURY The years 1859, 1860 and 1861 saw unprecedented antiquarian activity in St Andrews. A Bronze crematioe Ag n cemeter uncoveres ywa 185n i d Charley 9b s Howie (Anon 1861 t Lawhead)a , west t AndrewsoS f norte th hn Kinnese o ,ban th f ko s Burn (NGR 494O N : 3 1583) followine Th . g year, excavations by Robert Walker on the Kirkhill (Kirkheugh) revealed traces of the old church of St Mary of the Rock, with its extensive cemetery of medieval and earlier graves as well as long and prehistoric cists skullse Th . particularn i , , prove f interesdo BarnarJ o t t d Davies (1861, 191-9)e th , anatomist publisheo wh , d detailed measurement skulls6 1 f o s . After working at Lawhead, Charles Howie, attracted by the name 'Halyhill' (illus 1-3), decided investigato t e this siteenquiryn Roberd O . an e h t, Walker learned that 'several stone coffins, which resembled those uncovered at the Kirkhill, being of undressed stones and containing human skel- etons', had been dug upon the south side of the burn during agricultural work. For this reason they * St Andrews Heritage Services, 12 Wardlaw Gardens, St Andrews, Fife KY16 9DW I SOCIET 8 38 ANTIQUARIEF YO SCOTLANDF SO , 1996 conclusiocame th o et n that burialHalyhile th n so l wer f 'theo e present Christiar o , n period thad an t' hile th l should more correctl designatee yb Halloe dth w Hill (Anon 1861). A limited exploration was carried out by Howie in 1861, when five long cists were found and were t AndrewreporteS e th o dt s Literar Philosophicad yan l Society (Walker 186la). e Threth f eo skulls were donate Societe th o d t t tha ya t time t havbu , e since been lost Decemben I . r 1861 Walker (1861b) reported that Howie had uncovered a further 15 long cists, which he described in consider- able detail. Among these was one that attracted particular attention, 1861/Cist 5, in which Roman naturad an l objects accompanie childda ; thi sparticularle sais b cis o dwa t y deep, with fou r fivo r e layer f stoneso s ove . Thesit r e artefacts were publishe considerabln di e detail (Stuart 1867, lix)d an , most survived until c 1931 (Hay Fleming 1931, 252), but regrettably by 1975 no trace of them could founde b . These objects have acquire particulada r significanc becausw eno buriaea l e founth n di recent excavations, althoug lona t ghno cist, containe dsimilaa r collectio f objectsno . Stuart (1867, lix), reportin lone gth cise g th tcist d wit Romae san hth n artefacts, also recorded that the 20 excavated cists 'formed part of a larger number not yet examined'. However, no further archaeological activity took Halloplace th t ea w Hill unti excavatione th l s which for subjece mth f o t the present report. BACKGROUN EXCAVATIONO DT 1970E TH sN SI Pressur housinr efo Andrewt S n gi intenss late swa th e n e1960si whict ,a h period considerable develop- ment to the south of the burgh took place, while in the early 1970s, as part of this expansion, a large housing estat plannes whole Halloe ewa th th r f edo fo w Hill, the agriculturan i l use. Public interesn ti the possible significanc greao nams e s th t f etha wa edevelopmeno e th t t reduces nortsite th ewa hd dan of the area became a public park adjacent to the Lade Braes Walk. The summit of the Hallow Hill remained part of the development, although the site of the 19th-century discovery of long cists is clearly recorded on the Ordnance Survey map (1966) at NGR: NO 4940 1565, albeit that the precise site was not known (NMR 41O S NE8)N importance .Th Halloe th f eo w Hilwidels lwa y known locally because publishee ofth d report lone th gf so cist s discovere 1861n di . However provisioo n , e mads th nwa y eb various authorities for potential archaeological excavation or for recording discoveries that might be made during house-building. Extensive terracin landscapind gan Hallo2 1 f go w Hil lbee d (illuha n ) s4 required as a planning condition prior to construction in order to reduce the overall height of the house hile th l summitn o . Durin course gth f theseo e works many lorryload f soiso l were removed entirely fro sitee mth , whil substantiaea l amoun bulldozesois f to lwa fordo t m gardea n terrac north-wese th n eo t and buil slopinp du g groun plotease e soutd unknown th th an tf A .n ho do n numbe f lonro g cistd san other features was destroyed (JCB driver, pers comm, 1975). Later, during excavation of a trench in the east part of the garden, quantities of redeposited, broken human bones were found, and have been interpreted as coming from the terraced area, where only one cist (Cist 14) was afterwards recovered, deeply compressed by the bulldozer into the subsoil. However s onlwa y t i whe, r FullertonnM preparins , wa the , n12 gpatownea o n h f o acrosr s the north-east part of the garden that he discovered stones and bones, which he immediately reported to Professor W Frend of the University of Glasgow, who contacted the University of St Andrews. It was agreed that an excavation was desirable while part of the site was still accessible, because this provide opportunitn da investigato yt perhapd ean confiro st t leasma t detaile somth f eo s recorded in 1861. In due course the author was asked to organize a small excavation in the garden, in October 1975, and was assisted by local volunteers. Once it became clear that the project required a large, regular workforce an approach was made to the then SDD Historic Buildings and Monuments (now Historic Scotland), which could not fund PROUDFOOT: EXCAVATIONS, LONG CIST CEMETERY, HALLOW HILL ANDREWST S , , FIFE9 , 38 1975- I 7 ILLUS 1 Hallow Hill: location maps. (Based on the Ordnance Survey map © Crown copyright) 390 I SOCIETY OF ANTIQUARIES OF SCOTLAND, 1996 100m ILLUS 2 Location of the excavated area and some other sites in the vicinity of the Hallow Hill. (Based on the Ordnance Survey map © Crown copyright) the project at that time. Support was then sought from the newly established Manpower Services Commission (MSC), which agree fun o dt projece th d stagen i t s during 1976-8, using local unem- ployed workers course londu 5 n e14 I .g cist othed san r burials were located wels a , othes a l r features; almost all were examined. Post-excavation funding was provided for one year by MSC, linked to fundinFife th e r Archaeologicafo g l Index Sitea , Monumentd san s Record e Universitbaseth n di y t AndrewoS f s whic authoe hasketh s rwa manag o dt t thiea s time. Limited post-excavation prepara- humae th tio f no n bon alss eowa fundeMSCe th t research y bu d,b , preparatio archivee th f no , finds and report were funded by the author and specialists. The SDD, now Historic Scotland, grant-aided preparatio illustrationthe nof publicationsfor radiocarbothe , n dates and, later completiothe , the nof archive and the report for publication. When excavation had been completed and the site reinstated, two groups of cists were consolid- atelefd dtan visible becaus hige th hf eo leve f publie o cistlo th tw n si c e interes th site e t th bu , n i t garde n) wer 2 (Cist e& eventuall1 s ownerw e housene th f e o s;th y seve y filleb n ni d cists were displayed in the park (illus 6). DOCUMENTARY BACKGROUND The history of the early church at St Andrews, Cennrigmonaid, is confused, in part because informa- firs e Pictishe th tio(i t n no ) churcinterpretee b n sparss hi ca d varioun dei an arrivae th s waysn lca s a , PROUDFOOT: EXCAVATIONS, LONG CIST CEMETERY, HALLOW HILL ANDREWST S , , FIFE, 1975- I 739 1 ILLU S3 Aeria lHalloe vieth f wo w Hill from Nowak-Solinski)nortZ © h( of the relics of St Andrew (Anderson 1974, 1-13; 1976, 1-10).