HALLOWEEN OBSESSION Inside Kevin Ryan’s big CRAIN’S® bash P. 29 NEW YORK BUSINESS
VOL. XXVIII, NO. 43 WWW.CRAINSNEWYORK.COM OCTOBER 22-28, 2012 PRICE: $3.00
AN IPO EYEFUL Citi seen Shutterstock shares were up some 35% in their first seven days of trading. sounding $25 $24.36 10/18 retreat in $23.04 $23.08 $23.00 $22.95 10/17 10/15 10/16 10/19 the city $22.00 $21.66 10/12 10/11 close New CEO is likely
$20 to further shrink what used to be the largest employer in town
BY AARON ELSTEIN $17.00 PICTURE PERFECT: 10/11 Shutterstock CEO Jon Oringer opening paid close attention to the Citigroup Inc.’s long reign as New IPO’s every detail. A strong York’s largest private-sector employer balance sheet also helped. ended with a resounding thud during the Great Recession. Since then, Citi $15 has sacked a third of its local workforce. Source: Bloomberg News Now the new regime that took over last week is poised to go even further. Analysts expect the new team, led by Chairman Michael O’Neill and Chief Executive Michael Corbat, to move quickly to cut costs.That means taking a meat-ax to slow-growing, thin-margin lines of business, such as trading and branch banking—both of which are centered in New York City. The bank’s focus and its money will See CITI on Page 28 Shutterstock! Marathon The first NY tech IPO in years was a quiet smash. What hit with big Jon Oringer can teach Mark Zuckerberg about going public cop fees
BY MATTHEW FLAMM since 2010. week was trading at 20% above its of- The company, which sells stock fering price, according to Renais- City to quadruple Sometimes it pays to be ignored. photos online, also happened to have sance Capital. race’s 2013 traffic, Shutterstock Inc., unlike some of its one of the more successful initial The little-known Shutterstock Silicon Alley peers, had never been the public offerings in recent years. Its now has a market cap valued at more clean-up bill to $3M subject of frequent speculation about stock closed Friday at $23—35% than $750 million. its IPO plans. But on Oct. 11, it flew above its $17 offering price.That put The event was a far cry from Face- BY LISA FICKENSCHER in under the radar to become the first it leaps and bounds ahead of the av- book’s IPO meltdown in May, where New York City tech firm to go public erage U.S. IPO this year, which last See SHUTTERSTOCK on Page 25 For the first time in the ING New York City Marathon’s 43-year history, the city will present the event’s organ-
buck ennis izers with a multimillion-dollar bill to pay for the hundreds of workers who will control traffic, keep order and REPORT REAL ESTATE clean the city streets on Nov. 4. Park designers ride high, thanks to $1.5B The tab for police officers alone is expected to surge beyond $1 million— spent by the city on new greens P. 15 from zero in years past. “No question, this is a challenge for THE LIST Largest construction firms P. 19 us,” said Mary Wittenberg, CEO of NEWSPAPER See MARATHON on Page 27 STATS AND THE CITY
FRIGHT NIGHT EXPOSED It’s not just the city’s stoplight cameras prompting screams this time of year. Halloween is drawing near, and cash registers are ringing. FYICRAINSNEWYORK.COM 693K Pumpkins harvested in NYS in 2011, with value of $23.6 million, the highest in the U.S. NY shines in 60K+ Costumed revelers slated to walk in the 39th political limelight annual Village Halloween Parade s a longtime gimme for the Democrats, New
33 newscom Giant Captain America shields sold York state almost never by Abracadabra costume shop in A the first few weeks of the season experiences what happened last week—several days in which it basked front and center in the political limelight. It all began with VP candidate Paul Ryan attending an event at the Intrepid 1,564 Sea, Air and Space Museum featuring dozens of prominent Republican officials—and an angry Number of U.S. candy manufacturers, mob of protesters. for whom Halloween is huge, in 2010 On Tuesday, the focus shifted out to Long Island for the show of shows, the superheated 24.7 debate between President Barack Obama and former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney at Hofstra Pounds of candy consumed by the average University. Afterward, people differed as to who had scored more body blows, but everyone American in 2010 agreed on one thing: The event, with questions delivered by members of the audience, was a total Sources: U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, U.S. Census Bureau, Abracadabra and Village Halloween Parade winner in exposing the rest of the nation to the wonders of genuine LawnGuyland accents. istockphoto CASHING IN ON CLICKS At the end of the week, the candidates reunited—in white tie and tails—at the Waldorf- Internet ad revenue set fresh records in the first half of 2012, rising 14% Astoria for the 67th annual Alfred E. Smith Dinner, the Catholic archdiocese’s largest year-over-year. fundraiser of the year. Mr. Obama was the first sitting president to attend the dinner since Ronald Reagan in 1984. $20,000 Revenue in millions That came on the heels of what was billed as a three-day retreat for Romney campaign donors at 15,000 the Waldorf.There was no word on how much it raised. But in the coming weeks, the New York 10,000 Andrew Cuomo 5,000 show will roll on. Gov. has been tapped to stump the nation for his party. 0 —andrew j. hawkins 1H 1H 1H 1996 2004 2012 STOP-AND-FRISK’S COURT DATE. The projects like roof repairs to create Sources: Interactive Advertising Bureau and PricewaterhouseCoopers NYPD’s controversial stop-and- jobs and take advantage of cheap fi- HOORAY! frisk practice is getting its day in U.S. nancing costs. … NEWSWEEK TURNS THE RAINBOW ROOM, Rock Center’s ADDICTED TO NUMBERS? GET A DAILY DOSE AT @STATSANDTHECITY court. For the first time, a federal THE PAGE. After nearly eight legendary party venue, is officially a city judge in Manhattan is hearing testi- decades, Newsweek will finally close landmark. mony on whether NYPD tactics, in- the book on its print publication at THIS WEEK IN CRAIN’S cluding stopping people on the street year’s end. With circulation down and arresting others for trespassing and financial losses up, the long- in residential buildings, violate con- fading title will morph into an all- IN THE BOROUGHS------3 stitutional protections.The hearings digital publication called IN THE MARKETS------4 are expected to run for two weeks. Newsweek Global in 2013. In the THE INSIDER ------6 Among others eagerly awaiting the process, further cuts in staffing will outcome will be Mayor Michael be made. Newsweek’s announce- CORPORATE LADDER------10 Bloomberg, who has fully backed ment comes just a few months after A BOUNCE IN OPINION ------12 stop-and-frisk. ... SmartMoney announced it would go OY VEY! BUILDING. Surprise, surprise: After paperless. … STYLISH EATS FOR GREG DAVID------13 HARLEM. THE YANKEES blew their American many quarters of The news is League Championship Series with four REPORT: REAL ESTATE------15 nothing but bad out: Come the sum- straight losses. news, things are ‘I would not mer of 2015, REAL ESTATE DEALS------18 looking up for even Harlemites will be THE LIST ------19 builders. Construc- able to pick up or- tion in the city is ex- consider— ganic quinoa, arti- DIGITAL NEW YORK------21 pected to top out at even sanal cheeses and CLASSIFIEDS ------22 more than $30 bil- more from a Whole BUSINESS PEOPLE lion worth this year, consider—a Foods on West 125th FOR THE RECORD------David Paterson’s radio show 24 the most since 2008. Street and Lenox has kept the former governor NEW YORK, NEW YORK ------29 Major expansions pay raise’ Avenue. The high- in the public domain since ongoing at several Gov. Andrew Cuomo, end chain has an- SOURCE BREAKFAST------30 leaving Albany two years ago. colleges are helping explaining that until nounced it’s staked opment at the old Domino refinery P. 8 But will WOR keep him? OUT AND ABOUT ------31 and will likely push legislators get busy and out a place in a yet- on the Williamsburg waterfront are pass key reform legislation, CORRECTIONS the needle over $30 to-rise building back on the burner. Dumbo-based billion next year as all raises for lawmakers there,as well as a spot Two Trees has paid $185 million for Anupam Singhal and Nishant Mittal were investor colleagues before co-founding data well. The city will do will be off the table down on East 87th the long-stalled 11-acre site, but it analytics company Monaeo. Their previous connection was incorrectly characterized in the Oct. 8 “The App for the 1%.” its part, too. The Street and Third Av- has also hinted that it may want to mayor,along with Comptroller John enue, due to open in 2014—upping talk to local leaders about amending David Szuchman worked at the Manhattan district attorney’s office from 1997 to 2001 and was then rehired in 2010. Mr. Szuchman worked on a case in which nonprofit Liu, announced plans to push for- its Manhattan outposts to nine. ... the earlier plans. That could mean employees were stealing donors’ personal information to sell to local gangs. His dates ward $1 billion in spending for what REFINING DOMINO. Plans for a big delays, if nothing else. of employment at the D.A.’s office were misstated in the Oct. 8 “Mr. Paranoia.” The Hizzoner called “unglamorous” residential/commercial/retail devel- —lauren elkies story also misstated which suspects were selling information to local gangs. Michael Jaffe, a member of the New York State Trial Lawyers Association, was named president of the organization. His membership status was mischaracterized in the Oct. 8 Executive Moves. STORIES TO WATCH THIS WEEK vol. xxviii, no. 43, october 22, 2012—Crain’s New York Business (issn 8756-789x) is published weekly, except for double issues the weeks of July Fourth, Labor Day and Christmas, by Crain Communications Inc., 711 Third Ave., New York, NY 10017. Periodicals postage paid at Oct. 22: Confes- Oct. 24: Insider Oct. 26 and 27: Oct. 28: Crown New York, N.Y., and additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Send address changes to: Crain’s sional book Why trader Rajat Gupta WhiskeyFest opens of the Statue of New York Business, Circulation Department, 1155 Gratiot Avenue, Detroit, MI 48207-2912. for subscriber service: Call (877) 824-9379. Fax (313) 446-6777.$3.00 a copy, $99.95 one I Left Goldman sentenced in NY with bevy of Liberty reopens year, $179.95 two years. (GST No. 13676-0444-RT) ©Entire contents copyright 2012 by Crain Communications Inc. All rights reserved. Sachs is released. federal court. distillers and to the public. master blenders.
