-1-

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL ERNAKULAM BENCH

Review Application No.180/00012/2019 in Original Application No.180/00355/2014

Tuesday, this the 2nd day of April, 2019

C O R A M :

HON'BLE Mr.E.K.BHARAT BHUSHAN, ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER HON'BLE Mr.ASHISH KALIA, JUDICIAL MEMBER

1. Union of India represented by the General Manager, Southern Railway, Headquarters Office, Park Town PO, Chennai – 600 003.

2. The Chief Personnel Officer, Southern Railway, Headquarters Office, Park Town PO, Chennai – 600 003.

3. The Additional Divisional Railway Manager, Southern Railway, Palakkad Division, Palakkad – 678 002.

4. The Senior Divisional Personnel Officer, Southern Railway, Palakkad Division, Palakkad – 2.

5. The Divisional Personnel Officer, Southern Railway, Salem Division, Salem – 636 005. ...Review Applicants

(By Advocate: Mr.Thomas Mathew Nellimoottil)

v e r s u s

1. K. Retheesh, S/o. K. Mohandas, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot/Southern Railway/ Palakkad Railway Station, Palakkad Division. Permanent Address : Thazhathedath Aramb, Okkunu, Kacherykkunnu PO, – 673 013. -2-

2. E.K. Ajeesh, S/o. Asokan E.K., Senior Assistant Loco Pilot/Southern Railway/ Palakkad Railway Station, Palakkad Division. Permanent Address : Twins House, Keezhal PO, Vatakara, Kozhikode – 673 104.

3. N. Hareesh, S/o. Kunhan Nair T.T., Senior Assistant Loco Pilot/Southern Railway/ Palakkad Railway Station, Palakkad Division. Permanent Address : Kandlileri Jayanivas, Pantheerankave, Kozhikode – 673 019.

4. A. Subash, S/o. Arjunan K.K., Senior Assistant Loco Pilot/Southern Railway/ Palakkad Railway Station, Palakkad Division. Permanent Address : Laxmi Nivas, Parali PO, Palakkad – 678 612.

5. Jijesh Babu T.N., S/o. T.N. Chandran, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot/Southern Railway/ Palakkad Railway Station, Palakkad Division. Permanent Address : Chandini, Thachrakkal Nalukandathil, Chettikulam Elathur PO – 673 303.

6. B. Vijesh, S/o. Vijayan, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot/ Southern Railway/Calicut Railway Station. Permanent Address : V.S. Nivas, Near Edakkad Panchayat Office, Thottada, Kannur – 670 007.

7. P. Sujith, S/o. Sahadevan P., Senior Assistant Loco Pilot/Southern Railway/ Palakkad Railway Station, Palakkad Division. Permanent Address : Parambalath House, Chevayur PO, Kozhikode – 673 017.

8. Satheesh Gopi, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Shoranur Railway Station, Shoranur – 679 121.

9. Somkumar, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001. -3-

10. Praveen Sai M.P., Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001.

11. Arunlal M., Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001.

12. Roy Mathew, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

13. Shijil Elayanchery, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001.

14. Vijith Kumar T K., Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001.

15. Rajendra Kumar Meena, Loco Pilot(Goods), Southern Railway, Central Railway Station, Mangalore – 575 001.

16. Anuraj K R., Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Shoranur Junction Railway Station, Shoranur – 679 121.

17. V.S.Krishnakumar, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

18. Sreejesh Kumar N, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Mangalore Central Railway Station, Mangalore – 575 001.

19. Anoop Kumar K, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Shoranur Railway Station, Shoranur – 679 121. -4-

20. Akif Muhammed, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Shoranur Junction Railway Station, Shoranur – 679 121.

21. B.Kishor, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001.

22. C.Rajeev, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

23. Sreejith Kumar K S, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

24. Ajith S, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001.

25. Vineesh V, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

26. Sreekuttan A K, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001.

27. Praveen K G, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Shoranur Railway Station, Shoranur – 679 121.

28. Amrith T J, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001.

29. Muhammed Rafi, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

30. Vivek A C, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001. -5-

31. Roshan Xavier P A, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Shoranur Junction Railway Station, Shoranur – 679 121.

