Changes in the Marsh and Aquatic Vascular Flora of East Harbor State Park, Ottawa County, Ohio, Since 18951
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CHANGES IN THE MARSH AND AQUATIC VASCULAR FLORA OF EAST HARBOR STATE PARK, OTTAWA COUNTY, OHIO, SINCE 18951 DAVID L. MOORE, Department of Botany, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 43210 Abstract. Numerous changes in the marsh and aquatic flora of East Harbor State Park have occurred since 1895. Of the 89 species collected and identified before 1900, 22 are no longer present. This represents a loss of approximately 25% of the species originally reported by Moseley (1899) and Pieters (1901). The species lost would rise to 42%, if those species formerly abundant, but now rare, or occurring as one or two small, isolated populations disappear. Probable causes for these changes are wind and water erosion, fluctuating water levels, dredging, establishment and spread of species new to the park, and increase or decrease in abundance of species already present. OHIO J. SCI. 76(2): 78, 1976. Since it was purchased in 1946 as a These sites were visited at two week intervals from June to August 1972, with additional col- site for an outdoor recreational facility, lections in April, May, September, and October. East Harbor State Park has undergone Plant specimens representing all the vascular both natural and artificial changes. The taxa present were collected by traversing the park is located on the south shore of Lake study sites on foot in paths parallel to the shore- line of both Middle and East Harbor, until the Erie, 81 miles west of Cleveland and 45 entire study site had been covered. The water miles east of Toledo, near Sandusky, at surfaces of study sites III, IV, V, and VI were the junction of State Routes 163 and 269 surveyed by canoe. A drag hook was employed in Danbury Township, Ottawa County, to sample the submersed aquatics. Two aerial photo flights were used to map the study sites Ohio (fig. 1). The site is an extensive and shoreline as well as to plot large communi- sand beach behind which is swamp, ties of aquatics. Voucher specimens were woods, marsh, and open water. The dried, mounted, and deposited at the Ohio water portions are divided by a causeway State University Herbarium after identification was completed. Pieters (1901), Moseley (1899), into East and Middle Harbors, although and 14 other investigators (see Moore, 1973) a seven foot culvert permits mixing of the had studied the same area and their data was water masses. used for comparison with my own study. An Pieters' (1901) enumeration and de- analytical list of collected species appears as scription of the plants present at East table 2. Harbor provide a reference point from which to judge the changes occurring RESULTS AND DISCUSSION there since 1898. The following year, The park lies at the extreme eastern Moseley (1899) published a catalogue end of the Prairie Peninsula (Transeau, of the flowering plants and ferns growing 1935) just beyond the northeastern ex- in Erie County and the islands and pen- tremity of the Mississippi embayment insula of Ottawa County. These two (Gleason, 1922), and exhibits an as- papers provide a basis for estimating semblage of plant species with western floristic changes at East Harbor since and southern geographic distributions 1895. not seen at the eastern end of Lake Erie. Moseley (1899) discusses the unique METHODS floristic diversity seen in the Sandusky Eleven study sites (table 1) were selected for region (of which East Harbor is an in- study, including most of the park area where tegral part), noting that, "the region vascular marsh or aquatic plants occurred. contains 305 native plants not known to Manuscript received October 14, 1975, and grow within fifty miles of Buffalo which in revised form February 12, 1976 (#75-60). lies at the eastern end of Lake Erie: The 78 No. 2 CHANGES IN EAST HARBOR VASCULAR FLORA 79 1972 MIDDLE HARBOR LAKE ERIE LAKE ERIE EAST HARBOR to Lakeside - Marblehead S.R.163 FIGURE 1. Outline map of East Harbor Area. Stippled areas are study sites as labeled, except for study site III which includes the open water of Middle Harbor, and study site VI which includes the shallow water and shoreline adjacent to West Harbor (Drawn from aerial photos, 1972). 80 DAVID L. MOORE Vol. 76 lake's shore and marshes furnish quite a Stabilization of the plant communities number of species not found in the in- is intimately associated with fluctuating terior of the state . Owing to the water levels and, in low water years, ex- long summer enjoyed by places situated tensive mudflats were available where on the south shore of Lake Erie, many propagules of emersed species colonized. plants grow here which are not found In high water years, the abundance of farther north . quite a number of typical mudflat species was reduced, species appear to reach their eastern concomitant with decreased available limit." He lists some 80 species of habitat space. Occasionally floating mats which only 25 were recorded at East developed with communities