2 | Crain’s New York Business | October 22, 2012 IN THE BOROUGHS BRONX
LEAP OF FAITH: Yvette Campbell has run Harlem School of the Arts since 2011. Among her Shops rise tough calls was cutting the budget by 24%. from ashes of big fires Merchants return to fill in blanks, reknit Norwood’s fabric
BY HILARY POTKEWITZ
Three years after a pair of suspicious fires devastated a portion of a busy retail strip in the Norwood section of the Bronx, bulldozers have final- ly lumbered onto the site to begin filling in the last portion of the gap left by the tragedy.Their arrival sig- nals the beginning of the end of the predominantly working-class neighborhood’s struggle to knit it- self back together. A single-story commercial struc- ture boasting about 8,000 square feet of retail space—designed to ac- commodate up to a half-dozen stores—will rise Miracle on 141st Street on the site, ac- ODDS cording to plans buck ennis filed with the & ENDS Department of Up in the Bronx She added a preschool program to increase rev- Buildings. How a $5 million grant and savvy management enue. And she just lured noted dancer Twyla Though the Tharp and Grammy-winning Afro-Latin-jazz building will be 40 got Harlem School of the Arts back on its feet musician Arturo O’Farrill to become artists in a far cry from the FIRE STATIONS residence,which should raise the school’s profile. mega-malls forced to close for three weeks. She’s also negotiating with jazz great Wynton transforming 5,600 BY THERESA AGOVINO “I can really think about the future,” said Marsalis, already an adviser, to play a greater role other sections of STRUCTURAL Yvette Campbell, who has been president and in the institution. the city, it will FIRES in 2011 The Harlem School of the Arts must be the envy chief executive of the 48-year-old institution Her biggest problem, however, was paying have an outsize of many a nonprofit these days: All its debt, in- since January 2011. “We wouldn’t have survived $400,000 a year in debt.Few donors make grants impact on Bain- cluding its mortgage, was paid off—and its en- carrying our debt.” to repay loans; they prefer to support program- bridge Avenue. 38,325 HISPANIC- dowment was restored and even expanded— A donation from the same foundation in ming. But when Ms. Campbell explained her “When peo- OWNED thanks to a $5 million donation received last 2010 helped keep the doors open, but Ms. dilemma this summer to a meeting of donor- ple see that con- businesses month from the Herb Alpert Foundation. Campbell toiled mightily to prove the school was group executives, Rona Sebastian, president of struction is hap- Sources: NYC Fire Dept., Now the community school, which provides worthy of continued, and more generous, sup- the Herb Alpert Foundation, decided to break pening, it will Center for an Urban Future programs in dance, music, theater and the visual port. Ms. Campbell sliced $1.1 million, or 24%, the mold. give them a arts, is starting with a clean slate after surviving from the budget through such efforts as cutting “In this situation,it just made sense,”said Ms. sense of hope,” said Michael Lam- a brush with extinction in 2010, when it was staff by 68% and renegotiating service contracts. See MIRACLE on Page 28 bert,deputy director of the Mosholu Preservation Corp. He noted that the 2009 fires incinerated more than a dozen much-loved businesses— including a supermarket, a butcher, a baker, a cobbler, a beauty salon, a A perk the boss can’t afford diner and a Mexican restaurant— that together were key to what makes a neighborhood a neighbor- by about 50% since 2008, to I would.” hood. “Anything they can do to City Council wants to give $500,000 annually.To survive the re- ‘Doing As debate about the legislation bring back a sense of what existed small-biz workers paid time cession, Ms. Zayer’s business has re- continues, many small business before, people will be very excited quired single-minded devotion, and business in owners face a similar, ironic reality. about.” off—a benefit some of their the dedication of her 11 employees. NYC is If it passes, they will be forced to Daniel Katz,who signed a master employers can rarely take Yet despite razor-thin margins, provide time off that the rigors of lease on the property earlier this year, she has continued to offer health care onerous entrepreneurial life don’t allow is keen to deliver on that promise. benefits and profit sharing. Now, them to take themselves. For some “We saw an opportunity to recon- BY EILENE ZIMMERMAN with business finally starting to pick enough’ owners,taking a day off is unafford- struct and put in local businesses,” he up, Ms. Zayer faces another hurdle: able. For others, who are entwined said, adding that the new building Doreen Zayer, who has owned a Staten Island the Paid Sick Days Act,which would in virtually every aspect of their will have “a really beautiful, up-to- spa for 17 years, can’t remember the last time she require small businesses like hers to company’s operations, it’s hard to date look” by the time it is completed took a sick day. In fact, pregnant with her son give employees at least five days off find a substitute—to the extent that early next year.The first shops should shortly after starting the business, “I worked on per year. some find themselves working in situations that then open in the spring. my due date,” she recalled. “I wish I could pay my employees when they corporate counterparts might find unimaginable. “It’s an important corner, and it’s The past few years have been especially are sick,” said Ms. Zayer.“I really want to do the The Paid Sick Days Act, which is being unattractive to have a vacant lot stressful at Relax on Cloud 9. Sales have dipped best for them, and if I could afford it, believe me, See A PERK on Page 27 See RISING on Page 26
October 22, 2012 | Crain’s New York Business | 3 IN THE Food trucks nab midtown spot MARKETS by Aaron Elstein Operators get break where tenants can ment opened up an even order lunch empty lot in Long from parking tix; from them. flickr Island City,Queens, office workers gain Starting Oct. for food trucks. There 29, the location will accommodate are two other locations in the city, Astoria bank tries lunch choices one truck a day, including Eddie’s next to Bryant Park and in Hudson Pizza, Luke’s Lobster, Comme Çi Square in lower Manhattan,that of- Comme Ça and Frites ‘N’ Meats, fer seasonal spots for such vendors. BY LISA FICKENSCHER to forge new path which will be there from 11 a.m. to “This is a strategy that is work- 2:30 p.m. on weekdays. ing in Boston, Chicago and Wash- Midtown office workers will get 10 The initiative is part of a larger ington, D.C., where the local gov- storia Federal Savings new lunch options later this month trend in which major landlords in the ernments are devoting public space when 777 Third Ave., at East 48th city are leasing space to food trucks. for food trucks, and in New York is the kind of bank Street, opens up its loading dock to And it’s a welcome change for the City the private sector is helping us most folks would say a group of food truck operators. truck owners, who are often chased set up permanent spots,” said David A they want to see succeed. “Food trucks are a new amenity out of spots by competitors or ticket- Weber, president of the NYC Food in the city that we wanted to offer to ed by the city for illegal parking. Truck Association, which facilitat- The institution has been our tenants and to the greater com- “This allows us to have more se- ed the Third Avenue deal. serving New Yorkers since munity in Turtle Bay,”said Jonathan curity,so that we don’t have to move The number of food trucks in the 1888 and has a homespun Iger, vice president of Sage Realty in the middle of lunch or worry city has grown tremendously,from a charm that comes Corp., which manages the building about getting a ticket,” said David handful several years ago to as many
from sponsoring news daily new york and two others nearby. Schillace, owner of the Mexicue as 90 today,according to Mr.Weber. / Sage Realty is rolling out the red truck, which is among the those Still, Mr. Schillace, who owns events like an annual carpet for its new mobile tenants, vending at 777 Third Ave. two Mexicue restaurants,cites com- essay contest in which promoting them in its buildings, Earlier this year, Brookfield petition and a lack of available loca- children complete a CEO MONTE REDMAN and setting up a food truck camera Properties set up a food truck lot at tions as reasons that he has not in- may be forced to sell. so that office workers can gauge the 4 World Trade Center, where five vested in more than one truck. “We statement that begins, egan-chin debbie lines. Sage is also including a page trucks can park during the week, look at the truck as a marketing tool “If I save a lot today, in Ⅲ ASTORIA FINANCIAL about the trucks on its website, while last year Rockrose Develop- to promote our brand,” he said. the future I could …” CORP.’S STOCK PRICE, MONTHLY But Astoria, like a lot of small banks, is stuck between a rock and OCTOBER 2012 a hard place.The sluggish economy and ultralow interest rates make it tough for the $17 billion-in-assets institution to grow.Its core residen- Carmel Partners is pleased tial mortgage business faces pres- sure as it fights with government- to announce the final closing owned giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac for home-loan volume. Plus, of its fourth investment fund there are millions in new compli- ance costs,and Astoria’s shares have returned just 2% over the past three years, compared with 14% for its peer group. has identified thousands of small CARMEL PARTNERS Chief Executive Monte Redman, businesses on Long Island that his INVESTMENT FUND IV who has worked at Astoria since bank could serve, “what you see 1977 and took the helm last year, is these days is that businesses are not doing his best with a tough hand.He looking for loans,” he said. $ cut about 10% of the bank’s staff and An economic recovery would 820,000,000 slashed its dividend payout by 69% to certainly help on that front,and Mr. conserve cash.He’s also put a big em- Redman said prices have stabilized phasis on expanding the bank’s book in the Long Island housing market of small business and apartment after a painful slump. But small loans—a major shift for a thrift that’s business owners still fret over eco- Targeting a raise of $700 million, Carmel’s Fund IV reached long specialized in basic checking nomic and election uncertainties. its hard cap of $820 million. Carmel invests in multifamily and savings services for Queens and Or, as Mr. Redman puts it: “They Long Island homeowners. look at the what-ifs.” value-add, development and debt opportunities with compelling “This is a year of transition,”said Another bank that faced the risk-adjusted returns in high barrier markets throughout the US. Mr. Redman, who is 61. same sort of squeeze, Hudson City He’s encouraged by the results Savings, threw in the towel in Au- so far. Small business and apart- gust and agreed to be acquired by ment loan volumes are ahead of his M&T Bank. projections and make up about 22% Mr. Redman believes Astoria is of the bank’s loan portfolio, a figure well positioned to thrive once the he’d like to increase to 40%. That economy revives and business lend- growth helped the bank report ing picks up again. He even antici- third-quarter earnings of $13 mil- pates acquiring a few small banks lion, a 20% bump from the year- that can’t cope with all the new reg- earlier period. ulatory costs.“I think in a few years REALIZING THE POTENTIAL OF REAL ESTATE Still, powerful headwinds re- you’ll see a lot of good, smaller main. Although earnings grew, the banks overloaded by compliance www.carmelpartners.com bank’s loan portfolio continues to costs raise their hands,” he said. shrink as low interest rates drive The question is whether Mr. SAN FRANCISCO | DENVER | IRVINE | SEATTLE consumers to refinance their mort- Redman’s shareholders will wait that WASHINGTON, DC | HONOLULU | NEW YORK gages. And though Mr. Redman long before forcing him to sell. Ⅲ
SIZE OF THE U.S. government’s remaining stake in bailed-out insurer American International 16% Group. AIG Chief Executive Robert Benmosche (left) said last week that the feds may THIS APPEARS AS A MATTER OF RECORD ONLY sell the rest of it by year’s end. At one point, the government owned 92% of AIG’s stock.
4 | Crain’s New York Business | October 22, 2012 DON’T SETTLE.
VERIZON PUSH TO TALK OFFERS:
SWITCH TO FIND OUT WHY MORE PEOPLE CHOOSE AND STAY WITH VERIZON.
Visit any Verizon Wireless store today to 1.800.VZW.4BIZ(4249) talk about our Small Business solutions. verizonwireless.com/ptt
Push to Talk is available only with other Verizon Wireless Push to Talk customers. Largest claim based on comparison of carriers’ owned/operated networks. Network details & coverage maps at vzw.com. © 2012 Verizon Wireless. F4720 THE As pols play musical chairs, INSIDER consultants become the piper by Andrew J. Hawkins and Chris Bragg
ness note that quality can vary. differently, too. Many still special- Term limits, public “There’s a lot more people out ize in media relations or strategy. financing spark there who think they are consult- But down-ballot candidates may ants,” said the salty Democratic prefer full-service firms for a less demand and dollars strategist Hank Sheinkopf. expensive one-stop-shopping ex- for campaign pros Twenty years ago,Mr.Sheinkopf perience.And firm principals often was part of a select group of politi- register as lobbyists to maximize cal mavens, including David Garth, profits. BY ANDREW J. HAWKINS Hank Morris and Philip Friedman, who cornered the market. Each of- The Beltway model Election Day is nearly at hand, but “It’s a model that was widespread the city’s political consultants al- in Washington and came to New ready have dollar signs in their eyes Pay to sway: York about 10 years ago,” said Evan for 2013. Term-limit turnover has Stavisky,co-founder of the Parkside newscom spawned competitive elections next direct mail, Group, which offers direct mail, year for all three citywide offices— public relations, lobbying and cam- Life after Bloomberg stirs worries mayor, comptroller, public advo- polling, robo paign management. “Good firms cate—as well as for four of the five are going to have multiple practice he head of the city’s health care system said last week borough president posts, two dis- calls, Twitter areas.” that while the candidates for mayor in 2013 are trict attorney offices and about 25 Mark Guma, a consultant who generally strong supporters of the public hospitals, City Council seats. specializes in strategy, direct mail T Not since 2001, when pols first and advertising,said one-stop shops he worries that the protection from political interference the vacated their long-held seats, have are especially attractive to midsize system now enjoys could erode when Mayor Michael there been so many elections—or as fered specialized services—direct campaigns, such as City Council Bloomberg’s term ends. big a business opportunity for the mail, television and radio spots, bids.A recent trend has seen consul- industry that endeavors to shape print advertising and strategy. Mr. tancies consolidating their televi- “Our current mayor has managed to filter out some of them. Sheinkopf is still going strong, but sion and direct-mail services. the stakeholder influence,” said Alan Aviles (above), Mr. Garth has since retired, Mr. “You have a consultant that president and chief executive of the Health and Hospitals Pinstripes and hoodies Morris is in jail for accepting kick- doesn’t really have a vested interest in Consulting firms are scrambling backs, and Mr. Friedman commit- advocating for one medium versus Corp., answering a question at a Citizens Budget to scoop up clients as their business ted suicide in 2005. another,” he said.“So you get, in the- Commission forum. “We make decisions based on the undergoes its own upheaval.Besides The new generation of consult- ory, better decisions about where to facts. That could potentially change.” term limits, public funding of cam- ants runs the gamut. Most have of- spend what are usually scarce adver- paigns has helped finance a cottage fices near City Hall, but some are tising resources.” Mr. Aviles, whose 12-year is also known for its quality food industry of consultants. The emer- based in the outer boroughs. Some Others dismiss the full-service tenure at HHC dates back to the and short distance from New York gence of corporate clients has wear pinstripes and wingtips, oth- model, noting that polling firms Giuliani administration, did not City. Mr. Kruger is there serving sparked its professionalization, ers hoodies and high-tops. The rarely do media relations, or vice name names.The leading mayoral seven years—a term 28 times though some veterans of the busi- firms themselves are structured See CONSULTANTS on Page 27 contenders are all Democrats. longer than Mr. Lipsky’s. The sprawling system, with 37,000 employees and a $6.7 billion budget, is a juicy target for Truth in labor unions, consulting firms and advertising other politically connected constituencies. It includes 11 Scrambling to fend off a acute-care facilities, four nursing Republican challenge to his state homes, six large diagnostic and Senate seat in eastern Queens, treatment centers and more than Democrat Joseph Addabbo bought a 70 community-based clinics. full-page ad last week in a local Jewish paper touting his accomplishments—led by his 2011 Lobbyist’s “removal of the [Metropolitan ‘sweet’ deal Transportation Authority] payroll tax for private First, lobbyist Richard Lipsky schools and received a mere three-month yeshivas.” sentence for paying up to Unmentioned $200,000 in bribes to ex-state Sen. was Mr. Carl Kruger of Brooklyn. Now Mr. Addabbo’s crucial Lipsky will get to spend his short vote to pass the stint in the cushiest federal prison Joseph Addabbo 2009 MTA in New York—which happens to funding bill that be Mr. Kruger’s new home. included that tax. Last year, as Mr. Lipsky, whose “substantial part of an agreement spearheaded cooperation” led prosecutors to by Gov. Andrew Cuomo that push for the lenient sentence, had restructured the state’s tax code, a judge recommend that he go to private schools and yeshivas were Otisville, a haven for white-collar exempted from the tax, which was criminals that has been listed by highly unpopular in the Orthodox Forbes as one of the “12 Best Jewish community—a key voting Places to Go to Prison.” bloc in Mr. Addabbo’s race “You could do about anything against Councilman Eric Ulrich. you wanted there,” former inmate A spokeswoman for Mr. John Altman told the New York Post Addabbo said, “There was a time earlier this year. “It’s not just when more taxes were really good. It’s sweet. That’s why you needed, but Joe also supported the request to go there.” removal of the MTA payroll tax The prison, in Orange County, for private schools and yeshivas.” Ⅲ
Crain’s Insider, our award-winning politics newsletter, is now a blog. Read it every day at www.crainsnewyork.com/insider
6 | Crain’s New York Business | October 22, 2012 Commercial Banking Group
There’s no substitute for experience. At Capital One Bank®, we make it our business to work alongside companies like yours every day. Backed by the strength of a top-10 U.S. bank, we’ve got the industry experience to help give your business a lift.
