International Organisation for Standardisation s3

INTERNATIONAL ORGANISATION FOR STANDARDISATION ORGANISATION INTERNATIONALE DE NORMALISATION ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 11 CODING OF MOVING PICTURES AND AUDIO

ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 11 N6701 Palma de Mallorca – October 2004

Source Leonardo Chiariglione, Convenor Title Report of the 70th meeting Status

Report of the 70th meeting 1 Opening The 70th WG11 meeting was held at Palma de Mallorca on 2004/10/17-21 at the kind invitation of AENOR, the Spanish National Body. 2 Roll call of participants Annex 1 gives the attendance list. 3 Approval of agenda Annex 2 gives the agenda approved. 4 Allocation of contributions Annex 3 gives the list of input contributions 5 Communications from Convenor

6 Report of previous meeting This was approved. 7 Processing of NB Position Papers National Body papers were considered and answers provided where appropriate. 8 Work plan

8.1 Media coding

8.1.1 MPEG-4 Audio The following document was approved 6795 Draft 3rd Edition of 14496-3

8.1.2 New levels in MPEG-4 Simple profile The following documents were approved 6708 Disposition of Comments on ISO/IEC 14496-2:2004 PDAM2 6709 Text of ISO/IEC 14496-2:2004 FPDAM2 New Levels in Simple Profile

1 8.1.3 New levels in MPEG-4 Simple profile conformance The following documents were approved 6741 DoC on ISO/IEC 14496-4:200x/PDAM10 New Levels for Simple Profile Conformance 6742 ISO/IEC 14496-4:200x/FPDAM10 New Levels for Simple Profile Conformance

8.1.4 Implementation of IDCT The following documents were approved 6707 Request for Sub-division of ISO/IEC 11172-6 6735 Text of ISO/IEC 11172-6 CD: Specification for Implementation of Inverse Discrete Cosine Transform 8.2 Composition coding

8.2.1 Lightweight Scene Representation The following documents were approved 6852 DoC on ISO/IEC 14496-20/CD 6853 Text of ISO/IEC 14496-20/FCD 8.3 Description coding

8.3.1 MPEG-7 Profiles The following documents were approved 6826 DoC of FCD of ISO/IEC 15938-9 6827 Text of FDIS of ISO/IEC 15938-9 8.4 Systems support

8.4.1 Carriage of ISAN and V-ISAN metadata The following documents were approved 6846 DoC on ISO/IEC 13818-1:2000/FPDAM4 6847 Text of ISO/IEC 13818-1:2000/FDAM4 8.5 IPMP

8.5.1 MPEG-21 IPMP Components The following document was approved 6772 ISO/IEC CD 21000-4 MPEG-21 IPMP Components 8.6 Digital Item

8.6.1 Digital Item Binarisation The following documents were approved 6860 DoC on ISO/IEC 21000-16/CD 6861 Text of ISO/IEC 21000-16/FCD

8.6.2 Event Reporting The following document was approved 6783 ISO/IEC CD 21000-15 MPEG-21 Event Reporting

2 8.7 Multimedia architecture

8.7.1 MPEG-J extension for rendering The following document was approved 6751 Text of ISO/IEC 14496-21 CD

8.7.2 Digital Item Processing The following documents were approved 6781 DoC for the CD of ISO/IEC 21000-10 MPEG-21 Digital Item Processing 6780 ISO/IEC FCD 21000-10 MPEG-21 Digital Item Processing

8.7.3 MPEG Multimedia Middleware The following documents were approved 6835 MPEG Multimedia Middleware Requirements v2.0 6836 Call for Proposals for MPEG Multimedia Middleware 8.8 Reference implementation

8.8.1 MPEG-2 Reference software The following documents were approved 6737 ISO/IEC 13818-5 MPEG-2 Reference Software 2nd edition 9 Liaison matters

10 Organisation of this meeting

10.1 Tasks for subgroups Tasks were assigned to achieve the goals of the work plan. 10.2 Joint meetings The following joint meetings were held Groups What Where Day Time Req, Sys M3W, Laser, Font, MP4 FF Sys Mon 16:00-18:15 Req, MDS MP7 Profiles, JPSearch Req Tue 09:00-10:30 Req, MDS MP21 promotion Req Tue 10:45-11:30 Req, Vid, Aud, MDS, Sys MPEG-A, Streaming DI, MCF Req Tue 11:30-13:00 Req, Vid IDCT, SVC, Omnidir video Req Tue 14:00-15:30 Req, Tst MP21 PAT Amd Req Tue 15:30-16:30 Req, Aud Profiles, ScAC Aud Tue 16:30-17:30 Aud, Sys Time stamps Aud Tue 17:30-18:30 Req + Communicating MPEG Req Tue 17:30-18:00 Sys, MDS Applic. spec. binary encod Sys Wed 14:00-14:30 Req, MDS MP21 promotion Req Wed 15:30-16:30 MDS, Int MP21 Ref SW and Reqs MDS Wed 16:00-17:00 Req, MDS MP21 MDS Wed 11:30-12:30 Req, Sys, Vid, Aud, MDS MPEG-A Req Thu 09:00-10:15 Req, Sys Laser Sys Thu 10:15-10:30 Req, Sys M3W Req Thu 10:30-11:00 Req, MDS IPMP Scope Req Thu 12:00-13:00 Req, Vid 3DAV, SVC Vid Thu 14:00-15:00

3 Req, MDS MPEG-21 MAF MDS Thu 16:00-16:30

10.3 Administrative matters

10.3.1 Schedule of future MPEG meetings The following meeting schedule was approved

Meeting City Country Yr. Mo. Days 70th Palma de Mallorca ES 04 10 18-22 71st Hong Kong CN 05 01 17-21 72nd Busan KR 05 04 18-22 73rd Poznań PL 05 07 25-29 74th ? FR 05 10 17-21 75th ? ? 06 01 23-27

10.3.2 Promotional activities An ad hoc group with this mandate was re-established. 11 Planning of future activities The following ad hoc groups were established 6790 14496-3:2001/AMD 2:2004/DCOR 1 (SSC) 6749 AFX CE description 6750 AFX VM 16.0 6730 AHG on 3DAV Coding 6752 AHG on AFX documents, CEs, and software 6817 AHG on Audio Standards Maintenance 6734 AHG on Communicating MPEG to the business Community 6728 AHG on Core Experiments in Scalable Video Coding 6727 AHG on Description Tools for MPEG-7 New Visual Extensions 6842 AHG on Digital Item Serialization 6822 AHG On Exploration of Scalable Audio and Speech Coding 6840 AHG on Font Format Representation 6732 AHG on further Exploration in Wavelet Video Coding 6837 AHG on JPEG Liaison 6838 AHG on MAF Development 6725 AHG on Maintenance of MPEG-4 Visual related Documents, Reference Software and Conformance 6726 AHG on Maintenance of MPEG-7 Visual related Documents and Reference Software 6865 AHG on MPEG File Formats 6788 AHG on MPEG URI Fragment IDs 6787 AHG on MPEG-21 DIA 6785 AHG on MPEG-21 DIP& DID 2nd Edition

4 6786 AHG on MPEG-21 Event Reporting 6841 AHG on MPEG-21 Vision Update 6820 AHG on MPEG-4 Lossless Audio Coding 6755 AHG on MPEG-4 Part 9: Reference Hardware Description Phase 1 and 2. 6818 AHG on MPEG-7 Audio 6753 AHG on MPEG-J extensions for rendering 6733 AHG on Organization of a Workshop on Future Directions in Video Compression 6839 AHG on Persistent Association 6729 AHG on Scalable Video Model and SVM Software 6864 AHG on Scene Representation 6819 AHG on Spatial Audio Coding 6821 AHG on Symbolic Music Representation 6731 AHG on Video Coding Tools Repository 6724 AHG on Video IDCT Specification 6863 AHG on XML Structure Binarization and Streaming

12 Resolutions of this meeting These were approved (N6799) 13 A.O.B There was no other business 14 Closing The meeting closed at 2004/10/22T20:15.

