Sex Workers Who Provide Services to Clients with Disability

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Sex Workers Who Provide Services to Clients with Disability 1 Sex workers who provide services to clients with disability in New South Wales, Australia by Rachel Wotton Thesis Submitted in Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Philosophy (Medicine) By Research University of Sydney September 2016 2 Candidate’s Statement 3 Acknowledgments I would like to acknowledge a number of people who have given me their ongoing support, guidance and faith in my ability to deliver this final dissertation. My former supervisors, Dr. Russell Shuttleworth and Ms. Alison Arnot-Bradshaw. My ongoing supervisor Dr. Patricia Weerakoon who has supported me throughout this journey. Prof. Emeritus Trevor Parmenter who so graciously agreed to become my primary supervisor in my last year, going above and beyond to assist with the transfer to the Medical Faculty. Julie Cameron, at the Faculty of Health Sciences, who patiently jumped through all privacy and administrative hoops Survey Monkey created so that I could regain access to my raw data. John Paul Cenzato, for excelling in your role as librarian Amanda Reid who has been such a calming and supportive influence. Your guidance throughout the whole writing process with editing, suggestions and encouragement has been incalculable. Saul Isbister who, along with your amazing editing skills, has always believed in my ability to complete this. Your support and friendship is invaluable to me. Julie Bates, Liz Emrys and Kylie Maxwell for your encouragement, friendship and support. Natalie Hamam for giving me renewed inspiration. See you at the next graduation! Z.H. who has given me love and support throughout. I’d also like to thank all of my fantastic clients, who continue to choose to spend time with me. It certainly has contributed to my ability to self-fund my studies. Finally I would like to thank all of the sex workers who took time out of their busy lives to complete this survey. Without you this could never have been done. 4 Abstract SEX WORKERS WHO PROVIDE SERVICES TO CLIENTS WITH DISABILITY IN NEW SOUTH WALES, AUSTRALIA Aims: Sexuality and sexual needs/desires of people with disability have historically been overlooked amongst the general public. Long standing social attitudes and stereotypes have fundamentally dictated that people with disabilities cannot and should not express their sexual agency. In particular, when people with disability have sought to express their sexual needs via the services of a sex worker, this has tended to provoke much social and political ire. This research is an exploratory study about sex workers who provide services to clients with disability. The aim of this research is to identify the nature and extent of such activities to produce empirical data to support anecdotal evidence and recent emerging research in this field. Method: This exploratory online survey asked sex workers who worked in New South Wales (NSW) to share their experiences of providing services to clients with disability. This included the frequency, type and range of services provided, location of service delivery and how clients made contact. Questions were asked regarding third party assistance and the identification of any barriers or challenges faced by sex workers. The survey also encouraged sex workers to share personal reflections on what they thought were the most positive aspects of their work. 5 Results: The findings, from 65 respondents, indicate that sex workers in NSW have provided a wide range of sexual services to clients with disability across the state. The sex workers’ ages ranged from 21 to 61 years, identifying as either female, male or transgender. Services were provided in varied locations including brothels, massage parlours, private homes, hotels, nursing homes, the client’s hospital room or their client’s group home/ supported accommodation. Their clients’ disabilities were quite expansive, spanned both physical and cognitive disabilities and acquired and congenital disabilities. A number of issues and barriers were identified that concerned the client, carers, support staff and / or family and friends of the client. Forty seven sex workers shared their personal perspectives of what they considered the most positive aspects in providing services to clients with disability. Conclusions: The respondents’ narratives revealed their professional enthusiasm with interacting with clients with disability. This includes a desire to have further training and support to alleviate barriers and challenging situations that impede clear communication and supportive pathways between themselves and their clients. These results also contribute to an awareness of how decriminalisation can provide a supportive environment for this to occur. This study builds upon an expanding body of work that can be used to educate and influence the future development of training and awareness workshops for sex workers, disability services provider, clients with a disability, academics, policy makers and the general public. 6 Table of Contents Candidate’s Statement .........................................................................................................2 Acknowledgments................................................................................................................3 Abstract ................................................................................................................................4 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................6 List of Tables .......................................................................................................................9 List of Figures ....................................................................................................................10 Chapter 1. Introduction ......................................................................................................11 Chapter 2: Sexuality ...........................................................................................................20 Well known research scales for sexuality and sexual orientation ................................23 Sexuality within Australia............................................................................................28 Chapter 3: Sexuality and Disability ...................................................................................30 