Ellen Marshall, Commercial Banking Executive [email protected], (212) 764-8315
Products and services offered by Capital One, N.A., Member FDIC. © 2012 Capital One. Capital One is a federally registered service mark. All rights reserved. BUSINESS 19% of North American employees regularly break for lunch PEOPLE Source: Right Management
EXECUTIVE MOVES ON THE DIAL: David Paterson, the afternoon Financo Inc.: John A. host on WOR, gravitated Berg, 50, joined the to radio as a child after investment-banking losing much of his sight. boutique as chief executive. He was previously general partner at Weston Presidio Capital. Bret Lowry, 38, joined as vice president. He was previously vice president at Bank of America Merrill Lynch. Colin O’Neil, 36, joined as vice president. He was previously vice president at Raymond James. Citigroup Inc.: Michael Corbat, 52, was promoted to chief executive. He was previously chief executive for Europe, the Middle East and Africa. IntraLinks Holdings Inc.: Derek Irwin, 45, joined the technology provider as chief financial officer. He was previously chief financial officer at DoubleVerify. Marie Claire: Anne Fulenwider, 40, joined as editor in chief of the U.S. edition of the Hearst Magazines publication. She was previously editor in chief of Brides. American Express Publishing Corp.: Sean Murphy, 48, was promoted to vice president, custom media. He was previously director of content for custom media. Malkin Holdings: Christina Capowich, 30, joined the real estate company as director of marketing. She was previously communications buck ennis and media manager at CBRE. GOTHAM GIGS Weill Cornell Medical College: Dr. Carla Boutin-Foster, 43, was appointed assistant dean for faculty diversity at the school’s Office of Faculty Diversity in Medicine and Science. She will continue as associate professor of medicine in the division It’s the David Paterson show of general internal medicine, public health, and complementary and integrative medicine. The former guv reinvented himself on radio. But will WOR keep him? Dr. Rache M. Simmons, 50, was appointed assistant dean for faculty diversity at the school’s Office of David Paterson prefers a dimly lit radio studio in radio and as chairman of Icon Group Faculty Diversity in Medicine and Science. She will continue as the Anne ‘I wake up Manhattan’s financial district to the opulent Compliance Services than the $179,000 he made K. and Edwin C. Weiskopf professor governor’s suite in the state Capitol.The reason as governor. As a child, he gravitated to radio of surgical oncology and professor of in the surgery. is simple. He no longer has to deal with warring after losing much of his sight. “I had a friend who Loews Hotels & Resorts: Elizabeth morning, politicians, fiscal crises and pesky reporters. “I lived down the block from me,” he said. “I would Harlow, 42, joined as vice president, wake up in the morning, everything is not my be the host and he would be the guests.” ¶ His marketing. She was previously senior everything director of brand marketing for The fault,” said the state’s first African-American program launched in September 2011, but its Leading Hotels of the World. is not my governor. “I feel a lot better about things.” ¶ future is uncertain. WOR’s owners are selling the CNBC.com: Xana Antunes joined as Following the country’s financial meltdown in station to Clear Channel—the nation’s largest executive digital fault’ late 2008, Albany faced a $21 billion budget station owner. ¶ The former governor’s fallback editor and vice president. She was deficit. When Mr. Paterson took unpopular steps position is growing his construction consulting previously editor of to close the gap, “liberals and conservatives alike business, launched in August with friend Brian Crain’s New York found something they finally agreed with—they Aryai. ¶ Mr. Paterson employed a driver until he Business. TD Bank: Deney S. couldn’t stand me,” he said. He also had to deal became an unpaid MTA board member. Now Chau, 51, was promoted to senior vice with fallout from a coup that roiled state Senate commuters are shocked to see him on the president and commercial team leader in health care financial services. He Democrats, and an investigation into his office’s subway.“I’ve gotten on the train and had to line was previously vice president and handling of domestic-abuse allegations against passengers up so that they could take pictures senior lender in health care financial services. an aide. ¶ These days, Mr. Paterson, 58, makes with me,” he said. “It’s a lot of fun.” Emily N. Swan, 27, was promoted to more money as the afternoon host on WOR —don mathisen See EXECUTIVE MOVES on Page 10
8 | Crain’s New York Business | October 22, 2012 Neighborhood { find }
World-class care is now right around the corner from where you live and work. NYU Langone Medical Center’s expanding footprint offers convenient access to all your healthcare needs, from routine office visits to outpatient surgery and specialized testing. To find a multi-specialty group practice in your neighborhood, or to see a full list of our group practices, visit www.NYULMC.org.
Joan H. Tisch Center for Women’s Health | Upper East Side 646.754.3300 Continued from Page 8 commercial portfolio loan officer in CFO TO HELP VILLAGECARE EMBRACE HEALTH REFORMS health care finance. She was previously a credit analyst. VILLAGECARE , one of the city’s oldest health care nonprofits serving the elderly and those with HIV/AIDS, is adapting Valley National Bank: Andrew Hulse, 61, to changes in how it pays doctors by becoming a managed long-term care provider as well as a traditional service was promoted to first vice president and provider. “We want to keep providing the communities we serve with the same care, but we needed to bring New York health care financial services mandated-care expertise in-house,” said President and Chief Executive Emma DeVito. team leader. He was previously vice Rachel Amalfitano, 39, VillageCare’s new chief of finance, will be charged with equipping the Greenwich president. Village-based health care provider with new capabilities. She was formerly finance chief and executive vice Thor High Street president at American Medical and Life Insurance Co. Advisors: Matthew A. Ms. Amalfitano will be responsible for all finance management, information technology and health care reform Seigel, 32, joined the compliance. real estate firm as She was hired because she has both financial acumen and experience leading a managed-care executive vice program, and can help VillageCare maintain the quality of its medical services as it adds health plan president. He was features, according to Ms. DeVito. “If we can’t do something for our client,” she said, “we will find a way to previously senior connect them with someone who can.” —eva saviano director at Cushman & Wakefield. Thornton Tomasetti: Michael Pagano, 52, joined the engineering services firm as vice president. He was previously senior project engineer at Pfizer Pharmaceuticals. John T. Boyer, 49, joined as vice president. He was previously vice president and director of design at The Boyer Partnership. WABC-TV: Camille Edwards, 45, joined the television station as vice president of news. She was previously vice president of news at WRC-TV in Washington, D.C. Real Data Management: Blake Grosch, 32, was promoted to vice president of sales and marketing at the real estate services and software company. He was previously director of sales and marketing. EngageSciences: Rich Gascoyne, 46, joined the social media marketing company as general manager, Americas, a newly created position. He was previously strategic accounts executive at OpenText. HealthGuru: Chris Cooke, 27, joined the health information video production company as advertising operations manager. He was previously digital media planner at Footsteps Group/Omnicom. Richard Stora, 33, joined as advertising operations manager. He was previously quality assurance specialist in digital sales at NBCUniversal. You expect an expert Rose Associates Inc.: William S. Bergman, 36, was promoted to in Cash Management, commercial leasing manager at the real estate firm. He was Risk Management and, previously commercial leasing coordinator. LaVon Napoli, 36, was of course, Relationship hired as manager of residential marketing. Management. She was previously senior vice president at Sherman Advertising Associates. That’s Key. We have experts in every aspect of Western Façades: Michael C. Radigan, financial services. Starting with the relationship. 54, was promoted to senior operations manager at the construction company, a We are KeyBank. Our Relationship Managers help newly created position. He was you access a team of senior level specialists to previously senior project executive. assist you with any financial need. CNA Financial Corp.: Cheryl Paton, 54, joined the insurance company as We are also KeyBanc Capital Markets Inc., a full assistant vice president for Umbrella. service corporate and investment bank. So when She was previously vice president, excess your financial needs become more sophisticated, casualty, at Navigators Management Co. like maximizing liquidity or managing risk, we have Troutman Sanders: Hiroyuki Yasuda, 50, the expertise to help you succeed. joined as of counsel. He was previously of counsel at McDermott Will & Emery. We’re not just the expert you deserve. Nicole R. Sullivan, 39, joined as a patent agent. She was previously a patent agent We’re what you expect. at McDermott Will & Emery. Axinn Veltrop & Harkrider: Donald W. To learn more, visit key.com/whatyouexpect. Hawthorne, 52, joined the law firm as partner in its litigation and regulatory group and chair of its practice in the areas of structured finance, derivatives and mortgage crisis litigation. He was KeyBanc Capital Markets Inc., Member NYSE/FINRA/SIPC and KeyBank National Association (KeyBank N.A.) are separate but affiliated companies. previously counsel at Debevoise & Securities products and services are offered by KeyBanc Capital Markets Inc. and its licensed securities representatives. Plimpton. Securities products and services: EXECUTIVE PROMOTIONS Banking products and services are offered by KeyBank N.A. Member FDIC and Equal Housing Lender. The fastest way to get an announcement into Key.com is a federally registered service mark of KeyCorp. ©2012 KeyCorp. ADL4779 Crain’s is to submit online. Fill out the form at www.crainsnewyork.com/section/ executive_moves. The Executive Moves column is also available online. 