5 Annex 1 Attendance list

DavidAxelMyriamGiven Scott Name TaubmanBeckerAmielhFamily Name TheCISRA UniverityCompany Of Nsw / Organization AustraliaCountry ChristianKlausIanShaneGerrard TimmererLeopoldBurnettLaufDrury UniversityUow/EnikosTitr University KlagenfurtOf Wollongong Of Wollongong/Enikos AustriaAustralia SaarRobbieFrederikAlexandruAdrian DeSalomieMunteanu ZutterSutterKeukelaere GhentEtro Department, University Vrije Universiteit Brussel Belgium PeteerMaximiliamBorisJanRik ScholkensBaraisRoggeBormansVan De Walle VrijeMetanousKapeldreefGhent Universiteit University 75 Brussel-Ibbt Belgium WenAlex GaoLuccisano InstituteScientific Of Atlanta Computing Canada Technology ChinaCanada VaananenJaniChun-JenYi-ShingWen-Hsiao MauriLainemaTsaiTungPeng NokiaNCTU/ITRINational TaiwanChiao-Tung University University FinlandChina AbdellatifClaudeJean-ClaudeCyrilFx BenjellounSeyratDufourdConcolatoNuttall Touimi FranceExpwayEnst/StreamezzoENSTCISAC Telecom France IsabelleRoyanAvaroFredericAlexandre AmonouJeromeOlivierLorasCotarmanach France-TélécomFrance-TelecomFrance Telecom France DavidJean-BernardPierrickStephanePatrick ViretteRaultPhilippePateuxGioia France-Télécom France MichelBeatrice BarlaudPesquet-Popescu IGET-ENST 3s.Laboratory France GregoireJeromeFrancoiseMariusChristine CarpentierBarthelemyPreteuxPredaGuillemot IRCAMINTINRIA France OlawaletitusJeromeMarcStephaneVincent AbeVieronGuezValenteBottreau Vuche ChurchThomsonSCPPPhilipsIrisa-Inria Digital Choir Systems Labs GambiaFrance ChristophPeterBernhardAndreasMartin FehnListFeitenSchneiderDietz FhG/HHIDeutscheCoding Technologies Telekom, T-Systems Gmbh Germany MatthiasRalfThomasAljoschaHeiko GruhneGeigerWiegandSmolicSchwarz Fraunhofer IDMTHHI Germany StefanJuergenBernhardHaraldOliver KraegelohHerreGrillFuchsBaum Fraunhofer IIS Germany UlrichThomasDetlefHerbertRalph BenzlerWediMarpeThomaSperschneider RobertPanasonicFraunhofer Bosch InstituteIIS Gmbh, HHI Fv/Slh Germany PeterAndreasGeroMathiasJens-Rainer AmonHutterBaseWienOhm SiemensRwth Aachen AG University Germany CarstenHelgeTobiasTilmanGabriel HerpelDrummOelbaumLiebchenPanis ThomsonTecnnischeTechnischeTechnicalSiemens Ag University UniversitaetUniversitat Of Munchen Berlin Germany JoernKlausIngoAndreasJens OstermannDiepoldWolfGraffunderSpille UniversitätTUM-LDVT-SystemsThomson Hannover Germany ZviValentinEdwardVasileiosTillman LifshitzMuresanCookeMezarisWeyde OptibaseCentreInformaticsUniversity For Ltd. Of DigitalAnd Osnabrük Telematics Video Processing IsraelIrelandGreeceGermany MarcoVittorioMaurizioFilippoAharon TagliasacchiBaronciniCampanaiChiariglioneGill PolitecnicoFUBExitechCEDEOZoran Microelectronics Srl Di Milano ItalyIsrael AndreaPaoloPierfrancescoRiccardoGiovanni ValottiNesiBelliniLeonardiCordara UniversityTelecom Italia Of FlorenceBrescia Lab Italy YoshinoriYukikoTomokazuKimihikoMasatsugu SugiharaOguraMurakamiKazuiKitamura JapanIpsj/ItscjHitachiFujitsuFor More ElectronicsLaboratoires Convenient & Ltd.Information Av Life Japan HirofumiTokumichiKohtaroTakeshiTakafumi NishikawaMurakamiAsaiNorimatsuUeno MitsubishiMatsushita Electric Electric Corporation Japan HiromiMasayukiToshiakiCraigYoshihisa KinoshitaTanimotoFujiiSchultzYamada NaraNagoyaMultimediaMitsubishi Institute University Electric Architectures Of Science CorporationGraduate And School Technology Of Engineering Japan MasanoriTakahiroAkioToshiyukiKazumasa SanoKimotoYamadaNomuraYamazawa NHKNECNara Institute Of Science And Technology Japan ThiowSeishiTakehiroMasakiNoboru Keng TanTakamuraMoriyaKitaharaHarada NTT Docomo, Inc. Japan NaoyaTakanoriTakashiHideakiYukihiro TanakaSenohNishiKimataBando PanasonicOkiNTT-AtNTT/ Electric Cyber Industry Space Lab. Co, Ltd1-1 Hikarino -Oka Japan SatoshiTakeshiItaruTakuyoTeruhiko ItoChujohKanekoKogureSuzuki ToshibaTokyoTheSony University Corp. Polytechnic Corporation Of Tokio University Japan SangthoonJaejoonHiroshiHidekiSatoru OhKimWatanabeTakeharaSakazume DCFDaeguWasedaVictor Company University University Of Japan. Ltd KoreaJapan YeSeyoonYongiuChung-HyunJeho Sun JoungJeongChoAhnNam ETRI Korea Tae-JoonWeonJaeDaeheeKyeheon Gong Geun ParkOhKim ETRI Korea EueeWonYoungiooJeongilSoo-Jon YoungS JangYooSongSeoPark HanyangETRI University Korea Ik-HwanSeungliMunchurlHendrySun Young ChoYangKimHendryLee InhaInformationHanyang University University And Communications Korea HyongKiYong-SooJongDong-Seok Seob Tae Joong KimChoiJeong KangwonKAISTInha University National University Korea JungByeongKeunHyukminManbae HoSoo Ho ChoiParkKwonKim KTKETIKBSKangwon National University Korea DougyoungKyungmoKwangoGwang-HoonSeoung Jun SuhParkKoOh KyungheeKyungKwangwoon Hee University Unniversity University Korea SuengSueng-WookHee-SukByeongWon Ha Hyun Moon KimParkPangJeon LgLGKyunghee ElectronicsElectronics University Inc.Inc. Korea Korea JongYoung-KwonCheonDoeJi-Ho Hyun Jin Seog ChaeLimKimYoonPark NetntvNet&TvMovainLG Electronics Inc. InterjungboInc. 1582-6 Inc. Hanseo Co.Lct Bldg. 8f. Korea JooheeMahnjinJeongSang-KyunSangwook Hwan KimHanAhn SamsungSamsumg AitA.I.T. Korea Woo-JinHyunEunmiHi-YoungHye-Yun Mun HanKimOh Samsung ElectronicsAit Korea Yung-LyulMinhHaeKimBae KeunKwang Tuan LeeLeKimJong Ryul SejongSamsung University Electronics Korea SeokWoongNammeeKyungheeHan-Gil Hoon Il KimChoiMoonJi TheSungkyunkwanSITSeoul Korea National Digital University University Contents Forum Korea WilhelmusDirkLeonJanWerner Jeroen Ha BrulsBreebaartVanOomen DeDer Kerkhof Meer Philips Research Netherlands MarekGisleNeilAndrewJean H.A. Alexander DomanskiBjontegaardMckencieTokmakoffGelissen PoznanTandbergFbnTelematicaPhilips Netherlans Research University Instituut Of Technology PolandNorwayNetherlansNetherlands RongshanSusantoZhengguoAntonioFernando YuRahardjaLiNavarroPereira InstituteInstitueTelecomunicationsInstituto ForForSuperior InfocommInfocomm Tecnico Institute Research Research SingaporePortugal KokShengmeiChakSiXiao Wei Seng Joo ChongShenLeeMaLin PanasonicInstitute OfFor SingaporeComputing Infocomm Laboratoiries TechnologyResearch Singapore SuaJiunnMenZhongyangVincent HongHuang Bin NeoLimLeeHuangDiong Panasonic Singapore Laboratoiries Singapore PauloDavidMarcThomasChong Soon VillegasAparicioGauvinKummer-HardtLim TelefonicaSdaeAioPanasonic I+DSingapore Laboratoiries SpainSingapore KristopherEvaJaimeJoseFrancisco M KjörlingRodriguezDelgadoMartinezMoran CodingUniversitatUniversidadUniv. Politecnica Technologies Pompeu Autonoma De FabraMadrid Ab De (Madrid Upf) SwedenSpain MarcoChristofTouradjPerHeiko MattavelliFallerEbrahimiFröjdhPurnhagen EPFLEricssonCoding Technologies Ab SwitzerlandSweden FrancescoDiegoJean-ClaudeThomasGiorgio ZilianiSantaMichelouDiZoia Giacomo Cruz VisiowaveMiralab,UniversityEPFL Of Geneva Switzerland PaulKiaMartinMikeFrederic JessopNgRussNilssonVexo IfpiIcsrim-UniversityBTVrlab-Epfl Of Leeds UKSwitzerland CatherineRayRobertLeszekMiroslaw Steven James GrantTaylorO'callaghanCieplinskiBober NineNDSMitsubishi Tiles Electric Ite-Vil-LabIte-Vil UK PingNielsChrisCharithGary James WuRumpBarlasAbhayaratneCalder TandbergRightscomQueenOxford SemiconductorMary Television University Limited Ltd Of London UK TibetBarryVladimirScottSimon MimarHaskellLevantovskyFosheeWatt AtherosAppleAgfaAdobeUniversal Monotype Computer Communications Music Corp. International USAUK ThomasFengShengKatherineSchuyler Che DemartiniWangZhongCornogQuackenbush ContentGuard,ConesantBroadcomAvidAudio Technology Research Systems Inc. Labs. Inc USA AlanWalterFrankXinBradford Jeffrey C Robert SeefeldtGishBossenWangGandee DolbyDoCoMoContentGuard, Laboratories USA Labs.Inc. USA MarcoPankajMajidThomasMark Stuart M L HurtadoTopiwalaRabbaniMcmahonVinton IBMFastEastmanDolby Vdo Laboratories KodakLLC USA AndrewTeRobMunsiPeter Ming Alaul G. TescherChiuKoenenHaqueSchirling MicrosoftITRI,IntertrustIntelIbm ResearchCorporation Inc USA MikaelMichaelGaryFlorianJames J D Y. Bourges-SevenierKsarSullivanPestoniJohnston MindegoMicrosoft/UsMicrosoft Inc.Corp. Nb USA ChrisAjaySamHuifangAnthony RussellLuthraNarasimhanSunVetro MPAAMotorolaMitsubishi Inc. Electric Research L USA MartaJustinCharlesWoMarina KarczewiczRidgeFenimoreChangBosi NokiaNISTMPEG Inc. LA,LLC USA BruceYuriyVijiHsin-HaoGerald Anthony BlockReznikRaveendranChenPowell RecordingRealnetworksQualcommOES/ITRINTT DoCoMo, Industry Inc. Inc. Assc. Of America USA ViswanathanMohammedShijunShawminJohn William, Zubair SwaminathanVisharamSunLeiWoods SunSonySharpRensselaer Microsystems Electronics Labs PolytechnicOf America Inc Institute USA PengHaopingGregoryJillFelix M William YinYuCookBoyceFernandes ThomsonTexas Instruments Inc USA RobertNerminJonathanTruongMihaela DQ TurneyOsmanovicBoleyNguyenVan Der Schaar XilinxUniversityUcdsdUC Davis Of Miami USA

6 Annex 2 Agenda

Agenda item 1. Opening 2. Roll call of participants 3. Approval of agenda 4. Allocation of contributions 5. Communications from Convenor 6. Report of previous meeting 7. Processing of NB Position Papers 8. Work plan 1. 8.1 Media coding 1.1. AVC Fidelity Range Extensions Conformance 1.2. Scalable Video Coding 1.3. Audio Lossless Coding 1.4. Audio Scalable Lossless Coding 1.5. 1-bit Audio Lossless Coding 1.6. Spatial Audio Coding 1.7. AFX Extensions 1.8. Streaming Text Format 1.9. Video Coding Tool Repository 1.10 3D AV Coding . 1.11 Scalable Audio and Speech Coding 1.12 Font Format Representation 8.2 Composition coding 2.1. XMT extensions 2.2. Lightweight Scene Representation 2.3. Symbolic Music Representation 8.3 Description coding 3.1. Video Descriptor Extensions 3.2. Audio Descriptor Extensions 3.3. MPEG-7 Profiles 8.4 Systems support 4.1. Carriage of ISAN and V-ISAN metadata 4.2. Timestamps and Audio Codec Behavior 8.5 IPMP 5.1. MPEG-21 IPMP Framework 8.6 Digital Item 6.1. Digital Item Declaration 6.2. Digital Item Binarisation 6.3. DIA Conversions and Permission 6.4. Event Reporting 6.5. MPEG-21 Conformance

7 8.7 Transport and File Format 7.1. MPEG-21 File Format 8.8 Multimedia architecture 8.1. MPEG-J extension for scene control 8.2. MPEG-J extension for rendering 8.2. Digital Item Processing 8.3. MPEG Multimedia Middleware 8.9 Reference implementation 9.1. AVC Fidelity Range Extensions Reference Software 9.2. MPEG-4 Visual Reference Hardware Description 9.3. MPEG-4 AVC Reference Hardware Description 9.4. MPEG-21 Reference Software 8.1 Application formats 0 10.1 Music player Application Format . 10.2 Photo album Application Format . 8.1 Maintenance 1 11.1 Systems coding standards 11.2 Video coding standards 11.1 Audio coding standards 11.2 Visual description coding standards 11.3 Audio description coding standards MDS standards 9. Liaison matters 10 Organisation of this meeting . 10. Tasks for subgroups 1 10. Joint meetings 2 11 Administrative matters . 11. Schedule of future MPEG meetings 1 11. Promotional activities 2 12 Planning of future activities . 13 Resolutions of this meeting . 14 A.O.B . 15 Closing .

8 9 Annex 3 Input document list

Number Authors Title 11149 Wo Chang Document Register for SC29/WG11 Meeting Palma, ES 11150 Mike Ksar AHG on Font Format Representation Vladimir Levantovsky 11151 Chris Barlas AHG on MPEG-21 Integration and Outreach Chris Russell 11152 Wo Chang AHG on MAF Olivier Avaro 11153 Robert Turney AHG on MPEG-4 Part 9 Reference Hardware Description Phase 1 and 2 Marco Mattavelli 11154 Claude Seyrat AHG on XML Structure Binarization and Streaming Andreas Hutter Itaru Kaneko 11155 Jean-Claude Dufourd AHG on Scene Representation Alexandre Cotarmanac.h Young-Kwon Lim 11156 T. Chiang AHG on Maintenance of MPEG-4 Visual related Documents, Reference Yi-Shin Tung Software and Conformance Chung-Neng Wang 11157 L. Cieplinski AHG on Maintenance of MPEG-7 Visual related Documents and Reference A. Yamada Software Sang-Kyun Kim Stephan Herrmann 11158 Miroslaw Bober AHG on Description Tools for New Visual Extensions Sang-Kyun Kim 11159 Mihaela van der Schaar AHG on Core Experiments in Scalable Video Coding Justin Ridge 11160 Heiko Schwarz AHG on Scalable Video Model and SVC Software Jizheng Xu Mathias Wien David Taubman 11161 Aljoscha Smolic AHG on 3DAV Coding Hideaki Kimata 11162 Euee S. Jang Kohtaro Asai AHG on Video Coding Tools Repository none 11163 Jean Gelissen AHG on MPEG Multimedia Middleware Olivier Avaro Martin Russ 11164 Myriam Amielh AHG on MPEG 21 Media Locators Gerrard Drury YongJu Cho 11165 Simon Watt AHG on MPEG-21 IPMP 11166 Christian Timmerer AHG on MPEG-21 DIA Thomas DeMartini 11167 Gerrard Drury AHG on MPEG-21 DIP