of Pontederia Harbor, in this study. cor data, Sagittaria latifolia, Bidens spp., In the spring of 1945, causeway con- Polygonum spp., Rorippa paulstris, and struction made Middle Harbor a land- Cardamine spp., Car ex spp., Scirpus spp., locked lake. An unusually large number and grasses. Erosion has become a seri- of carp were confined within the harbor ous problem within the harbor area be- since this was the height of the spawning cause of high water, and power boats season (Anderson, 1950). Their feeding contribute to increased turbulence of the habits effected an almost complete loss of water in the shallower margins and cause Myriophyllum exalbescens, Najas flexilis, disturbances of the shoreline. Potamogeton crispus, P. foliosus, P. na- Some emersed species that were re- tans, P. pusillus, P. richardsonii, and P. ported by Pieters (1901) as abundant zosteriformis. Vallisneria americana was are now considerably reduced in abun- absent. Prior to 1945 vigorous growth dance or are quite rare. Examples are of Vallisneria americana was reported Eleocharis smallii, Justicia americana, along with Potamogeton pectinalus, My- Nelumbo lutea, Nuphar advena, Phrag- riophyllum exalbescens, and Scirpus vali- mites australis, Pontederia miles auslralis, dus. In October, 1948 rotenone was Pontederia cordata, Sagittaria latifolia, sprayed on Middle Harbor's 250 acres in Sagittaria rigida, Scirpus acutus, and a effort to reduce the excessive carp popu- Typha latifolia. Certain pioneer species lation (Wier and Starr, 1950). After of open areas on mudflats, which were spraying, a semiqualitative survey of rare in Pieters' time, are still rare or have plant species abundance was taken in even disappeared. Among these are September, 1949 (Anderson, 1950). The Ammannia coccinea, A triplex patula, Bol- most noticeable change was in the clarity tonia asteroides, Leucospora multifida, of the water. In one year Potamogeton Sagittaria graminea, Scirpus smithii, and pectinatus increased to about 28% dry Scirpus torreyi. Rooted submersed or weight of the sampling. About 6000 floating-leaved species which are now Vallisneria americana tubers were planted rare or absent include: in April, 1949 by park personnel, and by Elodea canadensis the time the survey was taken in Sep- Heteranthera dubia tember, substantial growth of these Megalodonta beckii plants had taken place. This growth of Najas flexilis V. americana, however, was not as pro- Najas guadalupensis Nymphaea tuberosa lific as in other areas of the park and Potamogeton amplifolius exhibited only rare seed production. Potamogeton gramineus Myriophyllum exalbescens increased only Potamogeton illinoensis to about 5% of the sampling, but today Potamogeton natans Potamogeton nodosus is one of the community dominants. Potamogeton perfoliatus Najas flexilis was reported as quite rare, Potamogeton richardsonii and Najas marina and N. minor com- Potamogeton robinsii posed 2% of the sampling (Anderson, Potamogeton zosteriformis 1950). No significant change in the Ranunculus longirostris amount of Potamogeton crispus was ob- Zannichellia palustris served, but it now shares commun- The reduction in the populations of many ity dominance with Myriophyllum of these species was most likely caused by exalbescens. the dredging of the harbor, resulting in No. 2 CHANGES IN EAST HARBOR VASCULAR FLORA 81 increased turbidity of the water, loss of of the Ohio State University, from his ex- suitable habitats, and increased use of tensive field experience. the area by man. Typha latifolia was the only cattail During the first season following dredg- noted in East Harbor by Pieters (1901). ing, 1968, the mudflat was photographed T. angustifolia was listed by Moseley and a record of the flora made by Dr. (1899) as scarce, occurring in the Castalia Ronald L. Stuckey and Mr. Alan Wentz stream, Portage River, and on North Bass of the Ohio State University. They Island, as opposed to the common occur- noted a total of 93 species (denoted by a rence of T. latifolia in the Sandusky area. t in table 2). By the summer of 1972, In 1972 only a few isolated colonies of the number had dropped to 73, a loss of T. latifolia at East Harbor State Park 21.4% of the species noted in 1968. If were found, three of which were in tem- rare species occurring in only one or two porary ponds behind the crushed rock- small populations are included, the loss fill in study site I. Conversely, T. would rise to 40% reflecting inundation angustifolia is dominant throughout study of nearly half of the mudflat because of sites II, IV, Va, Vb, VI, VII, VIII, and the high water in 1969 and subsequent XI (table 1). years, placement of crushed rockfill along Since 1900, several non-indigenous spe- the harbor shoreline resulting in the loss cies have become established and are of suitable shoreline habitat, and gradual spreading in the park. Among these are: invasion or expansion of the areas oc- Butomus umbellatus cupied by species such as Typha an- Echinochloa walteri guslifolia, Populus deltoides, Salix in- Epilobium hirsutum Lycopus asper terior, and 6".