10 | Crain’s New York Business | October 22, 2012 Davis Polk & Wardwell: H. Oliver Smith, Jones Day: Bruce W. Moorhead Jr., 60, Essence Digital: Howard Geisler, 45, 35, was promoted to partner at the law joined the law firm as a partner in the joined the agency as global client firm. He was previously an associate. banking and finance practice, a newly partner. He was previously director of CRAIN’S MANAGING EDITOR Ken Steinberg, 46, was promoted to created position. He was previously a global performance marketing at Nokia. JEREMY SMERD has been named managing editor of partner. He was previously an associate. partner at Hunton & Williams. SNR Denton: Michael Barz, 50, joined the Crain’s New York Business, overseeing Crain’s print Sidley Austin: Alexander Moon, 51, joined Butzel Long: Andrew D. Shaffer, 40, joined law firm as a partner. He was previously and digital news-gathering efforts. the law firm as a partner in its global the law firm as a shareholder. He was a partner at DLA Piper. Mr. Smerd, 38, joined Crain’s as a political finance practice. He was previously a previously a partner at Mayer Brown. Kenneth A. Wright Jr., 48, joined as a reporter in 2010. He covered health care for partner at Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Proskauer: Mary S. Consalvi, 53, joined partner in its capital markets practice. Pittman. the law firm as a partner. She was He was previously a partner at Skadden Workforce Management, another Crain Bingham McCutchen: Fred Gallo, 44, previously president and general counsel Arps Slate Meagher & Flom. Communications publication, and transportation for joined the law firm as a partner in its real at NetBio Systems Inc. Fried Frank Harris Shriver & Jacobson: Avi the New York Sun. An alumnus of Columbia estate practice group. He was previously WeiserMazars: Ron Ries, 65, joined the D. Feinberg, 35, was promoted to partner University’s Graduate School of Journalism, he’s a partner at Katten Muchin Rosenman. accounting, tax and advisory firm as a at the law firm. He was previously written for The New York Times, The New York Observer, the Pittsburgh Post- Morvillo Abramowitz Grand Iason Anello partner in the not-for-profit group. He special counsel. Gazette and the journal Creative Nonfiction, among others. and Bohrer: James Stovall, 35, was had been chief financial officer at JBFCS. Tal J. Golomb, 34, was promoted to promoted to partner at the law firm. He Charles Anastasia, 40, joined as a partner partner. He was previously an associate. “Jeremy’s deep knowledge of our local marketplace and commitment to was previously counsel. in the real estate group. He was Joseph J. LoBue, 48, was promoted to our mission makes him remarkably well suited to lead the newsroom’s daily Duval & Stachenfeld: Stephen B. Land, 57, previously a partner, financial services partner. He had been special counsel. Web and weekly newspaper efforts,” said Crain’s Editor Glenn Coleman. joined the law firm as a partner in its tax real-estate tax, at KPMG. —eva saviano practice group. He was previously head of the U.S. tax practice for Linklaters. Hunton & Williams: Michael P.Richman, 59, joined the law firm as a partner in its bankruptcy, restructuring and creditors’ rights practice group. He previously chaired the bankruptcy practice group at Patton Boggs. Kaufman Dolowich Voluck & Gonzo: Kevin Duffy, 50, joined the law firm as a partner. He was previously a consultant at Kinetic Partners. Ernst & Young: Julie Canty, 39, joined the assurance, tax, transaction and advisory services firm as a partner. She was previously a partner at Deloitte Tax. Carlos A. Schmidt, 37, joined as a partner. He was previously a partner at Deloitte Tax. Arnold & Porter: Evan Hollander, 51, joined the law firm as a bankruptcy partner. He was previously a partner at White & Case. Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz: S. Gregory Boyd, 38, joined the law firm as a partner and head of its interactive entertainment group. He also serves as an adjunct professor at New York Law School. Milbank Tweed Hadley & McCloy: Gerard Uzzi, 46, joined the law firm as a partner in its financial restructuring group. He was previously a partner in the financial restructuring and insolvency group at White & Case. Katten Muchin Rosenman: Stanford A. Renas, 39, joined the law firm as a part- ner. He had been a partner at Linklaters. David A. Crichlow, 48, joined as a partner. He was previously a partner at Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman. Duane Morris: Anthony Rao, 45, joined the law firm as a partner in its employment, labor, benefits and immigration practice group. He co- founded Rao Tiliakos. Michael Tiliakos, 41, joined as a partner. He co-founded Rao Tiliakos. Wilson Elser: Henry L. Solano, 62, joined the law firm as a partner. He had been a partner at Dewey & LeBeouf. Tai Rodriguez, 35, joined as of counsel. She was previously an associate at McDermott Will & Emery. Holland & Knight: Charles A. Weiss, 45, joined the law firm as a partner and head of its NY intellectual-property group. He was a partner at Kenyon & Kenyon. Steven Roosa, 42, joined as a partner and co-chair of the firm’s national data privacy and security team. He was previously a partner at Reed Smith. The Metropolitan Museum of Art: Pierre Terjanian, 43, joined as curator of its department of arms and armor. He was previously J.J. Medveckis Associate Curator of Arms and Armor and acting head of the department of European decorative arts and sculpture before 1700 at the Philadelphia Museum of Art. October 22, 2012 | Crain’s New York Business | 11 OPINION CRAIN’S NEW YORK BUSINESS How to price MTA fares editor in chief Rance Crain publisher, vp Jill R. Kaplan ew York wouldn’t be New York without decisions that are best for the system and the city. EDITORIAL editor Glenn Coleman a raucous public debate on mass-transit That’s why unlimited monthly and weekly MetroCards managing editor Jeremy Smerd fare hikes every couple of years. Four should get the biggest break.They empower and encourage deputy managing editors Valerie Block, people not only to commute but to shop, to socialize, to Erik Ipsen years out of five, though, is a bit much, assistant managing editor Erik Engquist and speaks to the serial underfunding of consume entertainment—in general, to make the most of senior producer, news Elisabeth Butler Cordova our vast and diverse city without adding automobile traffic. news producer Lauren Elkies transit by Washington, Albany and City contributing editor Elaine Pofeldt Hall. But that is where we are. No Unlimited cards are good for the city’s economy, columnists Greg David, Alair Townsend government rescue is imminent or even on the horizon. environment and quality of life.They increase ridership, and crain’s health pulse editor Barbara Benson senior reporters Theresa Agovino, As a result, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority expanding mass transit’s constituency will translate into Aaron Elstein, Lisa Fickenscher, Matthew Flamm N reporters Chris Bragg, Amanda Fung, has proposed four fare-hike alternatives that each generate more political support for the MTA. Andrew J. Hawkins, Adrianne Pasquarelli the same amount of revenue. A cynic might say the agency The discount for purchasing MetroCards in higher web reporter, producer Tania Karas is employing a psychological technique that parents of denominations was art director Steven Krupinski put in place to deter deputy art director Carolyn McClain young children know well: offering several choices to Unlimited staff photographer Buck Ennis distract us from the fact that none is especially palatable. straphangers from copy desk chief Steve Noveck copy editor Thaddeus Rutkowski Be that as it may, it’s indeed time to eat our vegetables. MetroCards buying tokens.That data editor Suzanne Panara The question at hand is whether single-ride, multiride or rationale disappeared assistant data editor Emily Laermer should get the researchers Eva Saviano, Amy Stern unlimited-ride MetroCards should be favored in the new when tokens did.The interns Ali Elkin, Emily Lundeen pricing scheme. Although public hearings have yet to begin, biggest break MTA has also been charging more per ride ONLINE AND INTERACTIVE SERVICES popular sentiment seems to be with multiride cards. Even senior web developer, interactive MTA Chairman Joseph Lhota,who at a recent Crain’s when multiride cards Chris O’Donnell forum had frowned on the 7% discount on these cards, is are bought for under ADVERTISING, MARKETING AND PRODUCTION now suggesting that it only be trimmed, not eliminated. $10, a policy that advertising director Trish Henry punishes the poorest New Yorkers. senior account managers Irene Bar-Am, The thinking is that multiride cards are the most Courtney McCombs, Sheryl Rose, Suzanne Wilson commonly purchased and thus should keep their discount to The upcoming hearings will undoubtedly feature account executive Jill Bottomley Kunkes benefit the greatest number of straphangers. But perhaps straphangers demanding to keep the discount to which sales coordinator Danielle Wiener newsletter product manager Alexis Sinclair they are popular because of the discount. It’s illogical to they’ve grown accustomed. But the MTA,rather than put credit Todd J. Masura (313-446-6097) discount a product because it is popular.The purpose of a its finger to the wind, should adjust fares to encourage more director, audience development Michael O’Connor fare discount should be to induce transit riders to make subway and bus trips. In the long run, everyone will benefit. senior marketing manager Catherine Schutten event producer Courtney Williams reprint sales manager Lauren Melesio CRAIN’S ONLINE POLL COMMENTS production and pre-press director Michael Corsi advertising production manager Suzanne Fleischman Wies Frick and Fracking TO SUBSCRIBE: For print and digital subscriptions or customer service, e-mail [email protected] ENOUGH WITH THE Incident Log.” I asked what @unclerush. or call 877-824-9379 (in the U.S. and Canada) or FEARMONGERING that was for, and he smiled —daymond john 313-446-0450 (all other locations). $3.00 a copy for and said, “Well, when you via Twitter the print edition; or $99.95 one year, $179.95 two Re “Fracking foes wield new have a bunch of 20-year-old @TheSharkDaymond years, for print subscriptions with digital access. weapon: crime” (The Insider, men who are away from home www.crainsnewyork.com/subscribe Oct. 16): This is unmitigated and making lots of money, INSIDER BECOMES A BLOG TO ADVERTISE: nonsense. It is part of an there’ll be some issues.” He Contact Advertising Director Trish Henry at ongoing effort to create and indicated that drug use, Final edition of Crain’s Insider [email protected] or call 212-210-0711. newscom exacerbate fears about drilling drunken driving and newsletter!?! [Last Monday it www.crainsnewyork.com/advertise for natural gas. While there are prostitution were some of became] a blog. Rhetorical SHOULD THE YANKEES legitimate issues surrounding those “issues.” Draw your own question: Why must all good FOR INFORMATION ON OUR EVENTS: DUMP ALEX RODRIGUEZ? fracking and its potential conclusions. things come to an end? Contact Event Producer Courtney Williams at consequences, we would —heidi g. —darren dopp [email protected] or 212-210-0257. benefit from talking about via Twitter @DarrenDopp www.crainsnewyork.com/events them in fact-based discussions, Date of poll: Oct. 18 ABOUT THOSE TO CONTACT THE NEWSROOM: not spreading unfounded fears. Very excited about the new 285 votes 30-SOMETHINGS 711 Third Ave., New York, NY 10017-4036 —mike uretsky @CrainsInsider. editorial phone: 212.210.0277 fax 212.210.0799 Damascus, Pa. Re your Oct. 15 “Reunion @andyjayhawk and Entire contents ©copyright 2012 Crain Communications Inc. Issue” celebrating 25 years of @ChrisBragg1 do great work. All rights reserved. ®CityBusiness is a registered trademark … THEN AGAIN the 40 Under 40 franchise at The Insider will be more of a of MCP Inc., used under license agreement. Crain’s New York Business: must-read than ever. PUBLISHED BY CRAIN COMMUNICATIONS INC. Last May, my husband and I When are you going to do an —michael j. murphy chairman Keith E. Crain 25% drove through Towanda, Pa., article on “50 Over 50”? : ) Via Twitter No president Rance Crain because as farm owners in —todd bassen @MichaelMurphyNY secretary Merrilee Crain upstate New York, we wanted Director, acquisitions treasurer Mary Kay Crain to get firsthand information Invesco Real Estate Meet the new @CrainsInsider executive vp, operations William Morrow 75% on fracking and its effects. We blog, via @AndyJayHawk & senior vp, group publisher Gloria Scoby Yes visited the chief of police in Always humbled & honored @ChrisBragg1. Definitely group vp, technology, circulation, Towanda, and the first thing I 2 get mentioned in worth reading obsessively. manufacturing Robert C. Adams vp/production, manufacturing David Kamis saw in his office was a big file @crainsnewyork articles with —azi paybarah chief information officer Paul Dalpiaz labeled “Gas Company icons like @mr_dupri & via Twitter @azipaybarah founder G.D. Crain Jr. (1885-1973) chairman Mrs. G.D. Crain Jr. (1911-1996) FOR THIS WEEK’S QUESTIONS: CRAIN’S WELCOMES SUBMISSIONS to its opinion pages. Send letters to [email protected]. Send columns of 475 Go to www.crainsnewyork.com/poll to have your say. words or fewer to [email protected]. Please include the writer’s name, company, address and telephone number. 