DOCSLIB.ORG

Relationship Between Geographical Location and Evaluation Of

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Relationship Between Geographical Location and Evaluation Of 1 Relationship between Geographical Location and Evaluation of 59 2 60 3 Developer Contributions in GitHub 61 4 62 5 Ayushi Rastogi Nachiappan Nagappan 63 6 64 7 UCI, Irvine Microsoft Research, Redmond 65 8 [email protected] [email protected] 66 9 67 10 Georgios Gousios André van der Hoek 68 11 TU Delft, Netherlands UCI, Irvine 69 12 [email protected] [email protected] 70 13 71 14 ABSTRACT 1 INTRODUCTION 72 15 Background Open source software projects show gender bias sug- Open source software (OSS) development has always been envi- 73 16 gesting that other demographic characteristics of developers, like sioned as a merit-based model [24]. This gave rise to the term ‘code 74 17 geographical location, can negatively influence evaluation of con- is king’ [11][24], indicating a belief that the quality of the code 75 18 tributions too. Aim This study contributes to this emerging body being contributed should be the sole factor in determining whether 76 19 of knowledge in software development by presenting a quantitative or not the code is accepted to be included in the primary line of 77 20 analysis of the relationship between the geographical location of de- development. 78 21 velopers and evaluation of their contributions on GitHub. Method Various studies, however, have shown that in addition to techni- 79 22 We present an analysis of 70,000+ pull requests selected from 17 cal factors relating to code quality, social factors influence accep- 80 23 most actively participating countries to model the relationship be- tance or rejection decisions. For instance, social closeness between 81 24 tween the geographical location of developers and pull request submitter and integrator, as built through prior interactions, can 82 25 acceptance decision. Results and Conclusion We observed struc- positively influence acceptance [27]. As another example, status 83 26 tural differences in pull request acceptance rates across 17 coun- in the community increases acceptance [27]), while size of the 84 27 tries. Countries with no apparent similarities such as Switzerland contribution decreases acceptance [15]. 85 28 and Japan had one of the highest pull request acceptance rates Only recently, a demographic attribute of contributors – gender, 86 29 while countries like China and Germany had one of the lowest pull is found to influence evaluation of contributions in OSS projects. 87 30 request acceptance rates. Notably, higher acceptance rates were In a study of 1.4 million GitHub user profiles, Terrell et al. found 88 31 observed for all but one country when pull requests were evaluated that code contributions by female developers were less often ac- 89 32 by developers from the same country. cepted than their male counterparts when their gender was identi- 90 33 fiable [26]. 91 34 CCS CONCEPTS This paper contributes to this emerging body of knowledge in 92 35 software development with a study that focuses on a demographic 93 • Software and its engineering → Open source model; Pro- 36 attribute of developers - geographical location. We elicit the re- 94 gramming teams; • Human-centered computing → Empirical 37 lationship between the geographical location of developers and 95 studies in collaborative and social computing; 38 evaluation of their contributions by modeling GitHub projects’ 96 39 archival data using country of residence of developers to measure 97 40 KEYWORDS geographical location and pull request acceptance decision to mea- 98 41 Open source, geographical location, pull requests, GitHub. sure evaluation of contributions. 99 42 We present an analysis of 70,000+ pull requests originating from 100 ACM Reference Format: 43 17 most actively participating countries on GitHub. We control 101 Ayushi Rastogi, Nachiappan Nagappan, Georgios Gousios, and André van 44 for the influence of other factors known to influence pull request 102 der Hoek. 2018. Relationship between Geographical Location and Evalu- 45 acceptance decision to quantitatively analyze the relationship of the 103 ation of Developer Contributions in GitHub. In ACM / IEEE International 46 Symposium on Empirical Software Engineering and Measurement (ESEM) country of submitters with overall pull request acceptance decision. 104 47 (ESEM ’18), October 11–12, 2018, Oulu, Finland. ACM, New York, NY, USA, We also consider the case in which submitter and integrator are 105 48 8 pages. https://doi.org/10.475/123_4 from the same country for its possible relationship with pull request 106 49 acceptance decision. 107 50 Our findings reveal that there are statistically significant dif- 108 51 Permission to make digital or hard copies of part or all of this work for personal or ferences in the acceptance rates among the pull requests issued 109 52 classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed by developers from different countries. We, however, could not 110 for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation 53 on the first page. Copyrights for third-party components of this work must be honored. attribute the observed differences to the factors which may seem 111 54 For all other uses, contact the owner/author(s). obvious otherwise. For example, we examined whether contribu- 112 55 ESEM, 2018 tors from non-English speaking countries have lower pull request 113 © 2018 Copyright held by the owner/author(s). 56 ACM ISBN 123-4567-24-567/08/06. acceptance rate compared to English speaking countries. We did 114 57 https://doi.org/10.475/123_4 not find any pattern though. 