10 Frederik De Keukaleare Munchurl Kim 11168 FX Nuttall AHG on MPEG-21 Event Reporting Andrew Tokmakoff 11169 Marius Preda AHG on AFX documents, CEs, and software Mahnjin Han Patrick Gioia 11170 Mikael Bourges-Sevenier AHG on MPEG-J extensions for rendering Vishy Swaminathan Itaru Kaneko 11171 Ralph Sperschneider AHG on Audio Standard Maintenance 11172 Matthias Gruhne AHG on MPEG-7 Audio 11173 S. Quackenbush AHG on Spatial Audio Coding 11174 Tilman Liebchen AHG on MPEG-4 Lossless Audio Coding 11175 Paolo Nesi AHG on Symbolic Music Representation Giorgio Zoia 11176 Jim Johnston AHG on Exploration of Scalable Audio and Speech Coding 11177 Jean-Claude Dufourd Initial Reference Software for LASeR and SAF 11178 Zhongyang Huang IPMP_Scheme Description for MPEG-21 IPMP Ming Ji Shengmei Shen Taka Senoh Takafumi Ueno 11179 Shane Lauf Examination of technology in IPMP WD 1.0 11180 TVA via SC 29 Secretariat Liaison Statement from the TV-Anytime Forum [SC 29 N 6237] 11181 SC 29 Secretariat Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC FCD 15938-9 [SC 29 N 6240] 11182 Niels Rump for the AhG Editor's input on possible 2nd Edition on PAT 11183 Mike Ksar Proposed Text - Open Font Format Specifications (OFFS) - Single Document - based on OpenType(R) v1.4 11184 on behalf of the MPEG-21 Notes from the Mountain View MPEG-21 IPMP AdHoc Meeting IPMP AdHoc group. 11185 ITTF via SC 29 Table of Replies on ISO/IEC 14496-11/FPAM 4 [SC 29 N 6249] Secretariat 11186 ITTF via SC 29 Table of Replies on ISO/IEC FDIS 21000-7 [SC 29 N 6251] Secretariat 11187 Zhengguo LI Customer Oriented Scalable Video Coding Xiaokang Yang Kengpang Lim Xiao Lin Susanto Rahardja Feng Pan 11188 Akio Yamada Contribution to MPEG-7 Visual Conformance 11189 Shane Lauf Mobile MPEG-21 Peer Implementation Ian Burnett 11190 Joerg Heuer MPEG-7 BiM for Unidirectional Networks Andreas Hutter 11191 ITTF via SC 29 Table of Replies on ISO/IEC 14496-4:200X/FDAM 7 [SC 29 N 6263]

11 Secretariat 11192 Jean H.A. Gelissen MPEG Multimedia Middleware Requirements v.2.0 11193 Niels Rump for the editors Editors' Input towards CD of 21000-15 11194 Thomas Di Giacomo CE Report for Physically-Based Animation of Cloth with Nadia Magnenat- PhysicsShapeProperties node Thalmann Marius Preda Francoise Preteux 11195 Jong-Tae Kim Objective Impairment Test Method for Video PAT Evaluation Weon-Geun Oh Won-young Yoo Hae-Kwang Kim Heung-Kyu Lee Young-Ho Suh 11196 Thomas Di Giacomo Proposal of a PhysicsBoneProperties node Nadia Magnenat- Thalmann Marius Preda Francoise Preteux 11197 Helge Drumm CE - Shadow: Final Results on Reference Software Implementation Thomas Di Giacomo 11198 Jean-Claude Dufourd CE Study of LASeR and SAF CD 11199 Schuyler Quackenbush DRAFT Report on Spatial Audio Coding RM0 Selection Tests (v2) 11200 Schuyler Quackenbush 69th MPEG Audio Subgroup Report 11201 Ik-Hwan Cho Guideline for the Selection of Standardized Test Stimuli in the Evaluation of Weon-Geun Oh Video Watermarking Hae-Kwang Kim Dong-Seok Jeong 11202 Jon Boley Spatial Audio Coding Listening Test Report- University of Miami 11203 Son Tran Implementation issues in MPEG-4 Reference Software Marius Preda Francoise Preteux 11204 Son Tran MPEG-J for real case applications: design of a minimal and universal Marius Preda primitive class Francoise Preteux 11205 Marius Preda Enriching stream control in BBA Francoise Preteux 11206 Marius Preda XMT encoding issues for BBA Octavian Folea Françoise Preteux 11207 Marius Preda http://mpeg.nist.gov/reg/_update.php?docnum=11207 Son Tran Francoise Preteux 11208 IEC TC 100 via SC 29 IEC CDV 62261-1 [SC 29 N 6286] Secretariat 11209 IEC TC 100 via SC 29 IEC CDV 62261-2 [SC 29 N 6287] Secretariat 11210 Jerome Royan Results on the CE for multiresolution footprint-based representation Patrick Gioia

12 11211 Thomas DeMartini Data Types and Methods for Implementing MPEG-21 REL Interpretation Vincent Tieu Reference Software Xin Wang 11212 Shane Lauf Proposed extensible DIDL schema Gerrard Drury Ian Burnett 11213 Shane Lauf Proposed IPMP DIDL schema Ian Burnett 11214 Truong Nguyen New spatial transform in SVC Min Li 11215 Mark Vinton Testing Environment and Procedures for Spatial Coding Performed at Dolby Laboratories 11216 Akio Yamada Proposed Corrigendum item on ISO/IEC 15938-3:2002/Amd.1 11217 Eunmi Oh Fine Grain Scalability in MPEG-4 BSAC multi-channel audio coding Miyoung Kim 11218 Hyuk-Min Kwon Progress of MPEG-21 DIA Utility Software Modules C, D, F, G, L, M, N & Man-Bae Kim AA. Jeho Nam Rin-Chul Kim Hae-Kwang Kim Seungji Yang Truong Cong Thang Yong Man Ro 11219 Wo Chang Draft for MPEG-7 Part 9 FDIS 11220 FX Nuttall MPEG 21 as a secure interoperable DRM ? 11221 Eva Rodriguez IPMP Information Schema Huang Zhongyang 11222 Jerome Royan New proposal for multi-resolution footprint-based representation Patrick Gioia 11223 Joohee Kim Responses to CE4 in SVC Hyeyeon Kim Doohyun Kim 11224 Gary Sullivan IDCT Specification: A Problem and Opportunity 11225 A. G. Tescher for USNB USNB Contribution: Replacement of IDCT Standard 11226 A. G. Tescher for USNB USNB Contribution: Issues for audio lossless coding 11227 A. G. Tescher for USNB USNB Contribution: Fine-grain scalable audio codec 11228 A. G. Tescher for USNB USNB Contribution: Preliminary comments on 14496-3:2001/PDAM 4&5 11229 A. G. Tescher for USNB USNB Contribution: JPSearch and MPEG-7 11230 Shun-ichi Sekiguchi Proposed corrections to visual part of MPEG-4 conformance text Yoshihisa Yamada Kohtaro Asai 11231 Hideaki Kimata Anchor bitstreams for preliminary Call for Evidence on multi-view video Masaki Kitahara coding 11232 Hideaki Kimata Framework on free-viewpoint video with shared memory video coding Masaki Kitahara 11233 Ray Taylor Core experiment report for Fast Random Access into MPEG7 BiM streams 11234 Seishi Takamura Proposal of SNR Scalability Method with up to Lossless Enhancement

13 Bandoh Yukihiro Yoshiyuki Yashima 11235 Yukihiro Bandoh Proposal of inter-band bit re-allocation for SVC Seishi Takamura Yoshiyuki Yashima 11236 Fabio Verdicchio Resilience in Scalable Video Coding using Embedded Multiple Description Adrian Munteanu Scalar Quantization Augustin Gavrilescu Jan Cornelis Peter Schelkens 11237 Hongkai Xiong CE Verification Report of HHI on CE2.3: Adaptive Block Transforms Chen Wang Li Song Feng Wu 11238 Eddie Cooke Multiple Image View Synthesis for Virtual Viewpoint Rendering 11239 José M. Martínez A Simple Profile for MPEG-21 DIA Usage Environment description tools Víctor Valdés Luis Herranz Jesús Bescós 11240 Aljoscha Smolic Predictive Compression of Dynamic 3D Meshes Karsten Mueller Philipp Merkle Matthias Kautzner Thomas Wiegand 11241 Peng Yin Complexity Scalable Video Codec Jill Boyce Purvin Pandit Alexis Michael Tourapis 11242 Marco Boltz SVC CE7 - Non-linear adaptation results from Bosch and verification of HHI results 11243 Marco Boltz SVC CE1 - Bosch verification of HHI results for medium grain and combined scalability 11244 Heiko Schwarz Technical description of the HHI proposal for SVC CE1 Tobias Hinz Heiner Kirchhoffer Detlev Marpe Thomas Wiegand 11245 Heiko Schwarz Technical description of the HHI proposal for SVC CE2 Tobias Hinz Detlev Marpe Thomas Wiegand 11246 Heiko Schwarz Technical description of the HHI proposal for SVC CE3 Jikun Shen Detlev Marpe Thomas Wiegand 11247 Heiko Schwarz Technical description of the HHI proposal for SVC CE4 Heiner Kirchhoffer Detlev Marpe Thomas Wiegand 11248 Heiko Schwarz Technical description of the HHI proposal for SVC CE7 Karsten Sühring

14 Detlev Marpe Thomas Wiegand 11249 Chris Barlas MPEG-21 - Comatose or Just Sleeping? Niels Rump 11250 David Crombie Accessible Information Processing in MPEG Roger lenoir Neil McKenzie 11251 Johnston CFI proposed to AGH on Scalable coding 11252 Thomas DeMartini Preliminary Comments on ISO/IEC 21000-2 2nd Edition FCD (Digital Item Marco Hurtado Declaration) Martha Nalebuff Pete Schirling Anthony Vetro Xin Wang 11253 Thomas DeMartini Preliminary Comments on ISO/IEC 21000-7 PDAM1 (Digital Item Marco Hurtado Adaptation) Martha Nalebuff Pete Schirling Anthony Vetro Xin Wang 11254 Thomas DeMartini Preliminary Comments on ISO/IEC FCD 21000-8 (Reference Software) Marco Hurtado Martha Nalebuff Pete Schirling Anthony Vetro Xin Wang 11255 Thomas DeMartini Preliminary comments on Text of ISO/IEC 21000-9 FCD (MPEG-21 File Marco Hurtado Format) Martha Nalebuff Pete Schirling David Singer Anthony Vetro Mohammed Zubair Vishram Xin Wang 11256 Thomas DeMartini Preliminary Comments on ISO/IEC 21000-16 CD (Binary Format) Marco Hurtado Martha Nalebuff Pete Schirling Anthony Vetro Xin Wang 11257 Heiner Kirchhoffer Verification of the Samsung AIT proposal for SVC CE4 Heiko Schwarz 11258 Julien Reichel SVC CE7: Verification of HHI results Francesco Ziliani Diego Santa Cruz 11259 Masayuki Tanimoto FTV (Free Viewpoint Television): Achievements and Challenge Toshiaki Fujii 11260 Yongju Cho Proposed URI scheme for mp4 file format Youngkwon Lim Moonsup Song Hyoung-Joong Kim

15 Jaegon Kim Jin-Woo Hong 11261 Shane Lauf IPMP DIDL Reference Software Contribution Ian Burnett 11262 Christian Timmerer Report of CE on Conversion Parameters Klaus Leopold Dietmar Jannach Hermann Hellwagner Mariam Kimiaei 11263 Inseon Jang Spatial Audio Coding RM0 Selection Test Report - ETRI Jeongil Seo Kyeongok Kang 11264 Jeongil Seo A New Cue Parameter for Spatial Audio Coding Han-gil Moon Seungkwon Beack Inseon Jang Kyeongok Kang Jinwoo Hong 11265 Kyung Mo Park LASER adaptive to time varying resources Kwang Oh Koh 11266 Yung-Lyul Lee Multi-view video coding using 2D direct mode Woo-chul Sung 11267 Paul Jessop Comments on 'Software Copyright Licencing (sic) Disclaimer for MPEG Standards' 11268 Peter Schirling A new way to look at IDCT Joan L. Mitchell Arianne T. Hinds Nenad Rijavec 11269 Masayuki Morimoto Report on the Evaluation Tests for Spatial Audio Coding Systems Hayato 11270 Teemu Saarinen Software implementation of a light-weight REL based DRM system for video Artur Lugmayr streaming to mobile devices 11271 J. J. Chae IPMPTransfer Description for MPEG-21 IPMP Jeho Nam Jae-Gon Kim 11272 Itaru Kaneko Comment on MPEG-J extension for rendering Mark Callow 11273 Hiroshi Yasuda Activity Report of DCCSDP&DCCSDC in Japan Takuyo Kogure 11274 Itaru Kaneko Application Specific Binary Coding (ASBC) of MPEG-21 descriptors Nobuyuki Kinoshita Spencer Cheng 11275 Woo-Jin Han SVC CE1 - Samsung verification of Univ. of Brescia (System I and II) 11276 SuSan Im The reference conformance test model(based on Mpeg-21 dii&didl) SangHoon Oh SeokHoon Kim Spencer Cheng 11277 Woo-Jin Han Technical description of Samsung proposal for SVC CE1 Bae-Keun Lee 11278 Yoon Sung-Yeol Kim Multi-view Video Coding using Layered Depth Image