12 | Crain’s New York Business | October 22, 2012 day, persuading the powers in Citi CEO ouster just Washington to save Citi because its demise would have risked the glob- al financial system. Mr. Pandit’s de- fenders say he succeeded in getting window dressing Citi through hard times. The government made a big profit on the taxpayers’$45 billion in hen the Citigroup board pushed out CEO direct capital injections into Citi. Vikram Pandit last week, the directors That’s something, I guess. Citi re- wanted to end the financial-crisis chapter mains deeply troubled—the weakest of the too-big-to-fail bank’s history. It is or second-weakest of the big banks, depending on how one assesses not that simple. Questions remain about Bank of America.Citi’s inept invest- whether Citi should even exist. Maybe it should have been put ment bank is way too big (as large as W Goldman Sachs), its domestic con- out of its misery in 2008 or 2009. The Pandit decision came just as former Federal Deposit sumer operations have missed out on the mortgage refinancing boom that Insurance Corp. Chairwoman have lifted both JPMorgan Chase Sheila Bair published her blistering and Wells Fargo, and its manage- account of the decisions to bail out ment continues to be suspect. the big banks at the height of the cri- The appointment of longtime sis in her book, Bull by the Horns. Citi insider Michael Corbat as chief Her key targets are Citi, Mr. Pandit executive was mostly met with the and the bank’s most fervent sup- comment, “Who’s he?’’ Maybe Mr. porter, then-New York Fed Presi- Corbat will be the next Jamie Di- dent Tim Geithner. mon, but the odds are that he’ll just As Ms. Bair tells the story, Citi be the next Vikram Pandit. Citi has was clearly a disaster before the cri- resisted fix-up efforts for more than sis broke. It lost $9.8 billion in the a decade now. last quarter of 2007, a total of $10 The available history suggests billion in the next three, and was so GREG DAVID Ms. Bair may have been right. Dis- poorly managed that it couldn’t tell mantling Citi would have sent a sig- anyone in Washington which of its nal that incompetence had conse- businesses were regulated and says was trying to preserve the rep- quences. Since it wasn’t, it remains which were not. It was paying out utation of his mentor, Robert Ru- unclear—almost four years later— $11 billion in dividends despite the bin, then a key Citi board member. how the United States will deal with hemorrhage of red ink and was de- Ms. Bair, in her role as FDIC another financial crisis, whether the pendent on uninsured foreign de- chief, wanted to dismantle Citi into big financial companies are still too posits.Mr.Pandit had no clue about the parts worth saving and get rid of big to fail and whether anyone will banking,Ms.Bair contends,but was everyone responsible for the mess. be held accountable. That’s not protected by Mr. Geithner, who she Mr. Geithner eventually won the good for anyone. JACK FRIEDMAN force makes its way back into our Queens’ racino bet local economy, from workers to businesses and back again, creating a cycle of much-needed economic pays off big-time growth in the borough. Procure- ment opportunities are available, with preferences given to Queens n the eve of Resorts World Casino New York businesses. New York City’s only City’s first anniversary this month, it is abun- casino continues to pour hundreds of millions of dollars into New York dantly clear that Queens’ bet on this important state for education funding. business has more than paid off. The success of Resorts World Public finances are stretched to their limits, should remove any doubt about the and private financing opportunities for large development proj- economic potential of New York’s O most diverse borough. The pes- ects in New York are sparse at best.But here in Queens,we have simists may have said that Aque- built one of the most prosperous and lucrative developments duct was too far from Manhattan to succeed, but the record speaks for New York has seen in years. Resorts itself:more than a million visitors in World has created more than 1,750 More than a July alone and the top-grossing permanent jobs and 1,400 construc- slots casino in the entire country in tion jobs and generated more than million visitors May. Now just imagine what table $410 million in total tax revenue.Of gaming would add to the equation. those permanent jobs, more than to Aqueduct in After years of false starts and 60% belong to Queens residents, missteps by previous developers, and 50% of the top management July alone Resorts World has fulfilled its jobs belong to people who live in the promises.The Queens Chamber of borough. Commerce has prioritized brand- This success is attributed not ing the borough as a destination lo- only to the fact that Aqueduct is a cation. Millions of visitors have de- fantastic location, but also because scended upon the great borough of Resorts World has taken the steps tive marketing programs together. Queens, and, in doing so, local res- necessary to fully integrate itself The continued influx of millions idents and businesses have emerged into the Queens business commu- of visitors to the casino from New as the winners. nity.Local businesses also are seeing York City, the tristate region and their bottom lines benefit through beyond has had the spillover effect Jack Friedman is executive director partnerships with the casino—for of creating additional jobs in the of the Queens Chamber of example, by cultivating vending community. Almost every dollar Commerce, of which Resorts World agreements and developing innova- earned by the Resorts World work- Casino is a dues-paying member. October 22, 2012 | Crain’s New York Business | 13 SMALL BUSINESS Growth in cruises buoys tiny firm Designers of luxury ships are in demand “Cruise-ship design is a specialized ened by a deadly cruise-ship crash in niche; there are only about a half- January off the coast of Italy, the as more vacationers opt to come on board dozen firms like us in the U.S.,” said Cruise Lines International Associa- Mr. Galutera, who is president of tion projects that its members—26 hattan firm, located on West 40th the New York chapter of the Interi- major cruise lines serving North BY BILL GLOVIN Street, are more likely to rack up or Design Association. He believes America—should carry more than frequent-flier miles traveling every- his firm is the only one of its kind in 17 million passengers in 2012, an in- rancesca Bucci and where from shipbuilding yards in New York. crease of roughly 1 million over 2011. Hans Galutera rarely South Korea to meetings with And the industry is thriving locally, have the time to enjoy cruise-ship companies in Miami, Crowded docks following renovations to the Man- buck ennis the cruise-ship interiors where many are based. Fast growth in the cruise industry hattan Cruise Terminal and con- SHIP SHAPE: Hans Galutera and Francesa they design at BG Stu- BG Studio is finding itself with is helping the small firm grow. Al- struction of the Brooklyn Cruise Ter- Bucci’s cruise-interior design shop is thriving. Fdio. The co-founders of the Man- no shortage of work these days. though some consumers were fright- minal. Passenger arrivals in New York City rose by 9% from 2010 to 2011, to 632,923, according to the city’s Economic Development Corp. “Manhattan is an increasingly popular departure point, since it saves on airfare associated with leav- ing [on a cruise] from another desti- nation and provides flexibility for last-minute getaways,” said Emma Rupp, president of Liberty Travel in Ramsey, N.J., who reports that one- quarter of the travel agency’s busi- ness nationally is now tied to cruises. Nonetheless, BG Studio operates in a challenging design sphere, FROM THE CENTER wrestling with strict nautical guide- lines and factors like tight spaces and captive passengers. “It’s not like a ho- OF THE WORLD tel or restaurant where,if the style turns you off,you can leave,”Ms.Bucci said. The firm must often work along- side its rivals on TO THE REST OF IT. projects. “Our $239M competitors are ECONOMIC usually involved to IMPACT of the THE MOST FLIGHTS give different cruise-ship zones in large industry on ships a varied New York City FROM NEW YORK CITY. Source: NYC Economic look,” said Mr. Development Corp. Galutera. Ms. Bucci and Mr. Galutera launched BG Studio (BG repre- sents their last initials) in 2002 after working together for Birch Coffey,a well-known designer in Manhat- tan.Ms.Bucci,an Italian native who received her master’s in architecture at the University of Rome, and Mr. Galutera, an Australian expat who studied interior design at Manhat- tan’s Fashion Institute of Technolo- gy, had been collaborating on a res- idential building project.When Mr. Coffey closed the firm shortly after Sept. 11, 2001, he told them they could continue to work for the client as independent contractors—and their business was born. The profitable BG Studio has grown to 12 employees, bringing in revenue in the $2 million to $2.5 million range in 2011.Its biggest ac- count is Royal Caribbean Interna- tional. BG Studio has had a hand in designing spas, lounges, lobbies, casinos, theaters and cabins in al- most every ship Royal Caribbean has built or renovated in the past 10 years, including those in its popular Celebrity Cruises line. “This duo and their team have an exquisite design style,” says Kelly Gonzalez, vice president of architec- tural design for Royal Caribbean. Ⅲ DELTA.COM/NYC The image of the FLATIRON BUILDING is a trademark and used under limited license. To sign up for Crain’s SMALL BUSINESS newsletter, go to www.crainsnewyork.com/smallbiz. 14 | Crain’s New York Business | October 22, 2012 REAL ESTATE INSIDE Deals New York Foundling turns its headquarters surplus space into revenue PAGE 18 The List New York area’s largest REPORT construction firms PAGE 19 SCULPTURED LOOK: Thomas Balsley’s firm’s ongoing work Staten I. on Riverside Park South has drawn praise. suddenly slips into high gear From Ferris wheel to outlet mall, North Shore eyes transformation BY AMANDA FUNG True, the world’s largest Ferris wheel and the city’s first outlet mall are both coming to the North Shore of Staten Island, but the even more surprising news is that they will have lots of company. In fact, several big develop- ments are set to transform long- underutilized areas that lie be- tween the Staten Island Ferry Terminal and Stapleton, along the harbor, into a bustling water- front community.Among them is a 286,000-square-foot project in- cluding a hotel and housing that Queens-based Triangle Equities plans to build on an erstwhile Coast Guard site. Less $480M than a mile Total private north, plans investment in Ferris wheel, mall are taking and hotel shape to turn a seven-acre decommissioned U.S. naval base site known as Homeport along the waterfront in Stapleton into another mixed- use development with housing and stores. buck ennis “We are seeing more and more creative spark and economic de- velopment move into Staten Is- land,”said David Barry,president of Ironstate Development, the New Jersey-based developer tapped last year by the city to de- Parks translate to profits velop the Homeport site. Homeport will be the first well as boosting property values—and Park spending Thomas Balsley Associates and project to take shape. Mr. Barry A bumper crop in the process, burnishing the reputa- under the Bloomberg Weiss/Manfredi. expects work to get underway on administration of designers blossom tions, as well as revenues, of a platoon “It’s been a real renaissance,” said the $115 million first phase, with of the city’s leading landscape archi- In millions of dollars Vin Cipolla, president of the Munic- 520 rental apartments, in the first as $1.5B in projects tects and design firms. Bronx ipal Art Society of New York.