115 58 1 116 ESEM, 2018 Ayushi Rastogi, Nachiappan Nagappan, Georgios Gousios, and André van der Hoek 117 2 BACKGROUND called the integrator or committer, receives what is called a pull 175 118 This section presents a brief history on bias at work originating request when a contributor submits their proposed update. The 176 119 from individuals’ demographic attribute - geographical location, integrator then ‘pulls’ the code from the repository of the contribu- 177 120 and how it translates to OSS projects. This is followed by relevant tor, examines it closely, and makes their decision as to whether to 178 121 background material concerning the notion of pull-based develop- push the code to the main branch. This two-phased process allows 179 122 ment and factors that are already known to influence pull requests. projects to be more transparent, with open discussions taking place 180 123 surrounding complex pull requests, thereby making the overall 181 124 2.1 Bias at work originating from individuals’ process more democractic [18]. Today, nearly half of the projects 182 125 geographical location on GitHub use the pull-based development model [12]. Particularly 183 126 because these projects tend to be larger and public, numerous pre- 184 127 The role of individuals’ demographic attribute - geographical loca- vious studies have focused on various aspects and implications of 185 128 tion - in influencing evaluation of contributions is known for long the pull-based development model (e.g., Yu et al. examined factors 186 129 in traditional workplaces, where people meet in-person for work influencing latency in pull request evaluation32 [ ] and Gousios et 187 130 and are aware of the demographic attributes of fellow contributors. al. studied aspects of work practices and challenges in pull-based 188 131 Indeed, a whole body of literature has emerged, albiet dispersed development [13]). 189 132 over many communities. For instance, in the Olympics and other 190 133 forms of international competitions, experienced judges with sig- 2.3 Factors influencing pull request acceptance 191 nificant training in fairly evaluating all participants were found 134 Previous studies have already begun to look at pull request accep- 192 to nonetheless rank participants from their own nations higher 135 tance and the influence that different factors may have. For instance, 193 than participants from other nations [23]. As another example, in 136 it has been found that a developer’s technical and social reputa- 194 academia, papers with authors from some regions receive fewer 137 tion positively influences acceptance of the changes they submit 195 citations than papers from authors of other regions, even when the 138 in their pull requests [7][15][20][27]. Some of these studies fur- 196 papers were of comparable quality [19]. 139 ther demonstrated that adhering to a project’s technical and social 197 In open source software development, in contrast, developers 140 norms increases the chances of acceptance [15][17][27], although 198 collaborate online, from same or different geographical locations 141 with the caveat that, the more mature and popular a project is, the 199 and were not aware of the demographic attributes of fellow de- 142 lower the chances of pull request acceptance are overall [15][27]. 200 velopers. In recent years, with the rise of environments such as 143 Focusing on the nature of a pull request itself, it has also been 201 GitHub [3], Bitbucket [1], and others (e.g., [4][5]), OSS developers 144 shown that the size of the change, its perceived quality, and the 202 today can become much more aware of the demographic attributes 145 theme and objective of the pull request, among others, influence 203 of their fellow developers [28], which may lead to them consciously 146 its chances of acceptance considerably [15][27][31][25]. 204 or subconsciously changing the way they interact with and make 147 Broadly, the factors that have been found to seemingly influence 205 decisions toward their fellow developers [29]. 148 pull request acceptance can be categorized as being related to: (1) 206 A recent study of 1.4 million GitHub user profiles reported bias 149 the developer themselves, (2) the project as a whole, and (3) the 207 in evaluation of code contributions when a demographic attribute 150 specific pull request.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Online Visualization of Geospatial Stream Data Using the Worldwide Telescope
    Online Visualization of Geospatial Stream Data using the WorldWide Telescope Mohamed Ali#, Badrish Chandramouli*, Jonathan Fay*, Curtis Wong*, Steven Drucker*, Balan Sethu Raman# #Microsoft SQL Server, One Microsoft Way, Redmond WA 98052 {mali, sethur}@microsoft.com *Microsoft Research, One Microsoft Way, Redmond WA 98052 {badrishc, jfay, curtis.wong, sdrucker}@microsoft.com ABSTRACT execution query pipeline. StreamInsight has been used in the past This demo presents the ongoing effort to meld the stream query to process geospatial data, e.g., in traffic monitoring [4, 5]. processing capabilities of Microsoft StreamInsight with the On the other hand, the WorldWide Telescope (WWT) [9] enables visualization capabilities of the WorldWide Telescope. This effort a computer to function as a virtual telescope, bringing together provides visualization opportunities to manage, analyze, and imagery from the various ground and space-based telescopes in process real-time information that is of spatio-temporal nature. the world. WWT enables a wide range of user experiences, from The demo scenario is based on detecting, tracking and predicting narrated guided tours from astronomers and educators featuring interesting patterns over historical logs and real-time feeds of interesting places in the sky, to the ability to explore the features earthquake data. of planets. One interesting feature of WWT is its use as a 3-D model of earth, enabling its use as an earth viewer. 1. INTRODUCTION Real-time stream data acquisition has been widely used in This demo presents the ongoing work at Microsoft Research and numerous applications such as network monitoring, Microsoft SQL Server groups to meld the value of stream query telecommunications data management, security, manufacturing, processing of StreamInsight with the unique visualization and sensor networks.