32. Shibin B K, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001.

33. Dibuchandran, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

34. Arun Sangeeth T S, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001.

35. Vimod Kumar V, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

36. Biji S, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

37. Pramod G, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Shoranur Junction Railway Station, Shoranur – 679 121.

38. Saju E S, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

39. Deepu Das D, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Shoranur Railway Station, Shoranur – 679 121.

40. Praveen M, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Shoranur Junction Railway Station, Shoranur – 679 121.

41. Ajith D S, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002. -6-

42. Harisanker M S, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001.

43. Dibin M D, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Shoranur Junction Railway Station, Shoranur – 679 121.

44. Sujin A S, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Mangalore Central Railway Station, Mangalore – 575 001.

45. Manoj M N, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

46. Aswin M V, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Calicut Railway Station, Calicut – 673 001.

47. Scaria Joseph, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

48. Jyothidas, Loco Pilot/Goods, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station,Palakkad – 678 002.

49. Syam M, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Shoranur Junction Railway Station, Shoranur – 679 121.

50. Vipin V M, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

51. Sreejith E G, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

52. Rejeesh N T, Loco Pilot/Goods, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002. -7-

53. Vishnu Das M G, Senior Assistant Loco Pilot, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

54. Desh Raj Meena, Loco Pilot(Goods), Southern Railway, Mangalore Central Railway Station, Mangalore – 575 001.

55. Anoop K A, Loco Pilot/Shunting, Southern Railway, Mangalore Junction Railway Station, Mangalore – 575 001.

56. Sreekumar K, Loco Pilot/Goods, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

57. Kana Ram Meena, Loco Pilot/Goods, Southern Railway, Mangalore Central Railway Station, Mangalore – 575 001.

58. Roop Singh Meena, Loco Pilot/Goods, Southern Railway, Mangalore Central Railway Station, Mangalore – 575 001.

59. Ram Khiladi Pareva, Loco Pilot(Goods), Southern Railway, Mangalore Central Railway Station, Mangalore – 575 001.

60. Lavkesh Kumar Meena, Loco Pilot/Goods, Southern Railway, Mangalore Central Railway Station, Mangalore – 575 001.

61. Jadunath Mandal, Loco Pilot/Goods, Southern Railway, Mangalore Central Railway Station, Mangalore – 575 001.

62. Anoop Kumar K, Loco Pilot/Goods, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002. -8-

63. Aneesh A O, Loco Pilot/Goods, Southern Railway, Palakkad Junction Railway Station, Palakkad – 678 002.

64. Harkesh Meena, Loco Pilot/Goods, Southern Railway, Mangalore Central Railway Station, Mangalore – 575 001. ...Review Respondents

(By Advocate : Mr.T.C.Govindaswamy [R1-7])

This RA having been heard on 2nd April, 2019 the Tribunal on the same day delivered the following :

O R D E R (O R A L)

Per : Mr.E.K.BHARAT BHUSHAN, ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER

There is no provision to condone the delay in filing the R.A beyond

30 days. Accordingly, the R.A and M.A.No.180/320/2019 to condone the delay in filing the R.A are dismissed.

(Dated this the 2nd day of April 2019)

ASHISH KALIA E.K.BHARAT BHUSHAN JUDICIAL MEMBER ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER

asp -9-

List of Annexures in R.A.No.180/12/2019 in O.A.No.180/355/2014 1. Annexure RA-1 – True copy of the order dated 11.12.2018 of this Hon'ble Tribunal in O.A.No.180/00355/2014.

2. Annexure RA-2 – True copy of the order dated 26.9.2018 of this Hon'ble Tribunal in O.A.No.180/1053/2017.

3. Annexure RA-3 – True copy of the interim order dated 21.9.2015 in SLP (CC) No.17238/2015.

4. Annexure RA-4 – True copy of the interim order dated 28.11.2014 in SLP (CC) No.18781/2014. ______