“A com- quarter of next year. He hopes to In the past decade, several big, $316 petitive city needs to be a livable city, finalize his construction financ- are rolled out in city transformative projects and a host of Brooklyn and the quality of the public realm is ing by year’s end. When com- smaller ones have blossomed. Among $352 on top of the list.” plete, the $150 million property BY STEPHEN KLEEGE the major ones are the 550-acre Hud- Manhattan All told, the city has spent about will have 900 residential units son River Park,based on a master plan $345 $1.5 billion on 2,019 park improve- and 30,000 square feet of retail All over the city,parks have been pro- by Quennell Rothschild & Partners; ment projects—including new space, plus a public plaza. liferating, offering New Yorkers the first two phases of the High Line Queens parks—since Mayor Michael “We are very excited,”said Mr. $358 everything from popular waterfront Park, designed by James Corner Field Bloomberg took office in 2002. New Barry, who started scouting Stat- destinations to quiet neighborhood Operations; and the Hunters Point Staten Island York currently has 167 park projects en Island for building sites four oases. It is a tide of green that is im- South project on the Long Island $116 with a total cost of more than $626 years ago. “We expect our project proving the quality of life and air, as City,Queens,waterfront,designed by Source: NYC Parks Dept. See PARKS on Page 16 See SI on Page 17 October 22, 2012 | Crain’s New York Business | 15 REPORT REAL ESTATE Hudson River shoreline stretching north from the Battery. Parks and profits Working with the landscape ar- chitects at Matthews Nielsen, in Continued from Page 15 once the world’s largest landfill, is 1997 Quennell Rothschild headed a million underway,and has budgeted New York’s biggest park develop- team of architects, marine engi- $279 million for design work on 253 ment in more than a century. But neers, artists, traffic consultants and more, according to the city’s De- that project was quickly overshad- the nonprofit Hudson River Park partment of Parks & owed by another that the Conservancy in devising the master Firm/founded: Recreation. JAMES CORNER company designed in 2004, plan for the 550-acre ribbon of A recent study on the FIELD the High Line park. It was parkland that is still being built. impact of five Manhattan OPERATIONS, James Corner’s work on “Each section was detailed or de- parks by real estate services 1998 that effort—along with ar- signed by other firms [based on the firm CBRE found that Head: James chitect Diller Scofidio & master plan],” said Andrew Moore, asking rents in adjacent of- Corner Renfro, and planting de- a Quennell Rothschild partner.The Notable buck ennis fice towers were nearly projects/ signer Piet Oudolf—that RAIL LIFE: Associate partner Lisa Tziona Switkin led the James Corner firm’s design work on the result is what he calls “an amazing 44% higher on average opened: “redefined what we think of hugely successful High Line. transformation” of what had been a than in buildings a block Ⅲ High Line, when we think of urban jumble of parking lots and aban- away. The biggest premi- Manhattan, 2009 parks,” according to the doned piers. um was on the periphery of (phase one) and Municipal Art Society’s helped: It was long, narrow and one “I’m very proud to have built one of More recently, the firm worked the rejuvenated Bryant 2011 (phase two) Mr. Cipolla. story high. the best parks in the country, and on the Newtown Creek Nature Ⅲ Freshkills Park, Park. There, asking rents Staten Island, The redevelopment of “From the beginning, this was Thomas Balsley did a great job [de- Walk in Greenpoint, Brooklyn. It are 63% higher than they 2012 (phase one the unused freight line, something that was seen as impos- signing it].” collaborated with landscape sculp- are a block away, not to projects) which starts from the meat- sible,”she said.“Now it’s well loved.” Similarly,the stretch of parkland tor George Trakas on the $6 million mention 46% above the Projects on packing district and ex- That success has hugely elevated along the Long Island City,Queens, first phase of the walk, in the im- the drafting midtown average. tends through Chelsea to the standing of its de- Firm/founded: waterfront that Mr. Balsley probable shadow of a towering board: the West Side rail yards,was signer. Founded by started with the design for wastewater treatment plant. A $13 Ⅲ THOMAS BALSLEY ames Corner Field Cornell NYC Tech a perfect fit for James British landscape archi- ASSOCIATES, Gantry Plaza State Park also million expansion is underway. So, Campus, 1981 Operations moved to Roosevelt Island Corner. tect and University of is moving forward. Con- too, is the firm’s work on a $20 mil- Manhattan from Ⅲ Lisa Tziona Switkin, the Pennsylvania professor Head: Thomas struction started last year on lion revamp of Battery Park at the J South Street Balsley Philadelphia in 2003, Seaport firm’s associate partner who James Corner, the firm’s the adjacent Hunters Point tip of Manhattan. the year after the fledgling redevelopment, headed up the design work previous biggest project Notable South Park, 13 years after That project will include a major Manhattan projects/ firm won the competition for the project, described had been a master plan opened: Gantry opened, and he is gathering space between Broadway to design the 2,200-acre that mission as “transform- for Philadelphia’s North Ⅲ Gantry Plaza working on the design for and Castle Clin- Firm/founded: Freshkills Park on Staten Island. ing underutilized, abandoned sites Delaware Riverfront State Park, Long the second half of the new ton, and the QUENNELL Since then, the staff has ballooned to something that becomes of value project. Today, his firm’s Island City, park. completion of a ROTHSCHILD & to 40, an eightfold increase. to the city.” projects extend from Queens, 1998 The firm’s international bikeway through PARTNERS Ⅲ Freshkills, a 30-year, $650 mil- The fact that the High Line was Qianhai Water City in Riverside Park business,which started in the the park to the (originally South, Manhattan, Nicholas Quennell lion project to transform what was no ordinary abandoned site also Shenzhen, China, to 2008 (phases one 1990s with several projects in East River. Associates), 1968 London, where the firm to four) Japan, has also helped offset “Their sense Heads: Nicholas recently opened an office Projects on the effects of the recession. of great design is Quennell, Peter to work on the legacy the drafting Back at home, Mr. Balsley’s in all the details,” Rothschild parks from the city’s board: trademark is his designs for said Warrie Price, Notable Olympics. Ⅲ Sheikh Khalifa neighborhood parks that jam president of the projects/ Medical City, Abu opened: multiple features into tiny Battery Conser- Dhabi, U.A.E. Ⅲ Master plan for homas Balsley Ⅲ Hunters Point spaces, such as the epony- vancy. “They are Hudson River Park started working in South Park, Long mous park he completed in excellent collabo- (with Matthews the landscape de- Island City, 2000 for Rose Associates. It rators.” Nielsen), Behind every real estate deal T Queens Manhattan, 1997 sign business in the manages to squeeze a kiosk While Quen- there is a thoughtful, 1970s, when many peo- café, a lawn, a garden, a nell Rothschild Ⅲ Newtown Creek Nature Walk, business-savvy professional. ple thought of parks as dangerous, greenmarket and a toddler area into has focused on Brooklyn, 2007 and green was still just a color. Since a third of an acre along Ninth Avenue projects in the Projects on then, he’s seen a complete turn- at West 57th Street. New York area, it the drafting around. has picked up board: “Society, and our city, is coming ollaborative projects are a out-of-town jobs Ⅲ Battery Park around to see the real benefits that Quennell Rothschild & such as Druid revamp, parks bring to the quality of our Partners specialty. It is an Hills park in Manhattan C Ⅲ Public plaza at lives,” he said. ability the firm first honed while Atlanta; the Pershing Square, Riding that rising wave,Thomas working with architect Robert Minneapolis Manhattan Balsley Associates grew to boast 22 Cabrera and the city’s Wildlife Sculpture Gar- staffers in 2007. Then came the re- Conservation Society designing the den,in collaboration with artists in- M.S. in Real Estate cession, tightening the competition Central Park Children’s Zoo, which cluding sculptor Claes Oldenburg; with other firms that had been lured opened in 1997. But nowhere has and the Monroe Center in Grand Even in the toughest of economic times, well-connected, well-informed real estate to the city by the park boom. that ability paid off more hand- Rapids, Mich., which it developed professionals who understand the markets and who anticipate the needs of their The newcomers in recent years somely than on the five miles of with artist Maya Lin. Ⅲ clients will fi nd success. The M.S. in Real Estate, off ered by the NYU Schack Institute include Michael Van Valkenburgh of Real Estate, integrates theory with real-world application, covering every Associates Inc. from Cambridge, segment of the industry. Learn from faculty members who are top professionals in Mass., which opened here in 2001 and is designing the Brooklyn the fi eld. Join a global network of more than 2,000 alumni. Gain the competitive Bridge Park; and West 8, the Dutch advantage in the real estate capital of the world – NYC. firm working on a major revamp of Choose from concentrations in: Finance and Investment or Governors Island. Today, Thomas Balsley’s annual Strategic Real Estate Management revenue is roughly $3 million, about the level of 2006. What helped was Information Session: Monday, October 22, 6–8 p.m. continued development of Manhat- NYU Kimmel Center, 60 Washington Square South, New York, NY tan’s 29-acre Riverside Park South. There, the firm is currently in “full For event information and to RSVP visit scps.nyu.edu/graduate-events6b gear”designing phases six and seven (phase five was designed in 2011), To request information and to apply: scps.nyu.edu/gradinfo6b which will link the completed wa- terfront green spaces along the To learn more about the program, Hudson River to Riverside Boule- visit us at: scps.nyu.edu/msre1b vard. or call 212-998-7100 Donald Trump, who developed much of the Riverside Park South buck ennis New York University is an affi rmative action/equal opportunity institution. ©2012 New York University School of Continuing and Professional Studies. residential complex just east of the PIER REVIEW: Andrew Moore and his firm, Quennell Rothschild, have transformed a collection park, said it has had a huge impact. of parking lots and abandoned piers into an urban oasis called Hudson River Park. 16 | Crain’s New York Business | October 22, 2012 REPORT REAL ESTATE Included: Superior service from a Type Personality.TM ON TRACK: All 91 units at the new Rail rental building We share your have been leased. PASSION FOR SUCCESS. NORWALK, CT PAWTUCKET, RI TAUNTON, MA PORT WASHINGTON, NY REVOLVING REVOLVING REVOLVING CREDIT REVOLVING seong kwon kwon seong / CREDIT FACILITY CREDIT FACILITY FACILITY & TERM LOAN CREDIT FACILITY $6,500,000 $25,000,000 $9,000,000 $65,000,000 map architects ASSET-BASED FINANCING At Webster, we care about helping local businesses succeed. That’s why we provide accessible financing that your business needs to achieve its goals. Talk with us today and together, we’ll find a way to make it happen. For more information about our asset-based financing solutions, contact Warren Mino at 212.806.4500, or go to websterbcc.com for an application. NEW YORK BOSTON HARTFORD PHILADELPHIA NYSE:WBS ® Business Credit Websterbcc.com MASS APPEAL: Harbor Commons will boast All credit facilities are subject to the normal credit approval process. 