16 Daehee Kim Sukhee Cho Kugjin Yun Chunghyun Ahn Sooin Lee 11279 Yoon Sung-Yeol Kim Coding of Layered Depth Image using Coherency between Point Samples Daehee Kim Sukhee Cho Kugjin Yun Chunghyun Ahn Sooin Lee 11280 Soo-Jun Park CE Report for Situation/View-based Photo Clustering Experiment (VCE-1, Myung Gil Jang Cross Check) 11281 Soo-Jun Park GT set proposed for situation/view based photo clustering experiment (VCE-1, Myung Gil Jang Cross Check) 11282 Soo-Jun Park Photo EXIF modification report on Ground Truth set of Situation/View based Myung Gil Jang photo clustering CE (VCE-1, Cross Check) 11283 Soo-Jun Park GT set proposed for category based photo classification experiment (VCE-2, Myung Gil Jang Cross Check) 11284 Soo-Jun Park Dataset of VCE-1 and VCE-2 Myung Gil Jang 11285 Won Ha Kim Verfication of SAMSUNG SVC software for CE1 Seyoon Jung 11286 Soo-Jun Park Proposal for a new CE: Query-by-ROI (region of interest) Min-Sung Ryu Chee Sun Won 11287 Jihun Cha A Proposal to Improve Compression Efficiency of LASeR Binary YeSun Joung Representation Won-sik Cheong Kyuheon Kim Young-kwon Lim 11288 Ian Burnett Suggestion to create MPEG-A Part 4 – MPEG-21 Content Format (MCF) 11289 Ian Burnett Requirements for Streaming Digital Items 11290 Myriam Amielh Classification of MPEG MIME types on behalf of the AhG for MPEG-21 Medialocators 11291 Myriam Amielh A Framework for MPEG URI fragment Identifiers Ernest Wan 11292 Sukhee Cho Multi-view video coding using image stitching Daehee Kim Kugjin Yun Chunghyun Ahn Soo In Lee Yongtae Kim Kawnghoon Sohn 11293 Soo-Jun Park CE Report for Image Categorisation into Classes (VCE-2, Cross Check) Myung Gil Jang 11294 Diego Santa-Cruz Verification of results for SVC on CE3: Low Delay 11295 Yoshihisa Yamada Coding performance of Intra-only coding in AVC High Profile Kazuo Sugimoto Kohtaro Asai Tokumichi Murakami 11296 Kyunghee Ji Proposed Changes to MPEG-21 Event Reporting WD v.2.0 Youngjoo Song

17 Nammee Moon Jaegon Kim 11297 Sang-Kyun Kim CE Report for Situation/View-based Photo Clustering Experiment (VCE-1) Seungji Yang Yong Man Ro Ji-Yeun Kim 11298 Sang-Kyun Kim GT set proposed for situation/view based photo clustering experiment (VCE-1) Seungji Yang Yong Man Ro Ji-Yeun Kim 11299 Sang-Kyun Kim Photo EXIF modification report on Ground Truth set of Situation/View based Seungji Yang photo clustering CE (VCE-1) Yong Man Ro Ji-Yeun Kim 11300 Sang-Kyun Kim A proposal of GT set determination where "Time" and "Visual" information Seungji Yang conflict for Situation/View based photo clustering (VCE-1) Yong Man Ro Ji-Yeun Kim 11301 Sang-Kyun Kim CE Report for Category-based Photo Clustering Experiment (VCE-2) Seungji Yang Yong Man Ro Ji-Yeun Kim 11302 Sang-Kyun Kim GT set proposed for category based photo classification experiment (VCE-2) Seungji Yang Yong Man Ro Ji-Yeun Kim 11303 Sang-Kyun Kim CE Report for Face-based Photo Clustering Experiment (VCE-3) Seungji Yang Yong Man Ro Ji-Yeun Kim 11304 Sang-Kyun Kim Photo contribution status for face-based photo clustering experiment (VCE-3) Seungji Yang Yong Man Ro Ji-Yeun Kim 11305 Sang-Kyun Kim Software cross-check result of Dominant Color Temperature experiment Sang Hyun Kim (VCE-4) 11306 Joohee Kim Motion-compensated temporal filtering under delay constraints Hyeyeon Kim 11307 Paolo Nesi Proposed SMR Evaluation Model and Procedure Giorgio Zoia Pierfrancesco Bellini James Ingram Kia Ng Maurizio Campanai Jerome Barthelemy Gregoire Carpentier 11308 Akio Yamada MPEG-7 Visual XM Document version 21.1 Sang-Kyun Kim 11309 Akio Yamada WD 2.1 of MPEG-7 New Visual Extensions Sang-Kyun Kim 11310 Kristofer Kjörling Additions to the profiles under consideration document.

18 11311 LEE Men Huang MCTF-based Scalable Video Coding in Low Delay Mode SHEN Sheng Mei Yoshimasa HONDA 11312 Kristofer Kjörling Company support for the proposed High Efficiency AAC v2 Profile Werner Oomen Takeshi Norimatsu Toshiyuki Nomura Jean-Bernard Rault 11313 Gregoire Carpentier Proposal for a Core Experiment on WeightedScalesDS Jerome Barthelemy 11314 Noboru Harada Proposal of CE for improved floating-point compression using ACFC Takehiro Moriya (Approximate-Common-Factor Coding) in ALS (Audio Lossless Coding) 11315 Senator Jeong Proposed Common Event Descriptor and DataType Yeon-Jeong Jeong Weon-Geun Oh Ki-Song Yoon 11316 Kyuheon Kim KNB comments on MPEG-4 BSAC multi-channel 11317 Sang-Wook Kim Report on verification of test bitstream submissions to Spatial Audio Coding RM0 test 11318 Maria Trocan Cross-Verification of RWTH Results on SVC CE-4 Gregoire Pau Beatrice Pesquet-Popescu 11319 Kohtaro Asai Intra coding tools for AVC High Profile Yoshihisa Yamada 11320 Ruiqin Xiong MSRA scheme for SVC CE1 Xiangyang Ji Jizheng Xu Feng Wu 11321 Xiong Jizheng Xu Cross-Verification of DANAE+Thomson results on SVC CE1 11322 Euee S. Jang Hanyang/Humax Contribution to VCTR Sunyoung Lee JongWoo Won Sungwon Park YongHo Cho YoungRyul Lee 11323 Naoya Tanaka Report on the Listening Tests for the Spatial Audio RM0 Selection Takeshi Norimatsu 11324 Karol Wnukowicz Report on Dominant Color Temperature Descriptor CE (VCE-4) Wladyslaw Skarbek 11325 Robbie De Sutter Using MPEG-21 Part 16 in Applications Christian Timmerer Hermann Hellwagner Rik Van de Walle 11326 Karol Wnukowicz Extension of Dominant Color Temperature Descriptor by Spatial Coherency Wladyslaw Skarbek field 11327 Yi-Shin Tung MPEG-4 Visual: List of Problems Reported, v.13.1 Chung-Neng Wang Tihao Chiang Jens-Rainer Ohm 11328 Vincent Bottreau SVC CE5 - Spatial Transform using Three Lifting Steps filters

19 Christine Guillemot Rashid Ansari Edouard François 11329 Francesco Ziliani Coordinator's report on SVC's CE3: Low Delay 11330 Philippe LUCAS (Orange) Mobile requirements for lightweight scene representation A. COTARMANAC'H (France Télécom) 11331 Jens-Rainer Ohm Draft Guidelines for the SVC CE Process and Elevation Procedure 11332 Cédric Thiénot Results of the Core Experiment on Laser Binarization Grégoire Pau Claude Seyrat 11333 Vittorio Baroncini Suggested Test Method for SVC CE Visual Tests Thiow Keng Tan Tobias Oelbaum 11334 Xiangyang Ji An Architecture of Incorporating MPEG-4 AVC into 3D Subband Video Jizheng Xu Coding Ruiqin Xiong Debin Zhao Feng Wu 11335 Claude Seyrat study of ISO/IEC 21000-16 CD 11336 Frederik De Keukelaere Contribution to DID conformance Rik Van de Walle 11337 Claude Seyrat Requirements for Laser Binarization 11338 Frederik De Keukelaere An object oriented approach for the DIBO APIs Thomas DeMartini Jeroen Bekaert Rik Van de Walle 11339 Saar De Zutter Proposal for DIP bootstrapping Frederik De Keukelaere Rik Van de Walle 11340 A. Hoelzer Report on Spatial Audio Coding Subjective Tests at FhG Test Site C. Spenger D. Weninger J. Herre 11341 Alexandre Cotarmanac'h MPEG General Audio Codecs Pierrick Philippe 11342 Stephan Herrmann Improving the efficiency of a search and retrieval system using MPEG-7 Vasileios Mezaris Visual descriptors Haralambos Doulaverakis Ioannis Kompatsiaris Michael G. Strintzis 11343 Gregoire Pau Response to the SVC CE-3 on coding efficiency with low-delay constraints Beatrice Pesquet-Popescu 11344 Vasileios Mezaris On the potential use of machine learning for image categorization (VCE-2) Symeon Papadopoulos Ioannis Kompatsiaris Michael G. Strintzis 11345 Gregoire Pau MPEG-21 binarisation status with MPEG-7 BiM reference software Claude Seyrat 11346 Tilman Liebchen Proposed Text of Study on ISO/IEC 14496-3:2001/PDAM4 (Audio Lossless

20 Coding) 11347 Tilman Liebchen Report on MPEG-4 ALS Core Experiment 8 (Multi-channel extension for Patrick Runge ALS) 11348 Hendry An improved IPMP tool schema for Resource Protection Jeongyeon Lim Qonita M. Shahab Kyung-Ae Cha Munchurl Kim Keunsoo Park 11349 Hendry An improvement to the MPEG-21 IPMP Info Schema Munchurl Kim Keunsoo Park 11350 Kazumasa Yamazawa Proposal for MPEG-A of omni-directional video Hideaki Kimata Hitoshi Habe 11351 Watt UKNB Comments on ISO/IEC FCD 21000-2 : Digital Item Declaration 11352 Mathias Wien SVC CE4: RWTH Verification of HHI contribution 11353 Holger Crysandt Verification Report of Core Experiment on Audio Rhythm Patterns 11354 Giorgio Zoia MPEG-4 and SMR: report on available functionality for graphics Pierfrancesco Bellini Paolo Nesi Jerome Barthelemy 11355 BNB Preliminary BNB comments on ISO/IEC 21000-2 2nd edition FCD 11356 Jean-Claude Dufourd Report of work on the CE for LASeR Harmonization with SVG 11357 Jean-Claude Dufourd Report of work on the CE on LASeR Binary Representation 11358 Andrew Kinane Updated Status on Hardware Acceleration Module for SA-DCT Valentin Muresan Noel O'Connor 11359 Leszek Cieplinski Cross-verification of RPI results on SVC CE-4 11360 Jean-Charles Gicquel Subjective evaluation of CE1 results Stéphane Pateux Isabelle Amonou Sylvain Kervadec 11361 Jean-Claude Dufourd LASeR/SAF reference software: codec aligned with study 11362 Oliver Baum Proposed WD 0.1 of AudioBIFS v.3 Conformance 11363 V. Bottreau Technical description of the DANAE+Thomson proposal for SVC CE1 E. Francois S. Pateux G. Pau B. Timmerman M. Wien 11364 V.Bottreau SVC CE1: DANAE+Thomson verification of MSRA contribution E. Francois S. Pateux G. Pau B. Timmerman 11365 Benoit Timmerman Response to SVC CE5 - Optimization of tradeoff between motion information Peter Amon and texture Andreas Hutter

21 11366 Valentin Muresan Updated Status on Hardware Acceleration Module for Motion Estimation Noel O'Connor 11367 Benoit Timmerman SVC CE5 - Verification of IRISA results Peter Amon 11368 Nicola Adami SVC CE1: STool - a native spatially scalable approach to SVC Michele Brescianini Riccardo Leonardi Alberto Signoroni 11369 Vincent Bottreau SVC CE5 - Verification of Siemens results 11370 Pierrick Philippe France Telecom's contribution to the CFI on Scalable Audio and Speech Jean Bernard Rault Coding 11371 Christian Timmerer Comments on ISO/IEC 21000-7 COR/1 WD v.1 Joerg Heuer Gabriel Panis Hermann Hellwagner Andreas Hutter 11372 Edouard Francois Discussion on evaluation criteria for experts viewing tests in SVC CE1 Vincent Bottreau Jean Charles Gicquel Mathias Wien Jerome Vieron 11373 Juergen Herre On Evaluation Criteria for Spatial Audio Coding 11374 Cyril Concolato Implementation of LASeR (and of SVG) in the open-source GPAC project 11375 Cyril Concolato Analysis of the study of CD of LASeR 11376 Andreas Hutter Results of the Core Experiment on Laser Binarization Joerg Heuer Bernhard Reiterer 11377 Rongshan Yu Proposed WD changes for Lazy Coding for MPEG-4 Audio Scalable Lossless (SLS) Coding 11378 Nicola Adami Fully embedded entropy coding with arbitrary multiple adaptation capabilities Michele Brescianini Riccardo Leonardi Alberto Signoroni 11379 Rongshan Yu Proposed changes for ISO/IEC 14496-3/PDAM5 (Scalable Lossless Coding) 11380 Kristofer Kjörling Working draft proposal for PS conformance Heiko Purnhagen Andreas Schneider Werner Oomen 11381 Heiko Purnhagen Spatial Audio Coding Listening Test Site Report - CT/Philips Kristofer Kjörling Werner Oomen 11382 Dong-Yan Huang Proposal for Lossless Audio Coding Haibin Huang Rongshan Yu Xiao Lin Susanto Rahardja 11383 Ralf Geiger Proposal for Reduced Complexity of SLS 11384 J. Herre Additional Information on Fraunhofer/Agere Spatial Audio Coding A. Hoelzer Submission C. Spenger