    [Show full text]
  • The Fourth Paradigm
    ABOUT THE FOURTH PARADIGM This book presents the first broad look at the rapidly emerging field of data- THE FOUR intensive science, with the goal of influencing the worldwide scientific and com- puting research communities and inspiring the next generation of scientists. Increasingly, scientific breakthroughs will be powered by advanced computing capabilities that help researchers manipulate and explore massive datasets. The speed at which any given scientific discipline advances will depend on how well its researchers collaborate with one another, and with technologists, in areas of eScience such as databases, workflow management, visualization, and cloud- computing technologies. This collection of essays expands on the vision of pio- T neering computer scientist Jim Gray for a new, fourth paradigm of discovery based H PARADIGM on data-intensive science and offers insights into how it can be fully realized. “The impact of Jim Gray’s thinking is continuing to get people to think in a new way about how data and software are redefining what it means to do science.” —Bill GaTES “I often tell people working in eScience that they aren’t in this field because they are visionaries or super-intelligent—it’s because they care about science The and they are alive now. It is about technology changing the world, and science taking advantage of it, to do more and do better.” —RhyS FRANCIS, AUSTRALIAN eRESEARCH INFRASTRUCTURE COUNCIL F OURTH “One of the greatest challenges for 21st-century science is how we respond to this new era of data-intensive
    [Show full text]
  • WWW 2013 22Nd International World Wide Web Conference
    WWW 2013 22nd International World Wide Web Conference General Chairs: Daniel Schwabe (PUC-Rio – Brazil) Virgílio Almeida (UFMG – Brazil) Hartmut Glaser (CGI.br – Brazil) Research Track: Ricardo Baeza-Yates (Yahoo! Labs – Spain & Chile) Sue Moon (KAIST – South Korea) Practice and Experience Track: Alejandro Jaimes (Yahoo! Labs – Spain) Haixun Wang (MSR – China) Developers Track: Denny Vrandečić (Wikimedia – Germany) Marcus Fontoura (Google – USA) Demos Track: Bernadette F. Lóscio (UFPE – Brazil) Irwin King (CUHK – Hong Kong) W3C Track: Marie-Claire Forgue (W3C Training, USA) Workshops Track: Alberto Laender (UFMG – Brazil) Les Carr (U. of Southampton – UK) Posters Track: Erik Wilde (EMC – USA) Fernanda Lima (UNB – Brazil) Tutorials Track: Bebo White (SLAC – USA) Maria Luiza M. Campos (UFRJ – Brazil) Industry Track: Marden S. Neubert (UOL – Brazil) Proceedings and Metadata Chair: Altigran Soares da Silva (UFAM - Brazil) Local Arrangements Committee: Chair – Hartmut Glaser Executive Secretary – Vagner Diniz PCO Liaison – Adriana Góes, Caroline D’Avo, and Renato Costa Conference Organization Assistant – Selma Morais International Relations – Caroline Burle Technology Liaison – Reinaldo Ferraz UX Designer / Web Developer – Yasodara Córdova, Ariadne Mello Internet infrastructure - Marcelo Gardini, Felipe Agnelli Barbosa Administration– Ana Paula Conte, Maria de Lourdes Carvalho, Beatriz Iossi, Carla Christiny de Mello Legal Issues – Kelli Angelini Press Relations and Social Network – Everton T. Rodrigues, S2Publicom and EntreNós PCO – SKL Eventos
    [Show full text]
  • Denying Extremists a Powerful Tool Hany Farid ’88 Has Developed a Means to Root out Terrorist Propaganda Online
    ALUMNI GAZETTE Denying Extremists a Powerful Tool Hany Farid ’88 has developed a means to root out terrorist propaganda online. But will companies like Google and Facebook use it? By David Silverberg be a “no-brainer” for social media outlets. Farid is not alone in his criticism of so- But so far, the project has faced resistance cial media companies. Last August, a pan- Hany Farid ’88 wants to clean up the In- from the leaders of Facebook, Twitter, and el in the British Parliament issued a report ternet. The chair of Dartmouth’s comput- other outlets who argue that identifying ex- charging that Facebook, Twitter, and er science department, he’s a leader in the tremist content is more difficult, presenting Google are not doing enough