100 outlet stores and *The NYSE ticker symbol of WBS is assigned to Webster Financial Corporation and does not constitute an offer to buy or sell securities by the Company, its subsidiaries or any associated party a 200-room hotel. and is meant purely for information purposes. Webster Bank, N.A. Webster Business Credit Corporation is a subsidiary of Webster Bank, N.A. The Webster Symbol and Webster Business Credit are registered in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. Member FDIC shop architects shop SI slips into high gear Continued from Page 15 rection from the island’s ocean to be well received.” beaches. Stapleton is the same stop Nearby, smaller efforts have al- that will serve Homeport visitors ready prospered. Brooklyn-based when it is complete. BFC Partners, one of the first de- “I want the North Shore to exist velopers to spot opportunity on without cars, like a Battery Park postrecession Staten Island, recent- City,” said Staten Island Borough ly finished leasing its 91-unit rental President James Molinaro. building called The Rail, less than a Realizing such a dream would TRANSPORTATION & year after putting the units on the throw the borough’s door open to INFRASTRUCTURE market. The six-story building on those roughly 2 million tourists who Bay and Prospect streets, across come over on the Staten Island Fer- BUILDINGS & from the Paramount Theater, fea- ry each year but who rarely leave the FACILITIES tures apartments ranging from ferry building. $700-a-month studios to $1,600-a- In with the outlet CONSTRUCTION month three-bedrooms. Prices are MANAGEMENT on par with those in comparable BFC Partners’ largest and latest buildings in the area, noted Joseph development on the island, a Ferrara, principal at BFC Partners, 350,000-square-foot outlet mall to be ENERGY whose first project on Staten Island known as Harbor Commons, will SERVICES was a 105-unit senior housing com- certainly help get people onto the plex that opened in April. sidewalks of the borough. Boasting On top of providing housing for 100 stores and a 200-room hotel, it young professionals at deep dis- will rise on a city-owned site just counts to Manhattan prices, BFC south of the home of the Staten Is- signed up a big retailer. It is Deal$, land Yankees,St.George’s Richmond which inked a 10-year lease for County Bank Ballpark. And so will 10,000 square feet at the base of The the Ferris wheel, with its 36 capsules Enduring. Driven. Visionary. Rail. The store opened earlier this that can carry a total of 1,440 passen- Reaching the century mark isn’t easy – you have to be year, and business has been brisk. gers, when it opens in early 2016 just north of the ballpark. The Ferris quality-driven, client-focused, and have a vision for the ‘Better retailers’ wheel and outlet mall are expected to future. At 100 years, STV is looking ahead. As an employee- “When we attract more people, bring a combined $480 million in pri- owned fi rm, our planners, architects, engineers and then we will get better retailers,”said vate investment into the borough. construction managers have a stake in the business, Mr. Ferrara, who hopes that the ar- Meanwhile, on the other side of and are committed to quality performance. We provide rival of Deal$ will draw enough traf- the ferry terminal,Triangle Equities fic to help landlords fill up some of is expected to start building its $105 personal attention and timely solutions, with an eye toward the many vacancies along Bay million mixed-use project by 2014. sustainability. And with more than 35 offi ces, we are a local An employee-owned firm Street, one of the island’s main “The North Shore has been ig- fi rm with national resources. Offices nationwide shopping strips.The Rail is 100 feet nored for 30 to 40 years,” said Don- Toll-free: 877-395-5459 from the Stapleton stop on the Stat- ald Capoccia, managing principal When it comes to getting your project delivered right, [email protected] en Island Railroad, which in turn is and founder of BFC Partners. “We choose the fi rm that has the drive and vision to be the best. www.stvinc.com just two stops from the ferry termi- want to enliven the area and create nal,and several stops in the other di- an urban environment.” Ⅲ October 22, 2012 | Crain’s New York Business | 17 REPORT REAL ESTATE DEALS cording to a source. Its new space facility for young athletes, is opening Swedish reinsurer will be designed by Perkins East- on the Upper East Side.The compa- Nonprofit touts its crosses B’way man, the source said. ny recently signed a 10-year deal for —amanda fung 7,400 square feet at 1629 First Ave. Sirius America, the U.S. arm of The deal includes 900 square feet on Stockholm-based Sirius Interna- the ground floor,a 1,500-square-foot space-saving model tional Insurance Group, is shifting Office-suites firm mezzanine and a 5,000-square-foot its headquarters to a new office on grows in midtown basement. The asking rent was near the far side of lower Broadway. $43 per square foot. he New York Foundling sees itself as a powerful new model for The multiline reinsurer serving Stark Business Solutions, a provider Fastbreak typically rents out the city’s vast nonprofit sector, but it’s not one that’s likely to the Americas and the Caribbean of executive office suites and services, space by the hour at schools.This will make many landlords happy. The 143-year-old organization market has signed a long-term lease is expanding its footprint at 1 Grand be its first full-time leased location. has just completed the first stage of a renovation that will fit its for roughly 26,000 square feet at 140 Central “It’s such a vibrant community 120 headquarters employees into far less space in the group’s Broadway,between Cedar and Liberty Place, across for young families,and there’s a large T150,000-square-foot building at 590 Sixth Ave. streets. The asking rent could not be the street number of private schools up there,” The consolidation will allow the organization, a child-welfare and fam- determined,but according to brokers, from the said Gary Alterman, the Robert K. ily-services agency, to rent out the remaining space it owns in the building, rent for similar spaces in the area is in landmarked Futterman & Associates broker bringing in a projected minimum of $500,000 annually in revenue.Five years the mid-$50s per square foot. train station. who, along with colleague Andrew ago, the Foundling sold the first six floors, or 100,000 square feet. Adam Foster, the broker at The firm Stern, represented both Fastbreak Bill Baccaglini, the Foundling’s CEO, said nonprofits can do more good CBRE Group Inc. who represented has signed a 10-year lease for 12,700 and the landlord, the Kibel Cos. by taking an entrepreneurial attitude toward their space. Sirius America, declined to com- square feet at the property at 60 E. Fastbreak founder Lonny “Any endowment that the Foundling has is largely the result of real es- ment. Cushman & Wakefield bro- 42nd St. (above). Stark Business al- Levine said his business currently tate decisions that have been made over the years,” Mr. Baccaglini said. kers Robert Constable and Louis ready occupies 25,400 square feet at trains about 1,000 athletes through- The organization still owns the building’s remaining 50,000 square feet D’Avanzo represented the building the 1.3 million-square foot build- out New York City. and used to occupy all that space, but it is cutting its own footprint by 40% owner, Union Investment Real Es- ing, where it has been a tenant for —adrianne pasquarelli and will rent out the top three floors in June. tate, according to CoStar Property. more than a decade. It renewed its The new workspace, occupying four floors in the building, will have a Neither could immediately be current space on the 46th and 47th bullpen-style floor plan with some separate meeting spaces and will allow reached for comment. floors last year and will be taking the B’klyn agency ups the organization to use space more efficiently. Currently, the company is locat- 40th floor in early November. The its act in Harlem “We are almost doubling the usage of our current space here by going to ed at 1 Liberty Plaza and will move asking rent was $59 per square foot. an open work environment,” said Mr. Baccaglini. to take over the entire 32nd floor of “Their business has taken off to the Edwin Gould Services for Children —ali elkin 140 Broadway early next year, ac- extent that they needed another and Families is headed to Park Av- floor,” said Fred Posniak of landlord enue. The nonprofit social-services Malkin Properties. agency has signed a 10-year lease for Ryan Kass and Julie Christiano, 12,440 square feet at the Lee Build- brokers at Newmark Grubb Knight ing at 1825 Park Ave., at 125th St. Frank, represented Malkin, while (below).The asking rent was $30 per Erik Goldschmidt of Goldschmidt square foot. The Brooklyn-based In today’s real estate market, you need a CPA Firm that knows the industry and the & Associates represented the tenant. agency will marketplace inside and out. That’s why WithumSmith+Brown has become one of the premier This year, four full floors at the leave behind a names among CPA firms in the Real Estate, Construction, and Architecture & Engineering 55-story 1 Grand Central Place are Harlem office being vacated, according to Mr. Pos- on Second Av- industries in the tri-state area. For nearly 40 years, our professionals have provided niak,so the Stark expansion was wel- enue that is 20% proactive solutions, expert advice and customized services to help businesses like yours come news for Malkin.“From a land- smaller. thrive. Contact any of our industry specialists, whose expertise in tax, accounting, audit and lord perspective, it worked out well “They out- grew their specialized advisory services will help put you and your company in a position of strength. because the 40th floor was filled be- fore it even became vacant,” he said. space, and it is —amanda fung one of the only available spaces in Harlem,” said Holley Drakeford Kids’ gym takes of Giscombe Realty Group, the first full-time spot landlord of the Lee Building. George Grace of GE Grace Cor- Lured by the large number of schools porate Real Estate Services repre- and families in the neighborhood, sented the tenant in the transaction. [email protected] Fastbreak Kids, a gym and training —amanda fung 212.751.9100 BARE BONES 100 W. 125TH ST. 4 TIMES SQUARE 601 W. 26TH ST. ASKING RENT; TERM: ASKING RENT; TERM: ASKING RENT; TERM: $180 per square foot; $2,500 per square foot; Not disclosed not disclosed 20 years SQUARE FEET: 11,000 SQUARE FEET: 39,000 SQUARE FEET: 42,500 TENANT; REP: Firefly TENANT; REPS: Whole TENANT; REP: H&M; Bob Value Partners; not Foods; Jacqueline Klinger Gibson of Cushman & disclosed and Chase Welles of SCG Wakefield Retail LANDLORD; REP: RXR LANDLORD; REPS: Durst Realty; in-house by LANDLORD; REP: Organization; Matthew William Elder Wharton Properties; in- Krell and Gary Trock of house by Jeff Sutton CBRE BACK STORY: The investment management BACK STORY: The BACK STORY: Swedish firm will occupy a small grocery store will occupy fast-fashion retailer is portion of the 15th floor the first and ground floors moving into space ESPN in the vast Starrett-Lehigh of a five-story building to Zone left in 2010, The Building overlooking the open in mid-2015, Wall Street Journal Hudson River. reports the New York Post. reports. 