Definitions within Australia .........................................................................................33 Prevalence within Australia .........................................................................................37 Disability rights within Australia .................................................................................38 Sexual rights and disability ..........................................................................................40 Representation in film, TV and multi-media platforms ...............................................42 Disability and Ageing ..................................................................................................48 Chapter 4: Sex Work ..........................................................................................................53 Definitions and terminology ........................................................................................55 Workplace locations and advertising ...........................................................................56 Demographics ..............................................................................................................58 7 The modern Sex Workers’ Rights Movement .............................................................66 Legislation....................................................................................................................70 Chapter 5: Clients of sex workers ......................................................................................77 Clients in general .........................................................................................................77 Motivation ......................................................................................................................... 79 Prevalence ......................................................................................................................... 81 Demographics ................................................................................................................... 85 Locations where clients visit ............................................................................................. 86 Female clients ................................................................................................................... 88 Clients with disability ..................................................................................................89 Motivation ......................................................................................................................... 92 Female clients ................................................................................................................... 93 Media……………………………………………………….……………………94 Prevalence ......................................................................................................................... 97 Organisations and access to the sex industry .................................................................... 99 Other forms of assisted sexual services .......................................................................... 102 Guidelines and policies
Recommended publications
  • Coldplay? 2016 CILL Season Begins 2016 Primary Election Results: So Goes City Island
    Periodicals Paid at Bronx, N.Y. USPS 114-590 Volume 45 Number 4 May 2016 One Dollar Coldplay? 2016 CILL Season Begins By VIRGINIA DANNEGGER and KAREN NANI ria Piri, concession stand managers Jim and singlehandedly did the job of several and Sue Goonan, and equipment manager people. Even though his boys aged out of Lou Lomanaco. Several of these board the league, John still dedicates his time to members have served multiple terms on the help.” He presented John with a framed board. CILL jersey and a plaque in appreciation Mr. Esposito gave special thanks to for his support of the league and the City Photos by RICK DeWITT the outgoing president, John Tomsen, Island community. It was a chilly start to the 2016 Little League season on April 9, but the baseball tradi- who threw out the first pitch. “John has “As many of you know, volunteering tion dating back to 1900 is alive and warm on City Island. There are major, minor and time is a family commitment. Whether it t-ball teams competing once again this season. The ceremonial first pitch was thrown been president of the CILL since 2009 by outgoing president John Tomsen, who was also awarded a framed jersey by the Continued on page 19 new league president, Dom Esposito (right, top photo). New York State Assemblyman Michael Benedetto joined Catherine Ambrosini, Mr. Esposito and Mr. Tomsen (second photo, l. to r.) for the season opener. The American Legion color guard bearers led the teams in the “Star Spangled Banner.” As the weather warms up, head down to Ambro- 2016 Primary Election Results: sini Field next to P.S.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Breaking Bad' Is Busting Stereotypes About Cerebral Palsy
    MENTAL HEALTH FEBRUARY/MARCH 2015 BY LINDA CHILDERS RJ Mi}e of 'Breaking Bad' is Busting Stereotypes About Cerebral Palsy Azer the role of a lifetime, Mi}e is changing how people think about cerebral palsy and speaking out against bullying. On the hit AMC television series Breaking Bad, RJ Mitte portrayed Walter "Flynn" White Jr., a young man with cerebral palsy (CP), the neurologic condition that Mitte was diagnosed with as a toddler. One of the few television actors with a visible disability, Mitte helped shed light on CP, which is marked by impaired motor coordination and affects one in 323 children in the United States. Unlike his on-screen character, Mitte has a milder form of CP, and does not use crutches or slur his speech. Yet the 22-year-old actor has faced many of the same medical and social challenges as White. "People with CP overcome hurdles every day," Mitte says. "One thing I've learned from my disability is that when there is an obstacle, you adapt and grow. You can't let that obstacle break you down and discourage you." Adopted shortly after birth by Ray Frank Mitte Jr. and his wife, Dyna, Mitte was a happy child who walked on his toes as a toddler. Doctors told his parents that if he did not walk normally by age 4, they would perform a heel operation. At the age of 3, a friend of Mitte's grandmother recognized the signs of CP in RJ, and urged the family to have him evaluated at Shriners Hospitals for Children- Shreveport, LA, their hometown.
