Divine Violence and the Christus Victor Atonement Model

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Divine Violence and the Christus Victor Atonement Model View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Middlesex University Research Repository DIVINE VIOLENCE AND THE CHRISTUS VICTOR ATONEMENT MODEL. A Thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy by Martyn John Smith Middlesex University Supervised at London School of Theology May 2015 i Abstract Martyn John Smith Divine Violence and the Christus Victor Atonement Model Doctor of Philosophy Middlesex University/London School of Theology 2015 More recently, there has been in some quarters a theological move away from the Penal Substitution model of atonement primarily due to the concerns it raises about God’s character. This is paralleled by a desire to replace it with a less violent approach to soteriology, with the concomitant representation of a less coercive God. This thesis addresses the biblical manifestations of divine violence across both Testaments in order to present God as one for whom violence is an extrinsic, accommodated function. Divine violence is particularly manifested soteriologically, finding its fullest expression, therefore, in the atonement. The Christus Victor Model is offered as the one best able to explicate and accommodate this divine violence. The main atonement models are assessed, revealing how each has sought to engage with, or deny, divine violence. Firstly, God and violence are explored in order to provide an ideological, linguistic and epistemological foundation for understanding what violence is. Biblical examples of violence are then examined including both Testaments along with consideration of the Satan and the demonic realm; showing how God utilises violence in order to overcome these ontological enemies. Various atonement models are then examined, followed by a consideration of metaphor in the context of soteriology and God. Key scholars addressing violence are then assessed, followed by a section on the primacy of the Christus Victor atonement model; it is then presented as the only one which can fully incorporate the concomitant issues of God’s character, divine violence and an actual, evil enemy seeking to confound both God and His purposes. Further, the Christus Victor model is presented as the only one which is ontological, expressing a view of the atonement that both acknowledges God’s incontrovertible use and endorsement of extrinsic violence as well as the need to overcome an actual enemy in the Satan. ii Acknowledgement. For my wife Suzanne, with eternal gratitude. iii Table of Contents. Prolegomena Page 1 Section 1 – God & Violence. 1.1 The Problem 8 1.2 Religious Use & Understanding of Violence 11 1.2.1 Persuasion & Coercion 12 1.2.1.1 The ‘Violence’ of Conversion 12 1.3 Jesus as a Model 14 1.3.1 Jesus & Confrontation 15 1.4 The Possibility of Divine Violence 16 1.4.1 Ancient Near Eastern Context 17 1.4.1.1 The Chronology of Evil 19 1.4.2 The Divine, Evil & Ontology 20 1.5 Knowing God 23 1.5.1 Relationship with God 25 1.6 Divine Attributes 26 1.6.1 Aposiopesis 27 1.6.1.1 The Deeper Essence 28 1.6.2 God’s Personhood 29 1.6.2.1 Thinking & Speaking 32 1.7 Disturbing Divine Behaviour 33 1.7.1 A Priori Agendas 34 1.7.1.1 Feuerbach’s Projections 35 1.7.1.2 Wisdom’s Parable 37 1.7.2 Responding to Violent Accusations 38 1.7.2.1 Unacceptable Ascriptions 40 1.7.3 God’s Wrath 41 iv 1.7.3.1 Anthropocentric Outlooks 43 1.7.4 Necessary Violence 44 1.7.5 Orthodox Perspectives 46 Section 2 – Biblical Violence 2.1 Old Testament Violence 47 2.1.1 Types of Violence 49 2.1.2 Abrahamic Violence 50 2.1.3 The Divine Warrior 52 2.1.4 Divine Genocide 56 2.1.4.1 The Flood 57 2.1.4.2 Sodom & Gomorrah 63 2.1.4.2.1 The Spectre of Infanticide 65 2.1.4.2.2 God’s Appropriate Response? 66 The Ban. 68 - ֵה ֶרמ 2.1.5 2.1.5.1 Etymology of the Ban 68 2.1.5.2 Applications of the Ban 70 2.1.5.3 Holy War & the Ban 71 2.1.5.4 The Ban at Jericho 73 2.1.6 Conclusion 75 2.2 New Testament Violence 76 2.2.1 The Violent Cross 77 2.2.1.2 God’s Hospitality 79 2.2.2 The Temple Incident 80 2.2.3 Eschatological Violence 90 2.2.3.1 Revelation Chapter 14 91 2.2.3.1.1 The Grapes of Wrath 92 2.2.3.1.2 The Shedding of Blood 94 2.2.3.1.3 Two Sides of the Same Coin 94 2.3 The Satan & the Demonic Realm 96 2.3.1 Biblical Background 97 2.3.2 Diobolic Definition 102 2.3.2.1 Diabolic Theology 103 v 2.3.3 Modern Understanding: Satanic Personhood 107 2.3.3.1 Seeking the Via Media 110 2.3.4 A Cosmic