18 | Crain’s New York Business | October 22, 2012 COMING UP: THE Largest Construction Companies The New York area’s largest law firms list will LIST Ranked by 2011 area revenue appear Oct. 29. TRENDS SPOTLIGHT NYC construction employment continues to fall JOB NUMBERS SOAR BUT SIZE SINKS Number of jobs When it comes to the city’s top 20 construction firms, there’s good news and 131,800 1,954 bad news. On the plus side: The number of major projects built by the top 20 leaped 120,700 112,400 111,500 37.7% last year. The bad news is that while total revenue rose in 2011, it was up less Number of key than 1%, hitting $10.5 billion, according to Crain’s research. projects built Fully half the firms on the list reported that solid growth in the number of contracts—driven by work in the health care, education and residential sectors—had in 2011 well exceeded the step up in revenue. The gap was attributed largely to a rise in the in the New York number of smaller renovation projects. area by the top “One part of our business that has grown is interior works,” said Charlie Murphy, senior vice president at Turner Construction Co., which topped Crain’s list of the 20 Charlie Murphy 2008 2009 2010 2011 20 firms local firms ranked by their New York-area revenue last year. “The market has grown, Sources: New York Building Congress, New York State Department of Labor but the dollars haven’t grown as much. A lot more clients are doing a lot of small projects.” Turner itself is a good example of the phenomenon. While the number of the firm’s key projects grew last year by 29.2%, to 177, its revenue headed in the other direction. It shrank by 16.2%, to $2.4 billion. One of its strongest sectors in Construction’s ebbs and flows recent months has been health care. Turner recently broke ground on the $210 million NYU Langone Medical Center Number of initial construction permits, by borough Energy Building. Another sector helping to buoy builders’ fortunes is education. As endowments begin to swell again at universities, ■ 2009 ■ 2010 ■ 2011 Totals 76,695 80,662 86,860 many are returning to construction. “They’re investing to attract students and faculty,” said Steven Pressler, executive vice president and chief operating officer of the construction management division at STV. That firm ranked No. 11 on the list, 45,000 40,000 after posting the largest revenue gain in 2011, soaring 141.4%, to $205.2 million. The gain was thanks mainly to three 35,000 projects, including the new police academy in College Point, Queens. 30,000 Construction in the residential sector has picked up more this year due to increased demand for rental 25,000 apartments, which is helping to push up rents and whet landlords’ appetites for more construction. “People from all over 20,000 the world want to live here,” said Richard Anderson, president of the New York Building Congress. “We are starting to get a 15,000 construction response to this high demand.” 10,000 Overall construction is expected to continue growing in 2012. In Manhattan, new building permits are up 94% so far 5,000 this year, to 70. Because erecting a building from scratch is much more costly than renovating one, that change in the mix 0 Manhattan Bronx Brooklyn Queens Staten Island should help drive revenue. Office construction is also expected to improve. Source: New York City Department of Buildings —EMILY LAERMER !""# !""# $ % $ % & & ' " ( ' " 6)*+,*!-+./*)0/1-+!- ! &B ) 3 35399 5! 8TrHdg`EcXqTghXit6PcVdcT TSXRPa'TciTg$ dhidcgdeTgiXTh 2pShdcCi rrripgcTgRdchigpRiXdcRdb )sTRpiXqTqXRTegThXSTci 'dbbTgRXPaDdrTg$'PcdcEC%WTPSfpPgiTgh$(TedhXidgtDgphi 8TrHdg`8H &@50A @9F 'aTPgXcV'dge "0"@70@@9 CTcXdgqXRTegThXSTci VTcTgPabPcPVTg 61.234+!-+./*)0/1-+!-*54+ ! !! &7305 "3A&7 5 ! ! ! GdgaSDgPST'TciTg$GdgaSDgPST'TciTg$DWT8TrCRWddah #!20!-354+6 rrriXhWbPcRdchigpRiXdcRdb 'WPXgbPc EcXqTghXit'TciTg$ TaUTgThTPgRW pXaSXcVPiGTXaa'dgcTaa TSXRPa Pg`%qT &F C&&0 'daaTVT 8TrHdg`8H gThXSTci )A "0751F@9 5/*)0/)*,6-+,2*74+184/1-+ !! &0A 7&1F 5 CiPigXR`h'PiWTSgPagTcdqPiXdc$dSXcdTSTgPa pXaSXcV gdPSrPt rrrhigpRipgTidcTRdb 'WPXgbPc ! bdSTgcXuPiXdcPcSgTWPQXaXiPiXdc$TehX'd2gTcdqPiXdc$ PggXdiiPc 8TrHdg`8H CRWgPVTg)SXiXdc2diTaRadR`idrTgRdcqTghXdc ),+9),4.,75!-+./*)0/1-+ ! &59 AA9A3B 5! cT $2tPii$'dapbQXP PcWPiiPcqXaaTTsePchXdc$(TaiPDTgbXcPa )0 '+0 rrraTcSaTPhTRdb TcTgPabPcPVTg 2TPSWdphT4dWc TccTStciTgcPiXdcPa%Xgedgi Pg`%qT 8TrHdg`8H 070&A0@9 6)::6!-+./*)0/1-+!- !! 0B0@ "55F 5 ! TaiPg`rPtiWgTTQgXSVTh$ tgPbXqTg gXSVT8TrHdg`CiPiT 8dgiWTgc aqS rrripaatRdchigpRiXdcRdbRdbePct gThXSTciRWXTUTsTRpiXqT DWgprPt$CTRdcS%qTcpThpQrPt D%RPeXiPaRdchigpRiXdc$DPsXrPt aphWXcV8H! gTWPQXaXiPiXdc4dWc TccTStciTgcPiXdcPa%Xgedgi ()9:4)!-. !! "&A !"37 5 TWPQXaXiPiXdcdUiWT'dapbQph'XgRaThiPiXdcRdbeaTsdciWT)XVWiW EabTgCi rrrYpSaPpRdb 'WXTUTsTRpiXqT %qTcpTPcS gdPSrPtaXcTh$gTWPQXaXiPiXdcdUiWT'paqTg6XcTqXPSpRi 'daaTVTdXci8H WPhT SXqXhXdc$gTWPQXaXiPiXdcdU%qTcpTEPcS8TR`dPShiPiXdch gXVWidc6XcT$gSCigTTihiPiXdcgTWPQXaXiPiXdc &)+/,*4-;,*/.!-+./*)0/1-+ !! &0A 077& 5 ! GXaadr2diTa$dpqTgcTpg2TPaiWRPgTCTgqXRTh$%%)%RPSTbt'WPgiTg %*-)5 rrrWpciTggdQTgihRVRdb gThXSTciRWXTUTsTRpiXqT CRWdda$GXaaTihdXciegTRdchigpRiXdc GdgaSXcPcRXPa'TciTg 8TrHdg`8H! #7B0@$0@BA#5371A %-/243!-+./*)0/1-+!- ! 7 &3&&@055& 5!! dpciCXcPXCRWddadU TSXRXcT$) iWCi$IpR`Tg2XaahXST CXsiW%qT rrrVdiWPbRdchigpRiXdcRdb gThXSTci ! ! 2dheXiPa8dgiWCWdgT6dcVhaPcS4TrXhW2TPaiWCthiTb$dgSWPb6Pr 8TrHdg`8H! CRWdda$CipSXd'Xit &B&@1&73'&B37!7 #9&-<,::!- ! #(&@ (5&7 5 C$ gdd`atc'daaTVTTgUdgbXcV%gih'TciTg$GPaiGWXibPc 8TridrcdPS rrrTrWdrTaaRdb gThXSTci PaaTsePchXdc$CbXiWhdcXPc'ddeTg2TrXii8PiXdcPa(ThXVc phTpb aPXcqXTr8H! $&F&A3@9 !-+/1%*-)5 ! @B 7B3 5 CiTdgVTRdchigpRiXdceWPhT8H'( D$ gdcsGWXiThidcT gXSVT PtCi rrrRdciXRdgeRdb gThXSTciRWXTUTsTRpiXqT ! DgXQdgdpVW gXSVTPcSDpccTa%piWdgXit$GWXiThidcTpTTch CiPiTchaPcS8H PcRWdgPVTDgXQdgdpVW gXSVTPcSDpccTa%piWdgXit$6 dciPp` QgXSVThgTWPQXaXiPiXdc 568!-+./*)0/1-+'+0 ! ! 373* )0@"03 5 daXRTDgPXcXcV%RPSTbtYdXciqTcipgT!$%qTcpTh+DWTGdgaSCRWdda$ Pg`%qTCdpiW rrrhiqXcRRdb )sTRpiXqTRWPXgbPc GPaiGWXibPcPcSPtbdcS%cVTghdaa2dphTh$(TaiPDTgbXcPa 8TrHdg`8H 4dWc TccTStciTgcPiXdcPa%Xgedgi )"#&@9!7 Continued on Page 20 October 22, 2012 | Crain’s New York Business | 19 THE LIST Largest Construction Companies !""# !""# $ % $ % & & ' " ( ' " 6,*31+4:!-+./*)0/1-+!-*5 ! 7&5, 37&55 5 4TghTt'XitbpcXRXePahTgqXRThRdbeaTs CiPiT2XVWrPt CdpiW rrriTgbXcPaRdchigpRiXdcRdb gThXSTciRWXTUTsTRpiXqT GddSXSVT84 %1:;4+, )1:91+7!- ! -3553& &35$&70!!! 5! 2Tcgt4'PgiTgCeTRXPait2dheXiPaPcS8pghXcVPRXaXit$CE8H !!XcTCi rrrVXaQPcTRdRdb -3553&" 0&9!!! PgbXcVSPaTCiPiT'daaTVTGWXibPcCXcRaPXgPcS2PaTWPaah$6TWbPc 8TrHdg`8H %XRTegThXSTcih 'daaTVTcTrhRXTcRTQpXaSXcV(dgbXidgt%piWdgXitdUiWTCiPiTdU8Tr &35$&70!7 Hdg` 0-+49+-0=!-+./*)0/1-+'+0 !!! ! ,35&A 0$ 5!! 'dpgiaPcSi'gThRTci$)a PggXd%gihePRT$2drPgS TPRWhTcXdgWdphXcV$ DWXgSCi rrrbdcRdcRdb gThXSTci 'aXcidc'dbbdch gdd`atc8H 524<3)/",.17+4+9 !! -3553&3A&73 5 ! %XRidgXPhCTRgTi! gdPSrPt$%eeaTgPcS'TcigPaDTgbXcPa$ !-+./*)0/1-+ rrrhWPrbpiRdb %XRTegThXSTci !! GPaSdgU%hidgXPepQaXRhePRTgTcdqPiXdc$6T TgcPgSXc )iWCi 8TrHdg`8H ' #>!-+./*)0/1-+ ! )7F @&7*5 5! ! %QQdii'PeXiPa PcPVTbTci$4TghTtPgSTch PaaiWT piaTi'daaTRiXdc$ GWXiTWPaaCi rrrXQTsRdchigpRiXdcRdb gThXSTci 6XiiaTTSCRWdda2dphTPcS)aXhPQTiWgrXc2XVWCRWdda$8dgShigdb 8TrHdg`8H hidgThbpaiXeaTadRPiXdch ($:,/02,*!*,43,*%5-+ !!!! 50B0@ @0&0@@ 5 ! TWPQXaXiPiXdcdUrPiTgbPXchqPgXdphhigTTihXc8TrPg`84$8H( D ) gdPSrPt rrrYURhdcRdb 'WXTUTsTRpiXqT hXVchigpRipgThPcSVpXSTgPXahCiPiTchaPcS gdcspTTch$ i%Tgcdc 2PR`TchPR`84 Gdg`h PcpUPRipgTSPhaPcigTbTSXPiXdc'dc)SXhdc$84( D dpiTrXSTcXcVPcSQgXSVTgTeaPRTbTci )*-*4!-+/*40/-*.'+0 !! ! @&7* #0@)@ 5 ! DWT PaaPi PtaPuP$TS)sgdpcSPRXaXit$2XaidcPgSTcccPi Ptcdg%qT rrrPpgdgPRdcigPRidghRdb gThXSTci CE8HCidct gdd`$CHC' 6dcVhaPcS dc`dc`dbP8H &,+,74+!-+./*)0/1-+!- ! &@007 ) #0701&7 5 ! E C$ dgVPcCiPcaTt$ Pc`dU%bTgXRP$ Ti6XUTTPa)hiPiT GiWCi rrrWTcTVPcRdb 'WPXgbPcRWXTUTsTRpiXqT ! ! 8TrHdg`8H &537A C@F0 gThXSTciRWXTUdeTgPiXcV dUUXRTg 9,,=.04*1+,'+0 !! 3&@) -00*A 5 ! adQPaDTgbXcPah$(8H PgXcT$Cadde'WPccTa gXSVTGPciPVW 'dbbTgRT(gXqT rrrrTT`hbPgXcTRdb gThXSTci Pg`rPt4dcTh TPRWCiPiTPg`$6drTgPhhPXRXqTghTSXbTcigTbdqPa 'gPcUdgS84 3:484!-+./*)0/1-+!-*54+9),-+"",04//,1.!-+./*)0/1-+!-*5<2102*4+=,9+1+/24+9/2*,.5,0/1?,:6-+:4./6,4*'.:1./9,0:1+,9/-54*/10154/,1+/21.6,4*'..)*?,65=4+.=475<2102*4+=,9/21*9-+:4./6,4*'.:1./919+-/*,.5-+9/-/21.6,4*'..)*?,6 1,< @-*= 4*,4 XcRapSTh 8Tr Hdg` 'Xit PcS 8PhhPp CpUUda` PcS GThiRWThiTg RdpciXTh Xc 8Tr Hdg` PcS TgVTc )hhTs 2pShdc PcS EcXdc RdpciXTh Xc 8Tr 4TghTt @&37.A ,0( /@* CA370AA phTh hiPUU gThTPgRW TsiTchXqT hpgqTth PcS iWT bdhi RpggTci gTUTgTcRTh PqPXaPQaT id egdSpRT Xih aXhih Qpi iWTgT Xh cd VpPgPciTT iWPi iWThT aXhiXcVh PgT RdbeaTiT Dd fpPaXUt Udg iWXh aXhi P RdchigpRiXdc RdbePct bphi WPqT P 8Tr Hdg` PgTP dUUXRT PcS bphi QpXaS egdYTRih Xc iWT PgTP %aa XcUdgbPiXdc rPh hpeeaXTS Qt iWT RdbePcXTh TqTcpT UXVpgTh PgT Udg UXhRPa tTPgh TcSXcV (TR pcaThh diWTgrXhT cdiTS TqTcpT UXVpgTh WPqT QTTc gdpcSTS id dcT STRXbPa eaPRT Pc`XcVh PgT QPhTS dc pcgdpcSTS cpbQTgh TcTgPiTS Ugdb egdYTRih QpXai Xc iWT 8Tr Hdg` PgTP TcTgPiTS Ugdb egdYTRih QpXai Xc iWT 8Tr Hdg` PgTP Xc iWT bdciWh TcSTS (TR paaiXbT PcS UpaaiXbTTfpXqPaTci dcat Ph dU 4pcT CTaTRiTS egdYTRihRaXTcih Udg rdg` RdbeaTiTS dg pcSTgrPt Xc iWT 8Tr Hdg` PgTP Xc %aa gTqTcpT XcRapSTh qPapT dU RdchigpRiXdc eaPRTS XhRPa tTPg TcSh CTei %aa gTqTcpT XcRapSTh qPapT dU RdchigpRiXdc eaPRTS c Pt RdbePct RWPcVTS Xih cPbT Ugdb dqXh 6TcS 6TPhT 6 cR XhRPa tTPg TcSh 4pcT TqTcpT Ugdb hdbT egdYTRih XcRapSTh qPapT dU RdchigpRiXdc eaPRTS !XhRPa tTPg TcSh CTei XhRPa tTPg TcSh 4pat XhRPa tTPg TcSh 8dq %aa gTqTcpT XcRapSThqPapTdURdchigpRiXdceaPRTS XhRPatTPgTcSh Ri ThTPgRW+CpuPccTPcPgP)bXat6PTgbTg Crain’s Health Tech The “Big Data” Revolution Transforming Summit: New York’s Health Care Industry Health care information technology is changing fast, and Panel Discussions entrepreneurs have an unprecedented opportunity to deliver Payers and Providers: Making Health Tech Work innovations to hospitals, doctors, providers and insurers. Join Crain’s Panelists: New York Business at a thought-provoking gathering of HIT s 0AMELA "RIER innovators, start-ups and the New York health care community at President and CEO, Maimonides Medical Center Crain’s Health Tech Summit: The “Big Data” Revolution s .EIL 3 #ALMAN -$ President and CEO, The Institute for Family Health; Professor and Transforming New York’s Health Care Industry. Chair Department of Family Medical and Community Health, Mount Sinai School of Medicine /PENING +EYNOTE $ISCUSSION s -ARCO $IAZ IBM on Watson: Overview of the system, impact, implications and the VP Benefits, North America, Thomson Reuters opportunities s #HARLES % 3AUNDERS -$ 3PEAKERS Chief Executive Officer of Emerging Businesses, Aetna Health Tech: Innovations and the Market Panelists: s 3UNDEEP "HAM CEO, Medivo !* ,ANG, Senior Vice Dan Cerutti, Vice s $AVID "LUMENTHAL -$ -00 President of Application President, IBM Watson Chief Health Information and Innovation Officer, Partners Development WellPoint, Inc. Commercialization HealthCare s -ARIA 'OTSCH %VENT )NFORMATION President and CEO, New York City Investment Fund DATE: TIME: s #HAIM )NDIG Tuesday, November 13, 2012 Networking Breakfast: CEO, Phreesia 8:00AM – 8:30AM VENUE: Program: 2%')34%2 4/$!9 Sheraton New York Hotel & Towers 8:30AM – 11:30AM CRAINSNEWYORKCOMEVENTS HEALTHCARETECH 811 Seventh Avenue @ 53rd St. COST TO ATTEND: 0,!4).5- 30/.3/2 &OR