22 11385 Konstantin Hanke Response to SVC CE4 - Spatial Lowpass Transition Filtering 11386 Konstantin Hanke SVC CE3 - Verification of ENST results 11387 Robert O'Callaghan Update of Results in Situation/View-Based Clustering (VCE-1) Miroslaw Bober 11388 Robert O'Callaghan Proposal on Ground Truth for Situation/View-Based Clustering (VCE-1) Miroslaw Bober 11389 werner oomen Working draft proposal for SSC conformance Frans de Bont Erik Schuijers 11390 Robert O'Callaghan Preliminary Results on Image Categorization (VCE-2) Miroslaw Bober 11391 Markus Beermann Quality-adaptive reconstruction-filtering: first results Mathias Wien 11392 Heiko Purnhagen Proposed corrigenda to AMD2, (parametric) Werner Oomen 11393 Kristofer Kjörling Analysis of spatial evaluation results Werner Oomen Jeroen Breebaart 11394 Herbert Thoma Test Bitstreams for Shape Coding 11395 S. R. Quackenbush Cross-check on ALS Core Experiment 11396 Andrea Kofler-Vogt CE report on systems extension (Siemens Index) Joerg Heuer Harald Kosch Andreas Hutter 11397 Heiko Schwarz Coordinators report on SVC CE5: Spatial Scalability 11398 Heiko Schwarz Further improvements of the HHI proposal for SVC CE1 Tobias Hinz Detlev Marpe Thomas Wiegand 11399 Heiko Schwarz Further results for the HHI proposal on combined scalability Detlev Marpe Thomas Wiegand 11400 Andreas Schneider Proposed Addition to MPEG-2 AAC Corrigendum 11401 Yongjun Wu Directional Intra-prediction for CE4 John W. Woods 11402 Yuriy A. Reznik Revision of MPEG-4 ALS Core Experiment 7 Tilman Liebchen 11403 Heiko Purnhagen Additional Information on CT/Philips Spatial Audio Coding System Kristofer Kjörling Werner Oomen 11404 Yuriy A. Reznik Cross-Check of SLS CE4 (Lazy Bitplane Coding) 11405 Gabriel Panis Report of CE on Bit-Stream Adaptation in Constrained and Streaming Christian Timmerer Environments Joerg Heuer Debargha Mukherjee Michael Ransburg Ingo Wolf Andreas Hutter Hermann Hellwagner

23 11406 Yuriy A. Reznik Status of Performance and Complexity of Lossless Audio Coding Architectures 11407 Yuriy A. Reznik Verification Report on ALS CE6 (Higher Predictor Orders) 11408 Daniel Larkin Updated Status of Shape Coding Binary Motion Estimation Hardware Valentin Muresan Acceleration Module 11409 Octavian Folea BBA implementation into AFX encoder: Donation to ISO Marius Preda Francoise Preteux 11410 Yuriy A. Reznik On Mostly-Lossless-Region Scalability 11411 Ihab Amer An IP Block for MPEG-4 Part 10 Context-Based Adaptive Variable Length Wael Badawy Coding (CAVLC) Graham Jullien 11412 Ihab Amer A Hardware Block for 2x2 Hadamard Transform and Quantization with Wael Badawy Application to MPEG–4 Part 10 Graham Jullien 11413 Ihab Amer A SystemC model for 2x2 Hadamard Transform and Quantization with Wael Badawy Application to MPEG–4 Part 10 Graham Jullien 11414 Ihab Amer A Hardware Block for 4x4 Hadamard Transform and Quantization in MPEG-4 Wael Badawy Part 10 Graham Jullien 11415 Ihab Amer A SystemC model for 4x4 Hadamard Transform and Quantization with Wael Badawy application to MPEG-4 Part 10 Graham Jullien 11416 Ihab Amer A Hardware Block for the MPEG-4 Part 10 4x4 Transformation and Wael Badawy Quantization Graham Jullien 11417 Ihab Amer A SystemC Model for the MPEG-4 Part 10 4x4 DCT-like Transformation and Wael Badawy Quantization Graham Jullien 11418 Blaszak Marek Domanski SVC CE6 results at Poznan University of Technology Rafal Lange 11419 Wo Chang MAF Photo Repository and Player 11420 Wo Chang MPEG-7 for WG1 (JPEG) JPSearch Project 11421 Jean-Claude Dufourd LASeR web site and logo Olivier Avaro 11422 Mohammed Zubair Supporting the storage of MPEG-21: Part 13 Scalable Video by an extension Visharam of the ISO Base Media File Format Ali Tabatabai Dave Singer 11423 Mikael Bourges-Sevenier Architecture updates and considerations for MPEG-4 Part 21 11424 Justin Ridge SVC CE6 co-ordinator report 11425 Mohammed Zubair Extending the AVC File Format (14496-15) to support FRExt Visharam Ali Tabatabai Dave Singer 11426 Justin Ridge Verification of SVC CE2 contribution for HHI Yiliang Bao Yilong Liu

24 11427 Justin Ridge FGS subband enhancements for scalable video coding Yiliang Bao Marta Karczewicz Xianglin Wang 11428 Justin Ridge FGS block enhancements for scalable video coding Yiliang Bao Marta Karczewicz Xianglin Wang 11429 Charles Fenimore Comparison of statistical methods for assessment of subjective video quality Stefan Leigh Alan Heckert 11430 Myriam Amielh Preliminary comments of DID v.2 FCD Gerrard Drury Shane Lauf Ian Burnett 11431 T. Mohamed Multiple IP-Core Hardware-Accelerated Software System Framework for W. Badawy MPEG4-Part9 11432 Wo Chang AHG on MPEG-7 Interoperability and Profiling 11433 IEC TC 100 via SC 29 IEC TC 100 NP [SC 29 N 6299] Secretariat 11434 Anthony Vetro Comments on Draft Call or Evidence on Multi-View Video Coding Hanspeter Pfister Wojciech Matusik Jun Xin 11435 Wojciech Matusik Calibration and Rectification Procedures for Multi-Camera Systems Hanspeter Pfister Tim Weyrich Anthony Vetro 11436 Jun Xin Preliminary studies on view interpolation for multi-view video coding Anthony Vetro Hanspeter Pfister Wojciech Matusik 11437 Marco Tagliasacchi Cross-verification of UNSW proposal for SVC CE1 11438 Davide Maestroni Cross-verification of UNSW proposal for SVC CE1 Marco Tagliasacchi Stefano Tubaro 11439 AUNB AUNB Contribution: Participation in core experiments 11440 Satoshi Ito Usage scenarios for composition of motion picture and study of constraint Toru Kambayashi description model for digital rights 11441 David Taubman SVC Core Experiment 1, Description of UNSW Contribution Reji Mathew Davide Maestroni Stefano Tubaro 11442 Miljan Vuletic Virtualisation Layer for Portable Hardware Accelerators Seamlessly Integrated Laura Pozzi into Software Applications Paolo Ienne 11443 Won-Young Yoo Watermarking attack technologies Weon-Geun Oh Young-Ho Suh 11444 TVA via SC 29 Secretariat Liaison Statement from the TV-Anytime Forum [SC 29 N 6308]

25 11445 TVA via SC 29 Secretariat Liaison Statement from the TV-Anytime Forum [SC 29 N 6309] 11446 SC 29 Secretariat Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 14496-2:2004/PDAM 2 11447 SC 29 Secretariat Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 14496-4:200X/PDAM 10 11448 SC 29 Secretariat Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC CD 14496-20 11449 SC 29 Secretariat Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 13818-1:2000/DCOR 3 11450 SC 29 Secretariat Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 13818-7:200X/DCOR 1 11451 SC 29 Secretariat Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 14496-1:200X/PDAM 1 11452 SC 29 Secretariat Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 14496-16/PDAM 1 11453 SC 29 Secretariat Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 14496-16:2004/DCOR 1 11454 SC 29 Secretariat Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 21000-6:2004/DCOR 1 11455 SC 29 Secretariat Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 21000-7/PDAM 1 11456 SC 29 Secretariat Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC CD 21000-16

26 Annex 4 Output document list

No. Source Title 6698 Convener List of Documents from the Palma, ES Meeting 6699 Convener Resolutions of the Palma, ES 6700 Convener List of AHGs Established at the 70th Meeting in Palma, ES 6701 Convener Report of the 70th Meeting in Palma, ES 6702 Convener Guidelines for Electronic Distribution of MPEG and WG 11 Documents 6703 Convener Press Release of the 70th Meeting in Palma, ES 6704 Convener Meeting Notice of the 71st Meeting in Hong Kong, China 6705 HoD Guide for WG 11 Meeting Hosts 6706 HoD MPEG 101 6707 Video Request for Sub-division of ISO/IEC 11172-6 6708 Video Disposition of Comments on ISO/IEC 14496-2:2004 PDAM2 6709 Video Text of ISO/IEC 14496-2:2004 FPDAM2 New Levels in Simple Profile 6710 Video MPEG-4 Visual: List of Problems Reported version 14.0 6711 Video Text of ISO/IEC 14496-10:2004/DCOR1 6712 Video Text of ISO/IEC 15938-3/Amd.1 DCOR1 6713 Video WD 3.0 of MPEG-7 New Visual Extensions 6714 Video MPEG-7 Visual XM Document version 22.0 6715 Video Description of Core Experiments for MPEG-7 New Visual Extensions 6716 Video Scalable Video Model Version 3.0 6717 Video SVM 3.0 Software 6718 Video Guidelines for the SVC CE Process and Elevation Procedure 6719 Video Description of Core Experiments in MPEG-21 Scalable Video Coding 6720 Video Call for Evidence on Multi-View Video Coding 6721 Video Requirements on Test Material for Multi-view Video Coding Experiments 6722 Video Study of Video Coding Tools Repository V2.0 6723 Video VCTR Textual Description V1.0 6724 Convenor AHG on Video IDCT Specification 6725 Convenor AHG on Maintenance of MPEG-4 Visual related Documents, Reference Software and Conformance 6726 Convenor AHG on Maintenance of MPEG-7 Visual related Documents and Reference Software 6727 Convenor AHG on Description Tools for MPEG-7 New Visual Extensions 6728 Convenor AHG on Core Experiments in Scalable Video Coding 6729 Convenor AHG on Scalable Video Model and SVM Software