to prevent field of digital forensics. In the past several more gray areas, than child pornography. their networks from becoming recruitment years, he has played a lead role in creating In a February 2016 blog post, Twitter laid tools for extremist groups. programs to identify and root out two of out its official position: “As many experts Steve Burgess, president of the digital fo- the worst online scourges: child pornogra- and other companies have noted, there is rensics firm Burgess Consulting and Foren- phy and extremist political content. no ‘magic algorithm’ for identifying terror- sics, admires Farid’s dedication to projects “Digital forensics is an exciting field, es- ist content on the Internet, so global online that, according to Burgess, aren’t common pecially since you can have an impact on platforms are forced to make challenging in the field.
    [Show full text]
  • Microsoft .NET Gadgeteer a New Way to Create Electronic Devices
    Microsoft .NET Gadgeteer A new way to create electronic devices Nicolas Villar Microsoft Research Cambridge, UK What is .NET Gadgeteer? • .NET Gadgeteer is a new toolkit for quickly constructing, programming and shaping new small computing devices (gadgets) • Takes you from concept to working device quickly and easily Driving principle behind .NET Gadgeteer • Low threshold • Simple gadgets should be very simple to build • High ceiling • It should also be possible to build sophisticated and complex devices The three key components of .NET Gadgeteer The three key components of .NET Gadgeteer The three key components of .NET Gadgeteer Some background • We originally built Gadgeteer as a tool for ourselves (in Microsoft Research) to make it easier to prototype new kinds of devices • We believe the ability to prototype effectively is key to successful innovation Some background • Gadgeteer has proven to be of interest to other researchers – but also hobbyists and educators • With the help of colleagues from all across Microsoft, we are working on getting Gadgeteer out of the lab and into the hands of others Some background • Nicolas Villar, James Scott, Steve Hodges Microsoft Research Cambridge • Kerry Hammil Microsoft Research Redmond • Colin Miller Developer Division, Microsoft Corporation • Scarlet Schwiderski-Grosche‎, Stewart Tansley‎ Microsoft Research Connections • The Garage @ Microsoft First key component of .NET Gadgeteer Quick example: Building a digital camera Some existing hardware modules Mainboard: Core processing unit Mainboard
    [Show full text]
  • A Large-Scale Study of Web Password Habits
    WWW 2007 / Track: Security, Privacy, Reliability, and Ethics Session: Passwords and Phishing A Large-Scale Study of Web Password Habits Dinei Florencioˆ and Cormac Herley Microsoft Research One Microsoft Way Redmond, WA, USA [email protected], [email protected] ABSTRACT to gain the secret. However, challenge response systems are We report the results of a large scale study of password use generally regarded as being more time consuming than pass- and password re-use habits. The study involved half a mil- word entry and do not seem widely deployed. One time lion users over a three month period. A client component passwords have also not seen broad acceptance. The dif- on users' machines recorded a variety of password strength, ¯culty for users of remembering many passwords is obvi- usage and frequency metrics. This allows us to measure ous. Various Password Management systems o®er to assist or estimate such quantities as the average number of pass- users by having a single sign-on using a master password words and average number of accounts each user has, how [7, 13]. Again, the use of these systems does not appear many passwords she types per day, how often passwords are widespread. For a majority of users, it appears that their shared among sites, and how often they are forgotten. We growing herd of password accounts is maintained using a get extremely detailed data on password strength, the types small collection of passwords. For a user with, e.g. 30 pass- and lengths of passwords chosen, and how they vary by site.