    [Show full text]
  • Please Click Here to Read RJ Mitte's Biography
    Best known for his portrayal of Walter “Flynn” White Jr for five riveting seasons of AMC’s Emmy and Golden Globe Award-winning dramatic thriller “Breaking Bad”, RJ Mitte is an actor, advocate and philanthropist who has carved out his niche in Hollywood by breaking down stereotypes and changing people’s mindsets with his easy going demeanor and positive outlook on life. During its final season, the “Breaking Bad” premiere drew approximately 5.9 million viewers, a number that nearly doubled to 10.3 million by the season’s final episode. As Walt Jr., referred to by fans as “The Breakfast King,” Mitte acted as the Cerebral Palsy-afflicted son of Walter (Bryan Cranston) and Skyler (Anna Gunn). Walter Jr.’s Cerebral Palsy on the show was embellished, meaning RJ had to learn how to walk on crutches and slur his speech to create a more dramatic version of his own disability. At the young age of three, Louisiana native Mitte was diagnosed with Cerebral Palsy, though that has never deterred his drive to succeed in television and film. After moving to Los Angeles due to his sister’s chance encounter with a casting director, Mitte landed roles in various shows such as SHOWTIME’s “Weeds,” NBC’s “Vegas,” CW’s “Everybody Hates Chris” and co-starred on ABC Family’s primetime hit show “Switched at Birth,” until being cast in his life-changing role on “Breaking Bad.” Concluding “Breaking Bad” Mitte, reemerged on the big screen in DIXIELAND, in his first non-handicapped leading role. Following this, he starred in a multitude of films such as: THE RECALL, opposite Wesley Snipes; TIEMPO COMPARTIDO (Official 2018 Selection World Cinema Dramatic Competition at Sundance); RIVER RUNS RED, in 2018, alongside John Cusack and George Lopez; and he also guest starred on Starz’ coming of age television thriller “Now Apocalypse,” which premiered in early 2019.
    [Show full text]
  • Interactive Toolkit
    Please download this PDF to your device and then open it using Adobe Reader. Depending on your browser, if you try to navigate through it in this browser window now, you may or may not have functionality due to browser variability. Click to start 2015 TOOLKIT Sex in the Military Toolkit: The Other Invisible Wounds RESEARCH OVERVIEW VIDEO VIGNETTES ACTIVITY HELP ATTENTION: Before proceeding, be sure you are using the most recent version of Adobe Reader to ensure you can access the videos and all functionality of this interactive toolkit. (Version 9.0 or above required) Please update your browser, as well if you are having difficulties. This course is most efficiently used on a desktop device. Mobile and tablet devices may not be fully supported. Thank you. Sex in the Military Toolkit: The Other Invisible Wounds RESEARCH OVERVIEW VIDEO VIGNETTES ACTIVITY HELP WELCOME BEHAVIORAL HEALTH PROVIDER! The Center for Innovation and Research on Students in an undergraduate or graduate Veterans & Military Families (CIR) of the social work or other behavioral health University of Southern California School of degree program are a secondary audience. Social Work is dedicated to strengthening the These materials are designed to be transition of veterans and their families into readily used by faculty in such academic the community. An important facet of this programs, and integrated with other transition involves the intimate relationship educational materials. and the integration of the service member back into family life. CIR developed this Focus. While sexual functioning toolkit to help behavioral health practitioners problems can occur in both military and address some of the sexual and intimate civilian populations, this toolkit focuses on relationship challenges that injured service the unique features within the military that members, veterans, and their spouse/partner can impact sexual functioning.
