Briefing-80 Briefing-80 An Introduction To An Introduction To Persistent Identifiers Persistent Identifiers A QA Focus Briefing Document A QA Focus Briefing Document
What are Persistent Identifiers? What are Persistent Identifiers? An identifier is any label that allows us to find a resource. One of the best-known An identifier is any label that allows us to find a resource. One of the best-known identifiers is the International Standard Book Number (ISBN), a unique ten-digit identifiers is the International Standard Book Number (ISBN), a unique ten-digit number assigned to books and other publications. On the Internet the most widely number assigned to books and other publications. On the Internet the most widely known identifier is the Uniform Resource Locator (URL), which allows users to find a known identifier is the Uniform Resource Locator (URL), which allows users to find a resource by listing a protocol, domain name and, in many cases, file location. resource by listing a protocol, domain name and, in many cases, file location. A persistent identifier is, as the name suggests, an identifier that exists for a very long A persistent identifier is, as the name suggests, an identifier that exists for a very long time. It should at the very least be globally unique and be used as a reference to the time. It should at the very least be globally unique and be used as a reference to the resource beyond the resource’s lifetime. URLs, although useful, are not very persistent. resource beyond the resource’s lifetime. URLs, although useful, are not very persistent. They only provide a link to the resource’s location at the moment in time they are cited, They only provide a link to the resource’s location at the moment in time they are cited, if the resource moves they no longer apply. The issue of ‘linkrot’ on the Internet if the resource moves they no longer apply. The issue of ‘linkrot’ on the Internet (broken links to resources), along with the need for further interoperability has led to the (broken links to resources), along with the need for further interoperability has led to the search for more persistent identifiers for digital resources. search for more persistent identifiers for digital resources.
Principles for Persistent Identification Principles for Persistent Identification The International Digital Object Identifier (DOI) Foundation [1] states that there are two The International Digital Object Identifier (DOI) Foundation [1] states that there are two principles for persistent identification: principles for persistent identification: 1. Assign an ID to a resource: Once assigned the number must identify 1. Assign an ID to a resource: Once assigned the number must identify the same resource beyond the lifetime of the resource or identifier. the same resource beyond the lifetime of the resource or identifier. 2. Assign a resource to an ID: The resource should persistently continue to be the same thing. 2. Assign a resource to an ID: The resource should persistently continue to be the same thing. Uniform Resource Identifiers Uniform Resource Identifiers A Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) is the string that is used to identify anything on the Internet. URLs along with Uniform Resource Names (URNs) are both types of URI. A Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) is the string that is used to identify anything on A URN is a name with global scope and does not necessarily imply a location. A URN the Internet. URLs along with Uniform Resource Names (URNs) are both types of URI. will include a Namespace Identifier (NID) Code and a Namespace Specific String A URN is a name with global scope and does not necessarily imply a location. A URN (NSS). The NID specifies the identification system used (e.g. ISBN) and the NSS is will include a Namespace Identifier (NID) Code and a Namespace Specific String local code that identifies a resource. For someone to find a resource using a URN they (NSS). The NID specifies the identification system used (e.g. ISBN) and the NSS is must use a resolver service. local code that identifies a resource. For someone to find a resource using a URN they must use a resolver service.
Produced by QA Focus – supporting JISC’s digital library programmes Feb 2005 Produced by QA Focus – supporting JISC’s digital library programmes Feb 2005 Persistent URLs Persistent URLs Persistent URLs (PURLs) [2] have been developed by the Online Computer Library Persistent URLs (PURLs) [2] have been developed by the Online Computer Library Centre (OCLC) as an interim measure for Internet resources until the URN framework Centre (OCLC) as an interim measure for Internet resources until the URN framework is well established. A PURL is functionally a URL, but rather than pointing at a location is well established. A PURL is functionally a URL, but rather than pointing at a location points at a resolution service, which redirects the user to the appropriate URL. If the points at a resolution service, which redirects the user to the appropriate URL. If the URL changes it just needs to be amended in the PURL resolution service. URL changes it just needs to be amended in the PURL resolution service. Example: http://purl.oclc.org/OCLC/PURL/summary. Example: http://purl.oclc.org/OCLC/PURL/summary. This is made up of the protocol (http), the resolver address (http://purl.oclc.org/) and the This is made up of the protocol (http), the resolver address (http://purl.oclc.org/) and the user-assigned name (OCLC/PURL/summary). user-assigned name (OCLC/PURL/summary).
Digital Object Identifiers Digital Object Identifiers The Digital Object Identifier (DOI) system was initiated by the Association of The Digital Object Identifier (DOI) system was initiated by the Association of American publishers in an attempt to assist the publishing community with copyright American publishers in an attempt to assist the publishing community with copyright and electronic commerce. DOIs are described by the International DOI Foundation, who and electronic commerce. DOIs are described by the International DOI Foundation, who manage them, as persistent, interoperable, actionable identifiers. They are persistent manage them, as persistent, interoperable, actionable identifiers. They are persistent because they identify an object as a first-class entity (not just the location), they are because they identify an object as a first-class entity (not just the location), they are interoperable because they are designed with the future in mind and they are actionable interoperable because they are designed with the future in mind and they are actionable because they allow a user to locate a resource by resolution using the Handle System. because they allow a user to locate a resource by resolution using the Handle System. The Handle System, developed by the Corporation for National Research Initiatives The Handle System, developed by the Corporation for National Research Initiatives (CNRI) includes protocols that enable a distributed computer system to store handles of (CNRI) includes protocols that enable a distributed computer system to store handles of digital resources and resolve them into a location. DOIs can be assigned by a digital resources and resolve them into a location. DOIs can be assigned by a Registration Agency (RA), which provides services for a specific user community and Registration Agency (RA), which provides services for a specific user community and may charge fees. The main RA for the publishing community is CrossRef [3]. may charge fees. The main RA for the publishing community is CrossRef [3]. Example: 10.1000/123456 This is made up of the prefix (10.1000) which is the string Example: 10.1000/123456 This is made up of the prefix (10.1000) which is the string assigned to an organisation that registering DOIs and the suffix (123456) which is a assigned to an organisation that registering DOIs and the suffix (123456) which is a unique (to a given prefix) alphanumeric string, which could be an existing identifier. unique (to a given prefix) alphanumeric string, which could be an existing identifier.
Using Persistent Identifiers Using Persistent Identifiers While DOIs hold great potential for helping information communities enhance While DOIs hold great potential for helping information communities enhance interoperability they have yet to reach maturity. There are still many unrersolved issues, interoperability they have yet to reach maturity. There are still many unrersolved issues, such as their resolution (how users use them in to receive a Web page), registration of such as their resolution (how users use them in to receive a Web page), registration of the DOI system, the persistence of the International DOI Foundation as an organisation the DOI system, the persistence of the International DOI Foundation as an organisation and what exactly their advantages are over handles or PURLs. Until these matters are and what exactly their advantages are over handles or PURLs. Until these matters are resolved they will remain little more than a good idea for most communities. resolved they will remain little more than a good idea for most communities. However the concept of persistent identifiers is still imperative to a working Internet. However the concept of persistent identifiers is still imperative to a working Internet. While effort is put into finding the best approach there is much that those creating Web While effort is put into finding the best approach there is much that those creating Web pages can do to ensure that their URIs are persistent. In 1998 Tim Berners-Lee coined pages can do to ensure that their URIs are persistent. In 1998 Tim Berners-Lee coined the phrase Cool URIs to describe URIs which do not change [4]. the phrase Cool URIs to describe URIs which do not change [4].
For further information on QA Focus see