    [Show full text]
  • The World-Wide Telescope1 MSR-TR-2001-77
    The World-Wide Telescope1 Alexander Szalay, The Johns Hopkins University Jim Gray, Microsoft August 2001 Technical Report MSR-TR-2001-77 Microsoft Research Microsoft Corporation 301 Howard Street, #830 San Francisco, CA, 94105 1 This article appears in Science V. 293 pp. 2037-2040 14 Sept 2001. Copyright © 2001 by The American Association for the Advancement of Science. Science V. 293 pp. 2037-2040 14 Sept 2001. Copyright © 2001 by The American Association for the Advancement of Science 1 The World-Wide Telescope Alexander Szalay, The Johns Hopkins University Jim Gray, Microsoft August 2001 Abstract All astronomy data and literature will soon be tral band over the whole sky is a few terabytes. It is not online and accessible via the Internet. The community is even possible for each astronomer to have a private copy building the Virtual Observatory, an organization of this of all their data. Many of these new instruments are worldwide data into a coherent whole that can be ac- being used for systematic surveys of our galaxy and of cessed by anyone, in any form, from anywhere. The re- the distant universe. Together they will give us an un- sulting system will dramatically improve our ability to do precedented catalog to study the evolving universe— multi-spectral and temporal studies that integrate data provided that the data can be systematically studied in an from multiple instruments. The virtual observatory data integrated fashion. also provides a wonderful base for teaching astronomy, Already online archives contain raw and derived astro- scientific discovery, and computational science. nomical observations of billions of objects – both temp o- Many fields are now coping with a rapidly mounting ral and multi-spectral surveys.
    [Show full text]
  • Web Search As Decision Support for Cancer
    Diagnoses, Decisions, and Outcomes: Web Search as Decision Support for Cancer ∗ Michael J. Paul Ryen W. White Eric Horvitz Johns Hopkins University Microsoft Research Microsoft Research 3400 N. Charles Street One Microsoft Way One Microsoft Way Baltimore, MD 21218 Redmond, WA 98052 Redmond, WA 98052 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] ABSTRACT the decisions of searchers who show salient signs of having People diagnosed with a serious illness often turn to the Web been recently diagnosed with prostate cancer. We aim to for their rising information needs, especially when decisions characterize and enhance the ability of Web search engines are required. We analyze the search and browsing behavior to provide decision support for different phases of the illness. of searchers who show a surge of interest in prostate cancer. We focus on prostate cancer for several reasons. Prostate Prostate cancer is the most common serious cancer in men cancer is typically slow-growing, leaving patients and physi- and is a leading cause of cancer-related death. Diagnoses cians with time to reflect on the best course of action. There of prostate cancer typically involve reflection and decision is no medical consensus about the best treatment option, as making about treatment based on assessments of preferences the primary options all have similar mortality rates, each and outcomes. We annotated timelines of treatment-related with their own tradeoffs and side effects [24]. The choice queries from nearly 300 searchers with tags indicating differ- of treatments for prostate cancer is therefore particularly ent phases of treatment, including decision making, prepa- sensitive to consideration of patients' preferences about out- ration, and recovery.