    [Show full text]
  • Vigil Against Hate Brings Call for All to Stand Together by WILLIAM K
    CYAN MAGENTA YELLOW BLACK » TODAY’S ISSUE U DAILY BRIEFING, A2 • TRIBUTES, A5 • WORLD, A6 • CLASSIFIEDS, B6 • PUZZLES, C3 COMING UP ACES IN VALLEY EVENT FINE-TUNING FOR SEASON PPluchPluPluchinsky,lu Rogner win Greatest titles Browns host Giants tonight on national TV SPORTS | B1 SPORTS | B1 50% OFF vouchers. SEE DETAILS, A2 8 M D ORE RVE THA S SE N 14,000 VALLEY GOLFER FOR DAILY & BREAKING NEWS LOCALLY OWNED SINCE 1869 MONDAY, AUGUST 21, 2017 U 75¢ Valley venues host viewing events today YOUNGSTOWN NIKOS FRAZIER | THE VINDICATOR The Rev. Neil C. Heller speaks during the Vigil Against Hate, hosted by Valley Voices United for Change at First Unitarian Universalist Church of Youngstown on Sunday. Vigil Against Hate brings call for all to stand together By WILLIAM K. ALCORN THIS IS NO TIME [email protected] TO STAND ON ECLIPSE YOUNGSTOWN With the backdrop of ra- THE SIDELINES. cially motivated violence I CHALLENGE YOU TO FIND in Charlottesville, Va., only YOUR TEAM AND GET TO a week ago, Sunday’s Vigil Against Hate at First Unitar- WORK CHANGING THE ian Universalist Church on WORLD.” the North Side was a call to action for everyone to stand Christopher Anderson, MANIA up against racism and in- Mahoning County By JORDYN GRZELEWSKI justice. Young Democrats [email protected] Three people died and YOUNGSTOWN SOLAR ECLIPSE EXPLAINED many were injured during a the violence. S THE MOON COVERS THE SUN white nationalist rally. Killed “What brought us togeth- today during the fi rst solar eclipse When the moon passes between the sun and Earth, the sun is masked and the sky ddarkenedarkened fforor viewers directldirectlyy behind the moon’s inner shadow or umbra.
    [Show full text]
  • Sagawkit Acceptancespeechtran
    Screen Actors Guild Awards Acceptance Speech Transcripts TABLE OF CONTENTS INAUGURAL SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS ...........................................................................................2 2ND ANNUAL SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS .........................................................................................6 3RD ANNUAL SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS ...................................................................................... 11 4TH ANNUAL SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS ....................................................................................... 15 5TH ANNUAL SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS ....................................................................................... 20 6TH ANNUAL SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS ....................................................................................... 24 7TH ANNUAL SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS ....................................................................................... 28 8TH ANNUAL SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS ....................................................................................... 32 9TH ANNUAL SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS ....................................................................................... 36 10TH ANNUAL SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS ..................................................................................... 42 11TH ANNUAL SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS ..................................................................................... 48 12TH ANNUAL SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS ....................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Nominations Announced for the 19Th Annual Screen Actors Guild
    Nominations Announced for the 19th Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards® ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Ceremony will be Simulcast Live on Sunday, Jan. 27, 2013 on TNT and TBS at 8 p.m. (ET)/5 p.m. (PT) LOS ANGELES (Dec. 12, 2012) — Nominees for the 19th Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards® for outstanding performances in 2012 in five film and eight primetime television categories as well as the SAG Awards honors for outstanding action performances by film and television stunt ensembles were announced this morning in Los Angeles at the Pacific Design Center’s SilverScreen Theater in West Hollywood. SAG-AFTRA Executive Vice President Ned Vaughn introduced Busy Philipps (TBS’ “Cougar Town” and the 19th Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards® Social Media Ambassador) and Taye Diggs (“Private Practice”) who announced the nominees for this year’s Actors®. SAG Awards® Committee Vice Chair Daryl Anderson and Committee Member Woody Schultz announced the stunt ensemble nominees. The 19th Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards® will be simulcast live nationally on TNT and TBS on Sunday, Jan. 27 at 8 p.m. (ET)/5 p.m. (PT) from the Los Angeles Shrine Exposition Center. An encore performance will air immediately following on TNT at 10 p.m. (ET)/7 p.m. (PT). Recipients of the stunt ensemble honors will be announced from the SAG Awards® red carpet during the tntdrama.com and tbs.com live pre-show webcasts, which begin at 6 p.m. (ET)/3 p.m. (PT). Of the top industry accolades presented to performers, only the Screen Actors Guild Awards® are selected solely by actors’ peers in SAG-AFTRA.