27 6730 Convenor AHG on 3DAV Coding 6731 Convenor AHG on Video Coding Tools Repository 6732 Convenor AHG on further Exploration in Wavelet Video Coding 6733 Convenor AHG on Organization of a Workshop on Future Directions in Video Compression 6734 Convenor AHG on Communicating MPEG to the business Community 6735 Video Text of ISO/IEC 11172-6 CD: Specification for Implementation of Inverse Discrete Cosine Transform 6736 Testing Report of the Subjective Quality Evaluation for SVC CE1 6737 Integration ISO/IEC 13818-5 MPEG-2 Reference Software 2nd edition 6738 Integration Text of ISO/IEC 14496-4:200x/DCOR1 Visual Bitstreams 6739 Integration Text of ISO/IEC 14496-4:200x/Amd1/DCOR1 FGS and Studio Bitstreams 6740 Integration Study of ISO/IEC 14496-4:200x/FPDAM9 AVC FRext Conformance 6741 Integration DoC on ISO/IEC 14496-4:200x/PDAM10 New Levels for Simple Profile Conformance 6742 Integration ISO/IEC 14496-4:200x/FPDAM10 New Levels for Simple Profile Conformance 6743 Integration Study of ISO/IEC 14496-4:200x/PDAM8 AVC FRext Reference Software 6744 Integration Draft DoC on ISO/IEC 21000-8 FCD MPEG-21 Reference Software 6745 Integration Study of ISO/IEC 21000-8 FCD MPEG-21 Reference Software 6746 Integration Methodology under consideration for MPEG-21 conformance 6747 SNHC Study text of DoC on ISO/IEC 14496-16/PDAM1 6748 SNHC Study text on ISO/IEC 14496-16/PDAM1 6749 SNHC AFX CE description 6750 SNHC AFX VM 16.0 6751 SNHC Text of ISO/IEC 14496-21 CD 6752 Convenor AHG on AFX documents, CEs, and software 6753 Convenor AHG on MPEG-J extensions for rendering 6754 ISG Status of HDL submissions and commitments for MPEG-4 Part-9 6755 ISG AHG on MPEG-4 Part 9: Reference Hardware Description Phase 1 and 2. 6756 ISG Updated status and Documentation on Hardware Acceleration Module for SA- DCT for MPEG-4 Part 2 6757 ISG Updated Status and documentation of the 4xPE Hardware Acceleration Module for Motion Estimation 6758 ISG Updated status and documentation of the 2-D IDCT Hardware Accelerator Module for MPEG-4 Part 2 6759 ISG Updated Status and documentation of the Shape Coding Binary Motion Estimation Hardware Acceleration Module 6760 ISG Updated status of Inverse Quantizer Hardware Accelerator Implementation for

28 MPEG-4 Part 2 6761 Liaison Liaison Statement to DCSDC 6762 Liaison Liaison Statement to the TV-Anytime Forum on MPEG-7 MDS 6763 Liaison Liaison Statement to OMA on LASeR 6764 Liaison Liaison Statement to 3GPP 6765 Liaison Liaison Statement to W3C 6766 Liaison Liaison Statement to WG 1 on JPSearch 6767 Liaison Statement of benefits from establishing a Category A liaison with ATSC 6768 Liaison Responses to National Body Comments 6769 Liaison List of Organisations with which MPEG entertains liaisons 6770 MDS Study of ISO/IEC FCD 21000-2 DID 2nd edition 6771 MDS Study of Preliminary Comments on ISO/IEC FCD 21000-2 DID 2nd edition 6772 MDS ISO/IEC CD 21000-4 MPEG-21 IPMP Components 6773 MDS TuC for 21000-4 MPEG-21 IPMP Components 6774 MDS Workplan for MPEG-21 REL/RDD Reference Software v.8 6775 MDS Study of preliminary comments on MPEG-21 DIA ISO/IEC 21000-7 PDAM-1 6776 MDS Study of text of MPEG-21 DIA ISO/IEC 21000-7 PDAM-1 6777 MDS Workplan for Core Experiment on DIA Conversions 6778 MDS Workplan for Core Experiment on Bit-Stream Adaptation in Constrained and Streaming Environments 6779 MDS MPEG-21 DIA Software Implementation Plan v.9 6780 MDS ISO/IEC FCD 21000-10 MPEG-21 Digital Item Processing 6781 MDS DoC for the CD of ISO/IEC 21000-10 MPEG-21 Digital Item Processing 6782 MDS MPEG-21 DIP Software Implementation Plan v.4 6783 MDS ISO/IEC CD 21000-15 MPEG-21 Event Reporting 6784 MDS WD 1.0 of ISO/IEC CD 21000-17 Fragment ID for MPEG Media Types 6785 Convenor AHG on MPEG-21 DIP& DID 2nd Edition 6786 Convenor AHG on MPEG-21 Event Reporting 6787 Convenor AHG on MPEG-21 DIA 6788 Convenor AHG on MPEG URI Fragment IDs 6789 Audio Study on 13818-7:2004/DCOR 1 “AAC ADTS buffer fullness correction” 6790 Audio 14496-3:2001/AMD 2:2004/DCOR 1 (SSC) 6791 Audio Study on 14496-3:2001/PDAM 4, Audio Lossless Coding (ALS), new audio profiles and BSAC extensions. 6792 Audio Study on 14496-3:2001/PDAM 5, Scalable Lossless Coding (SLS) 6793 Audio Study on 14496-3:2001/PDAM 6, Lossless coding of 1-bit oversampled signals 6794 Audio Status of Performance and Complexity of MPEG Lossless Audio Coding

29 Architectures 6795 Audio Draft 3rd Edition of 14496-3 6796 Audio Workplan for Audio Lossless Coding (ALS) 6797 Audio Workplan for Scalable Lossless Coding (SLS) 6798 Audio Proposed Clarification of Audio Codec Timestamp Behavior 6799 Audio Working Draft of High Quality Parametric Audio Conformance 6800 Convenor Terms of Reference 6801 Convenor MPEG Standards 6802 Convenor Table of unpublished standards at FDIS level 6803 Convenor Work plan and time line 6804 Convenor Work item assignment 6805 Audio Working Draft of Parametric Stereo Conformance 6806 Audio Working Draft of additional test sequences for BSAC Conformance 6807 Audio Working Draft 0.1 AudioBIFS v3 Conformance 6808 Audio Workplan for Audio contribution to MPEG-4 Conformance 6809 Audio Status of MPEG-4 Audio Conformance 6810 Audio Working Draft of 15938-4:2002/PDAM 2, High-Level Description Extensions 6811 Audio Workplan for Weighted Scale DS 6812 Audio SMR Evaluation Model and Procedure 6813 Audio Report on Spatial Audio Coding RM0 Selection Tests 6814 Audio Workplan for MPEG-4 Spatial Audio Coding 6815 Audio Workplan on CfI on Scalable Speech and Audio Coding 6816 Audio MPEG General Audio Codecs History and Tools 6817 Convenor AHG on Audio Standards Maintenance 6818 Convenor AHG on MPEG-7 Audio 6819 Convenor AHG on Spatial Audio Coding 6820 Convenor AHG on MPEG-4 Lossless Audio Coding 6821 Convenor AHG on Symbolic Music Representation 6822 Convenor AHG On Exploration of Scalable Audio and Speech Coding 6823 MDS Request for Subdivision of ISO/IEC 21000: Part 17 Fragment Identification for MPEG Media Types 6824 Requirements MPEG-4/2 Profiles under Consideration 6825 Requirements LASER Requirements Document 6826 Requirements DoC of FCD of ISO/IEC 15938-9 6827 Requirements Text of FDIS of ISO/IEC 15938-9 6828 Requirements MPEG-7 Overview

30 6829 Requirements Second Draft of PDTR for potential second edition of ISO/IEC 21000-11 6830 Requirements Requirements for Scalable Video Coding 6831 Requirements MPEG-21 Profiles under Consideration 6832 Requirements Multimedia Application Format Overview & Requirements v.2 6833 Requirements Description of Scenario for Digital Item MAF 6834 Requirements Requirements for Multi-view Video Coding 6835 Requirements MPEG Multimedia Middleware Requirements v2.0 6836 Requirements Call for Proposals for MPEG Multimedia Middleware 6837 Convenor AHG on JPEG Liaison 6838 Convenor AHG on MAF Development 6839 Convenor AHG on Persistent Association 6840 Convenor AHG on Font Format Representation 6841 Convenor AHG on MPEG-21 Vision Update 6842 Convenor AHG on Digital Item Serialization 6843 Liaison Liaison Statement to OMA on Base Media File Format 6844 Systems DoC on ISO/IEC 13818-1:2000/DCOR3 6845 Systems Text of ISO/IEC 13818-1:2000/COR3 6846 Systems DoC on ISO/IEC 13818-1:2000/FPDAM4 6847 Systems Text of ISO/IEC 13818-1:2000/FDAM4 6848 Systems Text of ISO/IEC 14496-1:2004/FPDAM1 6849 Systems ISO/IEC 14496-14:2003/DCOR1 6850 Systems WD 1.0 of ISO/IEC 14496-15 Support for FREXT 6851 Convenor Proposed New Text of Software Copyright Disclaimer 6852 Systems DoC on ISO/IEC 14496-20/CD 6853 Systems Text of ISO/IEC 14496-20/FCD 6854 Systems Core Experiment on LASeR Binary Representation 6855 Systems Core Experiment on LASeR Harmonization with SVG 6856 Systems WD2.0 of ISO/IEC 14496-20 Reference Software 6857 Systems WD 1.0 ISO/IEC 15938-1/Amd.2 6858 Systems Core Experiments for Systems Extensions 6859 Systems MPEG-7 Systems reference software workplan 6860 Systems DoC on ISO/IEC 21000-16/CD 6861 Systems Text of ISO/IEC 21000-16/FCD 6862 Systems Core Experiments on MPEG-21 Binary Format 6863 Convenor AHG on XML Structure Binarization and Streaming 6864 Convenor AHG on Scene Representation

31 6865 Convenor AHG on MPEG File Formats 6866 Liaison Liaison Statement to IEC TC 100 on NP: Multimedia home server systems 6867 Integration WD4.0 of ISO/IEC 21000-14 MPEG-21 Conformance 6868 Liaison Template Cover Letter for M3W Liaison

32 Annex 5 Report of Requirements meeting

S Rob o Koen u en r c e :

NB: this report does not duplicate the resolutions, but rather complements them. This implies that not all output documents and not all Ad Hoc Groups are explicitly listed in the report below. Monday 9:00- opening plenary meeting 13:30 13:30-14:30 Lunch (ends one hour after plenary ends) Open 14:30-16:00 Joint with Systems on M3W Discobolo 16:00-16:30 11163 AHG on MPEG Multimedia Middleware - Jean Gelissen, Olivier Avaro , Martin Russ (Systems) 11192 MPEG Multimedia Middleware Requirements v.2.0 - Jean H.A. Gelissen Joint with Systems on LASeR 16:30-17:00 11330 Mobile requirements for lightweight scene representation - Philippe Lucas, et.al. Discobolo 11337 Requirements for Laser Binarization - Claude Seyrat Joint with Systems on Font Representation 17:00-17:30 11183 Proposed Text - OFFS - Single Document - based on OpenType(R) v1.4 - Mike Ksar Discobolo 11150 AHG on Font Format Representation - Mike Ksar, Vladimir Levantovsky Joint with Systems on Accessible Information Processing in MPEG 17:30-18:00 11250 Accessible Information Processing in MPEG - David Crombie, Roger Lenoir, Neil Discobolo McKenzie Joint with Systems on MP4 18:00-18:15 Discobolo 11260 Proposed URI scheme for mp4 file format - Yongju Cho, e.al. Tuesday MPEG-7 “Plenary” 11219 Draft for MPEG-7 Part 9 FDIS - Wo Chang 11229 USNB Contribution: JPSearch and MPEG-7 - A. G. Tescher for USNB 09:00-10:30 Neptuno 11420 MPEG-7 for WG1 (JPEG) JPSearch Project - Wo Chang 11432 AHG on MPEG-7 Interoperability and Profiling - Wo Chang 11181 Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC FCD 15938-9 [SC 29 N 6240] - SC 29 Secretariat Joint meeting with MDS et.al. on MPEG-21 Purpose 10:45-11:30 11249 MPEG-21 - Comatose or Just Sleeping? – Chris Barlas , Niels Rump Neptuno 11151 AHG on MPEG-21 Integration and Outreach - Chris Barlas, Chris Russell Joint with Systems, Video, Audio and MDS on MPEG-A 11:30-13:00 11288 Suggestion to create MPEG-A Part 4 – MPEG-21 Content Format (MCF) - Ian Neptuno Burnett, et.al. 13:00-14:00 Lunch Joint with Video on IDCT Standardization 11268 A new way to look at IDCT - Peter Schirling , et.al. 14:00-14:30 Neptuno 11224 IDCT Specification: A Problem and Opportunity - Gary Sullivan 11225 USNB Contribution: Replacement of IDCT Standard - A. G. Tescher for USNB Joint with Video on omni-directional video 14:30-15:00 Neptuno 11350 Proposal for MPEG-A of omni-directional video - Kazumasa Yamazawa, et.al. Joint with Video on Scalable Video Coding 15:00-15:30 Neptuno AHG report