    [Show full text]
  • Microsoft Research Lee Dirks Dr
    Transforming Scholarly Communication Overview of Recent Projects from Microsoft Research Lee Dirks Dr. Camilo A. Acosta-Márquez Director, Education & Scholarly Communication Director Centro de Robótica e Informática Microsoft Research | Connections Universidad Jorge Tadeo Lozano Overview of Recent Projects from Microsoft Research Director, Education Director Centro de Robótica e Informática & Scholarly Communication Universidad Jorge Tadeo Lozano Microsoft Research | Connections | Outreach. Collaboration. Innovation. • • • • http://research.microsoft.com/collaboration/ The Scholarly Excel 2010 Windows Server HPC Collaboration Communication Windows Workflow Foundation SharePoint Lifecycle LiveMeeting Data Office 365 Collection, Research & Analysis Office OpenXML Office 2010: XPS Format Storage, •Word SQL Server & Archiving & Authoring •PowerPoint Entity Framework Preservation •Excel Rights Management •OneNote Data Protection Manager Tablet PC/UMPC Publication & Dissemination Discoverability FAST SharePoint 2010 Word 2010 + PowerPoint 2010 WPF & Silverlight “Sea Dragon” / “PhotoSynth” / “Deep Zoom” Data Curation Add-in for Microsoft Excel • California Digital Library’s Curation Center • • DataONE • • Support for versioning • Standardized date/time stamps • A “workbook builder” • Ability to export metadata in a standard format • Ability to select from a globally shared vocabulary of terms for data descriptions • Ability to import term descriptions from the shared vocabulary and annotate them locally • “Speed bumps” to discourage use of macros
    [Show full text]
  • Transcript of Rick Rashid's Keynote Address
    TechFest 2013 Keynote Rick Rashid March 5, 2013 ANNOUNCER: Ladies and gentlemen, please welcome Microsoft Chief Research Officer, Rick Rashid. (Applause.) RICK RASHID: Hi there. Well, hopefully this will be a very fun day for all of you. For me, it's interesting. It feels like we've been doing TechFest for a really, long time, but it's actually only been since 2001. So, technically, I think, this is the 13th TechFest event for Microsoft Research. Of course, in the first TechFest, it wasn't nearly as big an event as this. It was just for employees. We didn't take up nearly as much space. And we didn't even know how many people would really show up. I was actually one of the strongest skeptics about this whole idea of creating this technology show for our employees, because I wasn't really sure how many people would show up. I kept saying, “Well, gosh, it seems like it's going to be a lot of work, and I'm not sure it's going to be really valuable and worthwhile, but if you guys really think you want to do it, okay.” Of course, what happened that year was we had, I think, about 4,000 of our Puget Sound employees come over a two-day period. And of course Microsoft was a much smaller company back then, so that was just a huge fraction of our Puget Sound workforce at that time. And everybody was really excited. I mean, the researchers came away from the event really excited about being able to talk to so many of our employees, be able to interact with them, and to sort of sell their ideas, and show off what they've been doing.
    [Show full text]
  • Microsoft Research Worldwide Telescope Multi-Channel Dome/Frustum Setup Guide
    Microsoft Research WorldWide Telescope Multi-Channel Dome/Frustum Setup Guide Prepared by Beau Guest & Doug Roberts Rev. 1.4, October 2013 WorldWide Telescope Multi-Channel Setup Guide Introduction Microsoft Research WorldWide Telescope (WWT) is a free program designed to give users the ability to explore the universe in a simple easy to use interface. Recently support has been developed to include a variety of playback mediums. This document will detail the steps required for a multi-channel display setup for use in a dome or frustum environment. It is recommended before attempting to setup a multi-channel system that you familiarize yourself with WWT as a system. There are many introductory tours that will help in this process that are included with the software. WWT is an ever evolving program and the steps, descriptions, and information contained in this guide is subject to change at any time. Parts of this guide work on the premise that you have the required data regarding projector positioning and field of view/aspect ratio. Please obtain these data before attempting to start this process. WWT is a trademark of Microsoft and all rights are reserved. 2 WorldWide Telescope Multi-Channel Setup Guide Table of Contents Software Installation ......................................................................................................................................................... 4 FOV Values .....................................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Time-Travel Debugging for Javascript/Node.Js
    Time-Travel Debugging for JavaScript/Node.js Earl T. Barr Mark Marron Ed Maurer University College London, UK Microsoft Research, USA Microsoft, USA [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Dan Moseley Gaurav Seth Microsoft, USA Microsoft, USA [email protected] [email protected] ABSTRACT Time-traveling in the execution history of a program during de- bugging enables a developer to precisely track and understand the sequence of statements and program values leading to an error. To provide this functionality to real world developers, we embarked on a two year journey to create a production quality time-traveling de- bugger in Microsoft’s open-source ChakraCore JavaScript engine and the popular Node.js application framework. CCS Concepts •Software and its engineering ! Software testing and debug- Figure 1: Visual Studio Code with extra time-travel functional- ging; ity (Step-Back button in top action bar) at a breakpoint. Keywords • Options for both using time-travel during local debugging Time-Travel Debugging, JavaScript, Node.js and for recording a trace in production for postmortem de- bugging or other analysis (Section 2.1). 1. INTRODUCTION • Reverse-Step Local and Dynamic operations (Section 2.2) Modern integrated development environments (IDEs) provide a that allow the developer to step-back in time to the previously range of tools for setting breakpoints, examining program state, and executed statement in the current function or to step-back in manually logging execution. These features enable developers to time to the previously executed statement in any frame in- quickly track down localized bugs, provided all of the relevant val- cluding exception throws or callee returns.
    [Show full text]