    [Show full text]
  • Reminder List of Productions Eligible for the 88Th Academy Awards
    REMINDER LIST OF PRODUCTIONS ELIGIBLE FOR THE 88TH ACADEMY AWARDS ADULT BEGINNERS Actors: Nick Kroll. Bobby Cannavale. Matthew Paddock. Caleb Paddock. Joel McHale. Jason Mantzoukas. Mike Birbiglia. Bobby Moynihan. Actresses: Rose Byrne. Jane Krakowski. AFTER WORDS Actors: Óscar Jaenada. Actresses: Marcia Gay Harden. Jenna Ortega. THE AGE OF ADALINE Actors: Michiel Huisman. Harrison Ford. Actresses: Blake Lively. Kathy Baker. Ellen Burstyn. ALLELUIA Actors: Laurent Lucas. Actresses: Lola Dueñas. ALOFT Actors: Cillian Murphy. Zen McGrath. Winta McGrath. Peter McRobbie. Ian Tracey. William Shimell. Andy Murray. Actresses: Jennifer Connelly. Mélanie Laurent. Oona Chaplin. ALOHA Actors: Bradley Cooper. Bill Murray. John Krasinski. Danny McBride. Alec Baldwin. Bill Camp. Actresses: Emma Stone. Rachel McAdams. ALTERED MINDS Actors: Judd Hirsch. Ryan O'Nan. C. S. Lee. Joseph Lyle Taylor. Actresses: Caroline Lagerfelt. Jaime Ray Newman. ALVIN AND THE CHIPMUNKS: THE ROAD CHIP Actors: Jason Lee. Tony Hale. Josh Green. Flula Borg. Eddie Steeples. Justin Long. Matthew Gray Gubler. Jesse McCartney. José D. Xuconoxtli, Jr.. Actresses: Kimberly Williams-Paisley. Bella Thorne. Uzo Aduba. Retta. Kaley Cuoco. Anna Faris. Christina Applegate. Jennifer Coolidge. Jesica Ahlberg. Denitra Isler. 88th Academy Awards Page 1 of 32 AMERICAN ULTRA Actors: Jesse Eisenberg. Topher Grace. Walton Goggins. John Leguizamo. Bill Pullman. Tony Hale. Actresses: Kristen Stewart. Connie Britton. AMY ANOMALISA Actors: Tom Noonan. David Thewlis. Actresses: Jennifer Jason Leigh. ANT-MAN Actors: Paul Rudd. Corey Stoll. Bobby Cannavale. Michael Peña. Tip "T.I." Harris. Anthony Mackie. Wood Harris. David Dastmalchian. Martin Donovan. Michael Douglas. Actresses: Evangeline Lilly. Judy Greer. Abby Ryder Fortson. Hayley Atwell. ARDOR Actors: Gael García Bernal. Claudio Tolcachir.
    [Show full text]
  • The 12Th Annual Report on Human Rights in Syria 2013 (January 2013 – December 2013)
    The 12th annual report On human rights in Syria 2013 (January 2013 – December 2013) January 2014 January 2014 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction 3 Genocide: daily massacres amidst international silence 8 Arbitrary detention and Enforced Disappearances 11 Besiegement: slow-motion genocide 14 Violations committed against health and the health sector 17 The conditions of Syrian refugees 23 The use of internationally prohibited weapons 27 Violations committed against freedom of the press 31 Violations committed against houses of worship 39 The targeting of historical and archaeological sites 44 Legal and legislative amendments 46 References 47 About SHRC 48 The 12th annual report on human rights in Syria (January 2013 – December 2013) Introduction The year 2013 witnessed a continuation of grave and unprecedented violations committed against the Syrian people amidst a similarly shocking and unprecedented silence in the international community since the beginning of the revolution in March 2011. Throughout the year, massacres were committed on almost a daily basis killing more than 40.000 people and injuring 100.000 others at least. In its attacks, the regime used heavy weapons, small arms, cold weapons and even internationally prohibited weapons. The chemical attack on eastern Ghouta is considered a landmark in the violations committed by the regime against civilians; it is also considered a milestone in the international community’s response to human rights violations Throughout the year, massacres in Syria, despite it not being the first attack in which were committed on almost a daily internationally prohibited weapons have been used by the basis killing more than 40.000 regime. The international community’s response to the crime people and injuring 100.000 drew the international public’s attention to the atrocities others at least.
