COMPETITION BY EXAM AND ACADEMIC TITLES, ANNOUNCED ON 30/6/2020, PROT. N. 25861 FOR THE CONFERRAL OF 1 RESEARCH GRANT WITH A DURATION OF THREE YEARS FOR THE SECTOR _ 12/A1 PRIVATE AT THE DEPARTMENT OF LEGAL STUDIES OF UNIVERSITA’ COMMERCIALE “LUIGI BOCCONI” OF MILAN.

Minutes 1

The Judging Committee of the competition by exam and academic titles for 1 spot for a Research Grant related to sector 12/A1 Private Law (Scientific Sector IUS/01 Private Law)) with a duration of three years at the Department of Legal Studies of Università Commerciale "Luigi Bocconi" of Milan is made up of:

• Prof. Mario Notari, Full Professor • Prof. Pietro Sirena, Full Professor • Prof. Francesco Paolo Patti, Associate Professor

It met on 21 September 2020 at 18:45 through an online video conference to decide the scores to assign to the research and academic titles and publications.

The Committee had previously appointed Prof. Mario Notari as President and Prof. Francesco Paolo Patti as Secretary.

The Committee took note of the regulations set out in the notice of competition that the maximum points to be assigned are as follows:

• 30 points out of 100 for the evaluation of CV, academic titles and research and programming experience; • 30 points out of 100 for the evaluation of scientific publications presented and the “Document to pursue the research”; • 40 points out of 100 for the evaluation by interview. ------• 100 points out of a total of 100

Only candidates who achieve a minimum of 40 points in the evaluation of titles, publications and project will be admitted to be evaluated by interview.

Having read the applications and titles submitted by the candidates of the competition, which were all compliant with what was set out in the competition notice, the following points were assigned:

ACCONCIAIOCO Bruno 17 points Evaluation of CV, academic titles and research and programming experience

15 points Evaluation of scientific publications and the “Document to pursue the research”;

TOTAL 32 points

The candidate Bruno Acconciaioco has graduated in 2004 at the University of ‘’. At the same University, on 9 June 2014, he fulfilled a PhD in Italian and comparative private law (XXVI ciclo). The candidate informs that he was a Visiting Student at Boston University (BU) in 2012. The titles concerning courses of high specialization and (corsi di alta specializzazione e formazione), and the Master degree granted by the University L.U.M. Jean Monnet, do not concern the scientific disciplinary sector “12/A1” of the present recruitment proceeding. Also some of the publications are in part not coherent with the scientific disciplinary sector “12/A”. At any rate, they are merely informative contributions, sometimes aimed at professional updates. In the light of the experiences and the conducted studies, the titles and the publications of the candidate do not integrate the minimum standards to perform the research funded with the 3-years research grant.

BUONANNO Luigi 25 points Evaluation of CV, academic titles and research and programming experience

27 points Evaluation of scientific publications and the “Document to pursue the research”;

TOTAL 52 points

The candidate Luigi Buonanno graduated in 2015 at the University LUISS Guido Carli in Rome. He is finishing the third year of the PhD in ‘Legal Studies’ (XXXIII ciclo), at the Università Commerciale "Luigi Bocconi" of Milan. During the years 2018-2020, the candidate has been Visiting researcher at the Max Planck für ausländisches und internationales Privatrecht in Hamburg and in 2019 Visiting Graduate Student at the Institute of Comparative and European Law of the Oxford University. In 2019 he won the (ELI) ‘Young Lawyers Award 2019’ granted by the European Law Institute. In addition, the candidate has participated in national and international conferences. His publications are all coherent with the scientific disciplinary sector “12/A1”. The contributions are mainly published in top ranked law journals (‘A class’, according to the Anvurs’s lists). They demonstrate a great variety of interests – in the fields of obligations, contracts, civil liability and prescription – and a significant methodological accuracy. The experiences and the issues tackled within the publications integrate an adequate basis in order to fulfill the research granted by the 3-years research grant.

PATRONE Matteo 22 points Evaluation of CV, academic titles and research and programming experience

21 points Evaluation of scientific publications and the “Document to pursue the research”;

TOTAL 43 points

The candidate Matteo Patrone graduated in 2009 at the University of Genova and received a PhD at the in private law, Roman law and European legal culture in 2017. In 2015, he received a Master degree on the law of trusts at the University of Genova. In the same University, he was holder of a research grant from 10/2010 to 9/2011. He was also holder of another research grant at the European University (Università Europea) in Rome during the a.y. 2018/2019. In 2011, he participated at the translation from English to Italian of book X on Trust of the Draft Common Frame of Reference (DCFR), at the European Legal Studies Institute (ELSI) of the University of Osnabrück. His publications are all coherent with the scientific disciplinary sector “12/A1”. The contributions demonstrate an adequate level of scientific analysis and a good editorial positioning. However, they are almost only devoted to issues related to trusts. Significant connections to the topic of the research of the present recruitment proceeding are therefore absent.

Based on the regulations for this competition, the following candidates will be admitted to be evaluated by interview:

BUONANNO Luigi (52 points) PATRONE Matteo (43 points)

The interview will take place on the date 30 September 2020 at the time 13:00 via conference call.

The meeting ended at 19:30.

Pursuant to and in accordance with article 5 of the notice of competition, the Committee hereby communicates this report to the Faculty and Research Division of Università Commerciale "Luigi Bocconi'' for subsequent steps.

Read, approved and signed.

Milan, 21 September 2020

• Prof. Mario Notari (Presidente)

• Prof. Pietro Sirena (Membro)

• Prof. Francesco Paolo Patti (Segretario)