33 Joint with Test on Persistent Association Technologies 11182 Editor's input on possible 2nd Edition on PAT - Niels Rump for the AhG 11195 Objective Impairment Test Method for Video PAT Evaluation - Jong-Tae Kim, et.al. 15:45-16:30 11201 Guideline for the Selection of Standardized Test Stimuli in the Evaluation of Video Neptuno Watermarking - Ik-Hwan Cho, Weon-Geun Oh, Hae-Kwang Kim, Dong-Seok Jeong 11443 Watermarking attack technologies - Won-Young Yoo , Weon-Geun Oh , Young-Ho Suh Joint with Audio 11310 Additions to the profiles under consideration document. - Kristofer Kjörling 11312 Company support for the proposed High Efficiency AAC v2 Profile - Kristofer Kjörling, et.al. Urano 16:30-17:30 11251 CFI proposed to AGH on Scalable coding – Johnston (Audio) 11370 FT's contribution to the CFI on Scalable Audio and Speech Coding - Pierrick Philippe, et.al. 11227 USNB Contribution: Fine-grain scalable audio codec - A. G. Tescher for USNB 17:30-18:00 Communicating MPEG to the Business Community Neptuno Wednesday 09:00- Plenary meeting 11:00 Joint with MDS on MPEG-21 issues 11:30-12:30 11220 MPEG 21 as a secure interoperable DRM ? - FX Nuttall Jupiter 11276 The reference conformance test model(based on Mpeg-21 dii&didl) - SuSan Im, e.al. 12:30-13:00 Open 13:00-14:00 Lunch Open 14:00-15:30 MPEG-21 – next steps 15:30-16:30 11249 MPEG-21 - Comatose or Just Sleeping? – Chris Barlas , Niels Rump Neptuno 11289 Requirements for Streaming Digital Items - Ian Burnett 16:30-17:30 Joint with Systems - Review of M3W Requirements and Preliminary CFP Discobolo 17:30-18:00 JPSearch Neptuno Thursday Joint with Systems, Video, Audio and MDS on MPEG-A 11419 MAF Photo Repository and Player - Wo Chang 09:00-10:15 Neptuno 11239 Simple Profile for MPEG-21 DIA Usage Environment description tools - José Martínez, et.al. 10:15-10:30 Joint with Systems on LASeR Requirements Discobolo 10:30-11:00 Joint with Systems - Review of M3W Requirements and Preliminary CFP Neptuno 11:00-12:00 12:00-13:00 MPEG-21 IPMP Scope discussion Neptuno 13:00-14:00 Lunch 14:00-15:00 Joint with Video on 3DAV and SVC Video 15:00-16:00 Open 16:00-16:30 Joint with MDS on MPEG-21 MAF MDS 16:30-17:30 JPSearch Liaison Neptuno 17:30-18:00 MPEG-21 Vision Update Neptuno Friday Concluding MPEG-7  MPEG-7 p.9 FDIS (Wo) 08:00-08:30  Disposition of Comments on MPEG-7 (Masa/Rob - done) Neptuno  Liaison to JPEG on JPSearch (Wo)  AHG on JPSearch liaison Concluding MPEG-A  Multimedia Application Format Overview & Requirements v.2 (Rob)  AHG on MAF development (Rob/Klaus) 08:30-09:00 Neptuno A.1 J on 4 (Photo) A.2 DI MAF  Description of Scenario for DI MAF (Klaus) Concluding MPEG-4  MPEG-2/4 Profiles under Consideration (Kristofer - done) 09:00-09:10 Neptuno  AHG on Font Format Representation (Vlad)  LASeR Rqs Document (Olivier)

34 M3W 09:10-09:30  M3W Requirements (Jean) Neptuno  M3W Preliminary Call for Proposals (Jean) Concluding MPEG-21  Applications and Requirements for Scalable Video Coding (Ulrich)  AHG on Serialization of MPEG-21 DI’s (Ian) 09:30-10:00  MPEG-21 Profiles under Consideration Neptuno  Draft 2 of new PAT TR edition (Niels)  PAT outreach AHG (Niels)  AHG on MPEG-21 Vision Update (Bruce) Explorations 10:00-10:01  Requirements on Multiview Video Coding, v.2 (already approved) Neptuno  Call for Evidence for Multiview Video Coding (already approved) 12:30-14:00 Lunch 14:00-20:37 Plenary meeting

1 MPEG-1, -2 and -4 IDCT Specification 11268 A new way to look at IDCT - Peter Schirling , et.al. 11224 IDCT Specification: A Problem and Opportunity - Gary Sullivan 11225 USNB Contribution: Replacement of IDCT Standard - A. G. Tescher for USNB

The problem raised by IEEE removing the IDCT standard will be resolved by the Video Group. The desirability of specifying an integer transform as an alternative to the traditional IDCT was discussed. An AHG was started to study the issue, which was seen as separate from re-instating the IDCT in some way. 2 MPEG-4

2.1 Part 3: New Audio Profile? 11310 Additions to the profiles under consideration document. - Kristofer Kjörling 11312 Company support for the proposed High Efficiency AAC v2 Profile - Kristofer Kjörling, et.al.

A request was put forward in a joint meeting with Audio for the definition of a new MPEG-4 Audio profile that combines AAC, SBR and Parametric Stereo tools. At this meeting, enough support was gathered for the Requirements Group to give the go-ahead. There was no consensus on the name of this new Profile. The proposed name, HE AAC v.2, has advantages and disadvantages:  It could confuse market place  It could also give the right message, indicating yet a further improvement.

Still, Profiles as a principle never get re-defined, which would mean that the name is not suitable.

A new Profiles under Consideration Document was issued, N6824 2.2 Part 18 (?): OpenType as MPEG-4 part? 11183 Proposed Text - OFFS - Single Document - based on OpenType(R) v1.4 - Mike Ksar 11150 AHG on Font Format Representation - Mike Ksar, Vladimir Levantovsky

Pending the submission to MPEG of the OpenType specification free of encumbrances, the work in MPEG cannot continue. MPEG was informed that individuals will continue editing work in anticipation of such a submission. MPEG was informed that a decision from relevant IP holders could be expected by the first week of December

An AHG continued to operate, it has number N6840

35 2.3 Part 14 - MP4 File Format 11260 Proposed URI scheme for mp4 file format - Yongju Cho, e.al. Add suggestion to add a URI addressing scheme for identifying individual Elementary Streams to ISO file format was added to the “Technologies under Consideration” document. The Requirements Group supported the idea; the question is where to carry it the work, i.e., in what amendment. This decision is left to the Systems Group. 2.4 Part 20 - LASeR 11330 Mobile requirements for lightweight scene representation - Philippe Lucas, et.al. The Requirements and Systems Groups agreed that maximizing overlap between SVG and LASeR was a goal. The question was how far to take this, and how compatibility should be defined exactly. A break-out group edited the exact language which was added to the new version of the LASeR Requirements Document.

11337 Requirements for Laser Binarization - Claude Seyrat Requirements for harmonization with BiM were added to the Requirements Document as well. They were phrased as “may”s, indicating that this would be a nice-to-have, but no absolute must.

A new LASeR Requirements document was issued as N6825. 3 MPEG-7

3.1 General A new version of the MPEG-7 Overview was approved, with an editing period. If the respective group chair are good enough to contribute their parts, it may actually get released.

This document is N6828 3.2 Part 9 – Profiles and Levels 11219 Draft for MPEG-7 Part 9 FDIS - Wo Chang 11432 AHG on MPEG-7 Interoperability and Profiling - Wo Chang 11181 Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC FCD 15938-9 [SC 29 N 6240] - SC 29 Secretariat FDIS was approved with very minor changes to what was developed in the AHG. The Requirements Group thanked Wo Chang as editor, en the Japanese National Body for its insightful and thorough comments, as well as its contributions to resolving those comments.

The FDIS and document on FCD were issued as N6827 and N6826 respectively. 3.3 JPsearch Liaison 11229 USNB Contribution: JPSearch and MPEG-7 - A. G. Tescher for USNB 11420 MPEG-7 for WG1 (JPEG) JPSearch Project - Wo Chang A liaison was written to the JPEG WG indicating how MPEG-7 technology can support the JPSearch requirements, and expressing MPEG’s availability to support JPEG in its work on JPSearch if MPEG-7 technology will be considered.

The liaison has number N6766. The AHG that completed the editing and may assist in the evaluation work if required is N6837 4 MPEG-21

4.1 General; Requirements 11289 Requirements for Streaming Digital Items - Ian Burnett

36 The meeting agreed with the notion that providing support for streaming (or, more in general, transport and storage) of DI’s is a good idea. To better understand the scope of such work, an AHG was created.

The AHG number is N6842

11239 Simple Profile for MPEG-21 DIA Usage Environment description tools - José Martínez, et.al The contribution suggests to make simple Profile for DIA, which includes all UED tools. The meeting agreed that this could be a potential profile, and a version of the mPEG-21 Profiles under Consideration document was created.

The MPEG-21 PuC document has number N6831 4.2 Part 4: MPEG-21 IPMP 11220 MPEG 21 as a secure interoperable DRM ? - FX Nuttall Following this presentation, a discussion ensued on the goal of the DRM standardization work in MPEG-21. It appeared that there still is no real consensus on the IPMP work in MPEG-21. Different views exist over what mPEG-21 should do – standardize as much of an IPMP system as possible, or enable the communication between different DRMs? It was also noted that the uptake of the tools that do exist is relatively limited. This discussion was combined with two other discussions: the one on MPEG-21 Outreach (see below on concrete actions) and the one on and MPEG-21 MAF (also see below for conclusions). 4.3 Part 11: Persistent Association Technologies 11182 Editor's input on possible 2nd Edition on PAT - Niels Rump for the AhG The AHG work has resulted in two names of people interested in the work. That is a too small number compared to the interest in Audio, and the meeting concluded that more support would be needed to successfully complete a second version of the PAT that includes Video. The meeting decided to give it one more AHG study period to gather more interest. AN AHG was set up to contact experts, among other things at a relevant international conference the week after the MPEG meeting, in Seoul. (LNCS International Workshop on Digital Watermarking conference.)

The remaining contributions on this issue were evaluated assuming the work would indeed take place.

11195 Objective Impairment Test Method for Video PAT Evaluation - Jong-Tae Kim, et.al. Extending objective measures is good idea. The meeting concluded that they would need to be tested and verified before MPEG can reference them in its technical report. It was unclear if such verification has actually taken place.

11201 Guideline for the Selection of Standardized Test Stimuli in the Evaluation of Video Watermarking - Ik- Hwan Cho, Weon-Geun Oh, Hae-Kwang Kim, Dong-Seok Jeong

Again the proposal looked interesting, and again the meeting noted that there needs to be scientific proof that the metrics have some predictive value. There is an ANSI standard that may be a good candidate.

11443 Watermarking attack technologies - Won-Young Yoo , Weon-Geun Oh , Young-Ho Suh The same conclusion holds as for the previous two contributions. Potentially relevant work, the value of which needs to be scientifically documented.

The AHG has number N6839

37 The second draft of PDTR for potential second edition of ISO/IEC 21000-11 is N6829 4.4 Part 13: SVC After discussing the results of the AHG, the meeting agreed that the Applications/Requirements document needs more focus, and a better understanding about required configurations, that can later be mapped onto profiles.

The requirements themselves are good, with the low delay requirement having been clarified at the meeting.

Application examples should guide the prioritization. Because application examples did not yet map onto requirements, the document was restructured as follows: 1. requirements 2. application families 3. application examples

The idea is that examples map onto families, and that these families are used to derive requirements. The SVC Requirements Document was revised thoroughly. All old examples that are not yet rewritten into the new template have been collected into an annex. Examples that have not been rewritten by the next meeting will be dropped.

The new Requirements Document has number N6830 4.5 Part 14 – Conformance 11276 The reference conformance test model(based on Mpeg-21 dii&didl) - SuSan Im, e.al. This presentation, while registered for Requirements, was referred to the Integration and MDS groups. 4.6 MPEG-21 Outreach 11249 MPEG-21 – Comatose or Just Sleeping? – Chris Barlas , Niels Rump 11151 AHG on MPEG-21 Integration and Outreach – Chris Barlas, Chris Russell

Lively discussions ensued after the presentation of m11249. The contribution distinguishes:  technical reports – “scaffolding”  parts that deal with content by reference  parts that touch resources directly … and questions whether the parts that deal with content directly should be there at all. MPEG- 21’s Unique Selling Point, according to the authors of this contribution, is dealing with content by reference.

The following remarks were made on what could be problems and solutions facing MPEG-21 adoption:  “MPEG-21 deals with value chains … but has no integration method for value chains.  “Many people, inside and outside of MPEG, consider MPEG-21 too complex for end-point (consumer) delivery. It is targeted at no market in specific – so there is no specific interest.  “In addition, and unlike the situation for other MPEG standards, there are no identified subsets (Profiles) that manage complexity in MPEG-21.  “Being hybrid not the real problem. What we miss is solving “my little problem”. Don’t do anything top-down anymore, but start doing things bottom-up.  “Is the Unique Selling Point in addressing content by reference? Or in the DI paradigm?