    [Show full text]
  • 2014 Syria Regional Response Plan Jordan
    2014 Syria Regional Response Plan Jordan 2014 Syria Regional Response Plan Jordan Table of Contents A. Executive Summary 2 B. Context 3 C. Needs, vulnerabilities and capacities 6 D. Response strategy and priorities 12 E. Partnerships and coordination 15 F. Protection response 17 G. Food Security response 38 H. Education response 50 I. Health response 61 J. Shelter and Settlements response 75 K. Non-Food Items (NFI) response 89 L. Cash response 96 M. Water Sanitation and Hygiene (WASH) response 104 N. Jordan Financial Requirements Summary 115 1 2014 Syria Regional Response Plan Jordan Response Plan OVERVIEW A. Executive Summary Under the leadership of the Government of Jordan (GoJ) and coordinated by UNHCR, the refugee response is a collaborative effort between the donor community, UN agencies, international and national NGOs, community-based organizations, refugees and Jordanian communities. The total requirements for the Jordan RRP6 in 2014 are US$1,200,650,591 requested by 64 organizations, through 1,265 project submissions across the eight sectors1 of Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (WASH), Cash, Education, Food Security, Health, Non-Food Items (NFIs), Protection, and Shelter. In addition, the GoJ has presented projects totalling US$413,787,018 for prioritized needs in the municipalities and the Education, Health and Water sectors. This budget is calculated on the projected needs of an expected 800,000 refugees who will be protected in Jordan by the end of 2014, and includes assistance that will reach over two million Jordanians affected by the presence of refugees. The projection of 800,000 refugees represents an increase of 250,000 from the total of 550,000 refugees currently registered by UNHCR in early November 2013 as residing in Jordan.
    [Show full text]
  • Of Relapse in Sex Offenders
    If you have issues viewing or accessing this file contact us at NCJRS.gov. ! • ., " PREVENTION OF RELAPSE IN • SEX OFFENDERS • D. Richard Laws, Ph.D. Project No.1 R01 MH42035 • National Institute of Mental Health • 102319 • U.S. Oepartment of Justice Nalionallnstltute of Justice This document has been reproduced exaclly as received from the person or organization originating it. Points of view or opinions stated In this document are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official position or policies of the National Institute of Justice. Permission to reproduce this o~JTigMed material has been • granted by Public Domain National Institute of Mental Health to the National Criminal Justice Reference Service (NCJRS). Further reproduction outside of the NCJRS system requires permis­ • sion of th~l:lt owner. PREVENTION I OF RELAPSE IN • SEX OFFENDERS ~~ ..". • • • • D. Richard Laws, Ph.D. • Project No. 1 RO 1 MH42035 National Institute of Mental Health • • • • Table of·Contents Research Plan General ov~rview of the research ................................ l Specific aims •••• "' •• ,,"" '1"" .. ""."""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""",,.1 Preliminary studies""." '" " " .. " " .. " fI " " " " " " " • " " " " " " " " " • " " " • " " " " " " " " " " 3 Physiological assessment procedures ........................ 9 • Self-report assessment procedures ......................... 14 Behavioral treatment procedures .............•............. 23 Cognitive treatment procedures .....................•...... 30 Methods I. Participants and
    [Show full text]
  • Pornography, Law and Moral Theory
    PORNOGRAPHY, LAW AND MORAL THEORY Joel Bakan* 1. INTRODUCTION It is always important to remember that law is not an end in itself, but rather a means of realizing certain values. This becomes especially apparent when we are faced with the problem of creating laws in an area in which there is considerable conflict between competing values. Pornography is such an area. Liberals, legal moralists (conservatives) and feminists all appear to agree that, in certain circumstances, restrictions on pornography are justified, but they vehemently disagree as to why and in what circumstances such restrictions are justified. Liberals argue that restrict- ing pornography means curtailing freedom of expression and the right to individual liberty, and that such restrictions are only justified where the exercise of these rights and freedoms can be shown to cause harm to individuals. Legal moralists, on the other hand, argue that restrictions on pornography are necessary even where no harm to individuals can be shown. Pornography, they claim, is immoral, and the law must protect society from breaches of its moral standards. Feminists are not concerned with the moral or immoral nature of pornography, but with the harm that pornography causes to individual women. In this sense the feminist position is consistent with liberal theory, although there is a reluctance on the part of many liberals to recognize this. This article will investigate the problem of legal restrictions on pornography in the context of moral theory. A brief discussion of the two major moral theories that inform the pornography debate, liberalism and legal moralism, will be followed by a discussion of Canadian obscenity law in terms of its moral foundations.
    [Show full text]