Power-Encounter: The Great Battle 112 2.3.5 Divine Violence against the Satan 116 2.3.6 Decisions on the Devil 118 Section 3 – Metaphor & Models 3.1 Penal Substitution – Judicial Violence 122 3.2 Moral Influence – Denied Violence 126 3.3 Christus Victor – Cosmological Violence 131 3.4 Ransom Christus Victor – Deceitful Violence 137 3.5 The Use of Metaphor 141 3.5.1 The Primacy of Metaphor 143 3.5.2 Explicating Reality 145 3.5.3 Soteriological Metaphors 148 3.5.4 Closing the Epistemic Gap 152 3.6 God & Metaphor 154 3.6.1 Pushing Too Far… 155 3.6.2 Cultic & Ritual Metaphors 156 3.6.3 The Poetry of Metaphor 157 3.6.3.1 The Limitations of Language 158 3.6.4 Anthropomorphism 159 vi Section 4 – Scholars on Violence 4.1 Rudolf Otto 160 4.1.1 Palatable Attributes 162 4.1.2 The Numinous 163 4.1.2.1 Numinous Wrath 165 4.1.3 The Sublime 165 4.2 René Girard 166 4.2.1 Doubles Theory 168 4.2.2 Mimesis 169 4.2.3 Violence 171 4.2.4 Scapegoat 171 4.2.5 Sacrifice 173 4.2.6 Theory Conclusion 174 4.3 Nicholas Wolterstorff 176 4.3.1 Love on God’s Own Terms 177 4.3.2 Lex Talionis 177 4.3.3 Diminution of Wellbeing 178 4.3.4 Promoting ‘Life-Goods’ 180 Section 5 – The Primacy of the Christus Victor Model. 5.1 Revisiting Christus Victor 181 5.1.1 Breaking with Tradition 184 5.1.2 Atonement & Violence 186 5.2 A Cosmic & Ontological Model 188 5.3 A Violent, Dramatic & Holistic Model 191 Final Conclusion. 195 vii Prolegomena.1 This thesis is about God, atonement, divine violence and the demythologisation of Christian views of the Satan and the demonic realm. On the latter, Girard notes that in the period when the German theologian Rudolf Bultmann had such great influence, all the theologians who were up to date “demythologized” the Scriptures with all their might but, he adds, they did not even do the prince of this world the honour of demythologizing him.2 On the contrary, this desire to demythologize is not so prevalent today with other previously dark entities instead subsumed into the modern consciousness via their adaptation from mysterious and evil to scientific. Hjelm takes the concept of ‘vampire’ and examines its new and old paradigms in film observing that the move of the vampire away from the demonic and towards the scientific—a worldview ironically rejected only by the most hardcore fundamentalists of any religion—can be seen as an outcome of the sensitivity that a religiously and spiritually pluralistic culture engenders.3 The vampire presented as an evil, demonic being, only to be confronted and defeated by the forces of good manifest in either the cross or a religious representative is now perceived as one suffering from various explicable conditions and faced with a nemesis armed with technological devices. Evil not demythologized, but rather re-presented and enculturated in postmodern forms. The conjoining of evil and postmodernity often causes societal and theological consternation; indeed, in his speculation upon what postmodern society might exclude from conversation, for example, Wink concludes, Certainly not sex; at least in the more ‘sophisticated’ circles accounts of sexual exploits scarcely raise an eyebrow. But if you want to bring all talk to a halt in shocked embarrassment, every eye riveted on you, try mentioning angels, or demons, or the devil. 1 Pannenberg asserts that, “In the presentation of a theme there is nothing unusual about postponing the actual treatment in favour (sic) of a few preliminary remarks on the theme itself and the mode of presentation.” W. Pannenberg, Systematic Theology, Volume 1, Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1988, 26-27. He cites various presentations of Christian doctrine which begin with introductory observations, including the Prologue of Lombard’s Sentences, the first quaestio of the theological Summa of Aquinas and Melanchthon’s introductions to his Loci communes and his Loci praecipui theologici. We will do likewise. 2 R. Girard, I See Satan Fall Like Lightning, Maryknoll: Orbis Books, 1999, 32. 3 T. Hjelm, ‘Celluloid Vampires, Scientization, and the Decline of Religion’, C. Partridge and E. Christianson (eds.), The Lure of the Dark Side: Satan and Western Demonology in Popular Culture, London: Equinox, 2009, 105-121, 119. 1 You will be quickly appraised for signs of pathological violence and then quietly shunned.4 In case Wink’s observations appear dated it should be noted that in more recent times various invisible and visible forces, or monsters have become part of the postmodern vista and its parlance.