38  “Need to concentrate on own constituency – end-point delivery.  “Framework is very generic for everything – but not suitable for any particular problem. MPEG-21 seems to rely on other standardization bodies to take MPEG-21 and constrain it – but industry has no time for such an additional cycle. Companies are not interested  “MPEG-21 has too much fat – we confused vision with application. Need to go bottom-up, and see what tools we can provide to solve problems. o “Hard to imagine we would throw out the vision – it embodies what industry needs at this point o “don’t want to throw that out, but rather not to focus on redefining it now  “Vision of MPEG-21 as a conduit to deploy parts (2), 4 and 7 is still there. Need to get down to detail. o “MPEG-21 should be “glue-y” product. MPEG-21. The Sticky Standard.  “Keep adding parts, and passing the message is becoming increasingly hard!  “There are people out there that have taken MPEG-21 bits and built a solution around the parts. We can learn from them. Most of these seem to be in the library space. o Some people would prefer looking at the end-delivery space.

In conclusion of the discussion, there was a feeling that MPEG needs to go back to the original vision and see how that was relevant in today’s market, 4 to 5 years after starting MPEG-21. An AHG was started to do that.

The number of the AHG is N6841 5 MAF (MPEG-A)

5.1 General; Requirements 11419 MAF Photo Repository and Player - Wo Chang The meeting discussed the Jon4 MAF, and its value proposition. Jon4 must at least encompass all EXIF metadata, because that is what is already in common use today, and Jon4 shall not offer less. If need be, MPEG-7 shall be extended to include more EXIF metadata (v 2.2) than what is proposed now.

The meeting discussed the criteria for starting an MAF at some length. These criteria were capture in the MAF Overview and Requirements document, in the form of requirements for creating an MAF. The criteria (requirements) are aimed at making sure that everything is done to allow an MAF to become successful in the marketplace. The criteria are similar to those for establishing a profile (in MPEG-4, -7 or -21). One time added was the requirement that at least one white paper on the MAF should be available at the end the standardization process.

The new Multimedia Application Format Overview & Requirements v.2 is N6832 5.2 MPEG-21 MAF Session 11288 Suggestion to create MPEG-A Part 4 – MPEG-21 Content Format (MCF) - Ian Burnett Contribution contains proposal for MMPEG-21 Content Format. It would do something similar to the DCF in OMA. A discussion ensued on how complete the format should be. E.g., should it define encryption? Should binarization should be handled – or should it be handled separately? Some participatnts asked that this format unify existing approaches to, e.g., encryption (e.g., look at and use what ISMA has specified). It was agreed that the goal would be to focus at horizontal application domains, not just mobile. There was some opposition to doing this at all, allegedly

39 because of the confusion it might cause with, e.g., pure mp3 or mp4 formats, but this opposition was not shared and not sustained.

Three phases were identified for the development; it was left to future decision if these would all be published. 1) Format with no DRM at all 2) Only REL (binariized and profiled), but no further IPMP elements 3) Adding IPMP elements form MPEG-21 IPMP when that is ready

A break-out group studied a scenario that would form the basis of this format.

The scenario is described in N6833 The AHG to further study the scenario is N6838 5.3 Omni-directional Video 11350 Proposal for MPEG-A of omni-directional video - Kazumasa Yamazawa, et.al.

This contribution proposes an MAF for omni-directional video. The meeting looked at the proposed technologies and understood that almost all of them could be found in MPEG-4, with perhaps a few elements from MPEG-7.

Besides the issue of what would actually be the technologies in this MAF, the question came up of whether this would constitute an MAF in the way MAFs were intended. Will its use be wide enough?

After further discussion among the chairs meeting and in the requirements group, a set of general criteria were agreed (see above) and these were presented in a joint Video/Requirements meeting. Contributions are invited for a next meeting to allow the Requirements Group to judge if such requirements could be met for an omni-directional video MAF. 6 Explorations & Others

6.1 General 11250 Accessible Information Processing in MPEG - David Crombie, Roger Lenoir, Neil McKenzie Unfortunately, no one appeared to be present to introduce the contribution. 6.2 Scalable Audio Coding 11251 CFI proposed to AGH on Scalable coding – Johnston 11370 FT's contribution to the CFI on Scalable Audio and Speech Coding - Pierrick Philippe, et.al. 11227 USNB Contribution: Fine-grain scalable audio codec - A. G. Tescher for USNB

The Requirements and Audio Groups met jointly to discuss the proposed RFI. While the text of the RFI was largely OK, after this joint meeting, the audio group was left with the task to better define when a new technology would meet the requirements for a new standardization project to start. The Requirements Group later understood that the Audio Group decided not to issue an RFI at this point in time. The reader is referred to the report of the Audio Group for further discussion on this matter. 6.3 3DAV A Call for Evidence was approved and issued for Multiview Video Coding. The accompanying requirements (N6501), extracted from the general 3DA requirements, were approved as well.

The Requirements are found in N6834 The Call for Evidence is N6720

40 6.4 M3W 11163 AHG on MPEG Multimedia Middleware - Jean Gelissen, Olivier Avaro , Martin Russ 11192 MPEG Multimedia Middleware Requirements v.2.0 - Jean H.A. Gelissen

A new version of the requirements document was approved (6835). A Call for Proposals was discussed and released in preliminary version. The final version will be issued in January 2005. Responses to the Call are due in March 2005

The Requirements Document is N6835 The CfP is N6836

41 Annex 6 Report of Systems meeting

S Systems Chair and Break-out group o Chairs u r c e :

Title: Systems Meeting Report Status: Draft Editor: Olivier Avaro (Streamezzo)

Contributors: Claude Seyrat (Expway), Jean-Claude Dufourd (Streamezzo),

Overview The main outputs of the meeting from the Systems Sub-group perspective are:

No. Title TBP Available X 13818-1:2000/DCOR.3 Correction for Field Picture 6844 DoC on ISO/IEC 13818-1:2000/DCOR3 No 04/10/22 6845 Text of ISO/IEC 13818-1:2000/COR3 No 04/10/22 X 13818-1:2000/Amd.4 Metadata Application Format CP 6846 DoC on ISO/IEC 13818-1:2000/FPDAM4 No 04/10/22 6847 Text of ISO/IEC 13818-1:2000/FDAM4 No 04/10/22 X 14496-1 :2003/Amd.1 Text Profile Descriptor 6848 Study Text of ISO/IEC 14496-1:2004/PDAM1 No 04/10/22 X 14496-14 MP4 File Format 6849 ISO/IEC 14496-14:2003/DCOR1 No 04/10/22 X 14496-15 AVC File Format 6850 WD 1.0 of ISO/IEC 14496-15 Support for FREXT No 04/10/29 X 14496-20 LASeR 6852 DoC on ISO/IEC 14496-20/CD No 04/10/22 6853 Text of ISO/IEC 14496-20/FCD Yes 04/11/05 6854 Core Experiment on LASeR Binary Representation No 04/10/22 6855 Core Experiment on LASeR Harmonization with SVG No 04/10/22 6856 WD2.0 of ISO/IEC 14496-20 Reference Software No 04/11/25 X 15938-1 Systems 6857 WD 1.0 ISO/IEC 15938-1/Amd.2 No 04/10/22 6858 Core Experiments for Systems Extensions No 04/10/22 6859 MPEG-7 Systems reference software workplan No 04/10/22 X 21000-16 MPEG-21 Binary Format 6860 DoC on ISO/IEC 21000-16/CD No 04/10/22 6861 Text of ISO/IEC 21000-16/FCD No 04/10/29 6862 Core Experiments on MPEG-21 Binary Format No 04/10/22

42 General issues

General The meeting report from Redmond has been approved.

Discussion on the documentation of BiM across MPEG standards: - Option 1 : Separate MPEG Standard - Option 2 : Part of Generic Technology Standard with IDCT - Option 3 : Part of MPEG-21 - Current : Part of MPEG-7 Systems Décision will be made in January.

List of standards under development

Pr Pt Edit. Project Description CfP WD CD FCD FDIS 4 1 2004 Amd.1 Text Profile Descriptors 04/07 04/10 05/04 4 11 2003 Amd.4 XMT and MPEG-J 03/10 03/12 04/07 05/01 Extensions 4 14 2004 Cor.1 Correction on File-type Box 04/10 05/01 4 15 2004 Amd.1 Support for FREXT 04/10 05/01 05/07 06/01 4 17 2003 1st Ed. Streaming Text Format 03/03 03/07 03/12 05/01 4 20 2004 1st Ed. Lightweight Application 04/03 04/07 04/10 05/04 Scene 7 1 2004 Amd.2 BiM Extension 04/10 05/01 05/07 06/01 21 9 200x 1st Ed. File Format 03/12 04/03 04/07 05/01 21 16 200x 1st Ed. Binary Format 04/03 04/07 04/10 05/04

Standing Documents

Pr Pt Documents No. Meeting 4 13 MPEG IPMP Extensions Overview N6338 04/03 München 21 xx MPEG Multimedia Middleware Context and N6335 04/03 Objectives München

Demonstrations The following demonstrations were made: - M11207 INT: MPEG-4 3D Player. - Fraunhofer: AVC / He-AAC Streaming. - France Telecom R&D: Scalable representation of 3D content.

FAQ The FAQ were updated as needed.

43 AOB None.

44 MPEG-2 Systems (13818-1)

13818-1:2000 Amd.4 Topics 1. ISAN and VISAN Signaling. Contributions All NB comments were addressed and the final text of this amendment was produced.

Technical Work Finalized.

13818-1:2000 Cor. 3 Topics 1. Correction on Field Picture Contributions M11449: Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 13818-1:2000/DCOR 3. All comments were addressed and the final text of this amendment was produced.

Technical Work Finalized.

MPEG-2 Exploratory Activities Topics None.

MPEG-4 Systems (14496-1)

14496-1:2003 Amd.1 M11451: Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 14496-1:200X/PDAM 1. All comments were addressed and text of ISO/IEC 14496-1:200X/FPDAM 1 was produced.

Technical Work in Progress.

MPEG-4 Scene Description (14496-11)

14496-11:2003 Amd.4 Topics 1. XMT Extensions; 2. MPEG-J Extensions.

45 Contributions None.

MPEG-4 AVC File Format (14496-15)

14496-15:2004 Amd.1 Topics 1. Support for FREXT Contributions

M11425: Proposed amendment to Part 15 to support FREXT (Decoder specific info. extensions and support for additional NAL Units). Accepted. Production of WD.

Streaming Text (14496-17)

Topics 1. Coded Representation of Text Stream. Contributions None. This specification is currently at FCD stage. The editors of the document have requested additional time to implement the editorial guidelines decided in the July Redmong meeting. Text will be promoted to FDIS at the January Honk-Kong meeting. Technical Work in Progress.

Font Compression and Streaming (14496-18)

Exploratory Activities

Topics 1. OpenType Standardization Contributions M11183: Proposed Text - Open Font Format Specifications (OFFS) - Single Document - based on OpenType(R) v1.4.

Technical work will not be progressed before owners of the copyright of the specification have given their agreement to go forward. AHG will continue with appropriate mandate (Cf. Requirements report).

46 47 LASeR (14496-20)

Topics 1. Lightweight Application Scene Representation Contributions

Discussion on Requirements

M1130: Mobile requirements for lightweight scene representation. Agreement to add as a requirement that a profile of LASeR shall be compatible with SVGT1.2.

M11337: Requirements for Laser Binarization. Requirement 1a (Flexibility) is already here. Requirement 1b (Genericity) has bee taken into account. Requirement 2 (support MPEG-7 and MPEG-21) is only a nice to have and not a must have. Documented as such. Requirements 3 (extension with XML namespace) is supported through private data. Requirements 4 (Low footprint implementation) is already supported.

The LASER requirement document was updated accordingly. A discussion started on compatibility with SVG that did not reach conclusion. Current understanding is documented in the LASER Requirement document. These issues will be further studied in the CE on SVG Harmonization as well as on the LASER AHG reflector.

Input Contributions

M11448: All comments have been successfully addressed. See DoC.

M11198: CE Study of LASeR and SAF CD Used as a starting point as recommended by the AHG. May need to add a drawing to explain LASeR position with respect to SVG. Decisions on study text: Decision to start with the study with the AHG recommended changes to create the FCD. All open issues recorded in the CE on Harmonization workplan

M11330: Mobile requirements for lightweight scene representation Request document rendering model as SVG: accept (done). Remove switch from g and use restricted version of page/pageSet for that: to be investigated in the CE. Use restricted clip attribute instead of g extension: to be investigated in the CE. Xml events: already satisfied with study 4.7. LASeR should be able to encode ECMAScript in