Recommended publications
  • The Year's Music
    This is a reproduction of a library book that was digitized by Google as part of an ongoing effort to preserve the information in books and make it universally accessible. https://books.google.com fti E Y LAKS MV5IC 1896 juu> S-q. SV- THE YEAR'S MUSIC. PIANOS FOR HIRE Cramer FOR HARVARD COLLEGE LIBRARY Pianos BY All THE BEQUEST OF EVERT JANSEN WENDELL (CLASS OF 1882) OF NEW YORK Makers. 1918 THIS^BQQKJS FOR USE 1 WITHIN THE LIBRARY ONLY 207 & 209, REGENT STREET, REST, E.C. A D VERTISEMENTS. A NOVEL PROGRAMME for a BALLAD CONCERT, OR A Complete Oratorio, Opera Recital, Opera and Operetta in Costume, and Ballad Concert Party. MADAME FANNY MOODY AND MR. CHARLES MANNERS, Prima Donna Soprano and Principal Bass of Royal Italian Opera, Covent Garden, London ; also of 5UI the principal ©ratorio, dJrtlustra, artii Sgmphoiu) Cxmctria of ©wat Jfvitain, Jtmmca anb Canaba, With their Full Party, comprising altogether Five Vocalists and Three Instrumentalists, Are now Booking Engagements for the Coming Season. Suggested Programme for Ballad and Opera (in Costume) Concert. Part I. could consist of Ballads, Scenas, Duets, Violin Solos, &c. Lasting for about an hour and a quarter. Part II. Opera or Operetta in Costume. To play an hour or an hour and a half. Suggested Programme for a Choral Society. Part I. A Small Oratorio work with Chorus. Part II. An Operetta in Costume; or the whole party can be engaged for a whole work (Oratorio or Opera), or Opera in Costume, or Recital. REPERTOIRE. Faust (Gounod), Philemon and Baucis {Gounod) (by arrangement with Sir Augustus Harris), Maritana (Wallace), Bohemian Girl (Balfe), and most of the usual Oratorios, &c.
    [Show full text]
  • In Their Own Words: Voices of Jihad
    THE ARTS This PDF document was made available from www.rand.org as CHILD POLICY a public service of the RAND Corporation. CIVIL JUSTICE EDUCATION Jump down to document ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENT 6 HEALTH AND HEALTH CARE INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit research NATIONAL SECURITY POPULATION AND AGING organization providing objective analysis and PUBLIC SAFETY effective solutions that address the challenges facing SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY the public and private sectors around the world. SUBSTANCE ABUSE TERRORISM AND HOMELAND SECURITY Support RAND TRANSPORTATION AND INFRASTRUCTURE Purchase this document WORKFORCE AND WORKPLACE Browse Books & Publications Make a charitable contribution For More Information Visit RAND at www.rand.org Learn more about the RAND Corporation View document details Limited Electronic Distribution Rights This document and trademark(s) contained herein are protected by law as indicated in a notice appearing later in this work. This electronic representation of RAND intellectual property is provided for non-commercial use only. Unauthorized posting of RAND PDFs to a non-RAND Web site is prohibited. RAND PDFs are protected under copyright law. Permission is required from RAND to reproduce, or reuse in another form, any of our research documents for commercial use. For information on reprint and linking permissions, please see RAND Permissions. This product is part of the RAND Corporation monograph series. RAND monographs present major research findings that address the challenges facing the public and private sectors. All RAND monographs undergo rigorous peer review to ensure high standards for research quality and objectivity. in their own words Voices of Jihad compilation and commentary David Aaron Approved for public release; distribution unlimited C O R P O R A T I O N This book results from the RAND Corporation's continuing program of self-initiated research.
    [Show full text]
  • Music 18145 Songs, 119.5 Days, 75.69 GB
    Music 18145 songs, 119.5 days, 75.69 GB Name Time Album Artist Interlude 0:13 Second Semester (The Essentials Part ... A-Trak Back & Forth (Mr. Lee's Club Mix) 4:31 MTV Party To Go Vol. 6 Aaliyah It's Gonna Be Alright 5:34 Boomerang Aaron Hall Feat. Charlie Wilson Please Come Home For Christmas 2:52 Aaron Neville's Soulful Christmas Aaron Neville O Holy Night 4:44 Aaron Neville's Soulful Christmas Aaron Neville The Christmas Song 4:20 Aaron Neville's Soulful Christmas Aaron Neville Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow! 2:22 Aaron Neville's Soulful Christmas Aaron Neville White Christmas 4:48 Aaron Neville's Soulful Christmas Aaron Neville Such A Night 3:24 Aaron Neville's Soulful Christmas Aaron Neville O Little Town Of Bethlehem 3:56 Aaron Neville's Soulful Christmas Aaron Neville Silent Night 4:06 Aaron Neville's Soulful Christmas Aaron Neville Louisiana Christmas Day 3:40 Aaron Neville's Soulful Christmas Aaron Neville The Star Carol 2:13 Aaron Neville's Soulful Christmas Aaron Neville The Bells Of St. Mary's 2:44 Aaron Neville's Soulful Christmas Aaron Neville Tell It Like It Is 2:42 Billboard Top R&B 1967 Aaron Neville Tell It Like It Is 2:41 Classic Soul Ballads: Lovin' You (Disc 2) Aaron Neville Don't Take Away My Heaven 4:38 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville I Owe You One 5:33 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville Don't Fall Apart On Me Tonight 4:24 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville My Brother, My Brother 4:59 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville Betcha By Golly, Wow 3:56 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville Song Of Bernadette 4:04 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville You Never Can Tell 2:54 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville The Bells 3:22 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville These Foolish Things 4:23 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville The Roadie Song 4:41 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville Ain't No Way 5:01 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville The Grand Tour 3:22 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville The Lord's Prayer 1:58 The Grand Tour Aaron Neville Tell It Like It Is 2:43 Smooth Grooves: The 60s, Volume 3 L..
    [Show full text]
  • Joseph Ratzinger. Concerning the Notion of Person in Theology
    assumed in Christ and in the new law (on the basis of the Retrieving the Tradition resolution of the eternal law into the Christic predestination), and that which is assumed is not abolished: quod est assumpturn est senmtum. To one who does not believe, it is always possible to demonstrate the intrinsic reasonableness of a norm which is Concerning the notion of person knowable even naturally, without failing from the beginning to present it as an ingredient of a whole which receives its full in theology foundation only jn the Chdstic perspective. Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger Relativity toward the other constitutes the human person. The human person is the event or being of relativity. The concept of person, as well as the idea that stands behind this concept, is a product of Christian theology. In other words, it grew in the first place out of the interplay between human thought and the data of Christian faith and so entered intellec- tual history. The concept of the person is thus, to speak with Gilson, one of the contributions to human thought made pos- sible and provided by Christian faith. It did not simply grow out of mere human philosophizing, but out of the interplay between philosophy and the antecedent given of faith, espe- cially Scripture. More specifically, the concept of person arose from two questions that have from the very beginning urged themselves upon Christian thought as central: namely, the question, 'What is God?" (i.e., the God whom we encounter in Scripture); and, "Who is Christ?" In order to answer these fundamental questions that arose as soon as faith began to re- flect, Christian thought made use of the philosophically insig- nificant or entirely unused concept "prosopon" = "persona." It thereby gave to this word a new meaning and opened up a new dimension of human thought.
    [Show full text]
  • Judgment for Copyright Infringement and Permanent Injunction with the 16 Consent and on the Advice of Such Independent Legal Counsel
    UMG Recordings, Inc. v. BCD Music Group, Inc. et al Doc. 199 1 JEFFREY D. GOLDMAN (SBN 155589) [email protected] 2 ROBERT J. CATALANO (SBN 240654) [email protected] 3 LOEB & LOEB LLP 10100 Santa Monica Boulevard, Suite 2200 4 Los Angeles, California 90067-4120 Tel: 310-282-2000/Fax: 310-282-2200 5 Attorneys for Plaintiff JS-6 6 7 8 UNITED STATES DISTRICT 9 CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 10 UMG RECORDINGS, INC., a Case No. CV 07-05808 SJO (FFMx) 11 Delaware corporation Assigned to the Hon. S. James Otero 12 Plaintiff, JUDGMENT FOR COPYRIGHT 13 v. INFRINGEMENT AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION 14 BCD MUSIC GROUP, INC., a Texas corporation; and DOES 1-10, inclusive 15 Defendants. 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 LA1837611.1 JUDGMENT AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION 212374-10008 Dockets.Justia.com Based on the stipulation by and between plaintiff UMG Recordings, Inc., a 1 Delaware corporation (“UMG”), and BCD Music Group, Inc., a Texas corporation 2 (“BCD”), and for good cause appearing, 3 4 IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED THAT: 5 6 1. BCD infringed UMG’s copyrights in the following forty-three (43) 7 sound recordings (the “43 Sound Recordings”): 8 9 1. “War with God” (Ludacris) from the album Release Therapy. 10 2. “My House” (Lloyd Banks). 3. “Over and Over” (Nelly) from the album Suit. 11 4. “3 Kings” (Slim Thug). 12 5. “Say I” (Christina Milian). 6. “Bang Bang” (Young Buck), from the album Straight Outta 13 Cashville. 14 7. “Diamonds” (Fabolous). 8.
    [Show full text]
  • Abstract This Dissertation Addresses a Lacuna in the Study of the Literary
    Abstract This dissertation addresses a lacuna in the study of the literary portrayals of divine retribution in the Old Testament. Focusing on narrative texts, this work posits the presence of the divine messenger opposition type-scene, conventional scenes in which an antagonist opposes a divine messenger on whom God inflicts extreme fates that often seem disproportionate to the offense and occur in the absence of any divine proscription. Opposition to the messenger seems to be the offense grave enough to merit the peculiar fates these characters experience. The introduction discusses how the historical analysis of divine retribution has been limited to theological treatments. Recent studies have slightly expanded the analysis to sociological and anthropological approaches, but literary approaches to the topic have been scant. Addressing the intersection of convention and historiography provides a foundation for moving the discussion forward. Employing a literary-critical treatment—supplemented by form-, source-, historical-, and redaction-critical approaches where beneficial—to multiple narrative passages reveals the presence of the proposed type-scene. Chapter 2 explores Moses as the prototypical prophet validated through the bizarre fates experienced by his opponents. Korah’s destruction, Miriam’s leprosy, and the biting serpents all represent divine responses to opposition to Moses. Korah’s rebellion represents a paradigmatic template of the type-scene, one in which God validates Moses. Chapter 3 examines the type-scene in narratives involving the classical prophets. The stories of Jeroboam’s deformity, Ahab’s death, the fiery death of Ahaziah’s military squads, the mauling by bears of Bethel youths, Gehazi’s leprosy, and the trampling of a court official during the siege of Samaria all utilize the type-scene in a manner that validates the legitimacy of a prophet.
    [Show full text]
  • A Sermon Series at Huntersville Lutheran Solus Christus | Christ
    A Sermon Series at Huntersville Lutheran SOLus Christus | Christ Alone 10.25.20 Huntersville Lutheran A Changeless Message for A Changing Community Worshipping at the Brick Row Bible Class @ 8:45 | Worship @ 9:30am Huntersvillelc.com | 248-807-3057 | [email protected] elcome! Thank you for joining us for worship this morning. Our service is centered W on our Savior, Jesus Christ, who lived, died, and rose from the dead so that we would have eternal life in him. God reveals this soul saving message in his Word. We gather to find strength though God’s powerful and holy Word. Take a few moments to familiarize yourself with the order of service, readings, and hymns, and fill out the take action card. May God bless our time together this morning. About Our Worship The gospel is the good news about what Jesus did to be the Savior for sinners. It is also the power of God—the very thing he uses to work faith in our hearts and transform our lives. Therefore, gospel-centered worship places the gospel in central focus. This order of service is called the liturgy. In the message, in specially selected Scripture readings, and in carefully crafted songs, prayers, and creeds, the liturgy proclaims the good news about Jesus from start to finish. Gospel-centered worship is also designed to include the participation of the entire assembly (including children). For Your Convenience Restrooms are located through the doors at the rear of the building, to the right. Follow the arrows once you are in the hallway.
    [Show full text]
  • Comeback and Beyond
    Comeback & Beyond by Tim Storey Harrison House Tulsa, OK Unless otherwise indicated, all scripture quotations are taken from The Holy Bible, New International Version®. niv®. Copyright © 1973, 1978, 1984 by International Bible Society. Used by permission of Zondervan Publishing House. All rights reserved. Scripture quotations marked msg are taken from The Message New Testament With Psalms and Proverbs by Eugene H. Peterson. Copyright © 1993, 1994, 1995 by Eugene H. Peterson. NavPress, P. O. Box 35001, Colorado Springs, CO 80935. Scripture quotations marked nlt are taken from the New Living Translation, copyright © 1996, 2004 by Tyndale Charitable Trust. Used by permission of Tyndale House Publishers. Scripture quotations marked nkjv are taken from The New King James Version of the Bible. Copyright© 1979, 1980, 1982, 1983, 1984 by Thomas Nelson, Inc. Publishers. Used by permission. Scripture quotations marked kjv are taken from The King James Version of the Bible. Comeback…& Beyond ISBN 978-1-60683-118-2 Copyright © 2010 by Tim Storey 499 N. Canon Dr., Suite 400 Beverly Hills, California 90210 Published by Harrison House, Inc. P. O. Box 35035 Tulsa, Oklahoma 74153 Printed in the United States of America. All rights reserved under International Copyright Law. Contents and/or cover may not be reproduced in whole or in part in any form without the express written consent of the Publisher. Introduction Unfortunately, most people don’t know that even in their darkest hours and worst failures, God is there, rooting for them and wanting to help them. Because they either forget this or never knew this, in the midst of a setback they feel like a failure and take another step back.
    [Show full text]
  • The Human Person As an Icon of the Trinity*
    The human person as an icon Of the Trinity* KALLISTOS OF DIOKLEIA (Sobornost Vol. 8 no. 2, 1986) Batter my heart, three person‟d God John Donne ‘One-in-Three’: does it make any difference? Some twenty years ago a slim publication appeared with the title The Good Cuppa Guide. It described places, varying from the Ritz to stalls in the East End, where a satisfying cup of tea might be procured. Among other establishments the author, Jonathan Routh, visited the Surrey Room Restaurant at Waterloo Station, where at that time – now, alas, all has changed – it was possible to have tea served by a uniformed waitress at a table with a linen cloth and a linen napkin. „I was met as I entered it‟, records the author, „by a lady who asked “Are you one person?” which I found difficult to deny, so she escorted me to a table for one‟. In due course he was brought tea, toast, bread-and-butter, jam and „some slightly Fruit Cake‟. „I consumed all this while deliberating upon her original question […]. Was she in the habit of receiving visitations from persons who suddenly proclaimed that they were „Three-in-One and One-in-Three‟ and demanded bigger tables?‟1 What are we to make of Jonathan Routh‟s reflection in the Surrey Room Restaurant? „Three-in-One and One-in-Three‟: is this no more than a conundrum, a theological riddle, or does it radically affect our entire religious experience? What difference does it actually make to us as Christians that, unlike Jews and Muslims, we are not simply monotheists, nor yet are we polytheists, but we see in God both complete unity and genuine personal diversity? Commenting on the current neglect of the Trinity in the West, Karl Rahner is scarcely exaggerating when he observes: Christians, for all their orthodox profession of faith in the Trinity, are almost just „monotheist‟ in their actual religious experience.
    [Show full text]
  • Critique of Aulen's Christus Victor by GEORGE O
    Concol2()io Theological Monthly OCTOBER • 1957 A Critique of Aulen's Christus Victor By GEORGE o . EVENSON NE of the most significant theological books published in O recent decades is Christus Victor by Gustaf Aulen. In it he suggests that there are three main ideas or theories of the atonement: the classic, the Latin, and the subjective-humanistic. That which makes the book both significant and controversial is the author's contention that the authentic Scriptural doctrine of the atonement is the classic idea, that Luther was an exponent of the classic idea, and that therefore the orthodox Lutheran doctrine of the atonement differs markedly both from Scripture and from Luther. Aulen asserts that "the doctrine of Lutheranism became a very different thing from that of Luther." 1 The translator in his preface informs us that "Dr. Aulen shows how sharp is the contrast between Luther and the Lutherans" (p. ix). Hence Christus Victor faces us with an insistent challenge to seriously re-examine and re-evaluate the "traditional" Lutheran doctrine of the atonement. That the question cannot be avoided is made clear by Edgar Carlson's assertion that Aulen's view of the atone­ ment is in the main taken for granted in present-day Lundensian theology (Seminarian, pp. 36 f.). This article is only incidentally a defense of the doctrine of the vicarious satisfaction. It is primarily a criticism of the methodology and theology presented in Christus Victor. This critical position does not mean that this reviewer finds nothing to commend in the book. In it there is much for which to be thankful.
    [Show full text]
  • Teaching the Death and Resurrection of Jesus to Children
    Teaching the death and resurrection of Jesus to children Carrie Martens W hat do we believe about how Jesus died? What do we under- stand about how Christ’s death relates to our daily lives? When asking ourselves these questions, we often neglect to examine underlying presuppositions about God and Jesus that we devel- oped as children, and to consider how those assumptions influ- ence our adult understandings of the atonement. A child’s concept of the divine is formed early in life through interactions with family and environment. Our early understand- ings form the basis for future learning and are If the church is often remarkably resilient. If the church is concerned with how concerned with how adults understand the adults understand atoning work of Jesus, then we must be the atoning work of equally concerned—if not more concerned— Jesus, then we must with how Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection be equally con- are taught to and understood by children. cerned—if not more Popular theologies of the atonement, such concerned—with as Christus victor and Anselm’s satisfaction how Jesus’ life, theory (which includes the language of death, and resurrec- substitution and sacrifice), have dominated tion are taught to the theological landscape for centuries. Many and understood by contemporary theologians have pointed to children. problems in these formulations. Yet these theories remain prominent in Christian children’s materials. As we consider the impact these theories have on adult experience, we must also ask ourselves how these theories might shape a child’s understanding of God and relationship to the divine.
    [Show full text]
  • Christus Victor: Christ Our Ransom, Mediator and King
    Christus Victor: Christ our Ransom, Mediator and King December 8, 2019 Fort Langley Evangelical Free Church Christmas is the opening move in God’s invasion of a fallen world subject to sin, death and the Devil. Why the invasion of Christmas was needed: “The situation on the ground” God created this world good (Genesis 1:1-25), and created human beings “in His image” (Genesis 1:26-28). God’s image bearers rebelled against Him, and subject to sin, death, and the Devil. God made a plan: He chose Abraham and his descendants to explain his character, love and intentions and create the blueprint for what redemption requires. Then he sent his Son: “But when the fullness of time had come, God sent forth his Son, born of woman, born under the law, 5 to redeem those who were under the law, so that we might receive adoption as sons. 6 And because you are sons, God has sent the Spirit of his Son into our hearts, crying, “Abba! Father!” 7 So you are no longer a slave, but a son, and if a son, then an heir through God. Gal. 4:4-7 Why did God send his son to be born and then die on the cross? How will he liberate planet Earth? Today’s message will look at Christmas from some of the aspects of God’s amazing “secret invasion” of our world in the incarnation of His Son. 1. To Ransom us from Sin’s Penalty and Satan’s Grasp “For the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life a ransom for many.” Mark 10:45 There’s a sense then in which our rebellion has made us hostages to Satan.
    [Show full text]